Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion — G.S. Patel, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The Petitioner is a law student who graduated with an LLB in 2021 from Pravin Gandhi College of Law. He sought writ relief challenging three notices (Exhibits “A”, “A-1” and “A-2”) relating to an advertisement dated 2 March 2023 inviting applications for law clerks in the Bombay High Court (Principal Seat and Benches at Aurangabad and Nagpur).

Exhibit A-1 (dated 12 April 2023) listed 687 rejected applicants; the Petitioner appeared at Sr. No. 639 and his application was rejected on the ground that he had not submitted a recommendation as required by the advertisement. Twenty rejected applicants filed representations; the Petitioner filed a representation on 17 April 2023. On 9 May 2023 the Registrar-General published a notice accepting some representations, but the Petitioner's representation was not accepted.

The Petitioner filed the present Writ Petition on 17 May 2023 (during the summer recess), sought a listing by praecipe on 13 June 2023, by which time the selection and interview process before a committee of two judges had begun. The advertisement had been issued pursuant to revised High Court guidelines for assignment of work as law clerks.

The Court granted leave for the Petitioner to appear in person and made the rule returnable forthwith.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the procedure in clause (2) of the advertisement (and corresponding Guideline 3) requiring "recommendation" and, specifically, the requirement in clause (xiii) that colleges be "recognized by the University Grants Commission" (subject to the Chief Justice's approval) lawfully excludes students of affiliated colleges such as Pravin Gandhi College of Law from eligibility.
  2. Whether the Registry could lawfully reject the Petitioner’s application on the ground that Pravin Gandhi College of Law did not have separate UGC recognition under Section 2(f) of the UGC Act.
  3. Whether, as a consequence of any illegality in the advertisement/its application, the Petitioner should be added to the list of eligible candidates for the selection process (i.e., relief in the nature of mandamus as sought in prayer clause (c)).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The Petitioner pointed out that Pravin Gandhi College of Law is an affiliated college of the University of Mumbai; his mark sheet and passing certificate are issued by the University of Mumbai (not by the college), demonstrating that the college is affiliated to a UGC-recognised university.
  • The Petitioner argued that the Registry misread or misapplied the guideline by requiring UGC recognition of an affiliated college; the Petitioner contended that the UGC recognition requirement under Section 2(f) applies to universities or deemed universities, not to affiliated colleges.
  • The Petitioner sought inclusion in the list of eligible candidates for the ongoing selection process and challenged the rejection as unlawful insofar as it rested on the asserted lack of UGC recognition of his college.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Dr. Sathe for the Respondent relied on clause (xiii) of the advertisement, submitting that other colleges may be included only if they are recognised by the UGC and subject to approval by the Hon'ble the Chief Justice.
  • The Respondent pointed to an email exchange in which the Registrar (Personnel) queried the UGC on 24 April 2023; the UGC replied on 26 April 2023 indicating that Pravin Gandhi College of Law was not included under Section 2(f) of the UGC Act.
  • The Respondent submitted that any relief should operate prospectively (i.e., not affect the ongoing interviews and selections already begun).

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the advertisement's procedure for submitting applications (item 2 / Guideline 3) and focused on clause (xiii), which allowed "any other reputed Law College recognised by University Grants Commission subject to approval by the Hon'ble the Chief Justice."

The Court noted a lack of clarity in clause (xiii): it was unclear what "subject to the approval of the Hon'ble the Chief Justice" added if the sole requirement were UGC approval, because the Court found it inconceivable that a college holding necessary UGC approval would nevertheless be refused by the Chief Justice.

The Court addressed the Registrar's query to the UGC and the UGC's reply that Pravin Gandhi College of Law was not listed under Section 2(f). The Court found that the query, and the reliance on that reply, showed a misunderstanding: Section 2(f) of the UGC Act pertains to universities or deemed universities, not affiliated colleges. The Court relied on documentary evidence (the Petitioner's mark sheet and passing certificate issued by the University of Mumbai) to establish that the Petitioner had graduated from a college affiliated to the University of Mumbai, which is recognised by the UGC.

The Court highlighted internal inconsistencies and practical absurdities in the advertisement's procedures: for example, a student of an affiliated college who is otherwise qualified to practice (obtain a sanad and licence from the Bar Council) being ineligible for a law-clerk post because the college purportedly lacked separate UGC recognition; and the alternative path permitting recommendation by presidents of Advocates' Associations, which the Court described as effectively elevating such recommendations above the result of a qualifying law course.

On these bases, the Court concluded that the Registry had misread and misapplied the guideline by insisting on separate UGC recognition for an affiliated college like Pravin Gandhi College of Law. The Court observed that the rejection of the Petitioner's application before it was based solely on that asserted lack of UGC recognition and that no other grounds of rejection were shown to the Court.

The Court expressly limited its findings to the facts of the present Petitioner and to Pravin Gandhi College of Law; it declined to make broader observations regarding other colleges or candidates.

Holding and Implications

The Court summarized its holdings in three numbered parts:

  1. Recognition by the UGC is a valid criterion only for institutions that are universities or deemed universities which require UGC recognition; colleges affiliated to a recognised university do not require separate UGC recognition (example given: Pravin Gandhi College of Law).
  2. The Registry is not entitled to demand that every college have separate recognition by the UGC.
  3. The Petitioner shall be included in the list of eligible candidates to be considered and included in the selection process, subject to meeting all other eligibility criteria.

The Court's dispositive order was:

Rule made absolute in terms of prayer clause (c). The Petition succeeds to that extent. The relief sought in prayer clauses (a) and (b) (quashing of the impugned notices/Clause (2)) is rejected. No costs were awarded.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The Petitioner is to be restored to the list of eligible candidates for the selection process (subject to other eligibility requirements); the earlier rejection on the ground of lack of UGC recognition for his affiliated college is set aside.
  • Scope: The Court explicitly refrained from making broad pronouncements about other colleges or candidates; it limited its decision to the facts before it and to the Pravin Gandhi College of Law, indicating that no sweeping new precedent beyond that factual context was intended.

    Madhav Rajesh Ved v. Registrar General .

    G.S. Patel, J.:— Rule. Rule returnable forthwith.

    2. We grant leave to the Petitioner to appear in person.

    3. The Petitioner is a law student. He recently graduated with an LLB in 2021 from the Pravin Gandhi College of Law. He seeks a writ of certiorari to quash three notices at Exhibits “A”, “A-1” and “A-2” to the Petition. Alternatively, he seeks certiorari to quash clause (2) of Exhibit “A”. The third prayer is for a mandamus to add the Petitioner's name to the list of eligible candidates for the selection process for law clerks in this High Court.

    4. Exhibit “A” is an advertisement dated 2 March 2023 inviting applications for the position of law clerks in the Bombay High Court (at its Principal Seat and at its Benches in Aurangabad and Nagpur). Exhibit “A-1” is a list of 687 persons whose applications were rejected. That communication is of 12 April 2023. The Petitioner's name is at Sr. No 639 of this list and the reason for rejection was that the Petitioner had not submitted a recommendation as per the advertisement. Twenty of the rejected persons filed representations. On 17 April 2023, the Petitioner filed an representation. On 9 May 2023, the Respondent, the Registrar-General, published a notice accepting some of the representations. The Petitioner was not among the persons whose representations were accepted. The Petitioner filed this Writ Petition on 17 May 2023 (during the summer recess). He then sought a listing vide a praecipe dated 13 June 2023. By this time, the selection/interview process (before a committee of two judges) had begun.

    5. The advertisement in question was admittedly issued pursuant to certain revised guidelines adopted by the High Court for the assignment of work as Law Clerks.

    6. The specific challenge is to what is described as the three-part “procedure for submitting applications”. There is some mismatch in the numbering between the Guidelines and the advertisement. eligibility criteria are set out in Clause 1 of the advertisement (corresponding to Guideline 2), and there is no quarrel with those criteria. There is also no quarrel with the other provisions of the guidelines or the advertisement, namely, the selection process, the nature of work, the honorarium, the term of the assignment, the restriction on practice, requirements of conduct and the schedule programme for a selection process.

    7. Guideline 3, which is item 2 of the advertisement, reads thus:

    2. Procedure for submitting Applications:—

    (A) The candidature of each applicant should be recommended by the Principals of nay of the following institutions:

    i) National Law School, Bangalore

    ii) National Law School, Hyderabad

    iii) N. U. J. S. Law College, Calcutta

    iv) National Law School, Jodhpur

    v) Government Law Collage, Churchgate, Mumbai

    vi) ILS Law College, Pune

    vii) Symbiosis Law College, Pune

    viii) University College of Law, Nagpur

    ix) M.P. Law Collage, Aurangabad.

    x) Yashwant Law College, Nanded.

    xi) V.M. Salgaonkar, Law College, Miramar, Panaji.

    xii) Kare Law College, Margao, Goa or

    xiii) Any other reputed Law College recognized by University Grants Commission subject to approval by the Hon'ble the Chief Justice.

    B) The Applicants who have passed the L.L.B/L.L.M. examinations may in the alternative be recommended by:—

    For Principal Seat at Bombay:—

    a) the President of the Bombay Bar Association; or

    b) the President of the Advocates Association of Western India; or

    c) the President of the Incorporated Law Society

    d) For Bench at Nagpur the President, High Court Bar Association, Nagpur.

    e) For Bench at Aurangabad the President, High Court Bar Association, Aurangabad

    f) For Bench at Panji-Goa the President, High Court Bar Association, Panji Goa The Pravin Gandhi College of Law is not in the list of named colleges, the principals of which can recommend the candidate.

    8. Dr. Sathe for the Respondent draws our attention to Clause (xiii), emphasised above. He says that this allows other colleges to be included, provided they are recognised by the University Grants Commission (“UGC”) and this is also subject to approval by the Hon'ble the Chief Justice.

    9. There are significant difficulties with this Clause as it presently stands. We are unable to understand what is meant by ‘subject to the approval of the Hon'ble the Chief Justice’ if the requirement is UGC approval. For, it is inconceivable that if necessary UGC approval exists, there could ever be a refusal by the Hon'ble the Chief Justice.

    10. But the more fundamental question is whether every college requires UGC recognition. Dr. Sathe submits that pursuant to an email query by the Registrar (Personnel) on 24 April 2023 listing five colleges, of which the Pravin Gandhi College of Law was one, the UGC replied on 26 April 2023 saying that the Pravin Gandhi College of Law was not included in the list of colleges under Section 2(f) of the University Grants Commission Act.

    11. This really exemplifies the well-known saying, “Ask a wrong a question and you will get a wrong answer”. The reason is plain. Pravin Gandhi College of Law is not a university. It is not a deemed university. It is affiliated to Mumbai University, unquestionably recognized by the UGC. This is evident from the Petitioner's mark sheet that is annexed at page 133 and by the passing certificate at page 132, both of which are issued by the University of Mumbai, not the Pravin Gandhi College of Law, as the Petitioner quickly points out. There is no doubt that although the University of Mumbai is, curiously enough, not amongst the 12 universities listed in the list, it is undoubtedly recognised by the UGC.

    12. Therefore, there was no question of the Pravin Gandhi College of Law being ‘recognised’ by the UGC.

    13. The contradictions do not stop there. Nobody disputes that students who have passed the LLB from the Pravin Gandhi College of Law can obtain a sanad and a licence to practice from the Bar Council of Maharashtra and Goa after passing the qualifying examinations. What we are therefore being told is that a student of the Pravin Gandhi College of Law can practice as an Advocate but cannot be considered for the post of a Law Clerk.

    14. Then comes the third inconsistency. If the college institute in question is not among those listed and does not have the UGC certification (allegedly), though required, then, apparently, all is not lost — because the student can ‘alternatively’ get a recommendation from one of the Presidents of the Advocates' Associations. This borders on the farcical at two levels. First, it means that a student of law at a university or deemed university that does not have the necessary UGC approval can simply get by with a recommendation from a bar association president; implying that the recommendation is superior to a qualifying law course. Second, if a law graduate is entitled to practice law, it does not stand to reason that he or she should have to go to a President of a Bar Association or an Advocates' Association to get a recommendation to be considered as a Law Clerk.

    15. Dr. Sathe's submission that the Petitioner's case should be considered ‘prospectively’ (i.e., not in the ongoing interviews and selections) does not commend itself to us. This is a case where a guideline has simply been misread, misunderstood, and misapplied by executive action. The consequences of that error cannot be visited on the Petitioner. There is simply no concept or requirement of UGC recognition of an affiliated college under Section 2(f). That requirement only applies to a university or a deemed university. Colleges come under UGC purview only in relation to a question of aid. There may indeed be colleges that are or claim to be independent or deemed universities that require UGC accreditation. There may indeed be colleges that are or claim to be independent or deemed universities that require UGC recognition. But this does not mean that every affiliated college requires UGC recognition. Nothing in the guideline or the UGC Act suggests this. Consequently, the Respondents' insistence on “UGC Recognition” for the Pravin Gandhi College of Law, demonstrably affiliated to Mumbai University, cannot be sustained. The rejection of the Petitioner's application is on this solitary ground, at least before us. No other ground of rejection is shown to us.

    16. We are making no broader observation in regard to other colleges or other law clerk candidates. The Petitioner has quite correctly restricted himself to the facts of the case that are applicable to him in regard to the Pravin Gandhi College of Law and the unlawful rejection of his own application.

    17. Prayer clauses (a), (b) and (c) of the Petition read thus:—

    “(a) That this Hon'ble Court be pleased to issue a Writ of Certiorari or any other writ in the nature of Certiorari or any other appropriate writ, order or direction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India calling for all the papers and proceedings in the matter, and after going through the same, quash and/or set aside the Impugned Notices [Exhibits ‘A’, ‘A-1’ and ‘A-2’ hereto], as being perverse, arbitrary, unreasonable and illegal;

    (b) in the alternative to prayer clause (a) hereinabove, this Hon'ble Court be pleased to issue a Writ of Certiorari or any other writ in the nature of Certiorari or any other appropriate writ, order or direction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India calling for all the papers and proceedings in the matter, and after going through the same, quash and/or set aside the Clause (2) of the Impugned Notice [Exhibit ‘A’] and the Impugned Notices at Exhibits ‘A-1’ and ‘A-2’ as being perverse, arbitrary, unreasonable and illegal;

    (c) this Hon'ble Court be pleased to issue a Writ of Mandamus or any other writ in the of Mandamus or any other appropriate writ order or direction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India directing the Respondent to add the Petitioner's name in the list of eligible candidates”

    18. This is also not a PIL or a representative action. We are not concerned with the other applicants. Of the 687 rejected, 20 made representations. Only some were accepted. Of those whose representations were not accepted, only the Petitioner has come to court. We find, too, that there is no great or unexplained delay on the part of the Petitioner, as the foregoing dates show.

    19. In view of the foregoing discussion, we hold as follows:

    (a) Recognition by the UGC is a valid criterion only for those colleges or institutes that are universities or deemed universities that require UGC recognition in the first place. To clarify, colleges that are affiliated to a recognised university do not require separate recognition by the UGC, for example, the Pravin Gandhi College of Law.

    (b) It is, therefore, not open to the Registry to demand that every college must have separate recognition by the UGC.

    (c) The Petitioner is to be included in the list of eligible candidates for being considered and included in the selection process, subject to meeting all other eligibility criteria.

    20. The Petition succeeds to this extent. Rule is made absolute in terms of prayer clause (c). The relief in terms of prayer clauses (a) or, alternatively, (b), is rejected. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Madhav Rajesh Ved v. Registrar General .
    (Jun 14, 2023)