Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 313 of Cr.P.C.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 313 of Cr.P.C.
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Bindu Kumar Urmaliya v. State Of M.P

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH

    AT JABALPUR

    BEFORE

    HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK AGARWAL &

    HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE DEVNARAYAN MISHRA ON THE 17thOF OCTOBER, 2024 CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 607 of 1995

    BINDU KUMAR URMALIYA

    Versus

    STATE OF M.P

    Appearance:

    Shri Devendra Kumar Gangrade - Advocate for the appellant. Shri Manas Mani Verma - Govt. Advocate for respondent/State. Reserved on :- 27-09-2024.

    Pronounced on :- 17-10-2024

    JUDGMENT

    Per: Justice Devnarayan Mishra :-

    This appeal is preferred being aggrieved with the judgment, conviction and sentence recorded by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Maihar District Satna rendered in Sessions Trial No. 124/1993 dated 10-04-1995, by which the appellant has been convicted for the offence punishable under Section 302 of IPC and sentenced to life imprisonment.

    2. The prosecution case before the trial Court was that the deceased Nisha Garg was the wife of the appellant whose marriage was solemnised with the appellant in the year 1981. The deceased was working as Staff

    1

    Nurse and residing in the rented premises of Kalu Prasad (PW-1) at village Jaryari Police Station Maihar. On 27-06-1993, after attending a meeting at Maihar, she returned to her residence, cooked food and after having dinner with her husband, she went to sleep. At 12:00 AM in night, she ran out of the home in burnt condition crying for help. On that, landlord Kalu Prasad (PW-1) and Girja Prasad (PW-2) and neighbourers came there and extinguished the fire and brought Nisha in that condition to Community Health Centre, Amarpatan where she was medically examined by Dr. R.K. Jain (PW-6). On the certificate of Dr. R.K. Jain, her dying declaration was recorded by the Executive Magistrate. The deceased Nisha's situation being serious, she was referred to the District Hospital, Satna. Here also she was medically examined and Devesh Pathak (PW-3) requested the Executive Magistrate to record the dying declaration of the deceased. Dr. G.C. Chaturvedi (PW-7) recorded the statement. During treatment, the deceased died. Autopsy was conducted over the dead body by Dr. A.K. Agarwal (PW-

    8). Case was registered at Police Station Maihar as Crime No. 230/93 under Section 307 of IPC on 29-06-1993 as (Ex.P/9) and after death of the victim, Section 302 was added in the investigation. After investigation, charge-sheet was filed before the Court of ACJM. On committal, the case was sent for trial.

    3. The learned Trial Court framed charges for committing offence punishable under Section 302 of IPC. The appellant abjured the guilt and prayed for trial.

    2

    4. During trial, the trial Court recorded the statement of prosecution witnesses, examined the appellant under Section 313 of Cr.P.C. The appellant had taken defence that on the date of incident, he was not on the spot. He has been falsely implicated in this case. He has examined Dr. K.B.Singh (DW-1), who provided the treatment to him and Kalika Prasad (DW-2).

    5. After hearing the parties, the Trial Court passed the judgment, by which the appellant has been convicted for offence punishable under Section 302 of IPC and sentenced as stated in paragraph-1 of the judgment.

    6. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of appellant Shri Davendra Kumar Gangrade submits that the trial Court has committed error in convicting and relying on the dying declaration, as in the first Dying Declaration, the deceased has not stated, who put her on fire and in the second dying declaration was recorded when the family members of the deceased came in the hospital and the victim was tutored.

    7. Learned counsel for the appellant has further argued that Dr. R.K. Jain (PW-6) in cross-examination has clearly admitted that both hands of the deceased were burn, fingers thumb were burn, in that situation, no clear ridges and curves will come in the thumb impression on dying declaration. There is impression whether ridges and curves can be seen and argued on that basis that the dying declaration was fabricated and the dying declaration is doubtful and on that basis, the appellant cannot be convicted. Furthermore,

    3

    he had argued that when the first dying declaration was recorded by Executive Magistrate Shiv Kumar Tiwari (Ex.P/11) when the deceased was admitted in the Community Health Centre Amarpatant then what was the necessity of recording the dying declaration by Naib Tahsildar, Raghuraj Nagar and from the cross-examination of the deceased father, it is clear that they were present in the hospital, deceased was tutored and relying on paragraph-5 of the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of State of Punjab vs. Gian Kaur and another AIR 1998 SC 2809 and judgment of this Court in the case of Garibdas @ Pappu Choudhari vs. State of M.P. 2013

    (3) JLJ 385 and in the case of Shaikh Bakshu and Ors. vs. State of Maharashtra (2007) 11 SCC 269 submits that when the dying declaration is doubtful and ante dated relying on the dying declaration, the accused/appellant cannot be convicted.

    8. Learned counsel for the appellant further submits that on the date of incident, the appellant was under treatment and he was not on the spot. Dr. K.B. Singh (DW-1) has clearly stated that from 26-06-1993 to 28-06-1993, the appellant was under his treatment and proved the prescriptions (C/1 and C/2). Furthermore, the statement of Dr. Singh is further supported by Kalika Prasad (DW-2). Thus, it is clear that the deceased on the date of incident was alone in the house and the appellant was not present, on that basis it is not possible for him to burn his wife and the trial Court has not considered this aspect.

    9. Learned Govt. Advocate Shri Manas Mani Verma appearing on the

    4

    behalf of the State submits that the learned Trial Court has properly considered the dying declaration and from intimation by Ram Bihari Gupta, it is clear that the deceased came out from her residence in burn condition and Kalu Prasad( Landlord) and other persons were present on the spot and the deceased came out burning from her house and the villagers brought the victim to the hospital and the appellant was present in the house but, he ran away from the spot. Thus, the presence of the appellant is proved and the dying declaration (Ex.P/11) and the statement Ex. D/2 the deceased had specifically stated that the appellant set fire to her. Further, this fact was supported by her, in the dying declaration Ex. P/8, which was recorded by Executive Magistrate. Trial Court has appreciated the trustworthiness of the witnesses and the dying declaration and relied and convicted the appellant on that basis. Hence, no interference is called for.

    10. We have heard and perused the record.

    11. Kalu Prasad (PW-1) has clearly stated that the appellant and the deceased Nisha Garg were residing in the rented premises for last 6 months prior to incident. On the date of incident at about 12:00-1:00 AM, he was sleeping in his house then, the deceased Nisha Garg cried for help, he woke and saw that Nisha was burning and crying to save her. When he saw that she caught fire, he also cried for help, on that Girja Prasad, Dwarka, Ram Bihari came there. The appellant was present in his home and after the deceased caught fire, he was not found in the home and ran away. Nisha was a nurse in the Health Department. No doubt was cast on this witness though,

    5

    lengthy cross-examination by the defence.

    12. Girja Prasad (PW-2) stated that the deceased was 28 years of old and was working as a Nurse. The appellant is the husband of the deceased and were residing on rent in the house of Kalu Prasad (PW-1). He was neighbour. It was night and due to summer season, he was sleeping out of his house. He heard the cry for help at 12:00 AM and he ran away towards the direction of sound. He saw that Nisha was away from 200 feets from his house. The appellant was not present. He extinguished the fire and he was also burnt in that process.

    13. Dr. R.K. Jain (PW-6) supported the fact that on 28-06-1993 when he was posted at Community Health Centre as Assistant Surgeon at 2:30 AM, Constable Sadhu Ram Yadav No. 329 of Police Station Amarpatan brought Smt. Nisha Garg w/o- Bindu Kumar R/o- Jariaari Nadan Tahsil Amarpatan for medical examination. On medical examination, he found that she was burnt from head to sole. Few hairs of the head were burnt. The sole of the feet was not burnt. The back side was 100% burn. Smell of kerosene oil was coming from the body of the deceased. In the left hand, she was wearing two glass bangles, which were intact. Injured was conscious and responding properly. Superficial burn was found. He prepared MLC report (Ex.P/13).

    14. Dr. A.K. Agarwal (PW-8) conducted autopsy over the dead body on 01-07-1993 and stated that the whole body was burnt. The burn was ante mortem. The deceased died due to shock that was caused due to burn injuries and the injuries caused were of such nature that was sufficient to cause death

    6

    in the ordinary course of nature.

    15. In cross-examination, this witness clarified that in such burn cases, it is not necessary that the burn person may get unconscious within two hours and further stated that it depends upon medication and treatment and the treating doctor will clearly tell when deceased got unconscious.

    16. Thus, it is clear that the deceased was burn on 28-06-1993 at 12:00 AM. He was brought to hospital where she was medically examined and during treatment, she died. It is clear from the statement of Kalu Prasad (PW-

    1) an Girja Prasad (PW-2) that the appellant was present in home. and the deceased came out in burning condition from her residence. He has not tried to save the victim or to bring her for treatment in any hospital.

    17. On the point, where the victim got burn injuries. Kalu Prasad (PW-1) and Girja Prasad (PW-2) clearly stated that the deceased came out burning from her residence. H.L.Pathak (PW-3) stated that on 29-06-1993 at 4:30 PM, he visited the house of Kalu Prasad in village Jharari where the victim was residing. He found a tin container of 2 litres having kerosene oil that was placed near bed and piece of burn clothes attached with the wooden rod. There was smell of kerosene oil in the room. A matchbox was found. In the bed-sheets, smell of kerosene oil was coming. A blue coloured 'petticoat' was found in the 'choughan' of the house from which smell of kerosene oil was coming. He seized the above articles and seizure memo was prepared. From the seizure memo and the spot map Ex. P/3 and Ex. P/4, container of

    7

    kerosene oil, a partial burnt clothes attached with wooden rod and in the bed- sheet, smell of kerosene oil was found. A petticoat of the deceased was found, part of burn clothes were also found. The deceased was lying outside the home near the house of Kalu Prasad (PW-1).

    18. Thus, from the statement of witnesses and spot map, it is clear that the deceased got burn in her bedroom and kerosene and cloth attached with the wooden rod (patli dandi) was found which was partly burnt and smell of kerosene oil was coming from that. It shows that the occurrence took near the bed where the deceased was sleeping. It is also clear that some drop of kerosene oil were also found on the bed-sheet of the deceased. Thus, there are two circumstances that the accused was present in the house and he has not submitted any explanation in what circumstances, the deceased died.

    19. On this point, the appellant submits that he was not present at home at the time of incident. On this point, witness Dr. K.B.Singh (DW-1) stated that on 26-06-1993, he was posted as Medical Specialist in Government Hospital, Nagod. He examined and treated him. Ex. D/1 is the out-door patient prescription. Victim was suffering from pain in intestine. He treated the appellant from 26-06-1993 to 28-06-1993. The certificate is C/2. In cross-examination, this witness stated that he cannot recognise that by Ex.C/1 and C/2, he treated the person, is accused before the Court. He stated that from 26/28-06-1993, the patient was regularly coming for treatment. He further stated that on 28-06-1993, he prescribed the medicines. He cannot explain from 26-28/06/2024 at night time, where the patient was? He further

    8

    stated that in paragraph-5 of cross-examination that appellant may reach to Jhariari to spot from bus.

    20. Thus, from the statement and prescriptions of doctor, it is clear that these prescriptions were given to the appellant as out-door patient and nowhere patient stated that he was suffering from such acute or serious disease that he was unable to move.

    21. The witness Kalika Prasad (DW-2) stated that the appellant was residing at home from 26/28-06-1993. In cross-examination, he admitted that he did not disclose this fact to police authority when he was arrested and send to the jail and that appellant was with him.

    22. Thus, the appellant has taken a 'plea of alibi' but, the independent witness Kalu Prasad (PW-1) and Girja Prasad (PW-2) stated that appellant was present at home when the deceased got burn injuries. Thus, the statement of appellant that he was not present on the spot when her wife was burnt cannot be believed.

    23. On the role of the appellant to burn his wife, Dr. R.K. Jain stated that on the date of incident, the deceased was brought at 2:30PM by police Constable Sadhu Ram Yadav. He prepared MLC report. At 3:45 PM, when he was asked Executive Magistrate that whether the patient is capable to record her dying declaration. He has issued the Certificate Ex. P/11 and signed the document from 'B to B' and after completion of statement, he further certified that the patient was fit during the statement. Statement was

    9

    recorded by Executive Magistrate-Shiv Kumar Tiwari after recording the statement, thumb impression of patient Nisha was taken in the dying declaration and Naib Tahsildar has signed the dying declaration and further stated that the thumb impression was taken as her hands were burnt but, this witness has clearly stated that the palm and fingers of the patient were burnt. Thumb was also burnt but, it has not specifically been asked that the inner side of the thumb was burnt and in such a situation, it was not possible to take thumb impression and ridge will not come. In paragraph-9 of cross- examination, it has not been asked that if the skin of the thumb was burnt then, the ridge and conture thumb will not come and nothing more has been stated except that.

    24. Devesh Pathak (PW-3), the Investigating Officer stated that on 29-06-1993,he was posted in Police Station Satna as Sub-Inspector. He has registered FIR (Ex.-P/5). On direction of the OIC of the Police Station, he went to District Hospital, Satna. The dying declaration was recorded by the Naib Tahsildar, Raghuraj Nagar/Executive Magistrate, Satna and on that basis, he lodged the FIR (Ex.-P/5) under Section 307 of IPC.

    25. Dr. G.C. Chaturvedi (PW-7) on 28-06-1993, was posted as Assistant Surgeon in District Hospital, Satna. Ramadhar Shukla - Naib Tahsildar (PW-4) had recorded the dying declaration and he certified that the patient Nisha Garg was in condition to record her dying declaration, she was conscious. He has signed the certificate 'C to C', D to D' and Nisha Garg thumb impression was marked from "B to B'. Statement was recorded in the

    10

    presence from 11:05-11:20 AM ( Ex. P/8).

    26. Ramadhar Shukla (PW-4) stated that on 28-06-1993, he was posted as Naib Tahsildar/Executive Magistrate Raghuraj Nagar, Satna. On 28-06-1993, from 11:05-11:20 morning, he has recorded the dying declaration of the deceased Nisha Garg. She told her name as Nisha Garg, her fathers name Banke Bihari Garg. Before recording the dying declaration, he obtained the certificate from Dr. G.C. Chaturvedi. When he was recording the dying declaration, the victim was fully conscious and fit to state the dying declaration. He obtained the thumb impression of the deceased and this dying declaration (Ex.P/5), it has clearly been stated that at quarter to 11 PM, after having dinner, her husband was present in home and after reading newspapers, she went to sleep at 12:00 AM in the night. She felt the heat the fire on the upper part of her body. She saw her husband is putting on clothes when she asked what he is doing. Her husband caught hold her and poured kerosene on her and putting the burning fire by a 'Chimta', he set her ablazed. The kerosene oil was poured on her body and bed and she caught fire and he came out of her home and was trying to extinguish the fire then the landlord and other persons came and extinguished the fire and brought her on tractor to Amarpatan. Thus, in the dying declaration, the deceased had clearly stated that appellant poured kerosene oil and he already burnt fire and by putting a burning fire by 'chimta' on her and she caught fire and start burning.

    27. In this case, the first dying declaration that was recorded in the Community Health Centre, Amarpatan though, not proved by the author of

    11

    the dying declaration but, Dr. R.K.Jain (PW-6) clearly stated that he had certified that the patient was in position to record her dying declaration and was conscious and in that also, she had clearly stated that she got the burn injuries at her home. She also stated that she was sleeping at home and smell of kerosene oil was felt and when she saw she was in fire, she opened the door and came out. Her husband B.K. Urmalia was with her and further she clarified that when she got fire except her husband, no other person was present.

    28. Thus, it is clear that just after the incident at 3:50 PM, she stated clearly that she was sleeping, she felt the smell of kerosene oil and caught fire, when she was sleeping. Thus, as the defence had alleged that the Tahsildar has acted in connivance with the family members of the deceased and falsely recorded the dying declaration has challenged the statement of Banke Bihari (PW-9) but, the dying declaration is consistent. Furthermore, in this case, the second dying declaration was recorded as the police authorities and medical authorities were not having knowledge that the her previous dying declaration had been recorded at Community Health Centre, Amarpatan. Ex.P/6 is the requisition sent by the hospital authorities to Town Inspector, City Kotwali Satna and (Ex.P/7) is the written requisition by police authorities City Kotwali Satna to City Magistrate, Satna and on that basis, on 11:05-11:20 PM, dying declaration was recorded.

    29. Thus, it is clear that just after the incident, her dying declaration was recorded in which, she had clearly stated that she was sleeping and her

    12

    husband prepared a small 'masal' to burn her and opened the container of kerosene and on that she woke up and on that her husband poured kerosene on her by 'masal' and put fire to the deceased and she got burn injuries. The dying declaration cannot be discarded only on the basis that her fingers were burnt and her thumb impression cannot be taken, as it is not clear that the lower skin of the thumb was burnt and no thumb impression could have been obtained by that.

    30. In the case of State of Punjab vs. Gian Kaur (supra) , the High Court had disbelieved the dying declaration that the victim was 100% burnt and her thumb impression clear ridges and curves were found. In that case, it was specifically asked from the doctor, who conducted the autopsy over the dead body, that both the thumb of the deceased were burnt. This situation is not clarified in this case and hence, principle laid down in this case does not help the appellant.

    31. In the case of Garibdas @ Pappu Choudhari(supra), it is held that on the post-mortem no ink mark was found on the fingers and thumb of the deceased and dying declaration was not read over and explained to the deceased and on that basis, the dying declaration was disbelieved.

    32. In this case, it is clear that two dying declarations were written. Furthermore, it is also clear that the independent witnesses have supported that the deceased came burning out from her residence and appellant was present on the spot and when the deceased came out burning from home, the appellant ran away and no specific question has been asked from the autopsy

    13

    surgeon that the ink mark was found on fingers and thumb of the deceased or not as regarding ridges and curves, no specific question has been asked whether the thumb were completely burnt.

    33. In the case of Shaikh Bakshu (supra), the dying declaration was shown to be recorded between 6:00-6:10 PM whereas the information of the crime was recorded at the police station after 6:30PM and deceased died at 8:30PM. On that basis, the dying declaration was disbelieved but, in this case, there is no such situation. There is one other circumstance against the appellant except the dying declaration that the deceased and appellant were only at home where the victim got burn injuries and the appellant failed to explain the situation how the deceased got burn injuries. He had not taken the defence that the deceased has committed suicide and his 'Plea of alibi' has failed.

    34. In the case of Surinder Kumar vs. State of Punjab 2012 (12) SCC 120, the Apex Court has held that there is no format to record the dying declaration. In this case, it was argued that the deceased was burnt 90% muscle deep and in that situation, the victim cannot make dying declaration and she was not in a position to affix her thumb impression and sign and is it is not in 'question-answer' form.

    35. The Apex Court has held that there is no format prescribed for recording the dying declaration and no such format can be prescribed. Therefore, it is not obligatory that the dying declaration should be recorded

    14

    in 'Question-Answer' form. There may be occasion when it is possible to do so and in others it may not be possible to do so either because of prevailing situation or either because of pain and agony that the victim might be suffering at that point of time.

    36. In the case of Paranagouda and Anr. vs. State of Karnataka and Anr. 2023 SCC Online SC 1369. In paragraph-24, the Hon'ble Apex Court held that without corroboration, other evidence, dying declaration can be acted upon, if it is trustworthy and inspire confidence of the Court.

    37. Looking to the above situations and the material brought before us, the conclusion drawn by the trial Court cannot be said to be perverse or based on conjectures or surmises and they are based on proper appreciation of evidence.

    38. Hence, the conviction recorded by the trial Court is affirmed. The sentence is proper. The appeal being devoid of merit is dismissed. The appellant is on bail. His bail bonds are cancelled. He will surrender before the Trial Court to serve the remaining jail sentence within 15 days of publication of this judgment in default, the trial Court shall issue arrest warrant and after arrest shall send the appellant to serve the remaining jail sentence as per law.

    39. The order, regarding the disposal of the case property, of the trial Court is approved.

    40. With the copy of judgment, record of the trial Court be returned

    15

    (VIVEK AGARWAL)

    JUDGE

    (DEVNARAYAN MISHRA)

    JUDGE

    forthwith.

    41. The record of this appeal be consigned to record room.

    PG

    16

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bindu Kumar Urmaliya v. State Of M.P
    (Oct 17, 2024)