Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Acts
  • SECTION 126 EVIDENCE ACT
  • u/s 8 (1) (h) of the RTI Act, 2005
  • Section 8 (1) (e) of the RTI Act, 2005. Decision
  • section 8 (1) (e) & (h) of RTI Act 2005
  • u/s 126 of the Advocates Act, 1961
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Acts
  • SECTION 126 EVIDENCE ACT
  • u/s 8 (1) (h) of the RTI Act, 2005
  • Section 8 (1) (e) of the RTI Act, 2005. Decision
  • section 8 (1) (e) & (h) of RTI Act 2005
  • u/s 126 of the Advocates Act, 1961
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, Shri Surender Punyani, filed an RTI application dated 28.04.2022 seeking information related to his complaint dated 24.09.2020 concerning criminal conspiracy and cheating against Ashish Gupta and Nancy Gupta. The information sought included: (1) copies of note sheets and inquiry reports made by investigating officers and recommendations by senior officers; (2) a copy of the legal opinion sought from the Chief Public Prosecutor (Chief P.P.); and (3) certification of all documents supplied under the RTI Act.

The Public Information Officer (PIO), Addl. DCP, New Delhi District, responded on 25.05.2022 refusing to provide the information citing exemptions under Sections 8(1)(e) and 8(1)(h) of the RTI Act, 2005, relating to fiduciary relationships and information that would impede investigation or prosecution. Dissatisfied, the appellant filed a First Appeal on 22.06.2022. The First Appellate Authority (FAA) upheld the PIO’s decision by order dated 18.07.2022. Subsequently, the appellant filed the instant Second Appeal received on 22.08.2022 before the Central Information Commission.

During the hearing on 05.12.2023, the appellant stated that information on points 1 and 2 had not been provided. The respondent representatives stated that the investigation was completed and the inquiry report was handed over to the appellant during the hearing. However, the legal opinion was withheld as privileged communication under Section 8(1)(e) of the RTI Act.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the inquiry report and related documents sought under the RTI Act can be disclosed to the appellant after completion of the investigation.
  2. Whether the legal opinion sought from the Chief Public Prosecutor is exempt from disclosure under Section 8(1)(e) of the RTI Act as privileged communication.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Information on points 1 and 2 regarding the inquiry report, recommendations by senior officers, and legal opinion sought on his complaint had not been provided till date.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Exemption was initially claimed under Section 8(1)(h) of the RTI Act as the investigation was pending.
  • The investigation has since been completed and the inquiry report with relevant file notings has been provided to the appellant during the hearing.
  • The legal opinion is a privileged communication between the department and their advocate and is exempt from disclosure under Section 8(1)(e) of the RTI Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Union of India vs. Subhash Chandra Agrawal, LPA 168/2015 & C.M.No.5470/2015 and Union of India vs. R.K. Jain, LPA 199/2015 & C.M.No.6347/2015 (Delhi High Court, 03.02.2017) Interpretation of Section 126 of the Evidence Act regarding privileged professional communication. Used to affirm that legal opinions between advocates and clients are privileged and exempt under Section 8(1)(e) of the RTI Act.
Central Board of Secondary Education & Anr. vs. Aditya Bandopadhyay & Ors., (2011) 8 SCC 497 Definition and scope of fiduciary relationships under Section 8(1)(e) of the RTI Act. Clarified the nature of fiduciary relationships and limited the scope of information exempted under RTI.
Kokkanda B. Poondacha & Ors. vs. K.D. Ganapathi & Anr., (2011) 12 SCC 600 Nature of lawyer-client relationship as fiduciary and the duty of confidentiality. Reinforced that lawyers owe a duty of utmost good faith and confidentiality to clients, supporting exemption of legal opinions.
Superintendent and Remembrancer of Legal Affairs, West Bengal vs. Satyen Bhowmick & Ors., AIR 1981 SCC 917 Privilege under Section 126 of the Evidence Act relating to lawyer’s refusal to disclose confidential documents. Affirmed the right of lawyers to claim privilege over confidential communications and documents.
Reserve Bank of India & Ors. vs. Jayantilal N. Mistry & Ors., (2016) 3 SCC 525 Definition and recognition of fiduciary relationships in various contexts. Emphasized the fiduciary nature of lawyer-client relationships and the duty to maintain confidentiality.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Commission noted that the inquiry report and related file notings had been handed over to the appellant during the hearing, thereby addressing the first point of the RTI application. For the second point, the Commission relied on the settled legal position that communications between an advocate and client are privileged under Section 126 of the Evidence Act, 1961, and exempt from disclosure under Section 8(1)(e) of the RTI Act, 2005. The Commission extensively referenced authoritative judgments clarifying the fiduciary nature of the lawyer-client relationship and the scope of exemption under the RTI Act. The court concluded that the legal opinion sought qualifies as privileged communication and is therefore not subject to disclosure. Consequently, the Commission found that an appropriate response had been provided in accordance with the RTI Act.

Holding and Implications

The Second Appeal is disposed of.

The direct effect of this decision is that the appellant has received the inquiry report and related documents, but the legal opinion sought remains exempt from disclosure as privileged communication under the RTI Act. The Commission’s order affirms established legal principles regarding fiduciary relationships and privilege without creating new precedent or requiring further intervention.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Surender Punyani v. Delhi Police

    Page 1 of 6

    केीयेेे सचूनाूूू आयोग Central Information Commission बाबागगंनाथमागं ं ं , मिुनरकाुुु Baba Gangnath Marg, Munirka नईदली, New Delhi - 110067 ितीय अपील सं या / Second Appeal No. CIC/DEPOL/A/2022/138423

    Shri Surender Punyani … अपीलकता/Appellant VERSUS/बनाम

    PIO, New Delhi District, Delhi Police … ितवादीगण /Respondent Date of Hearing : 05.12.2023

    Date of Decision : 05.12.2023

    Chief Information Commissioner : Shri Heeralal Samariya Relevant facts emerging from appeal:

    RTI application filed on : 28.04.2022 PIO replied on : 25.05.2022 First Appeal filed on : 22.06.2022 First Appellate Order on : 18.07.2022 2ndAppeal/complaint received on : 22.08.2022

    Information sought and background of the case:

    The Appellant filed an RTI application dated 28.04.2022 seeking information on his complaint dated 24.09.2020 regarding criminal conspiracy and cheating etc. against Ashish Gupta and his wife Nancy Gupta on the following 03 points:-

    "

    1. Copies of Note sheet on which inquiry report made by the then I.O. S.I. Devender now S.I. Mohit and recommendations made by the senior officers like SHO/ CP, ACP/CP, DCP/ NDD and JT./CP/NDR may be supplied duly certified.

    2. A copy of legal opinion sought for into the complaint from chief P.P. as intimated by the than ACP/CP Mr. Jain, may also be supplied duly certified.

    3. All documents which are to be supplied under RTI Act should be certified by a G.Cs."

    The PIO/Addl. DCP, New Delhi District, vide letter dated 25.05.2022 replied as under:-

    " 1 & 2 :- In this regard a report of SHO/Connaught Place/NDD is enclosed herewith which is self-explanatory. Hence, the sought information/documents cannot be provided to you in view of section 8 (1) (e) & (h) of RTI Act 2005 i.e. "information available to a person in his fiduciary relationship, unless the competent authority is satisfied that the larger public interest warrants the disclosure of such information"

    1

    and "information which would impede the process of investigation or apprehension or prosecution of offenders".

    3:- Not applicable in view of point No.1&2 above"

    Dissatisfied with the response received from the CPIO, the Appellant filed a First Appeal dated 22.06.2022. The FAA/DCP, New Delhi District, vide order dated 18.07.2022 upheld the reply of the CPIO.

    Aggrieved and dissatisfied, the Appellant approached the Commission with the instant Second Appeal.

    Facts emerging in Course of Hearing:

    The Appellant with Shri Vijay Gupta participated in the hearing in person. Shri Gupta stated that information on points 1 and 2 pertaining to the inquiry report/ recommendations made by officers on his complaint and legal opinion sought on his complaint from Chief PP was not provided, till date. The Respondent represented by Shri B K Singh, ACP, New Delhi District and Shri Mohit Kumar, SI, PS Connaught Place participated in the hearing in person. Shri B K Singh stated that exemption was earlier claimed u/s 8 (1) (h) of the RTI Act, 2005 since investigation in the matter was pending. However, investigation has since been completed and the outcome of the Complaint has been informed to the Appellant. During the hearing he also handed over a copy of the inquiry report containing relevant files notings to the Appellant and the Commission. Regarding the legal opinion on the Complaint Shri Singh stated that the same was a privileged communication between the department and their advocate which was exempted from disclosure as per Section 8 (1) (e) of the RTI Act, 2005.

    Decision

    In the light of the facts of the case and the arguments made by both the parties, the Commission is of the view that an appropriate response as per the provisions of the RTI Act, 2005 has been provided. A copy of the inquiry report with file notings has been handed over to the Appellant during the hearing which addresses point 1 of the RTI application. Regarding point 2, it is a settled position of law that professional communication between an Advocate and his Client is a privileged communication u/s 126 of the Advocates Act, 1961 and exempted from disclosure as per Section 8

    (1) (e) of the RTI Act, 2005. The Division Bench of the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in the matter of Union of India vs. Subhash Chandra Agrawal, LPA 168/2015 & C.M.No.5470/2015 and Union of India vs. R.K. Jain, LPA 199/2015 & C.M.No.6347/2015 dated 03.02.2017 held as under:

    "22. Reference in this context may be had to Section 126 of the Evidence Act which reads as follows:- "126. Professional communications.—No barrister,

    2

    attorney, pleader or vakil shall at any time be permitted, unless with his client's express consent, to disclose any communication made to him in the course and for the purpose of his employment as such barrister, pleader, attorney or vakil, by or on behalf of his client, or to state the contents or condition of any document with which he has become acquainted in the course and for the purpose of his professional employment, or to disclose any advice given by him to his client in the course and for the purpose of such employment: Provided that nothing in this section shall protect from disclosure—

    (1) Any such communication made in furtherance of any 1[illegal] purpose; 2[illegal] purpose;"

    (2) Any fact observed by any barrister, pleader, attorney or vakil, in the course of his employment as such, showing that any crime or fraud has been committed since the commencement of his employment. It is immaterial whether the attention of such barrister, 2[pleader], attorney or vakil was or was not directed to such fact by or on behalf of his client. Explanation.—The obligation stated in this section continues after the employment has ceased."

    23. In a catena of judgments, the Supreme Court has reiterated that a lawyer acts in a fiduciary capacity with his client. Reference maybe had to the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Central Board of Secondary Education & Anr. vs. Aditya Bandopadhyay &Ors., (2011) 8 SCC 497. That was a case where the petitioner in the writ petition had made an application for inspection and re-evaluation of the answer book. While dealing with the contention of the CBSE that the examining body holds the evaluated answer books in a fiduciary relationship, the Supreme Court held as follows:- "

    41. In a philosophical and very wide sense, examining bodies can be said to act in a fiduciary capacity, with reference to students who participate in an examination, as a government does while governing its citizens or as the present generation does with reference to the future generation while preserving the environment. But the words 'information available to a person in his fiduciary relationship' are used in Section 8(1)(e) of RTI Act in its normal and well recognized sense, that is to refer to persons who act in a fiduciary capacity, with reference to a specific beneficiary or beneficiaries who are to be expected to be protected or benefited by the actions of the fiduciary - a trustee with reference to the beneficiary of the trust, a guardian with reference to a minor/physically/infirm/mentally challenged, a parent with reference to a child, a lawyer or a chartered accountant with reference to a client, a doctor or nurse with reference to a

    3

    patient, an agent with reference to a principal, a partner with reference to another partner, a director of a company with reference to a share-holder, an executor with reference to a legatee, a receiver with reference to the parties to a lis, an employer with reference to the confidential information relating to the employee, and an employee with reference to business dealings/transaction of the employer. We do not find that kind of fiduciary relationship between the examining body and the examinee, with reference to the evaluated answer- books, that come into the custody of the examining body"

    24. Similarly in the case of Kokkanda B. Poondacha & Ors. vs. K.D.Ganapathi & Anr., (2011) 12 SCC 600 the Supreme Court held as follows:- "12. At this stage, we may also advert to the nature of relationship between a lawyer and his client, which is solely founded on trust and confidence. A lawyer cannot pass on the confidential information to anyone else. This is so because he is a fiduciary of his client, who reposes trust and confidence in the lawyer. Therefore, he has a duty to fulfil all his obligations towards his client with care and act in good faith. Since the client entrusts the whole obligation of handling legal proceedings to an advocate, he has to act according to the principles of uberrima fides, i.e., the utmost good faith, integrity, fairness and loyalty.

    25. Reference may also be had to the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Superintendent and Remembrancer of Legal Affairs, West Bengal vs. Satyen Bhowmick & Ors., AIR 1981 SCC 917. That was a case in which the accused was charged under the Official Secrets Act. The Magistrate directed the lawyer to produce his notebook. The Magistrate permitted the defence lawyer to take copies of the statement of the witness in order to be in a position to cross-examine the witness. Subsequently, the Magistrate directed the lawyer to produce his notebook to examine that only a summary of the evidence has been taken by the lawyer not in extenso in violation of Section 14. The lawyer claimed privilege under Section 126 of the Act. The Supreme Court held as follows:- '26. xxx xxx

    4. That there was absolutely no impropriety on the part of the Magistrate in not taking action against the defence lawyer for his refusal to' show his register because the lawyer had rightly claimed privilege under Section 126 of the Evidence Act as the register contained instructions given by the client which being privileged could not be disclosed to the Court. On a parity of reasoning we find no impropriety on the conduct of the lawyer in refusing to show the statement of witnesses recorded by the Court in extenso in order to prepare himself for an effective cross-examination of the witnesses. Hence the strictures passed by the High Court on the Magistrate as

    4

    also on the lawyer of the defence were, in our opinion, totally unwarranted. xxx

    26. Similarly, in a recent judgment in the case of Reserve Bank of India & Ors. vs. Jayantilal N. Mistry & Ors., (2016) 3 SCC 525 the Supreme Court while dealing with the defence of RBI that it was in the fiduciary relationship with the Bank noted as follows:- "

    55. The Advanced Law Lexicon, 3rd Edition, 2005, defines fiduciary relationship as "a relationship in which one person is under a duty to act for the benefit of the other on the matters within the scope of the fiduciary relationship. Fiduciary relationship usually arise in one of the four situations (1) when one person places trust in the faithful integrity of another, who as a result gains superiority or influence over the first, (2) when one person assumes control and responsibility over another, (3) when one person has a duty to act or give advice to another on matters falling within the scope of the relationship, or (4) when there is specific relationship that has traditionally be recognized as involving fiduciary duties, as with a lawyer and a client, or a stockbroker and a customer. xxx

    57. The term fiduciary relationship has been well discussed by this Court in the case of Central Board of Secondary Education and Anr.

    v. Aditya Bandopadhyay and Ors. (supra). In the said decision, their Lordships referred various authorities to ascertain the meaning of the term fiduciary relationship and observed thus: 20.1) Black's Law Dictionary (7th Edition, Page 640) defines 'fiduciary relationship' thus:

    A relationship in which one person is under a duty to act for the benefit of the other on matters within the scope of the relationship. Fiduciary relationships-such as trusteebeneficiary, guardian-ward, agent-principal, and attorneyclient-require the highest duty of care. Fiduciary relationships usually arise in one of four situations: (1) when one person places trust in the faithful integrity of another, who as a result gains superiority or influence over the first, (2) when one person assumes control and responsibility over another, (3) when one person has a duty to act for or give advice to another on matters falling within the scope of the relationship, or (4) when there is a specific relationship that has traditionally been recognized as involving fiduciary duties, as with a lawyer and a client or a stockbroker and a customer."

    5

    In view of the above observations, no further intervention of the Commission is required in the instant Second Appeal which is disposed off accordingly.

    Heeralal Samariya (हीरालाल साम रया) Chief Information Commissioner (मुय सूचना आयु )ु ू ुु ू ुु ू ु Authenticated true copy

    (अिभ मािणत स यािपत ित)

    S. K. Chitkara (एस. के. िचटकारा)

    Dy. Registrar (उप-पंजीयक)

    011-26186535

    6

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Surender Punyani v. Delhi Police
    (Dec 5, 2023)