AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Order XXVI Rules 1 and 9 r/w. Section 151 of CPC
  • Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 r/w. Section 151 of CPC
  • Order XXVI Rule 9 of CPC,
  • Order XXVI Rule 18 of CPC
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Order XXVI Rules 1 and 9 r/w. Section 151 of CPC
  • Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 r/w. Section 151 of CPC
  • Order XXVI Rule 9 of CPC,
  • Order XXVI Rule 18 of CPC
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This writ petition was filed by Newspace Research and Technologies Private Limited under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, challenging the order dated 29.11.2024 passed by the XIX Additional City Civil and Sessions Judge, Bengaluru. The trial court had refused to grant an ex-parte order for appointment of a Commissioner in IA No.3 in O.S.No.8367/2024, but issued an emergent notice instead.

The petitioner had initially filed a suit for perpetual injunction restraining the defendants and associated persons from copying, sharing, or using confidential/proprietary information belonging to the plaintiff. Along with the suit, the petitioner filed interlocutory applications seeking an ex-parte temporary injunction (IA No.2) and the appointment of a Commissioner (IA No.3) for search and seizure of data storage media and related materials.

The trial court granted the ex-parte temporary injunction but declined to appoint the Commissioner ex-parte, only issuing notice to the defendants. The petitioner then approached the High Court, which on 06.12.2024 appointed a Court Commissioner by ex-parte order to conduct search and seizure from 20.12.2024 to 28.12.2024. The Commissioner submitted a report on 06.01.2025, which was taken on record.

The respondents raised preliminary objections regarding the maintainability of the writ petition and the ex-parte interim order granted by the High Court, contending that the trial court lacked jurisdiction to appoint a Commissioner ex-parte under Order XXVI Rule 9 of the CPC and that the High Court's ex-parte appointment was without jurisdiction.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the court can pass an ex-parte order appointing a Court Commissioner in an intellectual property rights case?
  2. Whether the trial court has jurisdiction to appoint a Commissioner ex-parte under Order XXVI Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC)?
  3. Whether the ex-parte interim order appointing the Court Commissioner without notice to the respondents is valid and within jurisdiction?
  4. What is the scope and applicability of the Court's power to appoint a Commissioner for search and seizure in intellectual property infringement matters?

Arguments of the Parties

Respondents' Arguments

  • The petitioner failed to establish a case for invoking the extraordinary jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 227 of the Constitution.
  • The trial court did not have the power to appoint an ex-parte Court Commissioner under Order XXVI Rule 9 of CPC; therefore, issuing summons instead of an ex-parte appointment was correct.
  • The ex-parte interim order passed by the High Court appointing the Commissioner was without jurisdiction since notice must be given to the respondents before such appointment.
  • The Court Commissioner’s report submitted pursuant to the ex-parte order cannot be accepted.
  • The appointment of a Court Commissioner under Order XXVI Rule 9 CPC is limited to local investigations for elucidating disputes or ascertaining values or damages, and does not extend to search and seizure of software or electronic devices without notice.
  • Reliance was placed on the Supreme Court judgment in Padam Sen and Another vs. State of Uttar Pradesh, AIR 1961 SC 218, which emphasized that courts cannot forcibly seize documents without prior summons and production by parties.
  • Also relied upon was Manohar Lal Chopra vs. Rai Bahadur Rao Raja Seth Hirelal, AIR 1962 SC 527, reinforcing procedural safeguards.
  • Sought dismissal of the writ petition on these grounds.

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The High Court’s ex-parte order dated 06.12.2024 appointing the Commissioner to search and seize documents has attained finality and the respondents, if aggrieved, must challenge it before the Supreme Court.
  • The Court Commissioner’s report should be transferred to the trial court for consideration, which can decide its legality after hearing both parties.
  • In intellectual property infringement suits, the court has the power to pass ex-parte orders appointing Commissioners for seizure of materials to preserve evidence.
  • Ex-parte appointment is necessary to maintain the element of surprise and prevent respondents from removing infringing products prior to inspection.
  • Relied on the Supreme Court judgment disposing Special Leave to Appeal (Civil) Nos. 12950-12951/2022 dated 17.11.2022.
  • Supported by the Delhi High Court’s guidelines in Autodesk Inc. and Another vs. A.V.T. Shankardass and Another, AIR 2008 Delhi 167 for appointment of local commissioners in software piracy cases.
  • Also relied on the Bombay High Court judgment in Foundry Visionmongers Ltd. vs. Ankur Sudhir Sachdev and Others, AIR 2016 SCC online Bombay 932.
  • Argued that the Supreme Court’s decision in Padam Sen concerned inherent powers under Section 151 CPC and did not address the power under Order XXVI Rule 9 CPC, thus it is not applicable.
  • Sought allowance of the writ petition and validation of the ex-parte appointment of the Commissioner.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Padam Sen and Another vs. State of Uttar Pradesh, AIR 1961 SC 218 Limits on court’s inherent power under Section 151 CPC to appoint Commissioner for seizure; requirement of summons and production of documents before forcible seizure. The Court held this precedent was not applicable to the instant case as it did not decide the power under Order XXVI Rule 9 CPC for ex-parte appointment of Commissioner in intellectual property cases.
Manohar Lal Chopra vs. Rai Bahadur Rao Raja Seth Hirelal, AIR 1962 SC 527 Procedural safeguards in appointment of Commissioners and seizure of documents. Referenced by respondents to assert necessity of notice and procedural compliance before appointment of Commissioner.
Anton Piller KG vs. Manufacturing Process & Others, (1976) 1 All ER 779 Origin and purpose of Anton Piller orders allowing ex-parte search and seizure to preserve evidence in intellectual property cases. Discussed by the Court to explain the rationale behind ex-parte appointment of Court Commissioners in IP infringement cases to preserve evidence and prevent tampering.
United States of America vs. John Doe (18 U.S.C. 1956 (b)(4)) Use of John Doe orders for unknown infringers allowing ex-parte relief in IP cases. Explained as part of the evolution of ex-parte relief in IP matters, supporting the use of surprise element in enforcement.
Taj Television Ltd. & Others vs. Rajan Mandal and Others (Delhi High Court, 2002) Use of John Doe and Anton Piller orders in Indian courts for IP enforcement. Referenced to show Indian judicial acceptance of ex-parte orders for appointment of Commissioners in IP infringement cases.
Autodesk Inc. and Another vs. A.V.T. Shankardass and Another, AIR 2008 Delhi 167 Guidelines for appointment of local Commissioners in software infringement and piracy matters. The Court relied on these guidelines to justify ex-parte appointment of Commissioner to preserve infringing evidence and maintain surprise element.
Foundry Visionmongers Ltd. vs. Ankur Sudhir Sachdev and Others, AIR 2016 SCC online Bombay 932 Support for ex-parte appointment of Commissioners in IP infringement cases. Relied upon to bolster the petitioner’s argument that ex-parte orders are appropriate in such contexts.
Special Leave to Appeal (Civil) Nos. 12950-12951/2022 (Supreme Court order dated 17.11.2022) Clarification that the legality and validity of Court Commissioner reports should be decided by the trial court after hearing parties; High Court should not pre-judge. The Court followed this precedent in directing the transfer of the Commissioner’s report to the trial court for appropriate consideration and opportunity to both parties.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the scope of Order XXVI Rule 9 of the CPC and the nature of intellectual property rights, recognizing the intangible and commercially valuable character of IP. The Court emphasized the necessity of ex-parte orders for appointment of Commissioners in IP infringement cases to preserve evidence and maintain the element of surprise, thereby preventing destruction or removal of infringing material by defendants.

The Court distinguished the precedent in Padam Sen, which dealt with inherent powers under Section 151 CPC and did not address the specific power under Order XXVI Rule 9 CPC to appoint Commissioners ex-parte in IP matters. The Court also relied on authoritative guidelines from the Delhi High Court in Autodesk Inc., which endorse ex-parte appointments in software piracy cases to protect evidence.

The Court noted that the Supreme Court, in the Special Leave to Appeal disposed of on 17.11.2022, clarified that the legality and validity of Court Commissioner reports are to be examined by the trial court after giving opportunity to parties, and the High Court should not pre-judge such reports.

Accordingly, the Court held that the ex-parte appointment of the Commissioner was valid and necessary in the circumstances. The Commissioner’s report submitted pursuant to the ex-parte order should be transferred to the trial court, which must decide its legality and validity after hearing both parties. The High Court refrained from expressing any opinion on the merits of the report.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is disposed of.

The Court directed the Registry to transfer the Court Commissioner’s report to the trial court, which is to decide on the legality and validity of the report after providing an opportunity to both parties. The High Court clarified that it has not expressed any opinion on the merits of the report, leaving the trial court to take an appropriate decision in accordance with law.

The trial court was also directed to dispose of IA No.IV expeditiously in accordance with law.

This decision directly affects the parties by validating the ex-parte appointment of a Commissioner in intellectual property infringement cases and establishing procedural guidance for handling Commissioner’s reports. No new precedent beyond the facts of the case was set by the Court.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    NEWSPACE RESEARCH AND TECHNOLOGIES PRIVATE LIMITED v. MR ANIRUDH PUTSALA

    1

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

    DATED THIS THE 29THDAY OF JANUARY 2025

    BEFORE

    THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H. T. NARENDRA PRASAD

    WP No.32999 OF 2024 (GM -CPC)

    BETWEEN

    NEWSPACE RESEARCH AND

    TECHNOLOGIES PRIVATE LIMITED

    A COMPANY REGISTERED UNDER

    COMPANIES ACT 2013

    HAVING ITS OFFICE AT NO. 2385

    1ST FLOOR 60 FEET ROAD

    SAHAKARNAGAR, BENGALURU

    KARNATAKA 560 092

    REP BY ITS DIRECTOR

    MR SAMEER JOSHI.

    ...PETITIONER

    (BY SRI. ANGAD KAMATH, ADVOCATE FOR

    SMT. RAMYA S., ADVOCATE)

    AND

    1 . MR ANIRUDH PUTSALA

    AGED MAJOR

    S/O PRASADA RAO PUTSALA R/AT 303, SRI LAKSHMI VEKATESHWARA PG

    NO. 1723, 1ST MAIN 6TH CROSS

    SANJEEVINI NAGAR

    KODIGEHALLI MAIN ROAD

    BANGALORE 560092.

    R

    2

    2 . LENVIZ TECHNOLOGIES PRIVATE LIMITED

    HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT L-58

    SECTOR 11 NOIDA, GAUTAM BUDDHA NAGAR

    UTTAR PRADESH 201 301.

    ALSO AT.

    GNEC-IIT ROORKEE PLOT NO. 20

    KNOWLEDGE PARK II, GREATER NOIDA

    UTTAR PRADESH 201 310

    REP BY ITS DIRECTOR

    MR PRABHAT SHARMA.

    3 . MR PRABHAT SHARMA

    AGED MAJOR

    S/O MR SHISHU PAL SHARMA

    DIRECTOR

    LENVIZ TECHNOLOGIES PRIVATE LIMITED

    L-58 SECTOR 11 NOIDA

    GAUTAM BUDDHA NAGAR

    UTTAR PRADESH 201 301

    ALSO AT GNEC IIT ROORKEE

    PLOT NO. 20, KNOWLEDGE PARK II

    GREATER NOIDA, UTTAR PRADESH 201 310

    ALSO AT B2/510 TOWER II SILVER CITY

    SECTOR 93, NOIDA

    UTTAR PRADESH 210 304.

    4 . MR AKASH PATIL

    AGED MAJOR

    S/O MADHUKAR PATIL

    FLAT NO. A031 VAJRAM ELINA

    R K HEGDE NAGAR, THANISANDRA MAIN ROAD

    BANGALORE, KARNATAKA-560 064

    ALSO AT FLAT NO. 1 ANUJ HEIGHTS

    PURNANAGAR, CHINCHWAD, PUNE 411 019

    …RESPONDENTS

    (BY SRI. ARUN KUMAR K, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR

    SRI RAKSHITH PAI & VYBHAVASHREE S., ADVOCATES)

    3

    THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 227 OF

    THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO

    SET ASIDE THE ORDER OF THE XIX ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL

    AND SESSIONS JUDGE (CCH-18) AT BENGALURU DATED:

    29.11.2024 ANNEXURE-A TO THE EXTENT THAT AD INTERIM

    EX PARTE RELIEF ON I.A.NOS. 3 OF 2024 WAS REFUSED

    AND EMERGENT NOTICE WAS ISSUED ETC.

    THIS WP HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR

    ORDERS ON 21.01.2025, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT

    THIS DAY, THE COURT, MADE THE FOLLOWING:

    CORAM: HON'BLE MR JUSTICE H.T. NARENDRA PRASAD

    CAV ORDER

    This writ petition is filed by the plaintiff under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, challenging the order dated 29.11.2024 passed by the XIX Additional City Civil and Sessions Judge, Bengaluru on IA No.3 in O.S.No.8367/2024, refusing to grant ex- parte order for appointment of Commissioner.

    2. The petitioner/plaintiff filed a suit for perpetual injunction, restraining the defendants, their agents, contractors, his employers, partners or any other person/entity claiming through or under the defendants from directly or indirectly copying, sharing

    4

    or using in any manner the confidential/proprietary information/material belonging to the plaintiff, inter alia, as referred in the forensic investigation report produced as document 20 and a decree of mandatory injunction directing the defendants, their agents, contractors, his employers, partners or any other person/entity claiming through or under the defendants to deliver up to the plaintiff all copies of, and destroy any remaining physical and digital copies of the confidential/proprietary information/material belonging to the plaintiff.

    3. Along with the plaint, plaintiff has filed IA No.2 under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 r/w. Section 151 of CPC with a prayer to grant an ad-interim order of ex- parte temporary injunction. IA No.3 is filed under Order XXVI Rules 1 and 9 r/w. Section 151 of CPC with a prayer to grant an ex-parte interim order to appoint a Commissioner. On consideration of IA Nos.2

    5

    and 3, the trial court issued an ad-interim ex-parte temporary injunction order against the defendants, restraining them, their agents, contractors, employers, partners or any other person/entity claiming through or under the defendants from directly or indirectly copying, sharing or using in any manner the confidential/proprietary information/ material belonging to the plaintiff, in the interest of justice and equity, till the next date of hearing. Regarding IA No.3, for appointment of Commissioner is concerned, refused to pass an ex-parte order, but only issued an emergent notice. Being aggrieved by the order dated 29.11.2024, the plaintiff is before this Court.

    4. This Court, on 06.12.2024, passed an ex-parte order appointing the Court Commissioner to carry out search and seizure of the operation of the data storage media, files, folders, documents etc. in the

    6

    premises of the respondents/defendants and directed the Commissioner to execute the warrant for seven days from 20.12.2024 to 28.12.2024 and report the same to this Court on 06.01.2025. On 06.01.2025, the Court Commissioner has submitted a report in a sealed cover and the same is taken on record.

    5. The learned counsel for the respondents/ defendants has appeared on 06.01.2025 and raised a preliminary objection regarding the maintainability of the writ petition and ex-parte interim order granted by this Court. On that issue, the matter was heard on

    15.01.2025.

    6. The learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondents/defendants raised the following contentions:

    (i) Firstly, the petitioner/plaintiff has sought to invoke the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court

    7

    under Article 227 of the Constitution of India. However, the petitioner has failed to make out any case for availing and invoking the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court.

    (ii) Secondly, the petitioner/plaintiff has filed an application for appointment of a Commissioner under Order XXVI Rule 9 of CPC. Since the trial court has no power to order the appointment of ex-parte Court Commissioner under Order XXVI Rule 9 of CPC, the trial court has rightly issued summons to the defendants. There is no error or illegality in the order passed by the trial court.

    (iii) Thirdly, the ex-parte interim order passed by this Court, appointing the Court Commissioner under Order XXVI Rule 9 of CPC is without jurisdiction. The Court Commissioner can be appointed only after the service of notice to the respondents/defendants.

    8

    Therefore, the report submitted by the Court Commissioner pursuant to the order passed by this Court on 06.12.2024, cannot be accepted.

    (iv) Fourthly, the Court Commissioner can be appointed under Order XXVI Rule 9 of CPC to make a local investigation for the purpose of elucidating any matter in dispute, or of ascertaining the market value of the property, or the amount of any mesne profits or damages or annual net profits. The Court Commissioner cannot be appointed for search and seizure of the software, computer and laptops from the premises of the parties, that too, without giving any notice and therefore, the writ petition filed by the petitioner/plaintiff itself is not maintainable. The ex- parte order passed by this Court appointing the Court Commissioner on 06.12.2024 is without jurisdiction. In support of his contentions, he relied on the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of PADAM

    9

    SEN AND ANOTHER vs. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH reported in AIR 1961 SC 218 and contended that before appointing a Commissioner the Court has to call upon the parties to produce documents, when the parties fail to produce the relevant documents which is in their possession, especially after it has been summoned from it, then only appoint a Court Commissioner. The court has no power to get hold of the documents forcibly from the possession of the parties.

    (v) Fifthly, the ex-parte interim order passed by this Court is contrary to the judgment of the Apex Court in the cases of PADAM SEN (supra) and

    MANOHAR LAL CHOPRA vs. RAI BAHADUR RAO RAJA SETH HIRELAL reported in AIR 1962 SC 527.

    Hence, he sought to dismiss the writ petition.

    10

    7. On the other hand, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner/plaintiff raised the following contentions:

    (i) Firstly, this Court, by order dated 06.12.2024 passed an ex-parte order, appointing the local Commissioner to search and seize the documents and some materials and a warrant has been issued to execute the same from 20.12.2024 to 28.12.2024. Pursuant to that, the warrant is executed and report has been submitted. If the respondents/defendants are aggrieved by that order, they have to challenge the same before the Apex Court. Since that order has attained finality, now the report has to be transferred to the trial court. The trial court may be directed to decide the legality and validity of the Court Commissioner's report, after giving opportunity to both the parties. In support of his contentions, he relied on the judgment of the Apex Court in Special

    11

    Leave to Appeal (Civil) Nos. 12950-12951/2022 disposed of on 17.11.2022.

    (ii) Secondly, in the suit for infringement of copy right, the court has the power to pass an ex-parte order appointing the Commissioner under Order XXVI Rule 9 of CPC for seizing and collecting all the materials. The appointment of a court commissioner in the intellectual property rights cases ex-parte is desirable to ensure that the surprise elements remain intact. In the absence whereof the respondents would easily be in a position to remove the infringing products when the Court Commissioner visits the premises of the respondents.

    (iii) Thirdly, the Delhi High Court in the case of

    AUTODESK INC. AND ANOTHER vs. A.V.T.SHANKARDASS AND ANOTHER reported in

    AIR 2008 Delhi 167 has issued a guideline for

    12

    appointment of the local commissioner in software infringement and piracy matter. The trial court, without appreciating the guidelines issued by the Delhi High Court, has erred in refusing to grant ex-parte order. In support of his contention, he has relied on the judgment of the Bombay High Court in the case of FOUNDRY VISIONMONGERS LTD. Vs. ANKUR SUDHIR SACHDEV AND OTHERS reported in AIR 2016 SCC online Bombay 932.

    (iv) Fourthly, this Court has rightly exercised the power under Order XXVI Rule 9 of CPC and passed an order on 06.12.2024.

    (v) Fifthly, in the judgment relied upon by the learned Senior Counsel for the respondents/ defendants in the case of PADAM SEN (supra), the question for determination is with respect to whether the court has right in exercising its inherent power

    13

    under Section 151 of CPC. The Apex Court has not decided the power of the Court under Order XXVI Rule 9 of CPC. In that view of the matter, the judgment relied upon by the learned Senior Counsel for the respondents/defendants is not applicable to the facts of this case. Hence, he sought to allow the writ petition.

    8. Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the writ papers.

    9. The point for consideration in this petition is,

    "Whether the court can pass an ex- parte order appointing a Court Commissioner in an intellectual property rights case?

    10. The intellectual property, though intangible, is probably the most important form of property today. The definition of intellectual property has widened with growth of international trade and

    14

    globalization of economy, giving the whole business a paradigm. Intellectual property having developed into a powerful commercial asset with the ever-evolving digital technology. Intellectual property rights are basically negative right, which allow the right-holder to (i) utilize, (ii) dispose of his rights and (iii) initiate legal action against those who infringe them. Anybody who misappropriates the property is faced with civil and/or criminal consequences. While the traditional remedies include injunction, cost, damages, etc. what has assumed more popularity in these days is the non traditional forms of remedies like, Anton Piller order, interlocutory injunction, etc.

    11. Anton Piller orders are legal mechanisms that allows an applicant to search a defendant's premises and seize evidence without prior notice or warning. They are often referred to as search orders or civil search warrants. The main purpose of Anton

    15

    Piller order is to stop the defendant tampering with any evidence that may be relevant to a court case in intellectual property rights matters. Anton Piller order originated in United Kingdom from the case ANTON PILLER K.G. vs. MANUFACTURING PROCESS & OTHERS reported in (1976) 1 All ER 779. However, this did not address the issue of unknown infringers. This led to adoption of John Doe Orders (whose origin can be traced in United States of America). When such orders were used to refer to unidentifiable defendants,

    UNITED STATES OF AMERICA vs. JOHN DOE (18 U.S.C. 1956 (b)(4)). This order was granted in U.S., Canadian and Australian Courts. Now the Indian Courts are using this concept of issuing ex-parte order in intellectual property rights cases to punish class of unknown infringers. The Delhi High Court passed John Doe order in the year 2002 in TAJ TELEVISION LTD. & OTHERS vs. RAJAN MANDAL AND OTHERS,

    16

    ESPN SOFTWARE INDIA PRIVATE LIMITED vs. TUDO ENTERPRISE. The Delhi High Court also issued Anton Pillar order (ex-parte order for appointment of Court Commissioner) and also issued guidelines in the case of AUTODESK INC (supra).

    The relevant portion is extracted below:

    "14. Coming now to the question of guidelines to be set, we have heard both the counsel for the parties. We are conscious of the fact that it is neither feasible nor practical to lay down guidelines, which would cater to numerous and all the situations that may arise. However, some of the following relevant factors and guidelines are being enumerated which the Court may take into consideration on the question of appointment of a Local Commissioner in software infringement and piracy matters:-

    (i) The object of appointment of a Local Commissioner in software piracy matters is not, as much to collect evidence but to preserve and protect the infringing evidence.

    17

    The pirated software or. incriminating evidence can only be obtained from the premises of the opposite party alone and in the absence of an ex parte appointment of a Local Commissioner there is likelihood that such evidence may be lost, removed or destroyed;

    (ii) Request for ex parte appointment of a Local Commissioner in such matters is usual and in fact is intended to sub serve the ends of justice as it is imperative to have an element of surprise so that the actual position is not altered;

    (iii) The test of reasonable and credible information regarding the existence of pirated software or incriminating evidence should not be subjected to strict proof or the requirement to demonstrate or produce part of the pirated software/incriminating evidence at the initial stage itself. It has to be tested on the touchstone of pragmatism and the natural and normal course of conduct and practice in trade.

    (iv) It may not always be possible for a plaintiff to obtain any admission by employing decoy

    18

    customers and gaining access to the defendant's premises. Any such attempt also inheres in it the possibility of dis-appearance of the pirated software/incriminating evidence in case the decoy customers is exposed. Accordingly, visit by decoy customer or investigator is not to be insisted upon as pre condition. A report of private Investigator need not be dis-regarded or rejected simply because of his engagement by the plaintiff. The information provided by the private Investigator should receive objective evaluation.

    (v) In cases where certain and definite information with regard to the existence of pirated software or incriminating evidence is not available or where the Court may nurture some element of doubt, it may consider asking the plaintiff to deposit cost in Court so that in case pirated software or incriminating evidence is not found then the defendant can be suitably compensated for the obtrusion in his work or privacy".

    19

    12. In view of the above, it is very clear that in the intellectual property rights cases, the ex-parte order of appointment of the Court Commissioner is to ensure that a surprise element remains intact, in the absence whereof the respondents would easily be in a position to remove the infringing products when the court commissioner visits the premises of the respondent. If the ex-parte order is not passed, the respondents/defendants may likely to uninstall or remove the infringed version of the software from their machines, thereby the person tampering with the evidence of the actual usage of the software. It is not as much collecting the evidence but to preserve and protect the infringing evidence. Therefore, an ex- parte order appointing the Court Commisisoner for search and seizure of the business premises of the respondents/defendants is necessary. The Court can pass the ex-parte order only in following situations:

    20

    (a) Where the plaintiff has an extremely strong prima facie case,

    (b) Where the actual or potential damage to the plaintiff is very serious,

    (c) Where it was clear that the defendant possessed vital evidence, and

    (d) There was a real possibility that the defendant might destroy or dispose of such material so as to defeat the ends of justice,

    (e) The purpose of Anton Piller order is the preservation of evidences.

    (f) The Court also has to pass an order safeguarding the interest of the defendant while granting ex-parte order, like undertaking by the plaintiff to compensate the defendant for the losses he wrongly suffered have to be provided while granting Anton Piller order.

    13. In the judgment relied upon by the learned Senior Counsel for the respondents/defendants in the case of PADAM SEN (supra), the issue for determination in that case is that whether the court,

    21

    in exercise of its inherent power under Section 151 of CPC can appoint a commissioner for seizing of the books of accounts of the parties. In the said case, the Apex Court has not decided the power of the court to issue an ex-parte order under Order XXVI Rule 9 of CPC. The judgment relied upon by the learned Senior Counsel for the respondents/defendants is not applicable to the facts of this case.

    14. Pursuant to the order passed by this Court on 06.12.2024, the Commissioner has submitted a report on 06.01.2025. In similar circumstances, the Gujarat High Court in Special Civil Application No. 2588/2020 and connected matters, disposed of on 29.04.2022, wherein the trial court has refused to grant an ex-parte order for appointment of the Commissioner, the plaintiff has approached the High Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India. The High Court has passed an ex-parte order

    22

    appointing a local commissioner in a software infringement and piracy matter. The Court Commissioner has submitted a report. The High Court set aside the Court Commissioner's report on the ground that the Court Commissioner has not given any notice to the respondent as per Order XXVI Rule 18 of CPC and discarded the Court Commissioner's report and directed the trial court to appoint a fresh Commissioner. That order has been questioned before the Apex Court in Special Leave to Appeal (C) Nos.12950-12951/2022. The Apex Court, by order dated 17.11.2022 allowed the appeal. The relevant paragraphs are extracted below:

    "Having heard learned Senior Advocates appearing for the respective parties, we are of the opinion that, while passing the impugned judgment and order, the High Court was not justified in considering the legality and validity of the Court Commissioner's Report. It should have been left to the concerned trial Court to

    23

    take a call on the Court Commissioner's Report and, of course, after giving an opportunity to the respondents on the court Commissioner's Report.

    In view of the above, without expressing anything on the legality and validity of the Court Commissioner's Report, we set aside the impugned common judgment and order passed by the High Court.

    We direct the learned trial Court to give an opportunity to the parties, including the respondents-herein, to make submissions on the legality and validity of the Court Commissioner's Report, before taking into consideration the Court Commissioner's Report. Now, the Court Commissioner's Report be sent to the concerned Commercial Court by the High Court within a period of two weeks from the date of receipt of the present order. Thereafter, it will be open for the respondents- herein/original defendants to raise the objections in writing on the Court Commissioner's Report. It will also be open for the petitioners to also make submissions on

    24

    the Court Commissioner's Report. That thereafter, the learned Commercial Court to take an appropriate decision on the objections to be raised by the respondents on the Court Commissioner's Report in accordance with law and on its own merits and also after giving an opportunity to the petitioners herein, before finally taking into consideration the Court Commissioner's Report any further. It is abundantly made clear that we have not expressed anything on merits on the Court Commissioner's Report and it is ultimately for the concerned Commercial Court to take an appropriate decision in accordance with law and on its own merits and considering the earlier directions issued by the High Court while directing to appoint the Court Commissioner.

    It also goes without saying that if the plaintiffs propose to rely upon the Court Commissioner's Report, in that case, the injunction application shall be decided only after an appropriate decision is taken by the Commercial Court on

    25

    the Court Commissioner's Report, as observed hereinabove."

    15. In view of the above, the point is answered in the affirmative and the following order is passed:

    (i) The writ petition is disposed of

    (ii) Registry is directed to transfer the Court Commissioner's report to the trial court.

    (iii) The trial court is directed to pass appropriate orders, in accordance with law, deciding the legality and validity of the Court Commissioner's report, after giving an opportunity to both parties.

    (iv) It is made clear that this Court has not expressed any opinion on the merits of the Commissioner's report. It is for the trial court to take appropriate decision in accordance with law, on its own merit.

    26

    (v) The trial court is also directed to dispose of IA No.IV, in accordance with law, as expeditiously as possible.

    Sd/-

    (H. T. NARENDRA PRASAD)

    JUDGE

    Cm/-

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    NEWSPACE RESEARCH AND TECHNOLOGIES PRIVATE LIMITED v. MR ANIRUDH PUTSALA
    (Jan 29, 2025)