AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 23(2) of the Customs At, 1962.
  • u/s 48 of the Custom Act, 1962,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 23(2) of the Customs At, 1962.
  • u/s 48 of the Custom Act, 1962,
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    SAURABH SUNEJA v. THE CHIEF MANAGER CONCOR

    DISTRICT CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION

    SOUTH II

    CONSUMER COMPLAINT NO. DC/AB1/670/CC/31/2020

    SAURABH SUNEJA

    PRESENT ADDRESS - 11/316, VASUNDHARA, GHAZIABAD-201012.SOUTH EAST,DELHI. .......Complainant(s)

    Versus

    THE CHIEF MANAGER CONCOR

    PRESENT ADDRESS - ICD, TUGHLAKABAD, NEW DLEHI.SOUTH EAST,DELHI. .......Opposite Party(s)

    BEFORE:

    MONIKA AGGARWAL SRIVASTAVA , PRESIDENT

    DR. RAJENDER DHAR , MEMBER

    RITU GARODIA , MEMBER

    FOR THE COMPLAINANT:

    NEMO

    FOR THE OPPOSITE PARTY:

    NEMO

    DATED: 28/11/2025

    ORDER

    CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION - X

    GOVERNMENT OF N.C.T. OF DELHI

    Udyog Sadan, C - 22 & 23, Institutional Area (Behind Qutub Hotel)

    New Delhi - 110016

    Case No.:31/2020

    Sh. Saurabh Suneja

    S/o Sh. Satish Kumar Suneja

    R/o 11/316, Vasundhara,

    1

    Ghaziabad - 201012 …..COMPLAINANTS Vs.

    1. The chief Manager

    CONCOR

    ICD, Tughlakabad, New Delhi …..RESPONDENT Date of Institution-11.02.2020 Date of Order- 28.11.2025

    O R D E R

    RITU GARODIA-MEMBER

    1. The complaint pertains to deficiency in services on part of OP.

    2. Facts as stated in the complaint are that on 06.06.2018, the complainant had brought 15 packets of his household goods and his used car, 12 years old BMW 320i series, in a container from Namibia to Delhi, India. The complainant purchased this car in Namibia for INR 3.5 lakhs in 2016 and extensively used for two years. It is stated that the value of the car in Namibia in March, 2018 was Rs.1,73,000/-. It is further alleged that the value of the car in India was Rs.7,00,000/- in June 2018.

    3. It is also stated that the custom duty of Rs.15,00,000/- was imposed on the said car. Accordingly, the complainant submitted a letter dated 26.06.2018 to Concor indicating surrender of said car for auction. The complainant also requested delivery of 15 packets of household goods.

    4. It is stated that the Customs Department approved his request vide letter dated 10.07.2018. The complainant requested the Chief Manager CONCOR, ICD, Tughlakabad, and the Customs Commissioner, ICD, Tughlakabad, vide his letters dated 18.05.2019 for delivery of 15 packets of household goods and market price of

    2

    this car.

    5. The complainant prays for handing over his 15 packets of household items, market price of his car or payment of a sum of Rs.8,00,000/- along with interest @18% and Rs.10,00,000/- towards harassment and Rs.20,000/- for litigation charges.

    6. The matter was taken up on admission. Vide Order dated 13.12.2021, Customs were deleted from the array of parties as being beyond the Commission's jurisdiction. Notice was only issued to Concor, ICD, Tughlakabad and OP2 i.e. The Customs Commissioner, ICD, Tughlakabad were dropped from the array of parties.

    7. OP in its reply stated that OP is a public sector undertaking and is governed by rules and regulation framed thereunder. It is stated that OP strictly follows the procedure laid down for disposal of unclaimed goods as per Custom Act.

    8. It is further stated that warehousing of unclaimed goods and auction of the same is not a contractual obligation towards the complainant, but a statutory duty imposed on OP. Disposal of unclaimed imported goods are done under supervision and permission of custom authority. Charges levied for warehousing and auction of such goods are as per the provision of customs Act.

    9. In the facts of the present case OP states that the goods of the complainant were transported as per contractual obligation without any delay. The consignment reached the ICD/TKD on 06.06.2018 that was not claimed due to custom duty dispute with custom departments.

    10. OP clarifies that delivery of goods/container can be done only after 'Custom Out of Charge' Certificate (COOC) is obtained and after payment of demurrage charges, ground rent and other charges incurred on the goods. Total demurrage charges due on the container as on 07.04.2022 was Rs.31,46,635/-.

    3

    11. OP states that the consignments of the complainant lay unclaimed/undeclared at ICD/TKD. Inventory was conducted on 29.10.2020 for the purpose of disposing of goods. Vide letter dated 24.02.2020, a NOC for disposal u/s 48 of the Custom Act, 1962, of consignment were sought and granted by custom department with remark that 'For BMW car-examination may be conducted in the presence of SIIB for ascertaining the year of manufacturing and other policy condition before their auction. Old and unused clothes are required to be sold to registered Co-operative societies as boards, Circular No.711/2/98-CUS (As) dated 11.02.1998.'

    12. OP prays for dismissal of the complaint.

    13. The complainant has filed rejoinder in consonance with averments made in the complaint.

    14. The complainant has filed his evidence by way of affidavit and exhibited the following documents:

    i) Copy of letter dated 26.06.2018 is exhibited as Annexure A.

    ii) Copy of letter dated 10.07.2023 is exhibited as Annexure B.

    iii) Copy of letter dated 18.05.2019 and 24.05.2019 is exhibited as Annexure C and Annexure D.

    iv) Copy of documents pertaining to the Cargo, seaway bill etc. are exhibited as Annexure E.

    15. OP has filed its evidence by way of affidavit and exhibited the following documents:

    i) Copy of written submission is exhibited as Annexure A.

    ii) Copy of terminal charges is exhibited as Annexure B.

    iii) Copy of ledger showing due dates is annexed as Annexure C.

    iv) Copy of SOP is exhibited as Annexure D.

    v) Copy of letter of auction levy charges is annexed as Annexure E. However, Annexure C and D are copies of letters dated 18.05.2019.

    4

    16. The Commission has considered the documents on record. It is admitted by both the parties that complainant had engaged the service of OP for transport of household goods and a car from Namibia to Delhi, India.

    17. The complainant vide letter dated 26.07.2018 to OP made the following request:

    Due to financial crisis I am not in a position to pay the custom duty approx. Rs.15 lakhs which is supposed to be charged by custom on car. I'm ready to surrender the car and not able to take the delivery. Kindly auction the same. Kindly allow me do de-stuff the car from the container and keep in your warehouse, The charges of the warehouse can be compensating from the auction amount. It is requested to allow me to take the delivery of 15 packets of unaccompanied baggage which is already been cleared from custom.

    18. The Dy. Commissioner Customs, ICD, Tughlakabad, sent a letter dated --.07.2018 to the complainant which is as follows:

    Please refer to your letter dated 26.06.2018 regarding relinquishment of "Used BMW Car 320i" imported vide Bill of Entry No. 6683732 dated 06.06.2018 and clearance of unaccompanied baggage.

    2. In this regard, it is informed that the competent authority has approved your request for relinquishment of the car under Section 23(2) of the Customs At, 1962. Further, you may take delivery of 15 packets of unaccompanied baggage which have already cleared by the Customs.

    Copy to:-

    1. The Deputy Commissioner of Customs, Import Shed, ICD, Tughllakabad.

    2. The Deputy Commissioner of Customs, Disposal Section(Import), ICD, Tughlakabad.

    It is obvious that this letter was not sent to CONCOR i.e. OP2.

    5

    19. OP vide letter dated 30.10.2018 replied as follows:

    Please refer to your letter No- Nil dated 26.06.2018 wherein you have requested this office to de-stuff the car and store the same to transit warehouse as you are not able to take the delivery of the car.

    In reference to above, this is to inform you that there is no space available for storing the car in transit warehouse as of now. So, it is requested to kindly take necessary action at your end please.

    20. The complainant vide letter dated 18.05.2019 to OP requested for release of his household goods and market price of the car.

    21. OP received a letter from Dy. Commissioner (Disposal) dated 23.02.2021 giving NOC in respect of 325 unclaimed/uncleared container. A list is annexed with the said letter which provided disposal of complainant's good as follows:

    For BMW car- examination may be conducted in presence of SIIB for ascertaining the year of manufacturing and other policy conditions required before their auction. Old and used clothes are required to be sold to registered Co-operative societies as Board's Circular No.711/2/98-CUS(AS) dated 11.02.1998.

    22. OP has filed a circular bearing no. CON/Area-1/TKD/ICD/SOP/IWH/2022/ dated 20.09.2022. Relevant Portion is as follows:

    18. For destuffing of the cargo in case of Warehouse Destuffing & Direct Destuffing containers, destuffing job order to be issued to Cargo handling operator after issuance of Customs Out of Charge (CooC). Necessary gate pass to be issued after loading of cargo on the nominated vehicle of the importer/CHA.

    23. Thus it is clear that OP has complied with the procedures laid down. OP could only release the container when it receives the Out of Charge Certificate from the customs. In fact, the customs have provided an NOC to OP to auction the car and the old and used clothes to be sold to registered co-operative societies. Hence, there is no deficiency in service on the part of OP. However, in the interest of justice, OP should hand over 15 packets of household goods to the complainant if it has not been already auctioned off or sold to co-operative societies. Parties to bear their own cost.

    6

    24. Order to be uploaded and sent to the parties free of cost. File be consigned to record room.

    ..................

    MONIKA AGGARWAL SRIVASTAVA

    PRESIDENT

    ..................

    DR. RAJENDER DHAR

    MEMBER

    ..................

    RITU GARODIA

    MEMBER

    7

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    SAURABH SUNEJA v. THE CHIEF MANAGER CONCOR
    (Nov 28, 2025)