AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Act, 1872-section 115-Doctrine of Estoppel, code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Section
  • Section 21(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
  • Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Act, 1872-section 115-Doctrine of Estoppel, code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Section
  • Section 21(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
  • Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    SMT. LALITAVVA LALITAVVA W/O TIRAKAPPA KABBUR v. SMT. PARVATEVVA W/O SHIVARUDRAPPA

    - 1 -

    MSA No. 100012 of 2018

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,

    DHARWAD BENCH

    DATED THIS THE 6TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2023

    BEFORE

    THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE M.G.S. KAMAL

    M.S.A.NO.100012 OF 2018

    BETWEEN:

    1. SMT. LALITAVVA W/O TIRAKAPPA KABBUR

    AGE: 51 YEARS, OCC:HOUSEHOLD AND AGR.,

    R/O HIRENANDIHALLI-581106,

    TALUKA: BYADGI, DIST:HAVERI.

    2. KUMARI SAVITA

    D/O TIRAKAPPA KABBUR,

    AGE: 27 YEARS, OCC: STUDENT,

    R/O HIRENANDIHALLI-581106,

    TALUKA: BYADGI, DIST: HAVERI.

    3. SHRIKANT

    S/O TIRAKAPPA KABBUR

    AGE: 25 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,

    R/O HIRENANDIHALLI-581 106,

    TALUKA: BYADGI, DIST: HAVERI.

    …APPELLANTS

    (BY SRI RAVI S.BALIKAI,

    SRI VINEETH R.BALIKAI,

    SRI F.M.MULZAN,

    SMT.REBECCA SOLOMAN, ADVOCATES)

    AND:

    1. SMT. PARVATEVVA

    W/O SHIVARUDRAPPA DODDAMANI

    AGE: 56 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,

    R/O HIRENANDIHALLI-581106,

    TALUKA: BYADGI, DIST:HAVERI.

    - 2 -

    2. SMT. GIRUJAVVA

    W/O SHIDDAPPA DUMMALLI,

    AGE: 54 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,

    R/O SHIRAGUMBI-581116,

    TALUKA: HIREKERUR, DIST: HAVERI.

    3. SMT. SAVITRI @ SAVITRAVVA W/O SHIVANANDAPPA MULIMANI

    AGE: 50 YEARS, OCC:HOUSEHOLD WORK,

    R/O HIRENANDIHALLI-581106,

    TALUKA: BYADGI, DIST:HAVERI.

    4. SMT CHANNABASAVVA

    W/O KALAPPA MUDDAPPANAVAR,

    AGE: 48 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK

    R/O HIREMALLUR-581205,

    TALUKA: SHIGGAON, DIST: HAVERI.

    5. SMT.PRAMELAVVA

    W/O UJJANAGOUDA HOSAGOUDRA

    AGE: 44 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK

    R/O OLD SHIDENUR-581106,

    TALUKA: BYADGI, DIST:HAVERI.

    6. SHIVANANDAPPA SIDDAPPA MULIMANI

    SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.

    SMT.SANKAMMA

    W/O SHIDDAPPA MULIMANI

    AGE: 75 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,

    R/O HIRENANDIHALLI-581106,

    TALUKA: BYADGI, DIST: HAVERI.

    7. PRAVEEN SHIVANANDAPPA MULIMANI

    AGE: 30 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,

    R/O HIRENANDIHALLI 581106,

    TALUKA:BYADGI, DIST: HAVERI.

    8. SHIDDAPPA SHIVANANDAPPA MULIMANI,

    AGE: 28 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,

    R/O HIRENANDIHALLI-581106,

    TALUKA: BYADGI, DIST: HAVERI.

    9. KUMARI SWETA

    D/O SHIVANANDAPPA MULIMANI

    - 3 -

    AGE: 28 YEARS, OCC: STUDENT,

    R/O HIRENANDIHALLI-581106,

    TALUKA: BYADGI, DIST:HAVERI.

    10. MAHADEVAPPA MURADEPPA MULIMANI

    AGE: 76 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,

    R/O: HIRENANDIHALLI-581106,

    TALUKA:BYADGI, DIST:HAVERI.

    …RESPONDENTS

    (BY SRI. I C PATIL.,

    SRI M.S.HUGAR, AND

    SRI S.K.ARALIKATTI, ADVOCATES FOR R.1 TO R5.

    NOTICE TO R.6 6O 9 : SERVED.

    RESPONDENT NO.10 : DECEASED)

    THIS MISCELLANEOUS SECOND APPEAL IS FILED UNDER

    ORDER XLIII RULE 1(U) R/W SECTION 104 OF CPC PRAYING THIS

    COURT TO SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED

    03.01.2012 PASSED BY THE II ADDITIONAL DISTRICT JUDGE,

    HAVERI SITTING AT RANEBENNUR IN R.A.NO.11/2013 AND SUCH

    OTHER RELIEFS.

    THIS PETITION COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS DAY,

    THE COURT DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

    JUDGMENT

    1. The present appeal is filed by the defendants being aggrieved by the order dated 03.01.2018 passed in R.A.No.11/2011 on the file of II Additional District Judge at Haveri (hereinafter referred to as "the First Appellate Court" for short) in and by which, the First Appellate Court while setting aside the judgment and decree dated 04.12.2012 passed in O.S.No.14/2011 on the file of Senior Civil Judge, Byadgi (hereinafter referred to as "the Trial

    - 4 -

    Court" for short) remanded the matter to the Trial Court for fresh disposal in accordance with law on merits after providing sufficient opportunity to the parties. Being aggrieved by the same, the defendants are before this Court.

    2. The above suit in O.S.No.14/2011 was filed by the plaintiffs for relief of partition and separate possession. The said suit came to be dismissed by the Trial Court on the issue of res-judicata holding that on an earlier occasion a original suit in O.S.No.123/2003 was filed, which was dismissed on the premise of plaintiffs not adding all the family properties for partition. The dismissal order was apparently carried up to this Court in regular second appeal in RSA.No.1579/2007 which had also confirmed the said order.

    3. It is stated that taking into consideration of the dismissal of the earlier suit, the Trial Court in the aforesaid impugned order framed the following issues:

    - 5 -

    1. zÁªÁ¹ÛUÀ¼ÀÄ ªÁ¢AiÀÄgÀÄ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ ¥ÀæwªÁ¢AiÀÄ ¦vÁæfðvÀ D¹ÛUÀ¼ÀÄ C£ÀÄßöªÀÅzÀ£ÀÄß ªÁ¢ gÀÄdĪÁvÀÄ ªÀiÁqÀÄvÁÛgÉAiÉÄÃ?

    2. gȨ́ ÀdÄnPÉl ¹zÁÞAvÀ DzÁgÀzÀ ªÉÄÃ¯É zÁªÁ ¤®ÄèªÀÅ¢®è CzÀÄ ªÀeÁ DUÀÄvÀÛzÉ ¥ÀæwªÁ¢ ¹zÁÞ ªÀiÁqÀÄvÁÛgÉAiÉÄÃ?

    3. ªÁ¢ zÁªÁ¸ÀévÀÄÛUÀ¼À°è ¥ÀjºÁgÀ PÉýzÀAvÉ 1:7 gÀAvÉ »¸ÉìAiÀÄ£ÀÄß ¥ÀqÉAiÀÄ®Ä ºÀPÀÄÌ ªÀżÀèªÀgÁVzÁÝgÉAiÉÄÃ?

    4. AiÀiÁªÀ DzÉñÀ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ rQæ?

    4. Trial Court taking into consideration of the dismissal of regular second appeal in RSA.No.1579/2007, which arose out of the dismissal of suit in O.S.No.123/2003, held that in view of dismissal of the said regular second appeal, the same was hit by principles of res-judicata and as such, the above suit in O.S.No.14/2011 was not maintainable.

    5. Being aggrieved by the same, the plaintiff has preferred regular appeal in R.A.No.11/2013 before the First Appellate Court. The First Appellate Court raised the following points for its consideration;

    1. Whether the Trial Court justified in dismissing the suit of the plaintiffs by holding that, suit of

    - 6 -

    the plaintiffs is hit by the principles of res- judicata as contemplated U/sec.11 of CPC?

    2. Whether the impugned judgment and decree passed by the trial court in O.S.No.14/2011 calls for any interference by this court?

    3. What order or decree?

    6. The First Appellate Court after appreciating the material evidence on record reversed the judgment and decree of the Trial Court by holding that dismissal of suit in O.S.No.123/2003 confirmed by this Court in RSA.No.1579/2007 did not amount to res-judicata and accordingly remanded the matter for fresh disposal in accordance with law after affording sufficient opportunity to the parties. It is this order is challenged by the appellants/defendants before this Court.

    7. Sri Ravi S.Balikai, learned counsel for the appellants apart from reiterating the grounds urged in the memorandum of appeal submits that, the First Appellate Court at the first instance did not have jurisdiction to try the suit as it lack pecuniary jurisdiction. In that regard, he

    - 7 -

    submits that the value of the properties which were subject matter of the suit was Rs.35,00,000/- and the value of the share which was under challenge was about Rs.30,00,000/- and the First Appellate Court therefore did not have pecuniary jurisdiction to try the appeal.

    8. Secondly he submits that, since the earlier suit which was dismissed and dismissal of which was confirmed by this Court in RSA.No.1579/2007 indeed amounts to res-judicata. In that view of the matter, he submits that there remained nothing for the First Appellate Court to remand the matter. Hence, he seeks for allowing the present appeal.

    9. Per contra, Sri I.C.Patil, learned counsel for respondent Nos.1 to 5 submits that, the objection with regard to pecuniary jurisdiction ought to have been raised by the defendants at the earliest point of time, that not having been done, the same was amounts to waiver and acquiescence wave. As regards the issue of res-judicata,

    - 8 -

    learned counsel submits that, there cannot be res-judicata in the present suit for partition as there was no partition. Hence, he submits that, the First Appellate Court was justified in remanding the matter to the Trial Court for fresh disposal in accordance with law.

    10. Heard and perused the records.

    11. Section 21(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 reads as under:

    "21. Objections to jurisdiction.-

    (1) xxxxx.

    (2) No objection as to the competence of a Court with reference to the pecuniary limits of its jurisdiction shall be allowed by any Appellate or Revisional Court unless such objection was taken in the Court of first instance at the earliest possible opportunity, and, in all cases where issues are settled, at or before such settlement, and unless there has been a consequent failure of justice."

    12. Thus the first contention of the learned counsel for the appellants, the First Appellate Court lacking pecuniary jurisdiction cannot be countenanced as the objection with regard to pecuniary jurisdiction ought to

    - 9 -

    have been raised at the first instance. Therefore the said plea is not available to be raised at this stage in this appeal.

    13. As regards the second contention of the earlier suit in O.S.No.123/2003 having been dismissed and the dismissal having been confirmed by this Court in RSA.No.1576/2007 amounting to res-judicata, also cannot be countenanced in as much as the suit is one for partition and separate possession and the earlier suit was dismissed on account of plaintiff not adding all the family properties for partition. Since the rights of the parties with regard to partition not having been decided, the dismissal of the suit would not amount to res-judicata.

    14. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of

    V.REJESHWARI (SMT.) VS. T.C.SARAVANABAVA reported in (2004) 1 Supreme Court Cases 551 at paragraph Nos.11 to 13 dealing with res-judicate has held as under:

    "11. The rule of res judicata does not strike at the root of the jurisdiction of the court trying the

    - 10 -

    subsequent suit. It is a rule of estoppel by judgment based on the public policy that there should be a finality to litigation and no one should be vexed twice for the same cause.

    12. The plea of res judicata is founded on proof of certain facts and then by applying the law to the facts so found. It is, therefore, necessary that the foundation for the plea must be laid in the pleadings and then an issue must be framed and tried. A plea not properly raised in the pleadings or in issues at the stage of the trial, would not be permitted to be raised for the first time at the stage of appeal [see (Raja) Jagadish Chandra Deo Dhabal Deb v. Gour Hari Mahato, Medapati Surayya v. Tondapu Bala Gangadhara Ramakrishna Reddi and Katragadda China Anjaneyulu v. Kattaragadda China Ramayya³). The view taken by the Privy Council was cited with approval before this Court in State of Punjab

    v. Bua Das Kaushal. However, an exception was carved out by this Court and the plea was permitted to be raised, though not taken in the pleadings nor covered by any issue, because the necessary facts were present to the mind of the parties and were gone into by the trial court. The opposite party had ample opportunity of leading the evidence in rebuttal of the plea. The Court concluded that the point of res judicata had throughout been

    - 11 -

    in consideration and discussion and so the want of pleadings or plea of waiver of res judicata cannot be allowed to be urged.

    13. Not only the plea has to be taken, it has to be substantiated by case. Maybe, in a given case only copy of judgment in previous suit is filed in proof of plea of res judicata and the judgment contains exhaustive or in requisite details the statement of pleadings and the issues which may be taken as enough proof. But as pointed out in Syed Mohd. Salie Labbai

    v. Mohd. Hanifa the basic method to decide the question of res judicata is first to determine the case of the parties as put forward in their respective pleadings of their previous suit and then to find out as to what had been decided by the judgment which operates as res judicata. It is risky to speculate about the pleadings merely by a summary of recitals of the allegations made in the pleadings mentioned in the judgment. The Constitution Bench in Gurbux Singh v. Bhooralal . placing on a par the plea of res judicata and the plea of estoppel under Order

    2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, held that proof of the plaint in the previous suit which is set to create the bar, ought to be brought on record. The plea is basically founded on the identity of the cause of action in the two suits and, therefore, it is necessary for the defence which raises the bar to

    - 12 -

    establish the cause of action in the previous suit. Such pleas cannot be left to be determined by mere speculation or inferring by a process of deduction what were the facts stated in the previous pleadings. Their Lordships of the Privy Council in Kali Krishna Tagore v. Secy. of State for India in Council pointed out that the plea of res judicata cannot be determined without ascertaining what were the matters in issue in the previous suit and what was heard and decided. Needless to say, these can be found out only by looking into the pleadings. the issues and the judgment in the previous suit."

    15. The First Appellate Court has also taken into consideration of the law laid down by this Court in the case of BABURAO VS. ERANNA AND OTHERS reported in

    ILR 2005 KAR 3177.

    "Evidence Act, 1872-section 115-Doctrine of Estoppel, code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Section II- RES Judicata-Suit for partition-Earlier partition suit filed by one of the brothers dismissed for default- Whether subsequent partition suit is hit by section II of CPC - Held - The right to suit for partition is a continuing right and incidental to the ownership of joint property. So long as the property remains joint, one of the co-owners has a cause of action for bringing a fresh suit for partition

    - 13 -

    notwithstanding the dismissal of a previous suit for partition filed by one of the co-owners. There is no scintilla of evidence and material on record to establish that, the plaintiffs are estopped from seeking relief of partition and separate possession in the joint family properties."

    16. In view of aforesaid settled position of law, no illegality or irregularity can be found with the order passed by the First Appellate Court. In that view of the matter appeal lacks merits, appeal is dismissed. Order of remand is confirmed.

    sd

    JUDGE

    EM

    List No.: 1 Sl No.: 49

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    SMT. LALITAVVA LALITAVVA W/O TIRAKAPPA KABBUR v. SMT. PARVATEVVA W/O SHIVARUDRAPPA
    (Jan 6, 2023)