O R D E R
HON'BLE MR. D. S. MAHRA MEMBER (J)
01. The applicant was initially appointed as Constable in the J&K Police on 14-10-1987. The applicant and his mother fell ill, prompting him to take leave which was duly sanctioned. However, he subsequently absented himself from duty without authorization. The applicant was removed from service for unauthorized absence on 09-08-1990. Against the order of removal from service dated 09-08-1990, the applicant filed Writ Petition No. 607/1991 before the Hon'ble High Court of J&K. The Hon'ble High Court vide order dated 08- 07-1997 set aside the removal order and further directed the respondents to initiate a fresh enquiry against the applicant. The Hon'ble High Court had
2
held as follows:
"Impugned Order No. 487 of 1990 dated 9.8.1990 shall stand quashed but it shall be open to the respondents to reinstate the petitioner or place him under suspension for facing an inquiry into the charge of his alleged unauthorised absence from service, if any proposed to be held, in accordance with law. In case the report of inquiry goes in his favour, his reinstatement in service and his case for grant of consequential benefits, shall be considered by the Competent Authority in accordance with rules. But, if he fails in the inquiry, respondents shall be at liberty to take appropriate action against him which may even involve his removal from service in accordance with law.
Requisite inquiry shall be completed within six months from today."
02. In pursuance of the direction issued by the Hon'ble
3
High Court, the applicant was reinstated vide order dated 11-11-1997 and simultaneously the respondent department initiated a fresh enquiry against the applicant. Mr. S. M. Khatotra, Deputy Commandant (SP), JKAP 8th Battalion, was appointed as an enquiry officer. The enquiry officer conducted a detailed enquiry and came to the conclusion that no charge was proved and recommended dropping of all the charges levelled against the applicant. The disciplinary authority (respondent no. 4), while accepting the enquiry report and his recommendation, exonerated the applicant from all the charges levelled against him in its final order dated 16-05-1998; however, the period from 09-08-1990 to 11-11-1997 was treated as dies non. The relevant portion of the order dated 16- 05-1998 is as follows:
"In view of the above facts, partially agreeing with the recommendation of the enquiry officer, it is hereby ordered that:- CONSTABLE ZAHOOR AHMED NO.313/8th
4
(EX.NO.554/8th) IS EXONERATED OF THE CHARGES LEVELLED AGAINST HIM. However, the period w.e.f 9.8.90 to 11.11.97 i,e 2647 days, he remained under dismissal is treated as DIES NON on the principle of "no work no pay".
The constable is reinstated into service with immediate effect and the period of suspension he remains present is treated on duty."
03. Feeling aggrieved by the said order dated 16-05-1998, the applicant filed a review petition under the Rules before the competent authority, which was dismissed on 10-11-2001 and affirmed the order dated 16-05- 1998. The applicant thereafter filed number of representations against the said impugned orders dated 16-05-1998 and 10-11-2001, which are still under active consideration of the respondents, with the latest communication dated 23-06-2023. The applicant has impugned the order dated 16-05-1998 & 10-11-2001 in the present OA along with the condonation of delay.
5
04. Learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the applicant had absented himself for reasons beyond his control, as he was unwell and his mother was also hospitalised. Therefore, the order treating the period as dies non is contrary to the rules. He further submitted that since Writ Petition No. 607/1991 remained pending before the Hon'ble High Court and was finally decided on 08.07.1997—whereby the removal order was quashed—the delay from 09.08.1990 to 11.11.1997 occurred solely due to the pendency of the said writ petition. Thus, the applicant cannot be held responsible or penalised for the delay. Learned counsel for the applicant further contended that since the enquiry officer did not held him guilty in the report submitted to disciplinary authority, the impugned order treating the said period as dies non was wholly unwarranted and ought not to have been passed.
05. On the other hand, Learned counsel for the
6
respondents submitted that there is delay in filing the OA and the order of dies non has been passed by the competent authority in accordance with law; therefore, the present OA deserves to be dismissed.
06. Heard Learned counsel for both sides and perused the material available on record.
07. The applicant was removed from service on 09.08.1990. He challenged the said removal by filing Writ Petition No. 607/1991 before the Hon'ble High Court of Jammu & Kashmir. The Writ Petition remained pending for nearly seven years and was finally decided on 08.07.1997. The delay in disposal of the writ petition cannot be attributed to the applicant. In compliance with the order of the Hon'ble High Court, the applicant was reinstated in service on 11.11.1997. A fresh departmental enquiry was also initiated as directed by the Court. The Enquiry Officer, after conducting a detailed enquiry, found that the
7
charges against the applicant were not proved. While accepting the report of the Enquiry Officer, the Disciplinary Authority, however, suo motu decided to treat the period from 09.08.1990 to 11.11.1997 as dies non. No prior notice was issued to the applicant before passing such an order, which was required under law. This action amounts to a clear violation of the principles of natural justice. In this way, there was no scope for the disciplinary authority to pass the impugned order treating the period from 09-08-1990 to 11-11-1997 as dies non. Moreover, this period was taken by the Hon'ble High Court in deciding Writ Petition No. 607/1991, for which the applicant cannot be held responsible.
08. The relevant provisions pertaining to dies non are contained in Article 163 of the Civil Service Regulations, Volume I, and the Explanation to Article
163. The said provisions are reproduced herein for ready reference:
8
Leave Without Allowances- Extraordinary leave without allowances may in case of necessity and when no other leave is by rule admissible, be granted for such time as may be necessary. Time spent on leave under this Article does not count as service for other leave. Subject to the provisions of Article 113 there is no limit to the length or frequency of leave under this Article. It may not be granted in combination with the grant of other leave, except as provided in Article 130. But it may be granted in continuation of other leave if circumstances arise which prevent the return of the officer to duty and which in the opinion of the Government or the authority empowered to grant leave, are such as to justify the concession. No officer is entitled to extraordinary leave."
Explanation- "The Word 'Dies-non' is an abbreviated form of 'Dies-non Juriducus' means a day on which no legal business is transacted or which is not reckoned for some particular purpose. The period which is directed to be treated as 'Dies- non' cannot therefore be counted for service benefits otherwise available for that period. In fact, the period required or ordered to be treated as 'Dies-non' is by way of concession for permitting the beneficiary thereof to have service in continuation of period before the beneficiary proceeded on unauthorized absence for particular period. Literal meaning of 'Dies-non' would boil down to mean that this period is not capable of being counted at all for purposes of possible benefits to the beneficiary. Rights which have accrued to him till the date of his proceeding on unauthorized leave or rights which may
9
accrue to him after he is allowed to join service as a result of directions that the period of absence be treated as 'Dies-non remain quite intact, but no benefit whatsoever can accrue to him as a result of, call it concession or legal fiction of construing the period of unauthorized absence as 'Dies-non' under any circumstances. This period cannot count for any purpose, whatsoever.] *[Recast by F. D. Notification SRO-514 dated: 22- 11-1999]
Accordingly, the import of the term 'Dies-non' is that:-
(i) It does not qualify for any remuneration (pay and allowances);
(ii) It does not count for pension;
(iii) It does not count for increments;
(iv) It does not cause any interruption for leave earned up to the date preceding that on which the period of Dies-non has commenced;
(v) It does not cause any interruption for the past service qualifying for Pension;
(vi) It shall not count for experience;
(vii) During 'Dies-non' the concerned Government servant shall not be entitled for promotion;
(viii) The concerned shall lose seniority in his cadre/category by the period, which is treated as 'Dies- non'.]"
09. Article 163 of the Civil Service Regulations, along with the Explanation annexed, makes it clear that dies
10
non carries several consequences in the service career of a Government employee [mentioned in the explanation from (i) to (viii)]. It affects pension, increments, experience, seniority, and promotion, among other service-related benefits. In this view, the provision of dies non has serious implications for the service prospects of an employee and, therefore, cannot be invoked in a casual manner.
10. Coming back to the present case, the punishment of removal from service imposed on the applicant for the period of alleged unauthorized absence was set aside by the Hon'ble High Court vide order dated 08-07- 1997, with a direction to the respondents to initiate a fresh enquiry. The enquiry was conducted by the designated enquiry officer, who recorded a finding that the charges against the applicant were not proved. It is a matter of record that the applicant remained out of service from 09-08-1990 to 11-11-1997. However, this period cannot be treated as unauthorized absence for
11
the simple reason that the Writ Petition No. 607/1991, challenging the order of removal, remained pending before the Hon'ble High Court during this time. The applicant's removal from service for this period was based on an order that was ultimately quashed. Following the direction of the Hon'ble High Court, the applicant was reinstated in service. In these circumstances, the impugned order treating the said period as dies non is apparently contrary to law, arbitrary in nature, and in violation of the principles of natural justice.
11. The order declaring the period from 09-08-1990 to 11-11-1997 as dies non has significant adverse consequences on the applicant's service career. The Hon'ble High Court of Jammu & Kashmir, in
Mohammad Iqbal Lone vs. State of J&K & Ors., SWP No. 2002/2015, decided on 24-09-2019, while dealing with a similar sitaution, observed as under:
"In view of the preceding analysis, the petition of the
12
petitioner is allowed, as a sequel thereto, the order impugned insofar as it pertains to treating the period of discharge of the petitioner from 18th of June, 1998 till 4th of August, 2009 as 'Dies-non', is quashed. However, the petitioner shall not be entitled to any salary for the aforesaid period only on the principle of 'No Work No Pay'."
12. In view of above, the decision of the disciplinary authority to treat the period from 09-08-1990 to 11-11- 1997 as dies non is contrary to law and the same is set aside. The respondents are directed to treat this period as on duty; however, the applicant shall not be entitled to any monetary benefits on the principle of "No Work No Pay". Delay, if any, is condoned on the ground that the claim of the applicant was still under active consideration of the respondents, which is evident from the communication dated 23-06-2023 addressed to the Director General of Police, J&K by the Principal, STC Sheeri Baramulla. The case of the
13
applicant is also covered by the latest judgment of the
Hon'ble High Court of J&K & Ladakh in the matter titled Mohd. Sadeeq Vs. State of Jammu & Kashmir, passed in SWP No. 452/2019 decided on 25-04-2024.
13. Accordingly, the OA is allowed. No order as to costs.
D S MAHRA
Member(J)
DEVENDRA TRIPATHI
14