Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Smt. S.Puneetha v. State of AP

    APHC010198612021

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH

    FRIDAY ,THE TWENTY

    TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY FOUR

    THE HONOURABLE DR JUSTICE K MANMADHA RAO

    WRIT PETITION Nos. 11360 of

    WRIT PETITION NO: 11360 OF

    Between:

    A.Sarala Kumari and Others State Of Andhra Pradesh and Others Counsel for the Petitioner(S):

    1. M PITCHAIAH

    Counsel for the Respondent(S):

    1. MANIKYA VEENA M (SC FOR PADMAVATHI MAHILA UNIVERSITY)

    2. GP FOR SERVICES I

    3. GP FOR HIGHER EDUCATION (AP)

    4. K SWARNA SESHU

    The Court made the following:

    COMMON ORDER:

    Writ Petition No.11360 of 2021 is filed under Article 226 Constitution of India

    1

    AT AMARAVATI

    (Special Original Jurisdiction)

    NINTH DAY OF OCTOBER

    PRESENT

    2021, 46084 of 2018, 21487 of 2021 and 21820 of 2022

    2021

    ...PETITIONER(S)

    AND

    ...RESPONDENT(S)

    [3310]

    of the

    1

    2

    "to issue a Writ or Order or Direction more particularly one in the nature of Writ of Mandamus declaring the action of the 2ndrespondent vide his Letter No.3014/UE/A2/2017, dated 15.04.2021, rescinding the ratification orders issued vide Government Letter No.3014/UE/A2/2017, dated 05.12.2018, as arbitrary, illegal and violative of Articles 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of India and provisions of A.P.Universities Act, 1991 and consequently set aside the same and direct the respondents to release the retirement benefits of petitioners 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 11, including the petitioners 15 and 16, 2ho are the legal heirs of Late K. Deenadayal, Special Increments due to the petitioners, under Automatic Advancement Scheme due to the petitioners, with interest @ 12% p.a grant costs of proceedings and pass such other orders.

    Writ Petition No.46084 of 2018 is filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India

    "to issue a Writ or Order or Direction more particularly one in the nature of Writ of Mandamus declaring the letter No.3015/UE/A2/2017, dated 23.10.2019 of 1st respondent as arbitrary, discriminatory and illegal and consequently direct Respondents to regularize services of petitioners, in the existing vacancies of Junior Assistants from the dates of petitioners' initial appointments in Respondent/ University in the year 1990/1992, as per proposals sent by 2ndrespondent vide letter dated 08.03.2018, and reminder letters dated 30.09.2018 and 12.11.2018, as has been done in respect of juniors to petitioners by setting aside letter No. 9742/UE.I/A.1/2007-2, dated 24.05.2008 of 1strespondent, in the light of judgment dated 13.12.2017 in W.P.No.3451 of 2009 and with all other consequential benefits, monetary or otherwise, pass such other order or orders as this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper in the circumstances of the case.

    (Prayer is amended as per order of this Court dated 15.11.2022 vide I.A.No.2 of 2019 in W.P.No.46084 of 2018)

    Writ Petition No.21487 of 2021 is filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India

    "to issue a Writ or Order or Direction more particularly one in the nature of Writ of Mandamus declaring the impugned G.O.Rt.No.91, dated 30.06.2021 of the 1st respondent, and the so called alleged speaking orders of the 2ndrespondent, dated 24.07.2021 in respect of the petitioners, rejecting their claim for regularization, as arbitrary, violative of Article 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of India and provisions

    3

    of the I.D.Act, 1947 and consequently direct the respondents to regularize the services of the petitioners from the date of their employment as Junior Assistants or such other date as this Hon'ble Court finds it appropriate by counting the entire service for the purpose of pensionary benefits, with all consequential benefits, such as arrears of salary and other attendant benefits, retirement benefits of the petitioners 2 and 5 i.e Gratuity, Leave Encashment and Pension with interest @ 12% p.a and grant costs of the proceedings and pass such other and further orders".

    Writ Petition No.21820 of 2022 is filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India

    "to issue a Writ or Order or Direction more particularly one in the nature of Writ of Mandamus declaring the impugned Proceedings in Roc.No/aPMVV/Estt/NT/2022, dated 28.06.2022, issued by the 3rdrespondent in respect of the petitioners, putting back the petitioners in the Minimum Time Scale, in terms of G.O.Rt.No.119, dated 16.02.2013, of the 1strespondent, depriving the petitioners the hitherto drawn Pay and Allowances, as arbitrary, violative of Articles 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of India and consequently set aside the said proceedings and direct the respondents to pay all arrears with interest @ 12 p.a grant costs of the proceedings and pass such other orders.

    2. Heard Mr. M. Pitchaiah, learned counsel for the petitioners; learned Assistant Government Pleader, Services-I and School Education and Mr. K. Swarna Seshu, learned Standing Counsel for the respondents.

    3. These Writ Petitions arise out of the same issue and therefore are being disposed of by a common order.

    4. The main grievance of the petitioners in W.P.No.11360 of 2021 is that they were given regular appointments as Office Subordinates and after working for some time, some of them were promoted as Junior Assistants in the year 2005 and others were promoted as Store Keepers in the year 2007. The petitioners were appointed in a sanctioned post by the 7threspondent

    4

    after following the prescribed procedure and they have put in about 31 years of service in the 7threspondent/ University. The 2ndrespondent had written a letter dated 05.12.2018 to the 7threspondent, ratifying the action of the 7th respondent, inter alia observing that they were appointed against clear vacancies. The 2ndrespondent issued letter dated 15.04.2021, rescinding the ratification order dated 05.12.2018 and directed the 7threspondent to take further action in the matter. Assailing the same, the present writ petition came to be filed.

    5. The main grievance of the petitioners in W.P.No.46084 of 2021 is that pursuant to the request made by the 2ndrespondent, names of the petitioners were sponsored by the District Employment Officer, Chittoor for appointment to the vacant posts of Junior Assistant in respondent/ university. The 2ndrespondent has appointed the candidates, who were selected in the selections as Junior Assistants and they were joined in to service in the year 1990 and 1992 respectively and having 26 to 28 years of service and possessed degree qualifications and some of them were having technical qualifications also. All the petitioners were fully qualified and eligible for appointment to the post of Junior Assistant in respondent/ university, in the vacancies existing as on date of their appointment. Initially the petitioners were sanctioned consolidated pay for a period of 59 days service, with an artificial break of one day, on completion of every 59 days. Therefore, the petitioners were appointed as Junior Assistants during the years 1990 and 1992, were constrained to file W.P.No.1353 of 1994 and 16964 of 1993 and

    5

    obtained interim order for regularization of their services in the existing or future vacancies. A number of vacancies of Junior Assistants have also arisen in the respondent/ university subsequently, but they were also filled up by promoting Attenders and other Class-IV employees as Juniors Assistants in the year 1994 itself. Therefore, serious injustice was meted out to the petitioners due to non-implementation of directions of this Court W.P.No.1353 of 1994. Even though, juniors to the petitioners were also appointed as Junior Assistants. However, the petitioners continue to discharge their duties as Junior Assistants, on par with other regular Junior Assistants on payment of meagre consolidated pay. The petitioners were sanctioned Time Scale of Pay attached to the cadre of Junior Assistant as per proceedings dated 09.06.2005, subsequently the petitioners were appointed as Junior Assistant in the scale of pay applicable to the said post, subject to ratification from the 2ndrespondent treated petitioners as regular employees in all respects. Instead of clarifying availability of vacancies in the cadre of Junior Assistant to the Government, 2ndrespondent mechanically issued orders dated 10.02.2009 informing the petitioners that appointment orders dated 05.05.2007 were modified to the affect that petitioners would be paid Minimum in the Time Scale of Pay w.e.f 01.02.2009 and the petitioners would not be eligible for any future increments. The petitioners have filed W.P.No.6122 of 2009 challenging the said order. While the matter stood thus, the 2nd respondent is taking steps to fill up the vacancies of Junior Assistant by resorting to direct recruitment, in pursuance to the permission granted by the

    6

    Government in the said letter dated 01.02.2014, instead or regularizing services of petitioners in the existing vacancies of Junior Assistants. Therefore, W.P.No.6798 of 2015 has been filed by the 6thpetitioner and obtained interim order. Without compliance, the 2ndrespondent continued to send misleading letters to the government to create eight additional Junior Assistants Posts/ supernumerary posts to regularize services of petitioners and two others. Therefore, the petitioners have filed Contempt Case No. 2731 of 2018 and 164 of 2016. Therefore, inaction of the 1strespondent, in according permission to the 2ndrespondent, to regularize the services of the petitioners, to comply with the directions of this Court is highly illegal and arbitrary. Hence, the present writ petition came to be filed.

    6. The main grievance of the petitioners in W.P.No.21487 of 2021 is that they have acquired degree, post graduation degree and other technical qualifications. The petitioners were selected and appointed as Junior Assistants in the year 1990 and 1992 respectively. The 1strespondent issued G.O.Rt.No.91, dated 30.06.2021, directing the universities in Andhra Pradesh, who have not completed 5 years of service as on 25.11.1993. Pursuant to the same, the 3rdrespondent issued speaking order dated 24.07.2021, stating that the petitioners claim for regularization cannot be considered. In view of the said order, the present writ petition came to be filed. The 2ndpetitioner retired from service on 30.06.2018, where as 5threspondent retired on 31.03.2019 on attaining the age of superannuation. Therefore, the retired petitioners made

    7

    several requests to the respondents to pay retirement benefits, but in vain. Therefore inaction of the respondents is questioned in this writ petition.

    7. The main grievance of the petitioners in W.P.No.21820 of 2022 is that the petitioners were duly qualified to be appointed to the post of Junior Assistant and the 3rdrespondent after following the due procedure in vogue, through a duly constituted selection committee, selected and appointed them as Junior Assistants in the year 1990 and 1992 respectively. The 1st respondent issued G.O.Rt.No.91, dated 30.06.2021, directing the universities in Andhra Pradesh, not to regularize the services of the employees working in the Universities in A.P, who have not completed 5 years of service as on 25.11.1993. Pursuant to the same, the 3rdrespondent issued speaking order dated 24.07.2021, stating that the petitioners claim for regularization cannot be considered. The said proceedings were challenged in W.P.No.21487 of 2021, thereafter, awaiting for more than one year, the 3rdrespondent issued proceedings dated 28.06.2022, placing the petitioners in the Minimum Time Scale in terms of G.O.Rt.No.119, dated 16.02.2013 of the 1strespondent, which is challenging in the present writ petition.

    8. During hearing, learned counsel for the petitioners would contend that the petitioners have been working in the respondent University in various categories, since long time i.e more than 20 to 31 years continuously without any interruption on par with regular employees. It is further contended that they were allowed to draw the time scale in some of the petitioners, but not

    8

    regularized their services inspite of best efforts and repeated representations made to the respondents. Therefore, the petitioners are eligible and entitled to claim benefit for regularization in these matters as per decisions of the Hon'ble Apex Court.

    9. Whereas, learned counsel for the respondents vehemently argued that the respondents rejected the claim of the petitioners that Time Scale Employees in the respondent/ university for regularization of their services as they are not eligible for regularization due to non-completion of 5 years of service in terms of G.O.Ms.No.212, dated 22.04.1994 and also act 2 of 1994. In support of their contention, relied on a decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in "Vibhuti Shankar Pandey v. State of Madhya Pradesh and Others"1, wherein the Hon'ble Division Bench held as follows:-

    "4. The learned Single Judge while allowing the writ petition gave directions for regularization of the appellant from the date on which his juniors were regularized. This order was challenged by the State Government before a Division Bench which allowed the appeal of the State Government. The Division Bench rightly held that the learned Single Judge has not followed the principle of law as given by this Court in State of Karnataka v. Umadevi2, as initial appointment must be done by the competent authority and there must be a sanctioned post on which the daily-rated employee must be working. These two conditions were clearly missing in the case of present appellant. The Division Bench of the High Court therefore has to our mind rightly allowed the appeal and set aside the order dated 27.06.2019.

    1 (2023) 3 SCC 639

    2 (2 006) 4 SCC 1

    9

    10. Further, relied on a decision of the Hon'ble Division Bench of the Hon'ble Apex Court in "University of Delhi v. Delhi University Contract Employees Union and Others" 3

    , wherein the Hon'ble Division Bench discussed Umadevi's case and held, are not entitled to benefit of regularization only for the reason that they had put in minimum 10 years of continuous service as envisaged and further held that though benefit of regularization cannot be granted, window of opportunity must be given to them to complete with available talent through public advertisement, considering that as of now most of them had completed 10 years of contractual service. Further relied on a decision of the Hon'ble Division Bench of Apex Court in

    "Upendra Singh v. State of Bihar and Others"4, wherein it was held as follows:-

    "8. Law pertaining to regularization has now been authoritatively determined by a Constitution Bench judgment of this Court in Secretary, State of Karnataka & Ors v. Umadevi & Ors. (2006) 4 SCC 1: (AIR 2006 SC 1806). On the application of law laid down in that case, it is clear that the question of regularization of daily wager appointed contrary to law does not arise. This ratio of the judgment could not be disputed by the learned counsel for the appellant as well. That is why she continued to plead that the appointment of the appellant was made after following due procedure and in accordance with law. …..

    The appellants claim to have been regularized within the staffing pattern. In out opinion, it is not the crux of the matter. The crucial question is if their initial appointment by the Managing Committee was in consonance with Article 14 of the Constitution of India by open advertisement and competitive merit selection. On account of various interpretations by more than one Bench of

    3 (2021) 16 SCC 71

    4 AIR 2018 SC 1315

    10

    M.L.Kesari (AIR 2010) SC 2587) (supra) reference was made to the Full Bench. We have already noticed from the order refusing regularization dated 13.08.2003 that the appointment of the Appellants on daily wage was not in consonance with the law."

    11. Learned Assistant Government Pleader further contended that in exercising power under Article 226 of the Constitution will not issue directions for regularization, absorption or permanent continuance, unless the employees claiming regularization had been appointed in pursuance of a regular recruitment in accordance with relevant rules in an open competitive process, against sanctioned vacant posts. Mere continuation of service by an temporary or ad hoc or daily-wage employee, under cover of some interim orders of the court, would not confer upon him any right to be absorbed into service. Even temporary, ad hoc or daily wage service for a long number of years, let alone service for one or two years, will not entitle such employee to claim regularization, if they are not working against a sanctioned post as held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in "State of Rajasthan and Others v. Daya Lal and Others 5

    . Further, relied on a recent decision of this Court in

    "Sudhamani and Others v. State of Andhra Pradesh and Others" 6

    ,

    wherein learned Single Judge held that mere publication of an advertisement does not make the petitioners appointment a valid appointment as per the constitutional scheme. It was also clarified that merely because of a temporary employee continued beyond the term of their appointment, they would be absorbed into regular service and made permanent merely on the strength of

    5 ÄIR 2011 SC 1193

    6 2021 (6 ) ALD 519 (AP)

    11

    such continuance, if the original appointment was not by a 'due process' of selection. Therefore, this Court following the decisions of the Apex Court in Umadevi and M.L. Kesari's case held that proper method of selection is need to be notified. There should be an advertisement/ wide publicity, examination, interview or the like to prove that there was a competitive testing/ elimination process after a proper screening of the applicants. That is the approved/ recognized scheme for appointment. Then only the petitioners were duly appointed. Further, she relied on a decision of Hon'ble Division Bench of this Court in "State of Andhra Pradesh v. Dr.D.Aruna Jyothi and others7. As per the said decision, the petitioners are not entitled to claim any benefit and they were not completed 10 years of service and their employment is not proper notification. Therefore, the petitioners are not duly appointed by proper procedure in the matters and hence, they are not entitled to claim any benefit in these writ petition and requested to dismiss the same.

    12. Perused the records.

    13. During hearing, learned counsel for the petitioners relied on a decision of erstwhile High Court of Andhra Pradesh in Kodali Raju and Others v. APSRTC, Hyderabad and Others" 8

    , wherein it was held as follows:-

    "18…..Here it is a case of casual appointment and may not be through selection process. It can at best be said to be an irregular appointment, but

    7 W.A.No.641 and 663 of 2022, dated 22.01.2024

    8 2011(1) ALD 234

    12

    not an illegal appointment. The sweeping and cleaning of buses is a perennial work attached to the main activity of the Corporation. Since the petitioners have been treated as working continuously for more than 10 years, regularization of their services have to be considered in the light of the said judgment. During the years 2004 and 2010, more than 4000 posts were sanctioned by the Government for regularizing the services of temporary/ contract employees working in the Corporation. The judgment rendered in Umadevi's case further was explained in State of Karnataka v. L. Kesari (supra), wherein it is stated that the true effect of the direction at paragraph 53 of judgment in Umadevi case is that all persons who have worked for more than 10 years as on 10.04.2006 without the protection of any interim order of any Court or Tribunal, in vacant posts, possessing the requisite qualification, are entitled to be considered for regularization. The continuation of petitioners in the Corporation of petitioners in the Corporation for the last more than 21 years itself can be construed that there are vacant posts available and the petitioners are entitled for regularization of their services and to be put on regular timescale."

    14. In "C. Mahender and Others v. Pottisreeramulu Telugu University, Hyderabad"9, wherein the Hon'ble Division Bench of High Court for the State of Telangana, held as follows:-

    45. There is no dispute that petitioners have been working on daily wage since 1990 and have put in almost (30) years of service by now. They have been given minimum time-scale from the year 2000. They have been continuously working without any Court orders in their favour from 1990 till date.

    …..

    48. It is not known why the 1strespondent has not followed the decision in Umadevi's case (supra), as explained in M.L.Kesari's case (supra) and undertaken a one-time exercise of preparing the list of daily wage employees, who had worked for more than ten (10) years without the

    9 2020(4) ALD 379 (TS) (DB)

    13

    intervention of the Courts and Tribunals as on 10.04.2006 and subject them to a process verification as to whether they are working against vacant posts and possess requisite qualifications for the posts, and if so, regularize their services."

    15. Therefore, learned counsel for the petitioners vehemently argued that the petitioners have long service for about 20 to 31 years and above in the respondent/ university and discharging their duties without any interruption and the same was recommended for consideration of regularization. It is further argued that there are number of vacancies in the respondent/ university, therefore, repeated requests were made on several occasions for legalization in the vacant posts by considering their eligibility, though the petitioners are qualified and suitable.

    16. The petitioners herein have filed serious of writ petitions seeking regularization by considering their past service and eligibility and obtained interim orders from this Court. But the respondent/ university without complying with the order of this Court making representation to the Government to fill up the posts of Junior Assistants by giving promotions to the other juniors to the petitioners by ignoring the petitioners, which is highly illegal and arbitrary as contended by the learned counsel for the petitioners. As could be seen from letter dated 3014/UE/A2/2008, dated 05.12.2018 addressed by the Special Chief Secretary to Government to respondent/ university, wherein it is very clear that the petitioners were appointed in clear sanctioned vacancies by following the Rule of Reservation and were appointed by conducting interviews. The expenditure on account of this is

    14

    being met from the block grant of the university would be continued as such including pension, gratuity etc., In view of the same, the case relied by the respondents in State of Andhra Pradesh v. Dr.D.Aruna Jyothi and others (cited supra) is not applicable to the present case.

    17. In similar circumstances of this case, the High Court for the State of Telangana in Pottisreeramulu Telugu University's Case (cited supra) held that the petitioners therein have been working on daily wage since 1990 (30 years of service by then) have been given minimum time scale from the year 2000. So also, in "U.V.S.R.Prasad and Others v. State of Andhra Pradesh and Another"10, wherein the Hon'ble Division Bench of erstwhile High Court of Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad held as follows:-

    "16. It is trite that the law declared by the Supreme Court is binding throughout the country under Article 141 of the Constitution of India. It is noteworthy that by the time the judgment in Uma Devi's case (supra) was rendered, the provisions of Act 2 of 1994 and G.O.Ms.No.212, dated 22.04.1994, were in existence. The Supreme Court, while denouncing the practice of regularization and absorption of persons, who entered service through back doors by giving a go-bye to the due procedure prescribed for appointments to public posts, consciously ordered for one-time absorption/ regularization of those, who were working for a period of not less than 10 years. It is has given directions in this regard to all the State Governments and also Union of India. The Supreme Court is presumed to be conscious of various State enactments such as Act 2 of 1994 and executive orders such as G.O.Ms.No.212, dated 22.4.1994, while giving directions in Para 53 of the judgment in Uma Devi's case (supra). But still, it has not made any exception in favour of the States where State enactments banning regularization absorption exist. Therefore, Act 2 of 1994 in G.O.Ms.No.212, dated

    10 2018(2) ALD 282 (DB)

    15

    22.4.1994, do not whittle down the width and the judgment in Manjula Bhashini's case does not lower the trajectory of the directions issued by the Supreme Court in para 53 of its judgment in Uma Devi's case. It is, therefore, not permissible for the respondents to take shelter under Act 2 of 1994 and G.O.Ms.No.212, dated 22.04.1994, to deny regularization to the petitioners who have, admittedly, satisfied the criteria laid down in para No.53 of the judgment in Uma Devi's case (supra)."

    18. In the instant case, the petitioners were allowed to draw the time scale and they are getting all the benefits on par with the regular employees, but except their services not being regularized, which is only the issue involved in this writ petition. The same principle would squarely apply to this case.

    19. As per information furnished by the petitioners would show that there are number of vacancies in the university, which kept unfilled, which were fallen vacant either due to retirement, death of promotions. Most of the petitioners have completed 20 to 31 years and above and some of them were also retired from service and one of them is also died. Further the Hon'ble Division Bench of this Court in W.A.No.782 of 2010 confirmed the W.P.No.24377 of 2007 i.e Kodali Raju's case (cited supra) held that the continuation of petitioners in the Corporation for the last more than 21 years itself can be construed that there are vacant posts available and the petitioners are entitled for regularization of their services and to be put on regular time scale. Therefore, the issue as held by this Court in earlier proceedings are very clear to regularize the services of the petitioners.

    16

    20. In similar circumstances of this case in nature, this Court allowed W.P.No. 5009 of 2021 and batch, dated 18.10.2024, which is squarely applicable to the facts of this case, therefore, the decisions relied by the learned counsel for the respondents would not apply as the case of the petitioners are continuation of service in the respondent/ university more than two to three decades. Further, there are clear vacancies in the university and further the petitioners were allowed to claim draw time scale on par with regular employees. Further there is no dispute with regard to working on consolidated pay by the petitioners in this case and hence the petitioners are entitled to claim benefit of regularization of their services with time scale.

    21. Having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case and considering the submissions of both the counsel and following the decisions of this Court relied by the learned counsel for the petitioners, the petitioners are entitled to claim reliefs in the writ petitions in the light of settled legal position.

    22. In view of foregoing discussion, this Court is inclined to allow the batch Writ Petitions, while setting aside the impugned orders respectively issued by the respondents as it is contrary to law, illegal and arbitrary. The respondents are directed to regularize the services of all the writ petitioners from the date of completion of 10 years of their service in terms of the order Kodali Raju's case i.e W.P.No.24377 of 2007 as confirmed by the Hon'ble Division Bench of this Court in W.A.No.782 of 2010, with all consequential benefits to the petitioners; Further a direction is given to the respondents to

    17

    grant retirement benefits and other consequential benefits to the petitioners. It is further directed the respondents to grant retirement benefits and other consequential benefits relating to the deceased K. Deenadayal to the writ petitioners 3 to 7 and 11, 15 and 16, who are legal representatives of deceased K. Deenadayal in W.P.No.11360 of 2021, within a period of three

    (03) months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. This Court is not awarding any interest for the benefits as claimed for. There shall be no order as to costs.

    23. With the above direction, the batch Writ Petitions are allowed. There shall be no order as to costs.

    As a sequel thereto, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending shall stand closed.

    ______________________________

    DR. JUSTICE K. MANMADHA RAO

    Dated: 29.10.2024.

    KK

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Smt. S.Puneetha v. State of AP
    (Oct 29, 2024)