Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The case concerns a maintenance claim filed by the wife under Section 125 of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC) seeking a monthly maintenance of Rs.5,000/-. The husband contested the claim. The learned Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Ponduru dismissed the maintenance petition on the grounds that the wife was in possession of assets sufficient to maintain herself and the husband was unable to maintain himself. Aggrieved, the wife filed a Criminal Revision Petition before the Family Court, which allowed the revision and granted maintenance and litigation expenses. The husband then filed the present revision challenging the Family Court's order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a husband who has sufficient means but neglects or refuses to maintain his wife, who is unable to maintain herself, is liable to pay maintenance under Section 125 of the CrPC.
  2. Whether the Family Court erred in setting aside the Magistrate's order dismissing the maintenance claim on the basis of the wife's ability to maintain herself and the husband's inability to maintain.
  3. Whether the husband's capacity or incapacity to earn and maintain should be considered alongside the wife's ability to maintain herself in deciding maintenance claims.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The spouses separated 34 years ago and the wife never sought maintenance or restitution of conjugal rights during this period.
  • The wife left without reasonable cause despite the husband's willingness to live with her.
  • The husband is aged and unable to work or earn, as supported by evidence, and the trial court correctly dismissed the maintenance claim on this basis.
  • The wife has been enjoying the husband's properties, negating the need for further maintenance payments.
  • The Family Court erred in overturning the trial court's order without proper consideration of the husband's incapacity to earn.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The wife was neglected and deserted by the husband who is a propertied man.
  • The wife has no assets and is unable to maintain herself.
  • The Family Court rightly corrected the trial court's errors and granted maintenance.
  • There is no justification for interference with the Family Court's order.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the evidence concerning the financial and personal circumstances of both spouses. It noted that the wife has been living in a house and cultivating agricultural land owned by the husband, earning approximately Rs.50,000 per annum. The trial court had found that the wife was able to maintain herself through these means and that the husband was unable to maintain himself due to his age and incapacity to work. The Family Court, however, focused only on the wife's inability to maintain herself and ignored the husband's incapacity to earn and the evidence of the wife's possession of the husband's assets. The court found this approach erroneous and held that the trial court's order was correctly based on a holistic appreciation of the evidence. The court also noted that both spouses expressed willingness to reconcile, indicating that the maintenance dispute might have been avoidable. Accordingly, the court restored the trial court's order dismissing the maintenance claim.

Holding and Implications

The revision petition is allowed. The order dated 15.11.2018 of the Family Court setting aside the Magistrate's order is set aside, and the Magistrate's order dated 26.02.2018 dismissing the maintenance claim is restored.

The direct effect of this decision is that the wife’s maintenance claim is denied based on the finding that she is able to maintain herself and the husband is incapable of paying maintenance due to his age and inability to earn. No new legal precedent was established beyond the application of Section 125 CrPC principles and the evaluation of evidence regarding the parties' capacities and possessions.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    K.BANGARI v. K.NARASAMMA

    APHC010012592019

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA

    PRADESH

    AT AMARAVATI

    (Special Original Jurisdiction)

    [3365]

    WEDNESDAY ,THE TENTH DAY OF JULY

    TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY FOUR

    PRESENT

    THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE DR V R K KRUPA SAGAR

    CRIMINAL REVISION CASE NO: 55/2019 Between:

    K.bangari ...PETITIONER

    AND

    K Narasamma and Others ...RESPONDENT(S) Counsel for the Petitioner:

    1. NUTHALAPATI KRISHNA MURTHY

    Counsel for the Respondent(S):

    1. TADDI NAGESWARA RAO

    2. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)

    The Court made the following:

    1

    2

    THE HON'BLE JUSTICE Dr. V.R.K.KRUPA SAGAR CRIMINAL REVISION CASE No.55 of 2019

    ORDER:

    1. A person having sufficient means neglects or refuses to maintain his wife who is unable to maintain herself, he shall be directed to pay maintenance to his wife is what section 125 of the CrPC mandates.

    2. The present revision under Sections 397 and 401 of the CrPC is filed by the husband. R1 is his wife. R2 is the State.

    3. The wife filed M.C.No.14 of 2016 seeking a monthly maintenance of Rs.5,000/- in terms of Section 125 of the CrPC. The husband filed his counter. During the enquiry, the wife testified as PW.1 and got examined PW.2 and 3. The husband testified as RW.1 and got examined RW.2. Both sides did not produce any documents for consideration of the court. After detailed narration of the facts and evidence, the learned Magistrate at paragraph No.12 of his order recorded that from the evidence, he found that the husband deserted his wife. However, he refused to grant maintenance on the premise that the wife has been in possession to maintain herself and further the husband was unable to maintain himself. Accordingly, the learned Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Ponduru dismissed the maintenance claim by an order dated 26.02.2018 in M.C.No.14 of 2016.

    3

    4. Aggrieved by that order, the wife preferred Criminal Revision Petition No.17 of 2018 before the learned Judge, Family Court - cum - III Additional District and Sessions Judge, Srikakulam. That court after affording an opportunity to both sides to advance their submissions, by an order dated 15.11.2018, allowed the revision petition and set aside the order of the Magistrate and granted a monthly maintenance of Rs.5.000/- and litigation expenses of Rs.2,000/-. The husband was granted three months time to remit the entire arrears at that rate.

    5. The aggrieved husband has come up with this revision. Sri N.Krishna Murthy, the learned counsel for revision petitioner and Sri T.Nageswara Rao, the learned counsel for R1 submitted their respective arguments.

    6. The principal submissions of learned counsel for revision petitioner are that the spouses got separated 34 years ago and for all these years wife did not seek any claim for maintenance and never moved any application for restitution of conjugal rights and she left him without any reasonable cause, and he has always been ready and willing to allow his wife to live with him. The further submission of the learned counsel is that the evidence on record amply disclose that the revision petitioner/husband is very aged and is not able to work and has not been earning anything and the learned trial court properly appreciated that and dismissed the petition. However, the learned family court committed an error in upsetting such order. It is

    4

    further submitted that the properties of the revision petitioner have been under the enjoyment of his wife/R1 and therefore no further order for maintenance was required and therefore learned counsel seeks to upset the impugned order.

    7. As against it, the learned counsel for R1/ wife submits that the evidence on record fully demonstrate that the wife has been neglected and was deserted by the husband and the husband is a propertied man and the wife had no assets and she has been unable to maintain herself and her children also died and it is only this revision petitioner being the husband who has to maintain her. The errors committed by the trial court were properly rectified by the learned Family court in the revision petition and there is no warrant for interference in this revision case.

    8. Before adverting to the contentious questions, the following undisputed facts pleaded and spoken to by both the parties need recapitulation. By now, more than forty years ago, the man and woman got married. During their wed lock, they were blessed with two sons and a daughter. At different ages, both the sons died. For one of the sons, there is a widow. The daughter of these spouses got married and she was in a different family. By the time, the maintenance case was filed in the year 2016, the woman was aged 55 years. Thus, by now she is aged about 63 years. In the maintenance case, the husband was shown to be aged 60 years. In his counter, he said that he was 65 years old. Thus, by now, he is aged around 70 years.

    5

    9. At one point of time, the woman got her pregnancy aborted. As per her version, this abortion brought rift between the spouses. It is undisputed that the spouses got separated and have been living separately at two different places and the husband after leaving his wife, got married with another woman by name Gowramma and through her, he fathered two sons. Thus, marrying another woman while his earlier marriage was in subsistence is also one of the causes that prevented reconciliation between the spouses. Thus, the happy life that emerged between the spouses got disrupted and decades went by and the spouses have been surviving by themselves separately.

    10. In the light of the above undisputed facts, the questions that cropped up in this revision is that the man is aged about 70 years and the woman is aged about 63 years and the woman had no parents and had no children and there is none to maintain her. It is undisputed that she is not an employee and is not doing any business. Though there were statements against her that she was possessed of wealth on her own, no tangible evidence was produced to make any court to believe existence of such independent assets for herself. To that extent, the material clearly demonstrates that the woman is unable to maintain herself. There are a few other aspects which shall bear their mention at appropriate places.

    11. The man/husband is now aged about 70 years. The evidence of the two witnesses/ PW.2 and 3 produced by the wife

    6

    show that they clearly, categorically, unhesitatingly stated that the man is not in a position to work and earn. Be it noted, in her petition for maintenance, she mentioned her husband does coolie work for his earning. Thus, a man depending on his body strength worked all those years and now has grown up in age where his body has not been helping him to work and earn. Thus, it cannot be said that he is an able bodied man to now earn for himself and his wife.

    12. In her evidence, the wife/PW.1 stated that she and her husband earlier lived in Gadabapalem Village where her husband has a house and an agriculture land. The native of that village testified as PW.2 and he stated that the R1/wife has been cultivating one acre of wet land belonging to her husband and has been living in a house that belonged to her husband. PW.1 admitted herself in her cross-examination that she has been living in the house that was owned by her husband. PW.3 said that his father is the brother of the present revision petitioner. In his evidence, he stated that PW.1 has been cultivating the land of her husband. The learned trial court properly considered all these pieces of evidence and concluded that for her living, there is a house and for her sustenance, there is a land which she has been cultivating and earning about Rs.50,000/- per annum. It was in such circumstances, it held that as the woman was able to maintain herself, it could not grant maintenance especially in the context of the fact that the husband himself was unable to work and earn. It further held that there was no clear proof showing revenue yielding assets for the husband to direct him to pay

    7

    maintenance to his wife. However, when the matter was placed before the learned Family judge, the court did not even think to frame a point for consideration about the husband's capacity or incapacity to earn and maintain. It simply framed a point for consideration about wife's ability or inability to maintain herself. It completely ignored the evidence that was elicited through the witnesses of wife. Thus, while the learned Family Judge rightly concluded that woman was not able to earn for herself, it completely ignored that her housing needs were satisfied as she has been living in the house of his husband and the maintenance needs were satisfied because she has been cultivating the land of her husband earning about Rs.50,000/- per annum. Thus, it completely failed to appreciate the evidence and thus it led itself to erroneous conclusions.

    13. In this revision case, learned counsel for respondent submits that there is no clear evidence to prove that the petitioner has been earning Rs.50,000/- per annum. It is true there are no documents indicating such revenue. However, after discussing the oral evidence that finding was recorded by the trial court. In this regard, one has to notice that the wife deposing as PW.1 did not even choose to make a mention about the house and land that she has been in possession and enjoyment which belonged to her husband. In the above referred circumstances, this court thinks that grave errors in appreciating the material occurred at the hands of the learned Family Court Judge and that requires interference. Before winding up, it may be mentioned that wife in her evidence as PW.1 categorically stated that she is willing to

    8

    live with her husband if he takes her. The husband in his counter made a clear statement that he is willing to receive his wife and live with her. Thus, it is a case where both the spouses wanted to live together. Instead of doing that they have been fighting for maintenance claims. It is hoped that they would reconcile and join together which harmony both of them clearly expressed in the process of their litigation.

    14. For the reasons mentioned above, this court finds that the judgment of the trial court is correct on facts and law and that must be restored.

    15. In the result, this revision is allowed. Order dated 15.11.2018 of the learned Judge, Family Court - cum - III Additional District and Sessions Court, Srikakulam in Crl.Revision Petition No.17 of 2018 is set aside. Order dated 26.02.2018 of the learned Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Ponduru in M.C.No.14 of 2018 stands restored.

    _____________________________ Dr. V.R.K.KRUPA SAGAR, J

    Date: 10.07.2024 Dvs

    9

    THE HON'BLE JUSTICE Dr. V.R.K.KRUPA SAGAR CRIMINAL REVISION CASE No.55 of 2019 Date: 10.07.2024

    Dvs

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    K.BANGARI v. K.NARASAMMA
    (Jul 10, 2024)