Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 374 CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE
  • SECTION 313 CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE
  • Sections 147 , 436 r/w 149, 302 r/w 149, 323 r/w 149 and 323 (Two counts) r/w 149 of IPC
  • Sections 147, 148, 323, 436, 336 and 302 of IPC and Sections 3(2) (iv) and 3(2) (v) of the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989.
  • Indian Penal Code and Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989
  • Sections 148, 436 r/w 149 and 302 of IPC; (iii) A6 to A9
  • Sections 323 r/w 149 against 323 (Two counts) r/w 149 of IPC and insofar as A10, A12, A13 to A15
  • Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Sections 147, 436 r/w 149 and 302 r/w 149 of IPC
  • Sections 148, 302 and 436 of IPC; (ii) A3 to A5
  • Section 323 r/w 149 of IPC
  • Sections 147, 148, 436, 323, 326 and 302 of IPC
  • Sections 147 , 436 r/w 149, 302 r/w 149, 323 r/w 149 and 323 (Two counts) r/w 149 of IPC stand set aside. A10, A12, A13 to A15
  • Sections 148, 436 r/w 149 and 302 of IPC; and A6 to A9
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 374 CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE
  • SECTION 313 CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE
  • Sections 147 , 436 r/w 149, 302 r/w 149, 323 r/w 149 and 323 (Two counts) r/w 149 of IPC
  • Sections 147, 148, 323, 436, 336 and 302 of IPC and Sections 3(2) (iv) and 3(2) (v) of the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989.
  • Indian Penal Code and Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989
  • Sections 148, 436 r/w 149 and 302 of IPC; (iii) A6 to A9
  • Sections 323 r/w 149 against 323 (Two counts) r/w 149 of IPC and insofar as A10, A12, A13 to A15
  • Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Sections 147, 436 r/w 149 and 302 r/w 149 of IPC
  • Sections 148, 302 and 436 of IPC; (ii) A3 to A5
  • Section 323 r/w 149 of IPC
  • Sections 147, 148, 436, 323, 326 and 302 of IPC
  • Sections 147 , 436 r/w 149, 302 r/w 149, 323 r/w 149 and 323 (Two counts) r/w 149 of IPC stand set aside. A10, A12, A13 to A15
  • Sections 148, 436 r/w 149 and 302 of IPC; and A6 to A9

    Ravi @ Gopu & Others v. State represented by. The Dy. Superintendent of Police, Nannilam Sub Division, Tiruvarur District

    (Memorandum of Grounds of Criminal Appeals under Section 374(2) of the Criminal Procedure Code against the judgment dated 29.05.2001 made in S.C.No.17 of 2000 on the file of the learned II Additional Sessions Judge (Protection of Civil Rights), Thanjavur.)

    D. Murugesan, J.

    Both the appeals arise from the judgment of conviction and sentence in S.C.No. 17 of 2000 on the file of the II Additional District and Sessions Judge (Protection of Civil Rights), Thanjavur. Criminal Appeal No.484 of 2001 is filed by A13 in Sessions Case No.17 of 2000 on the file of the II Additional District and Sessions Judge (Protection of Civil Rights), Thanjavur while Criminal Appeal No. 586 of 2001 is filed by A1 to A10, A12, A14 and A15 in the very same Sessions Case and in all 24 accused were put on trial on various charges under Indian Penal Code and Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 as detailed below:-

    Charge No.
    Accused
    Charged Under Section

    1
    A6 to A24
    U/s.147 of IPC

    2
    A1 to A5
    U/s.148
    of IPC

    3
    A1 and A2
    U/s.436
    of IPC

    4
    A3 to A24
    U/s.436 r/w 149 of IPC

    5
    A1 and A2
    U/s.3(2
    ) (iv) of SC and ST Act

    6
    A3 to A24
    U/s.3(2
    ) (iv) of SC and ST Act r/w 149 of IPC

    7
    A1 and A2
    U/s.3(2
    ) (iv) of SC and ST Act

    8
    A3 to A24
    U/s.3(2
    ) (iv) of SC and ST Act r/w 149 of IPC

    9
    A1 to A5
    U/s.302
    of IPC

    10
    A6 to A24
    U/s.302 r/w 149 of IPC

    11
    A1 to A5
    U/s.3(2)(V) of SC & ST Act

    12
    A6 to A24
    U/s.3(2
    )(V) of SC & ST Act r/w 149 of IPC

    13
    A11, A13, A15, A17, A18 and A23
    U/s.323 of IPC

    14
    A1 to A10, A12, A14, A16, A19 to A22 and A24
    U/s.32
    3 r/w 149 of IPC

    15
    A11, A13, A15, A17, A18 and A23
    U/s.323(2 counts) of IPC

    16
    A1 to A10, A12, A14, A16, A19 to A22 and A24
    U/s.32
    3 r/w 149 (2
    counts) of IPC


    2. The learned Sessions Judge, Special Court (PCR) after full trial acquitted A11, A16 to A24 while, found guilty A1 to A10, A12 to A15 alone, convicted and sentenced them under various offences as detailed below:-

    Accused
    Conviction
    Sentence

    A6 to A10

    A12 to A15
    U/s.147
    of IPC
    Each of the accused to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 1 year

    A1 to A5
    U/s.148
    of IPC
    Each of the accused to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 2 years



    A1 and A2
    U/s.436
    of IPC
    Each of the accused to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 10 years



    A3 to A10

    and

    A12 to A15
    U/s.436 r/w 149
    of IPC
    Each of the accused to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 10 years

    A1 to A5
    U/s.302
    of IPC
    Each of the accused to undergo imprisonment for life





    A6 to A10

    and

    A12 to A15
    U/s.302 r/w 149
    of IPC
    Each of the accused to undergo imprisonment for life

    A15
    U/s.323
    of IPC
    Each of the accused to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 6 months



    A1 to A10

    and

    A12 to A14
    U/s.323 r/w 149
    of IPC
    Each of the accused to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 6 months

    A15
    U/s.323
    (2
    counts) of IPC
    Each of the accused to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 6 months on each count



    A1 to A10

    and

    A12 to A14
    U/s.323 (2
    counts) r/w 149 of IPC
    Each of the accused to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 6 months on each count


    * All the sentences were ordered to run concurrently.

    3. Challenging the above said conviction and sentence, the convicts viz., A1 to A10, A12, A14, A15 and A13 preferred these appeals respectively.

    4. The appellants along with other accused were put on trial on the following prosecution case:-

    (a) All the Accused are Caste Hindus and of residents of Neikuppai Village. The deceased Murugaian was also a resident of the same Village but he hails from different community viz., Scheduled Caste. The deceased was one among the member of the Village Panchayat of Neikuppai consisting of Caste Hindus. A panchayat was convened to discuss on the issue of death of one Krishnamurthy Asari. As the villagers suspected the death, in the panchayat a fine of Rs.30,000/- was imposed upon one Subramania Chettiar. It was so happened, the deceased Murugaian was away from the Village and he did not take part in the panchayat. When he returned to the Village, he learnt about the issue, panchayat proceedings and the imposition of fine of Rs.30,000/- upon Subramania Chettiar. He therefore, convened another panchayat and resolved to reduce the fine from Rs.30,000/- to Rs.16,500/- The said action of the deceased was disliked by the Caste Hindus. P.W.1 Ganesa Murthy, a resident of a nearby Village and the son in law of the deceased had paid visit to his deceased father-in-law's house on the previous night of the occurrence and was staying with him. Disliked by the act of intervention by the deceased in the panchayat proceedings held by the Caste Hindus, they developed animosity over the deceased and had formed themselves into an unlawful assembly at about 7.30 a.m. at West Street, Neikuppai Village, with an intention to commit rioting and murder of the deceased. When P.W.1 was staying with the deceased, he saw the accused persons came in an unlawful assembly and by that time A1, uttered to his father-in-law, the deceased that he will kill him and he will not leave him alive. While saying so, A1 poured kerosene which was brought by him in a tin, over the roof of the house of the deceased; A2 lit fire on the roof and the roof immediately caught fire; apprehending danger to is life, the deceased had started running towards a nearby school and reached the pial of the house of one Mahalingam PW13, all the accused chased and he was initially cut by A1 and A2 and thereafter indiscriminately cut by the other accused. While the deceased was attacked by the accused, the members of the unlawful assembly pelted stones at P.W.1 and also one Ramesh PW3 and Raja PW2. They also sustained injuries in the course of the occurrence. P.W.1 immediately rushed to the Police Station and lodged Ex.P.1 Complaint at about 8.45 a.m. to P.W.19, the inspector of Police, Kudavasal Police Station. By the time, when P.W.2 and P.W.3 entered into the police station, they saw P.W.1 was already lodging the Complaint to the police. P.W.1 to 3 were referred to Government Hospital, Thiruvarur for treatment on police memo.

    (b) P.W.19, the Inspector of Police, Kudavasal in turn registered Ex.P.1 Complaint in Cr.No.132 of 1994 for the alleged offence under Sections 147, 148, 436, 323, 326 and 302 of IPC and prepared Ex.P.13 Printed F.I.R. He made arrangements to send the express FIR to the Court of Judicial Magistrate at Tiruvarur through P.W.15, the Head Constable attached to Kudavasal Police Station and took up investigation. The FIR reached the Court of Judicial Magistrate at 4.45 p.m. on the same date.

    (c) P.W.19, who took up investigation, rushed to the place of occurrence and at 9.55 a.m. he reached the place of occurrence; initially he inspected the occurrence house of the deceased Murugaian where the first occurrence took place, in the presence of witnesses; prepared Ex.P.2 Observation Mahazar, drew Ex.P.18 Rough Sketch; thereafter he visited the another occurrence place, where the deceased was found lying dead; again he prepared Ex.P.3 Observation Mahazar, drew Ex.P.19 Rough Sketch; he summoned panchayatars, held inquest at 11.30 a.m. and prepared Ex.P.20 Inquest Report; he sent the body of the deceased through P.W.15, the Grade-I Police Constable, attached to Kudvasal Police Station to Government Hospital, Thiruvarur for post mortem along with a request. He examined the witnesses P.W.1 to P.W.5 and recorded their statements. At about 4.15 p.m., recovered M.O.10, A burnt Bamboo piece; M.O.11, A burnt thatched leave piece; A12, A burnt Polyester saree; M.O.13, A burnt sprayer nostril ; M.O.14, A burnt wooden plank taken from the cart; and M.O.15 Some burnt paddy under the cover of Ex.P.4 Seizure Mahazar in the presence of P.W.7. He further recovered M.O.16 Blood stained earth collected from the mud pial situated in front of the house of one Mahalaingam (P.W.13) and M.O.17 Ordinary earth; and also M.O.18 Blood stained earth where the body of the deceased was lying and M.O.19 Ordinary earth at about 4.45 p.m. under the cover of Ex.P.5 Seizrue Mahazar in the presence of the very same attesting witness. He examined the attesting witnesses P.W.7 and some other witnesses.

    (d) On 13.03.1994 upon identification by P.W.14, the Head Constable at the request of the Investigating Officer, P.W.17 Doctor, the then Civil Assistant Surgeon, Government Hospital, Thiruvarur at about 4.30 p.m. conducted autopsy on the body of the deceased and noticed that the condition of the body when it was brought to him was cold and fresh and rigor mortis was present all over the body. He found the following ante-mortem external injuries:-

    1. 6" long elliptical, horizontal cut injury with clear edges of skin extending from angle of left mandible, across left neck up to the lateral process of spine "C2" without involving mastoid-bone, one cleaning dark blood clots, the steno cleido mastoid muscles @ Jugular veins & Carotid arteries are found cut.

    2. 1" below injury No.(1) a similar cut injury horizontal, extending from Adam's apple across left of neck up to C5 spins, lateral process in the back, 6" long, its depth extends, cutting the steno mastoid muscles and jugular veins and common carotid artery with profuse dark blood coming.

    3. Similar cut injury 3" long, horizontal, 1" below injury No.2 over root of neck, involving clavicle bone left.

    4. Irregular edged 2" x 1 X � " serrated � edged Abrasion over left scapula.

    5. 10" long lacerated injury with clear edges, very superficial running obliquely across the left breast to right ribs with two packets of injury 1" deep lying on the same line with 3% gap in between; this injury does not cut Heart, lungs and abdominal viscera.

    6. Cut injury 4" long, Horizontal and lateral side of left thigh 4" above knee joint just embracing femur bone.

    7. Below left knee joint similar injury 4" long over lateral side of leg completely cutting away the tibia @ fibula bones

    8. 2" below injury No.7, 3" long cut injury over lateral side 2" deep.

    9. Complete severing of left wrist separating the hand from its joint cutting running over the shoulder from scapula to Anterior of shoulder, cutting the tender insertion of Biceps, muscle chopping-off the head of humerus bone.

    He opined that the deceased would appear to have died of the injuries Nos.1 and 2 above due to severing of left carotid artery and jugular veins, leading to profuse hemorrhage, hypo-volumia, shock and death in sequence. He issued Ex.P.14 Post-mortem Certificate to that effect. He further opined to a suggestion that Weapons like M.Os.3 to 7 and 24 are enough to cause all the injuries.

    (e) On the very same day at about 06.00 p.m. P.W.17 Doctor attended to one Ganesamoorthy, who was alleged to have been assaulted by two known persons using stones at 7.30 a.m. On examination of P.W.1, the Doctor P.W.17 has noticed the following injuries on him:-

    1. Contusion left ear lobe with tenderness.

    2. Abrasion with edima 1" dia � over nape of neck. This injury is simple in nature and issued Ex.P.15 Copy of Accident Register.

    (f) He also attended to one P.W.2 Raja and P.W.3 Ramesh who have come with police memo and told him that they sustained injury at 7.30 a.m. On the same day at Bazaar and said to have been assaulted by known persons with stones. P.W.17 Doctor P.W.2 Raja at about 6.00 p.m., and noticed the following injuries on his person :-

    �" dia recent abrasion with surrounded edime, over right eye brow the injury was simple in nature. and issued Ex.P.16 Copy of Accident Register.

    (g) P.W.17 Doctor further attended to P.W.3 Ramesh at about 6.20 p.m., and noticed the following injuries on his person:-

    1. Recent Contusion with blood clot. �" dia abrasion over left crown of head.

    2. Tenderness over left calf muscles. These injuries are simple in nature. Ex.P.17 is the Copy of the Accident Register. He would say that all the above said injuries are possible in time and manner as stated by the injured persons.

    (h) In continuation of his investigation, on 13.03.1994, when P.W.19 the Inspector of Police, Kudavasal Police Station arrested Ravi (A1), Arunachalam (A8), Rajendran (A5), Mahendran (A3), Karunakaran, Selvaraj (A6), Iyyappan (A4), Sundaramurthy(A9), Singaravelu (A2), Balakrishnan (since died) at Manjangudi Village, A1 Ravi volunteered to give confessional statement; in turn P.W.19 recorded the same in the presence of P.W.8; Ex.P.6 is the Admissible portion of the confessional statement of A1. Pursuant to Ex.P.6 Admissible portion of confessional statement of A1, P.W.19, recovered a aruval about measuring 52 c.m., in length at the instance of A1; recovered a aruval measuring 38 c.m., in length at the instance of A2 Singaravel; recovered a aruval measuring about 71 c.m., in length at the instance of A3; recovered a aruval measuring about 51 c.m., in length at the instance of A4 Iyyappan; recovered a aruval measuring about 39 c.m., in length at the instance of A5; recover a aruval measuring about 114 c.m., in length at the instance of A6; recovered a aruval measuring about 95 c.m., in length at the instance of A7; recovered a aruval measuring about 155 c.m., in length at the instance of A8; recovered a aruval measuring about 107 c.m., in length at the instance of A9 and also recovered a aruval measuring about 38 c.m., in length at the instance of Balakrishnan @ Balasubramanian (since died) viz., M.Os.3 to 7 and M.Os.20 to 24 under the cover of Ex.P.19 Mahazar in the presence fo the attesting witnesses. He subjected the accused to judicial remand and sent the material objects to the Court along with a requisition for onward submission of the same to Forensic Science Department for Chemical Analysis. Further, on 15.03.1994, at about 10.15, he arrrested Accused Mohan (A10), Subbaian (A21), Rajamanickam (Since died), Santhanam (A22) and Kannan (A24) at in Kudavasal-Tiruvar Main Road at Manjangudi Bus Stand in the presence of P.W.8; A10 volunteered to give confession statement; P.W.19 accordingly recorded the the voluntary confession statement of A10 in the presence of P.W.8; pursuant to Ex.P.8 Admissible portion of confessional statement of A10, he recovered a Bamboo stick measuring about 87 c.m., in length at the instance of A10, a bamboo stick measuring about 112 c.m., in length at the instance of A22, a bamboo stick measuring about 113 c.m., in length at the instance of A24; a bamboo stick measuring about 74 c.m., in length at the instance of the accused Rajamanickam (since died); and one another bamboo stick mesuring about 107 c.m., in length at the instance of A21; which M.Os.33 to 37 under the cover of Ex.P.9 Seizure Mahazar in the presence of the very same attesting witnesses. Thereafter, on 15.03.1994 he recovered Blood stained Lunghi M.O.8, M.O.9 blood stained towel; at the instance of P.W.3; Blood stained Lunghi M.O.25, Blood stained full hand shirt M.O.26, at the instance of P.W.2; and Blood stained Dhoti M.O.27 and Blood stained Kadhi shirt M.O.28 at the instance of P.W.1 under the cover of Ex.P.10 Seizure Mahazar in the presence of P.W.10. On 16.03.1994, the above accused were remanded to judicial custody after being produced before the Judicial Magistrate and Concerned. P.W.19 sent the material objects to the Court of the Judicial Magistrate having jurisdiction.

    (i) In continuation of his investigation on 16.03.1994, P.W.14 the Inspector of Police, Kudavasal Police Station again examined P.W.5 ; on 18.03.1994 he arrested A14, A19, A12, A20, A16 at about 6.45 p.m. at Nanacheri Pilliyar Koil Bus Stop in the presence of P.W.11 and recorded the voluntary confession statement of A14; pursuant to Ex.P.11 Admissible portion of the confession statement of A14, P.W.19 recovered Bamboo stick at the instance of A14 and also Bamboo , Velikaruvai and Nochi sticks a at the instance of A19, A12, A20 and A16 under the cover of Ex.P.12 Seizure Mahazar. The Sticks recovered are M.Os.29 to 32 and M.O.20. On 19.03.1994, P.W.19 subjected the accused to judicial remand and sent the material objects to the Court for the purpose of sending the same to Chemical Analysis. On 20.03.1994 P.W.19 examined Subramaniyam Chettiar and some other witnesses and he was given to understand that the remaining accused persons moved the Court of Sessions, Nagapattinam and obtained anticipatory bail. In the mean time, P.W.19 went on leave and transferred.

    (j) P.W.20 the successor Inspector of Police, Kudavasal took up further investigation. On 15.04.1996 he examined the Doctor who conducted autopsy on the body of the deceased and treated P.W.1 to P.W.3 for the injuries sustained by them in the course of the occurrence. In the mean time he was also transferred. Subsequently, P.W.21, the then Deputy Superintendent of Police, Kumbakonam Sub Division took up further investigation on 18.10.1998. He obtained Ex.P.21 Community Certificate of the deceased who belonged to Hindu Scheduled Caste and Ex.Ps.22 to 25 Community Certificates relating to accused persons who belonged to Hindu Castes from the Tahsildar concerned. He made arrangements to get Ex.P.29 Chemical Analysis Report and Ex.P.30 Serology Report. Upon completion of his investigation, he laid the final report under Sections 147, 148, 323, 436, 336 and 302 of IPC and Sections 3(2) (iv) and 3(2) (v) of the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989.

    4. The prosecution, in order to prove its case, examined 21 witnesses, marked 30 exhibits and produced 38 material objects.

    5. When Accused were questioned under Section 313 of the Criminal Procedure Code as to the incriminating materials appearing against them, they denied each and every incriminating material as false. On the side of defence, 4 witnesses were examined and 18 documents were marked. However, after having considered both the oral and documentary evidence, the learned trial Judge found A-1 and A-10 guilty, convicted and sentenced them for the offence as stated earlier, but acquitted the rest of the accused from the charges set out in the earlier part of this common judgment.

    6.1. Mr.A.Padmanaban, learned counsel appearing for the appellants in Crl.A.No.586 of 2001 with much force would at the out set attack the complaint and FIR and submit that the genesis of the F.I.R. Itself is doubtful and when the very FIR itself is doubtful, the entire case of the prosecution should be thrown out. In support of his above submission, he would submit that P.W.1 who goes to the police station mentions the names of A1 to A9, whereas P.W.3 an another injured eye-witness would implicate as many as 26 persons in his evidence. The implication of the specified accused by P.W.1 creates a suspicion as to the very genuineness of the complaint. P.W.3 also disclaims the contents of the FIR said to have been given by P.W.1, as by that time when he reached the police station, P.W.1 has completed his complaint. P.W.2 in his evidence before the Court has stated that the complaint was prepared at the place of occurrence.

    6.2. He would further submit the FIR which was registered at 8.45 a.m. reached the Court only at 4.45 p.m. with an unexplained delay of nearly 8 hours and though the Jurisdictional Magistrate Court was Tiruvarur, the FIR was acknowledged by the Judicial Magistrate, Nagapattinam.

    6.3. He would again submit that one Manivasagam (A11) who was working as a Jailor at the relevant point of time was falsely implicated in the case. It has been successfully proved by the defence that the said Manivasagam (A11) was in fact on his duty at the relevant date and time of occurrence by examining D.Ws.1 to 4. In view of the false implication, the entire case of the prosecution as contained in the FIR is false. In the event, the FIR is disbelieved, the entire prosecution case must be disbelieved.

    7. Secondly, he would submit that the place of occurrence itself is doubtful and the prosecution has failed to prove the exact place where the occurrence had taken place. Though P.W.1 had stated both in Ex.P1 complaint and in his evidence before the Court that the deceased reached the house of P.W.13, Mahalingam and he was caught on the pial and was cut, the evidence of P.W.13, does not support the above version of P.W.1. In view of the fact that the house of P.W.13 lies one furlong away from the place of occurrence and in view of the said discrepancy, the case of the prosecution with regard to the place of occurrence must be disbelieved. The learned counsel would further that P.W.21, the Deputy Superintendent of Police has stated that some more witnesses had also stated that the place of occurrence is in front of Manickam's house.

    8. Thirdly, he would submit that one Mariappan, who was cited as witness No.7 in the charge sheet has been later on added as accused . This is admitted by one of the investigating officers viz., P.W.21. Such a serious lapse on the part of the prosecution throws a very serious doubt on the investigation as such. Therefore, the evidence of P.Ws.1 to 3 smacks serious doubt as to the varsity. P.W.1, is a resident of Kumbakonam claims to have come to the occurrence village on the previous night of the occurrence and witnessed the occurrence that allegedly took place on the next morning. Even when he was treated by P.W.17 Doctor, he has stated that he has sustained injury in front of his house. Likewise, according to P.Ws.2 and 3, they had first gone to Government Hospital, Kudavasal and then went to the Hospital at Tiruvarur. They had stated that they had sustained injury at Bazaar. Such Bazaar has not been shown in the Rough Sketch. Therefore, the evidence of P.Ws.1 to P.W.3 cannot inspire the confidence of this Court to sustain conviction and sentence.

    9. To sum up his arguments, (1) there was no impartial investigation conducted by the prosecution; (2) genesis of FIR is doubtful; (3) suppression of FIR; (4) place of occurrence not proved; (5) alibi proved; and the evidence of P.Ws 1 to 3 lacks credibility. In support of the above submissions he would rely upon the following judgments of the Apex Court:-

    (1) 1980 (SCC) Crl. 985 (Marudanal Augusti Vs. State of Kerala)

    (2) 1981 (SCC) Crl. 679 (Selvi and another Vs. State of Tamil Nadu and another)

    (3) 2004 (SCC) Crl. 1776 (State of Punjab V. Daljit Singh and another

    10. Mr.A.Natarajan, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Appellant/A13 in Crl.A.No. A484 of 2001 would submit that even Ex.P.1 does not contain the name of A13. P.W.1 even in his evidence does not implicate A13 for causing any injury either on the deceased or P.Ws.1 to 3. P.W.1 though identified one Mohan in the Court, as there are two accused in the name "Mohan" viz., A10 and A13 and in the absence of a definite identity conviction on the basis of the evidence of P.W.1 alone cannot be passed, as there are serious contradictions in between the evidence of P.Ws.1 to 3 and P.W.17 Doctor. The presence of P.Ws.1 to 3 in the scene of occurrence itself is doubtful. He would also submit that for all other grounds raised by the other appellants the conviction and sentence recorded by the trial Court are liable to be set aside.

    11. On the above submissions of the respective learned counsel for the appellants we have heard Mr.P.N.Pandithurai, learned Additional Public Prosecutor as well.

    12. We have carefully considered the rival submissions. We have also perused both the oral and documentary evidence adduced on either side.

    13. Before we enter upon the discussion on the rival submissions, we would like to refer to the motive aspect. It is not in controversy that the accused are Caste Hindus and the deceased belonged to Hindu Scheduled Caste. There is also no controversy that the deceased was one of the member of the panchayat committee of the Neikuppai Village and used to sit whenever the panchayat meeting was convened. The case of the prosecution is that as the villagers had entertained a suspicion over the death of one Krishnamurthy Asari, a resident of the village, a panchayat was convened and a fine of Rs.30,000/- was imposed upon one Subramaniya Chettiar. The deceased could not attend the said panchayat, as he was away from the village and when he returned back to the village and on coming to know the imposition of fine, he had on his part convened another panchayat and reduced the fine amount to Rs.16,500/-. As another panchayat was convened by the deceased sitting over the decision of the panchayatars consisting of Caste Hindus and also the deceased was instrumental for the protest of the people belonging to Scheduled Caste to work in the filed owned by Caste Hindus, the Caste Hindus of the Village had developed animosity over the deceased. To prove the above, the prosecution had examined P.Ws.2, 5 and 12. P.W.2 who is the resident of the Village and an independent eye witness has deposed the above. P.W.13, of course, the wife of the deceased had also stated in her evidence that only because of the reason that her husband had convened another panchayat and reduced the fine amount, the Caste Hindus disliked the same, developed animosity against her husband and decided to get rid off him. This evidence is also amply corroborated by the evidence of P.W.12, who is also a resident of the same Village. In these circumstances, the learned trial Judge by correctly appreciating their evidence found that the prosecution had clearly established the motive. In our considered opinion, from the categorical evidence of P.W.2, P.W.5 and P.W.12, the motive aspect is established by the prosecuting agency beyond any doubt.

    14. Coming to the first contention of the learned counsel for the Appellants as to the doubt over FIR, it must be kept in mind that the occurrence took place at 7.30 a.m. on 13.03.1994 and the complaint was lodged at 8.45 a.m. by P.W.1 to P.W.19 the Inspector of Police, within 45 minutes of the occurrence. The lodging of FIR by P.W.1 is also spoken to by P.Ws.2 and 3. We are refrained from discussing the challenge as to the contents of the FIR on the ground of discrepancies in the evidence of P.Ws.1 and 3 at this stage, as we would be discussing the same in appropriate portion of this judgment. It is pertinent to note that while a complaint Ex.P.1 was lodged by P.W.1, P.Ws.2 and 3 came to the police station. Their evidence is categorical that immediately after the occurrence, P.W.1 had gone to the police station and was actually lodging the complaint. Both P.Ws.2 and 3 had also rushed to the police only in order to give information to the police as to the occurrence and they found that already P.W.1 was in the police station and lodging complaint. Therefore, we are not inclined to accept the challenge over the FIR that it is doubtful, as it could not have been given as spoken to by the witnesses.

    15. FIR was also attacked on the ground that P.W.2 has stated that it was recorded at the place of occurrence and not in the police station. We have carefully perused the evidence of P.W.2. His evidence should be read with the evidence of P.W.19, the Inspector of Police, who had visited the place of occurrence even at 9.30 a.m. The Investigating Officer has stated that he enquired those persons in the place of occurrence including P.W.2 and recorded their statement. When Ex.P.1 Complaint was given at the police station and the same was registered immediately and the statements recorded from P.W.2 and other witnesses at the place of occurrence could be the statement recorded under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure by the Police in the course of investigation. The challenge on this ground is on total misconception of the evidence. We are therefore of the opinion that the argument that the Complaint Ex.P.1 was recorded at the place of occurrence is totally misconceived.

    16. Further, on registration of Ex.P.1 complaint, Express FIR Ex.P.13 was prepared and sent to the concerned Court through P.W.15 Head Constable attached to Kudavasal Police Station and of course the said Express FIR reached the Judicial Magistrate, Nagapattinam at 4.45 p.m. on 13.03.1994. The bone of contention raised by the learned counsel for the respective appellants is that there is not only delay in FIR reaching the Court but, but also the FIR was not sent to the Court which was having jurisdiction over Kudavasal Police Station. We perused the evidence of P.W.15, the Head Constable attached to Kudvasal Police Station. According to him, he was handed over the Complaint Ex.P1 and Express FIR Ex.P13 by the Inspector of Police P.W.19, at 9.30 a.m. On 13.03.1994; he reached the Court of the Judicial Magistrate at 12.00 noon, as it was a holiday , the Judicial Magistrate did not come to the court premises; he therefore, went to the residence of the Judicial Magistrate and delivered the Complaint and the Express FIR at 4.45 p.m. There is no reason to disbelieve the above explanation of P.W.15 as to the probable delay in reaching the FIR in the Court.

    17. This would take us to the next challenge that though P.W.15 has stated that he handed over the Express FIR to the Judicial Magistrate, Tiruvarur, a perusal of both Ex.P.1 Complaint and Ex.P13 Express FIR would go to show that they were received by the Judicial Magistrate, Nagapattinam. Of course, P.W.15 has deposed in his evidence that he handed over the Complaint and the Express FIR to the Judicial Magistrate, Tiruvarur, whereas they were actually handed over to the Judicial Magistrate, Nagapattinam. In our considered opinion, it is a mistake on the part of P.W.15, the Head Constable in mentioning the station of the Judicial Magistrate in his evidence before the Court and such a mistake would not have a serious impact on the prosecution case and to doubt the very FIR itself. So long as the FIR was acknowledged by the Judicial Magistrate as spoken to by P.W.15 at 4.45 p.m. on the very same day and the endorsement of the learned Judicial Magistrate found place in both the complaint and FIR as spoken by P.W.15, the Head Constable, merely because a reference has wrongly been made by the Head Constable, as to the station of the Judicial Magistrate would by itself cannot be a ground to throw the case of the prosecution doubting the FIR itself.

    18. While considering such challenge, the paramount consideration for the Court would be, as to whether the complaint was given without any undue delay and the FIR was registered in time; whether appropriate steps have been taken to send the FIR to the Court so as to reach the same in time; and whether the Court acknowledged the receipt of the FIR within a reasonable time.

    19. It has been repeatedly held by the Apex Court that the delay in FIR reaching the Court by itself cannot be vital as it is always for the prosecution to explain such delay. That apart, in the present case, having regard to our finding that there is no delay in registering the FIR and reaching the same to the Court, we see no force in the challenge on the FIR.

    20. Insofar as the next challenge as to the occurrence is concerned here, again the evidence of P.Ws.1 to 5, P.W.7and P.W.13 could be considered. Before delve upon the said challenge it would be proper for us to deal with the challenge as to the veracity of their evidence, as argued by the learned counsel appearing for the respective appellants as third ground of challenge. The evidence of P.W.1 is attacked on the ground that he could not have been present at the time of occurrence. It is the contention of the appellants that he being the residence of Kumbakonam, there was no occasion for him to come to the occurrence village. The said contention must fall to the ground for the simple reason that P.W.1 is none other than the son-in-law of the deceased. There is nothing strange for a son-in-law to make a visit to his father-in-law's house. Though, he ordinarily resides at Kumbakonam, which is located at a considerable distance from the occurrence village, the fact remains that he was also injured and he alone lodged Ex.P1 Complaint to the police, which was in turn registered by P.W.19, the Inspector of Police at 8.45 a.m. while the occurrence had taken place at 7.30 a.m. within 45 minutes of occurrence. He further explained that he came to his father-in-law's house on the previous night and he was staying with him. In as much as the documentary evidence as to the registration of his complaint at 8.45 a.m. as spoken to by P.W.19 the Inspector of Police and there is evidence of P.W.15, who was handed over the Complaint Ex.P1 and the Express FIR Ex.P13 at 9.30 a.m. and P.W.1 was also seen in the police station by both P.Ws.2 and 3 at 8.45 a.m. we find no merit in the contention that he could not have been present at the time of occurrence.

    21. Equally, the evidence of P.W.2 is also attacked on the ground that he has stated before the Investigating Officer as to the alleged attack on him by some of the accused with stones. Moreover, both P.Ws.2 and 3 did not go to Government Hospital, Tiruvarur, but had gone to Government Hospital, Kudavasal and they had also stated to P.W.17 Doctor that they sustained injuries in a Bazaar which is not shown in the both the rough sketches. Whether the above challenge would be sufficient to discard the evidence of P.Ws.2 and 3 in its entirety is the matter for consideration. P.W.2 is also a resident of the occurrence village. He has spoken about the motive and also spoken about the implication of the definite accused viz., A1 to A8, though spoke in respect of the involvement of some other accused as well. His evidence is cogent and credible. Further nothing had been elicited from him as why he had deposed against the accused by falsely implicating them alone.

    22. Further, the evidence of P.Ws.1 to 3 is attacked on the ground that while P.W.1 was attended to by P.W.17 Doctor for the injuries alleged to have been sustained by him during the course of occurrence, P.W.1 had stated to P.W.17, the Doctor that he was attacked near by his residence which is at Kumbakonam. In Ex.P.15, Copy of Accident Register, P.W.17 Doctor had recorded that P.W.1 had stated to him that he was attacked at his residence at Kumbakonam. It may reasonably be inferred that it is a mistake in mentioning the above. As admittedly, he was we seen in the police station at 8.45 p.m. By P.Ws.2 and 3 and the complaint Ex.P1 has been signed by him and the said complaint was registered immediately and was handed over to the Police Constable P.W.15, at 9.30 a.m. While so, the word "at his residence" contained in Ex.P.15 Copy of Accident Register, if at all mean the residence of the deceased. P.Ws.2 and 3 had also stated as could be seen from Exs.P.16 and 17 respectively that they were attacked in the Bazaar. Exs.P.18 and 19 refers the street name as Pallikuda Street @ Mariamman Koil Street. In this context, it would be appropriate to mention that duty of the Doctor is supposed to give treatment to the injured and any reference made either as to the names of the assailants or number of assailants or any other details touching with the occurrence may not have much bearing to support the prosecution case as to the place of occurrence and the number of accused and their involvement. The evidence of Doctor coupled with the Accident Register can utmost be used even by the prosecution only to prove the nature of the injuries and in the event, such injuries had resulted in the death of any person, to establish the cause of death. Here, we may usefully refer the judgment of this Court reported in 1993 Crl.L.J. 2173 (Basheer V. State of Sub Inspector of Police, Madurai) and 2007 (1) MLJ (crl) 319 (Annamalai v. State by Sub Inspector of Police, Thiruppathur Police Station). Merely because a reference as to the place of occurrence found place in the Copy of the Accident Register given by the Doctor would by itself cannot cast a doubt to materially affect the entire case of the prosecution, if the prosecution is able to prove the involvement of the assailants by way of the other credible evidence. Hence, we are not inclined to accept the submissions of the learned counsel for the respective appellants that the presence of P.Ws.1 to 3 at the occurrence place itself is doubtful. On a careful perusal of their evidence we are of the considered view that their evidence inspire confidence of this Court and we have no reason to reject their evidence.

    23. This takes us to the next challenge as to the place of occurrence. It is seen from the Complaint Ex.P1, which was lodged within 45 minutes of the occurrence that A1 to A9 are specifically implicated. In the Complaint Ex.P.1, P.W.1 had stated that the accused came in a group forming themselves into an unlawful assembly; A1 uttered the following word " eP capUld; nUf;Fk; tiu ne;Jf;fis gpiHf;ftplkhl;lha;. cd;idf; bfhy;yhky; tpLtjpy;iy" and by that time A2 poured kerosene on the roof of the house of the deceased. By the time when the deceased as well as P.Ws.1 to 5 came out of the house, the deceased was surrounded by all the above accused with deadly weapons viz., deadly weapons and sticks. On realising the situation that his life was in danager, the deceased ran away from the place. By that time, all the accused chased him and ultimately the deceased was indiscriminately cut with knives not only by A1 and A2, but also by the other accused in front of the house of one Manickam. As the accused had also thrown stones against P.Ws.1 to 3, they also ran from the scene of occurrence. P.W.1 had straight away gone to the police station to lodge the complaint followed by P.Ws.2 and 3. The deceased after sustained injuries fell down in front of the house of the said Mahalingam. The challenge as to the place of occurrence is that when the body was found in front of the house of one Mahalingam's house, the version of P.Ws.1 to 3 that the deceased was cut in front of one Manickam's house cannot be true and the case of the prosecution as to the place of occurrence has not been proved. In this context, it would be highly relevant first to refer to the Mahazar, Ex.P2 which mahazar prepared at the earliest point of time. It speaks of the first occurrence. Ex.P3 is the mahazar prepared at the place where the subsequent occurrence took place. All that show that the body was found in front of the house of Mahalingam. Though the mahazar does not contain the house of the said Manickam, going by the entirety of evidence, it appears to us, that the deceased was chased and he was cut in front of Manickam's house and thereafter he had run further to save his life and ultimately he fell down in front of the house of the said Mahalingam, where he succumbed to injuries. The said Mahalingam was also examined as P.W.13. His evidence would show that he saw the dead body of the deceased in front of his house. Therefore, it is reasonably held that a mere failure on the part of the investigating officer to show the house of the said Manickam would not in any way affect the entire case of the prosecution as put forth before the trial Court. We may utmost consider it as one of the laxity in the course of the investigation. In this context, we may usefully refer to the following judgment of the Apex Court :-

    1. 1974 (3) SCC 116 (Chandra Kant Luxman V. State of Maharashtra)

    2. 2000 (1) SCC 247 (State of H.P. v. Lekh Raj and another)

    3. 2004 SCC 851 (Dhanaj Sing @ Shera and others vs. State of Panjab)

    4. 2004 SCC 2045 (Ram Bali Vs. State of U.P.)

    5. 2003 SCC 641 (Amar Singh V. Balwinder Singh and another)

    6. 2006 (12) SCC 64 (Rotash Vs. State of Rajasthan)

    7. 1988 SCC (Crl) 559 (Appabhai and another Vs. State of Gujarat)

    24. As we have already believed the evidence of P.Ws.1 to 5 who have spoken about the occurrence, we do not find any force in the contention that the prosecution has not established the exact place of occurrence. Of course the prosecution is bound to establish the place of occurrence. On the fact of this case, we find that the prosecution has satisfactorily proved the place of occurrence as well.

    25. The next ground of challenge is that one Mariappan though was cited as one of the witnesses, he was later on added as accused in the charge sheet. This would in our considered view cannot have any bearing on the prosecution case to prove the charges on the accused, if the Court is of the opinion that the implication of the accused has been amply proved beyond any reasonable doubt through evidence and such a procedural defect would not by itself render the prosecution case unbelievable.

    26. Lastly, it was contended that the evidence of P.W.3 cannot be believed, as he is a convict in a triple murder case. We do not find any rule of law that Court must either discard or disbelieve the evidence of a convict and that too in a triple murder case. Evidence of a witness should be considered with reference to its veracity, truthfulness and credibility. Of course, the Court may while appreciating the evidence also take into consideration the back ground of such witness and find out whether the witness had sufficient reason to falsely implicate the accused. In the event the evidence of a convict is amply corroborated by other independent witnesses and that too such witness is also an injured witness, merely on the ground that he was a life convict in a triple murder case, his evidence cannot be discarded in toto and there cannot be any rule as such. In this case, P.W.3 is also an injured eye witness. He has been treated by P.W.17 Doctor for the contusion with blood clot with an abrasion over crown of head and tenderness over left calf muscles sustained during the course of occurrence. Hence, such contention is liable to be rejected.

    27. Further, it was contended that P.W.3 had disowned the contents of Ex.P.1 Complaint. Hence, the complaint itself is suppressed. In this context, it may be stated that P.W.3 is neither the author nor attester of the complaint Ex.P.1. P.W.1 also does not say that P.W.3 accompanied him to the police station and was with him at the time of lodging the Complaint Ex.P.1. P.W.19 the Investigating Officer who recorded the FIR had also not made any reference that P.W.3 was present at the time when Ex.P.1 Complaint was given by P.W.1. In these circumstances, the evidence of P.W.3 that he did not know the contents of the complaint reflects only the truthfulness of his statement. Therefore, the challenge that the complaint was suppressed to P.W.3 cannot be accepted. The Judgment relied on by the learned counsel appearing for the appellants in Crl.A.No. 586 of 2001 as to the proposition of impartial investigation and suppression of FIR is of no assistance to the appellants on the fact of the present case.

    28. One more argument was advanced as to the false implication of A11 in this case. It is true, that A11 was also charge-sheeted in the case and later on he was acquitted on the ground of alibi as spoken to by D.Ws.1 to 4. In this context, Ex.P.1 Complaint is referable. In the Complaint Ex.P1, the name of A11 has not been mentioned. It is significant to note that neither P.W.1 nor P.W.2 had implicated A11 for the occurrence. Though ti FIR is considered to set the law in motion by enabling the Investigating Officer to cause investigation, insofar as the truthfulness of the contents in the FIR is concerned, the Court while scrutinizing the evidence can also notice the specified names of the accused in the FIR . The Investigating officer during the course of investigation, if comes across the involvement of any other accused persons also for the offence and in case if such implication of the accused, whose names does not find a reference in the FIR, is acquitted on the ground that he has been implicated, mere fact that investigation officer has implicated that accused cannot be a ground to disbelieve the complaint and the evidence to implicating the other accused.

    29. In 2004 SCC 1776 (State of Punjab v. Daljit Singh and another), the Apex Court had held that when the trial Court accepted the evidence put forth by A3 that it was the case of alibi and having accepted the defence that he was not present at the time of occurrence it had failed to to consider the effect of such finding on the evidence of eye-witnesses indicating that the eye-witnesses are capable of including the names of innocent persons and upheld the order of acquittal passed by the High Court setting aside the judgment of conviction. That was the one of the grounds referred to by the High Court in the above case to disbelieve the case of the prosecution. However on the fact of this Case, neither Ex.P.1 Complaint nor the evidence of P.Ws.1 and 2 implicated A11. Of course, A11 was implicated by P.W.3 in his evidence who is neither the author nor a witness to the FIR. When there are other piece of evidence, as to the involvement of the other accused, as found in the evidence of P.W.1, P.W.2, P.W.4 and P.W.5, the case of the prosecution cannot be disbelieved in its entirety solely on the ground that P.W.3 had implicated A11 in his evidence for the commission of offence. Hence, on the fact of this case, the judgment relied upon by the learned counsel for the Appellants in Crl.A.No. 586 of 2001 is of no avail.

    30. The above discussion takes us to the next question as to the actual involvement of each of the accused in the occurrence. Ex.P.1 Complaint refers to not only the names of the accused viz., A1 to A9 but also, specific overt act attributed to A1, for having poured kerosene on the roof of the house of the deceased and A2 for having lit fire to the roof. When the deceased ran for a life, all the accused chased him and they had indiscriminately cut the deceased. It is also stated in the complaint that the accused were armed with deadly weapons viz., knives and sticks and also pelted stones against the witnesses. P.W.1 in his evidence would implicate all the accused for the commission of offence as stated in the FIR, as he is the author of the Complaint. Of course, P.W.1 has not mentioned the name of A7 in his evidence. Nevertheless, he would speak about the overt act of inflicting indiscriminate cut on the deceased with deadly weapons by the accused. P.W.2 has also implicated all the accused except, P.W.2. The evidence of P.W.1 is amply corroborated by the evidence of P.Ws.2 to P.W.5.

    31. As regards A10, A12, A13, A14 and A15, firstly neither their names have been found place in the Complaint Ex.P.1 nor any specific overt acts attributed against any of them. Secondly, none of the eye-witnesses had spoken about their presence at the time of occurrence with deadly weapons to form an unlawful assembly what what more none of the eye-witnesses have spoken about any specific overt act attributing their involvement in the occurrence. It is true that even though P.W.3 had spoken about one Mohan, as rightly pointed out by the learned senior counsel appearing for A13, in the absence of any clear identity of the accused with reference to the array of the accused, as there are two accused involved in the case in the identical name viz., Mohan, the evidence of P.W.3 cannot advance the case of the prosecution to implicate A13. In the absence of any evidence to prove the involvement of A10, A12 to A15 in the occurrence beyond any reasonable doubt, they are entitled to the benefit of doubt and ultimately they are acquitted from all the charges leveled against them.

    32. For the reasons discussed above, we are of the considered view that the accused namely A1 to A9 formed themselves into an unlawful assembly armed with deadly weapons viz., knives and sticks and committed murder. Accordingly, A1 and A2 are liable for the offence Under Sections 148, 302 and 436 of IPC; A3 to A5 are liable for the offence under Sections 148, 436 r/w 149 and 302 of IPC; and A6 to A9 are liable for the offence under Sections 147, 436 r/w 149 and 302 r/w 149 of IPC. Therefore, the Criminal Appeal No.484 of 2001 partly succeeds and A10, A12, A13 to A15 alone are entitled to the benefit of doubt and consequently the judgment of conviction insofar as A1 to A9 are concerned stand confirmed to the extent discussed above and they are acquitted from the charges under Section 323 r/w 149 of IPC and again under Section 323 (Two counts) IPC and Criminal Appeal No. 586 of 2001 succeeds in entirety

    33. In fine, Criminal Appeal No. 586 of 2001 is partly allowed. The judgment of conviction and sentence dated 29.05.2001 made in Sessions Case No.17 of 2000 on the file of the learned II Additional Sessions Judge (Protection of Civil Rights), Thanjavur in respect of

    (i) A1 and A2 for the offence Under Sections 148, 302 and 436 of IPC;

    (ii) A3 to A5 for the offence under Sections 148, 436 r/w 149 and 302 of IPC;

    (iii) A6 to A9 for the offence under Sections 147, 436 r/w 149 and 302 r/w 149 of IPC stand confirmed;

    the judgment of conviction and sentence in respect of A1 to A9 for the offence under Sections 323 r/w 149 against 323 (Two counts) r/w 149 of IPC and insofar as A10, A12, A13 to A15 are concerned, for the offence under Sections 147 , 436 r/w 149, 302 r/w 149, 323 r/w 149 and 323 (Two counts) r/w 149 of IPC stand set aside.

    A10, A12, A13 to A15 are acquitted from all the charges leveled against them by giving the benefit of doubt and the bail bond executed by them shall automatically stand cancelled.

    The learned II Additional Sessions Judge (Protection of Civil Rights), Thanjavur is directed to take necessary steps to secure A1 to A9 and commit them to prison to serve the remainder portion of sentences.

    Criminal Appeal No.484 of 2001 is allowed and the judgment of conviction and sentence dated 29.05.2001 in S.C.No.17 of 2000 on the file of the learned II Additional Sessions Judge (Protection of Civil Rights), Thanjavur imposed against A13 in respect of offence under Sections 147 , 436 r/w 149, 302 r/w 149, 323 r/w 149 and 323 (Two counts) r/w 149 of IPC stand set aside and he is acquitted from all the charges. The bail bond if any executed him shall stand cancelled.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ravi @ Gopu & Others v. State represented by...
    (Sep 26, 2008)