Per contra, the Learned Counsel for the Respondents supported the decision passed by the First Appellate Court. According to the Learned Counsel for the Respondent/Plaintiffs, documentary as well as oral evidences negate the plea of adverse possession. Giribala had never been in forceful possession. The Appellate Court, according to the Learned Counsel correctly decided the issues. The Appellant/Defendants asserted that possession of Giribala was forceful, continuous and adverse. Ext. H(1) being plaint of SCC Suit No. 122 of 1956 was field by Gnandra Nath Dey against Giribala, praying for compensation on account of use an occupation of the properties. These properties include CS Plot No. 235. In the plaint itself Giribala was mentioned as maid servant. It was further stated that Defendant was allowed to occupy CS Plot No. 239. Clearly, plaint shows that Giribala was in permissive occupation of Plot No. 239 to look after to Plot No. 235. Even it is mentioned that Plot No. 235 was in occupation of said Giribala. The Appellant/Defendants did not produce the written statement which Giribala might have been filed in that suit. Had this been produced, the stand of the Appellant/Defendants could have been clarified. Ext. No. H was the plaint in Title Suit No. 16 of 1958 filed on behalf of the deity against Giribala as well as the present Appellant/Defendants. In this plaint, it was averred that Giribala was allowed shelter as a maid servant but subsequently was driven out in Bengali month of Aashar of the Bengali year 1334. It was further pleaded that in the year BS 1351, constructions were made by the Plaintiff therein being the deity on the bank of Plot No. 235. What is pleaded was that the Defendants therein and occupied Plot No. 239, 237 & 238. In this suit, the Plaintiff being the deity prayed for recovery of possession from the Defendants being the said Giribala as well as the present
7
Appellant/Defendants. Suit property included CS Plot No. 235. The Appellant/Defendants did not produce the written statement filed in that case. Had the aforesaid written statements been produced stand and plea of the Appellant/Defendants could have been understood and considered. At least, Ext. H and H/1 shows that legal step was taken for recovery of possession from the Giribala as well as the present Appellant/Defendants which negate the claim of adverse possession by Giribala.
Appellant/Defendant No. 1 stated in course of cross-examination that Giribala used to possess the tank forcibly against Gnandra Nath Dey but not against the deity. He stated that his mother began to possess the suit tank forcibly two years after the deed of gift. The deed of gift bears dated 11/07/1928 but Ext. H and H/1 negates that plea.
The First Appellate Court considered the principal of adverse possession in its right purport. The hostile title is to be exerted against the owner of the property. In this case, the Appellant/Defendant No. 1 stated in course of cross-examination that hostile title was exerted against Gnandra Nath Dey, not against the deity being owner of the property. Therefore, even though adverse possession was pleaded that was not exerted against the true owner. Appellant/Defendant No. 1 was aware that Arpan Nama was made in favour of the deity by the said Gnandra Nath Dey. This was noted by the First Appellate Court in deciding the suit in favour of the Respondent/Plaintiffs.
On appreciation of evidence, certain things are clear. Even though forceful possession was asserted, that could not have been matured into adverse possession. Firstly, because suit for recovery of possession was instituted against Giribala as well as the Appellant/Plaintiffs. Secondly, title was exerted hostile not against the true
8
owner. Nothing is there in the record to show that they have been paying rent, therefore, the position is nothing akin to gratuitous licensee who are liable to be evicted in due process of law. The Trial Court for a queer reason failed to understand the legal position and failed to apply the same.
For reasons stated and in view of discussions made above, this Court concur with the judgment and decree passed by the First Appellate Court and uphold the same. The instant Appeal is dismissed without cost.
The Appellants are directed to deliver the possession within sixty days from passing off this appellate decree, in case of default of which, execution proceeding before the Trial Court may be initiated and the Appellant/Defendants shall be liable to pay mesne-profit, for which liberty is given to the Respondent/Plaintiffs to institute the separate suit.
The instant appeal is accordingly disposed of along with all pending applications.
Trial Court Records may be returned.
(Sugato Majumdar, J.)
9