Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2025 INSC 1035
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Water Act, 1974
  • Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002
  • Section 3 of the PMLA (Prevention of Money Laundering Act)
  • Section 15 of the NGT Act of 2010
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2025 INSC 1035
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Water Act, 1974
  • Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002
  • Section 3 of the PMLA (Prevention of Money Laundering Act)
  • Section 15 of the NGT Act of 2010
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Respondent No. 1 (the applicant before the National Green Tribunal (NGT)) alleged that the appellant industry was causing environmental degradation and pollution, illegally extracting groundwater, and releasing effluents into a nearby river (a tributary of the Ganga). It was further alleged that official respondents (State and Central Pollution Control bodies, the Central Ground Water Authority, and the District Collector) were “mute spectators” and often colluded in allowing the pollution.

The NGT proceedings ran for about three years. The NGT constituted a Joint Committee (including CPCB and UPPCB) which submitted multiple reports. Early reports (including 07.05.2019) recorded deficiencies such as ineffective effluent treatment, hazardous waste storage issues, and a thermocol unit operating without requisite consent. Environmental compensation (EC) was computed (including for illegal groundwater extraction) and a total EC of Rs. 2,49,71,157/- was imposed; the appellant is stated to have deposited Rs. 1,16,39,727/- after waiver on representations.

A subsequent Joint Committee report dated 30.07.2021 recorded full compliance (as noted by the NGT). Despite this, the NGT imposed compensation of Rs. 50 crores allegedly based on the appellant’s admitted turnover and issued additional directions, including a direction to the Enforcement Directorate (ED) to examine action under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (PMLA), and a sweeping direction to close divisions falling short of compliance. The appellant appealed to the Supreme Court challenging these directions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the NGT was justified in imposing environmental compensation of Rs. 50 crores by linking penalty to the appellant’s turnover, despite a later report recording compliance and despite prior EC computed by statutory bodies using CPCB methodology.
  2. Whether the NGT had jurisdiction/power to direct the Enforcement Directorate to examine and take action under the PMLA in relation to alleged environmental violations.
  3. Whether the NGT’s sweeping direction to close the appellant’s divisions for alleged shortfalls in compliance was warranted after acceptance of a compliance report, and how such enforcement should be left to jurisdictional Pollution Control Boards.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • The EC determined by statutory bodies had been paid, and mitigating measures were implemented, culminating in a 30.07.2021 report recording complete compliance with statutory conditions and PCB-imposed terms.
  • Despite the compliance report, the NGT imposed Rs. 50 crores based on turnover, which lacked rational nexus with alleged pollution and was contrary to this Court’s approach in Benzo Chem Industrial (P) Ltd. v. Arvind Manohar Mahajan.
  • The NGT’s direction to the ED to examine action under the PMLA was improper and had been frowned upon in Waris Chemicals (P) Ltd. v. U.P. Pollution Control Board.
  • The litigation did not fit within the contours of maintainability of PIL as declared in Ashok Kumar Pandey v. State of W.B. (though the Supreme Court declined to consider maintainability at this stage).

Pollution Control Board’s Arguments (UPPCB/PCB)

  • As of now, there was full compliance with environmental laws.
  • The NGT was within its power to enhance penalty as a deterrent measure.
  • Penalty quantum could be calibrated by applying multipliers under CPCB’s 2019 methodology instead of a flat turnover percentage.
  • Structural directions in paragraphs 569–571 of the NGT judgment were sought to be upheld.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Benzo Chem Industrial (P) Ltd. v. Arvind Manohar Mahajan Penalty/compensation for environmental damage must have nexus to environmental harm; turnover/revenue is not a legally recognized basis for quantifying penalty. The Court agreed that turnover-based penalty lacks nexus and struck down the NGT’s Rs. 50 crore compensation, noting the NGT should have referred to CPCB methodology if it found EC too low.
Waris Chemicals (P) Ltd. v. U.P. Pollution Control Board NGT’s direction to invoke PMLA was impermissible; PMLA Section 3 depends on proceeds of crime from scheduled offence; doubts expressed about NGT’s jurisdiction to direct PMLA prosecution. Following the approach in Waris Chemicals (and relying on Vijay Madanlal Choudhary), the Court set aside the NGT’s direction to the ED under the PMLA.
Ashok Kumar Pandey v. State of W.B. Contours of maintainability of PIL. Though cited by the appellant, the Court expressly declined to consider PIL maintainability at this stage given Joint Committee reports indicating environmental violations and delayed compliance.
Vijay Madanlal Choudhary v. Union of India Section 3 PMLA hinges on illegal gain of property as a result of criminal activity relating to a scheduled offence. Used to hold that, absent FIR/complaint for scheduled offences under environmental statutes, the PMLA-based direction could not be sustained; the NGT should remain within powers under Section 15 of the NGT Act, 2010.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

PIL maintainability not examined: The Court declined to decide maintainability of the PIL at this stage because initial Joint Committee reports indicated violations of environmental laws leading to penalisation by EC, and compliance was reported only in 2021 though proceedings began in 2019.

Compliance and continuing oversight: The Court noted that directions relating to fresh water audit, monitoring, and restoration were within the NGT’s powers and should be retained as a continuing process. Referring to CPCB submissions and a later joint inspection/report (inspection between 23–25.08.2022; report dated 24.12.2022), the Court recorded findings indicating normal soil parameters, explanations for groundwater yellowing, no reported crop damage within 2.5 km, no indicated air-borne disease burden requiring oxygen/ventilator support from OPD records, contribution by other nearby industries to environmental load, and installation of flow-meters/piezometers with negligible variance in water abstraction/consumption reconciliation, along with establishment of a common STP/ETP with advanced treatment systems. The Court also noted CPCB’s view that restoration should focus on aquifer recharge, continuous water-balance monitoring, and area-wide environmental load management, and emphasized recycling of treated water and robust monitoring.

Sweeping closure direction set aside: While accepting that statutory action (including closure notices) can be taken by jurisdictional PCBs upon non-compliance and that constant monitoring may be justified given past violations, the Court held that after accepting a compliance report there was no warrant for a sweeping direction to close divisions falling short of compliance. It set aside this NGT direction while expressly reserving the right of jurisdictional PCBs to proceed against any violations detected.

Turnover-based Rs. 50 crore compensation struck down: Relying on Benzo Chem Industrial, the Court reiterated that revenue/turnover has no nexus to environmental damage and that such a method is unknown to legal principle; it added that the rule of law does not permit the State/agencies to extract a “pound of flesh,” even in environmental matters. Even assuming an “admitted turnover” of Rs. 550 crores, the Court found no demonstrated nexus between turnover and the pollution alleged. Since statutory bodies had computed EC using CPCB methodology framed pursuant to NGT directions, the Court held that if the NGT thought EC was low it should have referred to that methodology rather than turnover. Accordingly, it struck down the NGT’s Rs. 50 crore compensation. The Court clarified it did not examine maintainability/validity of EC imposed by PCBs and did not verify the appellant’s statement about penalty payments; it left the appellant liberty to challenge the same subject to limitation, and allowed PCBs to recover any shortfall or impose further EC upon detecting non-compliance.

PMLA/ED direction beyond NGT’s powers: Following Waris Chemicals and Vijay Madanlal Choudhary, the Court held that PMLA Section 3 depends on illegal gains derived from criminal activity relating to a scheduled offence. Here, there was neither an FIR for a scheduled offence nor a complaint alleging scheduled offences under environmental statutes. The Court subscribed to doubts expressed earlier about NGT’s jurisdiction to direct prosecution under the PMLA and held that the NGT must act within its powers, identified as Section 15 of the NGT Act, 2010. It set aside the direction to the ED, without expressing any view on whether an offence was made out.

Critique of the NGT’s approach: The Court observed that application of mind is not proportionate to the number of pages, criticized the impugned judgment for elaborating general environmental law and extracting material already on record, and stated that courts/tribunals should avoid rhetoric without particular reference to facts—especially when the last report found complete compliance.

Holding and Implications

ALLOWED: The Supreme Court allowed the appeal and set aside the NGT order to the extent it (i) imposed Rs. 50 crores compensation based on turnover, (ii) directed the Enforcement Directorate to examine/take action under the PMLA, and (iii) issued a sweeping direction for closure of the appellant’s divisions for non-compliance.

The Court retained/endorsed only those directions that permit continuous monitoring and audit (including audit, monitoring, and restoration measures) as a continuing process within the NGT’s powers. Jurisdictional Pollution Control Boards were left free to take statutory action, recover any shortfall, and impose further EC if future non-compliance is detected. The Court expressly did not decide PIL maintainability and did not verify or adjudicate the correctness of EC already imposed/paid under PCB action, leaving any challenge to the appellant subject to limitation. Pending applications, if any, were disposed of. The judgment applied existing principles (particularly on nexus in penalty quantification and limits on NGT’s jurisdiction vis-à-vis PMLA) rather than stating any new broader precedent beyond the case’s direct effect.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    M/S C.L. GUPTA EXPORT LTD. v. ADIL ANSARI

    2025 INSC 1035

    Page 1 of 15

    Civil Appeal No. 2864 of 2022

    REPORTABLE

    IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

    CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

    CIVIL APPEAL NO. 2864 OF 2022

    M/s C.L. Gupta Export Ltd. …Appellant

    Versus

    Adil Ansari & Ors. …Respondents

    J U D G M E N T

    K. VINOD CHANDRAN, J.

    The respondent no.1, the applicant before the National Green Tribunal (for brevity, 'NGT') alleged that the appellant, the respondent no.1 before the NGT, as an industry was actively perpetrating environmental degradation and pollution as also extracting ground water; thus polluting the surroundings and also releasing effluents into the nearby river which is a tributary of the Ganga. It was also alleged that the other official respondents, the Pollution Control Board of the State &

    1

    Page 2 of 15

    the Centre, the Central Ground Water Authority and the District Collector were mute spectators to the activities of the appellant and often colluding, in polluting and damaging the environment. The proceedings before the NGT extended over a period of three years in which various reports were called for from a Joint Committee constituted by the NGT and eventually based on the reports, the matter was disposed of with certain directions, with which the appellant is aggrieved.

    2. Sh. Vikas Singh, learned Counsel appearing for the appellant would point out that the environmental compensation (for brevity, 'EC') as determined by the statutory bodies were paid up by the appellant. The appellant also had brought about all the mitigating measures, eventually leading to a report of complete compliance of the statutory conditions and the terms imposed by the Pollution Control Board (for brevity, 'PCB'). Despite that last report of 30.07.2021, clearly

    Page 3 of 15

    recording compliance, the NGT went ahead and imposed a compensation of Rs. 50 crores based on the allegedly admitted turnover of the appellant. There is no rational nexus in thus computing the penalty, which has also been deprecated by this Court in Benzo Chem Industrial (P) Ltd. v. Arvind Manohar Mahajan1. The NGT also directed the Enforcement Directorate (for brevity, 'ED') to examine the matter in the light of the observations made in the judgment and take appropriate action under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 20022wherein the environmental laws are also included in Part-A of Schedule I. The said measure has also been frowned upon in Waris Chemicals (P) Ltd. v. U.P. Pollution Control Board3. The contours of maintainability of a Public Interest Litigation (for brevity, 'PIL') is explicitly declared in Ashok Kumar Pandey v.

    1 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3543

    2 for brevity, "PMLA"

    3 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1261

    Page 4 of 15

    State of W.B.4; within which contours the present litigation does not fall.

    3. None appears for respondent no.1 who was the applicant before the NGT. It is to be observed at the outset that we are not inclined to consider the question of maintainability of the PIL, at this stage especially when the initial reports of the Joint Committee constituted by the NGT clearly indicate violations of the environmental laws which led to the penalisation by imposition of EC. The proceedings were commenced by the applicant in the year 2019 and it was only in the year 2021 that a modicum of compliance was reported.

    4. Mr. Saurabh Mishra, learned Advocate-on- Record, appearing for the Pollution Control Board submits that as of now there is full compliance of the environmental laws. However, it is urged that the NGT was within its power in enhancing the penalty since it is

    4 (2004 ) 3 SCC 34 9

    Page 5 of 15

    a deterrent measure. It is also pointed out that the calibration of the quantum of penalty could also be with reference to multipliers under CPCB, 2019 methodology, instead of a flat turnover percentage. It is also sought that structural directions in paragraph 569-571 of the NGT judgment may be upheld.

    5. The appellant was earlier engaged in four manufacturing activities when the proceedings commenced, which were Metal Art Ware, Glass Art Ware, Thermocol Blocks which later, were expanded with two additions; Marble Art Ware and Corrugated Boxes. There was also a residential area where 500-600 people, the employees of the appellant, resided. The appellant is said to be an exporter of handicraft items and has employed around 7,000 workers.

    6. On the allegation raised, the NGT had first constituted a Joint Committee comprising of the Central Pollution Control Board (for brevity, 'CPCB'), the

    Page 6 of 15

    respondent no.3 and the Uttar Pradesh Pollution Control Board (for brevity, 'UPPCB'), the respondent no.2. A report dated 07.05.2019 was filed which noticed ineffective effluent treatment, storage of hazardous wastes and the Thermocol manufacturing unit having not been granted the consent to establish/operate, among other defects. The report proposed a show cause notice under the Water Act, 1974, the closure of the unit and imposition of EC of Rs.10 lakhs. This was followed up with a notice dated 30.03.2019 by the UPPCB to which objections were filed.

    7. Further reports dated 16.07.2019 and 03.12.2019 were placed before the NGT in which EC was computed based on the "Assessment of Environmental Compensation in Case of Illegal Extraction of Groundwater" dated 26.06.2019 brought out by the CPCB in compliance with the orders of the NGT. A total EC of Rs.2,49,71,157/- was imposed. The appellant is said

    Page 7 of 15

    to have deposited an EC of Rs.1,16,39,727/-; after the waiver effected on representations made.

    8. Subsequently, yet another report dated 30.07.2021 was submitted before the NGT which even according to the NGT as is seen from page 145 of the order confirms full compliance with all prior recommendations/suggestions. This report was also partly accepted by the NGT in paragraph 466. The reservation expressed by the NGT seems to be of the amount of compensation determined/recommended by the Committee being not consistent with the directions of the NGT, issued in various other matters. Finding that the appellant had violated environmental laws including the provisions relating to extraction of groundwater, the NGT went ahead to discuss the provisions of the PMLA, various decisions with respect to that statute and also those decisions of the NGT, imposing compensation with reference to the turnover of the polluter on the principle:

    Page 8 of 15

    "polluter pays". The NGT thus imposed the compensation, issued directions including that with reference to PMLA as also made a sweeping direction for the closure of the divisions of the appellant, in which requisite steps are not taken to comply with the prescribed standards.

    9. As has been correctly pointed out by the CPCB, the order of the Tribunal relating to fresh water audit, monitoring and restoration has to be retained. Insofar as, the compliance is concerned we refer to the following in the written submissions made :

    "5. Pursuant to the above directions, a joint inspection was undertaken between 23- 25.08.2022 and a report dated 24.12.2022 was filed before this Hon'ble Court. The said report records inter alia that soil parameters were normal; yellowing of stored groundwater was attributable to oxidation of iron and manganese; there was no crop damage within a 2.5 km radius as per the District Horticulture Officer, Amroha; OPD records from the Chief Medical Officer, Amroha did not show any air-borne disease burden requiring oxygen or ventilator support; and that other industries in the vicinity also

    Page 9 of 15

    contributed to environmental load. The report further records that the Appellant has installed extensive flow-meters and piezometers, that reconciliation between fresh water abstraction and consumption shows negligible variance (approximately 0.39% over a five-month period), and that a common STP/ETP with advanced treatment systems has been put in place."

    The directions in the impugned judgment relating to audit, monitoring and restoration are necessarily within the powers of the NGT and is a continuing process. We also notice the submissions of CPCB that restoration measures should focus on aquifer recharge, continuous water balance monitoring and area wide environmental load management. Recycling of treated water, reduced usage of ground water withdrawal, continuous and robust monitoring would definitely guide the design of a prospective compliance regime.

    10. We cannot for a moment dispute that if there is non-compliance of any of the statutory conditions or that imposed by the PCBs in mitigation of the unit specific

    Page 10 of 15

    pollution, then such action sanctioned by the statute could be taken, including notice for closure by the jurisdictional PCB. We are also convinced that there could be constant monitoring of the unit especially looking at the past violations. But, we are not convinced that having accepted the report of compliance, there was any warrant for a sweeping direction to close such of the divisions of the appellant which are falling short of the compliance. Reserving the right of the jurisdictional PCBs to proceed against any violation of statutory or other conditions imposed, the direction issued by the NGT has to be set aside and we do so.

    1 1 . Benzo Chem Industrial (P) Ltd.1 was a case in which one of us (B. R. Gavai, J, as he then was) considered the question of imposition of penalties on a reference to the annual turnover wherein the NGT having noticed the revenue range of the polluter to be between 100-500 crores imposed a penalty of Rs.500 crores. This Court

    Page 11 of 15

    first noticed the huge disparity in the range noticed by the NGT, also taken from the public domain which would have clearly indicated the exact figure. It was categorically held that generation of revenue, or its quantum, would have no nexus with the amount of penalty to be ascertained for environmental damages. The methodology adopted by the NGT for imposition of penalty was held to be totally unknown to any principle of law. We fully agree with the observation and add that rule of law does not permit State or its agencies to extract a 'pound of flesh', even in environmental matters. Though in the present case there is an observation made that there was admitted turnover of Rs.550 crores; we still notice the absence of nexus between the turnover and the pollution alleged. In fact the penalty imposed on the appellant, by the statutory body was on the basis of a methodology framed by the CPCB, on the directions of the NGT. If at all the NGT was of the opinion that the EC

    Page 12 of 15

    imposed was minimal or low, it could have referred to the methodology framed by the CPCB and not merely looked at the revenue generation of the alleged polluter. We hence strike out the imposition of compensation of Rs.50 Crores by the NGT. However, we make it clear that we have not considered the maintainability of the EC imposed by the PCBs and the statement regarding the penalty paid by the appellant, has not been verified. If the appellant has avenues to challenge the same, they would be left liberty, subject to the laws of limitation. The PCB would also be entitled to recover any shortfall or impose any further EC on non-compliance being detected.

    12. Waris Chemicals (P) Ltd.3dealt with a similar direction to invoke the provisions of the PMLA as in this case. It was held, following Vijay Madanlal Choudhary

    v. Union of India5that Section 3 of the PMLA is dependent

    5 (2023) 12 SCC 1

    Page 13 of 15

    on illegal gain of property as a result of the criminal activity relating to a scheduled offence. As in the facts of the cited case, here, neither is there registration of FIR for any scheduled offence nor any complaint is filed alleging such offences under the various environmental protection statutes scheduled under the PMLA and coming within its ambit. This Court had also raised serious doubts about the jurisdiction of the NGT to direct the prosecution of individuals under the PMLA; which we fully subscribe to. The NGT should act within the contours of the powers conferred on it which is Section 15 of the NGT Act of 2010. Though such power would be available to a Court constituted under the PMLA or to constitutional courts, it would not be available for exercise by the NGT, constituted to ensure effective and expeditious consideration of cases relating to environmental protection and conservation of forests and other natural resources including enforcement of any legal right and

    Page 14 of 15

    giving relief and compensation for damages to persons and properties. We hence set aside the direction issued to the Enforcement Directorate; but say nothing on whether there is an offence made out or not, which at this stage is not within our ken.

    13. We have to necessarily set aside the directions issued other than that which permits a continuous monitoring and audit of the pollution control measures to ensure a pollution free, compliance regime. Before we leave the matter, with some anguish, we cannot but indicate that application of mind is not proportionate to the number of pages. The impugned judgment deals elaborately with the environmental law, the numerous

    pollution prevention measures, the guidelines and publications issued by various States as also decisions in that regard. It also extracts the various reports filed by the Joint Committee, the interim orders of the NGT and the objections raised by the industry; which would

    Page 15 of 15

    anyway be available in the records of the case. In the context of the last of the reports having found complete compliance, we cannot but observe that unfortunately this was an exercise in futility. Judicious consideration is the sum and substance of adjudication and the Courts/Tribunals should restrain themselves from engaging in mere rhetoric by stating the law in general without particular reference to the facts. We say nothing more and allow the appeal setting aside the order of the NGT to the extent noticed above.

    14. Pending applications, if any, shall stand disposed of.

    …….…………………….….. CJI.

    (B. R. GAVAI)

    .……….…………………….….. J.

    (K. VINOD CHANDRAN)

    NEW DELHI;

    AUGUST 22, 2025.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M/S C.L. GUPTA EXPORT LTD. v. ADIL ANSARI
    (Aug 22, 2025)