Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 302/120B/473/34 of the IPC
  • Section 439 (2) of Cr.P.C
  • Section 164 of Cr.P.C,
  • Sections 302 of the Penal Code, 1860, (for short I.P.C) 1860 read with Section 25/27 of the Arms Act 1959
  • Section 439(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure (for short Cr.P.C)
  • Section 439(2) Cr.P.C.
  • Section 439 (2) Cr.P.C. 20.
  • Section 164 Cr.P.C
  • Section 161 and 164 Cr.P.C
  • Section 161 Cr.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 302/120B/473/34 of the IPC
  • Section 439 (2) of Cr.P.C
  • Section 164 of Cr.P.C,
  • Sections 302 of the Penal Code, 1860, (for short I.P.C) 1860 read with Section 25/27 of the Arms Act 1959
  • Section 439(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure (for short Cr.P.C)
  • Section 439(2) Cr.P.C.
  • Section 439 (2) Cr.P.C. 20.
  • Section 164 Cr.P.C
  • Section 161 and 164 Cr.P.C
  • Section 161 Cr.P.C
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The case originated from a First Information Report (FIR) lodged by Sunanda Das on 12.07.2021 at Mongalkote Police Station, alleging the murder of his father, Asim Das. The case was registered as Mongalkote Police Station Case no. 143 of 2021 under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) along with charges under the Arms Act. The CID West Bengal investigated the case and found prima facie evidence of a conspiracy involving four accused parties who allegedly hired Obaidur Rahaman @ Suraj to commit the murder by firing a fatal gunshot on 12.07.2021. All accused were arrested and a charge sheet was submitted on 07.10.2021 under Sections 302, 120B, 473, and 34 IPC against nine accused persons, including the four opposite parties.

Subsequently, the Learned Vacation Judge, Purba Bardhaman, granted bail to the four accused on 26.10.2021 after considering the case diary and hearing both sides. Bail was granted on conditions including execution of bail bonds and weekly reporting to the CID to monitor any threat to witnesses.

Aggrieved by these bail orders, the defacto complainant filed an application under Section 439(2) Cr.P.C. (CRM no. 7296 of 2021) seeking cancellation of bail for the four accused. The State also filed a similar petition (CRM no. 8660 of 2021) for cancellation of bail against the same accused.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether there are prima facie grounds to cancel the bail granted to the accused under Section 439(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
  2. Whether the Learned Vacation Judge erred in granting bail by focusing only on the submission of the charge sheet and period of detention, ignoring the severity of the offence and incriminating evidence.
  3. Whether a single application under Section 439(2) Cr.P.C. challenging multiple bail orders is maintainable.
  4. What are the parameters and legal principles to be considered for granting or cancelling bail in heinous offences such as murder.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments (Defacto Complainant and State)

  • The Learned Vacation Judge granted bail based solely on the period of detention and submission of the charge sheet, ignoring the seriousness of the offence.
  • Material evidence such as statements under Section 164 Cr.P.C, identification of accused in Test Identification Parade, and mobile phone call records indicating conspiracy were not properly considered.
  • The bail orders failed to address the likelihood of interference with witnesses or tampering with evidence.
  • Separate bail orders challenged via a single application are maintainable given the circumstances.

Opposite Parties’ Arguments

  • Challenging three separate bail orders by a single application is not maintainable.
  • The Learned Vacation Judge considered all relevant materials including the case diary, period of detention, and submission of the charge sheet.
  • There was no justification for further detention as investigation was complete and accused were in custody for a considerable time.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Anil Kumar Yadav v. State (NCT of Delhi), (2018) 12 SCC 129 Relevant considerations for granting bail including seriousness of offence, character of evidence, likelihood of accused fleeing, impact on witnesses and society, and likelihood of tampering. Used to emphasize the necessity of judicious discretion and consideration of multiple factors when granting bail, especially in serious offences.
Subodh Kumar Yadav v. State of Bihar, (2009) 14 SCC 638 Grounds for cancellation of bail including non-application of mind and taking irrelevant material into consideration. Applied to support the proposition that bail can be cancelled if the original bail order was perverse or arbitrary.
Puran v. Rambilas with Sekhar v. State of Maharashtra, (2001) 6 SCC 338 Requirement of giving reasons while granting bail and grounds for cancellation if bail is granted without proper reasons in heinous crimes. Referenced to highlight the importance of reasons in bail orders and justification for cancellation of bail where such reasons are absent.
Ram Govind Upadhyay v. Sudarshan Singh, (2002) Calcutta Criminal Law Reporter (SC) 533 Cancellation of bail justified where there is tampering with evidence and threat to witnesses in heinous crimes. Applied to illustrate that bail cancellation is warranted in serious crimes when there is risk of interference with justice.
Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi), (2020) 5 SCC 1 (Constitution Bench) Clarification on the power of courts to consider correctness of bail orders and distinction between cancellation and setting aside of bail. Used to explain the scope of Section 439(2) Cr.P.C and the circumstances under which bail can be cancelled or set aside.
Dolat Ram v. State of Haryana, (1995) 1 SCC 349 Grounds for cancellation of bail including interference with justice, evasion, and abuse of liberty granted. Relied upon to emphasize that cancellation of bail requires cogent and overwhelming circumstances.
Jayendra Saraswathi Swamigal v. State Of T.N, (2005) 2 SCC 13 Factors to be considered while granting bail in non-bailable offences including nature and seriousness of offence, character of evidence, and public interest. Referred to for outlining criteria relevant to bail decisions in serious offences.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first addressed the objection regarding maintainability of a single petition challenging multiple bail orders, holding that no prejudice arises and such a petition is maintainable in the circumstances.

The central legal question was whether prima facie grounds existed for cancellation of bail under Section 439(2) Cr.P.C. The Court summarized the legal parameters for cancellation of bail, distinguishing between cancellation on the merits of the bail order itself (e.g., perverse or arbitrary orders) and cancellation based on post-bail misconduct (e.g., tampering or fleeing).

Upon review of the impugned bail orders, the Court noted that the Learned Vacation Judge had focused only on the submission of the charge sheet and period of detention, without dealing with incriminating evidence such as witness statements under Sections 161 and 164 Cr.P.C, identification of accused in Test Identification Parade, and mobile phone connectivity maps showing conspiracy communications.

The Court highlighted the serious nature of the offence—murder by hired killer following conspiracy—and the influential position of one accused in the locality, which increases the risk of interference with the administration of justice.

The Court emphasized that while detailed examination of evidence is not expected at the bail stage, a prima facie satisfaction of the charge and consideration of all relevant factors including likelihood of witness tampering and threat to complainants are essential. The impugned orders failed to apply these principles properly.

Drawing upon authoritative precedents, the Court underscored that bail orders in heinous crimes must be reasoned and that bail can be cancelled if granted arbitrarily or ignoring material evidence. The Court found the bail orders vulnerable for ignoring critical evidence and for relying on irrelevant factors.

Accordingly, the Court found it necessary to interfere with and set aside the bail orders in the interest of justice.

Holding and Implications

The applications for cancellation of bail under Section 439(2) of the Cr.P.C. (CRM nos. 7296 of 2021 and 8660 of 2021) are allowed.

The bail granted to the four accused by the Learned Vacation Judge on 26.10.2021 is set aside. The accused are directed to surrender before the jurisdictional court within seven days from the date of this order, failing which the court will take appropriate steps for their arrest.

This decision directly affects the parties by revoking bail in a serious murder case involving conspiracy and hired killing. No new precedent is established beyond the application of settled legal principles regarding bail and cancellation thereof in heinous offences.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    SUNANDA DAS v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.

    Bibhas Ranjan De, J.:— The genesis of the case began with First Information Report (for short ‘FIR’) which was lodged by one Sunanda Das (Petitioner of CRM 7296 of 2021) with Mongalkote Police Station on 12.07.2021 alleging murder of his father (Asim Das) leading to Registration of the case as Mongalkote Police Station Case no. 143 of 2021 dated 12.07.2021 under Sections 302 of the Penal Code, 1860, (for short I.P.C) 1860 read with Section 25/27 of the Arms Act 1959 corresponding to G.R case no. 618/2021.

    2. It is alleged that C.I.D West Bengal, took up investigation of the case and during investigation prima facie it has been revealed that opposite parties, four (4) accused, cooked up a conspiracy to kill the deceased father of the complainant and got it done by one Obaidur Rahaman @ Suraj, hired killer, who fired the fatal gun-shot at Asim Das on 12.07.2021. Accordingly, C.I.D West Bengal arrested said opposite parties and submitted charge sheet being no. 190 of 2021 dated 07.10.2021 under Section 302/120B/473/34 of the IPC against nine (9) accused persons including four opposite parties, after completion of investigation.

    3. Ld. Vacation Judge, Purba Bardhaman, granted bail to all four opposite parties on 26.10.2021 vide three criminal Misc. case nos. 2182/2021, 2185/2021 and 2193/2021 after perusal of case diary and after hearing both sides holding inter alia that investigation was completed by submitting charge sheet and accused were in custody for considerable period. Ld. Judge granted bail to all four opposite parties on executing bail bond of Rs. 10,000/- with two sureties of Rs. 5000/- each and also on condition to report to the C.I.D once in a week keeping an eye to the apprehension of any threat to the witness.

    4. Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the said orders dated 26.10.2021 passed by Ld. Vacation Judge, defacto complainant has filed an application under Section 439(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure (for short ‘Cr.P.C’) being CRM no. 7296 of 2021 against all four (4) accused (private opposite parties) granted bail by the order dated 26.10.2021 passed by the Ld. Vacation Judge, Purba Bardhaman, and the state has also filed a petition under Section 439 (2) of Cr.P.C against same four (4) accused (private opposite parties) for cancellation of bail being C.R.M no. 8660 of 2021.

    5. On behalf of the petitioner in C.R.M no. 7296 of 2021, Mr. Sekhar Kumar Basu, Ld. Senior Advocate, referred to the decisions reported in the cases as mentioned below:

    5.1 Anil Kumar Yadav v. State (Nct) Of Delhi & Anrs), (2018) 12 SCC 129

    5.2 Subodh Kumar Yadav v. State of Bihar, (2009) 14 SCC 638

    5.3 Puran v. Rambilas with Sekhar v. State of Maharasthra, (2001) 6 SCC 338

    5.4 Ram Govind Upadhyay v. Sudarshan Singh, (2002) Calcutta Criminal Law Reporter (SC) 533

    6. Mr. Basu contended that the Ld. Vacation Judge granted bail to the opposite parties on the ground of period of detention and submission of charge sheet ignoring the ‘severity of the offence’, statement recorded under Section 164 of Cr.P.C, identification of the accused in the Test Identification Parade, and the call records of mobile phones showing conversation among the opposite parties at the time of commission of offence. Therefore, according to Mr. Basu, the order of bail granted in favour of the opposite parties should be cancelled by setting aside the order dated 26.10.2021.

    7. In C.R.M no. 8660 of 2021 Ld. Additional Public Prosecutor on behalf of the State/Petitioner supporting the argument advanced by Mr. Basu contended inter alia that Ld. Vacation Judge did not adhere to the statement of witnesses recorded under Section 164 Cr.P.C as well as identification of the accused in Test Identification Parade and came to an erroneous finding by granting bail to the accused.

    8. Ld. Advocates Mr. Imtiaz Ahmed, Mr. Ali Hasan Alamgir and Mr. Uday Sankar Chattopadhyay on behalf of the opposite parties, have drawn our attention to the fact that separate bail order granted by three separate Misc. case have been challenged in both the C.R.M nos. 7296 of 2021 and 8660 of 2021 by a single application under Section 439 (2) of Cr.P.C which is not maintainable. Next, it is contended that Ld. Vacation Judge considered all relevant materials in the case diary and period of detention and also submission of charge sheet after investigation. That is why, it is contended that nothing else to be investigated to justify further detention of the opposite parties.

    9. In Anil Kumar Yadav (supra) it was observed by the Hon'ble Apex Court:

    “17. While granting bail, the relevant considerations are : (i) nature of seriousness of the offence; (ii) character of the evidence and circumstances which are peculiar to the accused; and (iii) likelihood of the accused fleeing from justice; (iv) the impact that his release may make on the prosecution witnesses, its impact on the society; and (v) likelihood of his tampering. No doubt, this list is not exhaustive. There are no hard-and-fast rules regarding grant or refusal of bail, each case has to be considered on its own merits. The matter always calls for judicious exercise of discretion by the Court.

    18. While considering the basic requirements for grant of bail, in State Of U.P Through Cbi v. Amarmani Tripathi ., (2005) 8 SCC 21, this Court has held as under : (SCC p. 31, para 18)

    “18. It is well settled that the matters to be considered in an application for bail are (i) whether there is any prima facie or reasonable ground to believe that the accused had committed the offence; (ii) nature and gravity of the charge; (iii) severity of the punishment in the event of conviction; (iv) danger of the accused absconding or fleeing, if released on bail; (v) character, behaviour, means, position and standing of the accused; (vi) likelihood of the offence being repeated; (vii) reasonable apprehension of the witnesses being tampered with; and (viii) danger, of course, of justice being thwarted by grant of bail [see Prahlad Singh Bhati v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2001) 4 SCC 280 and Gurcharan Singh v. State (NCT of Delhi) (1978) 1 SCC 118]. While a vague allegation that the accused may tamper with the evidence or witnesses may not be a ground to refuse bail, if the accused is of such character that his mere presence at large would intimidate the witnesses or if there is material to show that he will use his liberty to subvert justice or tamper with the evidence, then bail will be refused. We may also refer to the following principles relating to grant or refusal of bail stated in Kalyan Chandra Sarkar v. Rajesh Ranjan (2004) 7 SCC 528 : (SCC pp. 535-36, para 11)

    “11. The law in regard to grant or refusal of bail is very well settled. The court granting bail should exercise its discretion in a judicious manner and not as a matter of course. Though at the stage of granting bail a detailed examination of evidence and elaborate documentation of the merit of the case need not be undertaken, there is a need to indicate in such orders reasons for prima facie concluding why bail was being granted particularly where the accused is charged of having committed a serious offence. Any order devoid of such reasons would suffer from non-application of mind. It is also necessary for the court granting bail to consider among other circumstances, the following factors also before granting bail; they are:

    (a) The nature of accusation and the severity of punishment in case of conviction and the nature of supporting evidence

    (b) Reasonable apprehension of tampering with the witness or apprehension of threat to the complainant.

    (c) Prima facie satisfaction of the court in support of the charge. (See Ram Govind Upadhyay v. Sudarshan Singh (2002) 3 SCC 598 and Puran v. Rambilas (2001) 6 SCC 338.)””

    19. The test to be applied for grant of bail was also considered in Jayendra Saraswathi Swamigal v. State Of T.N ., (2005) 2 SCC 13, wherein it was held as under : (SCC pp.21-22, para 16)

    “16. . ……. The considerations which normally weigh with the court in granting bail in non-bailable offences have been explained by this Court in State v. Captain Jagjit Singh . ((1962) 3 SCR 622 and Gurcharan Singh v. State (NCT of Delhi) (1978) 1 SCC 118 and basically they are - the nature and seriousness of the offence; the character of the evidence; circumstances which are peculiar to the accused; a reasonable possibility of the presence of the accused not being secured at the trial; reasonable apprehension of witnesses being tampered with; the larger interest of the public or the State and other similar factors which may be relevant in the facts and circumstances of the case.”

    10. In Subodh Kumar Yadav (supra) Hon'ble Apex Court opined as follows:

    “In fact it is now well settled that if a superior court finds that the court granting bail had acted on irrelevant material or if there was non-application of mind or failure to take note of any statutory bar to grant bail, or if there was manifest impropriety as for example failure to hear the public prosecutor/complainant where required, an order for cancellation of bail can in fact be made. (See Gajanand Agarwal v. State of Orissa [(2006) 12 SCC 131 : (2006) 9 Scale 378] and Rizwan Akbar Hussain Syyed v. Mehmood Hussain [(2007) 10 SCC 368) at (SCC p.37, para7). Further, while cancelling bail, the superior Court would be justified in considering the question whether irrelevant material were taken into consideration by the court granting bail”

    11. In Puran (supra) it was decided by the Hon'ble Apex Court as follows:

    “He submitted that in view of these observations the learned Additional Sessions Judge did not give reasons whilst granting bail. He submitted that in these circumstances the Additional Sessions Judge cannot be faulted. He submitted that the High Court could not cancel bail on this ground. We see no substance in this contention. Giving reasons is different from discussing merits or demerits. At the stage of granting bail a detailed examination of evidence and elaborate documentation of the merits of the case has not to be undertaken. What the Additional Sessions Judge had done, in the Order dated 11-9-2000 was to discuss the merits and demerits of the evidence. That was what was deprecated. That did not mean that whilst granting bail some reasons for prima facie concluding why bail was being granted did not have to be indicated.

    Mr. Lalit next submitted that the High Court has itself not given reasons but has mechanically set aside the order of the bail. We see no substance in this submission. The High Court has correctly not gone into merits or demerits of the matter. The High Court has noted that evidence prima-facie indicated demand of dowry. The High Court has briefly indicated the evidence on record and what was found at the scene of the offence. The High Court has indicated that evidence prima facie indicated that a demand for Rs. 1 lakh was made just a month prior to the incident in question. The High Court has stated that the material on record suggested that the offences under Sections 498-A and 304-A (sic 304-B) were prima facie disclosed. The High Court has concluded that the material on record, the nature of injuries, demand for Rs. 1 lakh and the other circumstances were such that this was not a fit case for granting bail. Thus the High Court has given very cogent reasons why bail should not have been granted and why this unjustified erroneous order granting bail should be cancelled.

    Mr. Lalit next submitted that once bail has been granted it should not be cancelled unless there is evidence that the conditions of bail are being infringed. In support of this submission he relies upon the authority in the case of Dolat Ram v. State of Haryana reported in (1995) 1 SCC 349. In this case it has been held that rejection of bail in a non-bailable case at the initial stage and the cancellation of bail already granted have to be considered and dealt with on different basis. It has been held that very cogent and overwhelming circumstances are necessary for an order directing the cancellation of the bail already granted. It has been held that generally speaking the grounds for cancellation of bail broadly are interference or attempt to interfere with the due course of administration of justice or evasion or attempt to evade the due course of justice or abuse of the concession granted to the accused in any manner. It is, however, to be noted that this Court has clarified that these instances are merely illustrative and not exhaustive. One such ground for cancellation of bail would be where ignoring material and evidence on record a perverse order granting bail is passed in a heinous crime of this nature and that too without giving any reasons. Such an order would be against principles of law. Interest of justice would also require that such a perverse order be set aside and bail be cancelled. It must be remembered that such offences are on the rise and have a very serious impact on the Society. Therefore, an arbitrary and wrong exercise of discretion by the trial court has to be corrected.”

    12. In Ram Govind Upadhyay it was held by the Apex Court as follows:

    “In our view, the High Court has committed a manifest error in the matter of grant of bail when public tranquility has been stated to be disturbed on the electionday and when there is an obstruction for the exercise of a right guaranteed under the Constitution and when there is an existence of crime against the society at large. Irrespective of different factors to be taken note of in regard to the cancellation of the grant of bail, in our view interest of justice seem to be over-whelmingly in favour of the appellant herein in the matter of cancellation of the bail. The elder brother has been brutally murdered and the proceeding is pending before the Sessions Judge. It is during the period when the accused persons were enlarged on bail that another FIR was recorded and charge-sheet having been filed, the Court ought to have taken a serious note of these factual details. Tampering with the evidence and threatening of the witnesses are two basic grounds for cancellation of bail - both these two factors stand alleged and by reason of subsequent filing of charge-sheet therein, there should have been some mention of it in the order for grant of bail. The factum of the second charge-sheet has been omitted in its entirety.”

    13. At the very outset we may turn to the submission advanced on behalf of the accuseds to the effect that both the C.R.M are not maintainable because of challenging three separate orders by a single application. It has come to our notice that accused namely Sk. Babul @ khokon filed one bail application, Sabul Sk. And Samu Sk. filed another joint petition with a prayer for bail and accused Najrul Sk. filed a separate bail application for consideration before the Ld. Vacation Judge. On 26.10.2021 Ld. Vacation Judge disposed of all three bail applications by three separate orders. Being aggrieved defacto complainant ‘Sunanda Das’ filed one application for cancellation of bail (C.R.M no. 7296) and State also file one application for cancellation of bail against the same petitioners (C.R.M 8660 of 2021). In these circumstances, we are of the view, that the single cancellation petition against those three orders filed on the same day is not likely to prejudice any of the accused in any manner. No authority has been cited on behalf of the accused to say that a petition under Section 439(2) cannot be directed against several orders granting bail to accuseds involved in the same police case. Therefore, the cancellation petition cannot be said to be not maintainable.

    14. The question thus before us is as to whether there are prima facie grounds available for cancellation of bail under Section 439(2) of the Cr.P.C or not.

    15. The bail granted under Section 439(1) of the Cr.P.C can be cancelled where the accused:

    15.1. misuse his liberty by indulging in similar criminal activity;

    15.2. interferes with the course of investigation;

    15.3. attempts to tamper with evidence of witness;

    15.4. threatens witness or indulges in similar activities which would hamper smooth investigation;

    15.5. is likely to flee to another country;

    15.6. attempts to make himself scarce by going underground or becoming unavailable to the investigating agency;

    15.7. attempts to place himself beyond the reach of his surety etc.

    16. These are all post bail misconduct.

    17. Anil Kumar Yadav (supra) discussed elaborately the grounds to be considered at the time of granting bail under Section 439(2) Cr.P.C. On the other hand Subodh Kumar Yadav (supra) emphasised on the grounds required for cancelling bail. It was observed that the superior Court, while cancelling bail, would be justified in considering the question whether irrelevant materials were taken into consideration by the court granting bail. In that case judicial discretion was exercised by the Ld. Judicial Magistrate in an arbitrary manner. Puran (supra) dealt with the reasons to be assigned at the time of granting bail. It was further observed that cancellation of bail may be ordered where bail order is passed in a heinous crime ignoring the material and evidence on record and without giving any reasons. Such order can be set aside for interest of justice. Ram Govind Upadhyay (supra) dealt with one heinous crime like murder and cancellation of bail was ordered to be justified on the ground of tampering with the evidence and threatening of the witnesses.

    18. To eschew the prolixity we refrain ourselves from reproducing the entire impugned order dated 26.10.2021 passed by the Ld. Vacation Judge, Purba Bardhaman. But on perusal of the impugned orders we find that Ld. Judge only focused on the submission of charge sheet and period of detention. Keeping an eye to the submission on behalf of the state Ld. Judge also passed order directing the accuseds to report to the CID once in a week apprehending threat to the witnesses.

    19. In this conjecture, we think it appropriate to refer the case of Sushila Aggarwal v. state (NCT of Delhi), (2020) 5 SCC 1 (Constitution Bench) wherein Hon'ble Apex Court observed as follows:

    “85.8 It is open to the police or the investigating agency to move the court concerned, which granted anticipatory bail, in the first instance, for a direction under Section 439 (2) to arrest theaccused, in the event of violation of any term, such as absconding, non-cooperating during investigation, evasion, intimidation or inducement to witnesses with a view to influence outcome of the investigation or trial, etc. The Court, in this context, is the court which grants anticipatory bail, in the first instance, according to prevailing authorities.

    85.9 The correctness of an order granting bail, can be considered by the appellate or Superior Court at the behest of the State or investigating agency, and set aside on the ground that the Court granting it did not consider material facts or crucial circumstances. (See Prakash kadam v. Ramprasad Vishwanath Gupta, Jai Prakash Singh and State Of U.P Through Cbi v. Amarmani Tripathi .). This does not amount to “Cancellation” in terms of Section 439 (2) Cr.P.C.”

    20. Therefore, in Sushila Aggarwal (supra) Hon'ble Apex Court handed down a broader ruling on applicability of section 439(2) of Cr.P.C by expressing the view that the correctness of an order granting bail can be considered and set aside, if required, by the Appellate Court or Superior Court and that order cannot be said to be an order of ‘cancellation’ in terms of section 439 (2) of Cr.P.C. Therefore, the Power of Cancellation of bail can be invoked in the following two situations:

    19.1. on merit of a case mainly on the ground of the order granting bail being perverse, passed without due appreciation of merit or in violation of any substantive or procedural law.

    19.2. on the ground of misuse of liberty after the grant of bail or other supervening circumstances.

    21. The impugned orders dated 26.10.2021 clearly visualize that though Ld. Vacation Judge heard the submission made on behalf of the State regarding incriminating materials in the Case Diary but Ld. Judge did not deal with any of such incriminating materials in his order. Ld Judge, rather, focused on the fact of submission of charge sheet and the period of detention only.

    22. We have gone through the case diary and prima facie it appears that the offence is very serious one and relating to an incident of murder and that too by one hired killer following a conspiracy. It appears that the deceased was the Anchal Sabhapati and opposite party no. 2, Sabul Sk, is Anchal Saha Sabhapati and it is alleged to have a dispute between Anchal Sabhatpati and Anchal Saha Sabhapati.

    23. Case diary reflects series of statements of witness under Section 161 Cr.P.C and also statements under Section 164 Cr.P.C implicating all the accused/opposite parties in the murder. The witnesses also identified all the opposite parties during Test Identification Parade. From the charge sheet we find that during investigation IO collected ‘connectivity map’ of mobile phone calls of all accused/opposite parties and also accused Obidur Rahaman who is alleged to be a hired killer. That connectivity map of mobile phone show the communication for the day of 12 July, 2021 in between 5.30 p.m. and 7.30 p.m. when incident leading to the murder is alleged to have been taken place.

    24. Bail in the first type (para 19.1) of cases can be cancelled by Superior Courts only, whereas in the second category (para 19.2) of cases bail can be cancelled by the Court which has granted the bail also.

    25. Now, we propose to come to the parameters of law to be considered before granting bail in a case of non-bailable offence. While granting bail Court should keep in mind the following:

    24.1. nature of accusations;

    24.2. severity of punishment, if accusation entails a conviction;

    24.3. nature of evidence in support of the accusations;

    24.4. reasonable apprehension of witness being tampered with;

    24.5. apprehension of there being a threat for complainant.

    26. It is true that no discussion of entire evidence to form an opinion whether evidence would established guilt beyond reasonable doubt is expected at the stage of considering matter of bail. However, prima facie satisfaction of Court in support of charge must be there. As it is trite law that power of granting bail cannot be exercised in capricious or injudicious manner. Heinous nature of crime warrants more caution.

    27. In our case, taking the risk of repetition, centre of attention of Ld. Vacation Judge was only on the fact of submission of charge sheet and period of detention at the time of granting bail to the accused/opposite parties in a case of criminal conspiracy for killing persons, ignoring the parameters of law we discussed in para 24.

    28. After rummaging through the case diary we found that witnesses recorded statement both under Section 161 and 164 Cr.P.C implicating all accused/opposite parties who were also identified by the witnesses during the Test Identification Parade. Not only that, investigating Officer, during investigation also collected ‘connectivity map’ of mobile phones of the accused/opposite parties and therefore, it was found that at the time of commission of offence of murder accused/opposite parties talked to each other and even with alleged hired killer. That apart, Sabul Sk. one of the accused/opposite parties is “Anchal Saha Sabhapati” being an influential person of the locality.

    29. Therefore, position, influence and resources of the accused/opposite parties are also relevant factors to adjudge whether the accused/opposite parties are likely to interfere with administration of justice, trial or tamper with witnesses or evidence.

    30. We are not oblivious of the fact that the liberty is priceless treasure for a human being. We are also not oblivious of the fact that the liberty of an individual is not absolute. The society by its collective wisdom through process of law can withdraw the liberty that it has sanctioned to an individual when an individual becomes a danger to the collective and to the societal order.

    31. Ld. Vacation Judge, with due respect, seems to have ignored the overwhelming prima facie evidence appearing in the case diary as we discussed in para 27 and 28, rather took into consideration irrelevant materials i.e submission of charge sheet and period of detention.

    32. In aforesaid view of the matter, we find it necessary to interfere with the orders passed on 26.10.2021 by the Ld. Vacation Judge, Purba Bardhaman. Such vulnerable order granting bail needs to be set aside in the interest of justice.

    33. In the result, both the applications for cancellation of bail under Section 439(2) of the Cr.P.C stand allowed. Thereby, CRM no. 7296 of 2021 and 8660 of 2021 stand disposed of with a direction upon the opposite parties to surrender before the Jurisdictional Court within seven days from the order failing which jurisdictional Court will take appropriate steps for their arrest.

    34. Case dairy be returned.

    Debangsu Basak, J.:— I Agree.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    SUNANDA DAS v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.
    (Apr 1, 2022)