AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Acts
  • Section 61 of the 2003 Act. 56. In fact, Sections 61 and 62
  • sub-section (2) of Section 111 of the 2003 Act.
  • Section 61 of the 2003 Act. Determination
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Acts
  • Section 61 of the 2003 Act. 56. In fact, Sections 61 and 62
  • sub-section (2) of Section 111 of the 2003 Act.
  • Section 61 of the 2003 Act. Determination
Smart Summary

Calcutta High Court — Summary of Opinion (Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This batch of writ petitions was filed by electricity consumers of the Damodar Valley Corporation (DVC) challenging the West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission's (WBERC) tariff order for the financial year 2017-18 published on 5 May 2022. The petitioners also challenged a subsequent two-year tariff order for 2018-19 and 2019-20 published on 17 June 2022, on the ground that the 2017-18 order was framed as a Single Year Tariff (SYT) whereas the statutory and regulatory framework contemplated a Multi Year Tariff (MYT) regime.

Relevant procedural history included: (i) an earlier WBERC order dated 14 December 2016 (referring to a control period) which the petitioners alleged was superseded when the Commission later declared 2017-18 as a one-year control period; (ii) DVC had filed an application for tariff determination in 2016, but the tariff was determined in 2022 — a delay of about six years relied upon by petitioners; (iii) hearings concluded on 13.01.2023 and judgment was delivered on 17.02.2023.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the WBERC's adoption of a Single Year Tariff (SYT) for 2017-18 violated Section 61 of the Electricity Act, 2003 (requiring that the Appropriate Commission be guided by MYT principles) and the WBERC Tariff Regulation No. 48 of 2011 which contemplates an MYT framework.
  2. Whether the WBERC's tariff order dated 5 May 2022 (determining tariff for 2017-18) was invalid due to delay in breach of Section 64(3) of the 2003 Act (tariff to be published within 120 days of accepting application).
  3. Whether reasons in writing were required (and absent) because the WBERC's decision affected public interest and was quasi-judicial in nature.
  4. Whether the petitioners' challenge was maintainable given available alternative remedies (appeal under Section 111 of the 2003 Act) and applicable limitation periods.
  5. Whether the tariff determination in 2022 for the earlier period (2017-18) amounted to an impermissible retrospective imposition of tariff.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The WBERC's 2017-18 tariff was framed as a Single Year Tariff (SYT) contrary to the Multi Year Tariff (MYT) structure contemplated by Section 61(f) of the Electricity Act, 2003 and Clause 2.5.1 of the 2011 Regulations.
  • Sections relied upon included Sections 3, 61 and 181 of the 2003 Act; petitioners argued National Electricity Policy and National Tariff Policy (Section 3(5)) and Clause 5.3(h) of NTP indicate multi-year control periods (five years, or initially three years) and that the Commission could not disregard that guidance.
  • Regulation 2.10.2 of the 2011 Regulations requires tariff revision prospectively unless compelling written reasons exist; no such reasons were given for using SYT.
  • The tariff determination was delayed (DVC filed its application in 2016 but the tariff was determined only in 2022), allegedly in violation of Section 64(3) requiring publication within 120 days.
  • The WBERC abdicated its duty by allowing DVC to determine a "fuel surcharge" (petitioners said this permitted DVC to determine its own price contrary to the Act and Regulations).
  • The petitioners argued that when decisions affect public interest or are quasi-judicial, reasons in writing must be furnished, citing authorities on reasoned orders.
  • Reliance was placed on BSES Rajdhani (Supreme Court) to argue that 'truing up' under MYT is not the same as amendment under Section 64 and that SYT leaves no scope for truing up, creating uncertainty and adverse financial impact on consumers.
  • Petitioners sought that the SYT order for 2017-18 be struck down.

WBERC and DVC's Arguments (Respondents)

  • The essential principles of the MYT framework remain intact despite an SYT formatting for 2017-18; SYT can be accommodated within the MYT definitions (base year and ensuing year concepts) and calculations are performed year-by-year even under MYT.
  • The Commission has sole discretion under Clause 2.2.3 of the 2011 Regulations to apply MYT principles and choose the extent of reliance on those principles; the Regulations themselves permit flexibility including a single-year control period.
  • The WBERC's decision dated 14 December 2016 fixing a one-year control period was not challenged for six years and therefore attained finality; the tariff determination in 2022 was consequential to that earlier decision.
  • The delay in tariff determination was occasioned by DVC's failure to submit an investment proposal as directed by an earlier co-ordinate bench order, providing a factual reason for the delay.
  • Tariff determination and price fixation are legislative functions; courts should interfere only for manifest unreasonableness or arbitrariness. Precedent demonstrates limited judicial interference where complex regulatory exercises are involved.
  • Section 111 provides an efficacious alternative remedy (appeal to the appellate tribunal for electricity with a 45-day limitation). The petitioners did not pursue that remedy against the 2016 control period determination.
  • Reasons in writing were not required because the exercise was legislative (not quasi-judicial) in nature, and the tariff determined was uniform across licensees so there was no discriminatory impact between licensees.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
M.L. Jaggi Vs. Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Limited & others (1996) 3 SCC 119 Cited by petitioners for the proposition that decisions affecting public interest/quasi-judicial decisions require reasons in writing. The Court observed such authorities apply to quasi-judicial or adjudicatory orders; since the impugned exercise was legislative in nature, those authorities did not apply here.
Charan Singh Vs. Healing Touch Hospitals (2000) 7 SCC 668 Cited to support requirement of reasons in writing for decisions affecting public interest/quasi-judicial acts. The Court held the requirement pertains to quasi-judicial orders and found the WBERC's action legislative, so the citation was not applicable to invalidate the order.
S.N. Mukherjee Vs. Union of India (1990) 4 SCC 594 Cited on the necessity of reasoned orders in quasi-judicial contexts. The Court treated it as authority applicable to quasi-judicial decisions; it concluded that the WBERC's act was legislative and the authority did not mandate setting aside the tariff determination.
Kranti Associates Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Masood Ahmed Khan (2010) 9 SCC 496 Cited for the legal proposition that reasons in writing are required where decisions impact public interest/quasi-judicial matters. The Court held the case concerned quasi-judicial contexts; it concluded those principles did not apply to legislative-type tariff fixation by the Commission in this matter.
Poppatlal Shah v. State of Madras (AIR 1953 SC 274) Cited by petitioners for the principle of harmonious construction of statutes to ascertain legislative intent. The Court acknowledged the general principle but applied the statutory and regulatory scheme (2011 Regulations and the 2003 Act) to conclude that the MYT framework could accommodate a single-year control period.
University of Allahabad & others v. Amrit Chand Tripathi (1986) 4 SCC 176 Cited for rules on harmonious reading of statutory provisions. The Court used the statutory text and regulations themselves to interpret the MYT/SYT relationship, concluding harmony permitted a single-year control period.
D. Sanjeevayya v. The Election Tribunal, Andhra Pradesh (AIR 1967 SC 1211) Cited to support proposition of harmonious/statutory interpretation. The Court relied on the Regulations' definitions and statutory context rather than finding the petitioners' interpretation persuasive; the harmonisation principle supported reading the Regulations as permitting SYT.
BSES Rajdhani Power Ltd. Vs. Delhi Electricity Regulatory Commission (2022) SCC OnLine SC 1450 Cited by petitioners to argue that 'truing up' (in MYT) is different from amendment under Section 64 and that SYT lacks truing up mechanisms. The Court found the BSES Rajdhani authority not directly relevant: the present MYT/SYT framing for 2017-18 considered the base and ensuing year within the MYT framework, so the petitioners' reliance did not invalidate the SYT exercise.
Tata Power Company Vs. Maharashtra Electricity Regulatory Commission (2022) SCC OnLine 1615 Cited by the WBERC for the proposition that the National Tariff Policy cannot bind interpretation of the phrase "shall be guided" in Section 61 and that determination of tariff/framing regulations is within the Commission's domain. The Court accepted the relevance of Tata Power: it reinforced that Section 61 provides guiding factors and that the Appropriate Commission has discretion in framing regulations and determining tariffs.
Reliance Infrastructure Ltd. Vs. State of Maharashtra (2019) 3 SCC 352 Cited to show courts interfere in regulatory decisions only where manifest unreasonableness or arbitrariness is present. The Court noted the principle but indicated the Reliance decision had no direct relevance since the present challenge was to interpretation of the earlier WBERC order and existing Regulations rather than a fresh regulatory discretion exercise open to manifest-unreasonableness review.
Shri Sitaram Sugar Co. Ltd. & another Vs. Union of India (1990) 3 SCC 223 Cited by WBERC to support that price fixation/tariff determination is a legislative function. The Court treated this line of authorities as supporting that tariff determination is legislative in character and therefore not subject to quasi-judicial reasoned-order requirements in the same way.
Union of India Vs. Cynamide India Ltd. (1987) 2 SCC 720 Cited to support the proposition that price fixation is legislative. The Court relied on the principle to distinguish legislative tariff determination from quasi-judicial adjudication, limiting applicability of reasoned-order jurisprudence.
ESSAR Steel Ltd. Vs. Union of India (2016) 11 SCC 1 Cited to support the legislative nature of price fixation/tariff determination. The Court cited this authority to reinforce that price/tariff fixation is legislative in nature and to justify limited judicial interference absent manifest arbitrariness.
PTC India Ltd. Vs. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (2010) 4 SCC 603 Cited for the principle that tariff/price fixation is a legislative exercise. The Court relied on this jurisprudence in support of the view that the WBERC's action was legislative and not an adjudicatory/quasi-judicial action requiring the same scope of reasoned findings as would apply in judicial/quasi-judicial decisions.
WBERC Vs. Impex Ferro [FMA 4319 of 2014] (unreported Division Bench) Cited (by WBERC) for the proposition that a consumer's right in price fixation is limited. The Court noted the unreported decision and treated it as supportive of the respondent's contention regarding limited consumer rights in tariff fixation; the Court accepted limited consumer protection does not alone invalidate the order.
Ashok Kumar Sonkar Vs. Union of India (2007) 4 SCC 54 Cited by WBERC regarding non-interference where natural justice/norms are not violated. The Court acknowledged these authorities to support limited judicial intervention where natural justice principles are not breached.
Canara Bank & others Vs. Debasis Das & others (2003) 4 SCC 557 Cited on the principle of limited interference by courts absent violation of natural justice. The Court found these authorities relevant to the WBERC's submission that there was no prejudice shown warranting judicial interference.
Sohan Lal Gupta (Dead) Through LRS. & others Vs. Asha Devi Gupta (Smt.) & others (2003) 7 SCC 492 Cited by WBERC on principles limiting court interference where procedural fairness/natural justice are respected. The Court cited such authorities in support of the position that absent manifest unreasonableness or breach of natural justice, interference is not warranted.
S.L. Kapoor Vs. Jagmohan (1980) 4 SCC 379 Cited by WBERC for doctrine regarding limits on judicial interference and natural justice principles. The Court relied on that general authority to support the view that the WBERC's legislative exercise did not offend principles that would invite judicial intervention on such grounds.
West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission Vs. CESC Limited (2002) 8 SCC 715 Cited to support the proposition that statutory alternative remedies (appeal routes) preclude writ relief and for the principle of maintainability. The Court relied on this precedent to conclude that Section 111 of the 2003 Act provides a remedy by appeal and that the petitioners could have challenged the 2016 control-period decision within the limitation period; failure to do so rendered the earlier order final.
H.P. Electricity Regulatory Commission Vs. H.P. State Electricity Board (2006) 9 SCC 233 Cited similarly for the proposition that alternative statutory remedies (appeals) affect maintainability of writ petitions. The Court found this authority apt in holding that the petitioners had an alternative efficacious remedy under Section 111 and that the 2016 order had attained finality for failure to challenge within time.
Order of Harish Tandon, J. in WP 6442(W) of 2016 (dated 9.1.2017) and DVC Vs. WBERC [WP 26442(W) of 2016] Referred to as directing an investment proposal to be made (a factual prerequisite referenced by respondents for delay). The Court relied on these orders as explaining the factual background — DVC's failure to file the investment proposal delayed tariff determination and justified the delay in final tariff order until 2022.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a textual and contextual analysis of the Electricity Act, 2003 and the WBERC Tariff Regulations of 2011 to determine whether the Commission acted within law in adopting an SYT for 2017-18.

Key steps in the Court's reasoning:

  1. Definitions within the 2011 Regulations: The Court reviewed the definitions of "Control Period", "Base Year" and "Ensuing Year" in the 2011 Regulations and noted that "control period" is defined as a period consisting of a number of year(s) and that "base year" and "ensuing year(s)" language permits either single or multiple years. From this, the Court concluded the Regulations did not preclude a control period of one year.
  2. MYT Framework Flexibility: The Court examined Clause 2.5 (MYT Framework) and observed that even under MYT the tariff of each year is projected and/or adjusted and determined year-by-year. Therefore, the MYT framework itself afforded flexibility sufficient to permit the Commission to determine tariff for a single ensuing year.
  3. Commission's Discretion: The Court referred to Clause 2.2.3 and Clause 8.2 of the 2011 Regulations which confer discretion on the Commission to apply MYT principles and to fix or vary norms. The Court concluded that the Commission was entitled to choose the degree to which it relied on the various guiding factors in Section 61.
  4. Effect of the 2016 Order and Finality: The Court placed weight on the WBERC's order dated 14 December 2016 fixing the control period as one year and noted that this order was not challenged for six years; as a result it had attained finality. The 2022 tariff determination was a consequential exercise under Section 62 following that earlier determination.
  5. Delay in Tariff Determination: The Court accepted the respondents' factual explanation that the delay (2016 application but 2022 determination) was attributable, in material part, to DVC's failure to submit an investment proposal as directed by an earlier judicial order. Thus the delay did not, in the Court's view, establish legal invalidity of the tariff determination.
  6. Nature of the Exercise — Legislative v. Quasi-Judicial: The Court held that tariff determination and price fixation are legislative in character (citing authorities). Because the exercise impugned was legislative rather than quasi-judicial/adjudicatory, the petitioners' reliance on cases requiring reasoned orders in quasi-judicial contexts was misplaced.
  7. Maintainability and Alternative Remedy: The Court concluded that Section 111 provided an alternative, efficacious remedy (appeal) with a 45-day limitation against the 2016 order, which the petitioners did not pursue. That failure meant the 2016 order attained finality and the subsequent tariff determination could not be collaterally attacked in the writ petitions.
  8. Truing Up and BSES Rajdhani precedent: The Court considered the BSES Rajdhani decision but found it inapplicable: the Court found that the MYT framing for 2017-18 had considered the base year (2016-17) and the ensuing year (2017-18) within the MYT framework and therefore the petitioners' truing up argument did not invalidate the Commission's approach.
  9. Prejudice and Impact on Consumers: The Court found no evidence of prejudice of sufficient magnitude to warrant relief; the tariff determined was uniform across licensees and the impact, if any, applied only to DVC consumers.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The writ petitions were dismissed. Specifically, the Court dismissed the listed writ petitions (see opinion for complete list) "without any order as to costs" and directed that urgent certified copies be issued on compliance of formalities.

Implications (direct, as stated in the opinion):

  • The WBERC's tariff determination for 2017-18 (and related challenged orders for subsequent years insofar as they are consequential) stands; the petitions seeking to strike down the SYT determination were not allowed.
  • The Court concluded that (a) the 2011 Regulations and the statutory scheme permit the Commission sufficient discretion to determine a one-year control period; (b) the 2016 order fixing the control period as one year had attained finality because it was not challenged within the statutory period; and (c) factual delay in tariff determination was, in part, explained by DVC's non-compliance with prior judicial directions.
  • No broader precedent was asserted by the Court beyond its application of existing statutory/regulatory interpretation and settled principles regarding the limited scope of judicial interference in legislative/regulatory price-fixation exercises; the decision is consequential on the parties and the listed petitions only.

Note: This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion and does not add factual or legal information beyond that text.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    NILKANTH FERRO LIMITED AND ANR v. WEST BENGAL STATE ELECTRICITY REGULATORY COMMISSION AND ORS

    In the High Court at Calcutta Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction Appellate Side

    The Hon'ble Justice Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya W.P.A. No. 9857 of 2022

    H.P. Ispat Private Limited & Anr. Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors.

    With

    W.P.A. No. 10069 of 2022

    H.R. Ispat Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.

    Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. With

    W.P.A. No. 10107 of 2022

    Sumangal Ispat Private Limited and another Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. With

    W. P. A. No. 10315 of 2022

    Ruhr Ispat Private Limited and another Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. with

    W.P.A. No. 10654 of 2022

    Purulia Metal Casting Private Limited & Anr. Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. With

    W.P.A. No. 10700 of 2022

    IA No: CAN 1 of 2022

    East India Holdings Private Limited & Anr. Vs.

    Damodar Valley Corporation & Ors.

    1

    2

    With W.P.A. No. 10962 of 2022 IA No: CAN 1 of 2022 Supersmelt Industries Private Limited & Anr. Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. with

    W.P.A. No. 10963 of 2022

    Surya Alloy Industries Limited & Anr. Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. With

    W.P.A. No. 10967 of 2022

    Metsil Exports Private Limited & Anr. Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. With

    W.P.A. No. 11196 of 2022

    M/s. Sonic Thermal Private Limited & Anr. Vs.

    Damodar Valley Corporation & Ors.

    With

    W.P.A. No. 11200 of 2022

    M/s. Ispat Damodar Private Limited

    Vs.

    DVC & Ors.

    With

    W.P.A. No. 11268 of 2022

    M/s. SBIW Steels Private Limited & Anr. Vs.

    Damodar Valley Corporation & Ors.

    With

    W. P. A. No. 11691 of 2022

    Haldia Steels Private Limited and another Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors.

    3

    With W.P.A. No. 11913 of 2022 Jaishree Steels Private Limited & Anr. Vs.

    Damodar Valley Corporation & Ors. With

    W. P. A. No. 12060 of 2022

    Jai Venktesh Concast Private Limited and another Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. With

    W.P.A. No. 16133 of 2022

    Calstar Sponge Limited & Anr.

    Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory

    Commission & Ors.

    With

    W.P.A. No. 16136 of 2022

    XPRO India Limited & Anr.

    Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory

    Commission & Ors.

    With

    W.P.A. No. 16834 of 2022

    Maha Gauri Strips Private Limited & Anr. Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory

    Commission & Ors.

    With

    W. P. A. No. 17227 of 2022

    Arjan Dass and Sons Private Limited and another Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors.

    4

    With W. P. A. No. 17234 of 2022 Amit Ferro Alloys and Steel Private Limited and another Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. With

    WPA No. 22993 of 2022

    Shreevardhana Metaliks Pvt. Ltd and another Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission and others with

    W.P.A. No. 9861 of 2022

    HMB Ispat Private Limited & Anr.

    Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. with

    W.P.A. No. 9869 of 2022

    Expandable Enterprise Private Limited & Anr. Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. with

    W.P.A. No. 9872 of 2022

    Shreesatya Steel and Power Private Limited & Anr. Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. with

    W.P.A. No. 9892 of 2022

    Shree Waris Piya Steel Company Private Limited & Anr. Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. With

    W.P.A. No. 9897 of 2022

    Shree Ramdoot Rollers Private Limited & Anr. Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors.

    5

    with W.P.A. No. 9902 of 2022 Debeanjana Hard Coke Private Limited & Anr. Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. With

    W.P.A. No. 9933 of 2022

    Jai Ambey Metals Private Limited & Anr. Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. with

    W.P.A. No. 9938 of 2022

    Venky Hi-Tech Ispat Private Limited & Anr. Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. With

    W.P.A. No. 9942 of 2022

    Alishan Steels Private Limited & Anr. Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. With

    W.P.A. No. 9947 of 2022

    Arjan Dass and Sons Private Limited & Anr. Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. With

    W.P.A. No. 15255 of 2022

    IA No: CAN 2 of 2022

    CAN 3 of 2022

    Nilkanth Ferro Limited & Anr.

    Vs.

    West Bengal State Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. With

    W.P.A. No. 17114 of 2022

    Srinivasa Ferro Alloys Limited & Anr.

    Vs.

    West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors.

    6

    For the petitioners in W.P.A. No.9857 of 2022 : Mr. Partha Sarathi Sengupta, Mr. Tanoy Chakraborty,

    Mr. Gautam Shroff,

    Mr. Shayak Mitra

    Mr. Siddharth Shroff,

    For the petitioners in

    W.P.A. No. 9861 of 2022 : Mr. Surajit Nath Mitra, Mr. Tanay Chakraborty,

    Mr. Gautam Shroff,

    Mr. Siddharth Shroff,

    Mr. Shayak Mitra,

    For the petitioners in

    WPA 10107 of 2022

    WPA 10315 of 2022

    WPA 10963 of 2022

    WPA 10967 of 2022

    WPA 12060 of 2022

    WPA 16133 of 2022

    WPA 16136 of 2022

    WPA 9861 of 2022

    WPA 9869 of 2022

    WPA 9872 of 2022

    WPA 9892 of 2022

    WPA 9897 of 2022

    WPA 9902 of 2022

    WPA 9933 of 2022

    WPA 9938 of 2022

    WPA 9942 of 2022

    WPA 9947 of 2022 : Mr. Tanoy Chakraborty, Mr. Gautam Shroff,

    Mr. Shayak Mitra,

    Mr. Siddhartha Shroff

    For the petitioners in

    WPA 11196 of 2022 and

    WPA 11200 of 2022 : Mr. Sagar Bandopadhyay, Mr. Kausik Chatterjee,

    Ms. Sofia Nesar

    For the petitioners in

    WPA 11268 of 2022 : Mr. Sagar Bandopadhyay, Mr. Tapas Saha,

    Mr. Subhamay Dewanji

    7

    For the petitioners in WPA 10700 of 2022 : Ms. Sanchari Chakraborty, Mr. Deepan Sarkar,

    Ms. Akanksha Chowdhury

    For the petitioners in

    WPA 17227 of 2022,

    WPA 17234 of 2022 : Mr. Kumarjit Banerjee, Ms. Sanchari chakraborty,

    Mr. Sourojit Dasgupta,

    Ms. Akanksha Chowdhury

    For the petitioners in

    WPA 10069 of 2022

    WPA 16834 of 2022 : Mr. Tanay Chakraborty, Mr. Shayak Mitra,

    Mr. Abhijit Sarkar

    For the petitioners in

    WPA 11691 of 2022,

    WPA 22993 of 2022

    WPA 17114 of 2022 : Mr. Tanay chakraborty, Mr. Debsoumya Basak

    For the petitioners in

    WPA 10962 of 2022 : Mr. Srijan Nayak, Mr. Palash Mukherjee,

    Ms. Monideepa Banerjee

    For the petitioners in

    WPA 10654 of 2022 Mr. Abhrajit Mitra, Mr. Suchayan Banerjee,

    Ms. Sanjana Sinha,

    Mr. S.K. Banerjee,

    Mr. Souradeep Banerjee

    For the

    Damodar Valley Corporation : Mr. M.G. Ramachandran, Mr. Prasun Mukherjee,

    Mr. Deepak Agarwal,

    Ms. Anushree Bardhan

    For the WBERC in

    WPA 9857 of 2022

    WPA 9861 of 2022 : Mr. Pratik Dhar,

    Ms. Sharmistha Shosh,

    Mr. Amit Ghosh

    8

    For the WBERC in WPA 10069 of 2022, WPA 10107 of 2022, WPA 10315 of 2022, WPA 10654 of 2022, WPA 10700 of 2022, WPA 10962 of 2022, WPA 10963 of 2022, WPA 10967 of 2022, WPA 11196 of 2022, WPA 11200 of 2022, WPA 11268 of 2022, WPA 11691 of 2022, WPA 11913 of 2022, WPA 12060 of 2022, WPA 16133 of 2022, WPA 16834 of 2022, WPA 17227 of 2022, WPA 17234 of 2022, WPA 9869 of 2022, WPA 9872 of 2022, WPA 9892 of 2022, WPA 9897 of 2022, WPA 9902 of 2022, WPA 9933 of 2022, WPA 9938 of 2022, WPA 9942 of 2022, WPA 9947 of 2022 : Mr. Victor Chatterjee, Ms. Sharmistha Ghosh,

    Mr. Amit Ghosh

    For the WBERC in

    WPA 22993 of 2022 : Mr. Raja Saha, Mrs. Arpita Saha,

    Mr. Sanjay Mukherjee

    Hearing concluded on : 13.01.2023 Judgment on : 17.02.2023

    9

    Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J:-

    1. This batch of writ petitions has been filed by electricity consumers of the Damodar Valley Corporation (DVC), challenging the tariff order for the financial year 2017-18, published on May 5, 2022.

    2. Consequently, the subsequent 2-year tariff order for 2018-19 and 2019-20, published on June 17, 2022 has also been challenged since, according to the petitioners, the tariff order for 2017-18, in view of being in a Single Year Tariff (SYT) framework, is violative of the Multi Year Tariff (MYT) structure contemplated by the Electricity Act, 2003 (for short, "the 2003 Act") and the West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission Tariff Regulation No. 48 dated April 25, 2011.

    3. Learned counsel for the petitioners primarily place reliance on Sections 3, 61 and 181 of the 2003 Act. It is argued that the National Electricity Policy (NEP) and National Tariff Policy (NTP), as per Section 3(5) of the said Act, are formulated once every five years.

    4. Again, Section 61 provides that the Appropriate Commission (here the WBERC) shall specify the terms and conditions for determination of tariff and, in doing so, shall be guided by certain factors. Clause (f) of Section 61 stipulates MYT principles as one of the factors which shall guide such tariff determination. The expression "shall be guided", it is argued, signifies that the Commission is bound to take into consideration all the said factors and, at best, can decide the weight which should be placed on each, but cannot altogether overlook one of the said components. In the present

    10

    case, since the WBERC framed SYT for the financial year 2017-18, the same is violative of Section 61(f) of the 2003 Act.

    5. Learned counsel for the petitioners cite Section 181 of the 2003 Act, which confers powers on State Commissions to make Regulations, which have to be consistent with the Act and the Rules, generally to carry out the provisions of the Act.

    6. Such language, it is contended, indicates that the Regulations framed by the State Commissions have to be not only consistent with the 2003 Act and Rules but generally designed to carry out the provisions of the Act itself and cannot be in derogation of any provision of the said Act.

    7. It is argued that in the present case, despite having initially declared the Control Period to be 2017-18 to 2019-20 (3 years) on May 4, 2016, vide Order dated December 14, 2016, the WBERC, in supersession of the May 4, 2016 Order, declared that the financial year 2017-18 would be a one- year Control Period, thereby resorting to a SYT instead of MYT framework. The present impugned tariff order of May 5, 2022 is an implementation of such order and is effective for 2017-18. Such tariff order is the immediate cause of action for the challenge preferred by the petitioners in the present set of writ petitions.

    8. Learned counsel for the petitioners argue that as per Section 64(3) of the 2003 Act, the tariff order is to be published within 120 days from accepting any application for tariff determination by a generating company or licensee. In the present case, although DVC filed such application in the year 2016, the determination took place in 2022, that is, after about six

    11

    years' lapse. Such delay is also one of the grounds of challenge in the present writ petitions.

    9. It is next submitted that Regulation 48/WBERC of 2011, in Clause 2.5.1, refers to MYT framework. Hence, even the Regulations contemplate an MYT Framework and not an SYT system.

    10. Again, Clause 5.3(h) of the National Tariff Policy of 2006, which was framed in consultation with all stakeholders, including the WBERC, fixed the Control Period at five years. The said policy was enacted on June 6, 2006 and for about 16 years, till the month of May, 2022, such policy was never deviated from by the WBERC.

    11. Again, it is argued that when a decision affects public interest or is quasi- judicial in nature, reasons in writing have to be furnished for the same. In support of such contention, learned counsel for the petitioners cite primarily the following judgments:

    i) M.L. Jaggi Vs. Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Limited and others [(1996)

    3 SCC 119],

    ii) Charan Singh Vs. Healing Touch Hospitals and others [(2000) 7 SCC 668];

    iii) S.N. Mukherjee Vs. Union of India [(1990) 4 SCC 594]; and

    iv) Kranti Associates Private Limited and another Vs. Masood Ahmed Khan and others [(2010) 9 SCC 496].

    12. It is next contended that, to understand legislative intent of a statute, all its provisions are to be seen harmoniously. In support of such proposition, the petitioners cite:

    12

    i) Poppatlal Shah, Partner of Messrs Indomalayan Trading Company Vs. State of Madras, Represented by Deputy Commercial Tax Officer, Sowcarpet, Madras [AIR 1953 SC 274];

    ii) University of Allahabad and others Vs. Amrit Chand Tripathi and others [(1986) 4 SCC 176]; and

    iii) D. Sanjeevayya Vs. The Election Tribunal, Andhra Pradesh and others

    [AIR 1967 SC 1211].

    13. It is also sought to be argued, by placing reliance on Clauses 2.1.15 and 2.2.1(vi) of the 2011 Regulations, that it is the responsibility of the State Commission to determine tariff. However, the WBERC is abdicating such responsibility by foisting the determination of "fuel surcharge" on the DVC itself, thereby permitting the DVC to determine its own price, which is in contravention of the Scheme of the 2003 Act as well as the 2011 Regulations.

    14. Learned counsel for the petitioners then argue that a statute is to be prospective if it contains substantive provisions imposing penalty.

    15. Regulation 2.10.2 of the 2011 Regulations clearly provide that the tariff is normally to be revised from a prospective date unless there is compelling reason otherwise - if so, detailed justification in writing is required to be given for deviating from the said norm, which is utterly absent from the decision taken by the WBERC and the subsequent implementation of the same by introducing a tariff order for a single year control period. However, the WBERC accorded no reason, compelling or otherwise, for doing so.

    16. The petitioners also seek to argue that the policy is not pragmatic since it has a strong financial impact on consumers. Since 2017 onwards, tariff

    13

    was never determined by the WBERC. Whatever rates prevailed in the interregnum, were either as per various orders of different forums or as per the previous rates of DVC. In view of the impugned decision of the WBERC, there will be adverse financial impact on consumers now, since the tariff increases substantially.

    17. By placing reliance on BSES Rajdhani Power Limited Vs. Delhi Electricity Regulatory Commission, reported at (2022) SCC OnLine SC 1450, learned counsel for the petitioners contend that the concept of 'truing up', which has to be done for the second ensuing year onwards in MYT structure, is not on the same footing as amendment of tariff order under Section 64 of the 2003 Act. Hence, there is no parity between a single year and a multi year tariff inasmuch as the former leaves no scope for such truing up. Hence, without bringing about such a specific amendment to the tariff order, the tariff would be determined every single year which would create utter uncertainty.

    18. Since the licensees adjust the extra payments to be made by them with the price of power/electricity, the burden would ultimately be shifted on the consumers.

    19. Thus, it is contended that the single year tariff order for the financial year 2017-18 ought to be struck down.

    20. Learned senior counsel appearing for the WBERC and the DVC argue that the cardinal principles of an MYT framework are not changed despite the SYT structure of 2017-18.

    21. It is argued that, just as in an MYT structure, the so called SYT structure contemplates the year before the commencement of the tariff order as the

    14

    "Base Year" and the first year of the control period to be the first "Ensuing Year".

    22. That apart, the ARR and ERC are determined for each ensuing year of the Control Period. The initial determination of tariff is only for the first ensuing year and not at a flat rate for all the ensuing years. From the second year onwards in an MYT structure, there is a truing up/adjustment of tariff after taking into account the ARR of the ensuing year as determined in the first ensuing year. Under the MYT framework, the generating company and licensee files composite applications with projection of ARR and ERC without a tariff structure proposal for each ensuing year, which is for the purpose of ARR determination for each ensuing year, tariff determination for the first ensuing year and amendment of tariff of the first or any subsequent ensuing year for fixation of tariff of any ensuing year, after ARR adjustment.

    23. Therefore, tariff of each year of the control period is projected and/or determined separately and not all together at the inception of the Control Period. Hence, it is argued that there is no difference in principle between the SYT and MYT tariff structures as such.

    24. It is further argued that Section 61 contemplates guidelines which are to be considered at the preliminary stage of framing the Regulations and not for each control period decision.

    25. It is submitted that, under Clause 2.2.3 of the 2011 Regulations, the Commission has the sole discretion to follow the MYT principles stipulated in Section 61 and suitably apply the same. It is the prerogative of the

    15

    Commission to determine the extent to which reliance is to be placed on any one principle.

    26. The parameters take into consideration complex calculations and various components, which is best done by an expert authority, that is, the Commission and, as such, it cannot be said that the Commission erred in law by placing less reliance on the MYT framework stipulated in Section 61(f) of the 2003 Act. Chapter 8, Clause 8.2 (a) of the Tariff Regulations of 2011 confers discretion solely on the Commissioner to fix norms/limits. Again, Clause (b) of the same confers power on the Commission to vary or modify the Regulations.

    27. Learned senior counsel for the WBERC places reliance on Tata Power Commission Vs. Maharashtra Electricity Regulatory Commission, reported at (2022) SCC OnLine 1615. It was held therein, inter alia, that the National Tariff Policy law cannot bind or affect the interpretation of the expression

    "shall be guided" as used in Section 61. It was further observed that the determination of tariff and framing of Regulations is within the exclusive domain of the Appropriate Commission. In the present case, it is argued that the only said exercise had been undertaken by the WBERC. It is contended that Section 61 of the 2003 Act can at best specify the general terms and conditions and guiding factors. Section 86, on the other hand, stipulates that the State Government is to determine tariff.

    28. Learned senior counsel for the WBERC next cites Reliance Infrastructure Limited Vs. State of Maharashtra and others, reported at (2019) 3 SCC 352 wherein it was held that courts can interfere in judicial review in cases where the Commission has arrived at a decision only where manifest

    16

    unreasonableness or arbitrariness occurred. It was held by the Supreme Court that the Commission weighs numerous factors and its decision in carrying out complex exercise cannot be constrained. Moreover, the Regulation-framing powers are legislative in nature.

    29. The decision taken by the WBERC on December 14, 2016, that the next Control Period would be for the single year 2017-18, was never challenged for six years thereafter.

    30. As such, the writ petitions ought to be dismissed on such score alone, it is argued.

    31. It is further argued by the WBERC that there is uniformity in the decision of introducing single year tariff for a single financial year by the Commission inasmuch as the tariff for all other licensees have also been determined on single year basis for the same period. Setting aside of the impugned SYT tariff order shall affect the entire tariff structure for other licensees too, whose tariff determinations have already been acted upon by the concerned parties.

    32. It is argued on behalf of the WBERC that tariff determination is equivalent to price fixation, which has been declared by the Supreme Court to be a legislative function. For such proposition, learned senior counsel for the WBERC cites:

    i) Shri Sitaram Sugar Company Limited and another Vs. Union of India and others [(1990) 3 SCC 223];

    ii) Union of India and another Vs. Cynamide India Limited and another [(1987) 2 SCC 720];

    17

    iii) ESSAR Steel Limited Vs. Union of India and others [(2016) 11 SCC 1]; and

    iv) PTC India Limited Vs. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission

    [(2010) 4 SCC 603].

    33. It is further contended that the right of a consumer is very little in price fixation. In support of the said proposition, learned senior counsel relies on an unreported Division Bench Judgment in WBERC Vs. Impex Ferro [FMA 4319 of 2014].

    34. Moreover, it is argued that a co-ordinate Bench decision dated January 9, 2017 of Harish Tandon, J., in DVC Vs. WBERC [WP 26442(W) of 2016] contained a direction for making investment proposal. However, the DVC never made the same, due to which the delay occasioned in proceeding thereon was inevitable. Only when a connected matter came up before Amrita Sinha, J., a direction was given on January 13, 2022 for determining the tariff for the relevant period, pursuant to which the WBERC formulated the tariff order for 2017-18 and for the next control period of 2018-19 to 2019-20.

    35. The consumers, it is argued, shall not be prejudiced in any manner by the impugned order of the WBERC. It is argued that the "useless formality"

    theory comes into play. As both in SYT and MYT tariff structures, different tariff is determined for different ensuing years and the same is determined on the basis of base year for the first ensuing years, there is no difference in principle between the SYT and MYT structures.

    18

    36. On the score of prejudice and non-interference by courts if there is no violation of natural justice, learned senior counsel for the WBERC places the following judgments:

    i) Ashok Kumar Sonkar Vs. Union of India and others [(2007) 4 SCC 54];

    ii) Canara Bank and others Vs. Debasis Das and others [(2003) 4 SCC 557];

    iii) Sohan Lal Gupta (Dead) Through LRS. and others Vs. Asha Devi Gupta (Smt.) and others [(2003) 7 SCC 492]; and

    iv) S.L. Kapoor Vs. Jagmohan and others [(1980) 4 SCC 379].

    37. It is also contended by the WBERC that the writ petitions are not maintainable inasmuch as Section 111 of the 2003 Act provides sufficient efficacious alternative remedy to the petitioners. Such an appeal has a limitation period of 45 days. However, instead of preferring an appeal, the petitioners have taken out the present writ petitions.

    38. Moreover, there is no appeal against the May 5, 2022 tariff order as such. On the score of maintainability and alternative remedy, learned senior counsel for the WBERC places reliance on West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission Vs. CESC Limited, reported at (2002) 8 SCC 715 and H.P. Electricity Regulatory Commission Vs. H.P. State Electricity Board, reported at (2006) 9 SCC 233.

    39. The Regulations themselves having not been challenged as such, no Constitutional point has been questioned in the present case, it is argued. Accordingly, in the light of the existing Regulations as indicated above, which have never been challenged by the petitioners, no Constitutional point is raised in the present matters.

    19

    40. In order to properly appreciate the issues involved in the present writ petitions, certain terms are required to be looked into.

    41. The expression 'Control Period' is defined in Clause 1.2.1(xxx) of the 2011 Regulations. As per the said definition, control period is a period consisting of a number of year(s) fixed from time to time under the MYT framework.

    42. Clause 1.2.1(xviii) defines "Base Year" as the year preceding the first year of the control period.

    43. "Ensuing Year", as defined in Clause 1.2.1(xlviii), is year(s) in a control period for which the tariff is determined. 'One', 'two', etc. in reference to ensuing year means respectively the first, second, etc. year immediately subsequent to the base year. A careful perusal of the above definitions indicates that the term "base year" signifies a single year prior to the first year of control period whereas the expressions "control period" and

    "ensuing year" refer to "year(s)". The use of plural in parentheses indicates that both definitions may contemplate either a single or several years.

    44. Hence, there is nothing in the definitions to preclude an MYT Framework having only a single year of control period.

    45. Secondly, even in case of an SYT Framework, there can be a base year and at least one ensuing year.

    46. In our present example of SYT determination for the financial year 2017- 18, the base year would be 2016-17 and first ensuing year would be 2017-

    18.

    47. As such, even a 'Single Year Tariff' takes within its fold the consideration of at least two years, that is, the preceding year (base year) and the single year of control period (ensuing year). Thus, although we loosely refer to the

    20

    2017-18 tariff order as having a single year format, the minimum number of years which have to be taken into consideration in that case also are two, that is, 2016-17 and 2017-18.

    48. That apart, Clause 2.5 of the 2011 Regulations provides for Multi Year Tariff Framework. It is clear from the opening paragraph of Clause 2.5.1 that MYT Framework shall be based on certain elements, for calculation of ARR (Aggregate Revenue Requirement) and ERC (Expected Revenue from Charges) of each ensuing year. The determination of tariff is done only for the first ensuing year. From the second year onwards, there is amendment of tariff after adjustment with ARR of the ensuing year as determined in the first ensuing year. Under the MYT Framework, generating companies and licensees file composite applications with projection of ARR and ERC and tariff structure proposal for each ensuing year for the following purposes:

    a) ARR determination for each ensuing year,

    b) Tariff determination for first ensuing year.

    c) Amendment of tariff of first or any subsequent ensuing year for fixation of tariff for any ensuing year after ARR adjustment.

    49. As per the language of Clause 2.5 above, the tariff of each year of the control period is projected and/or adjusted and determined separately, as opposed to determination of tariff for entire control period at the inception.

    50. Hence, there is sufficient flexibility within the multi year tariff system itself to determine tariff for one ensuing year at a time.

    51. In any event, since the control period in the present case is a single year, the ARR and ERC calculations will remain valid only for the said period, as opposed to a control period of several years, in which case also each

    21

    ensuing year's tariff would have to be determined individually and not at a flat rate at the outset of the first ensuing year.

    52. Hence, I do not find any cardinal difference insofar as calculations are concerned between an MYT and an SYT system.

    53. Clause 5.3(h) of the National Tariff Policy contemplates Multi Year Tariff on the basis of Section 61 of the 2003 Act. It speaks about the MYT 'framework', which may also accommodate a control period of a single financial year, as discussed above.

    54. It mentions that the framework should feature a five year control period and the initial control period may be of three years if deemed necessary by the Regulatory Commission on account of data uncertainty and other practical considerations. In cases of lack of reliable data, the Appropriate Commission may state remissions in MYT for the first control period and a fresh control period may be started as and when more reliable data becomes available. Section 61(i) of the 2003 Act mentions the National Electricity Policy and National Tariff Policy as two of the guiding factors for determination of tariff. We must read the said Clause in proper perspective. The multi year framework and the initial suggestion of a five year control period is not a sole and exclusive binding factor on the State Commission and the weightage to be given to the said component of the guiding factors, which are about nine (09) in number, depends on the Commission itself.

    55. Although the National Tariff Policy is a factor to be considered, a particular expression or clause used in the National Tariff Policy cannot be so sacrosanct that it would transcend the component of guidance which it is

    22

    supposed to provide, along with other components under Section 61 of the 2003 Act.

    56. In fact, Sections 61 and 62 of the 2003 operate in different fields. Whereas Section 61 speaks about tariff regulations to be formulated by the Appropriate Commission, Section 62 deals with the actual determination of tariff.

    57. For the purpose of testing the legality of the Single Year Tariff under challenge, we are to look into the provisions of the 2003 Act and the 2011 Regulations.

    58. Since the tariff regulations, as reflected in the Clauses of the 2011 Regulations discussed above, read in conjunction with Section 61 of the 2003 Act, do not preclude the formulation of a control period of one year specifically, in the absence of any such bar, it cannot be said that the WBERC acted de hors the law in framing the 2017-18 control period.

    59. Under Clause 8.2(a) of the 2011 Regulations, the Commission is empowered, at its sole discretion, to fix suitable norms/limits for any or all the items of expenses.

    60. Sub-clause (b) of the Clause provides that the Commission may, at any time, at its sole discretion, vary, alter, modify, add or amend any provision of the Regulations.

    61. However, in the present case, sub-clause (a) is not applicable at all, since it is not a question of the Commission fixing norms/limits of expenses.

    62. Insofar as sub-clause (b) is concerned, there is no change in the Regulations, as such, in the present case to attract the said provision.

    23

    63. It is seen clearly that the WBERC acted within the ambit of its existing Regulations while fixing the tariff for the period 2017-18.

    64. As long back as on December 14, 2016, the 2017-2018 control period was declared by the WBERC by its order. Such order was not challenged over a period of six years prior to the tariff order itself being made effective for 2017-18 vide the impugned order dated May 5, 2022.

    65. Thus, it does not now lie in the mouth of the petitioners to say that the fixation of one-year control period was itself bad. The determination of tariff in 2022 was merely a consequence and incidental to the said fixation of one-year control period on December 14, 2016.

    66. Again, if we read Clause 2.2.3 of the 2011 Regulations, it is the Commission's sole discretion to follow the MYT principles and suitably apply those principles and also to choose the extent to which reliance on any one principle would be placed.

    67. In the present case, it is the MYT principles which are under consideration. Since the MYT Framework as contemplated in the 2011 Regulations themselves accommodate single year control period, there is no reason why the exercise of discretion under Clause 2.2.3 of the WBERC has to be faulted on the ground of statutory violation.

    68. Insofar as Tata Power Company (supra) is concerned, it is clearly observed that the National Tariff Policy cannot bind interpretation of the expression

    "shall be guided" under Section 61 of the 2003 Act. Determination of tariff and framing Regulations was held to be within the exclusive domain of the Appropriate Commission. As per Section 61, it is the State Commission which has to specify the terms and conditions for determination of tariff

    24

    and, as such, the impugned exercise was within the jurisdiction of the

    WBERC.

    69. However, Reliance Infrastructure (supra), cited by the WBERC, does not have any direct relevance since it was held there that the Commission weighs numerous factors and its decision in carrying out complex exercise cannot be constrained. The Court in judicial review can interfere in such a discretionary exercise only where there is manifest unreasonableness or arbitrariness, it was held. In the present case, however, the challenge is not directed against any Regulation framed by the Commission but concerns mere interpretation of an order of the WBERC in the context of existing Law and Regulations.

    70. It is seen that the tariff determined for the financial year 2017-18 is uniform for all licensees including the DVC.

    71. As such, there is no discrimination between the licensees inter se. In fact, the Commission is justified in arguing that in the event the tariff determination for the said financial year is interfered with at this juncture, it shall affect the entire tariff structure for other licensees as well, whose tariff determination exercise is long over and has been acted upon.

    72. It is evident from the judgments cited by the WBERC in the cases of Shri Sitaram Sugar Company Limited and another (supra), Cynamide India Limited and another (supra), ESSAR Steel Limited (supra) and the unreported judgment of this Court in WBERC Vs. Impex Ferro in FMA 4319 of 2014 that price fixation and tariff determination are legislative functions.

    73. In the present case, as such, the question of passing a reasoned order does not arise at all. First, since the order determining the control period, which

    25

    is substantially under challenge, was passed in the year 2016 and attained finality over the next six years. Secondly, there is no contravention of any law or Regulation on the part of the WBERC in consequentially fixing tariff for the financial year 2017-18.

    74. Insofar as the alleged delay on the part of the WBERC in passing the tariff order for 2017-18 in the year 2022 is concerned, one of the factors to be considered was that the order passed by the co-ordinate bench of Harish Tandon, J. in WP 6442(W) of 2016 dated January, 9, 2017 incorporated a specific direction for making investment proposal.

    75. Insofar as the DVC is concerned, no such tariff determination proposal was given. Only on January 13, 2022 another co-ordinate bench of Amrita Sinha, J., specifically directed the WBERC to determine the tariff, although no investment proposal came over the years.

    76. Hence, there is sufficient reason for the WBERC delaying the tariff determination awaiting investment proposal as per the order of Harish Tandon, J.

    77. As far as maintainability of the present challenge is concerned, it has been rightly argued on behalf of the WBERC that Section 111 of the 2003 Act provides for appeal by any person aggrieved by an order made by an adjudicating officer under the 2003 Act or an order made by the Appropriate Commission under the Act before the appellate tribunal for electricity. In the present case, if aggrieved by the order of the Commission dated December 14, 2016, whereby the control period was determined as one year for the financial year 2017-18, the present petitioners could very well have preferred a challenge within the limitation period of 45 days as

    26

    stipulated in sub-section (2) of Section 111 of the 2003 Act. Having not done so, the said order has attained finality and the tariff determination of 2022 is clearly an exercise under Section 62 of the 2003 Act consequential to the said order of 2016.

    78. Hence, the judgments of WBERC Vs. CESC (supra) and H.P. ERC Vs. H.P. SEB (supra) cited by the WBERC are apt in this regard.

    79. Inasmuch as the challenge to the alleged retrospectivity of the tariff determination of 2017-18 is concerned, the said argument does not stand on firm ground.

    80. In fact, the arguments advanced of such score refer primarily to the retrospectivity of statutes. In the present case, however, there is no question of any statute being retrospective. Insofar as the tariff determination itself is concerned, the stipulation of 120 days after the filling of the application for determination of tariff by the DVC in 2016, it was the DVC itself which delayed the matter by failing to honour the co- ordinate Bench direction of filing an investment proposal which was the reason for the entire delay in ascertaining the tariff. Moreover, the tariff for the period of 2017-18 was never decided before the year 2022.

    81. The first time it was determined was by the impugned determination in the year 2022. Whatever tariff was paid in the meantime in consonance with the orders of Courts/forums and/or Central Regulations prevailing from time to time, if any, were subject to the final determination of tariff by the WBERC, which is the State Commission.

    82. Since the tariff for 2017-18 has been determined by the WBERC for the first time in 2022 with effect from the year 2017-18, the same is not a

    27

    "retrospective" determination but a late/subsequent determination of tariff. It would, no doubt, be a retrospective determination in the true sense in the event a tariff had been determined previously for the relevant period of 2017-18 and subsequently another imposition of tariff was made for a previous period. The present determination, however, covers the period after 2016, till when the determinations had last been made. Therefore the retrospective argument fails.

    83. Insofar as the requirement of giving reasons in writing is concerned, as per the judgments cited by the petitioners, the same pertains primarily to quasi-judicial or judicial orders. In the present case, the exercise undertaken by the WBERC, which is impugned herein, was of a legislative nature and not a quasi-judicial or adjudicatory function relating to disputes of particular individuals. Hence, the said judgments do not apply as well in the present case.

    84. The argument that WBERC is foisting the determination of fuel surcharge on the DVC, thereby abdicating its own responsibility of determining tariff, is neither here nor there. The same is divorced from the entire challenge preferred in the present batch of writ petitions.

    85. If we look into the relevant Clauses of the 2011 Regulations, which have been cited by the petitioners, we do not find corroboration of the said argument of the petitioners. The calculation of fuel surcharge is in its very nature an additional charge to be imposed by the licensee itself, in the present case the DVC and does not have anything to do with the determination of tariff by the Regulatory Commission.

    28

    86. Inasmuch as the alleged financial impact on consumers is concerned, such argument does not find favour with this Court, since the WBERC determined tariff for the period of 2017-18 for the first time in 2022 by the impugned tariff order. The consumers were well aware that the tariff charged from them would ultimately be that determined by the WBERC. The charges previously paid were in terms of the orders of different forums and/or the previous rates of the DVC, passed from time to time, and were to be ultimately adjusted with the tariff to be determined by the WBERC.

    87. There is nothing on record to indicate that if the investment proposal was given by the DVC and taken into consideration, the Commission would not have increased the tariff instead of decreasing the same for the consumers.

    88. Moreover, the impact, if any, is not universal but only applies to the consumers to the DVC.

    89. There is nothing to show that there would be adverse impact on the consumers, sufficiently to afford a cause of action to the consumers to challenge the impugned tariff order.

    90. Inasmuch as BSES Rajdhani Power Limited (supra) judgment is concerned, the same does not acquire relevance in the present context. It was held there that 'truing up' is not amendment of tariff order under Section 64, which has no application in the facts of the instant case. In the present case, however, the MYT framed for 2017-18 took into consideration the base year of 2016 and the ensuing year of 2017, which falls entirely within the MYT Framework itself and does not violate any of the definitions in the 2011 Regulations and/or any concept therein.

    29

    91. Accordingly, there is no scope of interference in the present writ petitions. Hence the following writ petitions are dismissed without any order as to costs:

    i) WPA No.9857 of 2022 with

    ii) WPA No.10069 of 2022 with

    iii) WPA No.10107 of 2022 with

    iv) WPA No.10315 of 2022 with

    v) WPA No.10654 of 2022 with

    vi) WPA No.10700 of 2022 with IA No. CAN 1 of 2022 with

    vii) WPA No.10962 of 2022 with IA No. CAN 1 of 2022 with

    viii) WPA No.10963 of 2022 with

    ix) WPA No.10967 of 2022 with

    x) WPA No.11196 of 2022 with

    xi) WPA No.11200 of 2022 with

    xii) WPA No.11268 of 2022 with

    xiii) WPA No.11691 of 2022 with

    xiv) WPA No.11913 of 2022 wi9th

    xv) WPA No.12060 of 2022 with

    xvi) WPA No.16133 of 2022 with

    xvii) WPA No.16136 of 2022 with

    xviii) WPA No.16834 of 2022 with

    xix) WPA No.17227 of 2022 with

    xx) WPA No.17234 of 2022 with

    xxi) WPA No.22993 of 2022 with

    xxii) WPA No.9861 of 2022 with

    30

    xxiii) WPA No.9869 of 2022 with

    xxiv) WPA No.9872 of 2022 with

    xxv) WPA No.9892 of 2022 with

    xxvi) WPA No.9897 of 2022 with

    xxvii) WPA No.9902 of 2022 with xxviii) WPA No.9933 of 2022 with

    xxix) WPA No.9938 of 2022 with

    xxx) WPA No.9942 of 2022 with

    xxxi) WPA No.9947 of 2022 with

    xxxii) WPA No.15255 of 2022 with IA No. CAN 2 of 2022, CAN 3 of 2022 with

    xxxiii) WPA No.17114 of 2022.

    92. Urgent certified copies, if applied for, be issued to the applicants subject to compliance of due formalities.

    ( Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J. )

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    NILKANTH FERRO LIMITED AND ANR v. WEST BENGAL STATE ELECTRICITY REGULATORY COMMISSION AND ORS
    (Feb 17, 2023)