1. The instant writ petition is filed by the Deputy Director, Enforcement Directorate, Kochi Zonal Office, aggrieved by the registration of Exhibit P1 FIR by the Crime Branch wing of the State Police. The essential facts leading to the writ petition, are as under:
On 06.07.2020, O.R.No.7 of 2020 was registered at the Customs Commissionerate (Preventive), Kochi, consequent to seizure of 30 Kgs of gold worth Rs.14.82 Crores at the Thiruvananthapuram International Airport. The seizure was effected while the gold was being smuggled, camouflaging it as diplomatic baggage to the UAE Consulate. During the course of investigation it was revealed that the accused had committed offences under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 (UAPA) also. This resulted in the National Investigation Agency (NIA) registering a case against the very same accused, alleging commission of offences under Sections 17 and 18 of the UAPA. As the investigation progressed further, commission of the offence punishable under Section 4 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (PMLA) also came to light. Thereupon, ECIR/KCZO0/31/2020 was registered by the Enforcement Directorate (ED) on 13.07.2020 arraigning three persons as accused, one Smt. Swapna Suresh being the second accused and Sri. Sandeep Nair, the fourth accused. After registration of the case, the ED filed Exhibit P5 complaint before the Special Court for PMLA cases (Principal Sessions Court, Ernakulam. Later, two more persons were arraigned as accused, the fifth accused being the then Principal Secretary to the Chief Minister of Kerala. On the request of the Investigating Officer, custody of the second accused was given to the ED for seven days from 05.08.2020. The custody period was extended up to 14.08.2020 and thereafter, till 17.08.2020. During this period the accused were questioned and their statements under Section 50 of the PMLA recorded.
2. On 18.11.2020, an audio clip, purported to be that of Smt. Swapna Suresh, was aired by an online media channel, wherein she alleged that the ED officials had made her sign the Section 50 statements without allowing her to read its contents and that, she had been compelled by the officials to implicate the Chief Minister of the State. On 20.11.2020, the Deputy Director of ED sent the Exhibit R1(a) letter to the Director General of Prisons and Correctional Services, requesting for a detailed enquiry about the circumstances under which the alleged audio recording took place and to take appropriate action against the culprits. The Director General of Prisons forwarded the letter to the State Police Chief, who in turn directed a special investigation team to be constituted for conducting preliminary enquiry. During the course of such enquiry, two Women Police Constables, who had been assigned protection duty of Smt. Swapna Suresh, while she was questioned by the ED officials, stated that, on 12.8.2020 and 13.8.2020, they had overheard the ED officials coercing and cajoling the accused to give statements implicating the Chief Minister and others. The allegation being serious, legal opinion was obtained and Exhibit P1 FIR registered against the ED officials for offences under Sections 116, 120B, 167, 192, 193 and 195A of IPC.
3. The challenge against registration of the FIR and legality of the Crime Branch investigation is led by Sri.Tushar Mehta, learned Solicitor General of India, supported by Sri. S.V.Raju and Sri.K.M.Nataraj, learned Additional Solicitors General appearing for the Enforcement Directorate and Central Bureau of Investigation. Sri. Harin P. Raval, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the State of Kerala countered their contentions and justified the action of the Crime Branch.
4. According to the learned Solicitor General, registration of the crime by the Crime Branch wing of the State Police, against the officers of a Central Agency alleging flaws and excesses during their investigation, militates against the very concept of cooperative federalism enshrined in the Constitution. Further, such action, if permitted, will impair the conduct of free, fair and impartial investigation by the Central Agencies. It is contended that the Special Court having taken cognizance of the offences, based on the complaint filed by the ED, only the Special Court alone empowered to consider the complaint of the accused and that, parallel investigation by the Crime Branch would impinge the credibility of the investigation so far conducted by the ED and would result in an incredulous situation of a Magistrate deciding upon the authenticity and genuineness of the statements given by the accused, in a case under consideration before a Sessions Judge (Special Judge). It is contended that the allegations based on which the crime is registered, even if accepted in their entirety, do not make out any cognizable offence. That, in view of the bar under Section 195(1)(b)(i) of the Cr.P.C, the very registration of the crime is illegal. Attention is drawn to the decision in Patel Laljibhai Somabhai v. State Of Gujarat ., [(1971) 2 SCC 376], wherein the Honourable Supreme Court has exposited on the purpose behind the enactment of Section 195 of the Cr.P.C.
5. Sri.S.V.Raju contended that abetment of an offence punishable with imprisonment under Section 116 of the IPC would apply only on the ingredients of Section 107 being satisfied, which, as far as the instant case is concerned, are completely absent. It is contended that, in order to attract Section 167 of the IPC, a public servant charged with the preparation or translation of any document or electronic record should have framed, prepared or translated that document or electronic document in a manner which he knows or believes to be incorrect. Further, such framing, preparation or translation should be with intention to cause or knowing that his action is likely to cause injury to any person. That, in the absence of any allegation of the ED officials having framed or prepared any document or electronic document, the offence under Section 167 of the IPC is not attracted. It is contended that none of the ingredients necessary to constitute the offence of fabricating false evidence under Section 192 of the IPC are made out and even in cases where the ingredients are made out, the prohibition under Section 195 of the Cr.P.C would apply. As regards the offence under Section 195A of the IPC, it is contended that only a witness or any other person can file a complaint in relation to the offence and the words “any other person” should be read ejusdem generis. Hence, a person totally unconnected to the witness and the case cannot file the complaint. Reference is made to the statement of the second accused dated 13.08.2020 wherein, to a query as to whether the Chief Minister of Kerala or his wife had called her personally and whether they were close to her, the second accused had answered that they were neither close to her nor had they called her personally and that all her conversations with the Chief Minister had been for official purposes only. It is contended that if the intention of the investigating officer was to implicate the Chief Minister, that answer would not have been recorded. According to the learned Counsel, falsity of the allegations is evident from the fact that, in spite of the repeated opportunities available to appraise the jurisdictional court of the attempt to coerce her, the second accused had never raised such a complaint. Reference is made to Exhibits P15 and P16 remand orders dated 11.08.2020 and 14.08.2020, wherein the Special Judge, after interacting with accused Nos.1, 2 and 4, had observed that the accused appeared to be in sound health and mind and had no complaints. Particular emphasis is laid on paragraph 7 of Exhibit P17 order, wherein the learned counsel for Smt. Swapna Suresh had alleged that his client was tortured during questioning by the Enforcement Officials, without the presence of a woman officer. It is hence contended that the unbelievable narrative about the presence of women civil police officers while Smt. Swapna Suresh was questioned by ED officials, is nothing but a cooked up story. 6. Sri. K.M.Nataraj focused on the bar under Section 195(1)(b)(i) of the Cr.P.C and contended that the very purpose of that provision is to prevent instances like the one under consideration. That, the alleged act of coercing the third accused to name innocent persons as her accomplices being in relation to a proceeding pending before the Special Court, registration of the crime and investigation into such allegation is barred. The distinction between Sections 195(1)(b)(i) and 195(1)(b)(ii) is pointed out by emphasising on the import of the words “in relation to any proceeding in any court” in the former, as against the words “in respect of a document produced or given in evidence in a proceeding in any court” in the latter. It is contended that the former expression is of much wider amplitude than the latter, as held in Bhima Razu Prasad v. State [2021 SCC OnLine 210]. It is argued that the offence under Section 195A of the IPC would be attracted only if a person is threatened to give false evidence in court and not otherwise. In support of the proposition, attention is drawn to the latter part of Section 195A, dealing with the conviction of an innocent person in consequence of “such false evidence” and the definition of the word ‘evidence’ under Section 3 of the Indian Evidence Act.
7. Sri.Harin P. Raval countered the arguments and questioned the maintainability of the writ petition at the instance of an officer of the ED, without even mentioning whether the petition is filed in his individual capacity or as per the decision of the ED. Learned Senior Counsel took strong exception to the production of documents pertaining to the ongoing ED investigation along with the writ petition and later as additional documents. It is contended that the documents are produced without adhering to the procedure prescribed under Rule 147 of the High Court Rules and moreover, they have nothing to do with the issue raised in the writ petition. The purpose behind production of documents, it is submitted, is more to tarnish the name of certain highly placed personalities in the State Government, rather than substantiating the contentions in the writ petition. According to the learned Senior Counsel, the attempt of the learned Solicitor General and other counsel is to divert the attention of the Court from the cardinal issue, by raising a rhetorical contention that investigation by the Crime Branch would impinge the investigation of the ED case and the authenticity of the statements recorded under Section 50 of the PMLA. It is contended that the court should see through the smoke screen attempted to be created and address the real issue involved. The real issue being the authority, or rather the duty, of the Police to register a crime when commission of cognizable offences are brought to its notice. In support of this argument, reliance is placed on the decision of the Privy Council in King-Emperor v. Khwaja Nazir Ahmad [AIR 1945 PC 18] and of the Supreme Court in Abhinandan Jha and Others v. Dinesh Mishra [(1967) 3 SCR 668], State of Bihar and Another v. J.A.C.Saldanha and Others [(1980) 1 SCC 554] and the Constitutional Bench decision in Lalita Kumari v. Government of Uttar Pradesh and Others [(2014) 2 SCC 1]. It is contended that the bar under Section 195 of the Cr.P.C is only against taking cognizance and does not interdict investigation by the Police. Support for this argument is garnered from the decisions in State of Punjab v. Raj Singh and Another [(1998) 2 SCC 391], M.Narayandas v. State of Karnataka and Others [(2003) 11 SCC 251], Shafi v. Abdul Salam [2017 (4) KHC 929] and Nirmaljit Singh Hoon v. The State of West Bengal and Another [(1973) 3 SCC 753]. It is submitted that the attempt of the petitioner is to somehow thwart the investigation and prevent the truth from coming out, which is evident from the undue haste with which the writ petition has been filed. That, the petitioner and other officials of the ED had compelled and coerced the accused to give statements implicating highly placed personalities in the State Government, which is a heinous offence that needs to be unearthed and the culprits brought to book. It is also contended the the statements of the accused, recorded while they were in ED custody, cannot be termed as statements under Section 50(3) of PMLA. The circumspection required while exercising the inherent power under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C and the well settled position of the High Court being not expected to sift the evidence for deciding factual issues involved, while exercising such power, is reiterated with the aid of authorities.
W.P(C).No.8920 of 2021
8. The challenge in this writ petition is against the registration of Crime No.98/CD/ALP/D/2021 at the Crime Branch Police Station, Ernakulam, vide Exhibit P1 FIR dated 27.03.2021. The short facts, leading to the registration of the crime are as under:
Sri.Sandeep Nair, presently the fourth accused in ECIR/ACZO/31/2020 registered by the Enforcement Directorate, had sent Exhibit P2 letter dated 05.03.2021 to the Special Judge, alleging that he was compelled by the petitioner to name the Chief Minister and certain others as accomplices to the crime. News about the letter published in the visual media was noticed by Advocate R.Sunil Kumar, a practising lawyer. Being of opinion that the deliberate attempt to drag the State’s Chief Minister and others into the crime should be investigated, Advocate Sunil Kumar sent a complaint to the Additional Director General of Police (Crime Branch). Thereupon, Exhibit P1 FIR (Crime No. 98 of 2021) was registered for offences under Sections 116, 167, 192, 193 and 195A of IPC. During the course of investigation of the crime, the Crime Branch sought permission to question and record the statement of Sri. Sandeep Nair from the Central Prison, Thiruvananthapuram and the request was allowed by the Special Court as per Exhibit P3 order. The challenge in this writ petition is against Exhibit P1 FIR and Exhibit P3 order and is founded on the same grounds as in W.P(C).No.7641 of 2021. The additional ground of challenge is that registration of a second crime, based on the very same allegations as in the first crime, is barred. In support of this challenge, reference is made to the statement in the first crime (Crime No. 94 of 2021), of another accused in the case, Sri.Sandeep Nair, having also written a similar complaint to the District and Sessions Judge, Ernakulam alleging threat and coercion to give false evidence against the Chief Minister and that the entire matter require an indepth investigation by registering an FIR. Countering the challenge, learned counsel for the respondent State highlighted the marked differences between the incidents and the allegations in the two crimes, which, according to the learned counsel, can, by any stretch of imagination, be treated to be the same or even similar. Elaborate legal contentions are put forth by both sides, relying on the decisions of the Apex Court in Ram Lal Narang v. State (Delhi Administration) .) [(1979) 2 SCC 322], State of West Bengal v. Swapan Kumar Guha and Others [(1982) 1 SCC 561], T.T.Antony v. State of Kerala and Others [(2001) 6 SCC 181], Upkar Singh v. Ved Prakash and Others [(2004) 13 SCC 292], etc.
9. The legal issues arising for consideration in both writ petitions, except the challenge on the ground that Exhibit P1 in W.P(C).8920 of 2021 is the second FIR, being common, both writ petitions are being considered together.
10. The challenge against maintainability of the writ petition on the premise that the petitioner has filed the case in his individual capacity cannot hold good. Undoubtedly, the writ petition is filed by the petitioner in his capacity as the Investigating Officer in ECIR/ACZO/31/2020. The fact that, the writ petition is filed with official sanction is evident from the appearance of the learned Solicitor General. At the same time, I find substance in the objection raised by the Sri. Raval against the manner in which the documents pertaining to the ED case is produced and persons, who are not made parties, named in the writ petition. The explanation offered for production of the documents is that they form part of Exhibit P5 complaint. If that be so, the petitioner ought to have produced the entire set of documents appended to Exhibit P5 complaint, rather than producing the documents of his choice. Even though the petitioner's action is liable to be deprecated, that does not warrant dismissal of the writ petition.
11. Moving on to the merits of the contentions urged, the first and foremost is the contention based on the prohibition under Section 195 of the Cr.P.C. Needless to say that the finding on that contention will have an impact on the other legal points. Indisputably, the crimes are registered for offences punishable under Sections 116, 120B, 167, 192, 193 and 195A of the IPC of which, Section 193 is an offence falling within the ambit of Section 195(1)(b)(i) of the Cr.P.C. In order to understand the scope and ambit of Section 195 of Cr.P.C, it is necessary to analyse and understand the provision.
“195. Prosecution for contempt of lawful authority of public servants, for offences against public justice and for offences relating to documents given in evidence.—
(1) No Court shall take cognizance—
(a)(i) of any offence punishable under Sections 172 to 188 (both inclusive) of the Indian Penal Code (45 of 1860), or
(ii) of any abetment of, or attempt to commit, such offence, or
(iii) of any criminal conspiracy to commit such offence,
except on the complaint in writing of the public servant concerned or of some other public servant to whom he is administratively subordinate;
(b)(i) of any offence punishable under any of the following sections of the Indian Penal Code (45 of 1860), namely, Sections 193 to 196 (both inclusive), 199, 200, 205 to 211 (both inclusive) and 228, when such offence is alleged to have been committed in, or in relation to, any proceeding in any Court, or
(ii) of any offence described in Section 463, or punishable under Section 471, Section 475 or Section 476, of the said Code, when such offence is alleged to have been committed in respect of a document produced or given in evidence in a proceeding in any Court, or
(iii) of any criminal conspiracy to commit, or attempt to commit, or the abetment of, any offence specified in subclause (i) or sub-clause (ii),
except on the complaint in writing of that Court 115[or by such officer of the Court as that Court may authorise in writing in this behalf], or of some other Court to which that Court is subordinate.
(2) Where a complaint has been made by a public servant under clause (a) of sub-section (1) any authority to which he is administratively subordinate may order the withdrawal of the complaint and send a copy of such order to the Court; and upon its receipt by the Court, no further proceedings shall be taken on the complaint:
Provided that no such withdrawal shall be ordered if the trial in the Court of first instance has been concluded.
(3) In clause (b) of sub-section (1), the term “Court” means a Civil, Revenue or Criminal Court, and includes a tribunal constituted by or under a Central, Provincial or State Act, if declared by that Act to be a Court for the purposes of this section.
(4) For the purposes of clause (b) of sub-section (1), a Court shall be deemed to be subordinate to the Court to which appeals ordinarily lie from the appealable decrees or sentences of such former Court, or in the case of a Civil Court from whose decrees no appeal ordinarily lies, to the principal Court having ordinary original civil jurisdiction within whose local jurisdiction such Civil Court is situate:
Provided that—
(a) where appeals lie to more than one Court, the Appellate Court of inferior jurisdiction shall be the Court to which such Court shall be deemed to be subordinate;
(b) where appeals lie to a Civil and also to a Revenue Court, such Court shall be deemed to be subordinate to the Civil or Revenue Court according to the nature of the case or proceeding in connection with which the offence is alleged to have been committed.”
12. The purpose of enacting Section 195 (Criminal Procedure Code 1898, which is in pari materia with Section 195 of the 1973 Code) was considered by the Apex Court in Patel Laljibhai Somabhai v. State Of Gujarat ., [(1971) 2 SCC 376]. The relevant portion of the said judgment reads as under:
“The underlying purpose of enacting Section 195(1)(b) and (c) and Section 476, seems to be to control the temptation on the part of the private parties considering themselves aggrieved by the offences mentioned in those sections to start criminal prosecutions on frivolous, vexatious or insufficient grounds inspired by a revengeful desire to harass or spite their opponents. These offences have been selected for the court's control because of their direct impact on the judicial process. It is the judicial process, in other words the administration of public justice, which is the direct and immediate object or victim of those offence and it is only by misleading the courts and thereby perverting the due course of law and justice that the ultimate object of harming the private party is designed to be realised. As the purity of the proceedings of the court is directly sullied by the crime, the Court is considered to be the only party entitled to consider the desirability of complaining against the guilty party. The private party designed ultimately to be injured through the offence against the administration of public justice is undoubtedly entitled to move the court for persuading it to file the complaint. But such party is deprived of the general right recognized by Section 190 CrPC, of the aggrieved parties directly initiating the criminal proceedings. The offences about which the court alone, to the exclusion of the aggrieved private parties, is clothed with the right to complain may, therefore, be appropriately considered to be only those offences committed by a party to a proceeding in that court, the commission of which has a reasonably close nexus with the proceedings in that court so that it can, without embarking upon a completely independent and fresh inquiry, satisfactorily consider by reference principally to its records the expediency of prosecuting the delinquent party. It, therefore, appears to us to be more appropriate to adopt the strict construction of confining the prohibition contained in Section 196(1)(c) only to those cases in which the offences specified therein were committed by a party to the proceeding in the character as such party.”
The reason behind bringing certain specified offences under the purview of Section 195 of the Cr.P.C is because the commission of those offences have direct impact on an ongoing judicial proceeding and thereby, on the administration of justice. Section 193 of the IPC being one such offence, the prohibition under Section 195 of the Cr.P.C will apply.
13. The next question is whether the prohibition under Section 195(1)(b)(i) of Cr.P.C is from taking cognizance only or whether the Police is interdicted from conducting investigation of the offences enumerated in the section. Senior Counsel Shri.Harin P. Rawal argued with the aid of precedents that Section 195(1)(b) does not prohibit registration of crimes and investigation by the police. This argument is countered by Senior Counsel Sri. K.M. Nataraj, by drawing a distinction between Sections 195(1)(b)(i) and 195(1)(b)(ii). It is contended that all the offences mentioned in Section 195(1)(b)(i) are non-cognizable and hence the Police cannot register crime without following the procedure under Section 155 of the Cr.P.C and that the provision considered in the decisions cited by Mr.Raval was Section 195(1)(b)(ii), wherein the offences are cognisable. In order to address the contention, it is necessary to consider the cited decisions.
14. In Nirmaljit Singh Hoon v. State of W.B., (1973) 3 SCC 753, the offences were under Sections 463, 471, 475, 476 of the IPC and hence the Apex Court held that police authorities have a statutory right under Sections 154 and 156 of the Code to investigate into a cognizable offence, without requiring any sanction from a judicial authority and even the High Court has no inherent power under Section 561-A of the Code (Section 482 of the new Code) to interfere with the exercise of that statutory power.
15. In State of Punjab v. Raj Singh [(1998) 2 SCC 391], the appeal had arisen from the order by which the High Court had quashed an FIR, registered during the course of a civil suit, alleging commission of offences under Sections 419, 420, 467 and 468 of the IPC. The FIR was quashed on the ground that Section 195(1)(b)(ii) of the Cr.PC prohibited entertainment of and investigation into the offences by the police. While interfering with that judgment the Honourable Supreme Court held that from a plain reading of Section 195 Cr.PC, it is manifest that the prohibition comes into operation only at the stage when the court intends to take cognizance of an offence under Section 190(1) Cr.PC, and it has nothing to do with the statutory power of the police to investigate into an FIR which discloses a cognizable offence, even if the offence is alleged to have been committed in, or in relation to, any proceeding in court. The Apex Court further held that the statutory power of the police to investigate under the Code is in no way controlled or circumscribed by Section 195 of the Cr.PC. That, upon the charge-sheet (challan), if any, filed on completion of the investigation into such an offence the court would not be competent to take cognizance thereof in view of the embargo of Section 195(1)(b) of the Cr.PC, but nothing therein deters the court from filing a complaint for the offence on the basis of the FIR (filed by the aggrieved private party) and the materials collected during investigation, provided it forms the requisite opinion and follows the procedure laid down in Section 340 of the Cr.PC.
16. The distinction between Sections 195(1)(b)(i) and 195(1(b)(ii) has been succinctly laid down in Narendra Kumar Srivastava v. State of Bihar, [(2019) 3 SCC 318] in the following words;
“13. It is clear from sub-section (1)(b) of Section 195 CrPC that the section deals with two separate set of offences:
(i) of any offence punishable under Sections 193 to 196 (both inclusive), 199, 200, 205 to 211 (both inclusive) and 228 IPC, when such offence is alleged to have been committed in, or in relation to, any proceeding in any court; [Section 195(1) (b)(i)]
(ii) of any offence described in Section 463, or punishable under Section 471, Section 475 or Section 476 IPC, when such offence is alleged to have been committed in respect of a document produced or given in evidence in a proceeding in any court. [Section 195(1)(b)(ii)].
14. On the reading of these sections, it can be easily seen that the offences under Section 195(1)(b)(i) and Section 195(1)(b)(ii) are clearly distinct. The first category of offences refers to offences of false evidence and offences against public justice, whereas, the second category of offences relates to offences in respect of a document produced or given in evidence in a proceeding in any court.