Per contra, Mr. Lakshi Kumar Gupta, Senior Advocate, has submitted that the writ petitioners, although appointed on a temporary basis on 11th January, 2003 has been discharging his work as a teacher uninterruptedly and continuously till date and has been discharging the same work as that of a permanent regular teacher. The teachers were appointed for a fixed tenure against permanent posts, but subsequently their appointment was made to continue till their attaining 60 years of age and hence they cannot be treated as contractual teachers. In such circumstances, describing these teachers as contractual teachers is a contradiction in terms. The workload of the petitioner is no less than that of the regular teacher inasmuch as the petitioner has been assigned with works that are usually assigned to a permanent regular teacher like that of being an examiner and scrutinizer for the West Bengal Council of Higher Secondary Education for the subject of Economics on 26thDecember, 2013.
It is submitted that the respondents have taken a policy decision not to appoint any additional teachers for some of the Higher Secondary Schools which were running with part-time contractual teachers since 2003 with no additional posts being sanctioned to such Higher Secondary Schools for the subjects taken care of by the part-time contractual teachers meaning thereby that the Government has stopped the recruitment process of the full time teacher on permanent basis as the performance of the contractual part- time teachers was found to be satisfactory and at par with regular teachers already appointed. The very fact that the services of these contractual teachers were continued uninterruptedly shows that they were found to be
19
indispensable. Our attention is drawn to the letter dated 28thJuly, 2010 in which the Joint Secretary to the Government of West Bengal Education Department has communicated his decision to sanction ten days casual leave and ten days medical leave to the part-time contractual teachers attached to different Government-aided/sponsored Higher Secondary schools under the Directorate of School Education, Government of West Bengal, subject to the condition that they have to take equal number of classes per week like the duties of regular and full time teachers. Mr. Gupta submits that this communication itself shows that the contractual teachers were taking equal number of classes per week as that of the regular full time teachers.
It is submitted that the writ petitioner is a teacher of Economics in standards 11 and 12 at Khandra High School and is taking 22-26 classes per week in terms of the Government Order dated 29thAugust, 2008 as no additional teacher was sanctioned by the Government for the subjects which have contractual teacher posted. Our attention is drawn to paragraph 6 of the supplementary affidavits filed by the writ petitioner in which it has been stated:
"That the said school has a total number of 1193 students for this academic year reading in standards 5 to 12, and for the same the requirement as per Government circular dated 08.07.1975 was 27 teachers and at present in terms of government circular dated 05.03.1998 is 15 teachers".
20
It is submitted that the school has a sanctioned strength of 11 permanent teachers for standards 5 to 12. There is a shortfall of 16 teachers as per the circular dated 8thJuly,1975. Furthermore, none of the other teachers can take the class of Economics on the basis of their academic qualifications.
Mr. Gupta has drawn our attention to the order dated 8thOctober, 2013 passed in the earlier petition in which the Secretary of the Government School Education Department was directed to take a decision with regard to the prayer made by the petitioner for equal pay for the equal work and the order passed by the Secondary Education on 27thDecember, 2013. It is submitted that the authority has completely ignored the issue regarding the claim of equal pay by shutting its eyes to the ground situation of the number of classes the writ petitioner has to necessarily take in the interest of the students, as was realized by the respondent authorities while issuing the order being G.O. 1176-SE(S)/1S-37/09 dated 28thJuly, 2010. It is submitted that the chart disclosed in the supplementary affidavit showing allotment of classes would clearly demonstrate that the writ petitioner was discharging duties by taking equal number of classes akin to the permanent full time teachers.
The learned Senior Counsel submits that the selection of candidates was done by following the elaborate Guideline framed by the State for this special recruitment drive undertaken with a special object as would appear from Government order no.219-SE(HS)-16A-5/01 dated June 6, 2002. It is
21
submitted that the authority felt great difficulty in overcoming the G.O. No. 1176-SE(S) dated 28thJuly, 2010 which required such teachers to take the same number of classes as the permanent teachers do. In an attempt to wriggle out of this difficulty the said authority has withdrawn the said G.O., knowing fully well that such withdrawal is only paper work. The so-called contractual part-time teachers will have to continue taking the same number of classes as the regular teachers as they have been doing since at least September 2008, that is, after issuance of the Government Order No. 1757(20) GA dated 24.08.2008 when additional appointment of teachers was stopped in respect of the subjects being taught by teachers like the petitioner. The petitioner is entitled in law to get the same treatment regarding pay and all other service benefits as are being enjoyed by the permanent teachers recognised as such by applying the ratio laid down in Bhagwan Dass vs. State of Haryana and Ors., 1987 (4) SCC 634; Jaipal and Ors. vs. State of Haryana, 1988 (3) SCC 354; and State of Punjab and Ors. vs. Jagjit Singh, 2017 (1) SCC 148, no matter whether the mode of appointment is different.
The grievance of the petitioners finds support from Article 23(2) of the Constitution as they are being exploited by making them work full time and denying equal pay which was a factor considered in Jagjit Singh (supra). The case of Jagjit Singh considers claim of daily wagers / contractual employees having no permanence of service. Indisputably the situation of claimants given permanence in service was not the subject matter as in the instant matter the appointment of the petitioners is not a backdoor entry
22
but by following a selection process at state level, however, the initial appointment was on contractual basis but subsequently the same was made permanent and the petitioner's status ceased to be merely contractual. This situation did not come up in Jagjit's case. The petitioner qualifies the required standard mentioned in paragraph 42.5 of Jagjit's case for claiming equal pay. Requirement of being regular appointees as mentioned in paragraph 42.6 of Jagjit Singh's case was accepted by the Government in course of time by making the petitioner permanent by stopping appointment of additional teachers and by requiring the petitioner to take equal number of classes. In Jagjit Singh's case, court found that all conditions for grant of equal pay were satisfied, however, court only allowed minimum pay.
Mr. Gupta has submitted that the question of equal pay for equal work is distinct and separate from the question of regularization. Even if regularization cannot be granted equal pay cannot be denied. Mr. Gupta has submitted that these teachers have been rendering their service uninterruptedly and sincerely for almost 17 years but they have been deprived of their legitimate dues. The State cannot act arbitrarily and indulge in unfair exploitation of teachers.
On the basis of the aforesaid submission we have to assess the merits of the order passed by the learned Single Bench.
The undisputed fact that has emerged from the pleadings and the submissions made on behalf of the parties is that the Government by
23
notification dated 6thJune, 2002 sanctioned 900 posts of part-time teachers on contractual basis. The part-time teachers would be required to take 10 periods per week and carry out their duties in school as allotted to them. During vacation, they would get consolidated pay of Rs. 2000/- per month without any allowance. They would not claim appointment on regular basis on expiry of their tenure and their appointment would be terminable on one month notice on either side and before completion of the contractual period of one year. These terms are contra-distinguishable from the posts filled up through the respective School Service Commission vide notification dated 8th August, 2002 for the purpose of filling up the regular posts of teachers following the Reservation Rules (100 point roster) and all other rules and procedures, as framed by the Government from time-to-time. The honorarium of the part-time teachers on contractual basis was, however, enhanced from time-to-time and presently the part-time teachers are receiving an honorarium of Rs. 13,000/- per month. The Government, perhaps, was satisfied with the performance of the part-time teachers, who were appointed for up-gradation of Higher Secondary Schools as is discernible from the notification dated 25thFebruary, 2009. The Government, while enhancing the emoluments of the part time teachers to Rs. 6,000/- only per teacher per month with effect from 1stJanuary, 2009, made it clear that there would be no further appointment of any new part- time teacher (on contract basis) in Non-Government Higher Secondary Schools with effect from 1stApril, 2007. The existing part-time teachers (on contract basis) would continue until further orders. On 28thJanuary, 2010,
24
the Government issued an order to ensure that none of the part-time contractual teachers attached to Government-aided Higher Secondary Schools would be terminated or be released or their contracts renewed without obtaining the permission of the District Inspector of Schools (SE) concerned. By a subsequent Memo of 23rdApril, 2010, while enhancing the honorarium to Rs. 8,100/- with effect from 1stJanuary, 2010, the Government protected the service of the contractual teachers by securing their age of retirement at 60 years of age and clarified that on attaining 60 years of age or winding up of this project, they would be paid an ex-gratia retirement honorarium of Rs. 1 lakh only on lump sum basis. By a subsequent notification dated 23rdApril, 2010, the Government issued a further order dated 9thJune, 2010, by which it may be clear that no other allowances would be available to the part-time teachers attached to non- Government Higher Secondary Schools except the enhancement at the rate of 5% of the remuneration at every interval of 3 years, after the enhancement was done as on 1stJune, 2010. The service of the teachers would remain protected till they attained 60 years of age and the State Government would bear the expenditure. The benefit of 10 days casual leave and 10 days medical leave was extended to the contractual part-time teachers by the Government Order dated 28thJuly, 2010 subject to the condition that the part-time teachers would have to take the same number of classes per week as like the duties of a regular and full-time teacher. The documents reveal that the part-time teachers were also appointed as examiners by the West Bengal Council of Higher Secondary Education and
25
assigned the duties and responsibilities which regular teachers would be expected to perform.
The sequence of events from 6thJune, 2002 till 28thJuly, 2010 would demonstrate that the service of the contractual teachers were considered to be indispensable and their services were retained and secured up to 60 years of age with some benefits extended to them which are available to permanent teachers. The appointment of the teachers, as it stands, has now become a tenure based appointment up to 60 years with some facilities of a regular teachers being extended to these part time teachers. The writ petitioners have filed supplementary affidavits which disclosed the nature of their duties in their respective schools. The Head Master of the concerned schools has issued statements disclosing the number of classes per week the writ petitioners take from academic session 2007-08 to 2020. The statements of the respective Head Masters and Head Mistresses would clearly demonstrate that in addition to the duties that the said writ petitioners discharged, they take equal number of classes per week as like the duties of regular and full-time teachers of both normal and Higher Secondary School in terms of order No. 1176-SE(S)/IS-37/09 dated 28thJuly, 2010 of the Joint Secretary, Government of West Bengal School Education Department, Secondary Branch with effect from 28thJuly, 2010. The nation can only progress if the people are educated not in the sense of running riots in their brains but respect for human values and scientific bent of mind. The teachers can contribute significantly towards
26
developing such values and make them creative, intuitive and rational. It would be suicidal for a society to belittle the dignity of the teachers or to treat them unfairly. Every teacher whether contractual or regular is a teacher. If a contractual teacher performs same and/or similar duty that of a regular teacher, irrespective of source of recruitment the teacher concern can legitimately make a claim for minimum basic pay that his counterpart is receiving from the Government towards his salary. Unlike a contractual teacher as commonly understood, it is a tenure based appointment with certain facilities and to that extent it is not at par with ad hoc appointees or contractual appointees on a year to year basis.
In the given facts and circumstances of the case, it cannot be denied that the writ petitioners have performed their duties with sincerity and largely contributed and assigned the effort of the Government for up- gradation of the Higher Secondary Schools. The writ petitioners are performing the duties of the regular teachers both in the normal and Higher Secondary section. Even if they are not recruited through the School Service Commission but their appointment is neither illegal nor irregular. The appointment is now of a fixed tenure.
The learned Single Judge was influenced by the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Jagjit Singh (supra). In paragraph 44 to 46.10 of the said judgment, the Hon'ble Supreme Court discussed all the judgments on the concept of equal pay for equal work till that date and, upon noticing the discordant note in State of Haryana vs. Jasmir Singh, reported in
1996 (11) SCC 77, observed that having regard to a large number of
27
judgments, some of which were of the larger Benches, the benefit of the principle in question was extended to temporary employees (including daily wagers). Therefore, the views in Jasmir Singh (supra) could not be accepted. It was irreconcilable and inconsistent with the large number of judgments on this point.
The later judgment relied upon on behalf of the appellant does not dilute the ratio in Jagjit Singh (supra). Jagjit Singh (supra) has considered a large number of cases where a claim for pay parity raised by the hands of the temporary employees was accepted by the Apex Court by applying the principle of equal pay for equal work with reference to the regular employees. Our Constitution envisages the State to be a welfare state. The social contract theory is the precursor to the modern theory of democracy. Inspired by the philosophy of Hobbes, Mill and Bentham, the framers of the Constitution had conceived the State to be a welfare socialist egalitarian State. Discrimination on any ground is against the concept of fairness. Forced labour is strictly prohibited. It is the duty of the State to prevent exploitation of people at all level. The person who is required to perform a perennial job should not be deprived of at least the benefits of equal wages that a regular employee earns for doing the same kind of job. Artificial break in the service with a view to deprive a legitimate claim has been deprecated in a large number of decisions. However, all jobs may not be perennial and the Government may create a post for a particular project, and the job seekers, with their eyes wide open when accept such employment, cannot, thereafter, claim regularisation on the completion or fulfilment of the
28
projects. The principle of equal pay for equal work flows from Article 14 and 21 of the Constitution. The State cannot create a stratagem or a cloak under the garb of temporary employment to perpetrate and perpetuate exploitation. Inequality is an anathema to the constitutional right of equality.
In the instant case, as mentioned earlier, the writ petitioners were appointed to facilitate upgradation of the school to Higher Secondary Section and had discharged their job flawlessly, diligently and to the satisfaction of all the authorities. The documents disclosed in the supplementary affidavits clearly support our conclusion. In fact, the Government also ensured their employment till they attain the age of 60 years with certain benefits extended to them which are available to regular teachers. A welfare state committed to a socialist pattern of society cannot deprive its teachers, who are in fact the backbone of the society, of their legitimate claims. The writ petitioners are not claiming regularisation. In fact, having regard to the process of recruitment involved in the instant case the writ petitioners knew that it is not possible for them to seek regularisation, instead they prayed for an honourable settlement of their legitimate dues. We are satisfied that the writ petitioners are discharging the same duties and responsibilities that of regular teachers for the period to be stated hereinafter. Although a regular teacher may perform additional job than a part-time teachers and the source and mode of these recruitment are different, but it cannot be overlooked that these part time teachers cannot be denied at least payment of salaries equal to the basic pay of their counter-part particularly in view of
29
the decision of the School Education Department that there shall be no sanction of any additional post for Higher Secondary Schools which were running with part-time contractual teachers since 2002 with effect from April 1, 2007.
The State has not been able to demonstrate that the duties and responsibilities of the writ petitioners are different from that of the regular teachers. The very fact that the writ petitioners were and have been performing their duties since their initial date of appointment in 2003 uninterruptedly till date only speaks volumes of the contribution that they made for upgradation of school to a Higher Secondary school. The appelants have also recognised their efforts for such upgradation and secured their employment till they attain 60 years of age. Fairness requires that the State should extend at least some benefits if not all to these teaches, in parity, with the pay and benefits extended to a regular assistant teacher for the period as stated above.
The country needs dedicated teachers. The teachers deserve better treatment, security and standing in the society. The schools, colleges and universities require proper infrastructure and an environment conducive to learning. The society expects the teachers to devote more time in school, colleges and universities rather than in private tuitions and private tutorials mushrooming all over the country charging exorbitant fees. We have given our anxious consideration raised by the learned Advocate General and the Government Pleader with regard to the eligibility
30
of the writ petitioners to claim parity in payment. On the basis of the documents on record particularly pages 334 to 340 in MAT No. 1221 of 2019 and at page 25 of the supplementary affidavit affirmed by Barun Kumar Ghosh on 21stFebruary, 2020, it appears that the writ petitioners have been taking classes on a regular basis since 2010 in their respective schools and the nature of the duties as disclosed in the supplementary affidavit, clearly justify a minimum claim for basic pay that their counterparts are receiving at least from January 2010 till the date of withdrawal of the G.O. dated 28thJuly, 2010 vide memo dated 24th December, 2013.
While appraising the rival contentions on the factual aspect of rendering extent and nature of duty by the writ petitioner we cannot shut our eyes to the G.O. No. 1176-SE(S) dated 28thJuly, 2010 which is reproduced below:
"Government of West Bengal School Education Department Secondary Branch
Bikash Bhawan, Salt Lake, Kolkata - 91. No. 1176-SE(S)/1S-37/09 Dated Kolkata, the 28thJuly, 2010 From : Sri. T.K. Adhikari
Joint Secretary to the Govt. of West Bengal. To : The Director of School Education, West Bengal, Bikash Bhawan, 7thFloor, Salt Lake, Kolkata - 91. Sub : Sanction of 10 days C.L. and 10 days Medical Leave
31
in respect of contractual part-time teachers attached to Non-Govt. Higher Secondary Schools under Directorate of School Education, Govt. of West Bengal. The undersigned is directed to say that after careful consideration, the Governor has now been pleased to accord sanction of 10(ten) days casual leave and 10 (ten) days Medical Leave to the part-time contractual teachers attached to different Govt. aided/Sponsored Higher Secondary Schools under the Directorate of School Education, Govt. of West Bengal subject to the condition that they have to take equal number of classes per week as like as the duties of regular and full time teachers.
2. This order issues with the concurrence of the Finance (Audit) Deptt.'s U.O. No. 1151 Gr. P (Service) dt. 10.06.2010.
3. All concerned may kindly be kept informed immediately. Sd/- T.K. Adhikari,
Joint Secretary
No. 1176/1(4)-SE(S) Kolkata, the 28thJuly, 2010" We are aware of the fact that subsequently the said G.O. dated 28th July, 2010 was withdrawn by the Secretary, School Education Department, Law Branch vide issuing memo No. 1541/SE(Law)/SL/5S-615/2013 dated 24thDecember, 2013. The issuance of said memo dated 28thJuly, 2010 extended the benefit of 10 days' casual leave and 10 days' medical leave to the part-time contractual teachers attached to different government- aided/sponsored higher secondary schools with a rider that they were
32
required to take equal number of classes per week as attended by the regular and full-time teachers. Insertion of this condition unleash implied approval by the School Education Department, Secondary Branch, to permit the contractual teachers to take equal number of classes per week as taken by the approved teaching staff in a government-aided secondary school till the date of withdrawal of the said G.O. dated 28thJuly, 2010 vide memo dated 24thDecember, 2013.
It is also discernable from the G.O. dated 28thJuly, 2010 and the subsequent memo dated 24thDecember, 2013 whereby the previous G.O. dated 28thJuly, 2010 stood withdrawn that the contractual teachers were eligible and permitted to perform similar job as that of approved teaching staff and could take equal number of classes like the permanent approved teachers.
But for the period earlier to 2010 we are unable to arrive at a definite conclusion on the basis of the materials on record that the writ petitioners have discharged same and/or similar duties of a regular teacher in the respective institutions. However, it is left open to the writ petitioners to apply before the Secretary (School Education Department) in justification of basic pay for the period from 2007 to 2009 demonstrating discharge of similar duties that of a regular teacher for the said period. Mr. Gupta has made a passionate argument with regard to the entitlement of the writ petitioners post 24thDecember, 2013 by which previous Government Order dated 28thJuly, 2010 was withdrawn. Mr. Gupta has submitted that in view of the disclosure made in the supplementary affidavits showing that the
33
writ petitioners have been discharging duties similar to that of the regular teachers notwithstanding the memo dated 24thDecember, 2013 the Government as a model employer should extend suitable benefits to the teachers who are sincerely and devotionally performing their duties. Although our heart is with the writ petitioners but in the given facts we cannot interfere with the policy decision of the government as it has financial implications and the purpose and object of appointment of contractual teachers are significantly different from that of the regular teachers. However, at the same time we feel that the writ petitioners should not be the victim of exploitation in a socialist republic and the Government may consider upgradation of the service conditions of the writ petitioners based on record since it cannot be denied that the schools have been benefited by the services rendered by the writ petitioners for more than a decade.
Under such circumstances, we modify the order of the learned Single Judge by directing the appellant to make payment of salaries equal to basic pay in the scale of pay of a regular teacher working in Higher Secondary Section in a Non-Government Aided Higher Secondary School with effect from 28 July, 2010 being the date of the order which is quoted above till 24.12.2013 when the precious G.O. dt. 28thJuly, 2010 stood withdrawn under G.O. dt. 24.12.2013. The said Government order restrain any further appointment of any new part time teachers on contract basis in non- government aided higher secondary school with effect from 1stApril, 2007. The arrear salary shall be paid positively within four weeks from date. In the
34
event, the writ petitioners made a representation before the Secretary (School Education Department), in justification of basic pay for the period from April 2007 till December 2009 and after 24thDecember 2013 demonstrating discharge of similar duties, within a period of 4 weeks after the lockdown is relaxed and the normal functioning of the schools and colleges are restored, the Secretary, shall consider such representation within a period of 3 weeks thereafter upon giving an opportunity of hearing to the writ petitioners as well as concerned schools. The representations can be sent in the designated email of the Secretary in addition to hard copies. Ms. Kakali Samajpati, learned advocate appearing for the appellant shall furnish such email address to Mr. Partha Pratim Dutta Advocate and Mr. Sourav Dutta, Advocate respectively being the learned advocate for the writ petitioners within one week from date. It is needless to mention that Covid protocol in place on the date of hearing shall be strictly followed. The school authorities shall be under an obligation to produce the attendance register and the class routines for the aforesaid period before the Secretary (School Education Department) along with any other materials as may be directed in order to enable the Secretary (School Education Department) to decide the claim of the writ petitioners. It is needless to mention that the Secretary shall be guided by the principle laid down in this order and shall not deny the claim of the petitioners merely because of their initial contractual appointment in view of the fact that the school education department had taken a decision not to sanction any additional post for these higher secondary schools which were running with part time
35
contractual teachers since 2002 with effect from April 1st, 2007. The Secretary shall pass a reasoned order which shall be communicated to the writ petitioners and the concerned schools within two weeks from the date of the order. The order may be communicated at email address of the writ petitioners & their advocates to be provided by the parties while forwarding the representations in addition to hard copies.
The Government as a model employer may also sympathetically consider if some more benefits that are available to the regular assistant teachers could be extended to the writ petitioners till they attain 60 years. The appeal succeeds in part.
In the facts and circumstances of the case there shall be no order as to costs.
(Soumen Sen, J.) (Saugata Bhattacharyya, J.)