Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Court Opinion Summary: High Court of Karnataka (Dr. Justice H.B. Prabhakara Sastry) — Criminal Revision Petition No.586 of 2013

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent (complainant in trial) alleged that the petitioner (accused) had taken a loan of Rs. 18,000 on 03.02.1996 and, though agreeing to repay within eight months, failed to do so. The accused issued cheque No. 755481 dated 05.10.1996 drawn on State Bank of India, Hassan Branch, which was returned with the banker’s endorsement "payment stopped by drawer". A legal notice dated 16.10.1996 was issued to the accused demanding payment; payment was not made and a complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act (N.I. Act) was instituted.

The Trial Court (II Additional Civil Judge & JMFC, Hassan) convicted the accused on 16.10.2012 for the offence under Section 138 N.I. Act and sentenced him to one year simple imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 21,000 (Rs. 18,000 to the complainant and Rs. 3,000 to the State), with default imprisonment of six months for non-payment of fine. The accused appealed (Criminal Appeal No.154/2012) to the Additional Sessions Judge and Presiding Officer, Fast Track Court - I at Hassan, which by judgment dated 19.03.2013 dismissed the appeal and confirmed the conviction and sentence.

The accused filed the present Criminal Revision Petition under Sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C. seeking to set aside the Trial Court and Appellate Court judgments. At hearing before this Court, the accused's counsel stated he would not challenge the conviction but sought leniency on sentence, offering to pay the fine amount and relying on a decision of the Supreme Court (Meters and Instruments Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. v. Kanchan Mehta).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the sentence of one year simple imprisonment imposed on the petitioner for an offence under Section 138 of the N.I. Act (confirmed by the Appellate Court) should be modified in light of the petitioner's concession to pay the fine and his request for leniency.
  2. Whether the principles stated in the cited Supreme Court authority (Meters and Instruments Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. v. Kanchan Mehta) and related authorities justify mitigation of imprisonment in the present case.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner’s counsel expressly did not challenge the conviction affirmed by the Trial Court and Appellate Court; the prayer was confined to seeking a lenient view on the sentence of imprisonment.
  • The petitioner was willing and ready to pay the entire fine amount (Rs. 21,000) without delay and requested that imprisonment be set aside or reduced.
  • Counsel relied on the Supreme Court judgment in METERS AND INSTRUMENTS PRIVATE LIMITED AND ANOTHER v. KANCHAN MEHTA (reported (2018) 1 SCC 560), particularly paragraph 11 of that judgment, to support mitigation of sentence where compensation/repayment meets the ends of justice.

The respondent remained unrepresented at the hearing; no detailed counter-arguments are recorded in the opinion.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
METERS AND INSTRUMENTS PRIVATE LIMITED AND ANOTHER v. KANCHAN MEHTA, (2018) 1 SCC 560 Paragraph 11: Observations that post-2002 amendment, Section 143 of the N.I. Act permits discharge where the complainant is compensated to the Court's satisfaction; scope of Section 138 is not intended to punish a drawer whose conduct is reasonable or where compensation meets the ends of justice — particularly where the accused pleads guilty under Section 252 Cr.P.C. The petitioner relied on this decision to seek leniency. The Court considered the passage but distinguished its applicability because the accused did not plead guilty under Section 252 Cr.P.C. and had engaged in multiple rounds of litigation over many years; thus the Court did not apply full relief urged under this authority.
Subramanium Sethuraman v. State of Maharashtra, (2004) 13 SCC 324 Held that once the plea of the accused is recorded under Section 252 Cr.P.C., the procedure in Chapter XX Cr.P.C. must be followed to take the trial to its logical conclusion (decision rendered prior to the 2002 amendment). Cited within the discussion in Kanchan Mehta (paragraph 11 excerpt). The Court noted this decision was pre-2002 amendment and that post-amendment statutory scheme differs.
Mandvi Co-op. Bank Ltd. v. Badridas (reported (2010) 3 SCC 83) Considered in the context of the 2002 amendment to the Act; recognized the changed statutory scheme post-2002. Referenced in the excerpt from Kanchan Mehta to show that post-2002 authorities have interpreted Section 143 as conferring implied powers for certain compensatory resolutions; Court referenced this as part of the legal background but did not grant relief on that basis in view of case facts.
J.V. Baharuni (2014) 10 SCC 494 Also considered the post-2002 statutory scheme and the changed interpretation of Sections of the N.I. Act. Referenced in the same context as Mandvi Co-op. Bank to illustrate the post-amendment change in law; used as background authority in assessing the scope of paragraph 11 of Kanchan Mehta.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the record and the submissions. It noted that the petitioner limited his challenge to sentence and was prepared to pay the fine. The Court reviewed the Trial Court and Appellate Court judgments, and prior proceedings in the same matter.

Key factual and procedural observations made by the Court:

  • At the earliest point (07.09.2006), the accused had been convicted for the offence under Section 138 N.I. Act and sentenced to two months simple imprisonment with a fine of Rs. 3,000. That conviction was challenged in Criminal Appeal No.108/2006, which was allowed in part by the Sessions Judge on 01.03.2007 and remanded to the Trial Court.
  • After remand, the Trial Court again convicted the accused (dated 16.10.2012) and sentenced him to one year simple imprisonment and fine of Rs. 21,000, which was confirmed by the Appellate Court on 19.03.2013.
  • The accused has engaged in repeated litigation ("a voyage of two rounds" before the Trial Court and Sessions Judge) from 2000 onwards and has not pleaded guilty under Section 252 Cr.P.C.

Legal analysis and application:

  • The Court acknowledged the Supreme Court's observations in Kanchan Mehta and related authorities regarding the post-2002 amendment regime under Section 143 and the possibility of remedial/compensatory orders where appropriate. However, the Kanchan Mehta observations were particularly addressed to situations where the accused pleads guilty under Section 252 Cr.P.C. and/or where compensation to the complainant meets the ends of justice.
  • Because the petitioner did not plead guilty under Section 252 Cr.P.C., and had repeatedly contested the matter across multiple proceedings over many years (including an earlier conviction followed by remand and a later reconviction), the Court found the Kanchan Mehta rationale insufficient to entirely extinguish imprisonment in this case.
  • The Court also found that the one-year imprisonment imposed by the Trial Court (and affirmed by the Appellate Court) lacked stated reasons and was disproportionate and "slightly exorbitant" relative to the proven guilt. The Court compared the present sentence to the earlier two-month sentence imposed in 2006, deeming two months to be reasonable in the circumstances.

Holding and Implications

The revision petition is partly allowed.

Holding (core ruling):

  • The Court confirmed the conviction of the accused for the offence punishable under Section 138 of the N.I. Act as recorded by both the Trial Court and the Appellate Court.
  • The Court modified the Order on sentence: the sentence of imprisonment was reduced from one year simple imprisonment to two months simple imprisonment; the default sentence was reduced accordingly to one month's simple imprisonment.
  • The fine of Rs. 21,000 remained confirmed (with Rs. 18,000 to be paid to the complainant and Rs. 3,000 to the State), and the apportionment of the fine as found by the Trial and Appellate Courts remained unaltered.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: the accused's conviction stands; his term of imprisonment is reduced from one year to two months and the default period is reduced to one month; he remains liable to pay the confirmed fine of Rs. 21,000 with the same apportionment.
  • The Court reached its decision by applying established authority (as discussed above) but conditioned relief on factual features of the case (absence of a guilty plea under Section 252 Cr.P.C., multiple rounds of contested litigation, and the disproportionate nature of the one-year sentence). The opinion does not purport to set a new legal precedent beyond this factual application.

Order direction: Registry was directed to transmit a copy of this judgment to the Trial Court and Appellate Court along with their records forthwith.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    M.G. Raju v. H.T. Ravindra Kumar .

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

    DATED THIS THE 4TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2021

    BEFORE

    THE HON'BLE Dr. JUSTICE H.B.PRABHAKARA SASTRY CRIMINAL REVISION PETITION No.586 OF 2013

    BETWEEN:

    M.G. Raju S/o Late Madhvanda Rao, Aged about 54 years, Senior Technician, C/o INSAT, M.E.F., HASSAN - 573 201. :PETITIONER (By Sri Chethan B, Advocate)

    AND:

    H.T. Ravindra Kumar S/o Thimmappa, Aged about 45 years, Resident of Vedio Palace, Saraswathipuram,

    Salagame Road,

    Hassan - 573 201. :RESPONDENT (Respondent is served) This Criminal Revision Petition is filed under Section 397 read with S.401 of Cr.P.C. praying to set aside the Judgment dated 16.10.2012 passed by the II Additional

    1

    2

    Civil Judge and JMFC at Hassan in C.C. No.1131/2000 and the Judgment dated 19.03.2013 passed by the Addl. Sessions Judge and P.O., FTC - I at Hassan in Crl. A. No.154/2012 and such other order as the Court deems fit in the circumstances of the case.

    This Criminal Revision Petition coming on for Admission through Physical Hearing/Video Conferencing this day, the Court made the following:

    ORDER

    Present revision petition is by the accused who was convicted for the offence punishable under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (for brevity, hereinafter referred to as 'the N.I. Act'), by the learned II Addl. Civil Judge & JMFC, Hassan in C.C. No.1131/2000 by its impugned Judgment of conviction and Order on sentence dated 16.10.2012. He preferred an appeal challenging his conviction, in Criminal Appeal No.154/2012 in the Court of learned Additional Sessions Judge and the Presiding Officer, Fast Track Court - I at

    3

    Hassan (for brevity, 'Sessions Judge's Court') which Court by its impugned Judgment dated 19.03.2013 dismissed the appeal confirming the Judgment passed by the Trial Court in C.C. No.1131/2000 dated 16.10.2012. Aggrieved by the same, the accused has preferred the present revision petition.

    2. The present respondent has been the complainant in the Trial Court. The summary of the case of the complainant in the Trial Court is that the accused being known to him had availed a loan of `18,000/- from him on 03.02.1996 to meet the expenses of his sister's marriage. Though he had agreed to repay the loan amount within eight months, but he did not repay the said loan. However, towards the repayment of the loan, he issued a cheque to the complainant, bearing No.755481 dated 05.10.1996 drawn on State Bank of India, Hassan Branch. When the said cheque was presented by the complainant through his banker, the same came to be returned with the banker's endorsement "payment stopped by drawer".

    4

    It was thereafter the complainant got issued a legal notice to the accused on 16.10.1996 demanding the payment of the cheque amount. Even after the said legal notice, the accused did not pay the cheque amount. Hence, the complainant was constrained to institute the complaint against him.

    The accused appeared in the Trial Court and contested the matter. After recording the evidence led by both side and hearing the arguments, the Trial Court by its Judgment dated 16.10.2012 convicted the accused for the alleged offence punishable under Section 138 of the N.I. Act and sentenced him to undergo simple imprisonment for a period of one year and also to pay a fine of `21,000/-. In default to make payment of the fine amount, the accused was ordered to undergo simple imprisonment for a period of six months. Out of the fine amount of `21,000/-, a sum of `18,000/- was directed to be paid to the complainant and remaining sum of `3,000/- was directed to be paid to the State. Challenging the said Judgment of conviction and

    5

    Order on sentence, the petitioner preferred Crl.A. No.154/2012 in the Sessions Judge's Court which Court by its Judgment dated 19.03.2013, dismissed the appeal while confirming the Judgment of conviction and Order on sentence passed by the Trial Court. It is against the said Judgments of conviction and Order on sentence the accused has preferred the present revision petition.

    3. In spite of service of notice upon the respondent, he has remained unrepresented.

    4. Learned counsel for the petitioner in his single sentence argument submitted that he would not challenge the impugned Judgment of conviction passed by the Trial Court which was affirmed by the Appellate Court, however, he would only request this Court to take a lenient view on the order on sentence. He further submits that the petitioner / accused is ready to pay the entire fine amount, but however, the sentence of imprisonment may be set aside. In his support, he relies upon a Judgment of the

    6

    Hon'ble Apex Court in METERS AND INSTRUMENTS PRIVATE LIMITED AND ANOTHER Vs. KANCHAN MEHTA,

    reported in (2018) 1 SCC 560 and draws the attention of this Court to paragraph 11 of the said Judgment.

    5. In view of the above submission, though the matter is listed for admission, it is heard for final disposal. Perused the materials placed before this Court including the impugned Judgment passed by both the Trial Court and Sessions Judge's Court.

    6. In view of the fact that the petitioner through his counsel has submitted that he would not dispute or challenge his conviction for the offence punishable under Section 138 of the N.I. Act but would only request this Court to take a lenient view so far as the sentence of imprisonment is concerned, it is not required to go into the merits of the case so far as conviction of the petitioner for the offence under Section 138 of the N.I. Act is concerned. Since the revision petitioner himself now confines the present petition only in challenging the sentence of

    7

    imprisonment but not his conviction for the offence punishable under Section 138 of the N.I. Act as well the order of sentence to pay a fine amount of `21,000/-, it is taken that the said aspect of Judgment of conviction and Order on sentence imposing a fine of `21,000/- be need not revisited or revised.

    7. The contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner is that since the petitioner / accused is ready and willing to pay the entire fine amount without any further delay, the Court may take a lenient view in the matter. He relies upon KANCHAN MEHTA's case (supra) in his support and draws the attention of the Court to paragraph 11 of the said Judgment which reads as below:

    " 11. While it is true that in Subramanium Sethuraman versus State of Maharashtra [(2004)

    13 SCC 324] this Court observed that once the plea of the accused is recorded under Section 252 of the CrPC, the procedure contemplated under Chapter XX of the CrPC has to be followed to take the trial to its logical conclusion, the said judgment was rendered as per statutory provisions prior to

    8

    the 2002 amendment. The statutory scheme post- 2002 amendment as considered in Mandvi Coop. Bank [(2010) 3 SCC 83] and J.V. Baharuni [ (2014)

    10 SCC 494] has brought about a change in law and it needs to be recognised. After 2002 amendment, Section 143 of the Act confers implied power on the Magistrate to discharge the accused if the complainant is compensated to the satisfaction of the Court, where the accused tenders the cheque amount with interest and reasonable cost of litigation as assessed by the Court. Such an interpretation was consistent with the intention of legislature. The court has to balance the rights of the complainant and the accused and also to enhance access to justice. Basic object of the law is to enhance credibility of the cheque transactions by providing speedy remedy to the complainant without intending to punish the drawer of the cheque whose conduct is reasonable or where compensation to the complainant meets the ends of justice. Appropriate order can be passed by the Court in exercise of its inherent power under Section 143 of the Act which is different from compounding by consent of parties. Thus, Section

    258 CrPC which enables proceedings to be stopped in a summons case, even though strictly speaking is not applicable to complaint cases, since the provisions of the CrPC are applicable "so far as may

    9

    be", the principle of the said provision is applicable to a complaint case covered by Section 143 of the Act which contemplates applicability of summary trial provisions, as far as possible, i.e. with such deviation as may be necessary for speedy trial in the context."

    8. A reading of the said Judgment more particularly the paragraph 11 therein would clearly go to show that the Hon'ble Apex Court has made the observation to the effect that the scope of Section 138 of the N.I. Act is not for punishing drawer of a cheque whose conduct is reasonable or where compensation to the complainant to meet the ends of justice was made specifically in those circumstances, where the accused pleads himself guilty under Section 252 Cr.P.C. It is at that stage the Hon'ble Apex Court observed that the punishment need not be the object of Section 138 of the N.I. Act when the accused voluntarily pleads guilty for the alleged offence.

    9. Whereas, in the instant case, a perusal of the materials placed before me, go to show that at the earliest

    10

    point of time that was on 07.09.2006, the accused was convicted for the offence punishable under Section 138 of the N.I. Act and was sentenced to undergo simple imprisonment for a period of two months and also to pay a fine of `3,000/- for the offence punishable under Section 138 of the N.I. Act. It appears that he challenged the said Judgment of conviction and Order on sentence in Crl. A. No.108/2006 before learned Additional Sessions Judge at Hassan, which Court by its Judgment dated 01.03.2007 appears to have allowed the appeal in part and by setting aside the Judgment of conviction had remanded the matter back to the Trial Court. It is thereafter the Trial Court proceeded with the matter and pronounced the impugned Judgment of conviction and Order on sentence on 16.10.2012. Subsequently, challenging the said Judgment of conviction of the Trial Court dated 16.10.2012, the present petitioner preferred criminal appeal before the Sessions Judge's Court in Crl. A. No.154/2012 which came

    11

    to be dismissed on its merit by the Judgment dated

    19.03.2013.

    10. Thus it is crystal clear that the revision petitioner / accused had made a voyage of two rounds before the Trial Court and the Sessions Judge's Court in the matter and prior to the remanding of the matter by the Sessions Judge's Court and subsequent to the remand of the matter also he was convicted and the same was confirmed. Therefore, the accused apart from not pleading guilty under Section 252 Cr.P.C. has made futile exercise from the year 2000 till date in proving his alleged innocence towards the alleged offence but he has failed in his repetitive attempts. In such a circumstance, I do not find any reasons for setting aside the sentence of imprisonment in toto. Considering the fact that at the earliest point of time when he was convicted for the first time in the same case by the Trial Court on 07.09.2006, he was sentenced to undergo imprisonment only for two months and also imposed with fine and in the impugned Judgment passed

    12

    by the Trial Court, it has not given any reason for sentencing him to undergo simple imprisonment for one year and also considering the fact that even the Sessions Judge's Court also has not given its reasoning for confirming the said sentence of imprisonment, I am of the view that the said sentence of imprisonment of one year as simple imprisonment apart from payment of the fine amount is not proportionate to the gravity of the proven guilt against the accused. On the other hand, it is slightly exorbitant to the proven guilt. Therefore, considering the facts and circumstances of the case and also of the fact that the accused made two trips before the Trial Court as well as the Session Judge's Court and thus has made a futile exercise in ensuring the setting aside of his conviction which consequently has made the complainant to be deprived of the cheque amount for more than two decades, I am of the view that confining the sentence only to the fine amount would not meet the ends of justice and imposing the sentence of imprisonment is also warranted

    13

    in the circumstances of the case. However, one year simple imprisonment imposed since being on the higher side, the circumstances of the case warrant confining it to two months simple imprisonment which was originally and at the earliest point of time imposed against him by the Trial Court in its Judgment dated 07.09.2006 and that would be reasonable. Accordingly, I proceed to pass the following:

    ORDER

    The revision petition is partly allowed. Though the Judgment of conviction for the offence punishable under Section 138 of the N.I. Act holding the accused / petitioner guilty of the alleged offence is confirmed, however, the Order on sentence is modified. While confirming the fine amount imposed at `21,000/- against the accused/petitioner, the sentence of imprisonment is reduced from one year to two months and the default sentence to one month's simple imprisonment. The rest of the finding of both the Trial Court as well as the Session

    14

    Judge's Court in the apportionment of the fine amount would remain unaltered.

    Registry to transmit copy of this Judgment to the Trial Court and Session Judge's Court along with their respective records forthwith.

    Sd/-

    JUDGE

    sac*

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M.G. Raju v. H.T. Ravindra Kumar .
    (Jan 4, 2021)