Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order IX, Rule 13 of CPC
  • Order 9 Rule 13
  • Order 9 Rule 7 C.P.C.,
  • Order 17 Rule 2
  • Section 151 of C.P.C.,
  • Order IX, Rule 7
  • Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963,
  • Order IX, Rule 7 of CPC.
  • Order IX, Rule 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • Revision Petition Order IX Rule 7 Code of Civil Procedure
  • Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order IX, Rule 7 and non-application of the Limitation Act. 25. Order IX, Rule 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order IX Rule 7 of CPC in I.A.No.3 of 2020 in O.S.No.449 of 2014.
  • Article 137 of Limitation Act
  • Court), the provisions under Article 137
  • Coimbatore. 2.The Section Officer, V.R.Section, Madras High Court, Chennai - 600 104. 21/25 22/25 C.R.P.No.1948 of 2020 SATHI
  • Order 9 Rule 7
  • Order 8, Rules 1 and 9 of the Civil Procedure Code,
  • provisions of Order VIII Rule 1 CPC.
  • Order 9, Rule 7 of CPC
  • Act (1963), Schedule, Articles 137, 122, CPC., Order 9, Rule 9, Order 40, Section 115
  • Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • "Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908), Order 9, Rule 7 - Limitation Act, 1963 (36 of 1963), Article 137
  • Limitation Act under Article 137.
  • Order 9 Rules 6 and 7
  • Art.137 of the Limitation Act - When Art. 123
  • Article 137 of the Limitation Act
  • Order 9, Rule 13 CPC,
  • Order IX Rule 7 CPC
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order IX, Rule 13 of CPC
  • Order 9 Rule 13
  • Order 9 Rule 7 C.P.C.,
  • Order 17 Rule 2
  • Section 151 of C.P.C.,
  • Order IX, Rule 7
  • Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963,
  • Order IX, Rule 7 of CPC.
  • Order IX, Rule 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • Revision Petition Order IX Rule 7 Code of Civil Procedure
  • Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order IX, Rule 7 and non-application of the Limitation Act. 25. Order IX, Rule 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order IX Rule 7 of CPC in I.A.No.3 of 2020 in O.S.No.449 of 2014.
  • Article 137 of Limitation Act
  • Court), the provisions under Article 137
  • Coimbatore. 2.The Section Officer, V.R.Section, Madras High Court, Chennai - 600 104. 21/25 22/25 C.R.P.No.1948 of 2020 SATHI
  • Order 9 Rule 7
  • Order 8, Rules 1 and 9 of the Civil Procedure Code,
  • provisions of Order VIII Rule 1 CPC.
  • Order 9, Rule 7 of CPC
  • Act (1963), Schedule, Articles 137, 122, CPC., Order 9, Rule 9, Order 40, Section 115
  • Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • "Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908), Order 9, Rule 7 - Limitation Act, 1963 (36 of 1963), Article 137
  • Limitation Act under Article 137.
  • Order 9 Rules 6 and 7
  • Art.137 of the Limitation Act - When Art. 123
  • Article 137 of the Limitation Act
  • Order 9, Rule 13 CPC,
  • Order IX Rule 7 CPC
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This Civil Revision Petition (C.R.P.No.1948 of 2020) under Article 227 was filed by S. Krishnan (the Revision Petitioner), who is the 2nd Defendant in O.S.No.449 of 2014 on the file of the I Additional District and Sessions Judge, Coimbatore. The petitioner is stated to be the purchaser of the suit property (item '3' of the plaint schedule). He was set ex parte on 18.03.2015 (at the stage of filing of written statement) and only learned of that ex parte order much later. After a delay of about 4½ years he filed I.A.No.3 of 2020 under Order IX Rule 7 CPC seeking to set aside the ex parte order. The Trial Court (I Additional District and Sessions Judge) dismissed that application by order and decree dated 23.01.2020. The Revision Petitioner challenged that dismissal before the High Court by way of this Civil Revision Petition.

Relevant procedural posture at the time of the application: Plaintiff's evidence had been closed and the suit had reached the stage when the 1st Defendant (as D.W.1) had filed an affidavit as "examination-in-chief" and was to be cross-examined. The Revision Petitioner sought leave to be allowed to participate at that stage by setting aside the ex parte order. The Trial Court dismissed the application as belated; the High Court heard rival submissions and decided the revision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an application under Order IX Rule 7 CPC to set aside an ex parte order, filed about 4½ years after the ex parte order, is barred by limitation (Article 137 of the Limitation Act) or is maintainable.
  2. Whether the learned I Additional District and Sessions Judge erred in dismissing I.A.No.3 of 2020 (the petition under Order IX Rule 7 CPC) and, if so, what relief and procedural participation the 2nd Defendant (Revision Petitioner) should be permitted at the then-current stage of the suit.

Arguments of the Parties

Revision Petitioner (2nd Defendant) — main contentions

  • The Revision Petitioner is the purchaser of the suit property (item '3') and was impleaded as 2nd Defendant in O.S.No.449 of 2014.
  • He was unaware of the joint venture agreement between the 1st Defendant and the Plaintiff and was not privy to that unregistered document.
  • He is a senior citizen (aged 75) and resides approximately 75 km from the Court; he relied on his earlier counsel and thus could not appear on every date of hearing.
  • There was a communication gap with his earlier counsel who did not inform him of the ex parte order; on discovering that he had been set ex parte he promptly filed the petition under Order IX Rule 7 after changing counsel.
  • If not permitted to participate now, the suit will result in a miscarriage of justice and may cause multiplicity of proceedings; he seeks liberty to file a written statement and to participate at the stage of defendants' evidence (subject to limitations).

Respondents (Plaintiff / 1st Defendant) — main contentions

  • The petition to set aside the ex parte order was filed after 4½ years and is thus belated; Article 137 of the Limitation Act is applicable and bars the petition filed after three years, as argued by reference to certain precedents.
  • The 2nd Defendant had been represented by the same counsel as the 1st Defendant and had been quiet for a long period, despite the 1st Defendant having filed a written statement earlier (07.03.2015).
  • The 2nd Defendant's defence is substantially similar to the 1st Defendant's and he cannot raise matters beyond those already claimed by the 1st Defendant; moreover, the 2nd Defendant had the opportunity earlier but did not participate.
  • Various precedents were cited to submit that a petition under Order IX Rule 7 can be time-barred or otherwise improper depending on when it is filed and the stage of proceedings.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Visalakshi Vs. Umapathy & Others (2015 (5) CTC 67) Held that Article 137 of the Limitation Act applies to applications under the Civil Procedure Code; an application under Order IX Rule 7 filed after lapse of three years is barred by limitation. The Trial Court relied on this ruling when discussing limitation. The High Court noted that the Trial Judge discussed Article 137 and this authority, but the High Court ultimately distinguished the Trial Court's dismissal on the facts and set aside the dismissal (i.e., the High Court did not allow Visalakshi to be decisive against the Revision Petitioner in the facts of this case).
Satbir Singh Bakshi Vs. Saroja & Others (2016 (6) CTC 209) Stated (as cited) that there is no limitation prescribed to set aside an ex parte order under Order IX Rule 7 CPC. The High Court recorded this conflicting line of authority and considered it in the course of analysing whether limitation applies; the decision was noted but the High Court resolved the issue on the facts and procedural stage rather than adopting a blanket application of this ruling against the petitioner.
Swaminathan & another Vs. Esakkidoss (2018 (3) MWN (Civil) 577) Cited for the proposition that "There is no limitation prescribed to set aside ex parte order under Order IX, Rule 7 of C.P.C." Noted by the High Court among the authorities reflecting the view that no specific limitation exists for Order IX Rule 7 applications; the High Court considered this line of cases when addressing the conflict of authorities and the appropriate remedy in the present facts.
Gokarakonda Venkatasubbiah Vs. Daliparthi Lakshminarasimham (1925 SCC Online Mad 355 = AIR 1925 Mad 1274) Explains that if plaintiff had closed his case and the defendant was absent and therefore made ex parte as regards presentation of his case, he would not be allowed to come on later unless he got the ex parte order set aside under O.9 R.7; but if petitioner had not been called to produce his case, there could be no ex parte order against him with reference to his presentation of his case and he could proceed from the stage at which it stood. Cited by Respondents. The High Court referred to this authority and used its distinction to explain that a defendant may be allowed to proceed from the stage at which the suit stood (i.e., participation in future proceedings but not to reopen past stages), and applied that principle to permit limited participation by the 2nd Defendant.
Kodi Makku Naicker & Another Vs. Agathiappa Gounder & Others (1949 (1) MLJ 147) Holds that defendants may participate in future proceedings but not in what is past; since the stage for filing written statement and framing of issues had passed, no fresh written statement could be filed as of right. The High Court noted this decision as supporting the proposition that participation is limited to future stages and that past stages may not be reopened as of right. The High Court applied the limiting principle to allow the 2nd Defendant to participate only at the current stage and not to revisit plaintiff evidence.
Deo Nand Vs. Achaiber Misir & Others (1953 SCC Online All 239 = AIR 1954 All 631) Discusses precedents (including Radhabai) and distinctions about when a defendant who put in appearance but was later ordered ex parte could proceed; points to limited participation from the stage reached. Referred to by Respondents. The High Court treated this and the cases discussed therein as part of the body of authority showing limitations on relief under Order IX; but the High Court distinguished or limited their application on the facts, permitting the 2nd Defendant to participate under conditions.
Radhabai V. Anant Pandurang (AIR 1922 Bom 345) — cited within Deo Nand Past authority where a defendant put in appearance but was not allowed to take part in proceedings; High Court set aside that order because the defendant could proceed from the stage the case had reached without retracing steps. Noted by the High Court via Deo Nand's discussion; used to illustrate the principle that a defendant may proceed from the current stage and need not retrace past proceedings where appropriate.
Sangarm Singh Vs. Election Tribunal, Kotah and Another (1955 SCR 1 = AIR 1955 SC 425) Examines the applicability of Order 9 Rules 6 & 7; observes differing views in High Courts and notes that it is not always the case that once an ex parte order is passed a defendant cannot take further part unless the order is set aside. The High Court referred to this Supreme Court authority to demonstrate the complexity and differing judicial approaches to Order IX Rule 7, and used it in analysing whether the Trial Court's dismissal warranted interference; ultimately the High Court allowed participation subject to limitations consistent with these principles.
K.R. Chinnathambi Gounder Vs. Bhanumathy & Others (1998 (2) LW 271) Authority on Order IX Rule 7; applies principles regarding delay, conduct of applicant, suppression of facts and failure to show good cause — where petition filed after long delay (five years) was dismissed. Relied on by Respondents to show that a belated petition and lack of good cause can warrant dismissal. The High Court considered the facts of that authority but distinguished it from the present case given the petitioner’s age, distance from Court and asserted communication gap with prior counsel.
Vikas Dedeech Vs. Richlook Garments (P) Ltd. (2013 SCC Online Del 639) Stresses that a defendant who was aware of proceedings and did not act (or had lame excuses) failed to show good or sufficient cause for setting aside ex parte order. Respondents relied on this to challenge the petitioner's conduct. The High Court noted the authority and considered the conduct-based reasoning but found the petitioner’s specific circumstances (age, distance, reliance on prior counsel) acceptable and distinguished Vikas Dedeech on facts.
C.L. Cleetus Vs. South Indian Bank Ltd & Another (2007 SCC Online Ker 57 = AIR 2007 Ker 301) Relates to petitions under Order IX Rule 7; factual differences matter in whether cited authority helps a particular party. The High Court observed that the facts of the reported ruling would not help Respondents' case and expressly rejected reliance on it for the Respondents' position.
Rajaji Vs. R. Krishnaji (2006 (1) LW 790) Explains that Article 123 applies to ex parte decrees (not ex parte orders), that Article 137 is the residuary provision for certain applications, and that an application under Order 9 Rule 13 for setting aside an ex parte decree has a 30-day period while setting aside an ex parte order is governed by Article 137. Cited by Respondents; the High Court recorded and considered Rajaji's distinctions between ex parte decrees and ex parte orders. The High Court used these distinctions in its analysis of limitation and the proper application of Article 137 versus other provisions, while ultimately deciding the present petition on the facts and procedural stage.
Sarjo Devi @ Saroj Vs. Dharampal (Deceased) through Lrs and Others (Delhi High Court — cited) As quoted, addresses that where no limitation is prescribed under Order IX Rule 7, Article 137 (three years) applies and an application filed after three years is barred. Relied upon by Respondents and noted by the High Court. The High Court acknowledged the authority but found the circumstances of the Revision Petitioner distinguishable and hence did not sustain the Trial Court’s dismissal on that basis.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The High Court undertook a step-by-step analysis grounded in the stage of the trial and the statutory scheme:

  1. Statutory framework: The Court restated the scope of Order IX Rule 7 CPC — it applies where a Court has adjourned the hearing of the suit ex parte and the defendant offers a good cause for his absence; the Court may, on terms, hear him and deal with the suit as if he had appeared on the date fixed for hearing.
  2. Stage of proceedings: At the time the 2nd Defendant filed I.A.No.3 of 2020 the suit was part-heard: plaintiff's evidence had closed and D.W.1 (1st Defendant) had filed his affidavit as "examination-in-chief" and was to be cross-examined. The Court emphasised that Order IX Rule 7 can be invoked at any stage of the trial before pronouncement of judgment.
  3. Assessment of factual explanations: The petitioner provided affidavit evidence explaining the delay: advanced age (75 years), residence 75 kms from the Court, reliance on earlier counsel and a communication gap between him and that counsel. The High Court found these explanations acceptable in the facts of this particular case.
  4. Consideration of precedent and limitation arguments: The Court reviewed conflicting authorities — some holding that Article 137 applies (three-year residuary period) and others holding there is no specific limitation for Order IX Rule 7. The Trial Court had discussed Article 137 and certain authorities; the High Court noted those rulings but concluded that the Trial Court ought not to have dismissed the petition outright in the circumstances of this case.
  5. Relief tailored to the stage: Drawing on authorities that permit defendants to participate from the stage where the suit stands while limiting their ability to reopen past evidence, the High Court concluded that the 2nd Defendant should be permitted to participate but with defined limits. Specifically, the Court explained that the 2nd Defendant can file a written statement, be allowed to cross-examine the 1st Defendant (D.W.1) and to let in his own evidence as D.W.2, but cannot recall or cross-examine Plaintiff witnesses (P.W.1, P.W.2) nor seek to revisit closed plaintiff evidence.
  6. Exercise of judicial power: Invoking Section 151 CPC (inherent powers) the High Court held that justice required permitting the 2nd Defendant to participate at the current stage rather than sustaining the Trial Court's dismissal which would have precluded any participation and rendered his position a nullity.
  7. Disposition consistent with limits: The Court found that in the interest of justice the Trial Court's dismissal of I.A.No.3 of 2020 should be set aside and the 2nd Defendant be afforded a limited opportunity to put in pleadings and evidence, subject to the constraints noted above.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

This Civil Revision Petition is allowed.

Consequential directions and direct effects:

  • The order and decree dated 23.01.2020 (dismissing I.A.No.3 of 2020 in O.S.No.449 of 2014) are set aside to the extent that they denied the 2nd Defendant the opportunity to participate.
  • The I Additional District and Sessions Judge, Coimbatore, is directed to permit the Petitioner (2nd Defendant) to file his written statement within one month from the date of receipt of a copy of the High Court's order and to proceed with the disposal of the suit accordingly.
  • The 2nd Defendant is permitted to cross-examine D.W.1 (the 1st Defendant), and to let in evidence as D.W.2, but is not permitted to recall or cross-examine Plaintiff witnesses (P.W.1 and P.W.2) whose evidence had already been closed.
  • No costs were awarded; connected miscellaneous petition is closed.

Broader implications: The Court did not purport to lay down a new general precedent that overrides the conflicting authorities; rather, it addressed the matter on the facts and procedural posture of this case, applying and distinguishing earlier rulings and exercising inherent jurisdiction under Section 151 CPC to prevent a denial of justice. The decision's effect is direct and procedural: to allow the 2nd Defendant limited participation as directed above.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    S.KRISHNAN v. C.LAKSHMANAN

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS

    Orders Reserved on

    19.04.2023

    Orders Pronounced on

    30.06.2023

    CORAM

    THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SATHI KUMAR SUKUMARA KURUP

    C.R.P.No.1948 of 2020 and C.M.P.No.12039 of 2020 S.Krishnan .. Petitioner Vs.

    1.C.Lakshmanan

    2.C.Manibharathi .. Respondents

    Prayer: Civil Revision Petition filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, to set aside the order and decree dated 23.01.2020 in I.A.No.3 of 2020 in O.S.No.449 of 2014 on the file of the learned 1stAdditional District and Sessions Judge, Coimbatore.

    For Petitioner : Mr.D.Nandagopal

    for Mr.R.Rajarajan

    For Respondent 1 : Mr.C.R.Prasanan

    For Respondent 2 : No appearance

    O R D E R

    This Civil Revision Petition had been filed to set aside the fair and decretal order dated 23.01.2020 dismissing the I.A.No.3 of 2020 in O.S.No.449 of 2014 on the file of the learned 1stAdditional District and

    1/25

    Sessions Judge, Coimbatore.

    2. The learned Counsel for the Revision Petitioner expressed his apology for his non-appearance on the previous date of hearing.

    3. The learned Counsel for the Revision Petitioner submitted that the Revision Petitioner is the 2ndDefendant in the suit in O.S.No.449 of 2014 on the file of the learned I Additional District and Sessions Judge, Coimbatore. It is his contention that the Revision Petitioner is impleaded as 2ndDefendant in the suit in O.S.No.449 of 2014. He is the purchaser of the suit property in item '3' of the plaint schedule. The 2ndDefendant is not aware of the joint venture agreement entered into between the 1stDefendant and the Plaintiff. The learned Counsel for the Revision Petitioner further contended that the 1st Defendant and the Plaintiff had entered into joint venture agreement, which is an unregistered document. The Petitioner is aged 75 years. Also, he is residing 75 kms away from the Court. Therefore, he was unable to attend Court on every date of hearing. He was relying on his Counsel. The fact that the Revision Petitioner herein as 2ndDefendant in the suit in O.S.No.449 of 2014 was set ex parte was known to the 2ndDefendant very late. By the time, he came to know that he was set ex parte, immediately he filed a

    2/25

    petition under Order IX Rule 7 of CPC in I.A.No.3 of 2020 in O.S.No.449 of 2014. The Respondents objected stating that the petition had been filed after 4½ years after the 2ndDefendant was set ex parte. The learned Counsel for the Revision Petitioner contended that there had been communication gap between him and his earlier Counsel. The earlier Counsel had not informed him about the fact that he was set ex parte.

    4. On coming to know that the Revision Petitioner as 2ndDefendant in the suit was set ex parte, immediately, he had filed an application in I.A.No.3 of 2020 in O.S.No.449 of 2014 after changing his Counsel. If the suit is decided without hearing the Revision Petitioner herein as 2nd Defendant in the suit, it will end up in miscarriage of justice and also lead to multiple proceedings. To avoid such exigency, the learned Counsel for the Revision Petitioner seeks to set aside the order of dismissal in I.A.No.3 of 2020 in O.S.No.449 of 2014, on the file of the learned I Additional District and Sessions Judge, Coimbatore, dated 23.01.2020.

    5. The learned Counsel for the 1stRespondent submitted that Article 137 of the Limitation Act is not applicable to the facts of this case. The suit is filed in the year 2014. Written statement was filed filed by the 2nd

    3/25

    Defendant along with typed set of papers. The 2ndDefendant is stated to have purchased the property from 1stDefendant. The 1stDefendant had already filed written statement. 2ndDefendant is the Revision Petitioner herein. The 2ndDefendant had raised the defence almost similar to 1st Defendant. The 2ndDefendant cannot go beyond what is claimed by the 1st Defendant.

    6. The learned Counsel for the Respondents invited the attention of this Court to the contents of the written statement filed by the 1stDefendant on 07.03.2015. He also invited the attention of this Court to the dates drawn from the Court diary. The 2ndDefendant had kept quite for 4 ½ years. It is to be noted that the 1stDefendant and 2ndDefendant engaged the same Counsel.

    7. The learned Counsel for the Respondents also invited the attention of this Court to the typed set filed by them. The learned Counsel for the Respondents submitted that the Respondents typed set of papers contains the copy of the affidavit of the Plaintiff as "examination-in-chief" of P.W.1, which also contains date on which he was cross-examined by the learned Counsel for the 1stDefendant. It also contains the affidavit filed by the 1st Defendant in O.S.No.449 of 2014 on the file of the learned I Additional

    4/25

    District and Sessions Judge, Coimbatore, as "examination-in-chief" of D.W.1, which was filed on 16.08.2019. He is to be cross-examined. At that stage, the 2ndDefendant in the suit had filed a petition to set aside the ex parte order in I.A.No.3 of 2020 in O.S.No.449 of 2014 against him, which was dismissed by the learned I additional District and Sessions Judge, Coimbatore, by order dated 23.01.2020. Therefore, the 2ndDefendant in O.S.No.449 of 2014 had preferred this Civil Revision Petition and obtained stay. Therefore, the proceedings had been stayed and the suit could not be disposed of.

    8. The learned Counsel for the Respondents also invited the attention of this Court to the contents of the affidavit filed by the Revision Petitioner herein as Applicant in I.A.No.3 of 2020 in O.S.No.449 of 2014 in Page No.17 of the typed set of papers in Paragraph No.3 wherein, it is stated as follows;-

    " On the other hand, when the above suit stood posted on 18.03.2015 for filing my written statement. Owing to the above said reasons, I was not able to appear before this Hon'ble Court on that day; and therefore, this Hon'ble Court was pleased to pass an order setting me ex parte on 18.03.2015."

    Now, the suit had reached the stage of cross-examination of D.W.1. Therefore, the 2ndDefendant can participate only at the stage of Defendants

    5/25

    evidence.

    9. The learned Counsel for the Respondents also invited the attention of this Court to the order passed by the learned I Additional District and Sessions Judge, Coimbatore, dismissing the application in I.A.No.3 of 2020 in O.S.No.449 of 2014. It holds good. Therefore, the order passed by the I Additional District and Sessions Judge, Coimbatore, does not warrant any interference by this Court under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure and therefore, this petition is to be dismissed.

    10. As per Order IX, Rule 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure, it provides that in a situation where the Court has adjourned the hearing of the suit ex parte and the Defendant provides a good cause for his absence, the Court, on its terms and condition, may hear him and deal with the suit as if he had appeared on the date fixed for hearing.

    11. The learned I Additional District and Sessions Judge, Coimbatore, had discussed about the application of Limitation Act under Article 137. As per the ruling reported in 2015 (5) CTC 67 in the case of Visalakshi Vs. Umapathy & Others, wherein it is stated as follows;-

    6/25

    "Limitation prescribed under Article 137 would apply to all applications filed before Civil Court under Civil Procedure Code- Application filed to set aside ex parte order under Order 9 Rule 7 of C.P.C-after lapse of three years is barred by Limitation."

    12. Also in another ruling reported in 2016 (6) CTC 209 in the case of

    Satbir Singh Bakshi Vs. Saroja & Others and 2018 (3) MWN (Civil) 577

    in the case of Swaminathan & another Vs. Esakkidoss, wherein it is observed as follows;-

    " There is no limitation prescribed to set aside ex parte order under Order IX, Rule 7 of C.P.C."

    Therefore, the order dismissing the petition under Order IX, Rule 7 of C.P.C., does not warrant any interference by this Court.

    13. On perusal of the affidavit filed by the Petitioner, counter affidavit filed by the Respondents, the order passed by the learned I Additional District and Sessions Judge, Coimbatore, in I.A.No.3 of 2020 in O.S.No.449 of 2014 dated 23.01.2020 and the grounds of revision, it is found that the learned I Additional District and Sessions Judge, Coimbatore, having discussed that the Limitation Act is not applicable to this case and Order IX Rule 7, petition can be filed at any stage of the proceedings in the suit. He ought not to have dismissed the petition. Instead he could have allowed the

    7/25

    2ndDefendant to participate in the proceedings at the stage of cross examination of D.W.1. At that stage, he could file written statement alone and argue his case and he cannot revert back to the stage of P.W.1 cross- examination, he can participate in the proceedings by filing written statement by himself, 2ndDefendant and let in evidence and subject himself to cross examination by Plaintiff Counsel as well as the Counsel for the 1stDefendant if the 1stDefendant so desires. Having been set ex parte at the stage of filing written statement. Now, if he is permitted to participate in the proceeding, he has to file written statement at the stage of evidence of Defendants. The evidence of the Defendants had not been completed and first Defendant as D.W.1 is in the witness box. Therefore, as per Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the Petitioner herein as 2ndDefendant in the suit had to be afforded an opportunity. He cannot seek cross-examination of Plaintiff as P.W.1 he can seek cross examination of first Defendant as D.W.1 subject to filing of written statement of 2ndDefendant.

    14. The learned Counsel for the Respondents relied upon the ruling reported in 1925 SCC Online Mad 355 = AIR 1925 Mad 1274 in the case of (Gokarakonda) Venkatasubbiah Vs. Daliparthi Lakshminarasimham, wherein it is stated as follows;-

    8/25

    " 7. In the present case, if the plaintiff had closed his case, and the Petitioner had been called upon to produce his case, and he was absent and therefore, made ex-parte as regards the presentation of his case, I take it that he would not be allowed to come on later unless he got the ex-parte order set aside under O. 9 R. 7. But if the plaintiff had closed his case and the Petitioner had not been called upon to produce his case, there could be no ex- parte order against him with reference to his presentation of his case, which has to be set aside. Therefore, he could appear and go on with his case on the adjourned date from the stage at which it stood."

    15. The learned Counsel for the Respondents also relied upon the ruling reported in 1949 (1) MLJ 147 in the case of Kodi Makku Naicker & Another Vs. Agathiappa Gounder and Others, wherein it is stated as follows;-

    " ......... but we feel that the rule laid down by Wallace,J., supports the conclusion we have arrived at from a reading of Order 8, Rules 1 and 9 of the Civil Procedure Code, to which Varadachariar,J., made no reference. Wallace,J., held in effect that the defendants could participate in the future proceedings of the Court, but not in what was past. Since the stage for the filing of the written statement and the framing of issues had been passed, no fresh written statement could be filed as of right."

    16. The learned Counsel for the respondents further relied upon the rulings reported in 1953 SCC Online All 239 = AIR 1954 All 631 in the case of Deo Nand Vs. Achaiber Misir and Others, wherein, it is stated as follows;-

    " 7. Another case relied upon by the learned Counsel for

    9/25

    the applicant is that reported in - 'Radhabai V. Anant Pandurang', AIR 1922 Bom 345(1)(D). In that case the Court passed an order directing the case to proceed 'ex parte' against defendant No.4. The said Defendant put in appearance then and there but he was not allowed to take part in the proceedings. The High Court set aside that order. That case also is distinguishable because in that case also the defendant could proceed from the stage the case had reached and had not to retrace its steps. It may be pointed out that in this case their Lordships observed as follows;-

    "But if he (defendant) does not appear before the suit is heard then he has not right to be heard."

    17. The learned Counsel for the respondents further relied upon the ruling reported in 1955 (2) SCR 1 = AIR 1955 SC 425 in the case of

    Sangarm Singh Vs. Election Tribunal, Kotah and Another, wherein, it is stated as follows;-

    "35. Now, this is not a case in which the defendant with whom we are concerned did not appear at the first hearing. He did. The first hearing was on 11.12.1952 at Kotah. The appellant (the first defendant) appeared through Counsel and filed a written statement. Issues were framed and the case was adjourned till 16th March at Udaipur for the Petitioner's evidence alone from 16th to 21st March. Therefore, Order 9 Rules 6 and 7 do not apply in terms. But we have been obliged to examine this Order at length because of the differing views taken in the various High Courts and because the contention is that Order 17 Rule 2 throws one back to the position under Order 9 Rules 6 and 7 and there, according to one set of views, the position is that once an ex parte "order" is "passed" against a defendant he cannot take further part in the proceedings unless he gets that "order" set aside by showing good cause under Rule 7. But that is by no means the case."

    10/25

    18. The learned Counsel for the Respondent also relied upon the ruling reported in 1998 (2) LW 271 in the case of K.R.Chinnathambi Gounder Vs. Bhanumathy and 4 Others, wherein, it is stated as follows;-

    "Civil Procedure Code, O. 9, R. 7 - suit for declaration and permanent injunction -2nd defendant set ex parte for non-filing of written statement - contest by the 1st defendant alone - Petition to set aside ex parte order filed by 2nd defendant, filed after five years dismissed - Object of filing a fresh written statement by the Petitioner, held, could be to raise new plea - The applicant has failed to show good cause, and suppressed fact of filing counter in the application filed for violation of injunction - There is no reason why he did not pursue the matter for about five years - The act of Petitioner is only to drag on the proceedings which should not be allowed by the Court."

    19. The learned Counsel for the Respondents also relied upon the ruling reported in 2013 SCC Online Del 639 in the case of Vikas Dedeech Vs. Richlook Garments (P) Ltd., wherein, it is stated as follows;-

    "20. The conduct of the petitioner is such that despite being aware of the pendency of the case, plaintiff's evidence being already led and closed , he failed to wake up and when the case was just at the stage of final arguments, he filed this application praying for a relief which was not available to him in view of the provisions of Order VIII Rule 1 CPC.

    21. The contention of learned counsel for the petitioner that good cause shown by the petitioner in his application under Order IX Rule 7 CPC should be construed liberally, does not come to his rescue for the simple reason that lame excuses have been taken by the petitioner like blaming the counsel for non-appearance, having ample time to attend the business activities but no time to take part in the proceedings going on before the Trial Court either through counsel or by inspecting the record. It is also matter of common

    11/25

    knowledge that cause-list and all the proceedings as well as orders of the District Courts can be accessed through Internet. The defendant could have accessed the status of the case through Internet and taken timely action or at least could have taken part in the proceedings by cross examining the plaintiff. He remained busy in the business and perhaps did not consider it necessary to ensure that he is properly represented during the trial through his counsel. This shows that he had absolutely no cause what to talk of good or sufficient case for setting aside the exparte order.

    19. In view of above discussion, since the impugned order does not suffer from any infirmity or illegality, the present petition is hereby dismissed."

    20. The learned Counsel for the Respondents also relied upon the ruling reported in 2007 SCC Online Ker 57 =AIR 2007 Ker 301 in the case of C.L.Cleetus Vs. South Indian Bank Ltd & Another. The subject matter of the dispute is with regard to petition under Order IX, Rule 7 of CPC which was dismissed by the trial Court/Executing Court. The facts of the reported ruling will not help the Respondent's case. Hence, it is rejected.

    21. The learned Counsel for the Respondents also relied upon the ruling reported in 2015 (5) CTC 67 in the case of Visalakshi Vs. Umapathy, wherein it is held as follows;-

    "Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908), Order 9, Rule 7 - Limitation Act, 1963 (36 of 1963), Article 137 - Ex parte Order - Application filed to set aside ex parte order - Defendant set ex parte for non-appearance - Whether limitation of three years as prescribed under Article 137 of Limitation Act would

    12/25

    apply - Defendant set ex parte in year 2009 and Application to set aside ex parte Order filed in the year 2013 - Limitation prescribed under Article 137 would apply to all Applications filed before Civil Court under Civil Procedure Code - Article 137 would apply to Petition filed under Order 9, Rule 7 of CPC - Application filed to set aside ex parte Order after lapse of three years is barred by limitation"

    22. The learned Counsel for the Respondents further relied upon the ruling reported in 2006 (1) LW 790 in the case of Rajaji Vs. R. Krishnaji,

    wherein, it is stated as follows;-

    "Limitation Act (1963), Schedule, Articles 137, 122, CPC., Order 9, Rule 9, Order 40, Section 115 - Revision against order of lower court declining to set aside ex parte order appointing Receiver of the suit property - Application to set aside ex parte order filed after four months was dismissed by lower court on the ground that the petition was filed beyond thirty days of the order and that the application to set aside the ex parte order ougth to have been filed within thirty days from the date of order and the application filed beyond thirty days is not maintainable - Held:

    Art. 123 speaks of a Decree passed ex parte and not an ex parte order - Legislature has maintained the difference between -

    "Decree and Order"; and Art.123 shall apply only to ex parte decrees or ex parte orders having the force of Decree or Order which finally determines the right of the parties. Prescribed period of limitation for an application under Order 9, Rule 13 CPC, for setting aside an ex parte Decree is thirty days, but not for an application to set aside an ex parte order, with the result that an application for setting aside the ex parte order shall be governed by the residuary clause contained in Art.137 of the Limitation Act - When Art. 123 applies only to ex parte decree, the lower court was not right in finding that the application filed under Order 9, Rule 7 CPC beyond thirty days is not maintainable - Hence, the impugned order cannot be sustained - C.R.P. Allowed"

    13/25

    23. The learned Counsel for the Respondents also relied upon the decision of the Delhi High Court in the case of Sarjo Devi @ Saroj Vs. Dharampal (Deceased) Thr Lrs and Others, wherein, it is stated as follows;-

    "34. Since no limitation is prescribed under Order 9 Rule 7 C.P.C., like that of Order 9 Rule 13 as observed in Rajaji's case as well as in Vikas Dedeech's case (Delhi High Court), the provisions under Article 137 being residuary provision alone would be made applicable and therefore, under Article 137 of the Limitation Act, the period of limitation is prescribed as three years and since the application in I.A.No.87 of 2013 has been filed after the period of three years, it is squarely barred by limitation under Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963, as rightly concluded by the learned trial Judge, which according to this Court, does not require any interference and therefore, the revision petition deserves to be dismissed." (emphasis supplied)

    24. On consideration of rival submission and perusal of the order passed by the learned I Additional District and Sessions Judge, Coimbatore, it is found that the learned I Additional District and Sessions Judge, Coimbatore, had discussed about the application of Order IX, Rule 7 and non-application of the Limitation Act.

    25. Order IX, Rule 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure is invoked only in circumstances when the suit proceeding is pending before the Trial Court.

    14/25

    Therefore, at any stage of the Trial, Order IX Rule 7 can be invoked before pronouncement of judgment.

    26. Here, in this case by the time the 2ndDefendant had filed I.A.No.3 of 2020 in O.S.No.449 of 2014, the proceedings in the suit had reached the stage of part heard Trial where Plaintiff evidence was closed and the 1st Defendant as D.W.1 had filed an affidavit as "examination in chief" he is to be cross examined by the learned Counsel for the Plaintiff. At that stage, the 2ndDefendant had filed I.A.No.3 of 2020 in O.S.No.449 of 2014 under Order IX Rule 7 he had offered his explanation for his absence on the previous hearing. He came to know that he was set ex parte only very late it was a communication gap between him and his Counsel. Therefore, he had changed the Counsel. Under those circumstances, the submission of the learned Counsel for the Respondents that the Defendants 1 and 2 had engaged the same Counsel is found justifiable and acceptable. At the same stage, whether the 2ndDefendant is to be considered as sailing along with 1st Defendant or as independent written statement is to be decided by him alone. At that stage, if he had changed his Counsel he is entitled to file written statement and proceed with his evidence. Without written statement he cannot let in evidence. As the Civil Procedure Code placed that without

    15/25

    pleadings there cannot be evidence in a civil proceeding. Therefore, the stage of the suit is on the evidence of 1stDefendant. Now the 2ndDefendant had entered appearance, he is to be given a chance to file written statement for himself. If he is adopting the written statement of the 1stDefendant he is within his discretion to file a memo stating that he adopts the written statement of the 1stDefendant. Now the 1stDefendant as D.W.1 had filed affidavit as "examination in chief". Therefore, only after filing written statement by the 2ndDefendant whether the 2ndDefendant intends to cross examine the 1stDefendant as D.W.1 is to be decided by the Court and also by the 1stDefendant. Any how under Section 151 of C.P.C., the Court has a power to render justice.

    27. As per the reported rulings cited by the learned Counsel for the Plaintiff, who is the Respondent in the Revision Petition Order IX Rule 7 Code of Civil Procedure permits the Defendants to participate in the proceedings of the suit in the stage at which Order IX Rule 7 is filed. Therefore, to participate in the proceedings the 2ndDefendant is to be given a chance to file his written statement and to proceed with either cross examination of D.W.1 or to let in evidence by the 2ndDefendant as D.W.2. No prejudice will be caused to the Plaintiff by allowing the 2ndDefendant to

    16/25

    file written statement. In the interest of justice, the 2ndDefendant is to be given a chance to participate in the proceedings and his role is limited. He cannot cross examine P.W.1 or recall P.W.1 or P.W.2 at this stage as the suit had reached the stage of Defendants evidence.

    28. In the light of the above discussion, the order passed by the learned I Additional District and Sessions Judge, Coimbatore, dismissing the petition filed under Order IX, Rule 7 on the ground that it has been filed belatedly after a period of 4 ½ years is set aside on the ground that the reasons stated by the 2ndDefendant as Revision Petitioner herein in his affidavit before the Trial Court in I.A.No.3 of 2020 in O.S.No.449 of 2014 is found acceptable, considering his age and the place of his residence far away from Coimbatore. Therefore, it is found acceptable that he was depending on his Counsel and he was not appearing before the trial Court for every hearing. He was expecting the Counsel will inform him the stage of the case, but the Counsel did not do so. He came to know about the fact that he was set ex parte only from the 1stDefendant. Under those circumstances, invoking powers of this Court under Section 151 of C.P.C., the learned Judge ought to have allowed the petition under Order IX, Rule 7 of C.P.C. with a specific order that he cannot recall or cross examine P.W.1 and

    17/25

    P.W.2. Instead he had dismissed the petition. Therefore, that part of the order is to be set aside.

    29.In all the rulings cited by the learned Counsel for the Respondent, it is stated that petition under Order IX, Rule 7 of C.P.C. can be filed before the Court concerned, if the proceedings are pending and Limitation Act will not apply to the petition under Order IX, Rule 7 of C.P.C. At the same time, it is interpreted in all those rulings that it does not mean that a petition under Order IX, Rule 7 of CPC can be filed at any time, meaning that the petition under Order IX, Rule 7 of CPC can be invoked only in the pending proceedings in the suit. It distinguishes between the petition under Order IX, Rule 13 of CPC and petition under Order IX, Rule 7 of CPC. 30.In this case, the learned Counsel for the Revision Petitioner had stated that the Revision Petitioner was a senior citizen, who was residing far away from the court premises ie., 75 kms from the Court. Due to his old age and health status, his earlier Counsel had informed him that he will inform the stage of the case and he need not appear for every hearing. Believing the words of the earlier Counsel, the Revision Petitioner had not attended the Court. Later on, he came to know that he was set ex parte. Immediately, he

    18/25

    filed a petition to set aside the ex parte order passed against him. By the time he had filed petition to set aside the ex parte order, the suit had proceeded at the stage of D.W-1 cross-examination. Therefore, he had filed a petition under Order IX, Rule 7 of CPC seeking to set aside the ex parte order passed against him. This is the circumstances which the Revision Petitioner had clearly stated in his affidavit. Therefore, the rulings cited by the learned Counsel for the Respondent will not hold good. Once ex parte order is passed, the Revision Petitioner can participate in the proceedings only from the stage of D.W.1 evidence and he cannot apply for recall of the Plaintiff side witnesses. He can participate in the proceedings even in the argument stage. While so, the reported rulings relied on by the learned Counsel for the Respondent is not applicable to the facts of this case and hence rejected.

    31. In the light of the above discussion, the Petitioner is granted a chance to participate in the proceedings by filing written statement on his behalf as 2ndDefendant in the suit and to cross-examine D.W.1 and also to let in evidence as D.W.2 in the suit. Accordingly, the point for consideration is answered in favour of the Revision Petitioner and against the Respondents.

    19/25

    In the result, this Civil Revision Petition is allowed. The learned I Additional District and Sessions Judge, Coimbatore, is directed to permit the Petitioner as 2ndDefendant in the suit to file his written statement, within a period of one month from the date of receipt of a copy of this order and proceed accordingly with the disposal of the suit. No costs. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petition is closed.

    30.06.2023

    Index : Yes/No Internet : Yes/No Speaking Order/Non-Speaking Order ata

    20/25

    To 1.The I Additional District and Sessions Judge, Coimbatore.

    2.The Section Officer,

    V.R.Section, Madras High Court,

    Chennai - 600 104.

    21/25

    22/25

    C.R.P.No.1948 of 2020

    SATHI KUMAR SUKUMARA KURUP., J.

    At the time of pronouncing the order, the learned Counsel for the Respondents objected to the final part of the order whereby "the learned First Additional District and Sessions Judge, Coimbatore is directed to permit the second Defendant in O.S.No.449 of 2014 to file written statement within a period of one month from the date of receipt of copy of this order."

    2.This portion of the order is objected by the learned Counsel for the Respondents stating that under Order IX, Rule 7 of CPC if the ex parte order passed against the Revision Petitioner is set aside, he should be permitted to participate in the proceedings at the stage of the suit where it had reached. Now the suit had reached the stage of D.W-1 in the box. Therefore, he can be permitted to participate alone.

    3.The objection of the learned Counsel for the Respondents/Plaintiffs is rejected as in the earlier part of the order it had been clearly stated that the Petition in I.A.No.3 of 2020 filed by the second Defendant was filed after 4½ years from the date when he was set ex parte. By the time he came to know about the proceedings, the suit had reached the stage of witness of first

    23/25

    Defendant as D.W-1 and he had filed affidavit as examination in chief of D.W-1. Therefore, if the Petition filed by the second Defendant to set aside the ex parte order is allowed, he is permitted to file written statement regarding his part of the explanation to the suit. At the same time, it is made clear in the earlier part of the order that he does not have the right to recall Plaintiff witnesses as the Plaintiff evidence had been closed already. 4.Now if the right of the second Defendant to file written statement is curtailed, this order becomes a nullity. It has no difference between the order passed by the learned First Additional District and Sessions Judge, Coimbatore dismissing the Petition and now the Petitioner having been allowed, it does not make difference. Therefore, he should be given a chance to offer his explanation to the Plaintiffs' averments. Only then, the second Defendant will be able to put his evidence. Without pleadings, the observation of this Court "the second Defendant is permitted to participate in the suit proceedings will be an empty formality." Therefore, the objection by the learned Counsel for the Respondents is rejected. The same order holds good.

    30.06.2023

    srm

    SATHI KUMAR SUKUMARA KURUP., J.

    24/25

    srm Order made in C.R.P.No.1948 of 2020

    30.06.2023

    25/25

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    S.KRISHNAN v. C.LAKSHMANAN
    (Jun 30, 2023)