Rajani Dubey, J.:— Present appeal is preferred against the impugned judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated 07.09.1998 passed by the learned Special Judge, First Additional, District Judge, Raipur (C.G.) in Special Case No. 66/1991 whereby, the trial court has convicted and sentenced the appellant as under:—
S. No. Conviction Sentence 1. Under Section 161 of I.P.C. R.I. for 1 year and to pay fine of Rs. 1000/-, in default of payment of fine amount further imprisonment of R.I. for 3 months 2. U/s 5(1)(d)5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act R.I. for 1 year and to pay fine of Rs. 1000/-, in default of payment of fine amount further imprisonment of R.I. for 3 months
2. Brief facts of the case are that the in the year 1988, appellant was posted as Patwari at Village-Jawalpur, District-Bilaspur. Complainant Hukumchand (PW-2) has purchased some agricultural land and when he approached for mutation of his name, appellant namely Balduram on 04.02.1988 demanded bribe of Rs. 200/- for the said mutatition. Complainant Hukumchand (PW-2) made a written complaint and approached the Special Police Establishment of the Vigilance Commissioner at Bilaspur and trap was arranged. The Special Police Establishment marked currency of Rs. 200/- with phenolphthalein powder and gave to the complainant for handing over to the appellant. Complainant went and handed over the amount of Rs. 200/- to the accused/appellant which was kept in the register. On this report, primary panchnama (Ex.P/2) was prepared and thereafter, trap party reached the spot and Rs. 200/- was recovered from the appellant. The seizure memo (Ex.P/12) was prepared and panchnama was prepared vide Ex.P/13. On the basis of Dehati Nalishi (Ex.P/16), and FIR was registered vide Ex.P/17. Spot-map was prepared vide Ex.P/19. Seized articles were sent to the FSL vide memo Ex.P/20 and, thereafter, FSL report was received vide Ex.P/21. After completion of investigation, charge-sheet was filed against the appellant and charges were framed for the offence punishable u/s 5(1)(d) 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act and u/s 161 of IPC against the appellant.
3. So as to hold the accused/appellant guilty, the prosecution has examined as many as 09 witnesses. Statement of the accused/appellant was also recorded under Section 313 of the Cr.P.C. in which he denied the charges levelled against him and pleaded his innocence and false implication in the case.
4. On the basis of oral and documentary evidence, the trial court has convicted him for the offence punishable u/s 5(1)(d) 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act and 161 of IPC and sentenced him as mentioned in para 1. Hence, this appeal filed by the appellant.
5. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the conviction and sentence passed by the trial court is erroneous and contrary to the law. The reason given by the learned trial court for accepting the evidence is quite unsound and is perverse. He submits that the prosecution has to prove its case beyond all reasonable doubt, but without any such proof the conviction is bad in law. In the present case, the chemical report also did not support the case of the prosecution. Prosecution has completely failed to prove the vase against the appellant beyond reasonable doubt, hence the appellant ought to have been acquitted. In the present case, prosecution has failed to prove the demand and acceptance, therefore, the judgment is liable to be set aside. He has also placed reliance in the matters of Heera Devi Chandra v. State of M.P. (Now C.G.) reported in 2012 (4) C.G.L.J. 455, State of M.P. (Now C.G.) v. Vijay Kumar reported in 2007 (2) C.G.L.J. 536, Baharata Ram v. The State of Madhya Pradesh (Now C.G.) passed in Criminal Appeal No. 749/1993 vide judgment dated 04.08.2010, Santosh Kumar Patnaik v. State of Chhattisgarh passed in Criminal Appeal No. 2855/1998 vide judgment dated 23.08.2013, Rajjak Miyan v. State of C.G. reported in 2013 (3) C.G.L.J. 15, Yashwant Rao Maratha v. State of M.P. (Now C.G.) reported in 2012 (1) C.G.L.J. 132.
6. Per contra, learned Counsel appearing for the State supported the impugned judgment and submits that the sentence awarded by the trial court is just and proper and requires no interference.
7. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material available on record including the impugned judgment.
8. Complainant Hukumchand (PW-2) has stated in paras 1, 6, 8 & 11 of his examination-in-chief that,
9. Panch witness R.N. Singh (PW-8) has admitted the fact that the currency notes were recovered from the register and has stated in para 11 of his cross-examination that,
10. Investigating Officer S.S. Gour (PW-9) has admitted the fact in para 14 of his cross-examination that,
11. In the present case, it is an admitted position that there is no witness to demand and acceptance of money by the appellant except the complainant. In the matter of Yashwanta Rao Maratha v. State of M.P. (Now C.G.) reported in 2012 (1) C.G.L.J. 132 in para 12, it has been held as under:
12. In Panalal Damodar Rathi v. State Of Maharashtra . reported in (1979) 4 SCC 526 : AIR 1979 SC 1191 and Gulam Mahmood A. Malek v. State Of Gujarat . reported in 1980 Supp SCC 684 : AIR 1980 SC 1558, on which the reliance has been placed by learned counsel for the appellant, the Supreme Court held that the complainant would be in no better position than accomplice after introduction of S. 165-A of the IPC and there could be no doubt that the evidence of the complainant should be corroborated in material particulars. After introduction of S. 165-A of the IPC making the person who offers bribe guilty of abetment of bribery the complainant cannot be placed on any better footing than that of an accomplice and corroboration in material particulars connecting the accused with the crime has to be insisted upon. In Panalal Damodar Rathi v. State Of Maharashtra . (supra), there was no corroboration of testimony of the complainant regarding the demand for the money by the appellant. The Supreme Court said that on this crucial aspect, therefore, it has to be found that the version of the complainant was not corroborated and, therefore, the evidence of the complainant on this aspect cannot be relied on.
13. In Trilok Chand Jain v. State of Delhi reported in (1975) 4 SCC 761 : AIR 1977 SC 666, the Supreme Court following the judgment in Mahesh Prasad Gupta v. State Of Rajasthan . reported in (1974) 3 SCC 591 : AIR 1974 SC 773, held that the degree and the character of the burden of proof which Sec. 4(1) casts on an accused person to rebut the presumption raised thereunder, cannot be equated with the degree and character of proof which under Section 101, Evidence Act rests on the prosecution. While the mere plausibility of an explanation given by the accused in his examination under Section 342, Cr.P.C. (as it then was) may not be enough, the burden on him to negate the presumption may stand discharged if the effect of the material brought on the record, in its totality, renders the existence of the fact presumed, improbable. In other words, the accused may rebut the presumption by showing a mere preponderance of probability in his favour; it is not necessary for him to establish his case beyond a reasonable doubt.
14. In the present case, defence of the appellant was that the complainant do not have any registered sale deed and he kept the currency notes in the register without his knowledge.
15. The Investigating Officer S.S. Gour (PW-9) has admitted the fact that the currency notes were recovered from the register therefore, presumption under Section 4(1) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947 was rebutted by the appellant.
16. Looking to the evidence of the prosecution witnesses, it appears that the currency notes were recovered from the register and it is also admitted by panch witness that the colour of mixture was not pink, there is no evidence and the prosecution has failed to prove the demand and acceptance of bribe by the appellant from the complainant. Mere recovery of money from the register of the appellant by itself cannot prove the charges of prosecution against the appellant in absence of any evidence to prove demand of bribe or to show that the accused/appellant voluntarily accepted the money.
17. For the above reasons, the appeal is allowed, The conviction and sentence awarded to the appellant u/s 5(1)(d) 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act and u/s 161 of IPC are set aside. The appellant is acquitted of the charges framed against him. The appellant is on bail. His bail bonds stand discharged.