AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Acts
  • SECTION 2 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT
  • U/s. 35 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019
  • u/s 34 of the Consumer Protection Act,
  • provision of 69 (2) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Acts
  • SECTION 2 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT
  • U/s. 35 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019
  • u/s 34 of the Consumer Protection Act,
  • provision of 69 (2) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019
Smart Summary

Case Summary: District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Hooghly — Complaint Case No. CC/78/2021

Factual and Procedural Background

Complainant: Prodipta Halder (resident of Narua Panchanantala, Chandannagore, Hooghly). Opposite Parties: two entries for "Shine Job Consultancy Company" with addresses in Gurgaon (BPTP Park, Sector 30) and Kolkata (Prafulla Sarkar Street, Park Street).

Relevant facts as alleged by the complainant: The complainant received phone calls (from numbers 9568954171 and 8178474787) from a person named Kunal of Shine Job Consultancy, who advised the complainant to take paid services that would increase chances of obtaining a job and promised to send the resume to 1,000 companies and secure interview calls within 15 days. The complainant availed paid services through shine.com on 27.10.2020 and paid several specified fees that day totalling Rs. 21,945 (registration, education verification, employment fee, career assessment with expert counselling). After about a month with no interview calls, on 25.11.2020 a representative apologized and offered a refund of Rs.21,945 but said the complainant must submit an online complaint form and pay Rs.10. When attempting payment, the complainant received an OTP but, instead of Rs.10 being debited, Rs.22,000 was debited on 27.11.2020 (transaction details given in the record). The complainant alleges the total taken by shine.com was Rs.21,945 + Rs.22,000 = Rs.43,945, constituting unfair trade practice, fraud and deviation of service. The complainant lodged a general diary at Chandannagore P.S. (GD Entry No.1364/2020 dated 28.11.2020) and later sent written complaints to the police (dated 18.1.2021), but alleges no action was taken.

Procedural history: The complaint was filed under Section 35 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 (Complaint Case No. CC/78/2021, filed 28 Apr 2021). The complainant sought refund of Rs.43,945 and multiple heads of compensation (Rs.5,00,000; Rs.3,00,000; Rs.2,00,000) plus litigation costs. The matter proceeded ex parte against the opposite parties by order no.6 dated 21.12.2021. The opposite parties filed an ex parte set-aside petition which was rejected by order no.22 dated 14.12.2022. Subsequently the opposite parties filed evidence on affidavit denying the material allegations. The Commission heard the complainant's evidence on affidavit (replicating the complaint) and written arguments and ultimately delivered a final order dated 01 Dec 2023.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the complainant is the consumer of the opposite parties or not?
  2. Whether this Forum/Commission has territorial/pecuniary jurisdiction to entertain and try the case?
  3. Is there any cause of action for filing this case by the complainant?
  4. Whether there is any deficiency of service on the part of the opposite parties?
  5. Whether the complainant is entitled to get the relief which has been prayed by the complainant in this case or not?

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Framing and approach: The Commission combined the first three issues (consumer status, jurisdiction/maintainability, and cause of action) for initial discussion because they related to the threshold question of whether the case could be heard. The Commission then addressed issues 4 and 5 together (deficiency of service and entitlement to relief) because they were interlinked.

Threshold issues (consumer status; jurisdiction; cause of action):

  • The opposite parties, despite receiving notice, did not file a written statement or a petition contesting maintainability, jurisdiction or cause of action; the Commission noted the opposite parties' failure to raise those points formally.
  • Territorial jurisdiction: The Commission found the complainant to be a resident of Chandannagore, Hooghly, which lies within the territorial jurisdiction of the District Commission, and therefore territorial jurisdiction was satisfied.
  • Pecuniary jurisdiction: The claim was for below Rs.50 lakhs, placing the matter within the pecuniary jurisdiction of the District Commission under the Consumer Protection Act framework (the Commission references its jurisdiction under Section 34 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019).
  • Limitation: Although limitation was raised, the Commission considered Section 69(2) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 (permitting the District/State/National Commission to entertain complaints after two years if sufficient cause is shown) and observed that the cause of action was continuing; the complainant's pleadings were found to disclose sufficient grounds to entertain the complaint despite the limitation challenge.
  • Consumer status: Applying Section 2(1)(e) and Section 2(7) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 as relevant to the pleadings, the Commission concluded the complainant qualified as a "consumer" in law.
  • Conclusion on threshold: The Commission held that the complaint was maintainable, the complainant was a consumer, there was a cause of action, and the Commission had territorial and pecuniary jurisdiction. These three points were decided in favour of the complainant.

Merits issues (deficiency of service; entitlement to relief):

  • Evidence assessment: The complainant filed evidence on affidavit replicating the complaint and produced supporting documents. The opposite parties did not cross-examine or otherwise controvert that evidence in a manner that challenged its truthfulness; while the opposite parties filed evidence on affidavit denying the allegations, the complainant's evidence remained unchallenged and uncontroverted on material points.
  • Credibility and proof: The Commission found no reason to disbelieve the unchallenged testimony and documentary material of the complainant, and concluded that the complainant had proved a case of deficiency/failure in service regarding the payments and the alleged wrongful debiting of funds.
  • Relief for non-pecuniary loss: The Commission found that the complainant failed to produce sufficient evidence to substantiate claims for mental agony or similar heads of compensation; accordingly, the Commission declined to grant compensation for mental loss or agony.
  • Net result on merits: The Commission accepted the complainant's case in part — finding deficiency of service proved and entitlement to monetary relief for the amounts due — but rejected the higher compensation claims on the evidence presented.

All conclusions above are drawn strictly from the record and reasoning set out by the District Commission in its final order dated 01 Dec 2023.

Holding and Implications

Core holding: The complaint (Complaint Case No. 78 of 2021) was allowed ex parte but only in part.

Direct orders and immediate consequences:

  • Opposite Party Nos. 1 and 2 were directed to pay the amount of Rs. 49,945 (as stated in the order) together with interest at the rate of 9% per annum within 60 days from the date of the order (01 Dec 2023). If payment is not made within that period, the complainant is given liberty to execute the order as per law.
  • In the event of non-payment or non-compliance, the opposite parties are additionally directed to pay or deposit Rs. 5,000 into the Consumer Legal Aid Account of the DCDRC, Hooghly (to be utilized for the purpose of assisting poor litigants/public).
  • A plain copy of the order was to be supplied free of cost to the parties/their advocates/agents on record by hand under acknowledgement or sent by ordinary post for information and necessary action. The final order is to be made available on the website www.confonet.nic.in.

Broader implications: The Commission did not indicate that this decision was intended to set any new legal precedent. The ruling effects a partial monetary recovery for the complainant and affirms that unchallenged affidavit evidence and documentary proof can sustain a consumer claim even where the opposite party does not effectively contest maintainability, jurisdiction, or the material facts. The order denies the substantial compensation claims for mental agony due to insufficient evidentiary support.

Order signed by: Hon'ble Mr. Debasish Bandyopadhyay (President), Hon'ble Mrs. Babita Choudhuri (Member), Hon'ble Mr. Debasis Bhattacharya (Member).

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    PRODIPTA HALDER v. SHINE JOB CONSULTANCY COMPANY

    DISTRICT CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION, HOOGHLY

    CC OF 2021

    PETITIONER

    VERS

    OPPOSITE PARTY

    Complaint Case No. CC/78/2021 ( Date of Filing : 28 Apr 2021 )

    1. PRODIPTA HALDER

    NARUA PANCHANANTALA, P.S. AND P.O.- CHANDANNAGAR, HOOGHLY-712136

    HOOGHLY

    WEST BENGAL ...........Complainant(s) Versus

    1. SHINE JOB CONSULTANCY COMPANY

    BPTP PARK, CENTRA BUILDING, SEC-30, GURGAON, HARYANA-122001

    GURGAON

    HARYANA

    2. SHINE JOB CONSULTANCY COMPANY

    PRAFULLLA SARKAR STREET, PARK STREET,

    KOLKATA-700001

    KOLKATA

    WEST BENGAL ............Opp.Party(s)

    BEFORE:

    HON'BLE MR. Debasish Bandyopadhyay PRESIDENT HON'BLE MRS. Babita Choudhuri MEMBER HON'BLE MR. Debasis Bhattacharya MEMBER

    PRESENT:

    Dated : 01 Dec 2023 Final Order / Judgement

    Presented by:-

    Shri Debasish Bandyopadhyay, President.

    Brief fact of this case:- This case has been filed U/s. 35 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 by the complainant stating that Shine.com called the complainant from phone no.9568954171 and another phone no.8178474787 by a person namely Kunal, from Shaine Job Consultancy and advice complainant to avail paid services which will increase immense potentiality to get a suitable job and further promise the petitioner that if he avail the same then his resume will be send to 1000 companies and he will get plenty of relevant job interview calls within 15 days.

    1

    Complainant as job seeker believed the same and availed for the paid service from online job portal shine.com a job consultancy firm, on 27.10.2020 with a belief that he will get a job very soon. The above named online job portal shine.com demanded Rs.3657/- from the petitioner as registration fees to avail their paid services and the petitioner paid the same on 27.10.2020. The above named online job portal shine.com demanded Rs.5192/- for education verification and the petitioner paid the same on 27.10.2020. The above named online job portal shine.com demanded Rs.4837/- for employment the petitioner paid the same on 27.10.2020. The above named online job portal shine.com demanded Rs.8259/- for Career assessment test with expert counseling and the petitioner paid the same on 27.10.2020. The above named online job portal shine.com in total charged Rs.21945/- from the petitioner on 27.10.2020 to avail the opportunity of their paid services by the petitioner. Even after elapsing one month that is from the date of 27.10.2020 of availing paid services from online job portal "shine.com" no interview call was received by the petitioner and then suddenly on 25.11.2020 one person from shine.com called the complainant and apologized for their failure to provide the service to the complainant and told for that reason they want to refund the above said total amount Rs.21945/- but further said that to get refund the petitioner has to submit online complain form available at their website to lodge a complaint by paying Rs.10/- in on line mode. For paying Rs.10/- in online mode through "bill desk" to the shine.com the petitioner had to entered his debit card number and according to the system he received an OTP but after entering the OTP instead of deducting Rs.10/- from the SBI savings bank A/c of the petitioner Rs.22000/- had been debited or deducted on 27.11.2020 vide transaction ID INB

    IMPS/P2A/033211886659/XXXXXX095PYTM e CHQ:MOADOTMJG4. The above named online job portal shine.com in total taken Rs.21945/- +22000 = 43945/- which is utterly an example of unfair trade practice, fraud and deviation of service. The above said all the bank transactions were held by the SBI savings Bank A/c no.39146662223 of Chandannagar branch. The complainant lodged a general diary at Chandannagore P.S. by informing the above said matter vide G.D. Entry no. 1364/2020 dt. 28.11.2020 but the police took no action in view of the above said general /diary. Then the complainant further sent a written complaint by post to the Commissioner of Chandannagore Police and Inspector In-Charge of Chandannagore P.S. dt. 18.1.2021 but no action yet taken.

    Complainant filed the complaint petition praying direction upon the opposite parties to pay a sum of Rs. 43,945/- with interest and to pay a sum of Rs. 5,00,000/- for negligent service and unfair trade practice and to pay a sum of Rs. 3,00,000/- for loss of the precious time and to pay a sum of Rs. 2,00,000/- for negligent and fraudulent service and to pay a sum of Rs. 50,000/- as litigation cost.

    Defense Case:- This case is running ex parte against the opposite party vide order no. 6 dt. 21.12.2021. After that op had filed one ex parte set aside petition which was rejected vide order no. 22 dt. 14.12.2022 but the op by filing evidence on affidavit denying inter-alia all the material allegation as leveled against them and prayed for dismissal of this case.

    Issues/points for consideration

    On the basis of the pleading of the parties, the District Commission for the interest of proper and complete adjudication of this case is going to adopt the following points for consideration:-

    Whether the complainant is the consumer of the opposite parties or not?1.

    2

    Whether this Forum/ Commission has territorial/pecuniary jurisdiction to entertain and try the case?

    2.

    Is there any cause of action for filing this case by the complainant?3. Whether there is any deficiency of service on the part of the opposite parties?4. Whether the complainant is entitled to get relief which has been prayed by the complainant in this case or not?

    5.

    Evidence on record

    The complainant filed evidence on affidavit which is nothing but replica of complaint petition and supports the averments of the complainant in the complaint petition.

    Argument highlighted by the ld. Lawyers of the parties

    Complainant filed written notes of argument. As per BNA the evidence on affidavit and written notes of argument of complainant are to be taken into consideration for passing final order.

    Argument as advanced by the agent of the complainant heard in full. In course of argument ld. Lawyer of complainant has given emphasis on evidence and document produced by parties.

    DECISIONS WITH REASONS

    The first three issues/ points of consideration which have been framed on the ground of maintainability and/ or jurisdiction, cause of action and whether complainant is a consumer in the eye of law, are very vital issues and so these three points of consideration are clubbed together and taken up for discussion jointly at first.

    Regarding these three points of consideration it is very important to note that the opposite parties inspite of receiving notice have not filed any W/V and also have not filed any petition on the ground of nonmaitainability of this case due to the reason best known to them. Under this position this District Commission has passed the order of further hearing of this case. On this background it is also mention worthy that the opposite parties also have not filed any separate petition challenging the maintainability point, jurisdiction point and cause of action issue. This District Commission after going through the materials of the case record finds that the complainant is a resident of Chandernagore, Hooghly which is lying within the territorial jurisdiction of this District Commission. Moreover, this complaint case has been filed with a claim of below 50 lakhs and this matter is clearly indicating that this District Commission has also pecuniary jurisdiction to try this case. Moreover, u/s 34 of the Consumer Protection Act, this District Commission has jurisdiction to try this case. It has been pointed out that this case is barred by limitation. But in this connection it is important to note that the provision of 69

    (2) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 is very important and according to the provision of Section 69 complaint case can be entertained by the District Commission or State Commission or National Commission even after expiry of 2 years if the complainant satisfies the ld. Commission that he or she has sufficient ground for not filing the case within two years. Moreover in this instant case the cause of action has been continued and thus on close examination of the pleadings of the complainant it also transpires that there is cause of action

    3

    for filing this case by the complainant side against the opposite parties. Moreover after going through the provisions of Section 2 (1) (e) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 it appears that this case is maintainable and according to the provision of Section 2 (7) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019. Complainant is a consumer in the eye of law. All these factors are clearly depicting that this case is maintainable and complainant is a consumer of the opposite parties and this District Commission has territorial/ pecuniary jurisdiction to entertain and try this case and there is also cause of action for filing this case by the complainant against the opposite parties. Thus, the above noted three points of consideration are decided in favour of the complainant.

    The point no. 4 is related with the question as to whether there is any deficiency in the service on the part of the opposite parties or not? The point no. 5 is connected with the question as to whether the complainant is entitled to get any relief in this case or not? These two pints of consideration are interlinked and/ or interconnected with each other and for that reason these two points of consideration are clubbed together and taken up for discussion jointly. For the purpose of deciding the fate of these two points of consideration and for the interest of getting answers of the above noted questions, there is necessity of scanning the evidence on affidavit filed by the complainant and there is also necessity making scrutiny of the documents filed by the petitioner of this case.

    For the purpose of arriving at just and proper decision in respect of points of consideration nos. 4 and 5 this District Commission finds that there is necessity of making scrutiny of the evidence given by the complainant. In this regard it is important to note that the ops have not filed any W/V but filed evidence on affidavit to disprove the case of the complainant. On close examination of the evidence given by the complainant side it is revealed that the complainant has categorically described his case in the evidence and the evidence given by the complainant is also supported by documents. It is also revealed that the evidence (oral and documentary) which is given by the complainant side remains unchallenged and/ or uncontroverted as no cross examination has been highlighted in this case by the ops. After going through the materials of this case record this District Commission finds that there is reason to disbelieve the unchallenged and uncontroverted testimony of the complainant side. It also transpires that the complainant has proved his case by way of adducing evidence in connection with the points of consideration nos. 4 and 5 which have been adopted in this case. But fact remains that the complainant has failed to produce sufficient evidence to show that he has suffered mental loss and agony for which he has the ground of claiming compensation. So this District Commission is not at all inclined to pass any order in respect of granting compensation.

    All the above noted factors are clearly reflecting that the complainant is entitled to get relief in this case but in part which has been prayed by this District Commission. In the result it is accordingly

    ordered

    4

    that the complaint case being no. 78 of 2021 be and the same is allowed ex parte but in part. Opposite party nos. 1 and 2 are directed to pay the amount of Rs.49945/-alongwith interest at the rate of 9% per annum within 60 days from the date of this order otherwise complainant is given liberty to execute this order as per law.

    In the event of nonpayment/ non compliance of the above noted direction the opposite party nos. 1 and 2 are also directed to pay and/ or deposit Rs. 5000/- in the Consumer Legal Aid Account of D.C.D.R.C., Hooghly which is to be utilized for the purpose of poor litigant public. Let a plain copy of this order be supplied free of cost to the parties/their ld. Advocates/Agents on record by hand under proper acknowledgement/ sent by ordinary post for information and necessary action.

    The Final Order will be available in the following website www.confonet.nic.in.

    [HON'BLE MR. Debasish Bandyopadhyay]

    PRESIDENT

    [HON'BLE MRS. Babita Choudhuri]

    MEMBER

    [HON'BLE MR. Debasis Bhattacharya]

    MEMBER

    5

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    PRODIPTA HALDER v. SHINE JOB CONSULTANCY COMPANY
    (Dec 1, 2023)