AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    STATE OF MAHARASHTRA . v. SAHEBRAO KISHANRAO RAHANE & OTHERS.

    (1)

    FIRST APPEAL NO.569 OF 1997 WITH

    CROSS OBJECTION ST. NO.7500 OF 1998

    AND

    FIRST APPEAL NO.570 OF 1997 WITH

    CROSS OBJECTION ST.NO.7501 OF 1998

    Date of decision: 23RD MARCH, 2009 For approval and signature.

    THE HONOURABLE SHRI JUSTICE K.K. TATED

    1. Whether Reporters of Local Papers } Yes may be allowed to see the Judgment? }

    2. To be referred to the Reporter or not } Yes/No

    3. Whether Their Lordships wish to see } No the fair copy of the Judgment? }

    4. Whether this case involves a substantial } question of law as to the interpretation } No of the Constitution of India, 1950 or } any Order made thereunder? }

    5. Whether it is to be circulated to the } No Civil Judges? }

    6. Whether the case involves an important } question of law and whether a copy of } No the Judgment should be sent to Mumbai, } Nagpur and Panaji offices? }

    [A.S. Bhagwat)

    Personal Assistant to

    the Honourable Judge.

    1

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

    BENCH AT AURANGABAD.

    FIRST APPEAL NO.569 OF 1997

    IN

    LAND ACQUISITION REFERENCE NO.129 OF 1983

    The State of Maharashtra

    .... APPELLANT.

    VERSUS

    1) Sahebrao Kishanrao Rahane, Age-48 years, Occu:Govt. Service, R/o-Andhaner, Tq-Kannad, Dist-Aurangabad.

    2) Mansabrao Kishanrao Rahane, Age-46 years, Occu:Agril., R/o-Andhaner, Tq-Kannad, Dist-Aurangabad.

    .... RESPONDENTS.

    WITH

    CROSS OBJECTION ST. NO.7500 OF 1998

    IN

    FIRST APPEAL NO.569 OF 1997

    1) Sahebrao Kishanrao Rahane, Age-57 years, Occu:Retd. Govt. Servant & Agril., R/o-Andhaner, Tq-Kannad, Dist-Aurangabad.

    2) Mansabrao Kishanrao Rahane, Age-55 years, Occu:Agril., R/o-Andhaner, Tq-Kannad, Dist-Aurangabad.

    ....APPELLANTS.

    (CROSS OBJECTION PETITIONERS)

    2

    VERSUS

    1) The State of Maharashtra, Through the Collector, District-Aurangabad.

    2) The Special Land Acquisition Officer, Ambadi Project, Andhaner, Tq-Kannad,

    District-Aurangabad.

    ....RESPONDENT.

    AND

    FIRST APPEAL NO.570 OF 1997

    IN

    LAND ACQUISITION REFERENCE NO.123 OF 1983

    The State of Maharashtra

    ...APPELLANT

    VERSUS

    1) Suryabhan Bisanrao Rahane, Age-44 years, Occu:Agril., R/o-Andhaner, Tq-Kannad, Dist-Aurangabad.

    2) Baburao Bisanrao Rahane, Age-42 years, Occu:Agril., R/o-Andhaner, Tq-Kannad, Dist-Aurangabad.

    .... RESPONDENTS.

    WITH

    CROSS OBJECTION ST. NO.7501 OF 1998

    IN

    FIRST APPEAL NO.570 OF 1997

    1) Suryabhan Bisanrao Rahane, Age-45 years, Occu:Agril., R/o-Andhaner, Tq-Kannad, Dist-Aurangabad.

    2) Baburao Bisanrao Rahane, Age-43 years, Occu:Agril.,

    3

    R/o-Andhaner, Tq-Kannad, Dist-Aurangabad.

    .... APPELLANTS.

    (CROSS OBJECTION PETITIONER)

    VERSUS

    1) The State of Maharashtra, Through the Collector, District-Aurangabad,

    2) The Special Land Acquisition Officer, Ambadi Project, Andhaner, Dist-Aurangabad.

    .... RESPONDENTS.

    ...

    Mr.S.P. Dound, A.G.P. for Appellants in both the First Appeals and for Respondents in both Cross Objections.

    Mr.S.K. Rahane - party in person for himself and for other Appellants in Cross Objections and for Respondents in both First Appeals.

    ...

    CORAM: K.K. TATED, J.

    RESERVED ON : 17TH MARCH, 2009.

    PRONOUNCED ON: 23RD MARCH, 2009.

    COMMON JUDGMENT:

    1. Heard learned counsel for the parties.

    2. The undisputed facts in the present case are that Special Land Acquisition Officer (for short "S.L.A.O.") issued Notification of the Land Acquisition Act dated 17th January, 1974 for

    4

    acquiring Respondents'/ original claimants' land from village Andhaner Taluka Kannad, Dist-Aurangabad. for Ambadi Medium Project. Thereafter the S.L.A.O. issued Notification under Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act dated 17th August, 1975. After following due process of law, S.L.A.O. declared award dated 4th June, 1977 and awarded compensation of Rs.28,915.46 Paisa for land and Rs.13,980/- for fruit bearing trees in First Appeal No.570 of 1997 and a sum of Rs.1,31,577/- for land and Rs.14,523/- for fruit bearing trees in First Appeal No.569 of 1997. Being aggrieved by the said award, Respondents/ original claimants preferred Reference under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act. In the said Reference, the Respondents/ original claimants claimed enhanced compensation in respect of land as well as fruit bearing trees. The Reference Court by Judgment and award dated 1st October, 1992 awarded additional compensation of Rs.1,56,143.84 Paisa in First Appeal No.570 of 1997 and Rs.1,66,685/- as additional compensation in First Appeal No.569 of 1997.

    3. Being aggrieved by the Judgment and award

    5

    passed by the Reference Court, the State of Maharashtra preferred above mentioned Appeals on the ground that the Reference Court erred in coming to the conclusion that the claimants are entitled to enhanced compensation in respect of fruit bearing trees as well as land. Learned A.G.P. Mr. Dound submitted that the Reference Court without ascertaining number of trees, accepted number of trees which was stated by the claimants and granted compensation at the rate of Rs.3000/- per tree erroneously. Learned A.G.P. further submitted that the Reference Court erred in coming to the conclusion that the claimants are entitled to compensation in respect of acquired land at the rate of Rs.5000/- per acre though the claimants failed to produce any cogent evidence to show that they are entitled to enhanced compensation for land.

    4. On the other hand Respondent No.1 S.B. Rahane who appeared in person on his behalf as well as on behalf of Respondent No.2 - his brother, submitted that the Reference Court erred in coming to the conclusion that the claimants are entitled to compensation in respect of 42 mango

    6

    trees in each matter at the rate of Rs.3000/- per tree only. He submitted that the Reference Court ought to have held that the claimants are entitled to compensation in respect of acquired mango trees at the rate of Rs.8000/- per tree. He further submitted that the Reference Court erred in coming to the conclusion that the claimants are entitled to compensation in respect of acquired land at the rate of Rs.5000/- per acre only. He submitted that on the basis of sale deeds produced by the claimants in Reference Court, claimants are entitled to compensation in respect of acquired land at the rate of Rs.20,000/- per acre.

    5. In both the matters, the claimants have filed their Cross Objections for enhanced compensation in respect of acquired land as well as mango trees. In Cross Objections claimants claimed compensation in respect of fruit bearing mango trees at the rate of Rs.8000/- per tree and for land at the rate of Rs.20,000/- per acre.

    6. It is admitted position that though the Appellant State of Maharashtra filed their written statement before the Reference Court, they failed

    7

    to examine any witness to prove that the claimants are not entitled to enhanced compensation in respect of acquired land. Not only that the S.L.A.O. at the time of forwarding the Reference under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act along with his letter dated 12th February, 1982 to the Reference Court, failed and neglected to forward even copy of award passed by him. The Reference Court specifically observed in para 8 of the Judgment that along with Reference, original Record and Proceedings, award, statement E etc. were not sent by the S.L.A.O. The Reference Court further observed that inspite of several letters sent to the S.L.A.O. for sending the record, he failed to do so. Therefore, the Reference Court directed the claimants to produce copy of award in respect of acquisition of present lands and same was produced by claimants at Exhibit 57. This itself shows the negligence on the part of the S.L.A.O. to take appropriate steps in Court matters.

    7. On the other hand the claimants entered into Witness Box. Their evidence is recorded at Exhibit 24. It is specifically stated by the

    8

    claimant that their entire land was black cotton soil land and to the Eastern side of the land, Shiva river was flowing. Claimant further stated that in the year 1972 they installed electric motor. Claimant stated that they were taking cash crops like cotton, sugar cane, wheat, jawar, bajara, rice, chilli etc. They were supplying sugar cane to Godawari Sugar Factory in Laxmiwadi in the name of Bharat. To prove the supply of sugar cane to the sugar factory, claimants have produced receipts issued by the sugar factory on record. They also submitted 7/12 extract showing the position of their cultivation of acquired land. Those are at Exhibit 26 and 27. 7/12 extracts clearly show that the acquired land was Bagayat land. In support of their contention, the claimants relied on in all 10 sale deeds. Exhibit 16 is a sale deed dated 8/8/1974 in respect of 4 acres of land which was sold for Rs.17,500/-. The land involved in this Exhibit 16 sale deed is about 1 k.m. away from the acquired land and therefore the same cannot be considered for fixing the market value. Second sale deed is at Exhibit 17 dated 5/4/1973 in respect of 3.35 acres of land sold for Rs.18,000/-. The land in the said sale

    9

    deed is about 2 k.m. away from acquired land and therefore the same cannot be considered for fixing the market value. The third sale deed is at Exhibit 19 dated 18/5/1977 in respect of 3 acres of land sold for Rs.35,000/-. The rate comes to Rs.11,666/- per acre. The land involved in this sale deed at Exhibit 19 is about 2 k.m. away from acquired land. Fourth sale deed is at Exhibit 18 dated 20/5/1971 in respect of one acres of land which was sold for Rs.4000/- per acre. The land involved in Exhibit 18 is about one mile away from the acquired land. Fifth sale deed is at Exhibit 20 dated 22/3/1978 in respect of 4.17 acres of land sold for Rs.39,000/-. The land involved in this sale deed is about one mile away from acquired land. The rate comes to Rs.8813/- per acre. The sixth sale deed is at Exhibit 21 dated 7th October, 1976 in respect of 5.07 acres of land sold for Rs.27,000/-. The rate comes to Rs.5217/- per acre. The seventh sale deed is at Exhibit 24 dated 15/7/1971 in respect of 1.20 acres of land sold for Rs.4000/-. This land is about one mile away from the acquired land. Eighth sale deed is at Exhibit 22 dated 27/5/1976 in respect of 2.02 acres of land sold for Rs.18,000/-. The land

    10

    involved in this sale deed Exhibit 22 is adjacent to the acquired land. The approximate rate comes to Rs.8780/- per acre. Ninth sale deed is at Exhibit 23 dated 31/10/1974 in respect of 0.25 acres of land. The land sold for Rs.12000/-. The land is about 1 k.m. away from acquired land. The rate comes to Rs.19,200/- per acre. Tenth sale deed is at Exhibit 24A dated 13/2/1974 in respect of 6.11 acres of land sold at Rs.31,250/-. The land involved in this sale deed is about 1 k.m. away from the acquired land.

    8. The Reference Court for fixing the market value of the acquired land, relied on sale deeds at Exhibit 17, 18 and 24. On the basis of average of these sale deeds, the Reference Court decided the market value of the acquired land at the rate of Rs.5000/- per acre. The method adopted by the Reference Court is not correct. When Exhibit 22 i.e. sale deed dated 27/5/1976 in which the land was adjacent to the acquired land, was available on record for fixing the market value of the acquired land, the Reference Court has taken average method for fixing the valuation in the present case. The land involved in Exhibit 22 was

    11

    Jirayat land whereas the land acquired by the Appellants was Bagayat land. The claimants specifically pointed out that their lands were situated near to the river and water was available for entire year. Claimants further submitted that they were taking Bagayat crops through out the year. If the two crops were taken from the land then the said land has to be treated as Bagayat land. In support of this submission, learned counsel for claimants relied on Apex Court Judgment in the matter of Kallu vs. State of U.P. and others, reported in AIR 1990 Supreme Court, Page 477. The Apex Court held that different kinds of tests on the basis of which the authorities have to determine whether a land is irrigated land or not for the purpose of determining prevailing market rate are that:

    (1) availability of irrigation facilities and

    (2) the factum of raising or the capability of the soil for raising at least two crops in a agricultural year.

    . Para 10 of the said Judgment reads as under:

    12

    10. As regards the second contention relating to sub-clause (b), the clause refers only to the growing of at least two crops in a land found to be having assured irrigation facility in anyone of the relevant years. The sub-clause does not contemplate the raising of two crops on the entire extent of the land. The classification has to be made with reference to the potentiality of the land to yield two crops in one Fasli year and not on the basis of the actual raising of two crops on the entire extent of the land. Therefore, sub-clause (b) cannot be read so as to mean that two crops should have been grown on the entire extent of a land having irrigation facility for classifying the land as 'irrigated land' as it would have the effect of limiting the operation of the sub-clause contrary to the legislative intent. The High Court has taken the view that when the Legislature made amendments to the Act, it must have had in mind the advancement that has been made in agricultural science and farm technology and by reason of it a tenure holder can overcome hurdles and raise two crops in a year over the entire extent of a land having irrigation facility. We need not go as far as that. The normal presumption, in the absence of contra-material, would be that the quality and content of soil of a land would be uniform throughout its extent. Such being case if a tenure holder is able to raise two crops in a year in a portion of the land, then it would be logical to hold that the other portions of the land also would have the capacity to yield two crops if the tenure holder had utilised the entire extent to raise two crops instead of utilising a portion of the land alone. The raising of two crops even on a portion of the land will prove, in the absence of material to show poor quality of soil in portions of the land due to salinity etc., the uniform nature and content of the soil of the entire land.

    13

    The High court was therefore right in holding that the Prescribed Authority can treat a land, having assured irrigation facility, as 'irrigated land' if the tenure holder had raised two crops even in a portion of the land during anyone of the prescribed years and that it is not necessary that the raising of the two crops should have been made on the entire extent of the land in order to classify the land as 'irrigated land'."

    9. The Respondents/ original claimants further relied on Judgment in the matter of Collector of Panchmahals vs. Desai Keshavlal Pannalal, AIR 1969 Gujrat, Page 276 in which the Gujrat High Court held that agricultural land abutting on river always gets higher value in open market. Para 12 of the said Judgment reads as under:

    "12. Mr. Oza, the learned Advocate for the respondents, invited a reference to a decision in the case of Trent-Stoughton v. Barbados Water Supply Co., Ltd., 1893 AC 502, where it was held that the compensation due to the appellant included the value of his proprietary interest therein, and was not limited to the amount of pecuniary benefits obtained by past user thereof in disregard of possible benefits in the future In that case, certain streams of water had been abstracted from the appellant's property by a water company acting under the Water Supply Act, 1885 and in that regard while considering the question whether these streams of water being abstracted can be called 'damage or loss' within the meaning of the Act, it was observed that though he never had up to that time obtained one farthing for the use of the streams, and might never have made

    14

    any use of them, nevertheless, the damage or loss which he sustained was, that he was deprived of the power of using the property which was his. The decision may not have any application to the facts of the present case where the river water does not pass through the land belonging to the claimant as in that case a stream of water was passing through his property. Then he referred to the decision in the case In re an Arbitration between Lucas and The Chasterfield Gas and Water Board, (1999) 1 KB 16. In that case the land was compulsorily taken for the purpose of making a reservoir, and the land has a special adaptability for the construction of a reservoir. In determining the value arising from such special adaptability, it was held that the tribunal should have regard to the contingent value arising from the possibility of the land coming into the market when required for the particular purpose, and not to the value of the realised possibility arising from the fact of the promoters having obtained statutory powers for the construction of the reservoir. In other words, such an element of special adaptability of a particular land can well be taken into account in assessing the market value of the land. He then invited a reference to the case of Vyricherla Narayana Gajapatiraju v. Revenue Divisional Officer, Vizagapatam, AIR 1939 PC 98. There it was held that the land is not to be valued merely by reference to the use to which it is being put at the time at which its value has to be determined (that time under the Indian Act being the ate of the notification under S.4(1)), but also by reference to the uses to which it is reasonably capable of being put in the future. It is the possibilities of the land and not its realized possibilities that must be taken into consideration. This principle in determining the potential value of any such property has still remained good law. It was, however, pointed out by the learned Advocate-General by reference to some observations made in that decision at page

    15

    103 that 'the value of the potentiality must be ascertained by the arbitrator on such materials as are available to him and without indulging in feats of the imagination.' That position is no doubt true and has to be kept in mind while trying to assess potential value on that basis. The next case referred to by him was one of Daya Khusal v. Assistant Collector, Surat, ILR 38 Bom 37 = (AIR 1914 Bom 284). In that case, a piece of land was compulsorily acquired by Government for quarrying purposes and it appeared to be a land having such special adaptability for the purpose. That was held to be an element for consideration in fixing the amount of compensation. While, therefore, if the land by reason of the same abutting on a river has certain facilities or special adaptability for making beneficial use of the land, such a factor may well have to be taken into account while assessing the market value of the land under acquisition."

    10. Mr. Rahane - Respondent No.1 also relied on the Judgment in the matter of Kantabai Manibhai Amin and another vs. The Special Land Acquisition Officer, Baroda, reported in AIR 1990 Supreme Court 103, on the point of valuation of Bagayat land. In this case the Apex Court held that market value of Bagayat land to be fixed 25% excess than market value of Jirayat land. Head Note A of the said Judgment reads as under:

    "Land Acquisition Act (1 of 1984), S.23 - Compensation - Determination - Land in question bagayat land - Absence of proof of extent of superiority of land to jirayat land - Supreme Court determined its value

    16

    per acre after taking into consideration contemporaneous documents of sale of jirayat land and awarded 25 per cent excess compensation over and above market value of jirayat land."

    11. The Respondent No.1 relied on the Judgment in the matter of Land Acquisition Officer and Mandal Revenue Officer vs. V. Narasaiah, reported in AIR 2001 Supreme Court, 1117. It is held in this case that sale deeds relating to the similar lands situated in vicinity can be relied upon without examining vendee or vendor or anybody else connected with the sale. There is no dispute about this because as per the amended provisions of Section 51A of the Land Acquisition Act, certified copies of sale deeds can be considered by the Court for fixing market value of the land unless and until same is disputed by the other side. Mr. Rahane, Respondent No.1 further relied on the Judgment in the matter of Ajit Singh and others vs. State of Punjab and others, reported in (1994) 4 Supreme Court Cases 67. In this case the Apex Court held that fixation of rate of compensation at the average of sale price of two other pieces of lands contiguous to the land in question, can be done. In the case in hand, the Respondents failed to produce any comparable sale

    17

    deeds from the same locality. Considering the facts and circumstances in the instant case, this Authority is not applicable.

    12. The Respondent No.1 also relied on the Judgment in the matter of Kuldip Raj and others vs. State of Jammu & Kashmir and others, reported in AIR 1969 Jammu and Kashmir, 142 for justifying his submission that he is entitled to benefit as per amended provisions of the Land Acquisition Act i.e. 12% component payable under Section 23 (1A) of the Land Acquisition Act. In this connection, reference can be made to the Apex Court Judgment in the matter of Kashiben Bhikaji and others vs. Special Land Acquisition Officer and another, reported in (2002) 2 Supreme Court Cases, Page

    605. It is specifically held by the Apex Court that if the Collector's award is before amendment to the Land Acquisition Act, then the claimants are not entitled to 12% component payable under Section 23 (1A) of the Land Acquisition Act.

    13. The Respondent No.1 - Mr. Rahane further relied on the Judgment in the matter of Tata Chemicals Limited, Bombay vs. Sadhu Singh son of

    18

    Baljeet and others, AIR 1994 Allahabad, Page 66. It is held in this Authority that sale deeds executed subsequent to the Notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act can be considered where the market is stable and there is no fluctuation in prices. In any case in the present case the Respondents failed to produce any comparable sale deeds to show that they are entitled to compensation in respect of acquired land at the higher rate. Therefore, this Authority cannot be made applicable in the present case.

    14. The Respondent No.1 further relied on the following Authorities:

    (i) State of Maharashtra and another vs. Abdul Sattar Abdul Wahab and others, 1994 Mh. L.J., Page 1183,

    (ii) Krishna Yachendra Bahadurvaru vs. The Special Land Acquisition Officer, City Improvement Trust Board, Bangalore and others, AIR 1979 Supreme Court, Page 869,

    19

    (iii) The State of Madras vs. M. Nanjan and another, AIR 1976 Supreme Court, 651.

    . In the facts and circumstances of the present case, these Authorities are not applicable for determining the market value in respect of acquired land.

    15. Considering the submissions made by the claimants I hold that the acquired lands were Bagayat lands and therefore for determining the market value of acquired land sale deed at Exhibit 22 dated 27/5/1976 has to be taken into consideration. After considering sale deed at Exhibit 22 I hold that market value of the acquired land should be Rs.18,000/- per acre. Our High Court in the matter of State of Maharashtra vs. Baliram Girdhar Patil, reported in 2006 (6) Mh. L.J. Page 82 held that the market value of the Bagayat land should be double the value of dry land. Para 14 of the said Judgment read as under:

    "14. The trial Court has accepted the sale deeds Exh.12, Exh.14 and Exh.16. The trial Court has also accepted market rate of jirayat land to that of Rs.20,000/- per acre (Rs.50,000/- per hectare). The trial

    20

    Court, however, has considered the suggestion of learned District Government Pleader that market price of irrigated land can be one and half times more to that of the dry crop land. In the first instance, suggestion given in the evidence of witness cannot take place of proof. Secondly, availability of irrigation facility to the agricultural land is an important factor. The value and utility of the land in relation to its productivity depends upon the facility of irrigation to the land. Source of irrigation gives assurance for procurement of a good crop in such agricultural land. Cash crops give more and assured yield. Crop pattern can be scheduled and executed, if irrigation facility with water source is available. In the absence of irrigation facility, owner of such agricultural land i.e. dry crop land, is left at the mercy of nature. In this view of the matter , it would not be proper to consider the market price of irrigated land by one and half times more to that of the dry crop land. In my view, if the market price of dry crop land is worked out, for working out the market price of irrigated land, in the absence of any other evidence on record, double the market rate of jirayat land has to be awarded. The objective of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, while awarding amount of compensation, has to be kept in mind, for determining the market price of the agricultural land. As noted above, in the present case, the trial Court has referred to the suggestion of the learned District government Pleader and has determined the market value of bagayat land to that of one and half times more of the jirayat land, illegally."

    16. On the basis of above mentioned facts and circumstances I hold that the claimants are entitled to compensation in respect of acquired

    21

    land at the rate of Rs.18000/- per acre.

    17. The claimants submitted that the Reference Court erred in coming to the conclusion that they are entitled to compensation in respect of mango trees at the rate of Rs.3000/- per tree only. The claimants submitted that the Reference Court should have held that the claimants are entitled to compensation at the rate of Rs.8000/- per mango tree. In support of their contention, the claimants failed to produce any cogent evidence to show that they are entitled to compensation in respect of mango trees at the rate of Rs.8000/- per tree. Neither the claimants produced any valuation report from Horticultural Officer nor examined any expert witness to show that they are entitled to compensation in respect of mango trees at the rate of Rs.8000/- per tree. The Reference Court rightly considered that the claimants are entitled to compensation in respect of mango trees at the rate of Rs.3000/- per tree. Therefore, I hold that the claimants failed to produce any cogent evidence to show that they are entitled to enhanced compensation in respect of fruit bearing mango trees.

    22

    18. In the above mentioned facts and circumstances, I hold that the First Appeals preferred by the State of Maharashtra are liable to be dismissed with no order as to the costs and Cross Objections preferred by the Respondents/ original claimants are required to be partly allowed to the extent that the claimants are entitled to compensation in respect of acquired land at the rate of Rs.18000/- per acre. Hence

    the Order:

    O R D E R

    (i). Both the First Appeals i.e. First Appeal No.569 of 1997 and First Appeal No.570 of 1997 preferred by the Appellant State of Maharashtra are hereby dismissed.

    (ii) Both the Cross Objections i.e. Cross Objection St. No. 7500 of 1998 and Cross Objection St. No. 7501 of 1998 preferred by the original claimants are partly allowed to the extent that the claimants are entitled to compensation in

    23

    respect of acquired land at the rate of Rs.18,000/- per acre.

    (iii) The Judgment and award passed by the Reference Court dated 1st October, 1992 is modified to the extent that the original claimants are entitled to compensation in respect of acquired land at the rate of Rs.18,000/- per acre (including the amount already paid to them).

    (iv). No order as to the costs.

    [K.K. TATED]

    JUDGE.

    asb/u/fa569.97

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    STATE OF MAHARASHTRA . v. SAHEBRAO KISHANRAO RAHANE & OTHERS.
    (Mar 23, 2009)