AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Appellant, Superintending Engineer (TPSODL), filed Arbitration Appeal No.37 of 2022 under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, challenging the order dated 14.09.2022 by the learned District Judge, Ganjam, which rejected the Appellant's petition for condonation of delay in filing an application under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act (ARBP No.01 of 2021) and consequently dismissed the arbitration petition seeking to set aside an arbitral award dated 18.07.2018. The award was passed by the Micro & Small Enterprises Facilitation Council (MSEFC), Odisha, directing the Appellant to pay the Applicant (M/s. Maa Bhairabi Traders), a small scale industry under the MSME Development Act, 2006, a principal amount and interest for dues unpaid by the Appellant.

The Appellant received the arbitral award on 18.08.2018 but failed to file a timely application under Section 34 within the 90-day limitation period. Instead, the Appellant filed a writ petition which was dismissed with liberty to file the appropriate application with condonation of delay. The Appellant then filed a writ appeal which was disposed of with liberty to file the Section 34 application with condonation of delay by 31.08.2021. The Appellant filed the arbitration petition on 02.09.2021 without condonation of delay application, which was later filed on 16.04.2022. The District Judge rejected the condonation petition and dismissed the arbitration petition. The Appellant challenged this rejection in Arbitration Appeal No.37 of 2022, which was allowed by this Court on 21.11.2022 without notice to the Applicant, setting aside the District Judge's order and remitting the matter for hearing on merits.

The Applicant then filed the present application seeking recall of the order dated 21.11.2022 on the ground that the order was passed without giving the Applicant, who is an affected and necessary party, an opportunity of hearing.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the order dated 21.11.2022 passed in Arbitration Appeal No.37 of 2022, allowing the appeal without hearing the affected party (Applicant), is liable to be recalled.
  2. Whether the Limitation Act, 1963 applies to arbitration proceedings under the MSME Development Act, 2006.
  3. Whether the application for condonation of delay filed by the Appellant was properly rejected by the learned District Judge.
  4. Whether the Applicant is a necessary and proper party in the Arbitration Appeal and entitled to be heard before the appeal is decided.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The Applicant, as the award holder, had accrued a substantive right after the rejection of the Appellant's petition for condonation of delay and dismissal of the application to set aside the award, thereby enabling execution of the award.
  • The Applicant is a necessary and proper party in the appeal and the appeal could not have been decided without giving him an opportunity of hearing.
  • The order dated 21.11.2022 setting aside the District Judge’s order without hearing the Applicant prejudiced the Applicant's rights by depriving him of the benefit of the dismissal on grounds of delay.
  • The Appellant’s filing of the arbitration petition without condonation of delay application was not in conformity with the liberty granted by the Court, rendering the petition non-est in law.
  • The Court has jurisdiction to recall an order passed without hearing an affected party, and the present order ought to be recalled on this basis.

Opposite Party's Arguments

  • The petition for recall is misconceived and not maintainable as it effectively seeks a review of the Court’s order dated 21.11.2022, which is impermissible.
  • The order dated 21.11.2022 was not passed due to any error apparent on the face of the record and does not cause prejudice or injustice to the Applicant.
  • Following the order dated 21.11.2022, the Applicant appeared before the learned District Judge and filed an application under Section 19 of the MSMED Act, 2006, and the Appellant has deposited 75% of the awarded amount as required.
  • The Applicant’s request for adjournment before the learned District Judge was motivated by malafide intent to create undue litigation.
  • The proceeding under Section 19 of the MSME Act is independent and distinct from Section 34 of the Arbitration Act; hence provisions of Section 34 do not apply to the proceeding under Section 19.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
M/S. Silpi Industries vs Kerala State Road Transport Corporation (Supreme Court) Application of Limitation Act, 1963 to arbitration proceedings under Section 18(3) of the MSME Development Act, 2006. The Court relied on this precedent to hold that the Limitation Act applies to arbitrations under the MSME Act, reinforcing the requirement for timely filing and condonation of delay.
M/S. Bajaj Electricals Limited vs Micro Small And Enterprisers (Orissa High Court) Right to be heard of affected party in arbitration proceedings and writ jurisdiction for interference when such right is denied. The Court referred to this case to emphasize that the Applicant was not given the right of hearing and that interference under writ jurisdiction was justified.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined whether the Limitation Act, 1963 applies to arbitration proceedings conducted under the MSME Development Act, relying on the Supreme Court’s decision in M/S. Silpi Industries, which confirmed the applicability of the Limitation Act to such arbitrations. The Court noted that the Appellant had failed to file the application under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act within the prescribed 90-day period and had also failed to properly explain the delay in the subsequent condonation application.

The Court further analyzed the procedural history, observing that the Appellant’s arbitration petition filed without condonation of delay was non-est in law. The Court recognized that the Applicant, as the award holder and an affected party, had accrued a valuable right after the rejection of the condonation petition and dismissal of the arbitration petition by the District Judge.

Crucially, the Court found that the order dated 21.11.2022 allowing the Arbitration Appeal without hearing the Applicant, who was a necessary and proper party, was passed without affording the Applicant an opportunity of hearing. This denial of the right to be heard prejudiced the Applicant’s rights and was contrary to settled principles of natural justice and jurisdiction as per judicial pronouncements.

Accordingly, the Court held that the order dated 21.11.2022 deserved to be recalled on the ground of non-hearing of the affected party, without delving into the merits of the appeal or the delay issues.

Holding and Implications

The Court allowed the application and recalled the order dated 21.11.2022 passed in Arbitration Appeal No.37 of 2022. The appeal file was restored for fresh hearing.

The direct effect of this decision is that the earlier order allowing the Arbitration Appeal without hearing the Applicant is set aside, and the matter is remitted for reconsideration after affording the Applicant a proper opportunity of hearing. No new precedent was established beyond reaffirming the Court’s jurisdiction to recall orders passed without hearing affected parties and the applicability of the Limitation Act to MSME arbitrations.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    SUPTD. ENGNR. (TPSODL),ELECTRICAL CIRCLE v. M/S.MAA BHAIRABI TRADERS

    pg. 1

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK

    I.A. No.73 of 2022

    (Arising out of ARBA No.37 of 2022) Superintending Engineer (TPSODL), Electrical Circle, Bidyutpuri Colony, Berhampur

    …. Petitioner/

    Appellant

    -versus-

    M/s. Maa Bhairabi Traders,

    Berhampur, Ganjam and Anr.

    …. Opp. Parties/

    Respondents

    Advocates appeared in the case:

    For Petitioner : Mr. Suresh Chandra Dash, Adv. -versus-

    For Opp. Parties : Mr. G. M. Rath, Adv.

    CORAM:

    DR. JUSTICE S.K. PANIGRAHI

    DATE OF HEARING:-22.12.2022

    DATE OF JUDGMENT:-15.03.2023 Dr. S.K. Panigrahi, J.

    1. The Appellant has filed the present Arbitration Appeal bearing ARBA No.37 of 2022 under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Arbitration Act') assailing the order dated 14.09.2022 passed by the learned District Judge, Ganjam, Berhampur in C.M.A. No.05 of 2022 rejecting the petition filed by the Appellant for condonation of delay in filing the application under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act bearing ARBP No.01

    1

    pg. 2 of 2021 and also consequentially dismissing the said ARBP No.01 of 2021. The Appellant has filed the said ARBP No.01 of 2021 before the learned District Judge for setting aside the Arbitral Award dated 18.07.2018 passed in MSEFC Case No.33 of 2017 by the Micro & Small Enterprises Facilitation Council, Odisha (in short MSEFC) under the provisions of the MSME Development Act, 2006.

    2. The Applicant who was Respondent No.1 in the Arbitration Appeal has filed the present application for recalling of the Order dated 21.11.2022 passed in ARBA No.37 of 2022 without giving him an opportunity of hearing although he is an affected as well as proper and necessary party.

    I. F ACTUAL M ATRIX OF THE CASE:

    3. The Applicant is a 'small scale industry' under the provisions of the MSME Development Act, 2006. Owing to non- payment of its dues by the Appellant, the Applicant has approached the learned MSEFC, Odisha under Section 18 of the MSME Development Act, 2006 vide MSEFC Case No.33 of 2017. The MSEFC conducted arbitration proceeding in terms of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 and after hearing the parties, Arbitral Award dated 18.07.2018 was passed directing the Appellant to pay principal amount of Rs.31,28,823/- and interest amount of Rs.1,03,757/- calculated up to 31.07.2017.

    2

    pg. 3

    4. The Appellant admittedly received the Arbitration Award dated 18.07.2018 on 18.08.2018. After expiry of the limitation period of 90 days as per Section-34(3) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, the Appellant on 29.11.2018 filed Writ Petition(C) No.19024 of 2018 before this Court assailing the arbitration award. This Court after hearing it, was not inclined to entertain the said Writ Petition and disposed of the Writ Petition vide order dated 16.09.2019 giving liberty to the Appellant to file appeal/ application for setting aside the award along with a petition for condonation of delay within 3 weeks from that date which shall be disposed of in accordance with law.

    5. In the meantime, the Applicant had filed execution petition vide EP No.326 of 2019 before the learned District Judge, Ganjam, Berhampur under Section 6 of the Arbitration Act for execution of the award dated 18.07.2018. The Appellant did not file any application for setting aside the award and instead after expiry of the period granted by this Court in its order dated 16.09.2019, filed Writ Appeal No.551 of 2019 before the Division Bench of this Court on 21.10.2019. The Division Bench disposed of the said Writ Appeal vide order dated 27.07.2021 permitting the Appellant to withdraw the Writ Appeal with liberty to approach the appropriate forum under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act along

    3

    pg. 4 with an application for condonation of delay not later than 31.08.2021 explaining the delay on account of pendency of the proceedings before this Court. Further, the Division Bench clarified that it has not expressed any opinion either on merit or on the question of delay.

    6. The Appellant after expiry of the period granted by the Division Bench of this Court and without seeking any further extension of the period, filed an application for setting aside the award before the learned District Judge, Ganjam, Berhampur on 02.09.2021 vide Arbitration Petition No.01 of 2021 (e-Court Registration No.Arbitration Petition 05 of 2021). More than 7 months after filing of the said Arbitration Petition No.1 of 2021, the Appellant on 16.04.2022 filed an application for condonation of delay.

    7. The learned District Judge vide order dated 14.09.2022 rejected the petition for condonation of delay and consequentially, the Arbitration Petition. Assailing the order dated 14.09.2022, the Appellant had filed the present Arbitration Appeal before this Court. While the Applicant was pursuing the execution petition filed by it after dismissal of the application filed by the Appellant for setting aside the award, the Applicant came to know around 25.11.2022 that this Court vide order dated 21.11.2022 passed in ARBA No.37 of 2022 has set aside the order dated 14.09.2022 passed

    4

    pg. 5 by the learned District Judge and directed for hearing of the arbitration petition for setting aside of the award on merit.

    8. Upon inquiry from the official website of this Court, the Applicant came to know that the Appellant has filed the present arbitration appeal being ARBA No.37 of 2022 on 11.11.2022 and after scrutiny, it was registered on 16.11.2022. After being registered, the ARBA No.37 of 2022 was listed for the first time before this Court under the heading "Fresh Admission' on 21.11.2022. This Court after hearing the Appellant on 21.11.2022 and without issuing notice to the Applicant who was arrayed as Respondent No.1 in the appeal, has been pleased to allow the arbitration appeal by setting aside the order dated 14.09.2022 passed by the learned District Judge, Ganjam, Berhampur and has further been pleased to remit the matter back to the learned District Judge for hearing the arbitration petition on merit.

    II. APPLICANT'S SUBMISSIONS:

    9. Learned counsel for the Petitioner(s) earnestly made the following submissions in support of his contentions:

    10. The Applicant being the award holder, a substantive and valuable right has accrued in his favour after rejection of the petition for condonation of delay filed by the Appellant before the learned District Judge and consequential dismissal of the application for setting aside the award thereby removing all

    5

    pg. 6 the fetters on the due execution of the arbitration award. As such the Applicant is a necessary and proper party in the arbitration appeal filed by the Appellant. The appeal could not have been decided in absence of the Petitioner.

    11. The Applicant is the only affected party in the present lis at the instance of the Appellant. The petition for condonation of delay filed by the Appellant being rejected by the learned District Judge, setting aside the said order thereby restoring the application for setting aside of the award would affect and has in fact affected the Applicant. The Applicant has lost his right to challenge the application for setting aside the award filed by the Appellant on the ground of delay. Setting aside of the impugned order of the learned District Judge has the effect of taking away a valuable right accrued in favour of the Applicant without giving him an opportunity of hearing.

    12. The Applicant is a necessary and proper party in the appeal filed by the Appellant bearing ARBA No.37 of 2022 and the order dated 21.11.2022 having been passed by this Court allowing the said appeal without giving opportunity of hearing to the present Applicant who is an affected party, the said order dated 21.11.2022 deserves to be recalled.

    13. It is settled position of law sanctified by various judicial pronouncements that this Court has jurisdiction to recall an order which was passed without giving an opportunity of

    6

    pg. 7 hearing to an affected party. Further, in such a case, the Court does not go into the merit. A bare perusal of the order dated 27.07.2021 passed by this Court in Writ Appeal No.551 of 2019 would reveal that the Appellant has been given liberty to file a petition under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act along with an application for condonation of delay not later than 31.08.2021 explaining the delay on account of pendency of the proceeding before this Court. Upon such filing, the said application for condonation of delay shall be considered on merit. This Court has further clarified that it has not expressed any opinion either on the merit or the question of delay.

    14. Admittedly, the Appellant has filed the petition under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act vide Arbitration Petition No.01 of 2021 on 02.09.2021 without any application for condonation of delay and the said application for condonation of delay was filed only on 16.04.2022 without explaining the gross delay. As such filing of arbitration petition under Section 34 of the Act on 02.09.2021 is non-est in the eye of law and the said application could only said to have been duly filed on 16.04.2022. Such admitted action of the Appellant is not in consonance with the liberty given by this Court. In the circumstances, allowing the appeal without hearing the Applicant has seriously prejudiced the rights of the Applicant and as such the order dated 21.11.2022 deserves to be recalled.

    7

    pg. 8

    III. OPPOSITE PARTY'S SUBMISSIONS:

    15. Per contra, learned counsel for the Opposite Party intently made the following submissions:

    16. The present Petition is thoroughly misconceived in law and as such not maintainable. After disposal of the main case having no base, further interim application for recalling/ modification of the main order is also not permissible and maintainable. It is submitted that, the Applicant by filing such Petition has sought for Review of the Order dated 21.11.2022 passed by this Court in ARBA No.37 of 2022 which is not permissible in law. The said order was not passed on account of some order mistake or error apparent on the face of record. The order in no way causes prejudice or injustice to the Applicant who is the Opposite Party before the learned District Judge, Ganjam in Arbitration Petition No.01 of 2021 pending before him.

    17. Pursuant to this Court's order dated 21.11.2022 passed in ARBA No.37 of 2022, the present Applicant as appeared before the learned District Judge, Ganjam in ARBP No.01 of 2021 as Respondent and filed a Petition under Section 19 of the MSMED Act, 2006 praying for a direction to the Appellant (TPSODL) to deposit 75% of the awarded amount in MSEMFC Case No.33 of 2017 towards the statutory requirement in terms of Section 19 of the said Act. Accordingly, by order of

    8

    pg. 9 the learned District Judge, Ganjam passed in ARBP No.1 of 2021, the Appellant (TPSODL) has deposited the amount of Rs.33 lakhs in the Court and the case has been admitted to be heard and disposed of on merit.

    18. On the last date of haring before the learned District Judge, Ganjam, the present Applicant as Respondent has sought for an adjournment of the proceeding having motive and malafide intension in order to file the present Petition before this Court only to create undue litigation between the Parties. Hence, the present application not being in the bonafide interest of justice, but in the malafide interest is liable for rejection with cost.

    19. Section 19 of the said Act provides for filing of application for setting aside any decree, award or other order passed by the council. The said application shall be entertained by any court subject to deposit of 75% of the amount in terms of decree award. Under the said Section, there is no such period prescribed for limitation. As per the settled principle of law where the schedule of Limitation Act prescribed the period of limitation for Appeals or Applications to any Court, and the Special or Local law provides for filing of Appeals or Applications to the Court, but does not prescribe any period of limitation with regard to such Appeals or Applications, the period of limitation prescribed in schedule to the Limitation

    9

    pg. 10 Act will apply to such Appeal or Applications and consequently, the provisions of Sections 4 to 24 will also apply.

    20. Since MSME Act is a special Act and special provision is there under Section 19 to file application for setting aside any Decree, Award, the application has been filed before the learned District Judge along with an application under Section 5 read with Section- 14 of the Limitation Act for condonation of delay in preferring the application. MSME Act being a special Act in which Section-19 prescribes for filing appeal for setting aside any Decree or award, which does not prescribe any specific period with regard to such Appeal or Application. Nowhere under this Section did it prescribe that the provision of Arbitration and Conciliation Act shall apply. It is an independent Section wherein, provision for deposit of 75% of the Award is mandatory for entertaining of appeal which is not governed as per Section- 34 of the Arbitration Act.

    21. In Section 18 (2) and (3), it is well defined that when the council on receipt of reference undertakes for conciliation and on failure of such conciliation if conducts arbitration, the provisions of Arbitration and Conciliation Act shall apply to the dispute. From the above, the proceeding under Section 19 of the MSME Act is completely different from proceeding

    10

    pg. 11 under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act. So the provision of Section 34 of Arbitration Act is not applicable at all in the proceeding under Section 19 of the MSME Act.

    IV. COURT'S REASONING AND ANALYSIS:

    22. The first question of law that needs to be answered is whether the Limitation Act, 1963 applies to arbitration proceedings held under the MSMED Act. In this regard, it has been held by the Supreme Court in M/S. Silpi Industries vs Kerala State Road Transport Corporation1that:

    "When the settlement with regard to a dispute between the parties is not arrived at under Section 18 of the 2006 Act, necessarily, the Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council shall take up the dispute for arbitration under Section 18(3) of the 2006 Act or it may refer to institution or centre to provide alternate dispute resolution services and provisions of Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996 are made applicable as if there was an agreement between the parties under sub-section (1) of Section 7 of the 1996 Act. In view of the express provision applying the provisions of the Limitation Act, 1963 to arbitrations as per Section 43 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, we are of the view that the High Court has rightly relied on the judgment in the case of Andhra Pradesh Power Coordination Committee and held that Limitation Act, 1963 is applicable to the arbitration proceedings under Section 18(3) of the 2006 Act. Thus, we are of the view that no further elaboration is necessary on this issue and we hold that the provisions of Limitation

    1 C.A.Nos.1 570-1 578 of 2021 etc. (Supreme Court)

    11

    pg. 12 Act, 1963 will apply to the arbitrations covered by Section 18(3) of the 2006 Act."

    23. This Court in the case of M/S. Bajaj Electricals Limited vs Micro Small And Enterprisers2while dealing with a similar case has held that:

    "The question for consideration, adjudication and answer is whether petitioner was heard. Court is convinced that in facts and circumstances aforesaid, petitioner was not heard or given the right of hearing it was entitled to under the Act of 2006. Petitioner cannot be compelled to seek setting aside of the award, on being aggrieved. As such, it is a clear case where there must be interference in writ jurisdiction. The writ petition is found to be maintainable. Patel Engineering (supra) is not applicable in this case. Paragraph-45 must be read in context of adjudication by the Supreme Court regarding whether or not appointment made by the Chief Justice under sub- section (6) of section 11 (in the Act of 1996 before amendment), is an administrative or judicial order. On declaring that the order is a judicial order, it was said that there was no warrant for the approach to proceed on the basis that any order passed by an arbitral tribunal during arbitration, would be capable of being challenged under articles 226 or 227 of the Constitution."

    24. In fact, setting aside of the impugned order of the learned District Judge has the effect of taking away a valuable right accrued in favour of the Applicant without giving him an opportunity of hearing.

    2 W.P.(C) No.72 16 Of 2 02 0 (Orissa High Court)

    12

    pg. 13

    25. The Applicant is a necessary and proper party in the appeal filed by the Appellant bearing ARBA No.37 of 2022 and the order dated 21.11.2022 having been passed by this Court allowing the said appeal without giving opportunity of hearing to the Applicant who is a affected party, the said order dated 21.11.2022 deserves to be recalled.

    26. It is settled position of law sanctified by various judicial pronouncements that this Court has jurisdiction to recall an order which was passed without giving an opportunity of hearing to an affected party.

    27. Admittedly, the Appellant has filed the petition under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act vide Arbitration Petition No.01 of 2021 on 02.09.2021 without any application for condonation of delay and the said application for condonation delay was filed only on 16.04.2022 without explaining the reasons for the said delay. As such filing of Arbitration Petition under Section 34 of the Act on 02.09.2021 is non-est in the eye of law and the said application could only said to have been duly filed on 16.04.2022. Such admitted action of the Appellant is not in consonance with the liberty given by this Court. In the circumstances, allowing the appeal without hearing the Applicant/ Respondent will seriously prejudice his rights and contentions and as such the order dated 21.11.2022 deserves to be recalled.

    13

    pg. 14

    28. In light of the aforesaid discussion and having regard to the present position of law, this Court hereby allows the Application and recalls the order dated 21.11.2022 passed in ARBA No.37 of 2022. The ARBA No.37 of 2022 is restored to file.

    29. Accordingly, the I.A. is disposed of. ( Dr. S.K. Panigrahi )

    Judge

    Orissa High Court, Cuttack,

    Dated the 15thMarch, 2023/ B. Jhankar

    14

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    SUPTD. ENGNR. (TPSODL),ELECTRICAL CIRCLE v. M/S.MAA BHAIRABI TRADERS
    (Mar 15, 2023)