Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2021 DHC 3151-DB
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Article 16(4)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2021 DHC 3151-DB
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Article 16(4)
Smart Summary

Court Opinion Summary — Manmohan, J. (Oral)

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petition challenges the respondents' selection procedure for the post of Constable (GD) in the Central Armed Police Forces (CAPFs), NIA, SSF and Rifleman (GD) in Assam Rifles insofar as it prevents a candidate from a reserved category being adjusted against the General (unreserved) vacancy if the candidate has availed any relaxation, regardless of whether that relaxation is also available to General category candidates.

The petitioner is an Other Backward Class (OBC) candidate from the border-guarding district of Uttarkashi in the Garhwal division of Uttarakhand. He applied to the Examination notified on 21 July 2018 (Constable/Rifleman (GD) Examination, 2018) conducted by the Staff Selection Commission (Respondent No.1). The petitioner qualified the computer based test and was shortlisted for the Physical Efficiency Test (PET) and Physical Standard Test (PST), where he availed relaxations in height and chest measurements applicable to candidates from Garhwal and other specified regions.

In the final result declared on 21 January 2021 the petitioner scored 73.1913, which exceeded the score of the last candidate selected in the unreserved category from his State (72.45198) but was less than the last candidate selected in the OBC (Border) category from his State (74.88390); he was not selected in either category. The writ petition was filed seeking relief from this outcome.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a reserved category candidate who avails of relaxation in physical standards that is available to all candidates from a particular region (e.g., Garhwal) should be treated as selected on general merit and therefore adjusted against unreserved vacancies when his overall merit places him above the unreserved cut‑off.
  2. Whether Clause 11(xiv) of the Examination Notification—which provides that SC/ST/OBC/ExS candidates who qualify on the basis of relaxed standards are to be counted against reserved vacancies—applies to relaxations granted on anthropological/geographical grounds that are available to all candidates from a region, or whether such regional relaxations leave the candidate to be treated as having qualified on the same standard as general candidates (and thus not to be counted against reserved vacancies) pursuant to Clause 11(xiii) and relevant administrative clarifications.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner is an OBC from Garhwal who availed height and chest relaxations specifically provided for candidates from Garhwal (and other listed communities/regions) as per Clause 9(III) of the Examination Notification.
  • Because the relaxations he availed are available to all candidates from that region irrespective of category, the petitioner contends he qualified on the same standards as general candidates and therefore ought to be accommodated against unreserved vacancies under Clause 11(xiii) when his merit exceeds the unreserved cutoff.
  • The petitioner relies on Clause 11(xiii) of the notification which provides that SC, ST, OBC and ExS candidates who are selected on their own merit without relaxed standards will not be adjusted against reserved vacancies but will be accommodated against unreserved vacancies according to overall merit.
  • Counsel argued the settled principle that a reserved category candidate who succeeds on his own merit (without “crutches”) should be treated as a general category selection and not counted against the reserved quota.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents contended that because the petitioner availed relaxed standards in height and chest measurements, Clause 11(xiv) applies and he must be counted against reserved vacancies; Clause 11(xiv) addresses SC/ST/OBC/ExS candidates who qualify by virtue of relaxed standards such as height, chest, age or other relaxations.
  • Respondents relied on the Department of Personnel & Training (DoP&T) Office Memorandum No. 36011/1/98-Estt.(Res) dated 01/07/1998, which the respondents say supports counting candidates who qualify on relaxed standards against reserved vacancies except where they qualify on the same standard as general candidates.
  • Respondents referred to settled law that candidates selected on their own merit without availing relaxations are not to be counted against reserved posts.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Indra Sawhney v. Union of India, 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217 Held that reservations under Article 16(4) do not operate like communal reservations; members of reserved categories who are selected on open competition on their own merit are not to be counted against the reserved quota but treated as open competition candidates. The court relied on this principle to support the proposition that candidates selected on the same standard as general candidates should not be adjusted against reserved vacancies.
R.K. Sabharwal v. State of Punjab, (1995) 2 SCC 745 Reiteration (as stated in the opinion) of the principle that persons selected on their own merit are not to be counted against reserved posts. Cited as a similar view reiterated by the Supreme Court; used to bolster the court's interpretation of the notification provisions.
Union of India v. Virpal Singh Chauhan, (1995) 6 SCC 684 Reiterated the principle regarding selection on merit vis-à-vis reserved quotas (as summarized in the opinion). Referenced by the court as part of the line of Supreme Court authority supporting the principle that selection on general standards places a candidate in the open category.
Ritesh R. Sah v. Dr. Y.L. Yamul, (1996) 3 SCC 253 Another Supreme Court decision (cited) reflecting the same position on selections made on merit. Relied upon as part of the consistent judicial stance cited by the respondents and considered by the court.
P.V. George v. State of Kerala, (2007) 3 SCC 557 Cited in support of the proposition that courts may grant prospective declarations of law to avoid reopening settled issues and multiplicity of proceedings. Used by the court to justify the prospective effect of its judgment in this case.
Somaiya Organics (India) Ltd. v. State of U.P., (2001) 5 SCC 519 Cited as authority for limited/prospective relief by courts in appropriate circumstances. Relied upon as one of the authorities permitting the court to mould relief and make a prospective declaration.
Gaurav Tripathi v. State of U.P., 2009 SCC OnLine All 1608 Cited among authorities regarding the exercise of prospective or limited relief by courts. Invoked by the court to support granting relief with prospective effect.
Baburam v. C C Jacob, (1999) 3 SCC 362 Cited as an authority relevant to the court's power to give limited or prospective relief. Relied upon to support the court's decision to make its declaration prospective.
DoP&T Office Memorandum No. 36011/1/98-Estt.(Res) dated 01/07/1998 Administrative clarification: only such SC/ST/OBC candidates who are selected on the same standard as applied to General candidates shall not be adjusted against reserved vacancies. The court relied on this clarification to interpret the notification provisions and to conclude that regional relaxations applicable to all candidates do not make a reserved candidate's qualification one by "relaxed standards" for the purposes of counting against reserved vacancies.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded from a textual and contextual reading of the Examination Notification provisions and the cited administrative clarification (DoP&T OM). The central analytical steps, as expressed in the opinion, are summarized below.

  1. The court examined Clause 9(III) of the Notification which sets out physical standards and specific relaxations: it observed that relaxations in height and chest measurements are provided for candidates from Garhwali, Kumaoni, Dogra, Maratha communities and candidates from certain States (Assam, Himachal Pradesh, Jammu & Kashmir). These relaxations are described as applicable to those regional/anthropological categories.
  2. The court considered the Petitioner's factual position: he availed these region-specific relaxations and obtained a score that was higher than the last unreserved candidate from his State but lower than the last reserved (OBC-Border) selection.
  3. The court contrasted Clause 11(xiii) and Clause 11(xiv) of the Examination Notification. Clause 11(xiii) provides that SC/ST/OBC/ExS candidates selected on their own merit without relaxed standards will be accommodated against unreserved vacancies; Clause 11(xiv) states that SC/ST/OBC/ExS candidates who qualify on the basis of relaxed standards (including height/chest) are to be counted against reserved vacancies.
  4. The court deployed the DoP&T Office Memorandum of 01/07/1998 which clarifies that only SC/ST/OBC candidates who are selected on the same standard as applied to General candidates shall not be adjusted against reserved vacancies. The court took this as an administrative clarification that a candidate who qualifies on the same standard as general candidates (even if region-specific relaxations exist for all candidates from that region) should not be counted against reserved vacancies.
  5. Applying these provisions and the administrative clarification, the court concluded that the height and chest relaxations availed by the petitioner are regional/anthropological relaxations available to all candidates from the Garhwal region, including those belonging to the unreserved category; there are no height/chest relaxations specifically provided to OBCs in Clause 9(III).
  6. Therefore, the court found the respondents' interpretation—that any reserved category candidate who avails a relaxation must be counted against reserved vacancies—untenable in law in the present circumstances. The court agreed with a predecessor bench's prima facie interpretation that Clause 11(xiv) refers to relaxations by virtue of being SC/ST/OBC/Ex‑Servicemen (i.e., relaxations uniquely available to those categories) and not to region-specific relaxations available to all candidates from a region.
  7. The court also noted the inequity that would follow if the respondents' position were accepted: a reserved category candidate could be placed at a disadvantage as compared to the identical candidate if he had registered as unreserved from the region. The court held this to be contrary to the intention behind providing region-based relaxations.
  8. Finally, having declared the relevant legal position in the petitioner's favour, the court considered the remedy. Observing that training of selected candidates had already commenced, the court invoked the doctrine of prospective declarations (and relied on authorities cited) and exercised its equity jurisdiction to mould relief so as to avoid disturbing the selection list to date while ensuring that remaining vacancies are filled in accordance with the law stated by the court.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is allowed; the court declared that region/anthropology-based relaxations (such as those for Garhwal) that are available to all candidates from that region do not automatically render a reserved category candidate's selection one "on relaxed standards" for the purposes of counting against reserved vacancies.

Implications / Practical Effect

  • The immediate, direct effect: the judgment is given prospective effect. The court directed that the existing list of selected candidates declared till the date of this judgment shall not be disturbed because training has already commenced.
  • The vacancies that remain to be filled going forward shall be filled in accordance with a revised list prepared in conformity with the law as declared by this Court in the present judgment (i.e., treating candidates who qualified by region-specific relaxations available to all as not having qualified by category‑specific relaxed standards and therefore to be considered for unreserved vacancies when their overall merit so requires).
  • The court noted that no broader retrospective reopening of selection is ordered; the relief is tailored to avoid multiplicity and disruption, consistent with the authorities cited on prospective declarations and limited relief.

Disposition: The writ petition along with pending application stands disposed of in the terms set out above.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Hemant Pokhriyal v. Staff Selection Commission And Others

    Manmohan, J. (Oral):— Present writ petition has been filed challenging the selection procedure of the respondents for the post of Constable (GD) in the Central Armed Police Forces (CAPFs), NIA, SSF and Rifleman (GD) in Assam Rifles insofar as it debars a candidate from the reserved category from being adjusted against the General vacancy if the candidate has availed any relaxation irrespective of the fact that such relaxation is also available to the General category candidates.

    ARGUMENTS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER

    2. Learned Counsel for the petitioner states that the petitioner belongs to Other Backward Class (OBC) from the border guarding district of Uttarkashi, under the Garhwal division of Uttarakhand. He further states that the Petitioner applied for the post of Constable (GD) in the Central Armed Police Forces (CAPFs), MA, SSF and Rifleman (GD) in Assam Rifles (AR) Examination, 2018 held by the Respondent No. 1, Staff Selection Commission (SSC), pursuant to the Notification dated 21 July, 2018.

    3. He further states that the Petitioner qualified in the computer based examination and was shortlisted for the Physical Efficiency Test (PET) and Physical Standard Test (PST) in which he availed the relaxations in the standards of height and chest as available to all the male candidates falling in the categories of Garhwalis, Kumaonis, Dogras, Marathas and candidates belonging to the States of Assam, Himachal Pradesh and Jammu and Kashmir. These relaxations as provided vis-a-vis general candidates by Clause 9(111) of the Examination Notification are reproduced below:—

    III. Physical Standard Test (PST):—

    Physical standard laid down for the post of Constable/Rifleman are:

    a. Height Height (in cms) Male Female General SC & OBC candidates (except those mentioned below) 170 157 Relaxations:— The minimum height for the candidates falling in the categories of Garhwalis, Kumaonis, Dogras, Marathas and candidates belonging to the States of Assam, Himchal Pradesh and Jammu and Kashmir 165 155 b. Chest: Chest (in cms : unexpanded/minimum expansion) General, SC & OBC male candidates (except those mentioned below) 80/5 N/A Relaxations:— The minimum chest for male candidates falling in the categories of Garhwalis, Kumaonis, Dogras, Marathas and candidates belonging to the State of Assam, Himachal Pradesh and Jammu & Kashmir. 78/5 N/A

    (emphasis supplied)

    4. Learned counsel for the Petitioner states that in the final result that was declared by the respondents on 21 January, 2021, the Petitioner had scored 73.1913 which, though more than the score secured by the last candidate selected in the unreserved category from his state (72.45198), was less than the score secured by the last candidate selected in the OBC (Border) category from his state (74.88390). He states that the Petitioner was not selected in either of the categories.

    5. He states that subsequently it was revealed that the Petitioner was not accommodated in the un-reserved category because he had availed relaxation in the measurement of height and chest during the Physical Standard Test (PST). He submits that the relaxation that the Petitioner had availed was available not only for the OBC candidates but for all the candidates from the Garhwal area irrespective of their category. He states that since the relaxation availed by the Petitioner was also available to the candidates from the unreserved category, the petitioner should have been included in the final selection list of the unreserved category, having scored more than the cut-off. He contends that the Petitioner should have been considered in pursuance to Clause 11 (xiii) of the notification which reads as under:

    “(xiii) SC, ST, OBC and ExS candidates, who are selected on their own merit without relaxed standards, along with candidates belonging to other communities, will not be adjusted against the reserved share of vacancies. Such candidates will be accommodated against the unreserved vacancies as per their position in the overall Merit List. The reserved vacancies will be filled up separately from amongst the eligible SC, ST, OBC and ExS candidates.”

    (emphasis supplied)

    6. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner states that if a candidate of the reserved category performs better than a candidate of the general category without the ‘aid of any crutches’ then his selection is on the basis of merit and not on the basis of reservation and he shall have to be treated as a general category candidate because he makes it on his own merit and not by reason of the category to whom he/she belongs.

    ARGUMENTS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS

    7. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents contends that since the petitioner had availed the relaxed standards in height and chest measurement, he had to be considered in the category as per the provisions contained in Clause 11(xiv) and not under Clause 11(xiii) of the Examination Notification which reads as under:

    “(xiv) SC, ST, OBC and ExS candidate who qualifies on the basis of relaxed standards viz. age limit, height and chest measurement, experience or qualifications, permitted number of chances, extended zone of consideration larger than what is provided for general category candidate etc., irrespective of his/her merit position, such SC, ST, OBC and ExS candidates is to be counted against reserved vacancies. In so far as cases of ex-serviceman are concerned, deduction of the military service rendered from the age of ex-servicemen is permissible against the reserved or unreserved posts and such exemption cannot be termed as relaxed standards in regard to age.”

    (emphasis supplied)

    8. He states that the height & chest of the petitioner is less than the physical standards fixed for common recruitment test of CT(GD) in CAPFs & Assam Rifles, NIA and SSF and he has been declared qualified in the physical standard on relaxed standards as per the provisions contained in Clause 9(111) of the Notification on anthropological or geographical grounds. He further states that as per DOP&T OM No. 36011/l/98-Estt.(Res) dated 01/07/1998, only the SC/ST/OBC candidates who are selected on their own merits without relaxed standards, along with candidates of other communities will not be adjusted in the reserved vacancies.

    WHEN A CANDIDATE GETS SELECTED FOR APPOINTMENT TO A POST ON THE BASIS OF HIS OWN MERIT AND WITHOUT AVAILING THE RELAXATIONS THAT ARE AVAILABLE, THEN HIS SELECTION WOULD NOT BE COUNTED AGAINST THE RESERVED POST PARA IKXIIDOF THE EXAMINATION NOTICE ALSO STATES SO.

    9. It is settled law that when a candidate gets selected for admission or for appointment to a post on the basis of his own merit and without availing the relaxations that are available to them, then his selection would not be counted against the reserved post.

    10. In Indra Sawhney v. Union of India 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217, the Supreme Court has held as under:—

    ““[It] is well to remember that the reservations under Article 16(4) do not operate like a communal reservation. It may well happen that some members belonging to, say, Scheduled Castes get selected in the open competition field on the basis of their own merit; they will not be counted against the quota reserved for Scheduled Castes; they will be treated as open competition candidates.”

    11. A similar view has been reiterated by the Supreme Court in R.K. Sabharwal v. State of Punjab, (1995) 2 SCC 745; Union of India v. Virpal Singh Chauhan, (1995) 6 SCC 684; Ritesh R. Sah v. Dr. Y.L. Yamul, (1996) 3 SCC 253.

    12. This Court also finds that the examination notice in para 11(xiii) specifies that if a SC, ST, OBC and Ex-Serviceman are selected on their own merit and without any relaxed standards relatable to aforesaid categories or without consideration larger than what is provided for General category, then the candidate is not to be adjusted against the reserved vacancies.

    RELAXATIONS IN MEASUREMENT OF HEIGHT AND CHEST ARE AVAILABLE TO ALL THE CANDIDATES FROM GARHWAL REGION WHETHER THE CANDIDATE BELONGS TO A RESERVED OR UNRESERVED CATEGORY. PARA 11 (XIV) CLEARLY STATES THAT WHEN A RESERVED CATEGORY CANDIDATE IS SELECTED ON THE SAME STANDARD AS APPLICABLE TO A GENERAL CANDIDATE THEN HE SHALL NOT BE ADJUSTED AGAINST RESERVED VACANCIES

    13. This Court is of the view that the relaxations in measurement of height and chest are available to all the candidates from Garhwal Region or other specified regions whether the candidate belongs to a reserved or unreserved category. There is specific relaxation for Scheduled Tribes, but no relaxation with regard to height or chest is provided specifically to OBCs.

    14. The respondent No. 1's interpretation that since the petitioner is an OBC category candidate and has availed relaxation in measurement in the standards of height and chest which is available to a Garhwali candidate, he cannot be considered in unreserved category by virtue of para 11(xiv) is untenable in law as the instructions and the clarification clearly state that when a reserved category candidate is selected on the same standard as applicable to a General candidate then he shall not be adjusted against reserved vacancies. It is only when a candidate avails relaxations that are not otherwise available to the candidates of the unreserved category that he is to be considered in his category.

    15. The Office Memorandum dated 1 July, 1998 issued by the Ministry of Personnel, PG & Pensions, Department of Personnel & Training clarifies the position. It states as under:—

    “3. In this connection, it is clarified that only such SC/ST/OBC candidates who are selected on the same standard as applied to General candidates shall not be adjusted against reserved vacancies.”

    (emphasis supplied)

    16. In the present case the height and chest relaxations that have been availed by the Petitioner are available to all the candidates belonging to the Garhwal region. In fact, there are no height and chest relaxations provided for the candidates belonging to the OBC category in Clause 9(111) of the Notification and they are to be considered along with the General candidates.

    17. Even the learned predecessor bench in the order dated 02 August, 2021 had observed as under:—

    “We are prima facie of the opinion that when Clause 11 (xiv) of the Examination Notice supra refers to Scheduled Castes (SC), Scheduled Tribes (ST), OBC and Ex-Servicemen candidates who have qualified on the basis of relaxed standards, the same refers to the relaxation by virtue of being SC, ST, OBC or Ex-Servicemen and not relaxation given to candidates from particular States/region inasmuch as the said relaxations are available to all candidates from that region/State, even those belonging to the Unreserved category.”

    18. This Court respectfully agrees with the said interpretation.

    IF THIS COURT WERE TO ACCEPT THE ARGUMENT OF THE RESPONDENTS IN THE PRESENT CASE, THE FACT THAT THE PETITIONER BELONGS TO A RESERVED CATEGORY INSTEAD OF WORKING TO HIS BENEFIT WOULD RATHER WORK TO HIS DISADVANTAGE.

    19. Moreover, if this Court were to accept the arguments of the respondents in the present case, the fact that the petitioner belongs to a reserved category instead of working to his benefit would rather work to his disadvantage as he would have been better off (selected for the post) if he had registered for the exam as a General category candidate from the Garhwal region. This would however, be completely contrary to the intention of the legislators/administrator while making provisions for relaxations for certain categories.

    RELIEF MOULDED; JUDGMENT WOULD HAVE PROSPECTIVE EFFECT

    20. Consequently, the present petition is allowed. However, this Court is of the view that in the present case, as training of the selected candidates has already commenced, it would not be proper to direct the respondents to redraw the result in its entirety. After all, it is settled law that the prospective declaration of law is a devise innovated by the Apex Court to avoid reopening of settled issues and to prevent multiplicity of proceedings. Even the High Courts in exercise of their equity jurisdiction without applying the doctrine of prospective over-ruling, indisputably can grant a limited relief. [See : P.V. George v. State of Kerala, (2007) 3 SCC 557; Somaiya Organics (India) Ltd. v. State of U.P., (2001) 5 SCC 519; Gaurav Tripathi v. State of U.P., 2009 SCC OnLine All 1608 and Baburam v. C C Jacob, (1999) 3 SCC 362.]

    21. Accordingly, this Court directs that the present judgment would have prospective effect i.e. it would not disturb the list of selected candidates till date. However, the vacancies that remain to be filled, shall be filled in accordance with the revised list, that should be prepared in accordance with the law declared by this Court in the present judgment. With the aforesaid directions, the writ petition along with pending application stands disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Hemant Pokhriyal v. Staff Selection Commission And Others
    (Oct 1, 2021)