Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates
- MISS R LAWRENCE (instructed by Crown Prosecution Service) appeared on behalf of the APPELLANT
- The RESPONDENT did not appear and was not represented
Judges
- MR JUSTICE MAURICE KAY
- MR JUSTICE MACKAY
See more information ...
Click here to read the full judgment
Director of Public Prosecutions v. Santa-Bermudez
Smart Summary
Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion arises from a prosecutor's appeal by way of case stated against a decision of the Crown Court at Middlesex Guildhall on 6 December 2001. The Crown Court had allowed a defence submission of no case to answer in respect of an appeal against a conviction by a Magistrates Court for assault occasioning actual bodily harm. The alleged victim was a woman police officer. The incident occurred at an underground station where the officer approached the respondent, suspected of ticket touting, and sought to conduct a full body search under statutory authority. During the search, the officer was injured by a hypodermic needle concealed in one of the respondent's jacket pockets. The respondent had denied having any needles or sharps on him. At the close of the prosecution case, the defence submitted that an omission to act cannot constitute assault and that there was no evidence of any positive act by the respondent amounting to assault. The Crown Court accepted this submission and quashed the conviction. The question for this court was whether the Crown Court was correct in law to do so.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Crown Court was correct in law to accept the submission of no case to answer on the basis that an omission to act cannot amount to an assault.
- Whether the respondent’s conduct, including his dishonest assurances and concealment of needles, constituted a positive act sufficient to establish the actus reus of assault occasioning actual bodily harm.
- The applicability of legal principles concerning causation and foreseeability in cases where harm results indirectly from the defendant’s conduct.
Arguments of the Parties
Prosecutor's Arguments
- The respondent created a danger by keeping an exposed needle in his pocket, constituting a continuing act until the injury occurred.
- The respondent compounded this by making false assurances that he had no needles or sharps, which was a further positive act.
- It was reasonably foreseeable that the police officer would be injured by the needle when conducting the search following the respondent’s assurances.
- These actions amounted prima facie to assault occasioning actual bodily harm.
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent’s arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Fagan v Metropolitan Police Commissioner [1969] 1 QB 439 |
Established principles relating to actus reus and assault. |
Referenced as one of the few authorities initially submitted to the Crown Court. |
| Regina v Roberts 56 Cr App R 95 |
Test for causation in assault cases: whether the victim’s reaction was a reasonably foreseeable consequence of the defendant’s act or words. |
Adopted as the principal test for foreseeability and causation in this case. |
| Director of Public Prosecutions v K (1990) 91 Cr App R 23 |
Held that creating a dangerous situation and failing to warn others can amount to assault if recklessness is proved. |
Used to support the proposition that a continuing act creating danger can constitute assault. |
| Clarence (1888) 22 QBD 23 |
Established that laying a trap for another can constitute assault once the victim falls into it. |
Quoted to support the analogy of creating danger and liability for resulting harm. |
| Regina v Miller [1983] 2 AC 161 |
Confirmed that omissions to act can give rise to criminal liability if the defendant created the danger and had the requisite mental state. |
Supported the rejection of rigid distinctions between acts and omissions in criminal liability. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analysed the legal distinction between acts and omissions in the context of assault occasioning actual bodily harm. It acknowledged the established test from Regina v Roberts that harm caused indirectly by the victim’s actions is attributable to the defendant if those actions were a reasonably foreseeable consequence of the defendant’s words or deeds. The court considered the prosecutor’s submission that the respondent’s conduct—concealing needles and falsely denying their presence—constituted a continuing act creating a danger. The court referenced DPP v K and Clarence to illustrate that creating a dangerous situation and failing to warn others can amount to assault, especially where recklessness is present. It also cited Regina v Miller to reject the notion that omissions cannot give rise to criminal liability, emphasizing that failure to act to counteract a danger one created can be criminal if the mental element is satisfied. The court found that the Crown Court erred in concluding there was no evidential basis for the actus reus of assault, as the respondent’s dishonest assurances and concealment exposed the officer to a foreseeable risk of injury. The court thus held that the submission of no case to answer should not have been upheld.
Holding and Implications
The court’s final decision was to ALLOW THE APPEAL without further order. This means the Crown Court was incorrect in law to accept the submission of no case to answer and quash the conviction on that basis. The direct effect is that the respondent’s acquittal on this ground is overturned. The opinion does not set a new precedent but clarifies the application of existing principles concerning acts, omissions, and foreseeability in assault cases involving actual bodily harm.
Click here to read the full judgment