AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    DR. SAPANA GIRISH BHATE & ANR. v. SYNDICATE BANK Through its ITS MANGGER & ANR. & 1 ORS.

    Page | 1

    IN THE NATIONAL CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION

    AT NEW DELHI

    NC/CC/589/2014

    WITH

    IA/14567/2025

    (PLACING ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTS)

    Dr. Sapana Girish Bhate & Anr. … Complainants

    Versus

    Syndicate Bank Through its Manager & Anr. … Opp. Parties

    BEFORE:

    HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE A.P. SAHI, PRESIDENT HON'BLE MR. BHARATKUMAR PANDYA, MEMBER

    For the Complainants : Mr. Vatsalya Vigya, Advocate For the Opp. Party - 1 : Mr. Rishi Chauhan, Advocate Mr. Rajesh Kumar Gautam, Advocate

    For the Opp. Party - 2 : Mr. Udai B. Wavikar, Advocate Mr. Sanjoy Kumar Ghosh, Advocate

    Ms. Rupali Ghosh, Advocate

    Dated : 07.01.2026

    ORDER

    1. This is a consumer complaint by the legal heirs of late Dr. Girish Shivaji Bhate who was a medical practitioner and had earned a good fortune. He had secured his savings with the OP-1 Syndicate Bank and had invested certain amount of money in Fixed / Term Deposits and had also a Savings Bank Account No. 50052010064734 in the same Bank. The complainant no. 1 is the widow and the complainant no. 2 is the son of late Dr. Girish Shivaji Bhate. He had three brothers out of whom according to the complainants, since Dr. Bhate was not keeping well and had some health issues, he was unable to

    1

    handle his accounts and other properties, therefore he had entrusted this management to one of his brothers namely Mr. Vinod Bhate. The OP-2 Mr. Rajendra Shivaji Bhate is also the real brother of Dr. Girish S. Bhate and the allegation in the complaint is that an amount of Rs. 3,40,70,140.87p which was invested in Fixed Deposit was prematurely withdrawn while he was alive and it was encashed by the OP-2 that was permitted by the OP-1 Bank without any authority to transact the premature encashment of the said Fixed Deposits. It is also the allegation of the complainant that the OP-2 Mr. Rajendra S. Bhate had no authority whatsoever to transfer the said amount to the Savings Bank Account and then to withdraw the same.

    2. The contention is that the Bank acted in an irresponsible manner by allowing this transaction to be negotiated by the OP-2 which is a clear deficiency on the part of the Bank regarding the said withdrawals that were without any authority, particularly the premature encashment of the Fixed Deposits, that too even in the lifetime of Dr. Girish S. Bhate himself.

    3. In order to appreciate the controversy and the facts relating to the disputed transactions it would be appropriate to extract the statement of Bank Account of the Savings Bank as referred to above which was entirely in the name of late Dr. Girish S. Bhate. The same is extracted hereinunder:

    Syndicate Bank

    MATUNGA MAIN, MUMBAI

    Page Number: 1 Branch code : 5005 3-A DADAR MATUNGA ESTATE Product Name : SAVINGS BANK, METRO-URBAN K A SUBRAMANIAM ROAD Account Number: 50052010064734 MATUNGA

    2

    Customer Name : Mr. GIRISH S. BHATE MUMBAI 400019

    INDIA

    Customer Address: PARMESHWAR DHAM, RAJAWADI,

    1ST FLOOR

    GHATKOPAR (EAST)

    MUMBAI

    Statement Of Accounts From 01-Nov-2010 to 27-Aug-2012 Amount in Indian Rupee Debit Credit Balance

    4,62,524.16

    73,395.61 5,35,920.07

    83,759.35 6,19,679.42

    50,969.18 6,70,648.60

    51,224.02 7,21,872.62

    06-Dec.-

    10

    06-Dec.-

    10

    TO TR INCOME

    TAX COLL

    745284 90,000.00 6,31,872.62

    01-Jan-

    11

    01-Jan-

    11

    50054030005153 34,612.00 6,66,484.82

    01-Jan-

    11

    01-Jan-

    11

    50054030005153 34,440.00 7,00,924.82

    01-Jan-

    11

    01-Jan-

    11

    50054030005153 56,596.40 7,57,521.22

    01-Jan-

    11

    01-Jan-

    11

    50054030005153 49,593.60 8,07,114.82

    01-Jan-

    11

    01-Jan-

    11

    50054030005153 16,129.40 8,23,244.22

    10-Jan-

    11

    10-Jan-

    11

    50054030005153 99,32,465.54 1,06,55,709.76

    10-Jan-

    11

    10-Jan-

    11

    50054030005153 96,15,072.44 1,92,71,582.20

    10-Jan-

    11

    10-Jan-

    11

    50054030005153 28,02,152.95 2,20,73,735.15

    10-Jan-

    11

    10-Jan-

    11

    50054030005153 60,13,160.97 2,80,86,896.12

    10-Jan-

    11

    10-Jan-

    11

    50054030005153 59,83,244.75 3,40,70,140.87

    12-Jan-

    11

    12-Jan-

    11

    TO TR

    RAJENDRA

    SHIVAJ

    745285 75,90,000.00 2,64,80,140.87

    12-Jan-

    11

    12-Jan-

    11

    TO TR

    RAJENDRA

    SHIVAJ

    745286 68,50,000.00 1,96,30,140.87

    12-Jan-

    11

    12-Jan-

    11

    TO TR

    RAJENDRA

    SHIVAJ

    745287 82,30,000.00 1,14,00,140.87

    12-Jan-

    11

    12-Jan-

    11

    TO TR

    RAJENDRA

    SHIVAJ

    745290 50,75,000.00 55,25,140.87

    12-Jan-

    11

    12-Jan-

    11

    TO TR

    RAJENDRA

    SHIVAJ

    745289 37,85,000.00 17,40,140.87

    3

    10-Mar-

    11

    10-Mar-

    11

    TO TR INCOME

    TAX COLL

    745291 1,00,000.00 16,40,140.87

    31-Mar-

    11

    31-Mar-

    11

    CREDIT

    INTEREST

    CAPIT

    24,648.61 16,64,799.48

    23-Jun-

    11

    23-Jun-

    11

    TO TR

    SIDDHARTH R.

    BHA

    745292 16,50,000.00 14,789.48

    14-Sep-

    11

    14-Sep-

    11

    TO TR

    SIDDHARTH R.

    BHA

    130592 50,000.00 64,789.48

    14-Sep-

    11

    14-Sep-

    11

    TO TR DIERCT

    TAXES 50

    745293 50,000.00 14,789.48

    30-Sep-

    11

    30-Sep-

    11

    CREDIT

    INTEREST

    CAPIT

    14,575.03 29,364.51

    09-Dec-

    11

    09-Dec-

    11

    TO TR

    SIDDHARTH R.

    BHA

    130593 50,000.00 79,364.51

    09-Dec-

    11

    09-Dec-

    11

    TO TR DIRECT

    TAXES 50

    745294 50,000.00 29,364.51

    12-Mar-

    12

    12-Mar-

    12

    BY TR

    SIDDHARTH R.

    BHA

    753026 30,000.00 59,364.51

    13-Mar-

    12

    13-Mar-

    12

    TO TR DIRECT

    TAXES 50

    745295 25,000.00 34,364.51

    31-Mar-

    12

    31-Mar-

    12

    CREDIT

    INTEREST

    CAPIT

    602.56 34,967.07

    Totals 3,42,95,000.00 3,43,29,967.07

    4. The entries which are relevant in the above transacted account are in relation to the term deposit receipts that were received in the account on 10.01.2011 and then its withdrawal on 12.01.2011 by the OP-2 Mr. Rajendra Shivaji Bhate as highlighted above.

    5. There is one important aspect of the matter which needs to be mentioned at this stage which is that this complaint remained pending with exchange of affidavits after having been filed on 18.12.2014. Notices were issued to both the OPs and learned counsel for the OP's have appeared and have filed their responses. The OP-2 is represented by Mr. Uday B. Wavikar and Mr. Sanjoy Kumar Ghosh, who have also appeared online and have

    4

    advanced their submissions. During the pendency of the complaint, the written statements were taken on record and the W.S. of OP-2 was accepted on payment of Rs. 10,000/- as costs. Rejoinder and evidences were exchanged thereafter and the matter remained pending when the covid pandemic intervened. The matter proceeded for exchange of affidavits and pleadings thereafter. It may be pointed out that the matter had proceeded ex-parte against the Bank which order was set aside on 22.02.2022 and further time was granted for filing of written synopsis and completing the pleadings. The case was adjourned on several dates and could not be taken up for one reason or the other. The matter was ultimately taken up on 14.01.2025 when the following order was passed by the Bench hearing the matter:

    Heard learned counsel for the Complainant briefly.

    Essentially the matter pertains to certain transactions and withdrawals from the bankaccount of the spouse of the Complainant who was the account holder with the Opposite Party Bank by Mr. Rajendra Shivaji Bhate who is the brother of the deceased account holder.

    It is the contention of the widow of the account holder that her husband never authorized his brother, Opposite Party No.2 to make any transactions from his account in the Opposite Party Bank and that allowing of such volume of transactions from the Opposite Party Bank in favour of Opposite Party No.2 is illegal and the Bank is liable to compensate back the amounts in the account. On the other hand, learned Counsel appearing for Syndicate Bank (Opposite Party No.1) states that the account holder late Sh. Girish Shivaji Bhate had infact authorized the transactions to be undertaken vide letter dated 31.10.2005 from the SB Account no.40486 authorizing his brother Mr. Rajendra Shivaji Bhate to make the transactions.

    Careful perusal of the records reveals similar authorization on the same date and the same account in favour of Mr. Vinod Shivaji Bhate (stated to be son of late Sh. Girish Shivaji Bhate ) also.

    5

    However, both the said letters of authorization neither have complete name and associated details of the person so authorized as well as their specimen signatures. Further the name of the deceased account holder mentioned as S. S. Bhate, while, on the other hand, the Power of Attorney (Annexures A) at page 41 brought on record by Opposite Party No.2 states that Mr. Girish Bhate had signed as Girish Shivaji Bhate.

    On being queried about the difference in names and signatures as well as the absence of specimen signatures by persons so authorized in the letter of authority issued by the account holder, learned Counsel for the Opposite Party Bank seeks short accommodation to clarify on this issue. Learned Counsel for the Opposite Party No.2 states that he has been wrongfully impleaded as party in the case and that there is no consumer service provider relationship between him and the Complainant. Also in the Complaint no relief is sought against him.

    Considering the nature of the case and the allegations involved, we consider it appropriate to provide an opportunity to the parties to bring on record the requisite facts as stated above.

    All the parties are granted two weeks' time to file any additional document they wish to bring on record duly exchanged with each other and file objections thereto if so desired within a period of two weeks thereafter. List the matter on 20.03.2025 for final hearing.

    It is made clear that no further adjournment shall be granted in the matter.

    6. On a perusal of records, the Bench wanted a clarification from the Bank with regard to the authorisation of the transactions and some doubts were also expressed with regard to the status of signatures on authorisation documents on a comparison with the power of the attorney. Accordingly time was granted to the parties to file any additional documents for clarifying the same.

    7. Learned counsel for the Bank, Mr. Rajesh Kumar Gautam moved an affidavit vide a Dy. No. 9193 filed on 27.03.2025 bringing on record the affidavit of Mr. Pushpendra Singh Sisodia clarifying the status of authorisation

    6

    of the Bank Accounts. We will refer to the said affidavit at the appropriate stage hereinafter.

    8. Learned counsel for the OP-2 moved an application I.A. No. 14567/2025 through Dy. No. 32191 dated 05.12.2025 bringing on record certain additional documents including the proceedings of investigation by the police in respect of the criminal complaint before the Matunga Police Station in Mumbai. The police closed the complaint filed by the complainant no. 2 herein vide their intimation dated 14.08.2025 stating that the dispute was of a Civil nature and that a claim in that regard was pending before this Commission. We shall refer to the said letter later on.

    9. It is in this background that we have proceeded to hear this matter finally and learned counsel for the complainant has urged that the Bank has been unable to satisfy through any document to establish the authorisation of the transaction of the Fixed Deposits / Term Deposits and its premature encashment and then its deposits and withdrawals through the Savings Bank Accounts by the OP-2. He maintains that the OP-2 fraudulently deceived late Dr. Girish Shivaji Bhate during his lifetime and the Bank OP-1 committed a serious deficiency by allowing this transaction to have passed through thereby benefitting the OP-2 without any proper verification or authorisation and as such this deficiency deserves to be rectified. The complaint deserves to be allowed with a direction to the Bank to restore the entire amount that was allowed to be transacted and withdrawn by the OP-2.

    7

    10. The quintessence of the contention of the learned counsel for the complainants is therefore the alleged deficiency on the part of the Bank in allowing the said transaction without proper authorisation and verification and he submits that in spite of the specific query of the Bench vide a order dated 14.01.2025 quoted hereinabove, the Bank has failed to provide any letter of authorisation for the premature encashment of the Fixed Deposits / Terms Deposits that were received in the Savings Bank Account on 10thof January,

    2011.

    11. It is also urged that late Dr. Girish S. Bhate was very much alive on the date of the said transactions and he expired on 23.10.2012.

    12. Learned counsel contends that late Dr. Girish S. Bhate was helped by his brother namely Mr. Vinod Shivaji Bhate, who looked after the family business and affairs as karta of the family and it is he who helped in looking after the investments of late Dr. Girish S. Bhate. This fact has also been stated in paragraph 5 of the complaint. Unfortunately, Mr. Vinod Shivaji Bhate died on 22.11.2010. A copy of the death certificate has been filed as Annexure - C1. Learned counsel submits that apart from late Mr. Vinod Shivaji Bhate, no one else was ever been authorized by Dr. Girish S. Bhate to operate accounts or encash the deposits. There was no authorisation in favour of the OP-2 in respect of the premature encashment of the Term Deposits referred to above.

    13. It is further averred in the complaint that the complainant no. 1 was not informed about the status of the investments and that she was herself in a

    8

    peculiar mental state as Dr. Girish S. Bhate, as alleged in paragraph 6 of the complaint, had become introvert and secretive and ultimately he committed suicide on 23.10.2012. The complainant no. 1 therefore could not reconcile herself and she was herself under some medications due to heart ailment and when she started to think about her day to day affairs and made inquiry about investments, she was informed by the OP-2 that Dr. Girish S. Bhate had no properties or investments except the house in which the complainant was residing and the hospital by the name Sai Nursing Home.

    14. The complainant no. 1 has alleged in paragraph 8 that in August, 2013 efforts were made to receive information when it was revealed that the OP-2 had obtained the signatures of Dr. Girish. S. Bhate on a document purporting to be a Power of Attorney and with the help of such an unregistered document, the OP-2 had got some of the properties owned by Dr. Bhate transferred in his name.

    15. The allegation in the complaint is that on account of this deception further enquiries were made when the complainant came to know about the Bank investments and started searching for documents and then the details of the Saving Bank Account number referred to above was obtained revealing that the OP-2 had encashed the Term / Fixed Deposits of Dr. Girish S. Bhate and had withdrawn a huge amount of Rs. 3,40,70,140.87 p. and had transferred the amount in his own account and in the name of his son Siddharth R. Bhate.

    9

    16. It is thereafter a letter was dispatched on 27.09.2013 to the Bank to which a reply was given on 12.10.2013 by the Bank that the transactions had been duly authorized by Dr. Girish S. Bhate in favour of his two brothers Mr. Vinod S. Bhate and Mr. Rajendra S. Bhate for the purpose of operations of the accounts. It was further disclosed that the transactions have taken place through cheques signed by the OP-2 and the particulars were given. This letter dated 12.10.2013 has been filed as Annexure-C5.

    17. The complainants have also come forward with a case in paragraph 12 that the authorisation was only to Mr. Vinod Shivaji Bhate, who was already dead on 22.11.2010 and even otherwise the said authorisation does not indicate the correct signatures of Dr. Girish S. Bhate which do not match with his other signatures. As such there was no authority in favour of the OP-2 at all. A legal notice was sent on 19.08.2014 whereafter the present complaint was filed.

    18. Learned counsel submits that as indicated above, the documents which have been brought on record by the Bank on 27.03.2025 is only a one page account opening application form stated to have been signed by Dr. Girish S. Bhate and the said document is no proof or evidence of authorization for transacting the premature encashment of the Fixed / Term Deposits which was siphoned off by the OP-2 and in the absence of any such authorisation for such premature encashment, the Bank has committed a serious deficiency by allowing the said amount to be transacted and withdrawn on 10thand 12thof January, 2011.

    10

    19. The contentions have been disputed by the learned counsel for the Bank urging that the authorisation in favour of Mr. Vinod and the OP No. 2 is established, in as much as, the authorisation was in favour of the two brothers of Dr. Girish Shivaji Bhate, namely Mr. Vinod Shivaji Bhate and the OP-2 Rajendra Shivaji Bhate. Learned counsel for the Bank therefore urged that the authorisation was complete and there was no deficiency at all. The authorisation had been issued by the Account holder himself and the documents have already been brought on record demonstrating that the Account holder had issued proper authorisations and the transactions were carried out as per the said authorisation which was duly intimated to the complainants.

    20. Mr. Wavikar and Mr. Ghosh for the OP-1 have urged that as a matter of fact the transactions are of January, 2011 and Dr. Girish Shivaji Bhate died almost 10 months thereafter on 23.10.2012. The transactions and withdrawals had been made during his lifetime and there was no objection or complaint of any kind regarding the said withdrawals either by Dr. Bhate who was still alive nor did the complainants ever raise such issue. It is long after the death of Dr. Bhate that the complainants attempted to malign the OP-2 by making allegations which are absolutely unsubstantiated. At the outset, however, it was urged that the nature of the allegations are such which cannot be gone into in a consumer complaint and even otherwise there is no consumer service provider relationship between the complainant and the OP-2.

    11

    Consequently, the complaint deserves to be dismissed and even otherwise the deletion of the name of the OP-2 has been prayed for.

    21. Mr. Wavikar has invited the attention of the Bench to the documents that have been introduced through I.A. No. 14567/2025. He submits that the complainants had instituted a police complaint some time in June, 2025 alleging fraud against the OP-2 in respect of the incidents of the year 2011. The police had summoned the OP-2 vide notice dated 20.07.2025 to which a reply was given and the statement of the son of the OPO-2 Mr. Siddharth Bhate was recorded on 03.08.2025. It is therefore alleged that with all the material on record it is more than evident that all the transactions regarding the encashment of the deposits and its withdrawals were done during the lifetime of Dr. Girish S. Bhate and no objection whatsoever was raised in this regard either before the Bank or before any other forum. It is only after the death that all these issues were raked up in the year 2013 with the filing of the present complaint in the year 2014 and then the police complaint being moved in the year 2025. It is therefore urged that the complaint has no merits as it is a pure claim of succession and inheritance which cannot be entertained under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986.

    22. We have perused the reply filed on behalf of the Bank as also the reply filed on behalf of the OP-2. The reply of the Bank was filed on 12.05.2016 through Dy. No. 18292 and the reply of the OP-2 was filed on 05.02.2016 vide Dy. No. 5574 that are on record. A rejoinder has been filed on behalf of the complainant which seems to be a sort of a joint rejoinder to both the replies.

    12

    23. On a perusal of the documents on record, we find that the complainants along with their complaint have filed Annexure C-6 which is at page no. 29 of the paperbook. This document has been described in paragraph 12 of the complaint to have been given by the Bank which demonstrates that the authority to operate the account was allegedly given by Dr. Girish S. Bhate to his brother Mr. Vinod Shivaji Bhate, but it is alleged by the complainant that the said document does not match with the original signatures of Dr. Girish S. Bhate. This document of authorisation is dated 27.03.2006. This allegation in paragraph 12 and the said document have been denied by the Bank in paragraph 13 of their reply. On the other hand, the Bank has come up with the letters of authority issued in favour of the OP-2 Rajendra Shivaji Bhate with an endorsement also on a nomination register. What is more relevant is the document dated 15.09.2008 that has been filed by the OP-2 bearing the stamp of the Syndicate Bank that is on record of the reply of OP-2 and has also been filed along with I.A. No. 14567/2025. The said document is extracted hereinunder:

    13

    24. This letter confirms the issuance of the letter of authority in favour of Mr. Vinod Shivaji Bhate and the OP-2 with a further indication that a Power of Attorney was also executed in their favour as well.

    25. The affidavit filed by the Bank under the directions of this Court is also accompanied by an account opening form regarding the Savings Bank Account through which the amounts have been transacted. The contents of the affidavit filed on behalf of the Bank dated 24.03.2025 are extracted hereinunder:

    1. That I am PUSHPENDRA SINGH SISODIA Respondent No.1 and am well conversant with the facts and circumstances of the present case on the basis of official record and competent to depose the present affidavit.

    2. That this Hon'ble Court by order dated 14.01.2025, for the reasons mentioned therein, has permitted the Respondent Bank to place on record any document to show that Sh. Girish Shivaji Bhate the customer of the Bank has authorized his brother Sh. Rajinder S. Bahte to operate his Account/make transactions. This Hon'ble Court by further order dated 20.03.2025 has been pleased to grant further 01 week time to the Respondent Bank to place the aforementioned document on record.

    3. That pursuant to the directions passed by this Hon'ble Court and the liberty so granted, the Respondent Bank is placing on record the "Application for Opening of a Saving / Current Account Individual/Joint / Proprietorship" duly signed by Girish S. Bathe in respect of Account No. 50052010064734 whereby he has authorized Vinod S. Bhate and Rajinder S. Bhate. The instructions in Para 4.1 of the Form reads as under:-

    "4.1. We request and authorize you, until any one of us shall give you notice in writing to the contrary, to honour all cheques or other orders drawn or Bills of Exchange accepted or notes made on our behalf signed by Vinod S. Bhate/Rajendra S. Bhate of us jointly and/or severally and to debit such cheques to our account with you whether such account be for the time being in credit or overdrawn. We also request you to accept the endorsement of Vinod S. Bhate /

    14

    Rajendra S. Bhate of us jointly and/or severally on Cheques, Orders, Bills or Notes payable to us."

    4. That a copy of the aforementioned Application duly signed by G.S Bhate which is available on the record of the Bank is annexed herewith and marked as Annexure A-1.

    5. That the statement of facts contained in the Affidavit are true and correct to my knowledge derived from the records of the case.

    6. That the statements of legal submission contained in the Affidavit are based upon the advice of the counsel and believed to be correct and proper.

    7. That the annexures are copies of their original and are believed by me to be true and correct.

    26. Along with the said affidavit, the Account Opening Form 64734 has been filed and the same is extracted hereinunder:

    15

    27. A perusal of the said Account Opening Form in column 4 clearly indicates an authorisation in favour of Mr. Vinod S. Bhate and Mr. Rajendra S. Bhate. This document has nowhere been denied or challenged even though during the course of arguments learned counsel for the complainants attempted to dispute the same. He also urged that the nomination could have operated only after the death of Dr. Girish S. Bhate and therefore there was no question of the premature encashing of the term deposits and the withdrawal thereof through the Savings Bank Account during the life-time of Dr. Bhate by the OP-2.

    28. It is evident that Dr. Girish S. Bhate was very much alive as on the date of transaction on 10.01.2011 and its withdrawal on 12.01.2011. No such objection seems to have been taken either by Dr. Bhate or by the complainant in any capacity whatsoever and there is no evidence before this Commission to that effect.

    29. The argument of the learned counsel for the complainant is that the Bank was deficient in allowing the withdrawals without proper authorisation.

    30. Clause 4.1 in the Account Opening Form quoted above clearly authorises Mr. Vinod S. Bhate and Mr. Rajendra S. Bhate to transact the same. Thus, the Savings Bank Account could have been operated and the Bank cannot be said to have acted deficiently by permitting the OP-2 from operating the said Savings Bank Account. It may be noted that Mr. Vinod S. Bhate had already died in 2010 and the transactions are of 2011. As such, it is obvious that the OP-2 remained the only authorised person to operate the

    16

    account. Not only this, the letter dated 15.09.2008 is also on record which indicates the intimation of authorisation to the Bank to both the brothers namely Mr. Vinod S. Bhate and Mr. Rajendra S. Bhate as well as the execution of some Power of Attorney.

    31. Coupled with these facts, we cannot lose sight of the fact that Dr. Girish S. Bhate was very much alive on the date of the transaction and he died on 23.10.2012 almost 10 months thereafter. There is nothing on record to indicate any objection either by the account holder or by anybody else having been raised and according to the complainants it was for the first time that such enquiries were made in August, 2013 whereafter details were sought and the present complaint was filed in 2014.

    32. With these transactions, in this summary jurisdiction, we cannot castigate the OP-1 Bank for any deficiency in service or lack of exercise of diligence in allowing the account to be operated by the OP-2. In the face of these documents, it cannot be said that the Bank was acting negligently and was deficient in allowing the said transactions.

    33. Learned counsel for the complainant has vehemently urged that even assuming for the sake of arguments that there was an authorisation in the Bank Account Opening Form for operating the Savings Bank Account, the same is no authorisation for the premature encashment of the Fixed Deposit. We may point out that the Fixed Deposits which were encashed, were lodged in the same Savings Bank Account of the Account Holder Dr. Girish S. Bhate who was very much alive and who had executed the authorisation. It is from

    17

    the said account that the money was thereafter transferred and withdrawn by the OP-2, and as alleged was also deposited in the account of his son. We cannot assume in the absence of any cogent material that all this transaction of a huge amount of Rs. 3 Crores and odd was carried out without the knowledge of Dr. Bhate or for that matter his family members. Nonetheless, there is nothing on record to indicate that Dr. Bhate was unaware or unmindful of these transactions. During the course of arguments learned counsel for the complainants urged that Dr. Bhate was depressed and he was actually not in a position to communicate about these transactions and it is possible that he had no knowledge about the same. This allegation in this summary jurisdiction cannot be tried nor it has been proved that Dr. Bhate was mentally incapable of understanding these transactions of such a huge amount. It may require leading of evidence and comprehensive assessment which cannot be entertained by us in this complaint under the Consumer Protection Act.

    34. In these circumstances, we cannot find the Bank to be liable for any deficiency and what appears is that this may be a dispute amongst the family members about succession which cannot be tried in this jurisdiction. The complainants could have applied for a Succession Certificate or instituted a regular Suit as we find that the argument of the OP-2 is correct that there is no consumer service provider relationship between the complainant and the OP-

    2.

    35. Thus, the complaint cannot proceed against the Bank for any alleged deficiency and so far as the OP-2 is concerned, in the absence of any such

    18

    relationship of consumer and service provider, the complaint against the said OP is also liable to be dismissed. The complainants if they have any claim regarding succession over the disputed amount, it was always open to them to have approached the competent forum for any such declaration or orders from the appropriate forum about which they are at liberty to do so in accordance with law.

    36. At this juncture, we may add that the OP-2 also has filed I.A. No. 14567/2025 which brings on record the notice issued by the Matunga Police Station, Mumbai on 20.07.2025. A translated version of the said notice is reproduced hereinunder:

    19

    37. The OP-2 gave a reply to the same on 24.07.2025 which is extracted hereinunder:

    20

    38. The police also recorded the statement of the son of the OP-2 on 03.08.2025 which is extracted hereinunder:

    21

    39. After investigation and after going through the documents and the authorisation documents including the Savings Bank Opening Form referred to above, the complainant no. 2 was intimated about the closure of the case being a Civil dispute vide a letter dated 14.08.2025 of the Sr. Police Inspector, Matunga Police Station, Mumbai. The same is extracted hereinunder:

    22

    40. Even though these documents are in relation to a police investigation, yet these circumstances also reflect the existence of a pure civil dispute relating to succession or claims arising therefrom.

    41. In the absence of any deficiency in service, the complaint therefore cannot be maintained for all the reasons given hereinabove and is accordingly dismissed without prejudice to the rights of the complainants to approach the appropriate forum for the Redressal of their grievances in accordance with law as our observations are limited to the extent of the summary jurisdiction of this Commission about deficiency in service and unfair trade practice only under the Consumer Protection Act.

    ………………………………………

    (A.P. SAHI, J)

    PRESIDENT

    ………………………………………

    (BHARATKUMAR PANDYA)

    MEMBER

    Pramod/VM/Court-1/15

    23

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    DR. SAPANA GIRISH BHATE & ANR. v. SYNDICATE BANK Through its ITS MANGGER & ANR. & 1 ORS.
    (Jan 7, 2026)