ORDER
Per: Hon'ble Shri Justice Suresh Kumar Kait, Chief Justice
1. The issue involved in both the appeals are common thus they are being decided by this common order. For the sake of convenience the facts of Writ Appeal No.42/2022 are being taken to resolve the dispute therein.
2. The case of the writ petitioner before the writ Court was that he was engaged as Daily wager on the post of Junior Auditor on 16.01.1989. Salary
1
of writ petitioner petitioner/respondent No.1 herein is to be drawn against the post of LDC and he was paid fixed wages of Rs.565/- per month. Deputy Secretary, Madhya Pradesh State Agriculture Federation Board, Rewa wrote a letter dated 28.08.1989 to Collector, District Rewa and sought guidelines that writ petitioner is working as Daily wager against post of Junior Auditor. For said post, Pay Scale of 1260-1860 is sanctioned, therefore, guideline be issued that what salary be paid to concerned employees. Deputy Collector, Rewa vide order dated 05.09.1989 replied to said letter and fixed the salary of writ petitioner at Rs.1025/- per month in Pay Scale of Junior Auditor. Considering the said order, Deputy Secretary, M.P. State Agriculture Federation Board, Rewa gave sanction to fix the salary of writ petitioner at Rs.1025/- monthly. On 13.05.2008, Managing Director of M.P. State Agriculture Federation Board, Bhopal regularized writ petitioner on post of Junior Auditor in Pay Scale of 4000-100-6000. Within short time another order was passed by Managing Director by which writ petitioner was regularized on post of Assistant Grade-III in Pay Scale 3050-75-3950-80-
4590.
3. Further case of the writ petitioner before the writ Court was that the order dated 23.05.2008 is contrary to law. No opportunity of hearing was given before passing adverse order. the writ petitioner was reverted to lower grade and, therefore, he challenged the order dated 23.05.2008 before the writ Court.
4. The case of the appellant herein is that the claim of the writ petitioner is misconceived and order dated 13.05.2008 was recalled vide
2
order dated 20.09.2012. The petitioner has not challenged the said order before any Court of law, thus the order dated 20.09.2012 has become final.
5. Counsel appearing on behalf of appellant submits that the post of Junior Auditor was a Cadre Post and same was not available for engagement of daily wage employee. The said employee can only be engaged against Class-IV post and post of LDC. No Recruitment Rules were followed for engagement of writ petitioner. In fact, he was engaged as daily wager on post of LDC and not on post of Junior Auditor. If writ petitioner is being paid higher salary, then same will give no right to writ petitioner to claim a higher post.
6. It is further submitted that status of writ petitioner remained as LDC and he was rightly considered for regularization against the said post. Order dated 13.05.2008 was prepared due to miscommunication and was never circulated and communicated to writ petitioner, therefore, order dated 13.05.2008 does not create any right in favour of writ petitioner.
7. It is further submitted that when the appellants realized the mistake immediately and passed order dated 23.05.2008 correcting the mistakes. By said order, writ petitioner was rightly regularized against post of LDC. Further by order dated 20.09.2012, order dated 13.05.2008 was cancelled.
8. On perusal of the impugned order, we note that the learned writ Court observed the case of Secretary, State of Karnataka Vs. Uma Devi; (2006) 4 SCC 1 and noted that the State Government has framed policy for regularization of Daily wager. General Administration Department has issued a circular F5-3/2006/1/3 dated 16.05.2007. As per said circular,
3
Scrutiny Committee will consider the cases of Daily wagers who were engaged against sanctioned and vacant post for more than 10 years for their regularization. This exercise is to be carried out as one time exercise. On recommendations made by Scrutiny Committee, Appointing Authority will proceed for regularization of employees.
9. The case of writ petitioner was considered by Scrutiny Committee as per circular of General Administration Department dated 16.05.2007. The Scrutiny Committee consisted Principal Secretary, Farmer Welfare and Agriculture Department in which recommendation was made for regularization of writ petitioner on the post of Junior Auditor in Pay Scale of 4000-100-6000. Consequently, in view of recommendation dated 08.02.2008, order was passed by Managing Director to regularize the writ petitioner on 13.05.2008. Immediately thereafter appellants herein passed impugned order dated 23.05.2008 by which writ petitioner was regularized on post of Assistant Grade-III in Pay Scale of 3050-75-3950-80-4590. However more than four years later another order dated 20.09.2012 was passed by which order of regularization of writ petitioner on post of Junior Auditor was cancelled.
10. It is pertinent to mention here that the order dated 23.05.2008 is not an order of reversion however, It is an order for regularizing the writ petitioner on post of Assistant Grade-III. Earlier order of his regularization on post of Junior Auditor was cancelled. The validity of order dated 23.05.2008 and 20.09.2012 was considered by the learned Single Judge and he observed that both the orders mentioned above were passed contrary to
4
recommendation made by Scrutiny Committee dated 30.04.2008. As per circular of General Administration Department dated 16.05.2007 if recommendation is made by Scrutiny Committee for regularization, then Appointing Authority has to consider the same and pass order accordingly. In this recommendation, writ petitioner was recommended to be regularized on post of Junior Auditor.
11. It is also noteworthy that Scrutiny Committee has considered the case of writ petitioner and recommendation was made to regularize the writ petitioner against post of Junior Auditor. Said recommendation was not challenged before any Court of law and, therefore, said recommendation is binding upon the appellant herein as observed by the learned writ Court. In the impugned order, the learned writ Court has observed that there is no order on record to indicate that earlier recommendation of Scrutiny Committee dated 30.04.2008 was reviewed or subsequently modified. However, it is further observed that the order dated 23.05.2008 is contrary to the Scrutiny Committee recommendation dated 30.04.2008 which is in violation of circular of General Administration Department dated 16.05.2007. Scrutiny Committee has not held the appointment of writ petitioner as illegal but it has held that writ petitioner was appointed against the post of Junior Auditor, thus it was not held by Scrutiny Committee that Junior Auditor is a Cadre post and daily wageer cannot be engaged against such post. Decision taken by Scrutiny Committee on 30.04.2008 has become final and same has not been challenged before any Court of law.
12. In view of above, we find no perversity or illegality in the
5
(SURESH KUMAR KAIT)
CHIEF JUSTICE
(VIVEK JAIN)
JUDGE
impugned order passed by the learned Single Judge. Finding no merits in the present appeal, the same is accordingly, dismissed.
13. In terms of detailed order passed in Writ Appeal No.42/2022, Writ Appeal No.43/2022 is also dismissed.
Praveen
6