Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

These appeals arise from claims filed under the Motor Vehicles Act, challenging awards of compensation granted by the VIII Additional District & Sessions Judge, Bengaluru Rural District. The insurer, Bharathi AXA GIC Ltd., filed these appeals under Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act against judgments dated 28.06.2017 in three Motor Vehicle Claims (MVC Nos. 348, 349, and 350 of 2014). The Tribunal had awarded compensation with interest to the respondents, who were injured in accidents involving an auto-rickshaw insured by the appellant.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the insurer can be held liable for compensation when the Medico-Legal Case Register records the accident as involving a school bus and an auto-rickshaw, but the claim petitions state only that the auto-rickshaw lost control and toppled.
  2. Whether the insurer is liable when the offending auto-rickshaw did not have the requisite permit to ply on the road where the accident occurred, potentially constituting a breach of the insurance policy conditions.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Medico-Legal Case Register entry records the accident as between a school bus and an auto-rickshaw, whereas the claim petitions only mention the auto-rickshaw losing control and toppling, indicating contradictory versions and hence no liability on the insurer if a school bus was involved.
  • The offending auto-rickshaw did not have the necessary permit to operate on the road where the accident occurred, which constitutes a breach of the insurance policy conditions, thereby absolving the insurer of liability.

Respondents' Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court addressed the appellant insurer's contention regarding the Medico-Legal Case Register entry that indicated the accident involved a school bus and an auto-rickshaw. The court noted that the insurer did not examine the author of the Medico-Legal Case Register entries, and in the absence of such evidence, the insurer's argument that these entries must be accepted was rejected. Thus, the discrepancy between the register and the claim petitions was insufficient to absolve the insurer of liability.

Regarding the insurer's argument about the absence of a valid permit for the auto-rickshaw, the court recognized this as a breach of policy conditions. However, it clarified that such breach does not relieve the insurer from immediate liability to compensate the claimants. Instead, the insurer's remedy lies in paying the awarded compensation first and then seeking recovery from the vehicle owner.

Holding and Implications

The appeals were dismissed, affirming the Tribunal's award of compensation against the insurer.

The court clarified that the insurer must deposit the compensation amount before the Tribunal but retains the right to recover the amount from the owner of the offending vehicle subsequently. The decision directly affects the parties by upholding the compensation awards and does not establish any new legal precedent.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    THE MANAGER v. MARAKKA

    - 1 -

    MFA No. 8041 of 2017 C/W MFA No. 8040 of 2017 MFA No. 8042 of 2017

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

    DATED THIS THE 21ST DAY OF MARCH, 2023

    BEFORE

    THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE N S SANJAY GOWDA

    MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 8041 OF 2017

    (MV-I)

    C/W

    MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 8040 OF 2017,

    MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 8042 OF 2017

    IN MFA.No.8041/2017:

    BETWEEN:

    1. THE MANAGER

    BHARATHI AXA GIC LTD.,

    NO.30, 3RD FLOOR, 3RD BLOCK,

    BELLARY ROAD, PRIDE QUADRA,

    HEBBALA, BANGALORE-24.

    NOW REP. BY ITS LEGAL MANAGER,

    BHARAHI AXA GIC LTD.,

    1ST FLOOR, FERNS ICON,

    SURVEY NO.28, DODDANEKUNDI,

    K.R.PURAM HOBLI, BANGALORE-560037. …APPELLANT

    (BY SRI. PRADEEP B., ADVOCATE)

    AND:

    1. KAMALAMMA,

    W/O KRISHNAPPA, R/O.NO.65, KANAKAPURA MAIN ROAD,

    KALLU BEEDI, HAROHALLI,

    KANAKAPURA TALUK,

    - 2 -

    RAMANAGARA DISTICT-562112.

    2. GIRIDHAR

    S/O VENKATAGIRIYAPPA,

    MAJOR,

    R/O BYRAMANGALA VILLAGE AND POST,

    BIDADI HOBLI,

    RAMANAGARA TALUK AND DISTRICT-562112. …RESPONDENTS

    (BY SRI.P.SHIVAKUMAR, ADVOCATE FOR R-1 (VC); SRI. YATHISH .J.NADIG & SRI MANJUNATH B.R., ADVOCATE FOR R-2)

    THIS MFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 173(1) OF MV ACT

    AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED:28.06.2017

    PASSED IN MVC NO.350/2014 ON THE FILE OF THE VIII ADDITIONAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE, BENGALURU

    RURAL DISTRICT, BENGALURU, AWARDING COMPENSATION

    OF RS.39,900/- WITH INTEREST @ 8% FROM THE DATE OF

    PETITION TILL DEPOSIT.

    IN MFA.No.8040/2017:

    BETWEEN:

    1. THE MANAGER

    BHARATHI AXA GIC LTD.,

    NO.30, 3RD FLOOR, 3RD BLOCK,

    BELLARY ROAD, PRIDE QUADRA,

    HEBBALA, BANGALORE-24.

    NOW REP. BY ITS LEGAL MANAGER,

    BHARAHI AXA GIC LTD.,

    1ST FLOOR, FERNS ICON,

    SURVEY NO.28, DODDANEKUNDI,

    K.R.PURAM HOBLI,

    BANGALORE-560037. …APPELLANT

    (BY SRI. B.PRADEEP., ADVOCATE)

    - 3 -

    AND:

    1. GANGAMMA, W/O RAMAIAH,

    NOW AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS,

    R/O No.65, KANAKAPURA MAIN ROAD,

    KALLU BEEDI, HAROHALLI,

    KANAKAPURA TALUK,

    RAMANAGAR - 562112.

    2. GIRIDHAR

    S/O VENKATAGIRIYAPPA,

    MAJOR,

    R/O BYRAMANGALA VILLAGE AND POST,

    BIDADI HOBLI,

    RAMANAGARA TALUK AND DISTRICT-562112. …RESPONDENTS

    (BY SRI.P.SHIVAKUMAR, ADVOCATE FOR R-1 (VC);

    SRI. YATHISH.J.NADIG AND SRI. MANJUNATH B.R.,

    ADVOCATE FOR R-2)

    THIS MFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 173(1) OF MV ACT

    AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED:28.06.2017

    PASSED IN MVC NO.348/2014 ON THE FILE OF THE VIII ADDITIONAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE, BENGALURU

    RURAL DISTRICT, BENGALURU, AWARDING COMPENSATION

    OF RS.1,24,900/- WITH INTEREST @ 8% FROM THE DATE OF

    PETITION TILL DATE OF DEPOSIT.

    IN MFA.No.8042/2017:

    BETWEEN:

    1. THE MANAGER

    BHARATHI AXA GIC LTD.,

    NO.30, 3RD FLOOR, 3RD BLOCK,

    BELLARY ROAD, PRIDE QUADRA,

    HEBBALA, BANGALORE-24.

    NOW REP. BY ITS LEGAL MANAGER,

    BHARAHI AXA GIC LTD.,

    1ST FLOOR, FERNS ICON,

    SURVEY NO.28, DODDANEKUNDI,

    - 4 -

    K.R.PURAM HOBLI,

    BANGALORE-560037. …APPELLANT

    (BY SRI. PRADEEP B., ADVOCATE)

    AND:

    1. MARAKKA @ PUTTAMARAMMA, W/O ARASAPPA,

    NOW AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS,

    R/O No.65, HAROHALLI,

    KANAKAPURA TALUK,

    RAMANAGAR-562 112.

    2. GIRIDHAR

    S/O VENKATAGIRIYAPPA,

    MAJOR,

    R/O BYRAMANGALA VILLAGE AND POST,

    BIDADI HOBLI,

    RAMANAGARA TALUK AND DISTRICT-562112. …RESPONDENTS

    (BY SRI. P.SHIVAKUMAR., ADVOCATE FOR R-1 (VC); SRI.YATHISH.J.NADIG & SRI.MANJUNATH.B.R., ADVOCATE FOR R-2)

    THIS MFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 173(1) OF MV ACT

    AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED:28.06.2017

    PASSED IN MVC NO.349/2014 ON THE FILE OF THE VIII ADDITIONAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE, BENGALURU

    RURAL DISTRICT, BENGALURU, AWARDING COMPENSATION

    OF RS.77,300/- WITH INTEREST @ 8% FROM THE DATE OF

    PETITION TILL DATE OF DEPOSIT.

    THESE APPEALS, COMING ON FOR ORDERS, THIS DAY,

    THE COURT DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

    - 5 -

    JUDGMENT

    1. These appeals are filed by the insurer challenging the liability imposed on it by the Tribunal.

    2. It was the case of the insurer that in the Medico- Legal Case register, it had been recorded as accident between the school bus and auto-rikshaw, whereas in the claim petitions, it was merely stated that the driver of the auto-rikshaw had lost control and as a result, the auto- rikshaw toppled, resulting in injuries to the claimants. It is, therefore, contended that in the light of these contradictory pleas regarding the accident, it was clear that the insurer could not be made liable if a school bus was involved.

    3. It was also contended that the offending auto- rikshaw, which was insured by the appellant, did not have the permit to ply on the road where the accident occurred and therefore, on this ground also, the insurer is also not liable.

    - 6 -

    4. As far as the contention of the insurer that the Medico-Legal Case Register contained an entry regarding the accident between the auto-rikshaw and a school bus is concerned, the insurer has not chosen to examine the author of the entries in the Medico-Legal Case Register. In the absence of any evidence from the person who made the entries in the Medico-Legal Case Register, the argument of the learned counsel for the insurer that the entries in the Register are to be accepted, cannot be sustained and this argument is therefore rejected.

    5. Another contention raised by the learned counsel for the insurer that the offending auto-rikshaw did not possess the requisite permit is concerned, it has to be stated here that this is essentially a contention that there was a breach of policy conditions. If there is breach of policy conditions, the only remedy available for the insurer would be to pay the compensation to the claimants and thereafter proceed to recover the same from the owner of the offending vehicle.

    - 7 -

    6. In this view of the matter, there is no merit in these appeals and the appeals are dismissed.

    7. However, it is made clear that the insurer can proceed to recover the compensation amount after it deposits the same before the Tribunal, from the owner of the offending vehicle.

    8. The amount in deposit, if any, shall be transferred to the Tribunal forthwith.

    Sd/-

    JUDGE

    RK

    List No.: 1 Sl No.: 2

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    THE MANAGER v. MARAKKA
    (Mar 21, 2023)