Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Disabilities Act, 2016 (hereinafter referred as "Act, 2016").
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Disabilities Act, 2016 (hereinafter referred as "Act, 2016").
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Ms. Kritika Mandloi v. The State Of Madhya Pradesh

    NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2025:MPHC-IND:693

    IN THE HIGH

    HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUBODH ABHYANKAR WRIT PETITION No. 12082 of 2024

    MS. KRITIKA MANDLOI AND OTHERS

    THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH AND OTHERS

    Appearance:

    Shri L.C. Patne,

    Shir Ajay Raj Gupta, learned Government Advocate for the respondent/State.

    Shri Shashank Shrivastava, learned counsel for the respondent [R Reserved on

    Pronounced on

    …................................................................................................................. This petition having been heard and reserved for orders, coming on

    for pronouncement this day, the court passed the following:

    1] With consent of the parties, heard finally.

    2] This petition has been filed by the petitioners being aggrieved by the order dated 16.08.2023

    selection process for the post of Fisheries Inspector seats were not reserved for the

    1

    COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH

    AT INDORE

    BEFORE

    Versus learned counsel for the petitioners.

    : 05.11.2024

    : 09.01.2025

    ORDER

    ,which is an order of cancelling the entire , on the ground

    specially abled persons.

    WP No.12082 of 2024

    -3].

    that the

    1

    3] The brief facts of the case are that respondents issued an advertisement for appointment Fisheries Inspector, and all the petitioners also applied were also got selected. Copies of the result ha the petition. Thereafter, process of document verification has also been completed by the respondents

    impugned order (Annexure

    selection process has been cancelled.

    4] Counsel for the petitioners has also relied upon the reply filed by the respondents in W.P. No. 26820/2023

    Principal Seat at Jabalpur wherein the respondents have taken plea that the selection process has been cancelled on account of

    provisions as prescribed under the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 (hereinafter referred as "Act, 2016"). Co

    further submitted that the mandate which is prescribed under the Act, 2016 could also have been

    process. He has submitted that the respondents have compl circular dated 03.07.2018

    reservation to disabled persons has been provided in compartment. Counsel for the petitioners has also relied upon the judgment Dinesh Kumar Kashyap Vs. South Eastern Central Railways (2019 SCC 798 passed by Hon'ble Supreme Court.

    5] Counsel for the respondent No. 3 has opposed the prayer.

    6] Counsel for the respondent /State has opposed the contentions and reply has also been filed. It is contended that no case of made out in the advertisement dated 21.11.2022 (Annexure

    2

    on 21.11.2022 s on the post of for the same and they ve also been filed alongwith , however, the respondents have also issued the -P/6) and informing the petitioners that the , which has been filed at

    noncompliance of the

    unsel for the petitioners has

    followed without cancelling the entire selection , issued by the State Government, wherein WP No.12082 of 2024

    , the

    ied with the

    horizontal

    ) 12

    interference is -P/1), and has

    2

    also relied upon the condition No. 5.2 provides that a candidate shall not have any right to be appointed right of appointment shall be the

    7] In rebuttal submitted that this aspect case of Dinesh Kumar Kashyap (supra) paragraphs 24 to 38,

    Patne has also relied upon paragraph 13(3) of the GAD Circular dated 18.12.2014, which clearly provides that the appointment orders are to be made within three months after

    8] Heard counsel for the parties and perused the documents filed on record.

    9] The case is the post of Fisheries Inspector and their documents have also been verified. However, entire process of selection has been cancelled for the reasons as mentioned above, to provide reservation to the persons disabilities as provided under Act, 2016.

    10] So far as the objections raised by the respondents are concerned, following averments have been made in para 5 of the reply which reads as under:-

    "5. That, the answering respondent most respectfully submits Hon'ble that the merely qualifying the advertisement (Annexure P/1) 21.11.2022 a successful

    to the petitioners to obtain an

    department if the

    issuing the appointment orders as the process undertaken itself was not in accordance with the law as enumerated aforementioned. Even the

    (2) of the advertisement respondent department for the same. The clause 5 (2)

    3

    of the advertisement which clearly sole discretion of the employer. , Shri Patne, learned counsel for the petitioners has of the matter has already been taken

    by the Supreme Co

    and it is submitted that the petition be allowed issuance of selection list.

    not disputed, that the petitioners were selected for suffering from

    before this

    dated and becoming

    candidate confers no inherent right

    appointment order from the respective respondent department is abstaining themselves from clause 5

    reserves the right and prerogative with the reads as under:-

    WP No.12082 of 2024

    and the

    care of in the

    urt in

    . Shri

    3

    ¼2½ bu fu;eksa lwph esa dsoy ek= vH;fFkZ;ksa fu;qfDr dk dkbZ vf/kdkjh ¼d½ dksbZ

    djrk gS]

    ¼[k½ vH;FkhZ

    tkrk gS%

    ¼x½ vH;FkhZ us fu;qfDr ds fy, e.My }kjk fu/kkZfjr dks iw.kZ u dj fy;k

    ¼?k½ foHkkx us vH;FkhZ ds i{k esa

    gksA**

    The aforementioned clause was duly accepted by the rider while filing up the forms pursuant the by virtue of the doctrine of estoppels claim a right which otherwise they are cancellation order dated 16.08.2023.Taking into consideration the aforementioned facts and

    respondents the instant

    11] It is trite that a candidate has no legal right appointment even if he has been selected consider the reasons assigned for cancellation of the entire selection process, and if the same is found to be

    reasoning, the court can certainly exercise its powers of judicial review the present case, it is not the stand of the Government that requirement/demand for filling up any vacancy, or that for any other reasons, they are not inclined to make any fres

    cancelling the entire selection process is due to non

    provisions of the Act of

    is a curable defect and

    candidates of the reserved class.

    12] In the considered opinion of this C vacancies are already

    are many factors affecting a person's eligibility to participate in the same,

    4

    sa ds v/khu lapkfyr ijh{kk ds ifj.kkeska esa] vgZdkjh s Z sa dks gh j[kk tk,xk ijarq ik= vH;fFkZ;ksa ugha gksxk tc rd fd&

    foHkkx@midze fjDr in ds fy, ls dksbZ ekax Z dk uke ekaxdŸkkZ foHkkx@midze dks Hkst ugha Z s q s Z leLr ik=rk

    gks% vkSj

    s Z s sa fu;qfDr vkns'k tkjh u dj

    petitioners as a

    advertisement. Therefore

    petitioner are not entitled to

    not entitled for in light of the

    circumstances and bonafied act of the petition deserves to be dismissed."

    , but this court can certainly

    arbitrary or unjust and not based on any sound there is no further

    h appointment, but their reason for

    -compliance of the

    2016, which, in the considered opinion of this court if cured, would not cause any prejudice to any ourt, the Government

    hard to come by, and even if they are advertised, there WP No.12082 of 2024

    sa Z

    Z sa dks

    a ugha

    fn;k

    fn;k

    to claim

    . In of the

    4

    the most important of which is the age limit, and once a person has crossed the requisite age, notwithstanding his competence, his dream of obtaining a government job is shattered.

    into the process of document

    should not be normally cancelled citing technical infirmities in the original advertisement which are curable and can still be remedied. sees no justifiable reason to cancel the entire selecti respondents can very well issue a fresh advertisement

    for specially abled candidates

    the originally advertised seats in the advertisement dated ought to have been reserved

    the specially abled candidates.

    13] This court is of the considered opinion could have continued with the selection process and could have issued the appointment orders also by

    with disabilities as prescribed under Act, 2016

    not having issued the advertisement for disabled persons could have issued separate advertisement for their appointments by reducing the number of seats already advertised and also taking into account 03.07.2018 (Annexure

    P/8) and also decision rendered by Co

    case National Federation of Blind, M.P. Branch Vs. State of M.P. & Others, passed in W.P. No. 7275/2019.

    14] In view of impugned order dated 16.08.2023 is hereby quashed and respondents are

    5

    Thus, once a selection process has culminated verification after selection of a candidate, it Thus, t

    on process when the

    for the seats reserved

    by reducing the exact number of

    21.11.2022

    in the first place in the said advertisement that the respondents

    keeping aside/reserving the seats for the persons .As the respondents

    the

    -P/9) and the judgment dated 06.07.2023 (Annexure -ordinate Bench of this Court in the the aforesaid, present petition stands allowed and WP No.12082 of 2024

    his court

    seats from

    , which

    for

    , despite

    circular dated

    -

    5

    directed to issue appointment orders to the petitioners in accordance with law, and in the light of

    15] Let the aforesaid exercise be co within a further time of 2 months.

    16] Petition stands Vindesh

    6

    the observations made hereinabove. mpleted by the respondents allowed and disposed of accordingly.

    (SUBODH ABHYANKAR)

    JUDGE

    WP No.12082 of 2024

    6

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ms. Kritika Mandloi v. The State Of Madhya Pradesh
    (Jan 9, 2025)