Factual and Procedural Background
This is an undefended infringement action concerning registered designs, registered trade marks, and copyrights owned by the claimants, collectively referred to as "Sony," involving sales of Sony's goods into the European Economic Area (EEA) via an internet website. The claimants are corporate entities of a well-known electronics group, with the second claimant being a UK subsidiary of the first claimant, a Japanese company. The dispute centers on the sale of a hand-held portable game console ("PSP Consoles") and related items marketed under the PlayStation brand.
The defendant, a Hong Kong incorporated company trading under the name "Pacific," operates a website offering for sale various video games, consoles, and accessories, targeting customers in the EEA and specifically the UK. The defendant did not appear at the hearing. Sony had previously initiated related litigation against Pacific in both the UK and Hong Kong. Pacific applied to dismiss the UK action on grounds of forum non conveniens, but this application was dismissed by a prior judgment of Kitchin J. Pacific has failed to comply with certain court orders related to costs and acknowledgements of service.
Sony elected not to seek judgment by default but requested a reasoned judgment to facilitate enforcement abroad and to deter similar infringements by others. Evidence included a test purchase of a PSP Console from Pacific's website, which was shipped directly from Hong Kong to the UK. The console and packaging were genuine Sony products intended for the Japanese market only.
Sony served witness statements, including from a Vice-President of Legal & Business Affairs and several Japanese witnesses who provided evidence on copyright authorship and ownership. The intellectual property rights asserted include registered trade marks, registered designs, and copyrights in software and packaging.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Sony has given consent, express or implied, to the marketing and sale of PSP Consoles intended for the Japanese market within the EEA, thus engaging the principle of Community exhaustion of intellectual property rights.
- Whether the defendant's website activities constitute acts of infringement within the EEA under relevant trade mark, design, and copyright legislation.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Zino Davidoff v A&G Imports Ltd / Levi Strauss v Tesco Stores Ltd and Costco (Wholesale) Ltd [2002] Ch 109, [2002] RPC 403 |
Principles of Community exhaustion and implied consent by a trade mark proprietor regarding marketing goods within the EEA. |
The court relied on this ECJ jurisprudence to conclude that placing goods on the market outside the EEA does not imply consent for marketing within the EEA unless unequivocal renunciation of rights is demonstrated. The court applied these principles to the facts, finding no such consent by Sony. |
| Euromarket Designs Inc v Peters and Crate & Barrel Ltd [2001] FSR 20 |
Determination of whether a website constitutes use of a trade mark in a particular jurisdiction and the distinction between general commercial information and targeted offers for sale. |
The court adopted the approach that a website owner is not deemed to have used a trade mark in every country where the website is accessible, but should be assessed on whether the website conveys an offer for sale targeted at that jurisdiction. This informed the court’s finding that the defendant’s website targeted customers in the EEA and UK. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court first examined the principle of Community exhaustion, emphasizing that intellectual property rights are exhausted only where the proprietor or those with consent have placed the goods on the market within the EEA. The court found no evidence of Sony’s express or implied consent for the defendant to market PSP Consoles intended for Japan within the EEA.
Applying the ECJ’s precedent from the Zino Davidoff case, the court explained that implied consent requires unequivocal renunciation of rights by the proprietor, which was absent here. The court rejected arguments that lack of warnings or contractual restrictions alone imply consent.
The court then considered the nature of the defendant’s website and its intended market. Using the approach from Euromarket Designs, the court assessed whether the website was targeted at the UK or EEA. The facts showed the website was in English with prices in pounds sterling, offered manuals in European languages, included UK purchaser testimonials, and ran promotions relevant to the UK market. These factors demonstrated that the website was directed at customers in the EEA.
Given these facts, the court concluded that the infringing acts occurred within the EEA, not merely in Hong Kong, and that the defendant’s use of the website constituted acts of infringement under relevant intellectual property laws. The court reasoned that allowing infringement to be avoided by using a foreign website would undermine intellectual property rights within the EEA.
Holding and Implications
Judgment was given in favor of the claimants (Sony).
The court granted relief to Sony on the basis that the defendant infringed Sony’s registered trade marks, designs, and copyrights by offering for sale genuine PSP Consoles intended for the Japanese market within the EEA without consent. The decision confirms that intellectual property rights cannot be circumvented by using websites based outside the EEA to target consumers within the EEA. No new legal precedent was established beyond the application of existing ECJ jurisprudence and UK law principles. The judgment facilitates enforcement of rights against the defendant and serves as a deterrent to similar conduct by others.