Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges

    State Bank Of India v. Siddhartha Computer International Through Its Partner Mr. Sushant Singh And Another

    1. The State Bank of India has preferred the present writ petition primarily to assail the impugned orders passed by the DRAT, whereby the DRAT has restrained the petitioner from delivering possession of the auction property to the auction purchaser, i.e. respondent No. 2. The impugned orders had been passed in an appeal preferred before the DRAT by respondent No. 1/Siddhartha Computer International, being aggrieved by the order dated 01.10.2020 passed by the DRT-I, New Delhi in S.A. No. 50/2020.

    2. The aforesaid S.A. was preferred by respondent No. 1 to seek quashing of the auction notice dated 10.09.2020 issued by the petitioner bank seeking to auction property bearing Flat No. C-64 (Front Side, First Floor, without roof rights), Inderpuri, New Delhi. The primary submission of the S.A. applicant before the DRT was that though the notice dated 10.09.2020 was published in newspapers namely Jansatta and Financial Express, the same had not been served upon the borrower/mortgagor. While dismissing the said application, the DRT, inter alia, observed as follows:

    “6. The present SA has been filed on behalf of M/s. Siddhartha Computer International, a partnership firm through its partner Mr. Sushant Singh. Mrs. Prabha Singh, the mortgagor who is the wife of Mr. Sushant Singh, partner of applicant firm has not been made a party in the present proceedings. The SA filed by Mrs. Prabha Singh has already been dismissed by my Ld. Predecessor vide order dated 09.07.2019. It is a matter of fact that both Mr. Sushant Singh and Mr. Prashant Singh are brother and are also partner in the applicant firm; whereas Mrs. Prabha Singh is the wife of Mr. Sushant Singh. Apparently, the notice was also given at the address where Mr. Sushant Singh has been residing as well as the applicant firm, wherein both are partners i.e. A-62, Lower Ground Floor, Inderpuri, New Delhi-110012. It is an admitted fact that Mrs. Prabha Singh is residing with Mr. Sushant Singh and Mr. Sushant Singh is one of the partners of applicant firm whereupon notice has been affixed.

    7. Further, it is also matter of fact that in the present matter, earlier auction was held on 26.02.2020 and the same was withdrawn and thereafter on 23.03.2020, another notice was issued to the applicant herein regarding the auction notice. Therefore, the factum of auction was already within the knowledge of all the parties. Due notice of the auction proceedings was given. Apart that, publication was carried out in two newspapers which has been admitted by the applicant. Due compliance of the auction proceedings was there. Considering all the material available on record, I find no infirmity or illegality in the auction notice dated 10.09.2020. Even the SA filed by Mrs. Prabha Singh, the mortgagor has already been declined vide order dated 09.07.2019. The property in question has been put to auction repeatedly and the said fact was well within the knowledge of the applicant.”

    3. As noted above, the respondent No. 1 assailed the aforesaid order passed by the DRT by way of an appeal before the DRAT being Miscellaneous Appeal No. 119/2020. The said appeal was taken up for consideration by the DRAT on 20.10.2020, on which date the DRAT, while adjourning the matter to 06.11.2020, directed as under:—

    “In the meanwhile. if the auction purchaser is delivered the possession of the property in question the same would be subject to further orders to be passed in this appeal. Let this also be communicated to the bank so that the auction purchaser is not kept in dark.”

    4. Thus, it would be seen that on 20.10.2020, the learned DRAT was of the view that ends of justice would be met, if it was ordered that the delivery of auction property to the auction purchaser would be subject to further orders to be passed in the appeal. It appears that on 06.11.2020, when the matter was next taken up by the learned DRAT, it was informed that the auction purchaser had sought extension of time for paying the entire sale consideration. The DRAT, therefore, recorded the statement of the counsel for the bank that the petitioner bank would not deliver physical possession of the property to the auction purchaser till full payment was received. Pertinently, the DRAT while adjourning the matter to 14.11.2020, permitted the bank to approach the Tribunal in case the balance payment was received from the auction purchaser even before the said date. It is not in dispute that the auction purchaser paid the balance consideration and therefore, the petitioner bank approached the DRAT by way of an application being I.A. No. 526/2020 seeking permission to deliver physical possession of the property to the auction purchaser. The DRAT has, however, not allowed the said application and instead proceeded to grant waiver of pre-deposit to the respondent No. 1 and after hearing the arguments in the main appeal, reserved judgment thereon. It is in this background that the petitioner bank has approached this Court with a grievance that even though the entire auction amount has been paid by the auction purchaser, i.e. respondent no. 2, the bank is not being permitted to deliver the possession of the property to it.

    5. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent No. 1 submits that since the judgment has already been reserved by the DRAT, possession may not be delivered to the auction purchaser till the said judgment is rendered. He further submits that even otherwise the petitioner has not assailed the order passed by the DRAT on 04.01.2021, which rejected its application seeking to deliver possession of the property to the auction purchaser and, therefore, the writ petition is not maintainable.

    6. At this stage, learned counsel for the petitioner points out that the DRAT has not rejected the petitioner's application on merits but has merely disposed of the same by observing that since the judgment in appeal has already been reserved, no orders were required to be passed on the application at this stage.

    7. Having heard learned counsels for the parties, we are of the view that there is absolutely no justification to withhold possession of the auction property from respondent No. 2, who admittedly has paid the entire auction amount/sale consideration. Even otherwise, no prejudice would be caused to respondent No. 1 if possession of the property were handed over to respondent no. 2, since respondent No. 1 is, in any case, not in possession thereof. The petitioner bank had admittedly taken over possession of the property much prior to the date of the auction.

    8. From the order dated 01.10.2020 passed by the DRT noted hereinabove, it appears that the borrowers have time and again made endeavours to somehow block the auction and delivery of possession of the mortgaged property. Pertinently, on 20.10.2020, the DRAT itself was of the view that possession could be delivered to the auction purchaser, subject to the outcome of the appeal. That being the admitted position, in our view, the learned DRAT was not justified in not permitting the petitioner to deliver possession of the property to respondent No. 2/the auction purchaser, as soon as the entire auction amount had been deposited.

    9. We, accordingly, allow this petition and direct the petitioner to proceed to deliver the possession of the auction property to respondent No. 2 without any further delay. The impugned orders stand modified to the aforesaid extent.

    10. It is, however, clarified that if any articles of the respondent No. 1 are found lying in the premises at the time of delivery of possession to respondent No. 2, the same shall be collected by respondent No. 1 for which purpose, notice of time fixed for delivery of possession shall be given to respondent No. 1, including through an e-mail to its counsel. However, in case respondent No. 1 fails to appear to take possession of its article on the date fixed, it shall be open to the petitioner bank to deal with the same in accordance with law.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Bank Of India v. Siddhartha Computer ...
    (Jan 11, 2021)