Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India
  • Article 226 (2)
  • Section 286 IPC
  • Section 4 (A)(B)(i) of the Indian Explosives Substance Act, 1908
  • Section 45 (1) of UAPA
  • Section 45(1) UAPA
  • Section 45 of the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act, 1967
  • Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 15 (1) of the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act, 1967
  • Section 45 (1) of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967
  • Section 15 (1) of UAPA
  • Article 226(2) of the Constitution of India
  • Section 8 of the NIA Act
  • Section 45(1) of the UAPA
  • Article 226 of the Indian Constitution
  • Section 6 (5) of the NIA Act
  • Article 226 (1)
  • Section 302 IPC
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India
  • Article 226 (2)
  • Section 286 IPC
  • Section 4 (A)(B)(i) of the Indian Explosives Substance Act, 1908
  • Section 45 (1) of UAPA
  • Section 45(1) UAPA
  • Section 45 of the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act, 1967
  • Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 15 (1) of the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act, 1967
  • Section 45 (1) of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967
  • Section 15 (1) of UAPA
  • Article 226(2) of the Constitution of India
  • Section 8 of the NIA Act
  • Section 45(1) of the UAPA
  • Article 226 of the Indian Constitution
  • Section 6 (5) of the NIA Act
  • Article 226 (1)
  • Section 302 IPC
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — W.P.(CRL) 88/2022 (Sachin Hindurao Waze v. Union of India & Ors.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This writ petition was filed by the petitioner Sachin Hindurao Waze challenging (i) the constitutional validity of Section 15(1) of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 ("UAPA") as being ultra vires Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution or, in the alternative, seeking that it be read down; and (ii) an order dated 2 September 2021 passed by Respondent No.1 (Union of India through Under Secretary, CTCR Division, Ministry of Home Affairs) granting sanction under Section 45(1) UAPA for prosecution in respect of offences investigated by the National Investigation Agency (NIA).

The petition related to investigations and criminal proceedings arising from two FIRs registered in Mumbai: FIR No.35/2021 (dated 25 February 2021 at PS Gam Devi) concerning seizure of a vehicle and explosives, and FIR No.12/2021 (registered 7 March 2021) concerning the murder of a person (Mr. Mansukh Hiren). The NIA registered the case as RC-01/2021/NIA/Mumbai and conducted investigation in Mumbai. The petitioner was charge-sheeted (charge-sheet dated 3 September 2021) and proceedings (including custody, remand and trial-related steps) were taking place before the Special Judge, NIA at Mumbai.

A preliminary objection was raised on territorial jurisdiction. The Delhi High Court framed the jurisdictional question on 3 March 2022: whether an order of the Central Government granting sanction under Section 45 UAPA can be assailed standalone and where jurisdiction would lie. After hearing, the Court reserved and pronounced judgment on 7 October 2022.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Section 15(1) of the UAPA is ultra vires Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India, or should be read down to avoid invalidity.
  2. Whether the impugned order dated 2 September 2021 by Respondent No.1 granting sanction under Section 45(1) UAPA can be quashed and set aside by this Court.
  3. Whether an order by the Central Government granting sanction under Section 45 UAPA can be assailed standalone and, if so, in which court (i.e., the question of territorial jurisdiction to entertain a challenge to such sanction).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner (through Senior Counsel Mr. Santosh Paul) argued that the sanction order dated 2 September 2021 was passed by Respondent No.1 in New Delhi based upon recommendations of an Authority constituted under Ministry order No.11034/1/2009/IS-IV dated 3 July 2015 (consisting of a retired judge and retired Law Secretary) which had its report dated 28 August 2021. Since the sanction decision and the recommending Authority were located in Delhi, the petitioner contended that this Court has territorial jurisdiction to adjudicate the challenge.
  • The petitioner relied on several decisions of the Delhi High Court and the law on Article 226 — notably Malini Mukesh Vora, Sonu Sardar and Sterling Agro — to support the proposition that if part of the cause of action arises in the High Court's territory (and relevant material was located in Delhi), the High Court may exercise jurisdiction, subject to the doctrine of forum conveniens.
  • The petitioner highlighted that the Authority in Delhi reviewed the investigation materials and produced the report in Delhi; therefore a part of the cause of action arose in Delhi.

Respondent No.1's Arguments

  • The Additional Solicitor General (Mr. S.V. Raju) argued that the relevant incidents, investigation and all material events occurred in Mumbai: recovery of vehicle (25 February 2021), the threat letter (7 February 2021), and the murder (4 March 2021). The NIA investigated in Mumbai since 8 March 2021, filed the charge-sheet in Mumbai, cognizance was taken in Mumbai, and trial was to proceed in Mumbai.
  • It was submitted that issues of non-application of mind in sanctioning prosecution are matters to be adjudicated by the trial court (citing Parkash Singh Badal and subsequent authorities). If the petition sought to quash the sanction, the trial court in Mumbai would be the competent forum to consider such challenge.
  • The respondent emphasized the doctrine of forum conveniens: Mumbai is the natural forum because the substantive offences, investigation, trial and the petitioner's residence were all in Maharashtra (Mumbai).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Malini Mukesh Vora v. Union of India & Ors., 2009 SCC Online Del 1776 Article 226(1) vs Article 226(2) distinction: HC may issue writs to persons/authorities within its territory irrespective of where cause arose; Article 226(2) permits writs beyond territory if cause wholly or partly arose within the territory; distinction between challenge to legislation and executive action for territorial jurisdiction purposes. The Court relied on the principles to assess whether the Delhi High Court could entertain a challenge where the sanctioning Authority and decision were in Delhi but most events occurred in Mumbai; used to frame the two-element analysis (part of cause of action in territory AND forum conveniens).
Kusum Ingots & Alloys Ltd. v. Union of India, (2004) 6 SCC 254 Distinction between challenge to legislative action and challenge to executive action; place where legislative act is taken may not determine territorial jurisdiction. Referenced to explain that challenges to executive actions must be assessed differently and not automatically confer territorial jurisdiction where the executive act took place.
Sonu Sardar v. Union of India, 2016 SCC Online Del 6206 Where material to be examined is advice of the Cabinet and documents are in Delhi and decision taken in Delhi, the dominus litis may invoke Delhi HC; also distinction between pending criminal investigation and final executive action (mercy petition). The Court considered Sonu Sardar but found it distinguishable because Sonu Sardar involved review of executive action (mercy petition) where criminal proceedings had attained finality; here criminal proceedings were ongoing in Mumbai. Thus Sonu Sardar did not support exercising jurisdiction in Delhi in this case.
Sterling Agro Industries Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors., 2011 SCC OnLine Del 3162 (Special Bench) Doctrine of forum conveniens: even if a part of cause of action arises within jurisdiction, the Court must consider forum conveniens and may decline jurisdiction if another forum is more appropriate; balance of convenience must be applied. The Court relied heavily on the Special Bench's exposition of forum conveniens to conclude that even though the sanction order was in Delhi, forum conveniens pointed to Bombay/Mumbai and therefore Delhi HC should not assume jurisdiction.
Parkash Singh Badal v. State of Punjab, (2007) 1 SCC 1 Issue of alleged non-application of mind in sanctioning prosecution is a matter to be adjudicated by the trial court. The Court noted this principle to support the position that challenges to the sanction on non-application of mind could properly be addressed by the trial court in Mumbai.
Central Bureau of Investigation & Ors. v. Pramila Virendra Kumar Agarwal & Anr., (2020) 17 SCC 664 Authority for the proposition (as relied upon by Respondent) regarding adjudication of sanction-related issues and locus of review (cited alongside other authorities). Cited by the respondent to support that errors concerning sanction may be matters for the trial court; Court relied on respondent's reliance to reinforce that Mumbai courts could adjudicate challenges to sanction.
Central Bureau of Investigation v. Ashok Kumar Aggarwal, (2014) 14 SCC 295 Authority relied upon (para 58 cited) in connection with sanction and review principles; cited alongside Dinesh Kumar. Used by the respondent in submissions; Court noted these authorities as part of the legal landscape that supports adjudication of sanction-related issues at trial level.
Dinesh Kumar v. Chairman, Airport Authority of India & Anr., (2012) 1 SCC 532 Authority relied upon by higher courts in the line of cases addressing review of administrative decisions and sanction-related adjudication. Referenced by the respondent and noted by the Court as part of authorities establishing that issues of sanction may be resolved by trial courts; used to weigh jurisdictional considerations.
Ambica Industries v. Commissioner of Central Excise, (2007) 6 SCC 769 Referenced in the context of forum conveniens and the need to consider more than merely the arising of part of cause of action within a jurisdiction. Mentioned by the Court as part of the jurisprudential background emphasising that forum conveniens must be considered when determining territorial jurisdiction.
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. (Full Bench reference in Sterling Agro) Referenced within Sterling Agro: the Full Bench in that case did not sufficiently consider forum conveniens (as per Sterling Agro's reasoning). Quoted as part of the Special Bench's exposition that the Court should not treat situs of an appellate/revisional authority as determinative without regard to forum conveniens.
Navinchandra N. Majitha and Manoj Kumar Sharma (cases referenced in Sonu Sardar) Referenced in Sonu Sardar as cases that involved pending criminal investigations and therefore not analogous to mercy-petition/executive-action challenges. The Court noted (via Sonu Sardar) that these decisions did not assist the petitioner because those cases concerned pending criminal investigations, whereas the mercy-petition context in Sonu Sardar was different from the present ongoing criminal proceedings in Mumbai.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a focused, threshold analysis limited to the issue of territorial jurisdiction as framed on 3 March 2022. The Court's reasoning proceeded in the following steps, reflecting only the material contained in the judgment:

  1. Two-element framework: The Court affirmed that when considering territorial jurisdiction under Article 226, a Court must consider (i) whether any part of the cause of action arises within its territorial jurisdiction and (ii) whether the Court is the forum conveniens. The Court emphasized that a mere iota or shred of cause of action arising within a High Court's territory should not automatically compel the High Court to assume jurisdiction without considering forum conveniens (drawing upon the Special Bench in Sterling Agro and related decisions).
  2. Factual assessment: The Court carefully reviewed the record and concluded that virtually all operative events, investigations and proceedings occurred in Mumbai: FIR No.35/2021 (25 Feb 2021) relating to vehicle seizure and explosives; NIA registration RC-01/2021/NIA/Mumbai; FIR No.12/2021 (7 Mar 2021) relating to the murder; Ministry directions (dated 20 March 2021 and referenced 21 May 2021) directing NIA investigation; charge-sheet dated 3 Sep 2021; custody, remand and trial-related proceedings before the Special Judge, NIA at Mumbai. Thus the substantial matrix of events and adjudicatory action was situated in Mumbai.
  3. Delhi connection limited: The Court acknowledged that the sole connection to Delhi was the sanction order dated 2 September 2021 and the recommending Authority constituted under the Home Ministry order (Authority itself being in Delhi and having prepared a report dated 28 August 2021). The Court held that this solitary connection is insufficient, standing alone, to vest the Delhi High Court with jurisdiction to grant the relief sought, given that all other material and proceedings are in Mumbai.
  4. Forum conveniens: Applying the doctrine of forum conveniens, the Court concluded that Mumbai is the natural and appropriate forum for adjudicating the petition because the substantive offences, investigation, proceedings and the petitioner's residence were in Mumbai. The Court emphasized the need to weigh convenience of parties and witnesses, and the balance of convenience, as articulated in Sterling Agro and related cases.
  5. Scope of review of sanction: The Court accepted the submission that issues such as non-application of mind in sanctioning prosecution are matters that the trial court (in Mumbai) could adjudicate. Since the Special Court in Mumbai had taken cognizance and was seized of the matter, that forum was competent to address any challenge to the sanction as well.
  6. Interrelation of remedies: The Court observed that the petition's primary effective relief was quashing the sanction (prayer (b)), with the constitutional challenge to Section 15(1) UAPA (prayer (a)) being concomitant and not something to be severed and decided in isolation, reinforcing the need for a forum that can address the challenge comprehensively — i.e., Mumbai.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

DISMISSED FOR LACK OF TERRITORIAL JURISDICTION.

The Court answered the jurisdictional question by holding that the order of 2 September 2021 granting sanction must be considered in conjunction with the investigations and proceedings to which it relates, and therefore the courts at Mumbai have the natural and logical jurisdiction to decide the issues challenged in this writ petition. The writ petition was dismissed on that ground.

Direct consequences and implications:

  • The Writ Petition (W.P.(CRL) 88/2022) was dismissed for lack of territorial jurisdiction.
  • Related interim applications (CRL.M.A. 959/2022, 960/2022, 1449/2022, 1450/2022, 2095/2022, 2096/2022) were disposed of as infructuous in view of the dismissal of the writ petition.
  • The Court indicated that challenges to the sanction, including allegations of non-application of mind, can be addressed by the trial court in Mumbai where cognizance has been taken and trial proceedings are to occur.
  • This decision does not purport to decide the merits of the constitutional challenge to Section 15(1) UAPA or to quash the sanction on merits; it is a threshold territorial-jurisdiction decision. The judgment does not state that a new binding legal precedent on the substantive law was intended to be laid; rather, it applies existing principles (including forum conveniens) to the facts to decline jurisdiction.

Judges: HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MUKTA GUPTA and HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL. Judgment reserved 21 September 2022; pronounced 7 October 2022.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    SACHIN HINDURAO WAZE  v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.

    * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI % Reserved on.21stSeptember, 2022 Pronounced on: 7thOctober, 2022

    W.P.(CRL) 88/2022

    SACHIN HINDURAO WAZE ..... Petitioner Represented by: Mr.Santosh Paul, Sr. Advocate with Mr.M.Shetty, and

    Mr.Chaitanya Sharma, Advocates.

    versus

    UNION OF INDIA & ORS. ..... Respondents

    Represented by: Mr. S.V. Raju, ASG, Mr.Kirtiman Singh, CGSC with Mr. Madhav

    Bajan and Mr. Yash Upadhyay,

    Advocates for R1 and R2-Union

    of India, Mr.Akshai Malik, SPP

    and Mr.Sandeep K.Sadawarte,

    SPP with Mr. Shrikant and

    Mr.Khawar Saleem, Advocates

    for R3-NIA.

    CORAM:

    HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MUKTA GUPTA HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL

    JUDGMENT

    ANISH DAYAL, J.

    1. The petitioner has filed this Writ Petition praying for striking down Section 15 (1) of the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act, 1967 (UAPA) for being ultra vires Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India or read it down to save it from being rendered unconstitutional; and to quash and set aside the impugned order dated 2ndSeptember, 2021 passed by the respondent no. 1 (Union of India through Under

    1

    Secretary, CTCR Division, Ministry of Home Affairs) and grant consequential reliefs.

    2. A preliminary objection was raised that this Court would not have territorial jurisdiction over the subject matter of the present petition in light of relief prayed for. Accordingly, this Court on 3rdMarch, 2022 directed the parties to first address this Court on the following issue:

    "Whether an order rendered by Central Government granting sanction under provision of Section 45 of the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act, 1967 can be assailed standalone per se and if so, where would the jurisdiction/ proceedings lie?"

    Submissions on behalf of the Petitioner

    3. Mr. Santosh Paul, Senior Advocate addressing arguments on behalf of the petitioner canvassed that the impugned order dated 2nd September, 2021 granting sanction for prosecution under Section 45 (1) UAPA for prosecuting the accused persons (which included the petitioner charge-sheeted under Sections 16, 18 & 20 of UAPA) was passed on the basis of recommendations received by Respondent no. 1 from the Authority constituted under Ministry's order No - 11034/1/2009/IS-IV dated 3rdJuly, 2015 consisting of a retired judge and retired Law Secretary for making an independent review of the evidence gathered in course of investigation. Learned Senior Counsel highlighted the fact that the Authority gave its report to Respondent no.1 on 28thAugust, 2021 within a day of having received the investigation report from the National Investigation Agency (NIA) together with a list

    2

    of documents collected and witnesses examined during the course of the investigation. Therefore, addressing specifically on the issue of territorial jurisdiction, the learned senior counsel asserted that since this decision which it was seeking to quash and set aside was taken by the Respondent no. 1 in New Delhi based upon the report of the Authority also based in New Delhi, this Court would have jurisdiction to hear the matter.

    4. Learned Senior Counsel relied upon the judgment of this Hon'ble Court in Malini Mukesh Vora Vs. Union of India & Ors., 2009 SCC Online Del 1776 where this Court on a question of territorial jurisdiction held that Article 226 (1) empowered the High Court to issue writ to any person, authority or Government located within its territorial limits irrespective of where the cause of action arose while Article 226 (2) permitted the High Court to issue writs to persons, authorities or Governments located beyond the territories with respect to which it exercises jurisdiction, provided a cause of action in whole or in part arose within those territories. This Court had further held that Article 226 (2) supplements and does not supplant Article 226(1). Learned Senior Counsel highlighted the view expressed in para 19 and 20 of

    Malini Mukesh Vora (supra) where this Court stated that distinction has to be drawn between a challenge to a legislation and a challenge to an executive action. While in Kusum Ingots & Alloys Ltd. Vs. Union of India, (2004) 6 SCC 254, the challenge was to an exercise of legislative power, the challenge in this case was to an executive action and therefore it would have to be assessed differently for the purposes of territorial jurisdiction.

    3

    5. Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner further relied upon the decision of this Court in Sonu Sardar Vs. Union of India, 2016 SCC Online Del 6206 in a challenge to orders of the President on India and Governor of Chhattisgarh rejecting the mercy petition of the petitioner therein on account of delay, non application of mind etc. for a sentence of death, this Court held that since material to be examined was advice of the Cabinet and since all documents pertaining to the same were in Delhi and the decision was taken in Delhi, the convict being dominus litis was free to invoke the jurisdiction of this Court and this Court was vested with jurisdiction to entertain the petition.

    6. Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner further relied upon a judgment of a special bench of 5 Judges of this Court in Sterling Agro Industries Ltd Vs. Union of India and Ors, 2011 SCC OnLine Del 3162 when this Court held that even if a miniscule part of cause of action arises within the jurisdiction of this Court, writ petition would be maintainable before this Court.

    7. However, this Court noted that at para 33 (a) of the reported judgement in Sterling Agro Industries (supra) this Court concluded that a cause of action cannot be totally based on the situs of the tribunal /appellate authority/ revisional authority while completely ignoring the concept of forum conveniens. This Court had stated in para 32 that: "the principle of forum conveniens in its ambit and sweep encapsulates the concept that a cause of action arising within the jurisdiction of the Court would not itself constitute to be the determining factor compelling the court to entertain the matter. While exercising jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, the Court cannot be

    4

    totally oblivious of the concept of forum conveniens." Accordingly, this Court posited the senior counsel for the petitioner that based upon application of principles as cited in judgments noted above, simply because the impugned decision of 2ndSeptember, 2021 by Respondent no. 1 was passed in Delhi (based on the Authority's report which was also in Delhi), would this Court be obligated to accept jurisdiction and ignore of the principle of forum conveniens. Prima facie, application of the principle of forum conveniens would render the High Court of Bombay as the appropriate court considering that the substantive offence, the incident and the ongoing investigation and trial were all at Mumbai. Therefore, except for the sanction order under Section 45 (1) of UAPA being passed by Respondent no. 1 and the recommending Authority being in Delhi (by virtue of the statutory mandate), all other aspects of the alleged offence and the investigation were outside the jurisdiction of this Court.

    Submissions on behalf of Respondent no. 1

    8. Countering the submissions advanced on behalf of the petitioner, the learned Additional Solicitor General Mr. S.V. Raju submitted that there were three incidents which form basis of this investigation viz. (i) recovery of the vehicle on 25thFebruary, 2021; (ii) the threat letter dated 7thFebruary, 2021 and; (iii) the murder of the co-accused on 4thMarch, 2021. The learned ASG submitted that the NIA was investigating each of these aspects since 8thMarch, 2021 in Mumbai, the charge-sheet was filed in Mumbai, the cognizance after the sanction order was taken in Mumbai and the trial also was being conducted in Mumbai.

    5

    9. In response to the submission of the respondent that since the sanction order was made in Delhi and therefore this Court would have territorial jurisdiction, the learned ASG placed reliance on Parkash Singh Badal v State of Punjab, (2007) 1 SCC 1 wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that issue alleging non-application of mind sanctioning prosecution is a matter to be adjudicated by the trial court. Reliance was also placed on Central Bureau of Investigation & Ors. Vs. Pramila Virendra Kumar Agarwal & Anr., (2020) 17 SCC 664, para 11 and Central Bureau of Investigation Vs. Ashok Kumar Aggarwal, (2014) 14 SCC 295 para 58, both decisions relying upon

    Dinesh Kumar Vs. Chairman, Airport Authority of India & Anr.

    (2012) 1 SCC 532. He submitted that any error if committed by the trial court can be challenged before the High Court of Bombay. The learned ASG further submitted that the issue of sanction by the Respondent no. 1 was not significant any more since pursuant to that the trial court in Mumbai had already taken cognizance. Hence the if this Court would at all consider quashing the sanction (on the plea of the petitioner) then issue of cognizance would also be in its ambit. He further submitted that the challenge by the petitioner in this writ petition was effectively on non-application of mind while issuing sanction for prosecution under Section 45(1) of the UAPA based upon recommendations by the constituted Authority and not due to an inherent jurisdictional issue in the sanctioning order. As regards reliance of the senior counsel for the petitioner on Kusum Ingots Vs. Union of India (supra), the learned ASG drew this court's attention to para 26 and 27 where the Supreme Court is categorical in its decision that as regards a legislative act, the place where such an action is taken does not necessarily robe the court with territorial jurisdiction. The learned ASG further submitted that

    6

    applying the principle of forum conveniens Mumbai was the natural jurisdiction since the petitioner was resident of Maharashtra and therefore there was no reason why he would find it convenient to challenge the order of sanction before this Court.

    10. Rebutting the contention of learned ASG, learned senior counsel for the petitioner reiterated the contentions that he had advanced in detail in his opening arguments. He underscored para 27 of the decision in

    Kusum Ingots (supra) where the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that a challenge to a decision by a court/tribunal/executive authority under a statue would give jurisdiction to that place since that would constitute a part of a cause of action. The senior counsel contended that since the order according sanction was an executive order made in Delhi in accordance with the provisions of UAPA, a part of cause of action arose in the territorial jurisdiction of this Court and therefore this writ petition would be maintainable. He further reiterated reliance on the decision in

    Sterling Agro Industries (supra) and Sonu Sardar (supra) to state that the issue of forum conveniens had been considered in those decisions. Specifically relying upon the decision of Sonu Sardar (supra) the senior counsel for the petitioner canvassed that since all the material was located in Delhi when according sanction for prosecution, it was natural for the writ petitioner to invoke the territorial jurisdiction of this Court.

    Analysis

    11. Pursuant to an assessment of documents on record, appreciation of submissions advanced by the parties through respective senior counsels and the learned ASG, this Court is of the considered opinion that this

    7

    Court would not have territorial jurisdiction over the subject matter of the present petition for inter alia the following reasons:

    (i) The relief sought in the writ petition is firstly relating to the unconstitutionality of Section 15 (1) of UAPA; and secondly to quash and set aside the impugned order dated 02ndSeptember, 2021 passed by the Respondent No.1 according sanction for prosecution under Section 45(1) UAPA for prosecuting the accused (including the petitioners and others) in crime No. RC-01/2021/NIA/ME-I and taking cognizance of the said offence by the Court of competent jurisdiction. However, this determination is restricted to the threshold issue of territorial jurisdiction of this Court as encapsulated in the order of 3rdMarch 2020 (extracted above in para 2).

    (ii) A perusal of the FIR No.35/2021 dated 25thFebruary, 2021 registered at PS Gam Devi for offences punishable under Section 286/465/473/506 (2)/120 B IPC and Section 4 (A)(B)(i) of the Indian Explosives Substance Act, 1908 would categorically indicate that all events forming the basis of the FIR had occurred in Mumbai e.g. seizure of the vehicle Mahindra Scorpio bearing registration No. MH-01-DK-9945, discovery of the explosives in the sack found in the vehicle and discovery that the registration of the number plate was in the name of an employee of Reliance Company. The NIA, vide RC-01/2021/NIA/Mumbai based on the said FIR, registered the case in Mumbai for further investigation. A further FIR No.12/2021 was registered on 7thMarch, 2021 for offences punishable under Sections 302/201/34/120B IPC for the

    8

    murder of Mr. Mansukh Hiren in Mumbai. Accordingly, vide order dated 20thMarch, 2021, the Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India directed the NIA to take up the investigation under Section 6 (5) read with Section 8 of the NIA and investigate the offence vide FIR No.12/2021 as well, being connected with the earlier offence. Reference in this regard is made to the order of the Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India dated 21stMay, 2021. The writ petition is further appended with various other documents relating to police custody, remand of the petitioner in Mumbai including applications for bail, a copy of charge sheet dated 3rdSeptember, 2021, documents relating to the proceedings before the Special Judge, NIA at Mumbai, all proceedings being in Mumbai. It is therefore quite indubitable that the alleged offence, the subsequent complaint and investigation, the FIRs and the RC, filing of the charge sheet and all proceedings relating thereto including custody of the accused have all taken place in Mumbai.

    (iii) The only peg on which the petitioner wishes to hang and support its plea before this Court is on the order of sanction which was by the Authority constituted under the order of the Home Ministry No.11034/1/2009/IS-IV dated 3rdJuly, 2015. Therefore, even as per the petitioner, in the full canvas of the matter the only event which has happened in the jurisdiction of this Court is this impugned decision. In the considered opinion of this Court the mere fact that the authority which awards sanction for prosecution under UAPA is located in Delhi, will not give this Court the jurisdiction to grant relief to quash that order sans the fact that all possible ingredients,

    9

    events and proceedings in relation to the said matter are taking place in Mumbai.

    (iv) The contention of the learned ASG that finally the cognizance of the charge-sheet have been taken now by the Special Court in Mumbai and trial has to commence thereafter, which trial court would be competent to also adjudicate upon the challenge that the petitioner may have to the sanctioning order, also finds favor with this Court.

    12. On a broad holistic assessment of decisions cited by the petitioner would show that there are practically two elements which have to be considered by any court while accepting jurisdiction to decide a writ petition under Article 226 of the Indian Constitution - firstly, if any part of the cause of action arises within its territorial jurisdiction; and secondly if the said court is the forum conveniens. Only a mere shred or an iota of a cause of action potentially clothing a particular High Court with jurisdiction [per Article 226(2) of the Constitution of India] to adjudicate a writ petition, ought not to encourage a court to accept such jurisdiction completely divorced and dehors an assessment of forum conveniens. This has been categorically articulated in decisions of this Court. A Special Bench comprising 5 judges of this Court [Chief Justice Dipak Misra, Vikramajit Sen, J. A.K. Sikri, J. Sanjiv Khanna, J. and Manmohan, J.] in Sterling Agro (supra) after traversing the law relating to territorial jurisdiction in context of Article 226 of the Constitution of India emphasized that the High Court must not only advert to the existence of a cause of action but also remind themselves about the doctrine of forum conveniens also. In this regard the following

    10

    paragraphs of the judgment of the Special Bench are instructive which are reproduced as under for easy reference:

    "30. From the aforesaid pronouncements, the concept of forum conveniens gains signification. In Black's Law Dictionary, forum conveniens has been defined as follows: "The court in which an action is most appropriately brought, considering the best interests and convenience of the parties and witnesses."

    31. The concept of forum conveniens fundamentally means that it is obligatory on the part of the court to see the convenience of all the parties before it. The convenience in its ambit and sweep would include the existence of more appropriate forum, expenses involved, the law relating to the lis, verification of certain facts which are necessitous for just adjudication of the controversy and such other ancillary aspects. The balance of convenience is also to be taken note of. Be it noted, the Apex Court has clearly stated in the cases of Kusum Ingots (supra), Mosaraf Hossain Khan (supra) and Ambica Industries (supra) about the applicability of the doctrine of forum conveniens while opining that arising of a part of cause of action would entitle the High Court to entertain the writ petition as maintainable.

    32. The principle of forum conveniens in its ambit and sweep encapsulates the concept that a cause of action arising within the jurisdiction of the Court would not itself constitute to be the determining factor compelling the Court to entertain the matter. While exercising jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, the Court cannot be totally oblivious of the concept of forum conveniens. The Full Bench in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. (supra) has not kept in view the concept of forum conveniens and has expressed the view that if the appellate authority who has passed the order is situated in Delhi, then the Delhi High Court should be treated as the forum conveniens. We are unable to subscribe to the said view.

    (emphasis added)

    Accordingly, in para 33 of the reported judgement in Sterling Agro Industries (supra) this Court concluded that a cause of action cannot be totally based on the situs of the tribunal /appellate authority/ revisional

    11

    authority while completely ignoring the concept of forum conveniens, and that the High Court may refuse to exercise its discretionary jurisdiction by invoking the doctrine of forum conveniens.

    13. Reference was also made to a decision of the Division Bench of this Court in Sonu Sardar Vs. Union of India (2016) SCC Online Del 6206 where this Court while noting the decision in Sterling Agro (supra) examined issue of jurisdiction of this Court in a matter where the petitioner had impugned the orders of the President of India and the Governor of Chhattisgarh rejecting the mercy petition of the petitioner who had been sentenced to death. In Sonu Sardar (supra), this Court while adverting to the concept of cause of action drew a distinction between a situation where criminal investigation was pending and where criminal proceedings had attained finality and the challenge was merely to an executive action, as in the case of a mercy petition. Para 21 of the judgment of this Court in Sonu Sardar (upra) is extracted under for ease of reference:

    "The concept of cause of action in respect of criminal proceedings cannot apply sensu stricto to the present proceedings as the same are not a continuation of the judicial proceedings but premised upon executive orders. Accordingly, the judgments of the Supreme Court in Navinchandra N. Majitha (Supra) and Manoj Kumar Sharma (Supra) do not come to the aid of the applicant as in both the cases the criminal investigation was pending; while the present proceedings have arisen as a consequence of executive actions and by no means can be said to be an extension of the criminal proceedings, which have attained finality."

    Thereafter, this Court noted the decision in Kusum Ingots (supra) and

    Sterling Agro (supra) on the application of principle of forum conveniens and stated as under:

    12

    "27. In view of the aforegoing, it is clear that the courts should generally decide disputes upon which they have jurisdiction. They may decline to exercise such jurisdiction only if there are compelling reasons for not doing so. In doing so, the courts must apply a balancing test and reject to exercise jurisdiction only if there are compelling reasons keeping the Latin maxim Judex tenetur impertiri judicium suum in mind."

    14. Learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon the reasoning by this Court in para 30 of Sonu Sardar (supra) that since material to be examined is the advice tendered by the Cabinet and all documents and records were in Delhi, the decision was taken in Delhi and therefore, this Court has jurisdiction to entertain the writ petition. However, this Court notes that this reasoning was premised upon the observation in para 29 of the said decision where this Court noted that the scope of judicial review in rejection of mercy petitions is limited and it extends only to the material upon which the decision is based, i.e., whether all relevant material was considered before arriving at a conclusion. This decision will not come to the aid of the petitioner, since in the considered view of this Court, firstly this Court drew a distinction between a petition challenging an issue relating to criminal proceedings which were ongoing as opposed to a situation of a mercy petition where criminal proceedings had attained finality and what has to be examined in isolation was the executive action; secondly, this Court was fully cognizant of the law laid down in the line of decisions from Kusum Ingots (supra), Ambica Industries Vs. Commissioner Of Central Excise, (2007) 6 SCC 769, Sterling Agro (supra) where the court is obliged to consider not only existence of part of cause of action but also balancing it by applying the principle of forum conveniens.

    13

    15. The concept of forum conveniens is well articulated in the said decision and therefore this Court finds no basis or occasion to take a divergent view from the decision taken by the special Bench comprising of five judges of this Court. Having considered the facts and circumstances of the matter and the obvious forum conveniens for the petitioner, being a resident of Mumbai, seeking relief relating to proceedings underway in Mumbai, the special courts and authorities investigating and adjudicating the matter located in Mumbai, this Court finds no reason to clothe itself with territorial jurisdiction to adjudicate the relief sought in this petition.

    16. Considering that prayer (b) of this writ petition [quashing of the impugned order of the Respondent no. 1] is the dominant and effective relief for which the petitioner seeks immediate redress, the generic prayer (a) [regarding unconstitutionality of provisions of UAPA] can be considered as concomitant and conjunctive to prayer (b), as framed by the petitioner in the writ petition. Therefore, there is no reason why prayer (a) should be severed and considered in isolation to prayer (b).

    Conclusion

    17. For the aforesaid reasons, this Court is of the considered view that the order passed by Respondent no. 1 granting sanction for prosecution under Section 45 (1) of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 would have to be considered along with and in conjunction with investigations and proceedings which it relates to and therefore the courts at Mumbai would have the natural and logical jurisdiction to decide issues challenged in this writ petition. The issue framed by this Court on 3rdMarch, 2022, is answered accordingly.

    14

    18. In light of the foregoing, the Writ Petition is therefore dismissed for lack of territorial jurisdiction to adjudicate the relief sought.

    CRL.M.A. 959/2022 CRL.M.A. 960/2022 CRL.M.A. 1449/2022, CRL.M.A. 1450/2022, CRL.M.A. 2095/2022, CRL.M.A. 2096/2022

    19. In view of dismissal of the writ petition, the aforementioned applications are disposed of as infructuous.

    (ANISH DAYAL)

    JUDGE

    (MUKTA GUPTA)

    JUDGE

    OCTOBER 7, 2022/rk/sm

    15

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    SACHIN HINDURAO WAZE  v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
    (Oct 7, 2022)