AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Plaintiff, associated with edible-oil products bearing the registered “MAHAKOSH” trademark, complained of a video circulated on Facebook and WhatsApp containing allegedly disparaging and misleading remarks about its product. [1][2]

After issuing cease-and-desist notices and receiving no reply, the Plaintiff filed the proceedings against the platform-related defendants and arrayed Defendant No. 3 as “Ashok Kumar” in a John-Deo action. [3][4]

The application was urgently listed after private notice, with the affidavit of service directed to be filed within one week. [5] The Court permitted correction of the prayer clauses by replacing “decree of permanent injunction” with “temporary injunction”; the amendment was to be made within one week and re-verification was dispensed with. [6]

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Plaintiff was entitled to urgent ad-interim relief under Section 29(8)(a) and (c) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999, in relation to the allegedly disparaging video. [1][7]
  2. Whether temporary injunctions should restrain infringement and circulation of the video and require its removal from online platforms. [8][9][10][11]

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The video contained disparaging remarks about the Plaintiff’s edible-oil product bearing the registered “MAHAKOSH” trademark, and urgent relief was necessary to prevent continuing reputational harm. [1]
  • The video allegedly infringed the Plaintiff’s trademark and spread misleading and false information about the product. [2]
  • The Plaintiff relied on its word-mark and device-mark registrations, existing at least from 1998, together with its goodwill, turnover, advertising expenditure, and market presence. [12]
  • The Plaintiff stated that the videos targeted a particular community, promoted misinformation, and called for a boycott of the product. [13]
  • The Plaintiff issued cease-and-desist notices and requested removal of the videos, but received no response. [3]

Defendant No. 2's Arguments

  • Counsel for Defendant No. 2 appeared and objected to the grant of ad-interim relief against that defendant. [14]
  • The Plaintiff, on instructions, stated that it was not pressing ad-interim relief against Defendant No. 2 at that stage. [14]

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the material on record, including the Plaintiff’s contentions, the transcription of the video, and the documents concerning the registered marks. [15][7]

It found that the prima facie ingredients of Section 29(8)(a) and (c) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999, were satisfied. The video available on Defendant No. 1’s platform prima facie infringed the Plaintiff’s registered trademark, establishing a strong prima facie case for ad-interim relief. [7]

The Court further held that refusal of interim protection was likely to cause the Plaintiff grave and irreparable loss, and that the balance of convenience favoured the Plaintiff. [16]

Although relief was granted in terms of prayers (a), (b), and (c), the Plaintiff did not press relief against Defendant No. 2. The Court therefore clarified that the ad-interim relief would operate against Defendants Nos. 1 and 3, and directed Defendant No. 1 to take down the URLs specified in Exhibit “G” to the plaint. [8][14][17]

Holding and Implications

AD-INTERIM RELIEF GRANTED. The Court granted temporary injunctions restraining trademark infringement, restraining circulation of the impugned video, and directing its removal from the relevant online platforms, with the operative relief applying against Defendants Nos. 1 and 3. [8][9][10][11][17]

The application was listed for further consideration on 27 June 2023. [18] The direct effect was interim protection of the Plaintiff’s trademark and removal of the specified online content; the opinion cited no precedents and set no new precedent.

    Patanjali Foods Limited Applicant/plaintiff v. Meta Platforms Inc And Others Defendants.

    Manish Pitale, J.:— Heard, Mr. Prathamesh Kamat, learned Counsel appearing for the Applicant/Plaintiff.

    2. The Plaintiff had given private notice to the Defendants about listing of the application yesterday. An affidavit of Service is ready. The application is directed to be listed today, due to urgency in the matter. The affidavit of service be placed on record within one week from today.

    3. At the outset, the learned Counsel appearing for the Applicant submits that inadvertently there are typographical errors in prayer clauses of the application. Permission is sought to replace the words “decree of permanent injunction” with the words “temporary injunction”. In the interest of justice, the Applicant is permitted to carryout the said amendments in the prayer clauses of the application. The amendment be carried out within one week from today. Re-verification is dispensed with.

    4. The learned Counsel for the Applicant/Plaintiff submits that there is urgency in the matter, for the reason that the Plaintiff is aggrieved by a video circulating on Facebook pages containing disparaging remarks against the product of the Plaintiff i.e. edible oil bearing the registered trademark “MAHAKOSH”. It is the case of the Plaintiff that unless urgent ad-interim reliefs are granted, the said videos would continue to hurt the reputation of the registered trademark of the Plaintiff. Section 29(8) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999, particularly clauses (a) and (c) thereof, are invoked on behalf of the Plaintiff in the present proceedings, while pressing for urgent ad-interim reliefs.

    5. The Plaintiff is stated to be a leading manufacturer and marketer of a range of edible oils and it is a pioneer of Soya foods in India. It is the case of the Plaintiff that the defamatory video on online platforms has been circulated against a particular product of the Plaintiff called Mahakosh Refined Soyabean Oil. The video, not only infringes the registered trademark of the Plaintiff, but it has the effect of spreading misleading and false information and impression in the minds of the general public with regard to the said product of the Plaintiff bearing the registered trademark.

    6. The learned Counsel for the Plaintiff invited attention of this Court to the contents of the plaint and copies of certificates of registration of trademarks to show that the Plaintiff has registration for word mark “MAHAKOSH” and also a device mark. Such registrations have been granted in favour of the Plaintiff for a long period of time and atleast from the year 1998 onwards. It is submitted that substantial goodwill has been created in favour of the Plaintiff in the context of the said registered trademarks. in the aforesaid product. Reference is made to the sales turnover of the Plaintiff, to indicate that for the past about 10 years, the turnover has been about Rs. 55,35,068 Crores. Reference is also made to the substantial amounts spent by the Plaintiff towards advertisement and sales promotion, further indicating the presence of the Plaintiff in the edible oil market and in the public domain for a considerable period of time.

    7. According to the Plaintiff, sometime in the middle of April, 2023, the distributors and officials of the Plaintiff came across videos uploaded on the platform of Defendant No. 1, wherein disparaging remarks have been made about the product of the Plaintiff bearing the registered trademark. A particular community has been targeted to spread mis-information and disparaging information about the products of the Plaintiff, with a call to boycott of the said product.

    8. It is stated that upon noticing the aforesaid video being run on platforms of Defendant No. 1, including Facebook and WhatsApp, the Plaintiff issued cease and desist notices to Defendant No. 1 in April, 2023, and also an e-mail to take specific steps in order to ensure that such videos would be deleted from the platform. Since, there was no reply to the aforesaid notices, the Plaintiff is constrained to file the present proceedings.

    9. The Plaintiff has arrayed Defendant No. 3 as “Ashok Kumar” in the nature of a “John-Deo” action.

    10. The contents of the video are brought to the notice of this Court by quoting the transcription of the said video in the body of the plaint and annexing relevant documents to impress upon this Court that disparaging remarks have been indeed made against the product of the Plaintiff bearing the registered trademark “MAHAKOSH”, as also a related device mark.

    11. This Court has perused the material on record in the backdrop of the contentions raised on behalf of the Plaintiff. Considering the material on record, this Court is satisfied that prima facie the ingredients of Section 29(8)(a) and (c) of the aforesaid Act are made out. The contents of the video in question, available an the platform of Defendant No. 1, prima facie appears to have infringed upon the registered trademark of the Plaintiff. A strong prima facie case is indeed made out for granting ad-interim reliefs in favour of the Plaintiff.

    12. This Court is further convinced that unless ad-interim reliefs as prayed are granted in favour of the Plaintiff, it is likely to suffer grave and irreparable loss, thereby showing that the balance of convenience is in favour of the Plaintiff.

    13. In view of the above, there shall be ad-interim reliefs in favour of the Plaintiff in terms of prayer clauses (a), (b) and (c), which read as follows:

    “a. That pending hearing and final disposal of the present Suit, this Hon'ble Court be pleased to pass a order of temporary injunction restraining Defendants by themselves, their servants, employees, agents, dealers, distributors and all persons claiming under them from infringing the Applicant's registered trademarks, including “MAHAKOSH FUTURE FIT”;

    b. That pending hearing and final disposal of the present Suit, this Hon'ble Court be pleased to pass a order of temporary injunction against Defendant Nos. 1 and 2, restraining them from circulation of the Impugned Video, storyboard of which is annexed at Exhibit-“C” to the Plaint;

    c. That pending hearing and final disposal of the present Suit, this Hon'ble Court be pleased to pass a order of temporary injunction directing Defendant Nos. 1 and 2 to remove the Impugned Video (storyboard of which is annexed hereto at Exhibit-“C” to the Plaint) from their online platforms;”

    14. The Plaintiff reserves its right to press for ad-interim relief in terms of prayer clause (d).

    15. Mr. Shailesh Poria, learned Counsel has entered appeared on behalf of Defendant No. 2 and he objects to grant of ad-interim relief against the said Defendant. The learned Counsel for the Plaintiff, on instructions, submits that the Plaintiff, as on today, is not pressing ad-interim reliefs against the Defendant No. 2.

    16. Thus, it is made clear that the ad-interim reliefs granted hereinabove shall operate against Defendant Nos. 1 and 3. Consequently, the Defendant No. 1 shall take down URLs specified at Exhibit “G” to the Plaint.

    17. List the application for further consideration on 27th June, 2023.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Patanjali Foods Limited Applicant/plaintiff v. Meta Platforms Inc And Others Defendants.
    (May 4, 2023)