Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sub-section (1). (3)
  • sub-Section (2) of Section 148A of CPC, 1908,
  • provision of sub-section (2) of Section 148A of CPC
  • provisions of sub-Section (2) of Section 148A of CPC
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sub-section (1). (3)
  • sub-Section (2) of Section 148A of CPC, 1908,
  • provision of sub-section (2) of Section 148A of CPC
  • provisions of sub-Section (2) of Section 148A of CPC
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion — High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Jabalpur (15 January 2025)

Factual and Procedural Background

Respondents No.1 to 4 filed an application under Section 52 of the MPLR Code before the Upper Collector, and an interim order was granted despite the appellants having filed a caveat. The appellants (Mamta Devi and others) challenged the interim order by filing Writ Petition No.35549/2024, which was dismissed by the learned Single Judge by order dated 26.11.2024. The present Writ Appeal (No.3005 of 2024) under Section 2(1) of the Madhya Pradesh Uchcha Nyayalay (Khand Nyaypeeth ko Appeal) Adhiniyam, 2005, assails that dismissal. The appellants contended that they had filed a caveat before the Court of Additional Collector, Chhatarpur, but the interim order dated 25.10.2024 was passed without giving them an opportunity of hearing.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether compliance with sub‑section (2) of Section 148A of the Civil Procedure Code (service of notice of the lodged caveat by registered post, acknowledgment due, on the person by whom the application has been filed or is expected to be filed) is mandatory or directory.
  2. Whether non‑compliance with Section 148A(2) permits a court to proceed to pass an interim order without serving notice on the caveator and without hearing the caveator (i.e., the sequential operation of Section 148A(2) and (3)).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The impugned interim order was passed in contravention of Section 148A of the CPC and in gross violation of the principles of natural justice because the caveator was not given an opportunity to be heard.
  • The provisions of Section 148A(2) are directory, and failure to comply therewith cannot justify refusing or rejecting the caveat or passing an interim order without hearing the caveator.
  • Reliance was placed on a Single Bench decision: State of Karnataka v. NIL (ILR 1999 KAR 2986) to support the contention that the right to lodge a caveat cannot be taken away on the ground of non‑compliance with sub‑section (2).

Respondent/State's Arguments

  • It is mandatory for the caveator to serve notice of the caveat to the opposite party by registered post with acknowledgment due; sub‑section (2) of Section 148A imposes that condition precedent.
  • Since Section 148A(2) was not complied with, there is no question of invoking sub‑section (3); the learned Single Judge correctly concluded that the caveat was not validly constituted and the interim order does not require interference.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Karnataka v. NIL, ILR 1999 KAR 2986 Cited by appellants to support the proposition that the right to lodge a caveat cannot be taken away on the ground of non‑compliance with sub‑section (2) of Section 148A because that provision is directory in nature. The Court noted the appellants' reliance on this decision but did not accept the argument. The Court held that in the present case sub‑section (2) is mandatory and non‑compliance rendered the caveat invalid for purposes of attracting Section 148A(3).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reproduced Section 148A of the CPC and proceeded to examine compliance with sub‑section (2). It found as a fact that the appellants had not served notice of the caveat by registered post with acknowledgment due on the opposite party, as required under Section 148A(2). The Court reasoned that:

  • The object of Section 148A is to protect persons likely to be affected by an order passed on an application and to avoid multiplicity of proceedings; a caveat must specify the nature of the expected application and the caveator's right to appear.
  • Sub‑section (2) imposes an obligation on the caveator to serve a notice of the caveat on the person by whom the application has been or is expected to be made; this requirement must be fulfilled and evidence of service (receipt) should accompany the caveat application.
  • Because the appellants did not comply with Section 148A(2), there was no properly constituted caveat before the Additional Collector; consequently Section 148A(3) (which requires the Court to serve notice of the application on the caveator) could not be made operative in sequence.
  • The learned Single Judge therefore correctly treated compliance with sub‑section (2) as mandatory and concluded that the interim order could not be faulted on the ground of non‑hearing of the caveator.

Holding and Implications

Holding: THIS APPEAL IS DISMISSED.

Implications and direct effects:

  • The order of the learned Single Judge dated 26.11.2024 dismissing W.P. No.35549/2024 is upheld; the interim order passed by the concerned Court stands.
  • The Court held that compliance with Section 148A(2) of the CPC is mandatory for a caveat to be treated as valid for the purposes of invoking Section 148A(3); absence of the mandated service and proof of service means no valid caveat exists to entitle the caveator to notice under subsection (3).
  • No broader precedent beyond the immediate decision is articulated in the opinion; the direct consequence is that the appellants' caveat was ineffective in the circumstances and the appeal does not succeed.
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Mamta Devi v. Rakesh Kumar Yadav

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH

    AT JABALPUR

    BEFORE

    HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUSHRUT ARVIND DHARMADHIKARI &

    HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE AVANINDRA KUMAR SINGH ON THE 15thOF JANUARY, 2025

    WRIT APPEAL No. 3005 of 2024

    MAMTA DEVI AND OTHERS

    Versus

    RAKESH KUMAR YADAV AND OTHERS

    Appearance:

    Shri Saket Agrawal - Learned Counsel for the appellants. Shri S.S. Chauhan - Learned Government Advocate for respondent No.10/State.

    ORDER

    Per: Justice Sushrut Arvind Dharmadhikari Heard on the question of admission.

    2. Present Writ Appeal has been filed under Section 2(1) of the Madhya Pradesh Uchcha Nyayalay (Khand Nyaypeeth ko Appeal) Adhiniyam, 2005, assailing the order dated 26.11.2024 passed by the learned Single Judge in W.P. No.35549/2024, whereby the Writ Petition has been dismissed.

    3. The brief facts of the case are that respondents No.1 to 4 had filed an application under Section 52 of the MPLR Code before the Upper Collector, which was allowed and an interim order was passed in spite of the fact that caveat was filed by the present appellants. Feeling aggrieved the appellants filed W.P. No.35549/2024, which came to be decided finally by order dated 26.11.2024, wherein the appellants had raised grievance that they had filed a

    1

    caveat before the Court of Additional Collector, Chhatarpur yet without giving opportunity of hearing, the interim order passed on 25.10.2024.

    4. The learned Single Judge after hearing counsel for the appellants came to the conclusion that the appellants had failed to comply with the requirements of sub-Section (2) of Section 148A of CPC, 1908, which makes it obligatory upon the caveator to serve the notice of caveat by registered post acknowledgment due on the person by whom the application has been filed.

    5. Learned counsel for the appellants contended that the order impugned has been passed in contravention to Section 148A of CPC as well as in gross violation of the principles of natural justice. The learned Single Judge also failed to consider that the impugned order dated 25.10.2024 has been passed without serving notice on the caveator despite filing of the caveat. Moreover, the provisions of Section 148A (2) of the CPC are directory in nature and even if the same are not complied, it cannot be a ground to refuse or reject the caveat application and pass interim order without hearing the appellants. Learned counsel for the appellants relied upon a Single Bench decision in the case of State of Karnataka Vs. NIL reported in ILR 1999 KAR 2986 to contend that the right to lodge caveat cannot be taken away on the ground that provisions of sub-Section (2) of Section 148A of CPC are not complied with which are directory in nature. Therefore, the order passed by the learned Single Judge deserves to be set aside.

    6. Per contra, learned counsel for the State vehemently opposed the prayer and contended that it is mandatory for the appellants to serve a notice

    2

    of caveat to the opposite party, by whom an application for interim order has been or is going to be moved and unless that condition precedent is satisfied and as per sub-Section (2) of Section 148A Caveator/appellant is duty bound to serve the notice of the lodged caveat to the respondents by whom an application for interim order has been moved against the caveator. He further submitted that since sub-Section (2) of Section 148A of CPC has not been complied, there is no question of compliance of sub-Section (3) of Section 148A of CPC. The learned Single Judge has rightly come to the aforesaid conclusion. In view of the aforesaid, the order passed by the learned Single Judge does not require any interference and accordingly, this appeal is liable to be dismissed.

    7. Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.

    8. For the purpose of convenience, Section 148A of CPC is reproduced below:

    "[148 A. Right to lodge a caveat.-- (1)Where an application is expected to be made, or has been made, in a suit or proceeding instituted, or about to be instituted, in a Court , any person claiming a right to appear before the Court on the hearing of such application may lodge a caveat in respect thereof.

    (2) Where a caveat has been lodged under sub-section (1), the person by whom the caveat has been lodged (hereinafter referred to as the caveator) shall serve a notice of the caveat by registered post, acknowledgement due, on the person by whom the application has been, or is expected to be, made, under sub-section (1).

    (3) Where, after a caveat has been lodged under sub- section (1), any application is filed in any suit or proceeding, the Court, shall serve a notice of the application on the caveator.

    (4) Where a notice of any caveat has been served on the applicant, he shall forthwith furnish the caveator at the caveators expense, with a copy of the application made by him and also with copies of any paper or document

    3

    which has been, or may be, filed by him in support of the application.

    (5) Where a caveat has been lodged under sub-section (1), such caveat shall not remain in force after the expiry of ninety days from the date on which it was lodged unless the application referred to in sub-section

    (1) has been made before the expiry of the said period.]

    9. Admittedly, the appellants have not complied with the provision of sub-section (2) of Section 148A of CPC by serving notice of caveat by registered post acknowledgement due on the opposite party. Therefore, the learned Single Judge has rightly come to the conclusion that compliance of sub-section (2) of Section 148A of CPC is mandatory in nature and the same has to be followed sequentially, which has not been done in the present case.

    10. The object behind the introduction/insertion of the provision of caveat is to safeguard the interest of a person against an order that may be passed on an application filed or expected to be filed by a party in a suit or proceeding instituted or about to be instituted. Such a person lodging a caveat may not be a necessary party to such an application, but he may be affected by an order that may be passed on such an application. Further, another object behind the provision of Section 148A of CPC is to avoid multiplicity of proceedings. For instance, a person, against whom an order is passed on an application in a suit or proceeding to which he is not a party, has to take resort to legal proceedings for the purpose of getting rid of the order. The application referred to in sub-section (1) of Section 148A of CPC may be a substantive application and the person who may be affected by an order that may be passed on such an application may file the caveat for the purpose of

    4

    opposing the application.

    11. In the absence of such a form, it may be in the shape of a petition in which the caveator has to specify the nature of the application which is expected to be made or has been made and also his right to appear before the Court on the hearing of such application, under sub-Section (2) of Section 148A, the caveator also has to serve a notice of the caveat on the person by whom the application has been, or is expected to be, made under sub-section (1). Therefore, in the caveat the name of the person who is expected to file or has filed the application, the nature of the application and the right under which the person lodging the caveat claims to appear before the Court have to be stated explicitly.

    12. In the present case, the appellants did not serve the copy of the caveat application on the opposite party. Sub section (2) of Section 148A of CPC makes it obligatory upon the caveator to serve a notice of caveat by registered post acknowledgment due on the person by whom the application has been or is expected to be made. Thus, in absence of fulfilment of requirement of sub-section (2) of Section 148A of CPC, the learned Single Judge has rightly come to a conclusion that there is no valid caveat application filed before the Additional Collector necessitating indulgence on the part of Additional Collector. Unless and until requirement of Section 148A (2) of CPC are fulfilled and receipt of sending the application to the proposed the petitioners/appellants is enclosed along with the caveat application, it cannot be said that the same is properly constituted caveat application.

    5

    (SUSHRUT ARVIND DHARMADHIKARI)

    JUDGE

    (AVANINDRA KUMAR SINGH)

    JUDGE

    13. In the present case, the appellants themselves have failed to make mandatory compliance compliance of sub-Section(2) of Section 148A of CPC, therefore, the interim order passed by the concerned Court cannot be faulted with. The learned Single Judge has rightly interpreted the provisions of Section 148A of CPC and had rightly arrived at a conclusion that sub- section (3) is to be read in sequential manner and until and unless there is compliance of sub-section (2), sub-Section (3) of Section 148A of CPC will not come into operation.

    14. Accordingly, this Court is of considered opinion that the order passed by the learned Single Judge is in accordance with law and does not warrant any interference.

    15. This appeal being bereft of merits and substance is hereby dismissed.

    HS

    6

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mamta Devi v. Rakesh Kumar Yadav
    (Jan 15, 2025)