Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Order V, Rule 17,
  • sub-rule (1)
  • Order 9 Rule 7 of C.P.C.
  • Order 5 Rule 20 of C.P.C.
  • Order 1 Rule 10 C.P.C.
  • Order 5 Rule 17 of C.P.C.
  • provision of Order 5 Rule 20 of C.P.C.,
  • Order 9 Rule 6 of C.P.C.
  • Order 1 Rule 10 of C.P.C.
  • Order V, Rule 19,
  • Order 9 Rule 7
  • provisions contained in Rule 7 of Order 9 of C.P.C.
  • Order 5 Rule 17 and under Order 5 Rule 20
  • Rules 56 and 71 of Civil Court Rules
  • Order 9 Rule 6(1)(a)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Order V, Rule 17,
  • sub-rule (1)
  • Order 9 Rule 7 of C.P.C.
  • Order 5 Rule 20 of C.P.C.
  • Order 1 Rule 10 C.P.C.
  • Order 5 Rule 17 of C.P.C.
  • provision of Order 5 Rule 20 of C.P.C.,
  • Order 9 Rule 6 of C.P.C.
  • Order 1 Rule 10 of C.P.C.
  • Order V, Rule 19,
  • Order 9 Rule 7
  • provisions contained in Rule 7 of Order 9 of C.P.C.
  • Order 5 Rule 17 and under Order 5 Rule 20
  • Rules 56 and 71 of Civil Court Rules
  • Order 9 Rule 6(1)(a)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India was filed by defendant No. 5 against an order dated 29.01.2022 rejecting his application under Order 9 Rule 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure (C.P.C.) to set aside ex parte proceedings. The plaintiff filed a suit in October 2012 for specific performance of contract and permanent injunction concerning a part of house No. E-3/134 at Arera Colony, Bhopal. Defendant No. 5 was joined as a party defendant in 2013 by an application under Order 1 Rule 10 C.P.C. Notices to defendant No. 5 at the disputed property address were returned unserved, leading to substituted service by publication. Defendant No. 5 did not appear at the hearing, and the trial court proceeded ex parte against him. The petitioner later applied to set aside the ex parte order alleging non-service of notices and that he had sold the property in 2011 and relocated to Vadodara in 2012. The trial court rejected this application, leading to the present petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether summons were duly served on defendant No. 5 to satisfy the conditions under Order 9 Rule 6(1)(a) C.P.C. for proceeding ex parte against him.
  2. Whether the application under Order 9 Rule 7 C.P.C. for setting aside the ex parte proceedings filed after more than five years is maintainable.
  3. Whether substituted service was properly ordered and carried out in accordance with the requirements of Order 5 Rule 17 and Order 5 Rule 20 C.P.C.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • Notices were never served on him; he only learned of the suit in January 2022.
  • He sold the house in dispute on 14.03.2011 and shifted residence to Vadodara in 2012.
  • The plaintiff, being his co-brother, was aware of his relocation but still mentioned the old address in the plaint.
  • Notices issued on the application under Order 1 Rule 10 were returned unserved with a note stating no person by his name lived at the given address.
  • Despite this, notices and substituted service by publication were repeatedly made at the old address and local newspaper circulated in Bhopal.
  • He was proceeded ex parte without proper service as mandated by law.

Plaintiff’s Arguments

  • The application under Order 9 Rule 7 was filed after more than five years of the ex parte order and is thus not maintainable.
  • The application was filed solely to prolong litigation.
  • The petitioner was aware of the suit pendency as other co-defendants had appeared.
  • The petitioner deliberately avoided participation in the suit.
  • The trial court rightly rejected the petitioner’s application.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the relevant provisions of the C.P.C., particularly Order 9 Rule 7, Order 9 Rule 6(1)(a), Order 5 Rule 17, and Order 5 Rule 20, which regulate the procedure for setting aside ex parte orders and substituted service of summons. The Court noted that Order 9 Rule 7 requires an application for setting aside ex parte proceedings to be filed at or before the adjourned hearing with good cause shown for prior non-appearance. The Court emphasized that substituted service cannot be ordered routinely and requires satisfaction that the defendant is avoiding service and that summons could not be served in the ordinary manner.

In this case, the Court found that notices were repeatedly sent to the same address from which the petitioner had shifted years earlier, and the initial notice was returned unserved with a clear note that no person by the petitioner’s name resided there. Despite this, the plaintiff did not provide the correct address, and substituted service was ordered and executed only at the old address and by publication in a local newspaper circulated in Bhopal. The petitioner demonstrated by documentary evidence that he resided in Vadodara from 2012 onwards.

The Court held that proper procedure under Order 5 Rule 17 and Order 5 Rule 20 was not followed, and the petitioner was not properly served. The Court found the trial court erred in rejecting the application to set aside the ex parte proceedings and in concluding that summons were duly served.

Holding and Implications

The Court set aside the ex parte order dated 25.04.2016 and the subsequent order dated 29.01.2022 rejecting the petitioner’s application under Order 9 Rule 7 C.P.C.

The petitioner’s application was allowed, and both parties were directed to appear before the trial court on 23.06.2022. This decision restores the petitioner’s right to participate in the suit proceedings. No order as to costs was made. The Court did not establish any new precedent but rectified procedural irregularities affecting the petitioner’s right to fair trial.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Virendra Kumar Sondhi v. Sudesh Kumar Suri And Others

    Nandita Dubey, J.:— This petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India has been filed by one of the defendants namely defendant No. 5, against the order dated 29.01.2022 (Annexure P-4), passed in RCS No. 1108-A/2012, whereby the petitioner's application under Order 9 Rule 7 of C.P.C. for setting aside the exparte proceedings was rejected.

    2. Plaintiff/respondent No. 1 has filed a suit for specific performance of contract and permanent injunction in October 2012 with regard to one part of house No. E-3/134 situated at Arera Colony, Bhopal against defendant No. 1. In 2013, he filed an application under Order 1 Rule 10 of C.P.C. to join defendants No. 2 to 7 in the suit. Notices were issued to the other side. The notice to defendant No. 5 at the address E-3/134, Arera Colony, Bhopal was returned unserved. Substituted service by publication was therefore, permitted. Thereafter the application under Order 1 Rule 10 of C.P.C. was allowed and defendant No. 2 to 7 were formally impleaded as party defendants. Thereafter, notices of the plaint was sent to newly added defendants. The notices returned unserved on defendants No. 4 to 7, hence substituted service by publication in local newspaper was ordered. As defendant No. 5 did not appear on the date of hearing, the trial Court proceeded exparte against him.

    3. The petitioner preferred an application under Order 9 Rule 7 of C.P.C. in January, 2022, alleging that the notices were never served to him. He came to know about the pending suit in the first week of January, 2022 and on enquiry, came to know that he has been treated as served. It is urged that petitioner had sold the house in dispute on 14.03.2011 and shifted to Vadodara in the year 2012. It is submitted that petitioner and plaintiff/respondent No. 1 are co-brother (Sadhu Bhai) and plaintiff was aware about petitioner having shifted to Vadodara, despite that he mentioned the wrong address in the plaint. Taking this Court through the order sheets, pass book, electricity bills etc., it is contended by learned counsel for the petitioner that notices issued on the application under Order 1 Rule 10 of C.P.C. were returned unserved on 24.04.2014 with a note that “no person with this name lives on the given address”, despite that subsequent notice and paper publication were still made on the same address and the local news paper circulated at Bhopal. After being formally impleaded as party defendants, fresh notices were again issued on 05.10.2015 on the same address at Bhopal, which again remained unserved and the subsequent publication was also made at Bhopal and thereafter the petitioner was proceeded exparte on 25.04.2016, as he did not appear before the trial Court even after publication of the notice in the news paper.

    4. Per contra, the contention of learned counsel for the plaintiff/respondent No. 1 is that the application under Order 9 Rule 7 of C.P.C. filed after more than five years after passing the exparte order is not maintainable and filed only to prolong the litigation. It is stated that the petitioner was aware of the pendency of the suit as the other co-defendants were already appeared but he deliberately did not participate in the suit and now in order to cause delay has filed this application, therefore, the trial Court did not commit any mistake in rejecting the same.

    5. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.

    6. Before adverting to the rival submissions of the parties, it is apposite to refer to the relevant provisions. The provisions contained in Rule 7 of Order 9 of C.P.C. provides as under:—

    7. Procedure where defendant appears on day of adjourned hearing and assigns good cause for previous non-appearance.

    Where the Court has adjourned the hearing of the suit ex-parte and the defendant, at or before such hearing, appears and assigns good cause for his previous non-appearance, he may, upon such terms as the Court directs as to costs or otherwise, be heard in answer to the suit as if he had appeared on the day, fixed for his appearance.

    7. The main part of the Order 9 Rule 7 speaks of good cause being shown for non-appearance on a previous date. Further the words at or before used in the aforestated rule go to indicate that the application for setting aside the exparte order is to be filed latest before the date the case is adjourned after the defendant was proceeded ex-parte. If the party does not appear on the date to which the hearing of the suit is adjourned, he cannot be stopped from participating in the proceedings simply because he did not appear on the first or some other hearing. But though he has arrived to appear at an adjourned hearing, he has no right to set back the hands of the clock, Order 9 Rule 7 makes that clear, therefore, unless he can show good cause, he must accept or that has gone before and be condemned to proceed from the stage at which he comes in.

    8. Order 9 Rule 6 of C.P.C. provides thus:—

    6. PROCEDURE WHEN ONLY PLAINTIFF APPEARS.

    (1)……….. when the suit is called on for hearing, then-

    (a) When summons duly served: if it is proved that the summons was duly served, the Court may make an order that the suit shall be heard ex parte.

    9. This is the provision under which the Court below purportedly acted on 25.04.2016.

    10. The question in the present case is whether the summons were duly served on the petitioner/defendant No. 5 to satisfy the conditions enumerated under Order 9 Rule 6(1)(a) to proceed exparte against the defendant.

    11. Order 5 Rule 17 of C.P.C. provides thus:—

    17. PROCEDURE WHEN DEFENDANT REFUSES TO ACCEPT SERVICE, OR CANNOT BE FOUND.

    Where the defendant or his agent or such other person as aforesaid refuses to sign the acknowledgment, or where the serving officer, after using all due and reasonable diligence, cannot find the defendant, who is absent from his residence at the time when service is sought to be effected on him at his residence and there is no likelihood of his being found at the residence within a reasonable time and there is no agent empowered to accept service of the summons on his behalf, nor any other person on whom service can be made, the serving officer shall affix a copy of the summons on the outer door or some other conspicuous part of the house in which the defendant ordinarily resides or carries on business or personally works for gain, and shall then return the original to the Court from which it was issued, with a report endorsed thereon or annexed thereto stating that he has so affixed the copy, the circumstances under which he did do, and the name and address of the person (if any) by whom the house was identified and in whose presence the copy was affixed.

    12. Rules 56 and 71 of Civil Court Rules reads thus:—

    56. If the person addressed is absent from his residence at the time of attempted service and there is no likelihood of his returning there within a reasonable time and there is no agent empowered to accept service on his behalf, nor any other person on whom service can be made, service should be effected in the manner directed in Order V, Rule 17. It should be proved according to the circumstances of the case by the declaration of the serving officer and, if necessary, by the affidavit or solemn declaration of some other person or persons (if any), acquainted with the facts that the person was absent from his residence at the time of attempted service and that there was no likelihood of his returning within reasonable time and that there was no agent empowered to accept service, nor any other person on whom service could be made; and in any case that the house on the outer door or some other conspicuous part of which a copy of the process was affixed, was the ordinary residence or place of business of the person addressed at the time when it was so affixed. The Court may also proceed under Order V, Rule 19.

    Note 1. If the person is temporarily absent from home when the server calls, it cannot be said that he cannot be found and so cannot be served personally. If the person has gone to his field or to the bathing ghat or a temple, etc., or to a friend or relative in the town or village or on a short visit to a neighbouring village or town, the server should make reasonable search for him.

    Note 2.- If the process-server has reason to suspect that the person to be served is in hiding, he should repeat his visit to the house; he may also be able, with the assistance of respectable persons in the neighbourhood to induce the man to accept service.

    Note 3.- It the server has reason to believe that there is a good prospect of personal service if he stays for a short time in the village, he may stay there for not more than six hours, or he may re-visit the village after serving processes in the neighbouring villages.

    Note 4.- When after the exercise of all due and reasonable diligence the person though temporarily absent from home, can not or is not likely to be found and if not less than three weeks, or such other period as the District Judge may fix, will still remain before the hearing when the server returns to his headquarters the process should not be affixed to the house but brought back so that it may be sent out again.

    71. (1) In determining whether the service is good or sufficient, the attention of the Courts is drawn to the necessity of strictly following the requirements of law in the Civil Procedure Code. (2) Whenever process is returned under Order V, Rule 17, and the return is not verified by the affidavit of the serving officer, it is incumbent upon the Court to make an enquiry under Order V, Rule 19, and to record a distinct declaration of due service, if satisfied, or to order such service, as it thinks fit.

    13. Order 5 Rule 20 of C.P.C. further provides for substituted service, which reads thus:—

    20. Substituted service.

    (1) Where the Court is satisfied that there is reason to believe that the defendant is keeping out of the way for the purpose of avoiding service, or that for any other reason the summons cannot be served in the ordinary way, the Court shall order the summons to be served by affixing a copy thereof in some conspicuous place in the Court-house, and also upon some conspicuous part of the house (if any) in which the defendant is known to have last resided or carried on business or personally worked for gain, or in such other manner as the Court thinks fit.

    (1A) Where the Court acting under sub-rule (1) orders service by an advertisement in a newspaper, the newspaper shall be a daily newspaper circulating in the locality in which the defendant is last known to have actually and voluntarily resided, carried on business or personally worked for gain.

    (2) Effect of substituted service- Service substituted by order of the Court shall be as effectual as if it had been made on the defendant personally.

    (3) Where service substituted, time for appearance to be fixed- Where service is substituted by order of the Court, the Court shall fix such time for the appearance of the defendant as the case may require.

    14. However, the substituted service cannot ordered in a routine manner. Before restoring to the provision of Order 5 Rule 20 of C.P.C., it is obligatory for the Court to record its satisfaction that the defendant was keeping out of the way for the purpose of avoiding service and the summons could not be served in ordinary manner.

    15. In the present case, it is an admitted fact that plaintiff and defendant No. 5/petitioner are co-brothers (Sadu Bhai). The notice to respondent No. 5 was returned unserved on 24.04.2014 with a note that “no person with this name lives on the given address”. Thereafter by order dated 28.10.2014, substituted service was permitted by the Court below only on the submissions of the plaintiff that the defendants are avoiding the service. The Court below did not ask the plaintiff to give the correct address of defendant No. 5. Since defendant No. 5 did not appear, he was proceeded exparte. The application under Order 1 Rule 10 C.P.C. filed was ultimately allowed on 05.02.2015 and the defendant No. 5/petitioner was formally impleaded as party defendant No. 5 and fresh notices were directed to be issued on 05.10.2015, which again returned unserved and thereafter on 29.02.2016, on an application of plaintiff, filed on the same day, substituted service by publication was permitted. As the defendant No. 5 did not appear on the date of hearing, i.e., 24.05.2016, he was proceeded exparte.

    16. In the instant case, admittedly the notices were sent on the same address, i.e., E-3/134, Arera Colony, Bhopal, which returned unserved earlier also, with the note “no person with this name lives on the given address” and paper publication was also made in the local news paper circulated at Bhopal only.

    17. It is plaintiff's own case that he is the co-brother of defendant No. 5/petitioner, who alongwith his other brothers had sold and handed over the possession of the said house to defendants No. 2 and 3. Despite having knowledge of this fact, the plaintiff got the notices issued to defendant No. 5 on the address of the house, which he had already sold. Under the circumstances and looking to the relation between the plaintiff and the petitioner, it cannot be believed said that the plaintiff did not know the correct address of the petitioner or was not aware that petitioner had shifted from Bhopal to Vadodara.

    18. The petitioner has filed his pass-book and electricity bills to show that he was residing at Vadodara from the year 2012. The Court below rejected the application of the petitioner on the ground that petitioner has failed to show that he has not specified his whereabouts from the period 14.03.2011 to October-November, 2012. For recording a satisfaction that summons were duly served, the period when notices were issued/sent or served is to be considered and not the period prior to it. It is clear that proper procedure as mandated under Order 5 Rule 17 and under Order 5 Rule 20 was not followed. Therefore, it cannot be said that the petitioner was properly served.

    19. Considering the aforestated, in my considered opinion, the Court below has erred in rejecting the application of petitioner. In the result, the order dated 25.04.2016 is set aside, the application of petitioner is allowed. The exparte proceedings by order dated 29.01.2022 are also set aside. The petitioner and respondents shall appear before the Court below on 23.06.2022.

    20. The petition is allowed to the extent indicated hereinabove. No order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Virendra Kumar Sondhi v. Sudesh Kumar Suri And Others
    (Jun 14, 2022)