Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    ASHNA AMBROSE v. DR SRUTI S

    DISTRICT CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION

    ERNAKULAM

    CONSUMER COMPLAINT NO. DC/555/CC/181/2025

    ASHNA AMBROSE

    PRESENT ADDRESS - ERNAKULAM,KERALA. .......Complainant(s)

    Versus

    DR SRUTI S

    BUSINESS ADDRESS - ERNAKULAM,KERALA. .......Opposite Party(s)

    BEFORE:

    HON'BLE MR. D.B BINU , PRESIDENT HON'BLE MR. RAMACHANDRAN .V , MEMBER HON'BLE MRS. SREEVIDHIA T.N , MEMBER

    FOR THE COMPLAINANT:

    NEMO

    FOR THE OPPOSITE PARTY:

    NEMO

    DATED: 26/03/2025

    ORDER

    DISTRICT CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION, ERNAKULAM

    Dated this the 22nd day of March 2025

    Filed on: 10/02/2025

    PRESENT

    Shri. D.B. Binu Hon'ble President Shri. V. Ramachandran Hon'ble Member Smt. Sreevidhia T.N Hon'ble Member

    1

    CC. No. 181 of 2025 Complainant:

    Ashna Ambrose, 24 yrs, W/o Shibin, Valiyaveettil House, Chellanam.P.O, Kochi-682008.

    (Adv. M.S.Thomas, Adv. Anjana.P.A, North of Court Complex, T.B.Road, Cherthala.)

    VS

    OPPOSITE PARTY:

    Dr. Shruti.S, Gynecologist, Govt. District General Hospital, Ernakulam.

    .

    FINAL ORDER

    D.B. Binu, President

    1. A brief statement of facts of this complaint is as stated below:

    The complainant filed a complaint under Section 35 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, alleging medical negligence and deficiency of service against the opposite party, a gynecologist at the Government District General Hospital, Ernakulam. The complainant alleged that despite undergoing a tubal ligation procedure on 09.11.2022, which was performed by the opposite party with an assurance of permanent birth control, she became pregnant and delivered a baby on 12.05.2024.

    2

    The complainant alleged that the unwanted pregnancy was the result of negligence on the part of the opposite party, leading to emotional distress, financial loss, and physical hardship. The complainant sought compensation of �3,00,000/-, along with legal costs and other suitable reliefs.

    2. Issue for Consideration:

    Whether the complainant is a 'consumer' under 2 (7) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, when the medical services were provided free of charge at a government hospital by a salaried medical officer.

    3. Maintainability of Complaint under Consumer Protection Act, 2019

    The key issue is whether the complainant qualifies as a 'consumer' under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, when the medical services were provided free of charge by a government hospital. Section 2 (7) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, defines 'consumer' as follows:

    "Consumer means any person who hires or avails of any service for a consideration..."

    In the present case, the complainant has not produced any document or evidence to prove that any consideration was paid for the medical service provided by the opposite party. The medical service was rendered at a government hospital without any payment or charge. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has consistently held that free medical services rendered by government hospitals do not constitute a 'service' under the Consumer Protection Act.

    The Hon'ble Supreme Court, in the case of Nivedita Singh v. Dr. Asha Bharti and Ors. (Civil Appeal No. 103 of 2021, LL 2021 SC 721), held that:

    "The salary that is paid by the hospital administration to the

    3

    employee medical officer cannot be regarded as payment made on behalf of the person availing of the service or for his benefit so as to make the person availing the service a 'consumer' under Section 2(1)(d) in respect of the service rendered to him."

    In this case, a bench rejected an appeal on similar grounds, holding that medical services provided free of charge by a government hospital do not fall within the scope of "service" under the Consumer Protection Act.

    Similarly, in Indian Medical Association v. V.P. Shantha (1995) 6 SCC 651, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that:

    "Services rendered free of charge at a government hospital or health centre do not constitute a 'service' under the Consumer Protection Act since no consideration is involved."

    The counsel for the complainant was heard in detail. The Commission granted several opportunities to the complainant to submit evidence or establish proof of any payment or consideration for the sterilization procedure; however, the complainant failed to do so.

    Since the complainant has not demonstrated any payment or consideration for the sterilization procedure, the claim fails to satisfy the definition of "service" under the Consumer Protection Act. Based on the above analysis, this Commission finds that:

    The complainant is not a 'consumer' within the meaning of Section 2 (7) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, as no consideration was paid for the medical service provided by the opposite party. The medical service was provided free of charge by a government hospital, and as per the binding precedents of the Supreme Court, such services do not qualify as 'service' under the Act.

    4

    The complainant has failed to establish medical negligence or deficiency of service.

    Order:

    The complaint is hereby DISMISSED as not maintainable under the Consumer Protection Act 2019.

    No order as to costs.

    Pronounced in the Open Commission this the 22nd day of March, 2025. Sd/- D.B. Binu, President

    Sd/-V. Ramachandran, Member

    Sd/-Sreevidhia T.N, Member

    Forwarded/By Order Assistant Registrar istrar trar

    APPENDIX

    Complainant's Evidence:Nil Opposite Parties' Evidence: NIL

    Date of Despatch By Hand::

    By post::

    Br/-

    ..................

    D.B BINU

    PRESIDENT

    5

    ..................

    RAMACHANDRAN .V

    MEMBER

    ..................

    SREEVIDHIA T.N

    MEMBER

    6

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    ASHNA AMBROSE v. DR SRUTI S
    (Mar 26, 2025)