Court No. - 58 Case :- MATTERS UNDER ARTICLE 227 No. - 4464 of 2015
Petitioner :- Sufiyan
Respondent :- Additional District Judge Saharanpur And 6 Others
Counsel for Petitioner :- Sharad Kumar Pandey
Counsel for Respondent :- Ajay Kumar Singh,Ashish Kumar Singh
Hon'ble Manoj Kumar Gupta,J.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri Ashish Kumar Singh appearing on behalf of second respondent. The second respondent instituted Original Suit No. 61 of 2012. The case of the plaintiff-respondent was that one Abdul Hameed was the Bhumidhar of the suit property. His name was duly recorded in the revenue records. He had no son but only a daughter, namely, Smt Vakila. He, therefore, by a will bequeathed the suit property in favour of her daughter Smt Vakila. However, Zahoor Ahmad brother of Abdul Hameed succeeded in getting his name entered in the revenue records. After Smt. Vakila gained knowledge of the said fact, she filed objections. By order dated 5.11.2003 the objections were rejected. Ultimately, in appeal, by order dated 23.6.2004, name of Zahoor Ahmad was expunged from the revenue records and names of Suleman, Zulfaan, Mukarram and Manzoor, son of Smt Vakila were recorded in the revenue record, as in course of the proceedings Smt. Vakila died. Challenging the order passed by the Appellate Authority, sons of Zahoor Ahmad filed a revision before the Board of Revenue and on 28.7.2011, they got it dismissed. Thereafter, Suleman, Zulfaan and Mukarram transfered the suit property by registered sale deed dated 26.7.2004 in favour of the Anil Kumar Tyagi, who in turn, transferred the same to the plaintiff-respondent` by means of registered sale deed dated 1.3.2011. Accordingly, the plaintiff- respondent claimed himself to be the Bhumidhar in possession of the suit property.
On the other hand, the petitioner, who is one of the defendant in Neutral Citation No. - 2015:AHC:126203
1
the suit, while admitting that the suit property belonged to Abdul Hameed, took a plea that there is no will in existence and the property was inherited by Zahoor Ahmad brother of Abdul Hameed. It is claimed that Zahoor Ahmad appointed his son Rizwan as his power of attorney, who by means of sale deed dated 19.7.2002, transferred the suit property in favour of the petitioner.
The trial court rejected the application for temporary injunction filed by the plaintiff-respondent merely on the ground that copy of the will has not been brought on record.
In appeal preferred by the plaintiff-respondent, the appellate court by impugned judgment and order dated 13.5.2011, directed the parties to maintain status quo. The appellate court has held that it is not in dispute between the parties that Abdul Hameed was the original owner of the suit property. It has further been noted that as on date, name of neither the plaintiff nor the petitioner has been entered in the revenue records. The appellate court further observed that both the parties are challenging the sale deed executed in favour of the other side and till date there is no adjudication by any court regarding the validity of the sale deeds in favour of the respective parties.
In such circumstances, the appellate court has held that it would be in the interest of justice to direct the parties to maintain status quo, during the pendency of the suit, so as to preserve the suit property. Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that name of the brother of Abdul Hameed was duly entered in the revenue records. He further pointed out that the revision before the Board of Revenue was got withdrawn by playing fraud and the restoration application is still pending.
Be that as it may, it is not in dispute that the restoration application has yet not been allowed. Admittedly, name of sons of Smt. Vakila were duly entered in the revenue records after expunging the name of Zahoor Ahmad. It is also not in dispute that till date, the validity of the sale deed executed in favour of the respective parties, has not been a subject matter
2
of adjudication by any civil or revenue court. In such view of the matter, this Court is of the opinion, that the appellate court while directing the parties to maintain status quo has not committed any jurisdictional error or any illegality, which may warrant interference in exercise of supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution.
In the end, learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the petitioner is in possession of the suit property and under the garb of order of the status quo, there is eminent threat of plaintiff-respondent interfering in his possession. The argument is without any basis. The order of status quo will operate against both the parties and none of the parties will be entitled to change its nature and character or to interfere in the possession of the other party.
With these observations, this petition stands dismissed. (Manoj Kumar Gupta, J.)
Order Date :- 28.8.2015 Arif
3