AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 34 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
  • Sections 3, 4 & 5 of the Interest Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 34 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
  • Sections 3, 4 & 5 of the Interest Act.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff, P C Chanda & Company Private Limited, filed a suit seeking a decree for Rs. 14,69,095/- along with pendente lite interest and interest on judgment at 24% per annum. The defendant appeared and filed a written statement. The plaintiff subsequently filed an application (GA 5 of 2021) for a decree on admission for Rs. 9,09,136/-, which was contested by the defendant. The Court disposed of this application on 24.03.2021, granting a decree for Rs. 9,09,136/- with interest at 8% per annum from 01.07.2017 until realization, while relegating the balance claim and other interest claims to the suit.

The defendant appealed against this order, but the appeal was dismissed for default on 10.11.2022. The Court then proceeded with discovery, inspection, witness examination, and arguments, during which the defendant repeatedly failed to comply with procedural requirements and did not pay the decreed amount. The plaintiff claimed interest at 24% per annum as per invoice terms, while the defendant contended that the plaintiff was entitled only to the interest already awarded at 8% per annum.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to interest at the contractual rate of 24% per annum on the principal amount after the decree awarding interest at 8% per annum was passed.
  2. The applicability and extent of interest payable when a prior decree has already awarded interest at a lower rate.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The invoices exhibited during witness testimony contained a clause stipulating interest at 24% per annum if payment was not made within 15 days from the bill date.
  • The defendant failed to pay the amount within the stipulated period, entitling the plaintiff to interest at 24% per annum.
  • Relied on the Supreme Court judgment in Executive Engineer (Irrigation) Balimela & Ors. -vs- Abhaduta Jena & Ors. (1988) 1 SCC 418, emphasizing the Court’s power to allow interest as per contract and the interplay with the Interest Act and CPC Section 34.
  • Claimed that parties are entitled to interest as per their contract, and the prior decree awarding 8% interest did not preclude further interest claims.

Defendant's Arguments

  • The Court’s order dated 24.03.2021 had already awarded interest at 8% per annum from 01.07.2017 until realization.
  • The plaintiff had obtained a decree covering the principal and interest, and no further interest should be granted beyond that.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
(1988) 1 SCC 418 - Executive Engineer (Irrigation) Balimela & Ors. -vs- Abhaduta Jena & Ors. The Court’s power to allow interest in cases specified under Section 4(2) of the Interest Act and the applicability of Section 34 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. The Court recognized that parties are entitled to interest as per contract and that the Interest Act does not override provisions of the CPC.
(2014) 11 SCC - Tamil Nadu Generation & Distribution Corporation Limited -v- PPN Power Generating Company Private Limited Definition and nature of interest as compensation for deprivation of money due, including reliance on Central Bank of India v. Ravindra (2002) 1 SCC 367 and Riches v. Westminster Bank Ltd. (1947 AC 390). The Court referred to this precedent to clarify the nature of interest as compensation for delayed payment and the legal basis for awarding interest.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted that the defendant had failed to pay the principal and interest as decreed. While the initial decree awarded interest at 8% per annum from 01.07.2017, the plaintiff’s invoices contained a contractual clause for interest at 24% per annum if payment was delayed beyond 15 days. However, the plaintiff’s legal notice claimed interest at 18% per annum, showing some inconsistency.

The Court acknowledged the principle that parties are entitled to interest according to their contract and that the Interest Act and CPC permit such contractual arrangements. The Court also analyzed the nature of interest as compensation for the creditor’s deprivation of money beyond the due date, relying on authoritative precedents.

Balancing these factors, the Court concluded that although a decree had been passed for interest at 8%, the defendant’s failure to pay justified awarding further interest. However, instead of granting the full contractual rate of 24%, the Court fixed the additional interest rate at 10% per annum from 01.07.2018 until realization, reflecting a moderated approach considering the circumstances and prior decree.

Holding and Implications

The suit (CS 158 of 2018) is disposed of. A decree is drawn up for Rs. 9,09,136/- with interest at 8% per annum from 01.07.2017 till realization, and further interest at 10% per annum from 01.07.2018 till realization.

The decision enforces the contractual right to interest while recognizing the prior decree’s interest award. It clarifies that failure to pay the decreed amount may warrant additional interest, though at a moderated rate. No new precedent is established beyond the application of existing principles to the facts of this case.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    P C CHANDRA & COMPANY PRIVATE LIMITED v. BHARAT CHEMICALS & PAINTS

    IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA

    (Ordinary Original Civil Jurisdiction)

    COMMERCIAL DIVISION

    Present:

    The Hon'ble Justice Krishna Rao CS/158/2018

    P C Chanda & Company Private Limited Vs.

    Bharat Chemicals & Paints Mr. Ratul Das

    Mr. Shiv Ratan Kakrania

    Mr. Tanuj Kakrania

    Mr. Karanjeet Sharma

    …For the plaintiff.

    Mr. Arik Banerjee

    Mr. Shaunak Ghosh

    Mr. Sourav Mondal

    …For the defendant.

    Heard on : 20.01.2023

    Judgment on : 31.01.2023

    1

    2

    Krishna Rao, J.:

    The plaintiff has filed the instant suit praying for a decree for a sum of Rs. 14,69,095/- along with pendente lite interest and interest on judgment @ 24 % per annum. After receipt of Writ of Summons, the defendant had entered appearance and filed written statement. After filing of the written statement, the plaintiff had filed a general application being GA 5 of 2021 praying for a decree on admission for a sum of Rs. 9,09,136/-. The application filed by the plaintiff was duly contested by the defendant and accordingly this Court had disposed of the said application on 24.03.2021 by passing following order :

    "In the facts of the present case, the defendant issued a cheque for a sum of Rs.9,09,136/- in favour of the plaintiff. The cheque was dishonoured upon presentation. The reason for dishonour is fund insufficient. There is no material on record to establish that the defendant stopped payment of the cheque for the ground as alleged today.

    In such circumstances, since the cheque was dishonoured for fund insufficient, the defence sought to raise by the defendant is moonshine.

    Consequently, there will be a decree for a sum of Rs.9,09,136/- in favour of the plaintiff and as against the defendant. The plaintiff will be entitled to interest at the rate of 8% per annum on and from July 1, 2017 till realization. The balance claim of the plaintiff along with the claim for interest for any other period are relegated to the suit.

    IA No. GA/5/2021 in CS/158/2018 is disposed of accordingly. The decree be drawn up expeditiously."

    The defendant had preferred an appeal against the order dt. 24.03.2021 being APD No. 4 of 2021. The appeal preferred by the defendant

    3

    was dismissed for default on 10.11.2022 and in the said order, it is also clarified that "Interim order, if thereby any stand vacated".

    In the order dated 24.03.2021 while disposing of the application filed by the plaintiff being GA 5 of 2021, this Court had directed that the balance claim of the plaintiff along with claim for interest for any other period are delegated to the suit. In terms of the order dated 24.03.2021, the plaintiff had proceeded the case further and accordingly on 11.07.2022, this Court directed the parties to complete the discovery and inspection of the documents within four (4) weeks and accordingly the matter was adjourned till 22.08.2022. On 22.08.2022 though the Counsel for the plaintiff was present but none appears on behalf of the defendant and the defendant has also not offered for inspection of documents and also not come forward for inspection of documents of the plaintiff and accordingly for the interest of justice again the case was adjourned till 07.09.2022. On 19.09.2022, the matter was again placed before this Court but none appears on behalf of the defendant and the defendant had also not carried out inspection and discovery of the documents and thus finding no other alternative fix the case for witness action. On 27.09.2022, the plaintiff has examined the witness and during his examination, three documents were exhibited but none appears on behalf of the defendant and accordingly the evidence of the plaintiff was closed and the case was fixed for argument. On 09.01.2022, when the matter was taken up for argument, the Counsel for the defendant had appeared and submits that the defendants have taken appropriate steps for recalling of the order dt. 19.09.2022 and had prayed for time. For the

    4

    interest of justice, the case was adjourned till 16.11.2022. On 16.11.2022, the defendant has filed two application being GA 6 of 2022 and GA 7 of 2022 for recalling of the order dt. 19.09.2022 and 27.09.2022 and accordingly the Counsel for the plaintiff pray for time to file their affidavit in opposition against the said applications. The case was adjourned till 20.12.2022. On 20.12.2022, the plaintiff has filed affidavit in opposition in connection with both applications but none appeared on behalf of the defendant but for the interest of justice, the defendants were given liberty to file reply to the affidavit in opposition filed by the plaintiff and fixed the matter on 04.01.2022. On 04.01.2022 none appears on behalf of either of the parties and the case was adjourned on 13.01.2023. On 13.01.2023, the Counsel for the respective parties have appeared and the Counsel for the defendant submits that the defendant is ready to settle the matter by paying the interest but required sometime and as per the submission made by the Counsel for the defendant, the case was adjourned till 20.01.2023. On 20.01.2023, though the Learned Counsel for the respective parties have appeared but neither the defendant has paid the interest amount nor had filed the reply or pressed for hearing of the interlocutory application filed by the defendant and accordingly the suit was taken up for hearing for final argument was concluded.

    Now, the plaintiff has claimed interest on Rs. 9,09,136/- @ 24 % per annum in terms of the condition of invoices. Counsel for the plaintiff submits that during the evidence of witness, invoices were exhibited being Exhibit 2 collectively and in the said invoices, it is categorically mentioned

    5

    that "Interest @ 24% per annum will be charged if not paid within 15 days from the date of receipt of the bill".

    Counsel for the plaintiff submits that as the defendant failed to pay amount of the bill within 15 days and as such the plaintiff is entitled to get interest @ 24% per annum.

    Counsel for the defendants submits that while passing the order dated 24.03.2021 in GA 5 of 2021, this Court had awarded interest @ 8% per annum with effect from 01.07.2017 till realization and as such the plaintiff is not entitled to get any further interest. Counsel for the defendants submits that the plaintiff has already got a decree with respect of the principal amount as well as interest and as such no further interest can be granted to the plaintiff.

    Counsel for the plaintiff in support of his claim has relied upon the judgment reported in (1988) 1 SCC 418 (Executive Engineer (Irrigation) Balimela & Ors. -vs- Abhaduta Jena & Ors.) and submits that the Court can allow interest in the class of cases specified in Section 4(2) from the dates stipulated to the dates stipulated in the provision and Section 5 provides that nothing in the Act shall affect the provisions of Section 34 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.

    Considered the submissions made by the parties and materials on record.

    Though the defendant had filed written statement but the defendant has neither come forward to cross examine the witness nor have adduced

    6

    any witness. Initially this Court had already granted decree on admission with respect of the principal amount along with interest @ 8% per annum from 01.07/2017 till realization.

    As per submissions of the plaintiff after the order dated 24.03.2021, the plaintiff had already initiated execution proceeding but till date the defendant has not paid either the principal amount or the interest as decreed by this Court. The main contention of the plaintiff is that in terms of invoices there was a contract between the parties with respect of the interest which clearly provides that in case, the defendant failed to pay the amount within 15 days from the bill date, the defendant is liable to pay interest @ 24% per annum. This Court while passing the order dated 24.03.2021 has awarded interest @ 8% and relegated the further claim for trial. As per Exhibit 3 i.e. Legal Notice sent by the plaintiff to the defendant dt. 04.08.2017 wherein the defendant has claimed interest @ 18% per annum. The Judgment relied upon by the plaintiff in connection with Interest Act and the said case pertains to the arbitration proceeding. In the said case, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has defined Sections 3, 4 & 5 of the Interest Act. There is no doubt if the parties have agreed for the interest in a contract, the parties are entitled to get interest in terms of the contract. In the instance case, the plaintiff has relied upon the invoices and claiming interest @ 24% per annum and on the other hand, the plaintiff has claimed interest @ 18 % per annum through Exhibit 2 from the defendant. While passing orders on admission dt. 24.05.2021, this Court has awarded interest @ 8% from 17.07.2021 till realization. In the case reported in (2014) 11 SCC (Tamil

    7

    Nadu Generation & Distribution Corporation Limited -v- PPN Power Generating Company Private Limited) paragraph 73 reads as follows : -

    "73. With regard to the issue raised about the interest on late payment, APTEL has considered the entire matter and come to the conclusion that interest is payable on compound rate basis in terms of Article 10.6 of the PPA. In coming to the aforesaid conclusion, APTEL has relied on a judgment of this Court in Central Bank of India v. Ravindra [(2002) 1 SCC 367] . In this judgment it has been held as follows: (SCC p. 394, para 37)

    "37. … The essence of interest in the opinion of Lord Wright, in Riches v. Westminster Bank Ltd. [1947 AC 390 : (1947) 1 All ER 469 (HL)] (AC at p. 400 : All ER at p. 472E-F) is that:

    '… it is a payment which becomes due because the creditor has not had his money at the due date. It may be regarded either as representing the profit he might have made if he had had the use of the money, or, conversely, the loss he suffered because he had not that use. The general idea is that he is entitled to compensation for the deprivation;'

    the money due to the creditor was not paid, or, in other words, 'was withheld from him by the debtor after the time when payment should have been made, in breach of his legal rights, and interest was a compensation, whether the compensation was liquidated under an agreement or statute'.

    A Division Bench of the High Court of Punjab speaking through Tek Chand, J. in CIT v. Sham LalNarula [AIR 1963 P&H 411] thus articulated the concept of interest: (AIR p. 414, para 8) '8. The words "interest" and "compensation" are sometimes used interchangeably and on other occasions they have distinct connotation. "Interest" in general terms is the return or compensation for the use or retention by one person of a sum of money belonging to or owed to another. In its narrow sense, "interest" is understood to mean the amount which one has contracted to pay for use of borrowed money. …

    In whatever category "interest" in a particular case may be put, it is a consideration paid either for the use of money or for forbearance in demanding it, after it has fallen due, and thus, it is a charge for the use or forbearance of money. In this sense, it is a compensation allowed by law or fixed by parties, or permitted by custom or usage, for use of money, belonging to another, or for the delay in paying money after it has become payable."

    In view of the above, this Court finds that already a decree with respect of Rs. 9,09,136/- is passed along with interest @ 8% per annum

    8

    from 01.07.2017 till realization of the said amount. The defendant failed to pay the principal amount and the interest till date. Though in the invoice, there is clause that if the defendant failed to pay bill amount within 15 days from date, the defendant is liable to pay @ 24% interest per annum but in the notice i.e. Exhibit 2, the plaintiff has claimed only 18 % interest per annum and thus this Court is of the view that the defendant is liable to pay further interest on a sum of Rs. 9,09,136/- @ 10% per annum from 01.07.2018 till realization of the said amount.

    CS 158 of 2018 is disposed of. Decree be drawn accordingly. (Krishna Rao, J.)

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    P C CHANDRA & COMPANY PRIVATE LIMITED v. BHARAT CHEMICALS & PAINTS
    (Jan 31, 2023)