Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Constitution of India
  • Section 212(1)(c) of the Companies Act, 2013
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Constitution of India
  • Section 212(1)(c) of the Companies Act, 2013
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Petitioner, a Chartered Accountant, was appointed as a Non-Executive Independent Director on the Board of M/s. Techpro Systems Limited in 2007 and resigned in January 2015 due to employment and health reasons. Corporate Insolvency Resolution Proceedings were initiated against the company in 2017, with a Resolution Plan approved in 2019. In January 2021, a Look Out Circular (LOC) was issued against the Petitioner by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs and the Serious Fraud Investigation Office (SFIO). The Petitioner, who works in Oman, traveled to India in February 2021 but was stopped from leaving the country due to the LOC. He was summoned by the SFIO to appear for investigation. The Petitioner challenged the LOC seeking its quashing and interim relief in this petition. The matter is at the interim stage with pleadings yet to be completed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Look Out Circular issued against the Petitioner, in absence of a registered FIR or cognizable offence, is liable to be quashed.
  2. Whether the interim stay of the LOC should be granted, considering the Petitioner's right to travel and the ongoing investigation.
  3. The applicability and interpretation of the Office Memoranda dated 27 October 2010 and its amendment dated 5 December 2017 governing issuance of LOCs.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The Petitioner was not provided a copy of the LOC despite its issuance.
  • Reliance on Office Memoranda dated 27 October 2010 and 5 December 2017, which require an FIR or cognizable offence for issuance of LOC.
  • The LOC curtails the fundamental right to travel and should be quashed in absence of FIR or cognizable offence.
  • The Petitioner was a Non-Executive Independent Director with no role in day-to-day management, and cannot be held liable for the company’s alleged wrongdoing.
  • The Petitioner’s family and immovable properties are based in Delhi/NCR, reducing any flight risk.
  • The Petitioner’s travel to India was for employment purposes, and he was stopped from returning to Oman without prior notice of the LOC.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The Petitioner is alleged to have connived and conspired with the promoters in a large-scale fraud involving thousands of crores.
  • The Petitioner, as a Chartered Accountant and member of the Audit Committee, had obligations and responsibilities in the listed company.
  • The LOC was issued as part of multiple LOCs against promoters and directors of the company, justified due to the ongoing investigation and seriousness of allegations.
  • The Petitioner should not be allowed to travel abroad during the investigation.
  • A sealed note detailing the status of the investigation was submitted to the Court, confirming the ongoing nature of the inquiry.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sumer Singh Salkan v. Asst. Director [WP(Crl) No. 1315/2005, decided 11 August 2010] LOC can only be issued when FIR is registered or a cognizable offence is made out; requirement of stating reason in LOC; protection of fundamental right to travel. Used to establish that the LOC against the Petitioner is invalid as no FIR exists and no reason was provided in the LOC.
Nitin Sandesara v. Directorate of Enforcement [WP(C) 7559/2017, Order dated 29 August 2018] Office Memorandum dated 27 October 2010 mandates that LOCs are to be issued only in cognizable offences; no detention/arrest or travel restrictions without such basis. Reinforced that the absence of a reason in the LOC and the lack of a cognizable offence against the Petitioner invalidates the LOC.
Deept Sarup Aggarwal v. Union of India [WP(C) 5382/2020, decided 2 December 2020] LOC cannot be issued merely on the basis of ‘economic interest’ of India; strict conditions apply for issuance of LOCs as per the amended Office Memorandum. Supported the Court’s view that the Petitioner’s LOC was improperly issued without meeting the criteria of the amended guidelines.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the issuance of the LOC against the Petitioner in light of the Office Memorandum dated 27 October 2010 and its amendment dated 5 December 2017, which regulate the issuance of LOCs. The Court noted that these memoranda require a cognizable offence or FIR to be present and a specific reason to be stated in the LOC. The LOC issued against the Petitioner lacked any stated reason and no FIR had been registered against him. The Court emphasized the serious impact of an LOC on the fundamental right to travel and held that such restriction cannot be imposed lightly or without proper justification.

Reliance on precedents including Sumer Singh Salkan, Nitin Sandesara, and Deept Sarup Aggarwal established that LOCs must adhere to strict procedural and substantive safeguards. The Court found that the Petitioner’s role as a Non-Executive Independent Director, with no proven involvement in the alleged fraud, and his strong ties to India via family and property, reduced any flight risk. The Court expressed concern over the absence of notice to the Petitioner regarding the LOC, despite his cooperation with the investigation.

Balancing the Petitioner's rights and the ongoing investigation, the Court decided to suspend the operation of the LOC subject to conditions including periodic reporting to the Indian Embassy, undertaking to appear before authorities on notice, restrictions on transfer of immovable properties, and travel restrictions on the Petitioner's wife.

Holding and Implications

The Court disposed of the application for interim stay by suspending the operation of the LOC against the Petitioner subject to specific conditions designed to safeguard the investigation while protecting the Petitioner's rights.

The decision directly affects the parties by allowing the Petitioner to travel abroad while cooperating with the investigation under court-imposed conditions. The Court explicitly stated that this order is passed on the peculiar facts of the case and shall not be treated as a precedent applicable to other Directors of M/s. Techpro Systems Limited. No broader legal precedent was established beyond the case-specific relief granted.

    Brij Bhushan Kathuria v. Union Of India And Others

    Prathiba M. Singh, J. (Oral):— This hearing has been done through Video Conferencing.

    CM APPL. 10253/2021 (for interim stay)

    2. The Petitioner in the present petition has challenged the Look Out Circular (hereinafter, ‘LOC’) issued against him by Respondent Nos. 3 and 4 i.e., the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (hereinafter, ‘MCA’) and the Serious Fraud Investigation Office (hereinafter, ‘SFIO’) and prays for the same to be quashed.

    3. The brief background of the matter is that the Petitioner is a Chartered Accountant who was inducted in the Board of M/s. Techpro Systems Limited, as a Non-Executive Independent Director, in the Annual General Meeting dated 26 September 2007. The Petitioner is working in Oman and relocated there on 24 October, 2009. He is stated to have resigned from the post of Independent Director of M/s. Techpro Systems Limited on 13 January, 2015 due to his full time employment in Oman and health concerns. In 2017, Corporate Insolvency Resolution Proceedings were initiated against M/s. Techpro Systems Limited, and on 5 May 2019, the Resolution Plan was approved by the NCLT.

    4. The case of the Petitioner is that he had travelled to India on 2 February, 2021 and was scheduled to fly back to Oman on 21 February, 2021. However, he was stopped at the airport and was intimated about the LOC which has been issued against him at the behest of the SFIO. The Petitioner was thereafter issued summons bearing F. No. SFIO/INV/TSL/1304/2020 by the SFIO on 23 February 2021, through WhatsApp, to personally appear before the Investigating Officer on 2 March, 2021.

    5. This matter was heard in part on 17 March, 2021. Ms. Maninder Acharya, ld. Sr. Counsel, submits on behalf of the Petitioner that a copy of the LOC has not been given to the Petitioner. Reliance is placed upon Office Memorandum dated 27 October, 2010 and the amendments carried out therein vide Office Memorandum dated 5 December, 2017. It is submitted that the settled position in law is that unless and until an FIR is registered or a cognizable offence is made out, the LOC would be liable to be quashed or set aside, as it curtails the liberty of the Petitioner to travel in and out of India. Reliance is placed on the following three judgments/orders:

    • Sumer Singh Salkan v. Asst. Director [WP(Crl.) No. 1315/2005, decided on 11 August 2010];

    • Nitin Sandesara v. Directorate of Enforcement [WP(C) 7559/2017, Order dated 29 August 2018] and;

    • Deept Sarup Aggarwal v. Union of India [WP(C) 5382/2020, decided on 2 December 2020].

    6. It is further submitted that the Petitioner's entire family resides in Delhi/NCR. The wife of the Petitioner is a Senior citizen who lives in Delhi/NCR. Both his daughters also live in Delhi/NCR. Out of the two daughters, one of the daughters is married. The younger daughter is unmarried and lives with the Petitioner and his wife. The Petitioner also has several immovable properties in Delhi/NCR. Details of the bank accounts and bank statements of the Petitioner and his two daughters have already been submitted to the SFIO.

    7. It is argued on behalf of the Petitioner that the Petitioner was only a Non-Executive Independent Director in M/s. Techpro Systems Limited from 2007 to 2015 and has no role to play in the day to day management of the company. None of the allegations against the company or its promoters can be saddled upon the Petitioner.

    8. On behalf of the Respondents, a note has been handed over in a sealed cover on the status of the investigation. This Court has perused the said note. The overall allegations being confidential in nature, it is merely recorded that the investigation is currently on going. The Petitioner has also appeared before the SFIO on various dates and made detailed statements on oath, which have also been placed on record.

    9. The submission of Mr. Rakesh Kumar, ld. counsel appearing for the Respondents, is that the Petitioner is guilty of conniving and conspiring with the Promoters of M/s. Techpro Systems Limited. It is submitted that the Petitioner is a Chartered Accountant and was part of the Audit Committee. The fraud in the present case, according to the Respondents, is of several thousands of crores and accordingly, the Petitioner ought not to be permitted to travel abroad. It is further submitted that there are six to seven LOCs which have been issued against the Promoters and Directors of M/s. Techpro Systems Limited and the LOC issued against the Petitioner is only one of them. M/s. Techpro Systems Limited is a listed company and Independent Directors have a greater obligation in such companies. Thus, it is submitted that the Petitioner ought not to be permitted to travel abroad, outside the jurisdiction of this Court.

    10. At this stage, the Court is merely considering the question as to whether the LOC deserves to be stayed i.e., whether the interim relief is to be granted. The pleadings are yet to be completed. The admitted facts, insofar as the Petitioner is concerned, are as under:—

    (i) The Petitioner is employed in Oman. His certificate of employment has been placed on record and he has been working there since 2009.

    (ii) The Petitioner's wife and children reside in Delhi NCR.

    (iii) The Petitioner has several immovable properties in Delhi/NCR, a list of which has been submitted to the SFIO.

    (iv) The Petitioner has been asked by his employer in Oman to immediately join back duty.

    11. It is submitted that the Petitioner's travel to India was part of his employment and he was stopped from travelling back to Oman on 21 February, 2021. The LOC has admittedly been issued in January, 2021. However, the Petitioner was not given notice of the same. The Petitioner entered India on his own volition and not in response to any summons by the SFIO.

    12. Heard. The MCA, vide order dated 10 August, 2020, commenced investigation against M/s. Techpro Systems Limited under Section 212(1)(c) of the Companies Act, 2013, pursuant to which the LOC was issued. Issuance of LOCs is currently under the Office Memorandum issued by the Ministry of Home Affairs i.e., dated 27 October, 2010 along with the amendment dated 5 December, 2017. The legal position in respect of LOCs is governed by the judgment of this Court in Sumer Singh Salkan (supra), which is relied upon by the Petitioner. The position prior to the issuance of the two Office Memoranda was that recourse to the LOC can only be taken when there is a cognizable offence under the IPC/other penal law. The reason for opening the LOC also had to be provided in the said LOC.

    13. A perusal of the LOC, which had been placed on record in a sealed cover, shows that in so far as the Petitioner is concerned, no reason has been specifically mentioned in the LOC.

    14. Office Memorandum dated 27 October, 2010 is extremely clear that a reason has to be given for opening the LOC. The fact that there is no reason provided in the present case is quite telling. Moreover, at this point of time, there is also no FIR lodged against the Petitioner and even the role of the Petitioner is under investigation. Under such circumstances, the question is whether the Petitioner's everyday life can be put on a standstill. An LOC has the effect of seriously jeopardising the right to travel of an individual. The settled legal position, as per the judgment in Sumer Singh Salkan (supra) is that unless and until there is an FIR which is lodged or a criminal case which is pending, an LOC cannot be issued.

    15. In Nitin Sandesara (supra), Office Memorandum dated 27 October, 2010 was considered by a learned Single Judge. The ld. Single Judge of this Court had, in the said case, also observed as under:—

    “11. Mr. Kripal, learned counsel for the petitioner has also drawn the attention of this court to the Office Memorandum (OM) dated 27.10.2010 which refers to the judgement dated 11.08.2010 passed by this court in Sumer Singh Salkan v. Asst. Director W.P. (Crl) no. 1315/2008 and sets down the guidelines for issuance of LOC. Paragraph 8(g) and (h) of the said OM are relevant and are set out below:—

    “8. In accordance with the order dated 26.7.2010 of the High Court of Delhi, the matter has been discussed with the concerned agencies and the following guidelines are hereby laid down regarding issuance of LOCs in respect of Indian citizens and foreigners:

    xxxx xxxx xxxx

    g) Recourse to LOC is to be taken in cognizable offences under IPC or other penal laws. The details in column IV in the enclosed proforma regarding ‘reason for opening LOC’ must invariably be provided without which the subject of an LOC will not be arrested/detained.

    h) In cases where there is no cognizable offence under IPC or other penal laws, the LOC subject cannot be detained/arrested or prevented from leaving the country. The originating agency can only request that they be informed about the arrival/departure of the subject in such cases.

    Xxxx xxxx xxxx”

    12. In the present case, the LOC does not indicate any credible reason for issuing the same. Plainly, recourse to LOC cannot be taken as a matter of course; restricting the right of a citizen to travel is a serious imposition on his/her fundamental rights and even if it is assumed that such action is permissible in law, it can be taken only when necessary and for good reason.

    13. This Court also finds it difficult to understand the conduct of the officers of the Enforcement Directorate. Admittedly, the petitioner had joined the investigations and had appeared before the concerned officers as required by them. Notwithstanding the same, a request for LOC was issued and the petitioner was not even informed of such LOC. Notwithstanding the legality or validity of the LOC, the petitioner would have taken that into account before making his travel plans. The petitioner became aware of the LOC at 11.00 PM on 22.08.2017, when he was about to board a flight.”

    16. Recently, in Deept Sarup Aggarwal (supra), the amendment dated 5 December, 2017 to the Office Memorandum dated 27 October, 2010, which contains the amended clause, was also considered by the Court. The Court held that an LOC cannot be issued in every case by claiming that the same would affect the ‘economic interest’ of India.

    17. The relevant clauses of the Office Memorandum dated 27 October, 2010, as well as the amended Office Memorandum dated 5 December, 2017 by which clause ‘j’ was amended, are set out herein below:

    Office Memorandum dated 27th October, 2010

    “g) Recourse to LOC is to be taken in cognizable offences under IPC or other penal laws. The details in column IV in the enclosed proforma regarding ‘reason for opening LOC’ must invariably be provided without which the subject of an LOC will not be arrested/detained.

    h) In cases where there is no cognizable offence under IPC or other penal laws, the LOC subject cannot be detained/arrested or prevented from leaving the country. The originating agency can only request that they be informed about the arrival/departure of the subject in such cases.

    j) In exceptional cases, LOCs can be issued without complete parameters and/or case details against CI suspects, terrorists, anti/national elements etc. in larger national interest.”

    Office Memorandum dated 27th October, 2010, as amended on 5th December, 2017

    “Amendment-

    “In exceptional cases, LOCs can be issued even in such cases, as would not be covered by the guidelines above, whereby departure of a person from India may be declined at the request of any of the authorities mentioned in clause (b) of the above-referred OM, if it appears to such authority based on inputs received that the departure of such person is detrimental to the sovereignty or security or integrity of Indian or that the same is detrimental to the bilateral relations with any country or to the strategic and/or economic interests of India or if such person is allowed to leave, he may potentially indulge in an act of terrorism or offences against the State and/or that such departure ought not be permitted in the larger public interest at any given point in time.”

    Instead of:

    “In exceptional cases, LOCs can be issued without complete parameters and/or case details against CI suspects, terrorists, anti/national elements etc. in larger national interest.”

    18. It is clear from a perusal of clauses (g), (h) and (j) that unless and until the conditions in these clauses are satisfied, prima-facie an LOC cannot be opened.

    19. There is no criminal case pending against the Petitioner. His role is also yet to be ascertained by the investigating authorities. Phrases such as ‘economic interest’ or ‘larger public interest’ cannot be expanded in a manner so as to include an Independent Director who was in the past associated with the company being investigated, without any specific role being attributed to him, as in the present case. The Petitioner poses no flight risk given the fact that his wife and children are residents of Delhi/NCR. This Court is inclined to suspend the operation of the LOC, subject to the following conditions:—

    (i) The Petitioner shall present himself in the Indian Embassy in Oman on the 1 and 3 Monday of every month.

    (ii) The Petitioner shall file an undertaking in this Court, which would be supported with an undertaking by his wife, that the Petitioner would be present before the authorities upon being issued 15 days' notice.

    (iii) Insofar as the immovable properties are concerned, the immovable properties in the list emailed to the Court Master today i.e. at items 1 to 4, shall not be transferred/alienated by the Petitioner/his family, who may have rights in the same. Copies of the documents relating to the properties shall be filed in Court in a sealed cover within two weeks.

    (iv) The Petitioner's wife shall not leave India without seeking leave from the Court.

    20. Application is disposed of. This order has been passed in the peculiar facts of this case and shall not be taken as being applicable to any other Director of M/s. Techpro Systems Limited.

    W.P. (C) 3374/2021

    21. Counter affidavit be filed within six weeks. Rejoinder be filed within four weeks thereafter.

    22. Both the sealed envelopes shall be retained in sealed covers and tagged with the physical record. The same shall not be scanned.

    23. List on 13 August, 2021.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Brij Bhushan Kathuria v. Union Of India And Others
    (Apr 15, 2021)