AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • 3 of 9 3 under Section 81,
  • sub section (9) Harish 7 of 9 7 of Section 149,
  • sub section 6 of Section 81 of MCS Act,
  • provisions of MCS Act. Section 81 (1) (e) of MCS Act
  • Section 3 and 4 of the Maharashtra Protection of Interest of Depositors (In Financial Establishments Act, 1999).
  • Section 81(1)(a) of The Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 (MCS Act)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • 3 of 9 3 under Section 81,
  • sub section (9) Harish 7 of 9 7 of Section 149,
  • sub section 6 of Section 81 of MCS Act,
  • provisions of MCS Act. Section 81 (1) (e) of MCS Act
  • Section 3 and 4 of the Maharashtra Protection of Interest of Depositors (In Financial Establishments Act, 1999).
  • Section 81(1)(a) of The Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 (MCS Act)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition challenges the order dated 27th January 2023 passed by the Divisional Joint Registrar rejecting a Revision Application as not maintainable. The Revision Application sought to challenge an auditor's report prepared under Section 81(1)(a) of The Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 (MCS Act). The auditor's report was submitted following an audit ordered by the District Deputy Registrar under Section 81(1)(a) of the MCS Act concerning Janta Nagari Sahakari Pathsanstha Ltd., which was under interim liquidation since 31st March 2022. The audit, conducted for the years 2019-2020 to 2021-2022, concluded that managing committee members and office bearers had accepted deposits beyond permissible limits by luring depositors with higher interest rates, thereby cheating depositors on a large scale. Based on the auditor’s findings, a First Information Report (FIR) was registered against the managing committee members under the Indian Penal Code and the Maharashtra Protection of Interest of Depositors (In Financial Establishments) Act, 1999. The Revision Application was dismissed on the ground that the auditor's report does not constitute a "decision" or "order" and thus is not revisable under Section 154 of the MCS Act.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the auditor's report under Section 81 of the MCS Act constitutes a "decision" or "order" within the meaning of Section 154 of the MCS Act.
  2. Whether the auditor's report is revisable under Section 154 of the MCS Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • Section 81(6) of the MCS Act empowers the Registrar to direct a re-audit, and the audit provisions apply to such re-audit.
  • Section 82 requires that if defects are disclosed by the audit, the Society must be given an opportunity to rectify them, which was not provided in this case.
  • The auditor's report culminated in a decision that depositors were cheated and that criminal prosecution is warranted, thereby satisfying the requirement of a "decision" or "order".
  • Section 154 confers power on the Registrar to revise any inquiry or proceeding where a decision has been taken, and since the auditor’s report resulted in a decision, revision is maintainable.
  • There is no remedy of appeal under Section 152 of the MCS Act, making revision under Section 154 the only recourse.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The auditor conducted the audit pursuant to directions under Section 81(1)(a) of the MCS Act but did not pass any order.
  • In the absence of any decision or order, Section 154 of the MCS Act is not applicable for revision.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the statutory provisions relevant to the auditor’s role and the nature of the auditor’s report under the MCS Act. It noted that the auditor was appointed under Section 81(1)(a) and conducted an audit concluding that the managing committee members had engaged in financial irregularities amounting to cheating depositors and falsification of accounts. The Court observed that Section 81(5B) requires the auditor to report offences and file an FIR with the Registrar’s permission, or else the Registrar shall file it. The auditor’s conclusion triggered criminal proceedings, which the Court recognized as carrying finality and legal consequences.

The Court interpreted the terms "decision" and "order" under Section 154 of the MCS Act as synonymous and encompassing determinations that affect rights and have statutory consequences. The auditor’s report was found to be a final determination, not mere opinion, because it mandated criminal prosecution and thus had the character of an order or decision. Consequently, the auditor’s report could not be excluded from revision jurisdiction under Section 154.

The Court further noted that the Society and the Petitioner were not given an opportunity under Section 82 to explain or rectify the alleged irregularities, which is a procedural lapse. The Revisional Authority’s refusal to entertain the Revision Application based on the non-maintainability of revision was inconsistent with the finding that the Society and its office bearers had defrauded depositors. The Court held that the Revisional Authority must have jurisdiction to examine the validity of such a decision or order.

Holding and Implications

The Court held that the auditor’s report concluding large-scale defrauding of depositors constitutes a decision/order under the MCS Act and is therefore revisable under Section 154 of the Act.

Accordingly, the impugned order dated 27th January 2023 rejecting the Revision Application is quashed and set aside. The Divisional Joint Registrar is directed to reconsider the Revision Application on its merits and in accordance with law, uninfluenced by prior observations on merits.

The direct effect is that the petitioner’s Revision Application must be heard and decided afresh, ensuring procedural fairness. No broader precedent beyond the immediate parties is expressly established by this decision.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    DAULATRAO SHANKARRAO THAKARE v. THE DIVISIONAL JOINT REGISTRAR COOPERATIVE SOCIETIES AN DANR

    15-WP-7692-2023.doc

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

    CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

    WRIT PETITION NO.7692 OF 2023

    Daulatrao Shankarrao Thakare Age : 63, Occ :, Agri., R/o 1963, Lonar Galli, Yeola, Dist, Nashik ...Petitioner

    Versus

    1. The Divisional Joint Registrar Co-operative Societies, Nashik Division, Nashik

    2. Sanjiv T. Shinde Auditor, Co-operative Societies, Yevala, Tq. : Yevala, Dist.: Nashik. R/o Bahuuddeshiya Sankul, Administrative Building, Kopargaon Road, Yevala, Tq. : Yevala, Dist.: Nashik.

    3. The District Deputy Registrar Co-operative Societies, Nashik, Dist. : Nashik ...Respondents ——————

    Adv. Nitin Gaware Patil a/w Jay Salunke for the Petitioner. Adv. P. J. Gavhane, AGP for the State.

    ——————

    Coram : Sharmila U. Deshmukh, J. Date : July 26, 2024.

    ORAL JUDGMENT:

    1. Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith and heard finally with consent of the parties.

    Harish 1 of 9 2024:BHC-AS:30921

    1

    2. By this Petition, the challenge is to the order dated 27thJanuary, 2023 passed by the Divisional Joint Registrar rejecting the Revision Application as not maintainable by holding that the auditor's report under Section 81(1)(a) of The Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 (MCS Act) is not a decision or order and thus, revision under Section 154 of MCS Act is not maintainable.

    3. The only issue arising for consideration is whether the Auditor's report under Section 81 of MCS Act is revisable under Section 154 of MCS Act.

    4. The facts required to be exposited is that vide order dated 31st March, 2022 passed under Section 102(2) of MCS Act, the District Deputy Registrar passed an interim order of liquidation and liquidator came to be appointed on Janta Nagari Sahakari Pathsanstha Ltd. (Panthsanstha). By order dated 6thMay, 2022 the District Deputy Registrar appointed Respondent No. 2 auditor to conduct audit of the Patsanstha for the years 2019-2020 to 2021-2022 under Section 81(1)

    (a) of MCS Act as it was held that despite communications, the Pathsanstha had not conducted the audit. Pursuant thereto, audit was conducted and the audit report was submitted on 16thSeptember, 2022 concluding that the managing committee members and other office bearers have accepted deposits beyond the permissible limits

    Harish 2 of 9

    2

    by luring depositors with higher rate of interest and have thereby cheated the depositors on large scale and are liable to face a criminal prosecution. Pursuant to the finding given by the auditor, FIR bearing Crime No. 302 of 2022 was registered against the Managing Committee Members under IPC and under Section 3 and 4 of the Maharashtra Protection of Interest of Depositors (In Financial Establishments Act, 1999).

    5. The auditor's report dated 16thSeptember, 2022 came to be challenged by way of Revision Application under Section 154 of the MCS before Divisional Joint Registrar who dismissed the Revision Application for the reason that the Auditor's Report is not a decision or order.

    6. Heard Mr. Patil learned counsel for the Petitioner and Ms. Gavhane learned AGP for the State.

    7. Mr. Patil, learned counsel for the Petitioner has taken this Court to the provisions of Section 81 of MCS Act and would submit that under sub section 6 of Section 81 of MCS Act, the Registrar has the power to direct re-audit of any accounts of Society and the provisions of Act applicable to the audit of the account shall apply to such re- audit. He submits that Section 82 of the MCS Act would be applicable and if any, defects are disclosed as result of the audit held

    Harish 3 of 9

    3

    under Section 81, the Society is to be given an opportunity of rectifying the defects and to remedy the irregularities. He submits that such an opportunity was not given to the Society of which the Petitioner was an office bearer and thus, the Revision Application came to be preferred under Section 154 of the MCS Act as there is no remedy of Appeal under Section 152 of the MCS Act. He submits that the audit report culminated into a decision that the depositors have been cheated and that the Petitioner is liable to face criminal prosecution and thus, satisfies the requirement of decision or order. He would further point out that under Section 154 of the MCS Act, the Registrar has the power to examine the record of any inquiry or proceeding wherein decision has been taken and in the present case, pursuant to the audit inquiry, decision has been taken by the auditor and therefore, the revision under Section 154 of the MCS Act was maintainable.

    8. Per contra, learned AGP would submit that auditor has pursuant to the directions under Section 81(1)(a) of MCS Act conducted the audit and no order has been passed and thus, in the absence of any decision or order, the provisions of Section 154 of the MCS Act are not applicable.

    9. Considered the submissions and perused the record.

    Harish 4 of 9

    4

    10. The facts are not disputed that an audit was ordered by the District Deputy Registrar under the provisions of Section 81(1)(a) of the MCS Act. The audit was duly conducted and the Auditor has arrived at a conclusion that the depositors of the Panthsanstha have been cheated and there is necessity of initiating criminal proceedings against the concerned office bearers of the Panthsanstha. No opportunity was given to the Society or the Petitioner to tender any explanation in respect of the irregularities and FIR has been lodged against the Petitioner and others.

    11. It will be apposite to refer to the relevant provisions of MCS Act. Section 81 (1) (e) of MCS Act provides that in case of financial irregularities, the auditor shall investigate and report the modus operandi, the entrustment and amount involved. The proviso to Section 5B of Section 81 of MCS Act provides that where the auditor comes to a conclusion in his audit report that any person is guilty of any offence relating to the accounts or any other offences, a specific report is required to be filed and the auditor concerned shall after obtaining permission of the Registrar file a First Information Report and if the Auditor fails to do so, the Registrar shall cause a First Information Report to be filed.

    12. Reading of the above stated provision will indicate that in event

    Harish 5 of 9

    5

    the Auditor comes to a conclusion that any person is guilty of any offence relating to accounts which is detected during the conduct of audit, duty is cast upon the auditor to set the criminal law in motion. Section 82 of MCS Act gives an opportunity to the Society to explain to the Registrar the irregularities pointed out by the Auditor. In the instant case, the Auditor has arrived at a conclusion that the office bearers of the Panthsanstha are guilty of falsification of accounts and have cheated the depositors and liable to face criminal prosecution.

    13. The issue is whether the conclusion recorded in the Auditor's report is a decision or order. The expression "decision" is of wide connotation and will have to be construed in the background of the relevant provisions of the applicable statute. Considered in the context of Section 81 (5B) of MCS Act, the conclusion of the Auditor amounts to determination of the issues whether there is falsification of account and whether any person is guilty of the offence relating to the accounts. In terms of Section 154 of MCS Act, the expression

    "decision" and "order" are synonymous and amounts to determination of an issue by the concerned authority. The conclusion of the Auditor determining that there is a falsification of account and fixing the responsibility on the concerned has the trappings of finality mandated by the statute. Notably, the conclusion is not an opinion or

    Harish 6 of 9

    6

    view of the Auditor but a final determination entailing stated criminal consequences. The conclusion of the Auditor is in the nature of a command or a direction intended to affect the rights of the parties.

    14. The decision of the Auditor under Section 81 of MCS Act charts the further course of action to be taken by the Auditor or in event of his failure by the Registrar. Where in pursuance of the conclusion of the Auditor further actions are mandated by the statutory provisions, the conclusion partakes the character of an order/decision. The conclusion arrived at by the auditor takes the proceeding out of the realm of an ordinary audit report and amounts to an order/decision directing the criminal prosecution which has in fact been lodged by auditor himself. The conclusion itself is an order/decision taken that there is financial fraud which necessitates initiation of criminal action. Such decision can be challenged only before the authorities constituted under the MCS Act.

    15. The Revisional Authority has declined to exercise the jurisdiction under Section 154 of MCS for the reason that the auditor's report is not a decision or order. Under Section 154 of MCS Act the revisional powers can be exercised by the State Government or Registrar calling for examining the record of any inquiry or proceedings of any matter other than those referred to sub section (9)

    Harish 7 of 9

    7

    of Section 149, where any decision or order has been passed by any subordinate officer.

    16. Considering the consequences provided under Section 81 (5B) of MCS Act, the authorities constituted under the MCS Act cannot decline to exercise the jurisdiction vested in it to examine the record of the inquiry or proceeding to test the validity of the decision or order.

    17. The report of the auditor as rightly pointed out by Mr. Patil was not submitted to the Society so as to enable the Society to either explain the irregularities alleged or to rectify the same under Section 82 of the MCS Act. Where the legality and propriety of the finding arrived at in the Auditor's report is itself sought to be challenged by the Petitioner, the same can be examined by exercising the revisionary power under Section 154 of the MCS Act. The Revisional Authority though held that the Revision Application is not maintainable has arrived at a finding based on the audit report that the Society and its office bearers have defrauded the depositors which is impermissible if the Revisional Authority has held not to have the jurisdiction.

    18. In view of the above, the Audit Report concluding that there is large scale defrauding of the depositors constitutes a decision/order

    Harish 8 of 9

    8

    of the Auditor which is revisable under Section 154 of MCS Act. Resultantly, the impugned order dated 27thJanuary, 2023 is hereby quashed and set aside. The Divisional Joint Registrar is directed to consider the Revision Application of the Petitioner on its own merits and in accordance with law and uninfluenced by the observations on merits recorded in the order of 27thJanuary, 2023.

    19. Resultantly, Petition succeeds. Rule is made absolute in above terms.

    [Sharmila U. Deshmukh, J.] Harish 9 of 9

    9

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    DAULATRAO SHANKARRAO THAKARE v. THE DIVISIONAL JOINT REGISTRAR COOPERATIVE SOCIETIES AN DANR
    (Jul 26, 2024)