AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2023 DHC 3748
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 15 of the Patents Act, 1970
  • Section 3(n) of the Act
  • Patents Act, 1970 i.e. Section 3(k)
  • Section 3(k) of the Act
  • Section 2(1)(j) of the Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2023 DHC 3748
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 15 of the Patents Act, 1970
  • Section 3(n) of the Act
  • Patents Act, 1970 i.e. Section 3(k)
  • Section 3(k) of the Act
  • Section 2(1)(j) of the Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The present appeal challenges the order dated 18 November 2019 passed by the Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs, who refused the patent application no. 1983/DELNP/2008 filed by Microsoft Technology Licensing LLC. The application concerned an invention titled "FILTERING USER INTERFACE FOR A DATA SUMMARY TABLE." The Controller raised objections primarily under Section 3(k) of the Patents Act, 1970, on the ground that the invention was a "computer program per se" and thus non-patentable. Although other objections under Sections 2(1)(j) (lack of inventive step) and 3(n) (presentation of information) were noted, the Controller ultimately rejected the application solely under Section 3(k). The appellant challenged this order before the Delhi High Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the invention claimed in the patent application qualifies as patentable subject matter under the Patents Act, 1970, specifically considering the exclusion of "computer program per se" under Section 3(k).
  2. Whether the Controller erred in applying the 2016 Guidelines for Examination of Computer-Related Inventions instead of the revised 2017 Guidelines.
  3. Whether the absence of novel hardware in the invention necessarily precludes patentability of a computer-related invention.
  4. The proper interpretation and application of the principles laid down in the decision of this Court in Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson (PUBL) v. Intex Technologies (India) Limited regarding technical contribution and technical effect in computer-related inventions.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent's (Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs) Arguments

  • The invention is excluded from patentability under Section 3(k) as it is a computer program per se.
  • The claimed invention involves processing data via software executed on a general purpose computer without any novel hardware component.
  • The contribution of the invention lies solely in software and does not demonstrate a technical effect or technical contribution beyond conventional programming.
  • Reliance on the 2016 Guidelines for Examination of Computer-Related Inventions to assess patentability.
  • Rejected the appellant’s reliance on the Ericsson vs. Intex decision, holding that the invention does not meet the technical contribution requirement.

Appellant's Arguments

  • Contended that the invention complies with the requirements set forth by the Delhi High Court in Ericsson vs. Intex, which recognizes patentability if the invention has a technical contribution or effect beyond a computer program per se.
  • Argued that the Controller should have applied the revised 2017 Guidelines for Examination of Computer-Related Inventions, which provide clearer criteria emphasizing technical effect and contribution.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson (PUBL) v. Intex Technologies (India) Limited (2015 SCC OnLine Del 82) Recognition that a computer program may be patentable if it demonstrates a technical contribution or technical effect beyond a computer program per se. The Court found that the Controller misapplied this precedent by failing to consider the possibility of patentability without novel hardware and by ignoring the technical contribution principle.
Ferid Allani v. Union of India (2019 SCC OnLine Del 11867) Guidance on analysis of technical contribution and technical effect in patent applications related to computer programs. The Court directed that the Controller’s reconsideration of the application should be guided by the observations made in this case along with the 2017 CRI Guidelines.
Ericsson vs. Intex (Order in CS (OS) No. 1045/2014 dated March 13, 2015) Establishes that inventions with technical contribution or technical effect are patentable even if they involve computer programs. The Controller rejected the appellant's reliance on this case, but the Court found such rejection unsustainable and emphasized the need to apply the technical contribution test correctly.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the Impugned Order and found multiple errors in the Controller's approach. First, the Controller examined the patent application under the outdated 2016 Guidelines for Examination of Computer-Related Inventions, disregarding the 2017 revised Guidelines that were in force at the time of the decision. The 2017 Guidelines clarify the criteria for patentability of computer-related inventions, focusing on technical effect and technical contribution rather than the mere presence of novel hardware.

Second, the Court noted that the Controller misapplied the decision in Ericsson v. Intex by failing to acknowledge that a computer program may be patentable if it produces a technical effect or contribution, even without novel hardware. The Controller's reasoning that the absence of novel hardware automatically renders the invention non-patentable was incorrect.

The Court emphasized that under the 2017 Guidelines, patentability depends on whether the invention demonstrates a technical advancement and contribution beyond a generic computer program. The focus is on the technical nature and effect of the invention, not merely on hardware components.

Accordingly, the Court concluded that the Impugned Order is fundamentally flawed and must be quashed. The Controller was directed to reconsider the application afresh, analyzing the technical contribution and effect in light of the 2017 Guidelines, relevant case law including Ferid Allani v. Union of India, and the Manual of Patent Office Practice and Procedure (2019).

Holding and Implications

The Court ALLOWED the appeal and QUASHED the Impugned Order dated 18 November 2019.

The Controller of Patents is directed to re-examine the patent application considering the technical contribution and technical effect of the invention under the 2017 Guidelines and relevant judicial precedents. The decision on the application shall be rendered within four months from the date of release of the Court’s order.

The Court did not express any opinion on other objections raised by the Controller in the hearing notice, but expects a comprehensive order addressing all objections in the fresh examination.

This decision does not establish new precedent beyond reaffirming the application of the 2017 Guidelines and the principles enunciated in prior case law. It directly affects the parties by setting aside the prior rejection and mandating reconsideration consistent with current legal standards.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    MICROSOFT TECHNOLOGY LICENSING LLC  v. ASSISTANT CONTROLLER OF PATENTS AND DESIGNS

    2023:DHC:3748

    C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 140/2022 Page 1 of 6

    $~2 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI Date of Decision:10th May, 2023

    + C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 140/2022 MICROSOFT TECHNOLOGY LICENSING LLC ..... Appellant Through: Ms. Vindhya S. Mani, Mr. Gursimran Singh Narula and Ms. Vaishali Joshi, Advocates.

    versus

    ASSISTANT CONTROLLER OF PATENTS AND DESIGNS

    ..... Respondent

    Through: Mr. Harish Vaidyanathan Shankar, CGSC with Mr. Srish Kumar Mishra, Mr. Sagar Mehlawat and Mr.

    Alexander Mathai Paikaday,

    Advocates.

    CORAM:

    HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA

    JUDGMENT

    SANJEEV NARULA, J. (Oral)

    1. The present appeal is directed against order of the Assistant Controller of Patents and Design (Respondent) dated 18 November 2019 ("Impugned Order") under Section 15 of the Patents Act, 1970 ("Act") refusing Appellant's patent application 1983/DELNP/2008 for the invention titled

    "FILTERING USER INTERFACE FOR A DATA SUMMARY TABLE".

    2. In the hearing notice, the Controller raised objections on the following grounds: (A) Section 2(1)(j) of the Act, asserting that the invention lacks inventive steps in light of the prior arts, cited as D1 to D4. (B) The invention

    1

    being a "computer program per se" is non-patentable under Section 3(k) of the Act; and (C) subject matter of amended claims 1 to 9 are excluded as per Section 3(n) of the Act (presentation of information). However, the Controller finally rejected the application under Section 3(k) of the Act, without delving into the other objections.

    3. The Court has heard counsel for parties. Controller's reasoning in support of findings rendered by him are as follows:

    "Regarding objection no. 9 |section 3(K)|:-

    Amended claims 1-10 still objected to as being non-statutory subject matter under the provisions contained in section 3 (k) of the Patents act 1970. The present invention (i.e., as claimed in claim 1 and claim 9) involves processing large amount of primary data based on one or more filter options as has been claimed in claim 9. Furthermore, the present subject matter also involves determining the data type of the data present within one or more field and automatically moving the field into the appropriate zone within the layout pane. Pertinent Section of the statute:

    The section 3(k) of Patents Act is quoted below for reference:

    a mathematical or business method or a computer program per se or algorithms. The section proscribes patenting of matter falling under any of the categories mentioned above. Admittedly, the matter does not relate to a mathematical or business method. However, whether it pertains to category titled computer program per se is an inquiry which I would make in the light of the facts pertinent to this case.

    In the recently published guidelines for examining the computer related inventions, the test indicators to determine patentability are:

    1. Properly construe the claim and identify the actual contribution;

    2. If the contribution lies only in mathematical method, business method or algorithm, deny the claim;

    3. If the contribution lies in the field of computer programme, check whether it is claimed in conjunction with a novel hardware and proceed to other steps to determine patentability with respect to the invention. The computer programme in itself is never patentable. If the contribution lies solely in the computer programme, deny the claim. If the contribution lies in both the computer programme as well as hardware, proceed to other steps of patentability.

    2

    If I read through the principal claim 1 and 9, I find that there is a general purpose computer system, in which method steps are executed.

    From the above paragraph, it is clear that the actual contribution of the invention solely lies in software and there is no specific hardware available in the claimed invention. All the steps of the invention are carried out by computer program only. The only hardware mentioned in the present invention are the general purpose computer system, which comprises processor which executes program in a conventional or normal manner.

    Applicant's submission that the present invention complies with the official requirements set forth by the Hon'ble Delhi High Court in Ericsson vs. Intex (order in CS (OS) No. 1045/ 2014 dated March 13, 2015). The order holds that, 'Thus, it is appears to me prima facie that any invention which has a technical contribution or has a technical effect and is not merely a computer program per se alleged by the defendant and the same is patentable.' In this regard, it is stated that claimed invention does not qualify the said order as the contribution lies solely in the area of the excluded subject matter as computer program. If the computer program is able to operate the computer/system in a new and different way to consider it has a technical effect/technical contribution rather than processing the data in a conventional manner. Therefore, in view of the above, the claims 1-10 are not patentable u/s 3 (k) for being computer program per se. It is noted that although the hearing submissions have attempted to address the other requirements, yet without fulfilling the substantive requirements of the Patents Act, 1970 i.e. Section 3(k), this instant application is not found in order for grant.

    Thus, in view of the aforesaid and unsatisfactory submissions made by the Agents in respect of the pertinent requirements as raised in the said hearing notice, this instant application no. 1983/DELNP/2008 does not comply with the requirements of the Patents Act, 1970. I, therefore, hereby order that the grant of a patent is refused under the provisions of Section 15 of the Patents Act.

    Dated: 18/11/2019

    (Srinivasarao Reesu) Assistant Controller of Patents & Designs"

    4. Heard the counsel for parties. The Impugned Order is not legally tenable for several reasons discussed hereinafter. Firstly, the subject application has been examined relying upon Guidelines for Examination of Computer-Related Inventions (CRIs) of 2016, without noticing the revised guidelines of 2017 ("CRI 2017 Guidelines") which were in force on the

    3

    date of passing of the Impugned Order.1CRI 2017 Guidelines provide clarification on the patentability of computer-related inventions and bring more clarity and consistency to the examination process for computer- related inventions. They cite the Joint Parliamentary Committee discussions on introduction of the term 'per se' with computer programme under Section 3(k) of the Act, which notes the legislative intent behind introducing the phrase 'per se'. These new CRI guidelines outline certain criteria that inventions related to computer programs, must meet in order to be considered patentable in India which is radically different from the previous version of the guidelines that have been relied upon by the Controller. One of the key improvements in the CRI 2017 Guidelines is the increased focus on technical effect and technical contributions. The new guidelines emphasize that for an invention to be eligible for a patent, it must demonstrate a technical advancement and a technical contribution beyond the generic computer program. The ambiguities and uncertainties that existed in the previous guidelines have been removed and CRI 2017 Guidelines. They provide more specific criteria for determining the patentability of computer-related inventions. Thus, Controller's examination through the prism of 2016 Guidelines cannot be sustained and the subject invention must be re-examined.

    5. Secondly, the Controller has misapplied the decision of this Court in

    Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson (PUBL) v. Intex Technologies (India)

    1 On page 3 of the Impugned Order, Respondent has given only a vague indication that the present invention has been analysed under the recently published guidelines for examining the computer related inventions. However, the guidelines quoted on page 4 of the Impugned Order are not from the latest CRI 2017 Guidelines.

    4

    Limited.2Despite acknowledging the significance of technical effect and contribution as guiding principles in the evaluation of Computer-Related Inventions (CRIs), the Respondent fails to consider the Court's observations that even a computer program may qualify for patent protection if it showcases a technical contribution to the field or delivers a discernible technical effect.

    6. Thirdly, the Controller has emphasised upon the lack of novel hardware as one of the grounds for rejecting the patent application. In the Court's view, the Controller has wrongly assumed that absence of novel hardware renders computer programme to be inherently non-patentable. This observation is erroneous as for technical effect and contribution in the field of computer programmes, conjunction with novel hardware may not be always be necessary. Under the 2017 CRI Guidelines, dependency on novel hardware is not mandatory for the patentability of computer-related inventions. The CRI 2017 Guidelines acknowledge that inventions related to computer programs can be patentable if they meet the criteria of demonstrating a technical advancement and a technical contribution beyond the generic computer program. In other words, even if an invention is purely software-based, it may still be considered patentable if it provides a technical solution to a technical problem and goes beyond conventional programming techniques. The focus is on the technical nature and technical effect of the invention rather than the presence of specific hardware components. Thus, the entire foundation of the Impugned Order is flawed and it deserves to be set aside.

    7. For the foregoing reasons, the present appeal deserves to be allowed.

    2 2 015 SCC OnLine Del 82 2 9 at Paragraph 12 0.

    5

    The Impugned Order is quashed. The Controller shall re-consider the application and analyse the technical contribution and technical effect of the invention claimed in the subject application. This decision shall be rendered keeping in mind the observations made herein above, the views expressed by this Court in Ferid Allani v. Union of India3, CRI 2017 Guidelines, Manual of Patent Office Practice and Procedure (2019), as also other judgments on this issue rendered by this Court.

    8. Taking into account the relatively short lifespan of the potential patent, which is projected to expire as early as 2026, it is hereby ordered that a decision shall be reached within a timeframe of four months, starting from date of release of this order.

    9. The Court has not expressed any opinion on the other objections raised in the hearing notice. However, it is expected that the Controller shall, pass a comprehensive order dealing with other objections set out in the hearing notice while deciding the application afresh.

    10. Allowed in the above terms.

    SANJEEV NARULA, J

    MAY 10, 2023

    d.negi

    [Corrected and released on 27th May, 2023]

    6

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    MICROSOFT TECHNOLOGY LICENSING LLC  v. ASSISTANT CONTROLLER OF PATENTS AND DESIGNS
    (May 10, 2023)