AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    DR C SARAVANAN v. CENTRAL DRUGS STANDARD ORGANIZATION

    CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

    ERNAKULAM BENCH

    O.A. No.180/00194/2025

    Tuesday, this the 10thday of June, 2025

    CORAM:

    HON'BLE Mr. JUSTICE K. HARIPAL, JUDICIAL MEMBER

    Dr. C. Saravanan, Aged 41 years, S/o T. Chinnadurai Drugs Inspector, Central Drugs Standard Control Organization Custom House, Willingdon Island, Kochi-682009 Residing at House No.12/867, Vembrakattu House ESI Road, Palluruthy, Kochi-682006

    - Applicant [By Advocates: Mr. P.Nandakumar, Ms.Amrutha Sanjeev, Mr.Vivek Vijayakumar]

    Versus

    1. The Director General of Health Services, Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, Room No. 330-A, Nirman Bhavan, Maulana Azad Road New Delhi-110011.

    2. The Drugs Controller General (India), Central Drugs Standard Control Organization, FDA Bhavan, Kotia Road, New Delhi-110002.

    3. The Deputy Director (Administration), Central Drugs Standard Control Organization, FDA Bhavan, Kotla Road, New Delhi-110002.

    4. The Director (Administration), Central Drugs Standard Control Organization, FDA Bhavan, Kotla Road, New Delhi-110002.

    5. B. Siva Kumar Reddy, Drugs Inspector, Central Drugs Standard Control Organization, West Zone-1, 4th Floor, Zonal FDA Bhawan, GMSD Compound, Bellasis Road, Mumbai Central, Mumbai-400 008

    - Respondents [By Advocate: Mr. V.A.Shaji, ACGSC for R1 to R4]

    The application having been heard on 04.06.2025, the Tribunal on 10.06.2025 delivered the following:

    1

    O R D E R

    Applicant is a Drugs Inspector in the Central Drugs Standard Control Organisation, CDSCO for short, who commenced his service on 10.11.2017 in the New Delhi office of the organisation. His wife is also a Drugs Inspector under the State Government service of Tamil Nadu. On his request on spouse ground he was transferred as Drugs Inspector to Chennai South Zone, where he took charge on 13.07.2018. It is a sensitive post. On the directives of the Central Vigilance Commission, a person holding a sensitive post cannot work in a single station for more than three years. Thus, on completion of three years tenure in Chennai, he was transferred to Kochi. From 11.05.2022 he was working in Kochi. On completion of three years in Kochi, by Annexure-A7 order dated 02.05.2025 he stands transferred as Drugs Inspector to East Zone in Kolkata. Even before passing Annexure-A7 he had made numerous representations to the competent authority seeking transfer to Chennai on spouse ground. While such representations were pending, according to the applicant, he has been transferred to Kolkata overlooking his

    2

    seniority and also the request on spouse ground. According to the applicant, he has two female children, aged 10 and 6 yeas, who are studying in Kendriya Vidyalaya, Kochi, staying with him, away from their mother. Highlighting Annexure-A1 transfer policy he submits that such transfers have to be effected taking in to consideration seniority and Government policy on working spouse. But both the vital aspects were overlooked in his case. In Annexure-A7 he is sl.No.38. Sl.Nos.6,9,16,17,41 and 61 are Drugs Inspectors transferred to Chennai. Out of these persons, except sl.No.17, all are juniors to him in the seniority list. There are also persons overstaying in Chennai. He is aggrieved by the Annexure- A7 and has approached this Tribunal for quashing the same to the extent it transfers him to Kolkata, to declare that he is entitled for a posting at Chennai in South Zone considering his seniority and priority under spouse ground, to direct the respondents to give him posting in Chennai and also to direct the 1strespondent to consider and pass appropriate orders on Annexure-A9 appeal submitted before the 1strespondent against Annexure-A7 and to permit him to continue in Kochi till its disposal.

    3

    2. When the O.A. had come up for admission on 13.05.2025, Sri.V.A.Shaji, learned Additional Central Government Standing Counsel, took notice for the respondents 1 to 4 and sought time for getting instructions. When the learned counsel pressed for an interim order staying the operation of transfer of the applicant, he was specifically asked as to whether he was relieved from the present station at Kochi. The learned counsel submitted that he was not yet relieved and his substitute, the 5threspondent, is not interested in moving to Kochi. It was also submitted that Annexure-A9 representation was not yet considered by the 1strespondent. Then the Tribunal directed the 1strespondent to dispose of Annexure-A9 representation within 15 days, till then, Annexure-A7 order, as far as the applicant is concerned, be put on hold.

    3. Thereafter, it was submitted that the Annexure-A9 representation was disposed of by the 3rdrespondent himself, which was illegal. The learned Standing Counsel submitted that pursuant to Annexure-A7 the applicant was relieved on 07.05.2025 itself. The learned counsel for the applicant disputed this contention. He claimed that the

    4

    applicant is still working as Drugs Inspector in Kochi and that he is regularly attending the office. Without entering into that controversy, since the respondents 1 to 4 had filed reply, the very O.A. was decided to be heard finally.

    4. One Nitin M Jadhav claiming himself as a respondent filed reply on behalf of respondents 1 to 4 denying the contentions of the applicant. According to him, Annexure-R1 indicates that the applicant was relieved as per the relieving order dated 06.05.2025 with effect from 07.05.2025. The Annexure-R1 was duly communicated to the applicant on 06.05.2025 itself through e-mail. Further, it is submitted that the Annexure-A9 representation was considered and Annexure-R3 order has been passed rejecting the claim. According to them, the interim order was obtained misrepresenting that the applicant was still continuing in office that after obtaining the interim order on 13.05.2025 the applicant was simply attending the office.

    5. It is further submitted that the 5threspondent, the substitute of the applicant, was relieved from Mumbai on 14.05.2025. He had

    5

    reported in the office on 16.05.2025. But in the light of the controversy, he proceeded on leave without joining duty.

    6. Moreover, it is submitted that the transfer was effected in tune with the transfer policy. The applicant had been working in Chennai, accepting his request on spouse ground, from 13.07.2018 to 10.05.2022. Such a clause in the transfer policy gives departments only some discretion, subject to availability of posts. On that premise, the applicant cannot remain in Chennai indefinitely, which would defeat the purpose of rotational transfer policy and would set an undesirable precedence adversely affecting the cadre discipline and administrative function.

    7. According to the respondents, the claim of the applicant regarding seniority also is displaced. Transfers are decided not based on seniority alone, but by the length of stay at a station. It being a rotational transfer, administrative requirements have to be given primacy. The applicant has already availed spouse ground transfer to Chennai in 2018 and was later transferred to Kochi on completion of full tenure. Thus the respondents prayed for dismissing the O.A.

    6

    8. The applicant filed a rejoinder appending Annexures-A10 to A16 documents. He produced copy of the attendance register and denied the contentions in the reply. According to him, in the afternoon of 07.05.2025 he suffered acute pain on his right flank on account of past history of kidney stone. Though he was admitted in Medical Trust Hospital, since there was no bystander, got discharged at his request with advice for medication and rest for three days. According to him, thereafter also he attended the office and still continuing in the office on the strength of the interim order.

    9. Heard the counsel on both sides in detail.

    10. The respective contentions were reiterated.

    11. At the time of hearing, learned counsel for the applicant fairly submitted that, it being a sensitive post, he is liable to be transferred on completion of the tenure. But he is seriously aggrieved by the non- consideration of Annexure-A9 representation by the 1strespondent to whom it was addressed. However, the 3rdrespondent, who issued Annexure-A7 himself has rejected it through Annexure-R3 which is like

    7

    himself acting as a Judge in his own case, which is contrary to the accepted principles of natural justice and propriety. Learned counsel also relied on the decision in Hussain M.M. v. State of Kerala and others [2020 (6) KHC 426] and Pradeep Kumar and another v. Commissioner Hindu Religious Institution and Charitable Endowment [2020 KHC 4796]

    of the Karnataka High Court. So, the learned counsel submitted that Annexure-R3 is illegal and therefore, at this stage, he is only pressing for making the interim order absolute, till the disposal of Annexure-A9 by the 1strespondent.

    12. Sri.V.A.Shaji, learned Additional Central Government Standing Counsel has submitted that the applicant has not come with clean hands. He has suppressed material facts. The fact that he was relieved with effect from 07.05.2025 has been suppressed from this Tribunal. That order was duly communicated to the applicant as evident from Annexure- R2. Moreover, at the time of hearing, he also produced an office letter dated 06.05.2025 deputing one Dr.Pranab Jyothi Das, Drugs Inspector, CDSCO, Airport, Chennai to proceed to Kochi and take over charge in the

    8

    office of Kochi from Dr.C.Saravanan, the applicant, with effect from 07.05.2025 AN. He has also produced copy of the employee attendance register of the said Pranab Jyothi Das and submitted that he had reported in Kochi and joined duty. However, the applicant did not handover the log-in credentials and associated files to him and was clinging to the office after 13.05.2025 on the strength of the interim order, which was obtained by misleading the Tribunal. Learned counsel for the applicant submitted that merely by passing an order of relief one cannot leave office unless log-in credentials and associated files are transferred/handed over to the new incumbent or his/her reporting officer. Relying on Annexure-A11 the learned counsel wanted to say that the applicant is continuing in office. His absence in the afternoon of 07.05.2025 was since he had rushed to the Medical Trust Hospital with acute pain on the right flank, as seen in Annexure-A12.

    13. Even though the learned counsel for the applicant submitted that he is pressing only the 3rdrelief for making his interim order absolute till the disposal of Annexure-A9 representation by the 1strespondent,

    9

    before proceeding to that aspect, the merits of the contentions of the parties require to be considered.

    14. The service profile of the applicant is not in dispute. After his initial appointment in New Delhi as Drugs Inspector on 10.11.2017, for a full term from 13.07.2018 he was working in Chennai where his wife is working as Drugs Inspector under the State Government. Admittedly, it is a sensitive post. There are standing instructions by the Chief Vigilance Commissioner that an officer shall not be allowed to continue in a sensitive post for more than three years. Therefore, on completion of the tenure, transfer of the applicant is imminent. The applicant has no quarrel on that point. But he is aggrieved by not considering his petition for transferring to Kolkata overlooking seniority and claims on spouse ground.

    15. It is true that the applicant is senior to many, who have been transferred to Chennai under Annexure-A7. But that ipso facto does not entitle him to get a transfer to Chennai every time. It is not disputed that the applicant holds an important post of Drugs Inspector under the

    10

    CDSCO. There is only one such post in Kerala. He holds a vital assignment. He has all India transfer liability. He is bound to go anywhere as the employer directs. Ordinarily, such a transfer order cannot be questioned unless it is vitiated by malafides. It is the settled proposition of law that a transfer should be effected by the competent authority. It should be to the cadre or post held by the person and there should not be any malafide in the order of transfer. The applicant has no contention that Annexure-A7 is bad on these aspects.

    16. As rightly submitted by the learned Standing Counsel, even though the seniority also is required to be considered while effecting transfers, it cannot be the sole consideration. What is important is the length of service rendered by him in a particular station. Before transferring to Kochi, the applicant was working in Chennai for a full term. Therefore, he cannot plead that he should be posted in Chennai in every alternate tenure.

    17. According to the learned counsel, no one else had asked for a posting in Chennai on spouse ground. As stated earlier, he has already

    11

    been granted posting in Chennai on spouse ground during the previous tenure. If such an argument is upheld, the applicant will have to be posted every time in Chennai or Tamil Nadu, where his wife is working, who does not have chance to move out of Tamil Nadu.

    18. In this case, it is appropriate to extract the following observations of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Punjab and Sind Bank and others v. Durgesh Kuwar [AIR 2020 SC 3040].

    "17. We must begin our analysis of the rival submissions by adverting to the settled principle that transfer is an exigency of service. An employee cannot have a choice of postings. Administrative circulars and guidelines are indicators of the manner in which the transfer policy has to be implemented. However, an administrative circular may not in itself confer a vested right which can be enforceable by a writ of mandamus. Unless an order of transfer is established to be malafide or contrary to a statutory provision or has been issued by an authority not competent to order transfer, the Court in exercise of judicial review would not be inclined to interfere. These principles emerge from the judgments which have been relied upon by the appellants in support of their submissions and to which we have already made a reference above. There can be no dispute about the position in law."

    12

    19. Regarding the claim for transfer on spouse ground, in Bank of India v. Jagjit Singh Mehta [(1992) 1 SCC 306], the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held thus:

    "5. There can be no doubt that ordinarily and as far as practicable the husband and wife who are both employed should be posted at the same station even if their employers be different. The desirability of such a course is obvious. However, this does not mean that their place of posting should invariably be one of their choice, even though their preference may be taken into account while making the decision in accordance with the administrative needs. In the case of all-India services, the hardship resulting from the two being posted at different stations may be unavoidable at times particularly when they belong to different services and one of them cannot be transferred to the place of the other's posting. While choosing the career and a particular service, the couple have to bear in mind this factor and be prepared to face such a hardship if the administrative needs and transfer policy do not permit the posting of both at one place without sacrifice of the requirements of the administration and needs of other employees. In such a case the couple have to make their choice at the threshold between career prospects and family life. After giving preference to the career prospects by accepting such a

    13

    promotion or any appointment in an all-India service with the incident of transfer to any place in India, subordinating the need of the couple living together at one station, they cannot as of right claim to be relieved of the ordinary incidents of all-India service and avoid transfer to a different place on the ground that the spouses thereby would be posted at different places. In addition, in the present case, the respondent voluntarily gave an undertaking that he was prepared to be posted at any place in India and on that basis got promotion from the clerical cadre to the officers' grade and thereafter he seeks to be relieved of that necessary incident of all-India service on the ground that his wife has to remain at Chandigarh. No doubt the guidelines require the two spouses to be posted at one place as far as practicable, but that does not enable any spouse to claim such a posting as of right if the departmental authorities do not consider it feasible. The only thing required is that the departmental authorities should consider this aspect along with the exigencies of administration and enable the two spouses to live together at one station if it is possible without any detriment to the administrative needs and the claim of other employees."

    20. Transfer is an incidence of service. It is for the employer to decide where an employee should work. The applicant has no allegation that Annexure-A7 is vitiated by malafide. Only the grievance is that he

    14

    should be given a posting in Chennai on spouse ground. Considering the nature and importance of the post held by him, it may not be feasible to transfer him during every rotational transfer and post him in Chennai. He does not have a vested right to get a transfer to Chennai. It is for the respondents to decide on the basis of administrative exigencies and functional conveniences as to where he should be posted. The public interest and interest of administration should always give way to temporary inconveniences of an officer. It is also the settled proposition that unless the order of transfer is vitiated by malafides or is made in violation of any statutory provisions the Court cannot interfere with it. The fact that these are vacant posts in Chennai has no consequence. That means, the applicant is not entitled to get an order on merits.

    21. Now, coming back to the first aspect, after perusing the documents produced by both sides, there are reasons to believe that the applicant had misled this Tribunal for passing an interim order on 13.05.2025. Firstly, the Annexures-R1 and R2 clearly indicate that the applicant was relieved by order dated 06.05.2025 with effect from the

    15

    forenoon of 07.05.2025. This order was duly communicated to the applicant on 06.05.2025 at 5.51 pm. He has no case that he is unaware of the order. So, the applicant must have received knowledge about the alternate arrangements made from Chennai for relieving him.

    22. Secondly, though not part of the pleadings, the learned Standing counsel has taken to me an office order dated 06.05.2025 whereunder Dr.Pranab Jyothi Das, Drugs Inspector, CDSCO, Airport Chennai, was deputed to Kochi to take over the charge of the office of the applicant with effect from the afternoon of 07.05.2025. This has to be read along with Annexures-R1 and R2. It is true that Annexure-A7 mandates handing over of log-in credentials and associated files to the new incumbent or his/her reporting officer. The said Dr.Pranab Jyothi Das was deputed to honour this mandate. Employee Attendance Register produced by the learned Standing Counsel, at the time of hearing, also indicates that the said Dr.Pranab Jyothi Das had attended office of the applicant at 12.47 pm on 07.05.2025 and had been attending office on 08.05.2025 and 09.05.2025. The learned Standing Counsel also

    16

    complained that the applicant did not hand over the credentials and files purposely for moving this Tribunal.

    23. Apparently, from Annexure-A11 it is evident that the applicant did not attend office on 08.05.2025 and 09.05.2025. It was stated that he was taking rest; may be. But there is no case that he had applied for leave on these days.

    24. Thirdly, as mentioned earlier, the Tribunal was made to believe that he was not relieved from the office, which stands disproved from the materials produced. On his own showing, from Annexure-A14 it is evident that after attending the office on 07.05.2025 at 8.15 AM he had reached the office only on 13.05.2025, that too at 10.42 AM. In this connection, it is important to note that, ordinarily, on all days he had attended the office, he used to reach the office before 9 AM. But on 13.05.2025, he reported only at 10.42 AM. As rightly submitted by the learned Standing Counsel, such a delayed attendance should be read along with the misrepresentation made before this Tribunal. On 13.05.2025 this matter was listed as item No.2 in the admission list. This

    17

    Court starts sitting invariably at 10.30 AM. Immediately thereafter item 2 was taken up and the interim order was passed. In all probability, such a delayed attendance on 13.05.2025 must have been done after knowing about the interim order.

    25. Added to this, it is important to refer to Annexure-A10, a communication issued by the applicant to the respondents at 4.30 PM on 13.05.2025. After referring to the previous developments and also the interim order passed by this Tribunal, it is stated that,

    "..........I resumed my duty at CDSCO Cochin Sea Port today. This is for your kind information."

    26. All these aspects unequivocally suggest that the applicant was relieved by Dr.Pranab Jyothi Das. However, he had not handed over the log-in credentials and other files with the intention to approach this Tribunal.

    27. He cannot be blamed for attempting a common law remedy. But that should be with clean hands, but the submission before the Tribunal on 13.05.2025 that 'he was not yet relieved' was factually incorrect.

    18

    28. Such a person cannot seek an equitable remedy from the Tribunal.

    29. The arguments of the learned counsel based on the decision in Hussain M.M. and Pradeep Kumar, quoted supra, cannot be sustained. Those decisions were rendered in different factual situations. Secondly, it is true that Annexures-A7 and R3 were issued by the same official, Pawan Kumar, Deputy Director (Admin). But both were issued with the approval of the competent authority. In no stretch of imagination, it can be thought that he had issued Annexure-R3 usurping the powers of the 1st respondent. Even though Annexure-A7 is not an appealable order, still, in Annexure-R3, it is stated that it has been issued with the approval of the competent authority. Therefore, the applicant cannot be heard to say that the 3rdrespondent had issued Annexure-R3 behind the back of the 1st respondent. Such an argument does not hold water.

    19

    Resultantly, the Original Application lacks merits and is dismissed. Interim order stands vacated. I abstain from awarding costs. (Dated, this the 10thJune, 2025)

    JUSTICE K.HARIPAL

    JUDICIAL MEMBER

    ds

    20

    List of Annexures Annexure A1: True copy. of order. F.No.A. 22011/02/2023-D dated 03.07.2023 issued by the 4threspondent

    Annexure A2: True copy of Office Memorandum No.DOPT- 1669289899529 dated 24.11.2022 issued by the Department of Personnel & Training

    Annexure A3: True copy of representation dated 13.06.2024 submitted by the applicant to the 3rdrespondent

    Annexure A4: True copy of representation dated 10.02.2025 submitted by the applicant before the 2ndrespondent

    Annexure A5: True copy of Office Memorandum F.No.A-12013/01/ 2023-D dated 12.02.2025 issued by the 3rdrespondent Annexure A6: True copy of representation dated 17.04 2025 submitted by the applicant before respondents 2 and 3

    Annexure-A7: True copy of order No.A.22012/01/2024-D dated 02.05.2025 issued by the 4threspondent.

    Annexure A8: True copy of proceedings F.No.A.23021/02/2019-D dated 19.02 2025 issued by the 3rdrespondent along with the relevant extract of the final seniority list of Drugs Inspector in CDSCO as on 01.11.2024

    Annexure A9: True copy of appeal dated 05.05.2025 submitted by the applicant before the 1strespondent

    21

    Annexure A10: True copy of email dated 13.05.2025 sent by the applicant to all the respondents in the OA including the Deputy Drugs Controller (India), Wet Zone, Mumbai. Annexure A11: True copy of attendance of the applicant for the month of May 2025

    Annexure A12: True copy of discharge summary of the applicant dated 07.05.2025 issued by the Medical Trust Hospital Annexure A13: True copy of request dated 31.01.2024 submitted by the applicant.

    Annexure A14: True copy of Order No: A 22012/01/2024-D dated

    07.06.2024

    Annexure A15: True copy of Order F No: A.22012/01/2024 dated 09.05.2025 issued by the 4threspondent

    Annexure A16: True copy of representation dated 17.05.2025 submitted by the applicant before the 1strespondent

    Annexure R-1: True copy of the Relieving Order No.2-27/ADC/CHE/ 2025/65 dated 6.5.2025 issued by the Deputy Drugs Controller, O/o The Assistant Drugs Controller (India), Seaport, 4thFloor, Annex Building, Rajaji Salai, Custom House, Chennai

    Annexure R-2: True copy of the e-mail sent by the Deputy Drugs Controller to the applicant dated 6.5.2025.

    Annexure R-3: True copy of the Speaking Order F.No.A.22012/01/2024- D dated 23.5.2025 issued by the Respondent No.3 with the approval of Respondent No.1

    22

    Annexure R-4: True copy of the Relieving Order of the 5threspondent Ref.No.1-9/Admin-RO/WZ-2025/331 dated 14.05.2025 issued by the office of CDSCO West Zone Mumbai

    Annexure R-5: True copy of the mail dated 14.05.2025 sent by Shri B. Siva Kumar Reddy (Respondent No. 5) regarding joining the office of CDSCO, Cochin Sea Port on 16.05.2025 **************

    23

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    DR C SARAVANAN v. CENTRAL DRUGS STANDARD ORGANIZATION
    (Jun 10, 2025)