Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 11 of the 1963 Act
  • Section 5/11 of the Maharashtra Ownership of Flats (Regulation of the Promotion of Construction, Sale, Management and Transfer) Act, 1963
  • the provisions of the 1963 Act
  • the "1 963 Act"
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 11 of the 1963 Act
  • Section 5/11 of the Maharashtra Ownership of Flats (Regulation of the Promotion of Construction, Sale, Management and Transfer) Act, 1963
  • the provisions of the 1963 Act
  • the "1 963 Act"
Smart Summary

Supreme Court of India

Factual and Procedural Background

The dispute concerns 1,519.56 sq. m. of land (Survey No. 22, Hissa No. 1, C.T.S. No. 75/B) situated at Bandivali Hill Road, Jogeshwari (West), Mumbai. The larger parcel was conveyed in 1951 to Byramjee Jeejeebhoy Private Limited (BJPL). BJPL leased the land in 1952 to Ramkishor Singh Kunjbihari (respondent 3), who in turn permitted M/s Prakash Builders (respondent 4) to develop it. Respondent 4 erected an unauthorised 27-flat building, whose purchasers formed Prakash Apartment Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. (respondent 2).

BJPL later conveyed its interest to the appellant (M/s Faime Makers Pvt. Ltd.) on 07 July 2010. Subsequent litigation between the appellant and respondent 3 ended in 2012 consent terms, dividing rights in the larger property.

Respondent 2 sought a deemed conveyance from the Competent Authority under Section 11 of the Maharashtra Ownership of Flats Act, 1963 (“1963 Act”):

  • Application No. 53 of 2020 – dismissed on 22 Feb 2021; the Authority held the issues too complicated and directed the Society to first obtain relief from a civil court.
  • Application No. 101 of 2021 – filed 24 Mar 2021 without approaching any civil court; allowed on 05 Oct 2021, granting unilateral assignment of leasehold rights over 1,321.36 sq. m. land plus 198.20 sq. m. recreational area.

The appellant’s Writ Petition No. 8186/2022 challenging the second order was dismissed by the Bombay High Court on 10 Nov 2023. The present civil appeal (arising out of SLP (C) No. 26654/2023) challenges that dismissal. A connected contempt petition (C) No. 684/2024 was also before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Application No. 101 of 2021 before the Competent Authority was barred by res judicata in view of the unchallenged order dated 22 Feb 2021 dismissing Application No. 53 of 2020.
  2. Whether the Competent Authority, being a statutory quasi-judicial body under the 1963 Act, possessed any power to review its own earlier order.
  3. Whether, on merits, a unilateral assignment of leasehold rights could be granted to respondent 2 for an area exceeding the footprint of the unauthorised building.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • The second application was impermissible until the Society resolved the “legal complications” before a civil court, as expressly directed on 22 Feb 2021; hence Application No. 101/2021 was barred by res judicata.
  • The Competent Authority lacks statutory power of review; allowing the second application amounted to an unlawful review of its own order.
  • The Society cannot obtain benefits under Section 11 because the building was constructed without approvals; even if assignable, the grant should have been limited to the 870 sq. m. area actually occupied.
  • The High Court mis-read the 22 Feb 2021 order as vague, whereas it clearly imposed pre-conditions before any fresh application could be entertained.

Respondent 2 (Society)’s Arguments

  • The first order granted “unconditional liberty” to file a fresh application; therefore the second application was maintainable and did not amount to a review.
  • The second application sought a distinct relief confined to leasehold rights, so no bar of res judicata applied.
  • Challenges to the demarcated area were unsubstantiated; post-High Court survey reports cannot be relied upon in appeal.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ujjam Bai v. State of U.P. (1962 SCC OnLine SC 8) Principle that res judicata applies to quasi-judicial authorities; their decisions bind unless set aside in accordance with law. Used to establish that the Competent Authority’s order dated 22 Feb 2021 attained finality and barred a subsequent identical application.
Abdul Kuddus v. Union of India (2019) 6 SCC 604 Reaffirmation that opinions of quasi-judicial bodies operate as res judicata and cannot be revisited by a coordinate authority. Strengthened the conclusion that the Competent Authority had no jurisdiction to entertain Application No. 101/2021 contrary to its earlier decision.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court undertook a textual examination of the Competent Authority’s first order (22 Feb 2021) and found it “very clear” that:

  • The Society could apply afresh only after resolving legal complications before an appropriate court.
  • Until such resolution, the Authority lacked power to transfer leasehold rights.

Because the Society neither challenged that order nor sought civil-court clarification, the Authority lacked jurisdiction to consider Application No. 101/2021. Entertaining it amounted to an impermissible review, which statutory bodies cannot undertake absent express authority.

Invoking Ujjam Bai and Abdul Kuddus, the Court reaffirmed that findings of quasi-judicial authorities attain finality and attract res judicata. Consequently, the High Court erred in construing the earlier order as granting unconditional liberty; its contrary interpretation was held unsustainable.

Given this dispositive jurisdictional flaw, the Supreme Court found it unnecessary to address other factual controversies (e.g., demarcation of 870 sq. m.).

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; High Court judgment set aside; Writ Petition allowed; Competent Authority’s order dated 05 Oct 2021 quashed; Application No. 101/2021 dismissed.

Direct Implications: Respondent 2’s unilateral conveyance is nullified; the Society retains liberty—already granted in the 22 Feb 2021 order—to reapply only after resolving identified legal complications in an appropriate court. The connected contempt petition is dismissed as infructuous.

Broader Implications: The judgment reinforces that principles of res judicata bind quasi-judicial authorities and limits their power to revisit settled issues, thereby promoting finality of administrative adjudication under the Maharashtra Ownership of Flats Act.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    M/S FAIME MAKERS PVT. LTD. v. DISTRICT DEPUTY REGISTRAR

    2025 INSC 423

    CA NO…./2025@ SLP(C) NO.26654/2023 ETC. ETC. Page 1 of 14

    REPORTABLE

    IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

    CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

    CIVIL APPEAL NO. OF 2025

    (@ SLP(CIVIL) NO.26654 OF 2023) M/S FAIME MAKERS PVT. LTD. …APPELLANT(S)

    VERSUS

    DISTRICT DEPUTY REGISTRAR,

    CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETIES (3), MUMBAI & ORS. …RESPONDENT(S)

    WITH

    CONTEMPT PETITION (C) NO. 684 of 2024

    IN

    SLP (CIVIL) NO. 26654 OF 2023

    J U D G M E N T

    VIKRAM NATH, J.

    1. Leave granted.

    2. The appellant has assailed the correctness of the judgment and order dated 10.11.2023, passed by the High Court of Bombay, whereby the appellant's Writ Petition No. 8186 of 2022, assailing the correctness of the order dated 05.10.2021 passed by the District Deputy Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Mumbai/

    1

    Competent Authority, was dismissed. By the order dated 05.10.2021, the competent authority had allowed Application No. 101 of 2021, filed by Prakash Apartment Co-operative Housing Society Limited (respondent No.2-Society) under Section 5/11 of the Maharashtra Ownership of Flats (Regulation of the Promotion of Construction, Sale, Management and Transfer) Act, 19631, directing the execution and registration of a unilateral deed of assignment with respect to 1321.36 square meter area of land and the building situated thereon along with 198.20 square meter on the recreational ground in the name of respondent No.2-Society.

    3. Briefly stated, the facts relevant for the present controversy are as follows:

    3.1. The subject land of the dispute comprises Survey No. 22, Hissa No. 1, corresponding to C.T.S. No. 75/B, admeasuring 1,321.36 square meters, along with 198.20 square meters in the Recreational Ground, totalling 1,519.56 square meters, out of a larger parcel of 2,752.9 square meters, situated at Bandivali Hill Road, Jogeshwari (West), Mumbai - 400102, within the Village Bandivali, Taluka Andheri.

    1 Hereinafter referred to as the "1 963 Act"

    2

    3.2. The larger property, which includes the subject land, was transferred to Byramjee Jeejeebhoy Private Limited (hereinafter, "BJPL") through a Deed of Conveyance dated 24.07.1951, executed between Nanabhoy Byramjee

    Jeejeebhoy and BJPL

    3.3. On 29.10.1952, BJPL, as the lessor, executed an Indenture of Lease in favour of Ramkishor Singh Kunjbihari (respondent No.3) as the lessee. Subsequently, respondent No.3 granted development rights over the leased land to M/s Prakash Builders (respondent No. 4).

    3.4. Respondent No.4 constructed an unauthorized building on the land, without approved plans, comprising approximately 27 flats. These flats were sold to various purchasers, who later formed respondent No.2-Society.

    3.5. On 07.07.2010, BJPL executed a Deed of Conveyance in favour of the appellant, whereby it sold its right, title, interest, and share in the larger property—including the subject land—to the appellant. Consequently, the appellant became the landowner as per the provisions of the 1963 Act.

    3.6. On 06.09.2012, the legal heirs of the late Ramkishor Singh (respondent No. 3) filed a suit against the appellant and BJPL. The dispute was eventually settled through Consent Terms, wherein the parties agreed to divide the larger property into two portions.

    3.7. Pursuant to the Consent Terms, a Deed of Surrender of Leasehold Rights was executed on 30.12.2012 between the appellant and

    3

    respondent No.3. Through this deed, the appellant surrendered 3,596 square meters of land from the larger property in favour of respondent No.3, while respondent No.3 relinquished his leasehold rights over 2,786 square meters in favour of the appellant. As a result, the appellant became the owner of 2,768 square meters of land within the larger property.

    3.8. The respondent No.2-Society applied for a Unilateral Certificate of Deemed Conveyance under Section 11 of the 1963 Act before the Competent Authority which was registered as Application No.53 of 2020.

    3.9. By an order dated 22.02.2021, the Competent Authority dismissed the respondent No.2- Society's application, observing that the Society was eligible to seek the relief of unilateral conveyance of assignment of leasehold rights. The application was also rejected due to legal uncertainties and complications regarding the identity of the land's promoter and on account of transfers. The order directed that the parties should first seek appropriate relief from a competent Civil Court, following which the Society was granted liberty to file a fresh application. This order attained finality as it was not assailed before any superior forum/Court.

    3.10. Despite the Registrar's directive, the respondent No.2-Society did not approach the Civil Court to resolve the legal complications. Instead, on 24.03.2021, it submitted a fresh

    4

    application to the Competent Authority, seeking a Unilateral Assignment of Leasehold Rights which was registered as Application No.101 of 2021.

    3.11. On 05.10.2021, the Competent Authority passed an order granting the unilateral assignment of leasehold rights in favour of the respondent No.2-Society.

    3.12. Aggrieved by this order, the appellant challenged it by filing Writ Petition No. 8186 of 2022 before the High Court of Bombay and by the impugned order dated 10.11.2023, the High Court dismissed the appellant's writ petition, leading to the present appeal.

    4. We have heard Shri Dama Seshadri Naidu, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant and learned counsel appearing for respondent No.2- Society as also the intervenors.

    5. Mr. Naidu, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant made the following submissions:

    (i). The Competent Authority had dismissed the first application filed by the respondent No.2- Society under Section 11 of the 1963 Act by order dated 22.02.2021, on the finding that the issues involved were complicated and the respondent No. 2-Society ought to get the same sorted out by a competent Civil Court and only thereafter apply afresh. A further finding recorded was that no conveyance of sale could

    5

    be directed. However, only conveyance of assignment of leasehold rights could be granted, but that too after sorting out of the issues. The said order dated 22.02.2021 was never assailed by the respondent No.2-Society. Respondent No.2-Society thereafter did not take any steps to approach the appropriate forum for sorting out or resolving out the issues mentioned in the order dated 22.02.2021 and instead, within a month, it moved a second application before the Competent Authority on 24.03.2021, registered as Application No. 101 of 2021, seeking relief for the unilateral assignment of leasehold rights in favour of respondent No.2-Society. The submission was that the second application was not maintainable without the issues being resolved by the competent Civil Court as directed in the order dated 22.02.2021. The second application for leasehold rights could have been filed only after the issues resolved by the competent Civil Court. The second application was thus barred by the principle of res judicata, and the Competent Authority, while allowing the second application, committed a serious error in entertaining the same.

    6

    (ii). The Competent Authority is a statutory authority and would fall within the category of quasi-judicial authority as it decides the application as per the statutory provisions after providing due opportunity of hearing to the concerned parties, as such until and unless specifically provided by Statute, it would not have power of review. The order dated 05.10.2021, passed by the Competent Authority allowing Application No. 101 of 2021, clearly amounted to a review of the first order dated 22.02.2021. No power was vested in the said authority by the Statute i.e. the 1963 Act as such was without jurisdiction or authority of law.

    (iii). Even on merits, the Competent Authority erred in granting the relief for unilateral assignment of leasehold rights, as the constructions made were not authorised, and no commencement certificate for raising the construction of building in question was ever obtained, and as such no benefit could be extended to the respondent No.2-Society under Section 11 of the 1963 Act for the inaction of the builder in transferring the ownership rights in favour of the members of the respondent No.2-Society.

    7

    (iv). It was next submitted that even assuming for the sake of argument that unilateral assignment of leasehold rights could be extended to the respondent No.2-Society, there was no justification for granting the same for an area of 1,361 square meter, whereas the building in question was situtate, enclosed within a boundary wall, covering only 870 square meters.

    (v). The High Court committed a manifest error by not correctly reading the first order of the Competent Authority dated 22.02.2021. The High Court went on the premise that the first order dated 22.02.2021 was little vague and confusing. Which was not correct in as much the first order of 22.02.2021 was very clear that the respondent No.2-Society needed to get the complications resolved by the competent Civil Court and only thereafter apply afresh for assignment of leasehold rights.

    (vi). On such submissions, it was prayed that the appeal deserves to be allowed, the impugned orders deserve to be set aside, and the application No. 101 of 2021, filed by respondent No.2-Society under Section 11 of the 1963 Act

    8

    before the Competent Authority, deserves to be rejected.

    6. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent No.2-Society has made the following submissions:

    (i). The High Court correctly appreciated and interpreted the first order dated 22.02.2021 to record a finding that the said order granted unconditional liberty to the respondent No.2- Society to file a fresh application for the assignment of leasehold rights.

    (ii). It was next submitted that the second order dated 05.10.2021 would not amount to a review, as it was dealing with an application seeking a distinct relief from the first application, and in view of the liberty granted, there was no question of any review. The second application was to be dealt with on its own merits, independent of the first order rejecting the first application.

    (iii). It was also submitted that the issue relating to the demarcation of boundary, with respect to the building in question covering only 870 square meter was although raised before the High Court but was completely

    9

    unsubstantiated, as no supporting documents were filed in that regard. The report of the City Survey Officer which was subsequent to the judgement of the High Court cannot be looked into or relied upon by this Court in this appeal.

    7. Having considered these submissions and having perused the order dated 22.02.2021, we have no hesitation to hold that there was no unconditional liberty granted to respondent No.2-Society to apply for the unilateral assignment of leasehold rights. The order dated 22.02.2021 is very clear that complications had arisen because of various transactions inter se parties at different points of time. The relevant facts have already been noted in the earlier part of this judgment.

    8. The relevant extract of the order dated 22.02.2021, whereby the application was dismissed for the reasons given therein, with liberty to apply afresh after sorting out the issues, is reproduced hereunder:

    "…Therefore, the petitioner has to appeal to the appropriate court in this regard. As there is a legal complication in this case, the authority will not be able to make a human transfer in the name of the applicant society. Due to this, the applicant

    society should only demand assignment of leasehold claim and also the competent court should resolve the legal issues related to the

    10

    transfer of the name of the respondent No.3 of the rate of income.

    It is not possible to transfer the leasehold right of the said property in the name of the applicant Society unless these matters are settled. Therefore, I am convinced that after the settlement of these matters, the applicant should be allowed to re-apply for the human transfer of the leasehold rights of the said property and the application submitted by the applicant Society should be rejected."

    9. A plain reading of the above findings of the Competent Authority in its order dated 22.02.2021 leaves no manner of doubt that respondent No.2- Society could approach the Competent Authority afresh for the unilateral assignment of leasehold rights only after getting the complications sorted out before the appropriate Court. The order clearly indicates that the competent authority could not grant leasehold rights under the existing set of facts until and unless the complications were sorted out.

    10. There is no explanation from the side of respondent No.2-Society with respect to the above findings of the Competent Authority recorded in the order dated 22.02.2021, as to why the same was not challenged before a superior forum. Once the said order has been accepted by the parties and has attained finality, the Competent Authority would not have

    11

    jurisdiction to entertain a second application contrary to the findings and directions given by the Competent Authority in the first order.

    11. It has been settled by this Court that the principle of res judicata applies to and binds quasi-judicial authorities. This Court in Ujjam Bai v. State of U.P.2 has taken the view that principles of res judicata equally apply to quasi-judicial bodies. Whenever a judicial or quasi-judicial tribunal gives a finding on law or fact, its findings cannot be impeached collaterally or in a second round and are binding until reversed in appeal or revision or by way of writ proceedings. The characteristic attribute of a judicial act or decision is that it binds, whether right or wrong. Thus, any error, either of fact or law, committed by such bodies cannot be controverted otherwise by way of an appeal or revision or a writ unless the erroneous determination relates to the jurisdictional matter of that body.

    12. This position has been further reinforced in Abdul Kuddus vs. Union of India and others3 which relies upon Ujjam Bai (supra). In Abdul Kuddus (supra), this Court held that the opinion by the Foreigners Tribunal is a quasi-judicial order. Therefore, it would

    2 1962 SCC OnLine SC 8

    3 (2019) 6 SCC 604

    12

    be incorrect to hold that the opinion of the Tribunal and/or the consequential order passed by the Registering Authority would not operate as res judicata. Further, it was established that any quasi- judicial Authority would not ordinarily have the power to unilaterally take a contrary view taken by a coordinate or predecessor authority at an early point in time.

    13. From the foregoing discussion, it is evident that once a Competent Authority (quasi-judicial in nature) settles an issue, that determination attains finality unless it is set aside in accordance with law.

    14. In our opinion, the High Court erred in giving a different interpretation to the above text of the first order dated 22.02.2021. The High Court had extracted the above findings, conclusions, and directions in its impugned order but still moves on to hold that unconditional liberty was given to respondent No.2-Society, which in our opinion, was not correct.

    15. Without further burdening this order by entering into the other issues, we are satisfied that the impugned order cannot be sustained. The second application filed by the respondent No.2-Society under Section 11 of the 1963 Act before the Competent Authority, being Application No. 101 of 2021, deserves to be

    13

    dismissed. However, the liberty granted in the first order of the Competent Authority dated 22.02.2021, while rejecting Application No. 53 of 2020, would still be available to the respondent No.2-Society but only after getting the complications resolved/sorted out before the appropriate Court/Forum.

    16. Accordingly, the appeal is allowed, impugned order of the High Court is set aside, the writ petition would stand allowed, and the order dated 05.10.2021 passed by the Competent Authority is quashed.

    17. In view of the above findings, the Contempt Petition

    (C) No. 684 of 2024 would not require any further consideration. It is accordingly disposed of.

    18. Pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.

    ………………………………..J.

    [VIKRAM NATH]

    ………………………………..J.

    [PRASANNA B. VARALE]

    NEW DELHI;

    APRIL 01, 2025

    14

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M/S FAIME MAKERS PVT. LTD. v. DISTRICT DEPUTY REGISTRAR
    (Apr 1, 2025)