AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    MARVELEDGE REALTORS PRIVATE LIMITED v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS

    3-WP-10912-22 judgment.doc Rameshwar Dilwale

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

    CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

    WRIT PETITION NO.10912 OF 2022

    Marveledge Realtors Private Limited }

    Through one of its Directors, }

    Shri. Vishwajeet Subhash Jhavar, }

    Having registered address at 301-302, }

    Jewal Towar, Arthvishwa, Lane No.5, }

    Koregaon Park, Pune-411004 } .. Petitioner Vs.

    1. The State of Maharashtra }

    Through Government Pleader, }

    Bombay High Court, Mumbai }

    2. Maharashtra Real Estate Regulatory }

    Authority, Pune (MahaRERA), }

    Through its Registrar and }

    Ld. Adjudicating Officer, Pune-present }

    3. The Collector, Pune District, }

    Address at New Collector Office }

    Building, Station Raod, Opp. Sassoon }

    Hospital, Pune-411001. }

    4. The Tahasildar, Pune City }

    Address at New Collector Officer }

    Building, Station Raod, Opp. Sassoon }

    Hospital, Pune-411001. }

    5. Mrs. Panna Haresh Asher }

    6. Mr. Haresh Asher }

    Both Respondent Nos.5 & 6 residing at}

    301, Puja Kunj, Plot No.198, }

    Sher-e-Punjab Society, Andheri (E), }

    Mumbai-400093. }

    7. Classic Promoters & Builders Pvt. Ltd. }

    Having its Registered Office at Level 8, }

    Solitaire World, Off. Bangalore }

    Mumbai Highway, Pune -411037 } .. Respondents

    1/8

    RAMESHWAR

    LAXMAN

    DILWALE

    Digitally signed by RAMESHWAR

    LAXMAN

    DILWALE

    Date: 2024.09.18 18:43:17 +0530

    2024:BHC-AS:37044-DB

    1

    ...

    Mr. Amit A. Gharte, Advocate for the petitioner. Mr A.K. Saxena, Advocate for the respondent no.2-MAHARERA. Mr. Amogh Singh with Mr. Nikhil Wable, Mr. Mihir Kakade, Ms. Parita Mashruwala i/by Jayakar & Partners, Advocates for respondent nos.5 & 6.

    Mrs. Reena A. Salunkhe, AGP for respondent-State.

    …

    CORAM : A.S. CHANDURKAR &

    RAJESH S. PATIL, JJ

    DATE : 13th SEPTEMBER, 2024.

    ORAL JUDGMENT :(A. S. CHANDURKAR, J)

    1. Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith and heard the learned counsel for the parties. The challenge raised in this writ petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of the India is to the order dated 15/11/2018 passed by the Adjudicating Officer, MAHARERA, Pune thereby directing the petitioner to pay an amount of Rs. 2,15,07,733/- with simple interest. The aforesaid amount includes an amount of compensation of Rs.5,00,000/- as well as an amount of refund to be payable to the fifth and sixth respondents towards stamp duty paid by them.

    2. The learned counsel for the fifth and sixth respondents at the outset raised an objection to the maintainability of the writ petition on the ground that the order passed by the Adjudicating Authority was liable to be challenged by filing an appeal before the Real Estate Appellate Tribunal. Without availing that remedy the

    2/8

    writ petition preferred by the petitioner did not deserve to be entertained.

    3. The learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon the decision in Newtech Promoters and Developers Pvt. Ltd. Vs. State of UP, AIR Online 2021 SC 1018 and submitted that insofar as the amount of refund as well as interest on the amount of refund is concerned, that adjudication has to be undertaken by the Regulatory Authority under Section 71 of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016. Insofar as the Adjudicating Authority is concerned, he has jurisdiction only to determine the relief seeking compensation and interest thereon. In the present case, the Adjudicating Authority had passed a composite order directing payment of the amount of refund, interest on that amount and had also determined the amount of compensation. Since the Adjudicating Officer had no jurisdiction to determine the amount of refund and interest payable on that amount which jurisdiction is conferred on the Regulatory Authority, the impugned order travels beyond the jurisdiction conferred under the Act of 2016. In such situation, availability of an alternate remedy would not preclude the petitioner from approaching this Court in its extraordinary jurisdiction. Since the

    3/8

    petitioner's challenge was based on an exercise of jurisdiction beyond powers conferred on the said Authority, the writ petition ought to be entertained on merits. In that regard, the learned counsel referred to the decision in Kiran Singh Vs. Chaman Paswan, AIR 1954 SC 340.

    4. The learned counsel for the fifth respondent and sixth respondent opposed aforesaid submissions. According to him, the aspects sought to be raised by the petitioner in the writ petition could also be raised in the appeal if filed against the impugned order. There was no exceptional case made out to invoke writ jurisdiction. He therefore submitted that the writ petition did not deserve to be entertained.

    5. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and we have perused the documents on record. Since the petitioner seeks to invoke the extra ordinary jurisdiction of this Court by contending that the Adjudicating Officer has committed a jurisdictional error by directing payment of the amount of stamp duty by way of refund alongwith interest when he had no authority under the Act of 2016 to do so, it would be necessary to examine this aspect. In Newtech Promoters and Developers Pvt. Ltd

    4/8

    (supra), the Supreme Court considered various issues arising under the Act of 2016. Question no.2 as decided therein reads as under:-

    "2. Whether the authority has jurisdiction to direct return/refund of the amount to the allottee under Sections 12, 14, 18 and 19 of the Act or the jurisdiction exclusively lies with the adjudicating officer under Section 71 of the Act?"

    While answering the same it has been held in paragraph 86 as under:-

    "86. From the scheme of the Act of which a detailed reference has been made and taking note of power of adjudication delineated with the regulatory authority and adjudicating officer, what finally culls out is that although the Act indicates the distinct expressions like 'refund', 'interest', 'penalty' and 'compensation', a conjoint reading of Sections 18 and 19 clearly manifests that when it comes to refund of the amount, and interest on the refund amount, or directing payment of interest for delayed delivery of possession, or penalty and interest thereon, it is the regulatory authority which has the power to examine and determine the outcome of a complaint. At the same time, when it comes to a question of seeking the relief of adjudging compensation and interest thereon under Sections 12, 14, 18 and 19, the adjudicating officer exclusively has the power to determine, keeping in view the collective reading of Section 71 read with Section 72 of the Act. If the adjudication under Sections 12, 14, 18 and 19 other than

    5/8

    compensation as envisaged, if extended to the adjudicating officer as prayed that, in our view, may intend to expand the ambit and scope of the powers and functions of the adjudicating officer under Section 71 and that would be against the mandate of the Act 2016.

    6. From the aforesaid decision it is clear that insofar as the prayer for grant of compensation and interest under Sections 12, 14, 18 and 19 of the Act of 2016 is concerned, it is the Adjudicating Officer who has the power to determine the same on the basis of provisions of Section 71 read with Section 72 of the Act of 2016. Insofar as the relief for seeking refund of the amount paid as well as interest on such amount or interest for delayed delivery of possession or penalty and interest thereon is concerned, the jurisdiction vests with the Regulatory Authority in view of Sections 18 and 19 of the Act of 2016.

    7. Perusal of the impugned order passed by the Adjudicating Officer indicates that besides determining the amount of compensation payable to the fifth and sixth respondent, he has also adjudicated the prayer for grant of refund and payment of interest thereon. The latter part of the said direction is thus beyond the jurisdiction of the Adjudicating Officer. Since this

    6/8

    aspect goes to the root of the matter and raises a jurisdictional issue, the writ petition is entertained to that extent. The law in this regard is well settled as referred to in Kiran Singh (supra).

    8. It is thus clear from the decision in Newtech Promoters and Developers Pvt. Ltd. (supra) that the Adjudicating Officer can only determine the amount of compensation and not the prayer for refund with interest thereon. Hence to that extent a case for interference has been made out. Since the impugned order suffers from a jurisdictional error to the extent it determines the amount to be refunded alongwith interest when such adjudication is required to be made by the Regulatory Authority, that part of the order is liable to be set aside. Liberty instead can be granted to the fifth and sixth respondent to approach the Regulatory Authority for determining the prayer for grant of refund and interest.

    9. Accordingly, the following order is passed.

    i) In terms of the order dated 15/11/2018 passed by the Adjudicating Officer, MAHARERA, Pune dated 15/11/2018, the petitioner shall deposit an amount of Rs. 5,00,000/- within a period of three weeks with the Maharashtra Real Estate Regulatory Authority, Pune of uploading of this order. This deposit is without prejudice

    7/8

    to the rights and contentions of the parties.

    ii) Insofar as the relief sought by the respondent nos.5 and 6 for grant of refund as well as interest on the said amount, the said respondents are at liberty to move the Regulatory Authority to seek adjudication of the same in terms of the judgment of the Supreme Court in Newtech Promoters and Developers Pvt. Ltd. (supra). Since the order dated 15/11/2018 was the subject matter of challenge in the present writ petition which has been decided today, the fifth and sixth respondents are granted time of four weeks from the date of uploading of this order to approach the Regulatory Authority for determining the amount of refund and the interest, if any. If such proceedings are filed, the same shall be decided on their own merits and in accordance with law. The time spent in defending the present proceedings shall be taken into consideration while entertaining the said proceedings. All points raised on merits are kept open. The Writ Petition is partly allowed in aforesaid terms with no order as to costs.

    [ RAJESH S. PATIL, J. ] [ A.S. CHANDURKAR, J. ]

    8/8

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    MARVELEDGE REALTORS PRIVATE LIMITED v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS
    (Sep 13, 2024)