Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2023 AHC 220646
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2023 AHC 220646
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 31.05.2022, the District Magistrate of Sonebhadra issued a show cause notice to the petitioner, Ramlala, alleging illegal excavation over Plot No.824 Kha based on an inspection report. The petitioner responded by stating that he held a lease for mining on Plot No.421 Ga, area 0.506 hectare, and was conducting mining activities only on that plot. However, the final order dated 20.06.2022 addressed illegal mining over Plot No.421 Kha, which differed from the plot mentioned in the show cause notice. The petitioner challenged this discrepancy, leading to the present writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an order passed on grounds or allegations different from those mentioned in the show cause notice is valid.
  2. Whether the show cause notice must clearly specify the subject matter and grounds of the action to enable the petitioner to effectively respond.
  3. Whether proceedings and orders based on a defective or unclear show cause notice are liable to be quashed.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The show cause notice pertained to Plot No.824 Kha, but the final order dealt with Plot No.421 Kha, which was not the subject of the notice.
  • If the show cause notice is defective or unclear regarding the subject matter, subsequent proceedings and orders are invalid.
  • The authority issuing the show cause notice must be clear about the subject of the notice; failure to do so renders the proceedings null and void.
  • Relied on the Supreme Court judgment in State of Punjab v. Davinder Pal Singh Bhullar and others (2011 (14) SCC 770) to argue that illegality at the initial stage vitiates all consequent proceedings.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The impugned order related to Plot No.421 Kha, and the petitioner participated in the proceedings and gave explanations.
  • There was no error in the impugned order, and the court should not interfere.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Punjab v. Davinder Pal Singh Bhullar and others; 2011 (14) SCC 770 Illegality at the initial stage vitiates all subsequent proceedings ("sublato fundamento cadit opus"). Used to emphasize that a defective show cause notice invalidates subsequent orders and proceedings.
Badrinath v. State of Tamil Nadu & Ors., AIR 2000 SC 3243 Once the basis of a proceeding is gone, all consequential acts and orders fall automatically. Supported the principle that initial invalidity nullifies subsequent actions.
State of Kerala v. Puthenkavu N.S.S. Karayogam & Anr., (2001) 10 SCC 191 Same as above regarding invalidity of subsequent proceedings. Reinforced the principle of nullity of proceedings founded on an invalid initial action.
Mangal Prasad Tamoli (dead) by Lrs. v. Narvadeshwar Mishra (dead) by Lrs. & Ors., (2005) 3 SCC 422 Orders bad in law at initial stage render all further proceedings non est. Applied to hold that defective initial order invalidates all consequent proceedings.
C. Albert Morris v. K. Chandrasekaran & Ors., (2006) 1 SCC 228 A legal right exists only when it has lawful origin. Used to underline the necessity of lawful foundation for orders.
Commissioner Of Customs, Mumbai v. Toyo Engineering India Ltd., (2006) 7 SCC 592 The Revenue cannot go beyond the grounds mentioned in the show cause notice. Established that the case must be founded on the show cause notice; otherwise, the proceedings are invalid.
Commissioner of Central Excise, Bhubaneshwar v. Champdany Industries Ltd., (2009) 9 SCC 466 Points not mentioned in the show cause notice cannot be argued or relied upon later. Confirmed that the foundation of the case must be laid in the show cause notice.
Commissioner of Central Excise, Chandigarh v. Shital International, (2011) 1 SCC 109 Revenue cannot build a new case against the assessee not founded in the show cause notice. Reiterated that fresh pleas or contradictory stands not in the show cause notice are impermissible.
The Board of High School and Intermediate Education, U.P. v. Kumari Chitra Srivastava and Others; 1970 (1) SCC 121 Principles of natural justice, including audi alteram partem, must be followed even if burdensome. Supported the requirement that the noticee must be given a fair opportunity to respond to allegations.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the discrepancy between the show cause notice and the final order. The notice directed the petitioner to respond to allegations concerning illegal mining over Plot No.824 Kha, whereas the final order addressed Plot No.421 Kha. The court emphasized settled legal principles requiring that a show cause notice clearly specify the grounds and subject matter of the action to enable the affected party to present an effective defense, in line with the principles of natural justice (audi alteram partem).

The court relied extensively on Supreme Court precedents establishing that if the foundation of the case (the show cause notice) is defective or unclear, all subsequent proceedings and orders based on it are invalid. The rationale is to prevent authorities from extending punishment beyond what was communicated in the notice, which would violate natural justice by denying the noticee a fair opportunity to respond to new or different allegations.

Given that the show cause notice and the final order concerned different plots, the court found the notice to be badly drafted and incomplete, and the order inherently misconceived as it went beyond the scope of the notice. Consequently, both the show cause notice and the order were quashed.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is allowed.

The court quashed and set aside the show cause notice dated 31.05.2022 and the order dated 20.06.2022 on the ground of fundamental defect in the notice and consequent invalidity of the order. The District Magistrate, Sonebhadra is permitted to initiate fresh proceedings in accordance with law. The decision directly affects the parties by invalidating the impugned proceedings but does not establish any new precedent beyond reaffirming established principles regarding the necessity of clarity in show cause notices and adherence to natural justice.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Ramlala v. State Of U.P. And 4 Others

    AFR

    Neutral Citation No. - 2023:AHC:220646-DB

    Court No. - 3 Case :- WRIT - C No. - 31059 of 2023

    Petitioner :- Ramlala

    Respondent :- State Of U.P. And 4 Others

    Counsel for Petitioner :- Shailesh Kumar Pathak

    Counsel for Respondent :- C.S.C

    Hon'ble Siddhartha Varma,J. Hon'ble Shekhar B. Saraf,J.

    1. Heard learned counsel for petitioner and learned Chief Standing Counsel for the State.

    2. On 31.05.2022, the District Magistrate, Sonebhadra, based on some inspection report, issued a show cause notice as to why the petitioner may not be punished for having excavated over Plot No.824 Kha. The petitioner replied to the said notice and submitted that he had a lease of mining work with regard to Plot No.421 Ga area 0.506 hectare and he also submitted that the petitioner was continuing with the mining work on the aforesaid plot alone. However, when final order dated 20.6.2022 was passed, it dealt with illegal mining over Plot No.421 Kha, which was definitely not the subject matter of the show cause notice dated

    31.05.2022.

    3. Learned counsel for the petitioner states that since the show cause notice was with regard to Plot No.824 Kha, the order ought to have been dealt with illegal mining over Plot No.824 Kha and no other plot. He has relied upon a judgment of Supreme Court rendered in the case of State of Punjab v. Davinder Pal Singh Bhullar and others; 2011 (14) SCC 770

    and submitted that if the show cause notice is defective then the consequential proceedings cannot stand. He further submits that if the show cause notice was with regard to some other plot and the punishment is being imposed with regard to some other plot then it would be deemed that the authority, which had issued the show cause notice, was not clear

    1

    of the subject matter and, therefore, when there is no clarity in the show cause notice itself, the authority which has passed the impugned order could not have passed the same with regard to some other plot. Learned counsel for the petitioner also states that when final order mentioned some other plot and the show cause notice mentioned some other plot then the entire proceedings were null and void.

    4. Learned Chief Standing Counsel Sri Sandeep Kumar Singh, however, submits that the order impugned was passed with regard to Plot No.421 Kha and during the proceedings the petitioner had participated and given explanation, therefore, there was no error in the order impugned and this Court may not interfere with the same.

    5. Learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon the judgment of Supreme Court in Davinder Pal Singh Bhullar's case (supra) to buttress his arguments in relation to the above submissions. He placed reliance on paragraph Nos.107 to 110 of the said judgment, which are extracted as under:

    "107. It is a settled legal proposition that if initial action is not in consonance with law, all subsequent and consequential proceedings would fall through for the reason that illegality strikes at the root of the order. In such a fact-situation, the legal maxim "sublato fundamento cadit opus" meaning thereby that foundation being removed, structure/work falls, comes into play and applies on all scores in the present case.

    108. In Badrinath v. State of Tamil Nadue & Ors., AIR 2000 SC 3243; and State of Kerala v. Puthenkavu N.S.S. Karayogam & Anr., (2001) 10 SCC 191, this Court observed that once the basis of a proceeding is gone, all consequential acts, actions, orders would fall to the ground automatically and this principle is applicable to judicial, quasi-judicial and administrative proceedings equally.

    2 of 6

    109. Similarly in Mangal Prasad Tamoli (dead) by Lrs. v. Narvadeshwar Mishra (dead) by Lrs. & Ors., (2005) 3 SCC 422, this Court held that if an order at the initial stage is bad in law, then all further proceedings, consequent thereto, will be non est and have to be necessarily set aside.

    110. In C. Albert Morris v. K. Chandrasekaran & Ors., (2006) 1 SCC 228, this Court held that a right in law exists only and only when it has a lawful origin.

    (See also: Upen Chandra Gogoi v. State of Assam & Ors., (1998) 3 SCC 381; Satchidananda Misra v. State of Orissa & Ors., (2004) 8 SCC 599; Regional Manager, Sbi v. Rakesh Kumar Tewari ., (2006) 1 SCC 530; and Ritesh Tewari & Anr. v. State of U.P. & Ors., AIR 2010 SC 3823)."

    6. It may further be noted that the Supreme Court in a catena of judgments has held that the grounds, upon which the action is to be taken against a person, are required to be mentioned in the show cause notice. In

    Commissioner Of Customs, Mumbai v. Toyo Engineering India Ltd. ., (2006) 7 SCC 592, the Supreme Court has held has under:

    "16. Learned counsel for the Revenue tried to raise some of the submissions which were not allowed to be raised by the Tribunal before us, as well. We agree with the Tribunal that the Revenue could not be allowed to raise these submissions for the first time in the second appeal before the Tribunal. Neither the adjudicating authority nor the Appellate Authority had denied the facility of the project import to the respondent on any of these grounds. These grounds did not find mention in the show- cause notice as well. The Department cannot travel beyond the show-cause notice. Even in the grounds of appeals these points have not been taken."

    3 of 6

    7. Furthermore, in Commissioner of Central Excise, Bhubaneshwar v. Champdany Industries Ltd., (2009) 9 SCC 466, the Supreme Court has held as under:

    "38. Apart from that, the point on Rule 3 which has been argued by the learned counsel for the Revenue was not part of its case in the show-cause notice. It is well settled that unless the foundation of the case is made out in the show-cause notice, the Revenue cannot in Court argue a case not made out in its show- cause notice. (See Commr. of Customs v. Toyo Engg. India Ltd. [(2006) 7 SCC 592] ) Similar view was expressed by this Court in CCE v. Ballarpur Industries Ltd. [(2007) 8 SCC 89] In para 27 of the said Report, learned Judges made it clear that if there is no invocation of the Rules concerned in the show-cause notice, it would not be open to the Commissioner to invoke the said Rules."

    8. Finally, one may take further recourse to the judgment of the Supreme Court in Commissioner of Central Excise, Chandigarh v. Shital International, (2011) 1 SCC 109. Relevant paragraph of the said judgment is delineated below:

    "19. As regards the process of electrifying polish, now pressed into service by the Revenue, it is trite law that unless the foundation of the case is laid in the show-cause notice, the Revenue cannot be permitted to build up a new case against the assessee. (See Commr. of Customs v. Toyo Engg. India Ltd. [(2006) 7 SCC 592] , CCE v. Ballarpur Industries Ltd. [(2007) 8 SCC 89] and CCE v. Champdany Industries Ltd. [(2009) 9 SCC 466] ) Admittedly, in the instant case, no such objection was raised by the adjudicating authority in the show-cause notice dated 22-6-2001 relating to Assessment Years 1988-1989 to 2000-2001. However, in the show-cause notice dated 12-12-2000, the process of electrifying polish finds

    4 of 6

    a brief mention. Therefore, in the light of the settled legal position, the plea of the learned counsel for the Revenue in that behalf cannot be entertained as the Revenue cannot be allowed to raise a fresh plea, which has not been raised in the show- cause notice nor can it be allowed to take contradictory stands in relation to the same assessee."

    9. The principle that emerges from the above judgements is patently clear that a show cause notice is required to provide details of the nature of the offence and the grounds on which the show cause notice has been issued. Furthermore, the order that is subsequently passed, based on the show cause notice, cannot go beyond the said show cause notice and cannot in any manner penalise the noticee on grounds that were not stated in the show cause notice.

    10. The rationale for not allowing the respondents from going beyond the realm of the show cause notice is that the petitioner has to be given a chance to put up his case with regard to the said show cause notice. In the event, a particular case is made out in the show cause notice and the order passed subsequently is beyond the said show cause notice, the same would amount to violation of the principles of natural justice, as the petitioner would not have been aware of the new grounds or new factual elements and could never have placed his case for the above before the authority concerned. It is in this background that the Supreme Court in umpteen judgments has laid down the law that an order passed by an authority cannot go beyond the scope of the show cause notice. In fact, the Supreme Court in the case of

    The Board of High School and Intermediate Education, U.P. and Others

    v. Kumari Chitra Srivastava and Others; 1970 (1) SCC 121 has categorically stated that the principles of audi alteram partem are required to be followed even if the same is burdensome in nature. Justice S.M. Sikri in his inimitable style stated as follows:

    "Principles of natural justice are to some minds burdensome but this price - a small price indeed - has to be paid if we desire a society governed by the rule of law."

    5 of 6

    11. Having heard learned counsel for the parties, we find that in the show cause notice dated 31.5.2022, the District Magistrate, Sonebhadra had directed the petitioner to show cause with regard to the illegal mining over Plot No.824 Kha but when the order impugned was passed we find that it is with regard to Plot No.421Kha. We also find that the plot, which was mentioned in the show cause notice, had no bearing with the order impugned in the instant writ petition. In the light of above, it is crystal clear that not only is show cause notice badly drafted and incomplete but also the order passed subsequently is inherently misconceived going way beyond the show cause notice issued. Ergo, show cause notice dated 31.05.2022 and the order dated 20.6.2022 are quashed and set aside.

    12. Needless to mention, it shall be open to the District Magistrate, Sonebhadra to initiate the proceedings afresh in accordance with law.

    13. With these observations, the writ petition is allowed.

    Order Date :- 21.11.2023 Kuldeep

    6 of 6

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ramlala v. State Of U.P. And 4 Others
    (Nov 21, 2023)