AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • COMPANIES ACT 1956
  • Section 3 of the SAFRFAESI Act, 2002
  • Section 3 of the SAFRAESI Act, 2002
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • COMPANIES ACT 1956
  • Section 3 of the SAFRFAESI Act, 2002
  • Section 3 of the SAFRAESI Act, 2002
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Ms Narsimha Laxmi Paldewar Foods India Pvt Ltd v. Reliance Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd

    [APK] (SA No.72/2020, 73/2020, OA 143/2016 & 144/2016) Page 1 of 9

    Presented on: 24.03.2016 Registered on: 31.03.2016 Decided on: 04.09.2023 Duration: Y M D

    07 05 11

    IN THE DEBTS RECOVERY TRIBUNAL, AT AURANGABAD

    COMMON JUDGMENT

    IN

    ORIGINAL APPLICATION No.143/2016

    Reliance Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd. A company incorporated under The Companies Act, 1956 and registered as A Securitization and Reconstruction Company Under Section 3 of the SAFRAESI Act, 2002 Having its registered office at Reliance Center, 19, Walchand Hirachand Marg, Ballard Estate, Mumbai - 400038 and corporate office at Reliance Centre, 6th floor, North Wing, Prabhat Colony, Santacruz (East), Mumbai - 400 055 in its capacity as A Trustee of Reliance ARC- AUCB 2014 (1) Trust (Being the Assignee of The Akola Urban Co-operative Bank Ltd. Akola) Through its Chief Manager, Mr. Rajesh S. Bichitkar

    … Applicant Versus

    1. M/s. Narsinha Laxmi Paldewar Foods India Pvt Ltd., A private Limited company, registered under the Companies Act, 1956 Having its registered office at & factory at Plot No A-2/1 & 2 M.I.D.C. Area, Nanded - 431602 (Maharashtra)

    2. Shri. Nagnath Gangadhar Paldewar Age- Adult, Occupation- Business Director of Respondent no.1, Mortgagor & Guarantor for Defendant no.1

    1

    3. Shri Prashant Nagnath Paldewar Age- Major, Occu- Business Director of Respondent no.1, Mortgagor & Guarantor for Defendant no.1

    4. Shri. Pravin Nagnath Paldewar Age- major, Occu- Business Director of Respondent no.1, Mortgagor & guarantor of defendant no.1

    5. Shri. Sachin Nagnath Paldewar Age- Major, Occu- Business Director of Respondent no.1, Mortgagor & Guarantor for Defendant no.1

    6 Mr. Nagnath Gangadharrao Paldewar

    (HUF)

    6A. Sau. Vijayalaxmi Nagnath Paldewar Age- Major, Occu- Business Coparcener of Respondent no.6 HUF Mortgagor & Guarantor for Defendant no.1

    6B Mr. Prashant Nagnath Paldewar, Age- Major, Occu- Business Coparcener of Respondent no.6 HUF Mortgagor & Guarantor for Defendant no.1

    6C Shri.Pravin Nagnath Paldewar Age- major, Occu- Business, Coparcener of Respondent no.6 HUF Mortgagor & Guarantor for Defendant no.1

    6D. Shri. Sachin Nagnath Paldewar Age- Major, Occu- Business, Coparcener of Respondent no.6 HUF Mortgagor & Guarantor for Defendant no.1 All the Defendants no. 2 to 6D are having their Address at 111/112, Vasant Nagar, Airport Road Nanded.

    … Defendants

    2

    AND

    ORIGINAL APPLICATION No.144/2016

    Reliance Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd. A company incorporated under The Companies Act, 1956 and registered as A Securitization and Reconstruction Company Under Section 3 of the SAFRFAESI Act, 2002 Having its registered office at Reliance Center, 19, Walchand Hirachand Marg, Ballard Estate, Mumbai - 400038 and corporate office at Reliance Centre, 6thFloor, North Wing, Prabhat Colony, Santacruz (East), Mumbai - 400055 in its capacity as a Trustee of Reliance ARC-AUCB 2014 (1) Trust (Being the Assignee of The Akola Urban Co-operative Bank Ltd. Akola) Through its Chief Manager, Mr. Rajesh S. Bichitkar

    … Applicant Versus

    1. Shri. Nagnath Gangadhar Paldewar HUF Through its Karta Mr. Nagnath Gangadhar Paldewar Having their residence and office at 111/112. Vasant Nagar, Airport Road, Nanded.

    2. Shri Prashant Nagnath Paldewar Coparcener, Mortgagor and Guarantor

    3. Shri. Pravin Nagnath Paldewar, Coparcener, Mortgagor and Guarantor

    4. Shri. Sachin Nagnath Paldewar Coparcener, Mortgagor and Guarantor

    5. Sau. Vijayalaxmi Nagnath Paldewar Coparcener, Mortgagor and Guarantor All the Defendants nos. 2 to 5 are having their address at 111/112, Vasant Nagar, Airport Road, Nanded.

    … Defendants

    3

    APPEARANCE

    For the Applicant Mr. A.A. Yadkikar - Advocate For Respondents Mr. S.V.Adwant - Advocate

    AND

    SECURITISATION APPLICATION No.72/2020

    Presented on: 11.11.2020 Registered on: 18.11.2020 Decided on: 04.09.2023 Duration: Y M D

    02 09 18

    1. M/s Narsimha Laxmi Paldewar Foods India Pvt. Ltd., A Private Limited Company, registered Under the Companies Act, 1956 and having its registered office at 111/112, Vasant Nagar, Airport Road, Nanded Factory at Plot No: A-2/l/ 2 & A1/1 MIDC Nanded, Through its director,

    2. Shri Pravin Nagnath Paldewar, Age: 16 years, Occ: Business, R/o: 111/112, Vasant Nagar, Airport Road, Nanded.

    3. Shri Prashant Nagnath Paldewar, Age: 48 years, Occ: Business, R/o: 111/112, Vasant Nagar, Airport Road, Nanded.

    4. Shri Sachin Nagnath Paldewar, Age:41 years, Occ: Business, R/o: 111/112, Vasant Nagar, Airport Road, Nanded.

    5. Shri Nagnath Gangadharrao Paldewar (HUF) 111/112, Vasant Nagar, Airport Road, Nanded.

    … Applicants Versus

    1. Reliance Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd. Reliance Centre, North Wing, 6th Floor, Off Western Express Highway, Santacruz (East), Mumbai - 400 055.

    4

    2. The Authorised Officer, Reliance Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd. Reliance Centre, North Wing, 6thFloor, Off Western Express Highway, Santacruz (East), Mumbai - 400 055

    … Respondents

    AND

    SECURITISATION APPLICATION No.73/2020

    1. Nagnath Gangadharrao Paldewar (HUF) Age:

    Major, Occu: Business, R/o: 111/112, Vasant Nagar, Airport Road, Nanded. Through Coparcener Shri Pravin Nagnath Paldewar

    2. Shri Pravin Nagnath Paldewar, Age: 46 years, Occ: Business, R/o: 111/112, Vasant Nagar, Airport Road, Nanded.

    3. Shri Prashant Nagnath Paldewar, Age: 48 years, Occ: Business, R/o: 111/112, Vasant Nagar, Airport Road, Nanded

    4. Shri Sachin Nagnath Paldewar, Age:41 years, Occ: Business, R/o: 111/112, Vasant Nagar, Airport Road, Nanded

    5. Sou. Vijayalaxmi Nagnath Paldewar Age :

    Major, Occu: Business, R/o. 111/112, Vasant Nagar, Airport Road, Nanded

    … Applicants Versus

    1. Reliance Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd. Reliance Centre, North Wing, 6th Floor, Off Western Express Highway, Santacruz (East), Mumbai - 400 055

    2. The Authorised Officer, Reliance Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd. Reliance Centre, North Wing, 6thFloor, Off Western Express Highway, Santacruz (East), Mumbai - 400 055.

    … Respondents

    5

    APPEARANCE

    For the Applicant Mr. S.V.Adwant - Advocate For Respondents Mr. A.A.Yadkikar - Advocate

    Shri Vimal Gupta Presiding Officer

    JUDGEMENT PRONOUNCED ON : 04.09.2023

    JUDGMENT

    1.

    There are two Original Applications No.143/2016 (Reliance ARC Ltd. V/s M/s Narsinha Laxmi Paldewar Foods India Pvt. Ltd. & others) filed by the bank for Recovery of Rs.11,62,79303.11/- praying for interest @ 14.75 & 14.25% p.a. Another Original Application No.144/2016 (Reliance ARC Ltd. V/s Nagnath Gangadhe Paldewar & others) filed by the bank for Recovery of Rs.5,36,82,586.44/- praying for interest @ 16.50%.

    2.

    The Reliance ARC is the assignee of the debt from Akola Urban Co-operative Bank Ltd. vide assignment letter dated 15.05.2014. There happens to be two Securitisation Application nos.72/2022 & 73/2022 been filed challenging the action of respondent reliance ARC for the sale of the securities. There are various interrelated issues of the defendants / Securitisation Application applicants with the Reliance ARC and also there were issued amongst the defendant themselves.

    3.

    The Reliance ARC shows the magnanimity and on 14.01.2021 they sanctioned a settlement with the defendants/ SA applicants for an amount of Rs.19,60,00,000/-. The Securitisation Applicants kept on showing the difficulties in making the payment in order to get the

    6

    properties released on payment of market value.

    4.

    The Reliance-ARC was not keen of releasing the properties without the amount being paid. However, with mutual consent, certain developments took place in the matter. The Securitisation Application applicants started making the payments and Reliance ARC has released the respective properties.

    5.

    As there is dispute between the defendants / Securitisation applicants the consent decree could not be filed as one of the defendants refused to sign the same.

    6.

    There were some other issues of Joint Hindu family property and also ill-health of the main person of the group who remained hospitalized for a long time. This Tribunal permitted the revocation of the OTS letter, still Reliance-ARC was agreeable to get the money with delayed period interest.

    7.

    The issues were also raised under assignment and also on the purchase price. However, once settlement took place everything took the back seat as the loan stood admitted and all other issues raised also go to take back stage.

    8.

    In these circumstances, the Tribunal is informed that though there is delay of more than two and half years though the Securitisation Applicants have paid an amount of Rs. 19,60,00,000/-. In these circumstances the issue remains only for the delayed period interest which has been left to the discretion of this Tribunal.

    9.

    Reliance-ARC pleaded that they are looking @18%, whereas the learned counsel for the applicant was ready and agreeable to pay

    7

    the interest somewhere around @ 8 to 9% simple. In these circumstances the Tribunal called for the cost of funds being raised by the Reliance-ARC. The Reliance ARC has placed the documents, which shows that the cost of fund @ 13% interest. To balance the equity and to end the litigation, the Tribunal inclined that The SA applicants to pay interest @ 9% looking in to the fact that the payment was coming before 30thSeptember, 2023.

    10.

    The learned counsel for the reliance ARC submits on instruction that it is not possible for them to go below 13% and convince to their Board of Directors to agrees for such a proposal.

    11.

    The learned counsel for the SA applicant submits that the letter issued by the Reliance ARC without any time line stated that 10% interest will be charged for the delayed period which was counted by another letter to show that 18% interest was demanded.

    12.

    After detailed deliberation it was agreed by both counsels on instruction to have 13% interest being calculated for delayed period on reducing balance

    13.

    In view of the above facts and circumstances and the observations, I pass the following order:

    ORDER

    A. Original Application nos.143/2016 & 144/2016 stands allowed as prayed for and shall be satisfied on payment of Rs. 19.60 crores (already paid) along with 13% simple delayed period interest calculated on reducing balance and delay to be calculated from the last date of payment agreed by Reliance ARC.

    8

    B. Securitisation Application no. 72/2020 & 73/2020 also stands disposed of with no order as to costs C. All interlocutory applications stand disposed off accordingly.

    D. Original Applications and Securitisation Applications for an amount and payments with terms as stated above stands disposed off.

    E. The SA applicants are directed to pay interest @ 13% simple by 30thSeptember, 2023 on reducing balance as the delayed period interest.

    F. On payment as above, all the securities shall be released forthwith and no dues be issued thereafter. G. Files be consigned to record room.

    H. True Copy of the Judgment be placed in OA No.144/2016, S.A. No.72/2020 & S.A. No. 73/2020, Copy of the order be uploaded on the website and free copy be sent to all the parties.

    Date : 04.09.2023

    (Vimal Gupta) Presiding Officer Debts Recovery Tribunal, Aurangabad.

    9

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ms Narsimha Laxmi Paldewar Foods India Pvt Ltd v. Reliance Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd
    (Sep 4, 2023)