Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeking, by way of mandamus, a declaration that a registered Deed of Revocation/Cancellation dated 29.09.2017 (registered 03.10.2017) executed by respondent No.4 (the petitioner’s paternal grandmother) and a subsequent registered sale deed dated 28.10.2017 (registered 06.11.2017) in favour of respondent No.5 are illegal, arbitrary, violative of the Registration Act, 1908 and related rules, and therefore null and void.

The factual matrix as pleaded: respondent No.4 had earlier executed a registered gift settlement deed dated 20.09.2014 (document No.3876/2014) transferring 3.24 acres of land to the petitioner out of love and affection; the petitioner accepted and took possession the same day and sought mutation in revenue records. Subsequently, the petitioner discovered via an Encumbrance Certificate (received 25.01.2019) that respondent No.4 had executed and got registered a cancellation/revocation deed on 29.09.2017 (registered 03.10.2017) purportedly revoking the gift, and thereafter had executed a sale deed in favour of respondent No.5 (registered 06.11.2017).

The petitioner contended the cancellation was unilateral, mala fide, and not permissible because the gift was absolute and the donor could not revoke it once transferred by registered deed; further, the registration of the cancellation deed did not comply with the procedure under Rule 26(i)(k)(i) of the Rules under the Registration Act, 1908.

The Court heard the petitioner’s counsel and the learned Government Pleader for Stamps and Registration (respondents 1 to 3). The Court concluded that no notice to the non-official respondents (4 & 5) was necessary and disposed of the writ petition on the basis of the submissions and the material on record.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a donor can unilaterally execute and register a deed of cancellation/revocation of a previously executed registered gift settlement deed transferring immovable property, without notice to or consent of the donee, and whether such cancellation and its registration are valid in law.
  2. Whether the registration of a unilateral cancellation/revocation deed that does not follow the procedure in Rule 26(i)(k)(i) of the Rules under the Registration Act, 1908 renders the cancellation void and, consequentially, whether any subsequent sale deed executed by the donor is valid.
  3. Whether the writ court can entertain relief in such circumstances or whether the petitioner must pursue a civil remedy to set aside the cancellation deed.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The gift settlement deed dated 20.09.2014 conferred absolute rights on the petitioner and was executed out of love and affection; possession was delivered to the petitioner the same day.
  • The deed of cancellation/revocation dated 29.09.2017 was executed unilaterally by respondent No.4 and therefore could not be validly registered by the District Registrar/Sub-Registrar.
  • The grounds stated in the revocation (non-delivery of possession, deception, non-fulfilment of word) are false and the gift was not conditional; hence the donor had no right to revoke the gift.
  • The registration officer (2nd respondent) failed to follow Rule 26(i)(k)(i) of the Rules under the Registration Act, 1908 which prescribes safeguards before registering cancellation deeds of previously registered conveyances.
  • Accordingly, the cancellation deed is null and void and the subsequent sale deed in favour of respondent No.5 is sham and not enforceable; the petitioner sought declaration and consequential reliefs.

Respondents' (Government Pleader) Contentions

  • The learned Government Pleader, while not disputing the settled legal position that unilateral cancellation is impermissible, contended that if the petitioner is aggrieved by the cancellation/revocation deed he should approach a civil court to seek the common law remedy for setting aside the same and cannot approach the writ court. The Court rejected this contention in the circumstances of the case.
  • The Government Pleader for Stamps and Registration appeared for respondents 1 to 3 and the Court found no necessity to issue notice to non-official respondents 4 & 5 to dispose of the petition on the available submissions and record.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ediga Chandrasekhar Gowd and another v. State of Andhra Pradesh and others, 2017 (3) ALT 420 = 2017 (4) ALD 12 Referenced by petitioner's counsel as an analysis of the law on the point (the opinion relied upon the provisions and precedents). The Court noted the reliance placed on this decision by the petitioner’s counsel; it formed part of the precedential background referred to by the parties.
Yanala Malleshwari v. Ananthula Sayamma, 2006 (6) ALT 523 (Full Bench) = 2006 (6) ALD 623 (FB) Held that unilateral cancellation of sale deeds could be done and registered without notice to the executant by the Registrar; this decision prompted the State to introduce Rule 26(i)(k)(i). The Court discussed this Full Bench decision as the antecedent position which led to the introduction of Rule 26(i)(k)(i), but also noted that this judgment was later set aside by the Supreme Court.
Kaitha Narasimha v. The State of Government of AP rep. by its Principal Secretary, Revenue Department, 2011 (8) MLJ 769 Division Bench rejected challenge to Rule 26(i)(k)(i), holding the rule incorporates natural justice safeguards and does not take away the rights of executants/claimants but ensures notice before cancellation registration. The Court cited this decision as authority upholding the validity of Rule 26(i)(k)(i) and its intention to ensure opportunity to be heard before registration of cancellation of previously registered conveyances.
Thota Ganga Lakshmi v. Government of Andhra Pradesh, 2012 (3) ALT 50 (SC) = 2012 (1) ALD 90 (SC) Supreme Court held that there cannot be unilateral cancellation of a sale deed; cancellation must be by competent civil court after notice to parties, and registration of unilateral cancellation in the absence of such court declaration or notice is void and non est. The Court treated this Supreme Court decision as binding precedent and applied its principle analogously to the gift deed cancellation in the present case: unilateral cancellation and its registration are void if not preceded by court declaration or compliance with Rule 26(i)(k)(i).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by identifying the controlling legal position from the authorities and the statutory/regulatory framework:

  • The Court noted that a Full Bench of the erstwhile High Court (Yanala Malleshwari) had earlier permitted unilateral registration of cancellation deeds, which prompted the State to introduce Rule 26(i)(k)(i) to add procedural safeguards at registration stage.
  • The Court then observed that the Division Bench in Kaitha Narasimha validated Rule 26(i)(k)(i) as embodying natural justice safeguards to ensure executants and claimants of a previously registered conveyance receive notice before cancellation registration.
  • The Supreme Court in Thota Ganga Lakshmi was identified as having set aside the Yanala Malleshwari view and held that unilateral cancellation of registered sale deeds is impermissible; cancellation can only follow a competent civil court’s order after notice to concerned parties, and registration of unilateral cancellations without such court declaration or notice is void and non est.
  • The Court reasoned that the principle established by the Supreme Court with reference to cancellation of sale deeds applies by analogy to cancellation of a registered gift settlement deed: once the donor has executed and delivered a registered gift creating absolute rights in the donee, the donor cannot unilaterally revoke it and have a cancellation deed validly registered without following the prescribed procedures or obtaining a competent court’s order.
  • Applying Rule 26(i)(k)(i) and the Supreme Court’s pronouncement, the Court found that the 2nd respondent (the registration authority) did not put the petitioner on notice nor follow the required procedure before registering the revocation/cancellation deed dated 29.09.2017 (registered 03.10.2017).
  • Given the failure to follow the prescribed procedural safeguards and the settled legal position against unilateral cancellations, the Court held the revocation/cancellation deed to be null and void. The Court further held that, because no one can convey a better title than he/she possesses, the subsequent sale deed executed by respondent No.4 in favour of respondent No.5 could not be valid.
  • As to the Government Pleader’s contention that the petitioner should seek a civil remedy instead of writ relief, the Court explained that when a cancellation deed is unilateral and void, it is just and fair to permit writ relief declaring such document null and void while still leaving open the executant’s right to seek common law remedies in civil court.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is allowed. The Court declared the deed of cancellation/revocation dated 29.09.2017 (registered 03.10.2017) executed by respondent No.4 as null and void and of no effect. Consequentially, the subsequent sale deed executed by respondent No.4 in favour of respondent No.5 was also held not valid.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The cancellation/revocation deed and the subsequent sale deed are declared invalid; the petitioner’s title under the registered gift settlement deed is effectively protected by this declaration.
  • The Court expressly left open the right of the executant of the cancellation/revocation deed (respondent No.4) to pursue common law remedies in a civil court to challenge this outcome; the order does not preclude civil proceedings to seek appropriate relief.
  • No order as to costs was made and miscellaneous petitions, if any, were closed.
  • The opinion did not purport to overrule or re-evaluate the precedents; it applied settled principles (including the Supreme Court view) to the facts. The decision operates as a disposition of the petition on the facts and law as applied in this case and does not announce any broader novel legal principle beyond application of existing authorities and Rule 26(i)(k)(i).

    Kolli Rajesh Chowdary v. State of A.P., rep. by its Principal Secretary, Revenue (Stamps & Registration) Dept & Others

    1. This writ petition, under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, is filed by the petitioner, seeking verbatim the following relief:

    "..to issue a writ, order or direction , more particularly one in the nature of writ of Mandamus declaring the action of the 2nd respondent in registering the Deed of Revocation/cancellation, dated 29.09.2017 vide document No.4581/2017, dated 03.10.2017 executed by the respondent No.4. Where under she cancelled the gift deed dated 20.09.2014 vide document No.38761/ 2014 executed by her in favour of the petitioner herein as illegal, arbitrary, violative of principles of natural justice and contrary to the provisions of The Registration Act, 1908 and the Rules made there under including Rule 26(i)(k) and also declare the subsequent registered sale deed document No.5136/2017, dated 06.11.2017 executed by respondent No.4 in favour of respondent No.5 as sham and nominal and that those documents are null and void and not enforceable and pass such other order or orders in the interests of justice."

    2. I have heard the submissions of the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner; and, of the learned Government Pleader for Stamps and Registration appearing for the respondents I to 3.

    2.1 In view of the legal position relied upon by the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and the learned Government Pleader, this Court is of the considered view that no notice is necessary to the non-official respondents 4 & 5; and, that the writ petition can be disposed of having regard to the submissions of the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and of the learned Government Pleader.

    2.2 I have perused the material record.

    3. The case of the petitioner, in brief, is this: The 4th respondent is the paternal grandmother of the petitioner. The 5th respondent is his aunt, being wife of his paternal uncle. The 4th respondent possessed certain movable and immovable properties of her own. She had settled on the petitioner her immovable property viz., Ac.3.24 cents of dry land in Sy.No.255/1 of Muppalla Village, Chanderlapadu Mandal, Krishna District, by executing a registered gift settlement deed, dated 20.09.2014, bearing document No.3876 of 2014. The said gift settlement deed was executed out of love and affection she had for the petitioner, who is the son of her elder son, and with a view to provide the said property for his livelihood. The gift was accepted and the possession of the property was delivered to the petitioner on the same day. Thereafter, the petitioner made an online application, on 09.05.2015, before the 3rd respondent and paid the requisite fee and requested for mutation of the said property in his name in the revenue records and for issuance of pattadar passbook. The same was acknowledged vide a receipt No. 3310848. Since the date of the gift settlement deed, the petitioner is in continuous possession and enjoyment of the above said property covered by the said deed. In the absence of assured irrigation sources to the said land, the petitioner used to raise only one crop per year depending upon the monsoon. On the suggestion of the neighbouring ryots, he got established a bore-well in the land to enable him to raise two crops per year. In order to meet the expenses for establishing the bore-well and the submersible motor etcetera, he had applied for an Encumbrance Certificate. The same was received, on 25.01.2019. He was surprised to notice that the 4th respondent, having executed a deed of cancellation, dated 29.09.2017, registered the same, on 03.10.2017, and revoked the gift settlement deed, dated 20.09.2014, executed by her in favour of the petitioner. The petitioner also noticed that, after execution of such cancellation deed, she had further executed a sale deed, dated 28.10.2017, in favour of the 5th respondent and registered it, on 06.11.2017. Since the property in question was transferred in favour of the petitioner with absolute rights by the 4th respondent by executing the registered gift settlement deed, she has no right to execute the deed of cancellation either cancelling or revoking the gift settlement deed executed by her in favour of the petitioner. The reasons stated by the 4th respondent in the revocation deed/deed of cancellation to the effect that possession of the above said property was not given to the petitioner and that he had got the gift settlement deed registered in his name by deceiving her and that he did not fulfil the word given to her are all false. The gift under the gift settlement deed is not a conditional gift. Hence, the gift settlement deed executed by the 4th respondent in favour of the petitioner cannot be cancelled on the alleged grounds mentioned in the deed of revocation or deed of cancellation. However, the 4th respondent cancelled the gift settlement deed executed in favour of the petitioner with a mala fide intention. Under the gift settlement deed, valuable rights in respect of the property covered by the said deed had accrued to the petitioner. The donor has no right to revoke the gift, once the property is gifted under a registered deed. As per settled legal position, unilateral cancellation of sale deeds and other documents transferring or alienating the property is impermissible. Unless the parties to the earlier deed consent for cancellation of the deed and the beneficiary under the deed join as a party to the deed of cancellation, the deed of cancellation cannot be registered. The relevant procedure is prescribed under Rule 26(i)(k)(i) of the Rules framed under the Registration Act, 1908. The said procedure is not followed by the 2nd respondent before registering he deed of cancellation executed by the 4th respondent. For all the reasons stated, the deed of cancellation cancelling the gift settlement deed executed by the 4* respondent in favour of the petitioner is null and void. Hence, the present writ petition is filed.

    4. Learned counsel for the petitioner reiterated the pleaded case of the petitioner, which is already stated supra, in detail. His main contention is that the deed of cancellation/revocation, dated 29.09.2017, executed by the 4th respondent cancelling/ revoking the gift settlement deed, dated 20.09.2014, executed by her in favour of the petitioner was one executed unilaterally and the same cannot be registered by the District Registrar/Sub-Registrar concerned and, therefore, the registration of the cancellation deed by the 2nd respondent is not valid in law and that the cancellation deed or revocation deed is null and void.

    4.1 Learned counsel placed reliance on the decision of the High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad for the State of Telangana and the State of Andhra Pradesh in Ediga Chandrasekhar Gowd and another v. State of Andhra Pradesh and others (1) 2017 (3) ALT 420 = 2017 (4) ALD 12, wherein the entire law on the point was analysed having regard to the provisions of law and the precedents.

    5. Before proceeding further, it is necessary to note the legal position obtaining. A Full Bench of the then High Court of Andhra Pradesh in Yanala Malleshwari v. Ananthula Sayamma (2) 2006 (6) ALT 523 (F.B.) = 2006 (6) ALD 623 (FB), had held that unilateral cancellation of sale deeds can be done and they can be registered without notice to the executant by the District Registrar/Sub-Registrar. Since the State perceived that this judgment would create lot of complications to the holders of the land and that they could be exposed to problems created by their transferor's by unilateral cancellation of the sale deeds and other documents transferring or alienating property executed by them, it introduced Rule 26(i)(k)(i) by way of notification, dated 29.11.2006. The relevant portion of the said rule reads as under:

    "26. (i) Every document shall, before acceptance for registration, be examined by the Registering Officer to ensure that all the requirements prescribed in the Act and in these rules shall have been complied with, for instance...

    (k)(i) The registrating officer shall ensure at the time of presentation for registration of cancellation deeds of previously registered deed of conveyances on sale before him that such cancellation deeds are executed by all the executant and claimant parties to the previously registered conveyance on sale and that such cancellation deed is accompanied by a declaration showing mutual consent or orders of a competent Civil or High Court or State or Central Government annulling the transaction contained in the previously registered deed of conveyance on sale;

    Provided that the registering officer shall dispense with the execution of cancellation deeds by executant and claimant parties to the previously registered deeds of conveyances on sale before him if the cancellation deed is executed by a Civil Judge or a Government Officer competent to execute Government Orders declaring the properties contained in the previously registered conveyance on sale to be Government or Assigned or Endowment lands or properties not register able by any provisions of law."

    A challenge was made to the validity of the said rule on the ground that it is ultra vires the provisions of the Registration Act, 1908 However, the said challenge was rejected by a Division Bench of the said Court in Kaitha Narasimha v. The State of Government of AP rep., by its Principal Secretary, Revenue Department (3) 2011 (8) MLJ 769. The Division Bench held the the Rule merely incorporates, one of the facets of the rules of natural justice in the procedure laid down for registration o: cancellation deed of previously register's document and is intended to ensure that £ duly registered sale deed is not cancelled without the executant and claimant getting an opportunity to contest the registration of cancellation deed and that the said Rule does not have the effect of taking away the right of the executant of cancellation deed and only seeks to put the executant and claimants of the original document to notice that somebody is seeking cancellation thereof. It is not in dispute that the said Rule applies to the gift settlement deed in question. Be that as it may. The judgment in Yanala Malleshwari and others [2nd supra] was set aside by the Supreme Court in Thota Ganga lakshmi v. Government of Andhra Pradesh (4) 2012 (3) ALT 50 (SC) = 2012 (1) ALD 90 (SC), wherein the Supreme Court opined that there cannot be any unilateral cancellation of a sale deed and that a party, who wants to cancel a sale deed executed, has to necessarily file a civil suit for its cancellation or seek re conveyance from the vendee, and that executing a cancellation deed, or getting it registered, is unheard of in law. The Supreme Court also referred to the above said Rule and stated that the said Rule is consistent with the view of the Court that a cancellation deed can be registered only after a sale deed is cancelled by a competent civil Court after notice to the concerned parties and that in the absence of any declaration by a competent Court or notice to parties, the cancellation deed as well as registration thereof were wholly void & non est and that such transactions are meaningless transactions.

    6. From the precedential guidance in the decision of the Supreme Court, it is manifest that there cannot be an unilateral cancellation of registered sale deeds and that a cancellation deed cancelling a sale deed can be registered only after the same is cancelled by a competent civil Court, after notice to the parties concerned, and that in the absence of any declaration by a competent Court or notice to parties, the execution of deed of cancellation as well as its registration are wholly void and non est and such transactions are meaningless transactions. In my opinion, the analogy which the Supreme Court applied to cancellation of sale deed equally applies to the present deed of cancellation by which the 4th respondent cancelled unilaterally, the gift settlement deed executed by her in favour of the petitioner. In the present case, the procedure prescribed in the Rule afore-stated has admittedly not been followed and the petitioner was not put on notice by the 2nd respondent before registering the revocation deed/deed of cancellation executed, on 29.09.2017 and registered, on 03.10.2017.

    7. Accordingly, the said deed of cancellation/deed of revocation is declared as null and void and that it is of no effect. As a sequel to the said finding that the cancellation deed or revocation deed is null and void and further, in view of the settled legal position that no one can convey a better title than what he/she has, it is to be further held that the subsequent sale deed executed by 4th respondent in favour of the 5th respondent is also not valid.

    8. Before parting, it is to be noted that the learned Government Pleader, while not disputing the settled legal position, had contended that if the petitioner is aggrieved of the cancellation or revocation deed he has to approach a civil Court and seek the common law remedy for setting aside the same but he cannot approach the writ Court. In the considered view of this Court such a contention needs a mention only to be rejected for the reason that when the cancellation deed or revocation deed unilaterally executed is null and void and that when such transaction is meaningless, it is just and fair to allow the writ petition leaving it open to the executant of the Cancellation deed or revocation deed to seek the common law remedy by approaching the Civil Court. Hence, liberty is reserved accordingly the non official respondents.

    9. In the result, the Writ Petition is accordingly, allowed as prayed for. Since this Court did not go into the correctness or otherwise of the contents of the subject cancellation or revocation deed and has set it aside and/or declared it as null and void, having regard to the legal position obtaining, this order shall not preclude the executant of the said cancellation or revocation deed to seek the common law remedy, which the law permits.

    There shall be no order as to costs.

    Miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand closed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kolli Rajesh Chowdary v. State of A.P., rep. ...
    (Mar 7, 2019)