AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • PROBATION OF OFFENDERS ACT 1958
  • NATIONAL SECURITY ACT 1980
  • life.249. Section 2(d) of the PO Act
  • Rule 64 of the Model Rules
  • Amendment Act 1 of 1988.
  • Sub-section 2 of Section 4
  • law.246. Section 360 of the CrPC
  • Section 4 of the PO Act, 1958,
  • provisions of Act 14 of 1982. Preventive Detention
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • PROBATION OF OFFENDERS ACT 1958
  • NATIONAL SECURITY ACT 1980
  • life.249. Section 2(d) of the PO Act
  • Rule 64 of the Model Rules
  • Amendment Act 1 of 1988.
  • Sub-section 2 of Section 4
  • law.246. Section 360 of the CrPC
  • Section 4 of the PO Act, 1958,
  • provisions of Act 14 of 1982. Preventive Detention
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion addresses the state of the criminal justice system in Tamil Nadu based on data collected district-wise for the period 2013 to 2018, pursuant to orders of this Court dated 18/2/2019. The Court acknowledges the efforts of the police and prosecution in compiling and presenting this data. The opinion analyzes crime statistics, conviction and acquittal rates, and highlights discrepancies in data from certain districts. It further discusses systemic issues in policing, investigation, preventive detention, and the role of probation officers, culminating in the constitution of a committee to recommend reforms.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What reforms are necessary for the reformation, rehabilitation, and reintegration of convicts and accused persons into society?
  2. How can the quality of criminal investigations be improved in Tamil Nadu?
  3. What are the implications of the current preventive detention laws and their implementation in the State?
  4. What is the role and significance of probation officers and pre-sentencing reports in the criminal justice system?
  5. How should the criminal justice system balance punishment with the objective of reformation?

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Gujarat v. Hon'ble High Court of Gujarat, (1998) 7 SCC 392 Emphasis on reformation through punishment; recognition that circumstances transform individuals into criminals and that reformation should be the dominant objective of punishment. The Court relied on this precedent to highlight the importance of reforming offenders rather than condemning them as irredeemable, supporting a humane approach to sentencing.
Mohd. Giasuddin v. State of A.P, (1977) 3 SCC 287 Reformative profile of sentencing principles; criticism of harsh punitive measures without addressing underlying causes. Extracted to emphasize that punishment should awaken the inner being rather than merely inflict exterior compulsion, supporting rehabilitation.
Commr. of Police v. Sandeep Kumar, (2011) 4 SCC 644 Modern approach to criminal justice favors reform over lifelong branding as criminals; mercy and rehabilitation for offenders who show respect for law. The Court invoked this case to advocate for mercy and reform, citing Lord Denning’s reasoning on balancing law enforcement with compassion.
Kokaiyabai Yadav v. State of Chhattisgarh, (2017) 13 SCC 449 Use of punishment as incapacitation or reform; recognition of exemplary conduct as a basis for reform. The Court referred to this to support the proposition that the justice system’s objective is to reform criminals who understand their wrongdoing and desire to live lawfully.
Rajendra Pralhadrao Wasnik v. State of Maharashtra (Review Petition (Criminal) Nos. 306-307 of 2013), Decided on 12.12.2018 Importance of considering reformation, rehabilitation, and reintegration in sentencing; balanced approach to crime and criminal. Used to underline that courts must assess the possibility of reform and rehabilitation, not just the nature of the crime, and that social reintegration is a critical part of sentencing.
Mithilesh Kumar Kushwaha v. State, 2015 SCC OnLine Del 12325 Probation officers’ role in pre-sentencing reports and importance of impartial and professional assessments for rehabilitation. The Court highlighted deficiencies in probation officers’ training and impartiality, stressing the need for professional reports to aid sentencing decisions.
Sampurna Behura v. Union of India, (2018) 4 SCC 433 Detailed duties of probation officers; significance of social investigation reports for juvenile rehabilitation. Referred to emphasize the comprehensive role probation officers play in rehabilitation and social reintegration of juveniles and the need for proper training.
M.C.D v. State of Delhi, (2005) 4 SCC 605 Mandatory calling for probation officer's report before exercising powers under Section 4 of the Probation of Offenders Act. The Court cited this to stress the statutory requirement of probation reports in sentencing and their importance as a sentencing tool.
Morris v. Crown Office, (1970) 2 QB 114 Judicial approach to mercy and reform in sentencing, especially for youthful offenders. Invoked to illustrate the value of mercy and reformative approach in criminal justice.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by analyzing crime data from 2013 to 2018, noting an overall increase in crime rates in Tamil Nadu, with significant variations across districts and discrepancies in data reliability. It observed a high proportion of convictions arising from pleaded guilty cases, particularly in offences punishable with imprisonment up to three years. The Court identified systemic issues such as the tendency of police to register multiple FIRs against individuals for statistical purposes and to sustain preventive detention, often affecting young adults.

The Court critiqued the misuse of preventive detention laws, highlighting Tamil Nadu’s disproportionately high number of detenues compared to other states, and noted judicial interventions quashing many detention orders. It underscored the decline in the quality of police investigations and emphasized the need for dedicated investigation wings in police stations, alongside effective witness protection and regular training for police officers, especially to tackle cybercrime.

Drawing on neuroscience and philosophical insights, the Court challenged the traditional notion of free will in criminal behavior, advocating a shift in mindset towards viewing offenders as subjects for reformation and rehabilitation rather than mere punishment. It stressed that the criminal justice system must balance assessment of guilt with the potential for reform, reintegration, and social utility.

The opinion elaborated on the critical role of probation officers and pre-sentencing reports as essential tools for courts to assess the offender’s background and prospects for rehabilitation. It identified deficiencies in training and impartiality among probation officers and called for improved standards and sensitization, referencing statutory provisions and Supreme Court precedents that mandate the use of such reports.

Finally, the Court constituted a heterogeneous committee to recommend reforms aimed at improving reformation, rehabilitation, reintegration of offenders, and enhancing the quality of criminal investigations. It directed the committee to scrutinize and verify crime data for accuracy, and mandated government support for the committee’s functioning.

Holding and Implications

The Court constituted a committee tasked with formulating recommendations for reforms in the criminal justice system of Tamil Nadu, focusing on reformation, rehabilitation, reintegration of convicts, and improving investigation quality.

The direct effect of this decision is the institutionalization of a reform-oriented approach to criminal justice in Tamil Nadu through the committee’s work and subsequent implementation of its recommendations. The opinion emphasizes systemic changes without setting new legal precedents but reinforces existing jurisprudence advocating rehabilitation over mere punishment. The Court’s initiative aims to restore effective law enforcement and humane treatment of offenders, thereby impacting policy and practice within the State’s criminal justice framework.

    M. Murugesan And Another Petitioners/Accused v. State Rep. By The Inspector Of Police .

    N. Anand Venkatesh, J.:—

    ORDERS ON CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM

    1. Pursuant to the orders passed by this on 18/2/2019, details as required by this Court has been provided District wise for the period 2013 to 2018. Before proceeding further, this Court appreciates the sincere efforts taken by the DGP, the entire team of Police Officers and the learned Additional Public Prosecutor Tmt. M. Prabhavathi, who took sincere efforts to collect the data, collate them and present it before this Court. The data is extracted here under district wise. A Bar Graph is also prepared for serious offences punishable with imprisonment upto 7 years and above to get a birds eye view of the prevailing status.

    Note 1:—

    i. A careful analysis of the data compiled and submitted by the police reveals the following:

    ii. Tirunelveli district saw 12640 FIR's being registered in 2013 under the “upto 3 years category”. In 2017, the number for Tirunelveli in the same category was 12216 and, worryingly in 2018, the number stood at a record high of 15105 FIR's. Decreases were also spotted. Thus, for instance, in Sivagangai, the total decreased from 10162 in 2015 to 7531 in 2018 in the “upto 3 years category”. However, an overall assessment clearly reveals that the crime rate has been on the increase in the State. For instance, Greater Chennai appears to have seen a marked increase in the crime rate qua serious offences which is obvious from the fact that it recorded the highest number in the “upto 10 years category” with 297 FIR's in 2017 which rose to a record high of 476 FIR's in 2018. Similarly, in the “lifeimprisonment category” Greater Chennai recorded 203 FIR's in 2017 which rose to a record high of 230 FIR's in 2018, the highest in any district in the State.

    iii. Data as regards the conviction rate reveals a fairly large chunk of convictions fell in the pleaded guilty category in the “upto three years” category. For example, Coimbatore City recorded 1423 contested convictions and 9805 pleaded guilty cases in the “upto 3 years” category for 2013. In 2018, the number stood at 334 contested cases and 7161 pleaded guilty cases. A similar trend was noticed in Tirunelveli district which revealed that 817 contested cases and 3424 pleaded guilty cases in the “upto three years” category were recorded 2015. In 2018, the number of pleaded guilty cases in Tirunelveli district stood at a record high of 7351 in the same category. Out of a total of 3,35,749 cases of conviction in the “upto three years” category 2,85,646 cases ie., 85% of all convictions in the “upto three years” category were pleaded guilty cases.

    iv. In the “upto 10 years” category, 1017 cases of conviction were recorded out of which 302 cases ie., 29.6% were pleaded guilty cases. Similarly in the life imprisonment category, 868 cases of conviction were recorded out of which 171 cases ie., 19.7 % were pleaded guilty cases.

    v. As between the rate of conviction and the rate of acquittal, 3,35,749 cases of conviction and 54,052 cases of acquittal were noticed in the “upto three years” category. A converse trend is seen in the “upto 10 years” category where the aggregate figure for 2013-2018 stood at 1017 convictions (contested and pleaded guilty cases) in contrast to 1892 acquittals in the same period. In the “life imprisonment” category the aggregate number of convictions for the same period stood at 868 whereas the rate of acquittal was almost double at 1558 cases.

    vi. Ramanathapuram district recorded 101 acquittals in 2013 for the “above 7 years” category qua 24 convictions during the same period. The figure was at 100 acquittals qua 43 convictions in 2014 and 91 acquittals qua 48 convictions in 2015 for the same category, rising to 111 acquittals qua 63 convictions in 2016. The general trend, however, shows that the rate of acquittal far outweighs the rate of conviction in the serious offences category.

    Note 2:—

    A careful assessment of the data produced by the respondent police reveals that the data in relation to certain districts are skewed and do not portray the actual picture.

    i. For instance, data for Kanchipuram district reveals that all parameters in the above 7 years, upto 10 years and life imprisonment category were assigned the value “0” irresistibly indicating that the data for this district was patently skewed. Near similar patterns were noticed for Thiruvallur, Vellore, Thiruvannamalai, Villupuram, Pudukottai. Tanjore and Nagapattinam districts as well.

    ii. More particularly, in Pudukottai, Thanjavur, and Nagapattinam districts, data with respect to offences falling under the “above 7 years” and “up-to 10 years” category were strangely assigned the value “0” in all parameters, giving one a utopian impression that these districts are free from crime. In Thanjavur and Nagapattinam districts data in relation to serious offences punishable with life imprisonment were puzzlingly quantified with the value “0”. Judicial notice can obviously be taken of the fact that these figures are skewed and that they do not reflect the actual ground realities.

    iii. Discrepancies were also noticed in the data for Madurai District where the data in relation to offences under the “above 7 years category” were assigned the value “0” in all parameters. Identical discrepancies were noticed in the data pertaining to Madurai City as well.

    2. The artificial intelligence pioneer Marvin Minsk's once defined free will as “internal forces I do not understand”. People intuitively believe in free will, not just because we have this terrible human need for agency but also because most people know next to nothing about those internal forces. The criminal justice system starts with the premise that we have complete free will on our behaviours, Criminal or otherwise. The only exception being that of an act of a person of unsound mind and that to at the time when the offence is committed. Extensive studies in Neuroscience has conclusively proved that Free will is an illusion. Our wills are simply not of our own making. Thoughts and intentions emerge from background causes of which we are unaware and over which we exert no conscious control. We do not have the freedom we think we have. Take a moment to think about the context in which your next decision will occur: You did not pick your parents or the time and place of your birth. You didn't choose your gender or most of your life experiences. You had no control whatsoever over your genome or the development of your brain. And now your brain is making choices on the basis of preferences and beliefs that have been hammered into it over a lifetime-by your genes, your physical development since the moment you were conceived, and the interactions you have had with other people, events, and ideas. Where is the freedom in this? Yes, you are free to do what you want even now. But where did your desires come from?

    3. No one is born as a criminal. The men and women on death row have some combination of bad genes, bad parents, bad environments, and bad ideas (and the innocent, of course, have supremely bad luck). Which of these quantities, exactly, were they responsible for? No human being is responsible for his genes or his upbringing, yet we have every reason to believe that these factors determine his character. Our system of justice should reflect an understanding that any of us could have been dealt a very different hand in life. In fact, it seems immoral not to recognize just how much luck is involved in morality itself. Viewing human beings as natural phenomena need not damage our system of criminal justice. If we could incarcerate earthquakes and hurricanes for their crimes, we would build prisons for them as well. We fight emerging epidemics-and even the occasional wild animal-without attributing free will to them. Clearly, we can respond intelligently to the threat posed by dangerous people without lying to ourselves about the ultimate origins of human behavior. We will still need a criminal justice system that attempts to accurately assess guilt and innocence along with the future risks that the guilty pose to society. Certain criminals must be incarcerated to prevent them from harming other people. The moral justification for this is entirely straightforward: Everyone else will be better off this way. But the logic of punishing people will come undone-unless we find that punishment is an essential component of deterrence or rehabilitation.

    4. The above prelude becomes necessary in order to change our mindset in dealing with criminals who in majority of the cases require Reformation, Rehabilitation and Re-integration into the main stream of the society. A true barometer to assess a welfare state is to watch how it deals with its Criminals.

    5. One of the central aims of the criminal law is to reform the offender and to rehabilitate him in a bid to render him useful to society. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has repeatedly reiterated this important, and oft neglected area of criminal jurisprudence which lends a human face to the application of abstract legal principles. India is a signatory to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, adopted bythe General Assembly of the United Nations on 19 December, 1966. Article 10.03 of the ICCPR lays down as under:—

    “The penitentiary system shall comprise treatment of prisoners the essential aim of which shall be their reformation and social rehabilitation. Juvenile offenders shall be segregated from adults and be accorded treatment appropriate to their age and legal status.”

    6. In State of Gujarat v. Hon'ble High Court of Gujarat, (1998) 7 SCC 392 the Hon'ble Supreme Court said

    30. It is a grand transformation recorded in the epics that the hunter Valmiki turned out to be a poet of eternal recognition. If the powers which brought about that transformation had remained inactive, the world would have been poorer without the great epic “Ramayana”. History is replete with instances of bad persons transforming into men of great usefulness to humanity. The causes which would have influenced such swing may be of various kinds. Forces which condemn a prisoner and consign him to the cell as a case of irredeemable character belong to the pessimistic society which lacks the vision to see the innate good in man.

    31. The theory of reformation through punishment is grounded on the sublime philosophy that every man is born good but circumstances transform him into a criminal. The aphorism that “if every saint has a past every sinner has a future” is a tested philosophy concerning human life. V.R. Krishna Iyer, J. has taken pains to ornately fresco the reformative profile of the principles of sentencing in Mohd. Giasuddin v. State of A.P. [(1977) 3 SCC 287 : 1977 SCC (Cri) 496] The following passage deserves special mention in this context: (SCC pp. 289-90, para 7)

    “If the psychic perspective and the spiritual insight we have tried to project is valid, the police bully and the prison drill cannot ‘minister to a mind diseased’, nor tone down the tension, release the repression, unbend the perversion, each of which shows up as debased deviance, violent vice and behavioural turpitude. It is a truism, often forgotten in the hidden vendetta in human bosoms, that barbarity breeds barbarity, and injury recoils as injury, so that if healing the mentally or morally maimed or malformed man (found guilty) is the goal, awakening the inner being, more than torturing through exterior compulsions, holds out better curative hopes.”

    32. Reformation should hence be the dominant objective of a punishment and during incarceration, every effort should be made to recreate the good man out of a convicted prisoner. An assurance to him that his hard labour would eventually snowball into a handsome saving for his own rehabilitation would help him to get stripped of the moroseness and desperation in his mind while toiling with the rigours of hard labour during the period of his jail life. Thus, reformation and rehabilitation of a prisoner are of great public policy. Hence they serve a public purpose.

    7. In Commr. of Police v. Sandeep Kumar, (2011) 4 SCC 644, the Hon'ble Supreme Court reiterated as under

    “9. In this connection, we may refer to the character “Jean Valjean” in Victor Hugo's novel Les Miserables, in which for committing a minor offence of stealing a loaf of bread for his hungry family Jean Valjean was branded as a thief for his whole life. The modern approach should be to reform a person instead of branding him as a criminal all his life.

    10. We may also here refer to the case of Welsh students mentioned by Lord Denning in his book Due Process of Law. It appears that some students of Wales were very enthusiastic about the Welsh language and they were upset because the radio programmes were being broadcast in the English language and not in Welsh. They came up to London and invaded the High Court. They were found guilty of contempt of court and sentenced to prison for three months by the High Court Judge. They filed an appeal before the Court of Appeals. Allowing the appeal, Lord Denning observed:

    “I come now to Mr. Watkin Powell's third point. He says that the sentences were excessive. I do not think they were excessive, at the time they were given and in the circumstances then existing. Here was a deliberate interference with the course of justice in a case which was no concern of theirs. It was necessary for the Judge to show-and to show to all students everywhere-that this kind of thing cannot be tolerated. Let students demonstrate, if they please, for the causes in which they believe. Let them make their protests as they will. But they must do it by lawful means and not by unlawful. If they strike at the course of justice in this land-and I speak both for England and Wales-they strike at the roots of society itself, and they bring down that which protects them. It is only by the maintenance of law and order that they are privileged to be students and to study and live in peace. So let them support the law and not strike it down.

    But now what is to be done? The law has been vindicated by the sentences which the Judge passed on Wednesday of last week. He has shown that law and order must be maintained, and will be maintained. But on this appeal, things are changed. These students here no longer defy the law. They have appealed to this Court and shown respect for it. They have already served a week in prison. I do not think it necessary to keep them inside it any longer. These young people are no ordinary criminals. There is no violence, dishonesty or vice in them. On the contrary, there was much that we should applaud. They wish to do all they can to preserve the Welsh language. Well may they be proud of it. It is the language of the bards-of the poets and the singers-more melodious by far than our rough English tongue. On high authority, it should be equal in Wales with English. They have done wrong-very wrong-in going to the extreme they did. But, that having been shown, I think we can, and should, show mercy on them. We should permit them to go back to their studies, to their parentsand continue the good course which they have so wrongly disturbed.” (Vide Morris v. Crown Office [(1970) 2 QB 114 : (1970) 2 WLR 792 : (1970) 3 All ER 1079 (CA)], QB at p. 125C-H.)

    In our opinion, we should display the same wisdom as displayed by Lord Denning

    8. Recently, in Kokaiyabai Yadav v. State Of Chhattisgarh ., (2017) 13 SCC 449, Sikri, J (as he then was) made the following observations in an illuminating passage

    “6. If the object of our justice system is to reformthe criminal, the appellant's exemplary conduct has aptly fit the bracket. Punishment can be used as a method of reducing the incidence of criminal behaviour either by incapacitating and preventing them from repeating the offence or by reforming them into law-abiding citizens. Reforming criminals who understand their wrongdoing, are able to comprehend their acts, have grown and nurtured into citizens with a desire to live a fruitful life in the outside world have the capacity of humanising this world.”

    9. In Rajendra Pralhadrao Wasnik v. State of Maharashtra (Review Petition (Criminal) Nos. 306-307 of 2013 In Criminal Appeal Nos. 145-146 of 2011 Decided on December 12, 2018), Justice Madan Lokur, in his swansong, observed as under:

    53. Consideration of the reformation, rehabilitation and re-integration of the convict into society cannot be over-emphasised. Until Bachan Singh, the emphasis given by the courts was primarily on the nature of the crime, its brutality and severity. Bachan Singh placed the sentencing process into perspective and introduced the necessity of considering the reformation or rehabilitation of the convict. Despite the view expressed by the Constitution Bench, there have been several instances, some of which have been pointed out in Bariyar and in Sangeet v. State of Haryana where there is a tendency to give primacy to the crime and consider the criminal in a somewhat secondary manner. As observed in Sangeet “In the sentencing process, both the crime and the criminal are equally important.” Therefore, we should not forget that the criminal, however ruthless he might be, is nevertheless a human being and is entitled to a life of dignity notwithstanding his crime. Therefore, it is for the prosecution and the courts to determine whether such a person, notwithstanding his crime, can be reformed and rehabilitated. To obtain and analyse this information is certainly not an easy task but must nevertheless be undertaken. The process of rehabilitation is also not a simple one since it involves social re-integration of the convict into society. of course, notwithstanding any information made available and its analysis by experts coupled with the evidence on record, there could be instances where the social re-integration of the convict may not be possible. If that should happen, the option of a long duration of imprisonment is permissible.

    Criminal Justice Scenario in our State

    10. I had the advantage of handling Criminal side portfolio for the last 9 months and I was able to observe a pattern in the manner in which FIR's are registered by the police. The data provided by the police and referred supra, by itself gives sufficient indications. There is a clear tendency to keep adding FIR's against a person who is caught in a particular crime. This is more so in cases of theft, robbery, NDPS offences, Prohibition offences etc., and petty crimes, where it is done for the purpose of statistics. In many of the FIRs even the description of the incident and the wordings are a replica. This is done just to rope these persons into an occurrence of which they are not even remotely connected. In many FIRs this Court found that the accused person inroduced themselves by revealing their names and thereafter proceeded to commit theft. The very reading of such FIRs will show that the incident that is projected in the FIR is a figment of imagination of the Police and it is done only with a view to keep adding FIRs against a particular person or persons. By doing this, the system ensures that these persons never get out of the criminal net and their whole life goes like that.

    11. Yet another pattern that is seen is in cases where persons are involved in serious crimes like Murder, Decoity etc., The police keep adding FIR's against these persons for Criminal Intimidation, attempt to Murder, Grevious Hurt, involving more number of accused person and add these persons based on alleged confession of Co-accused. By doing this a ground is created for detaining them under the preventive detention laws and thereby ensure that these accused persons don't come out of jail for sometime. Unfortunately in most of these cases, this court was able to notice that the accused persons were in the age group of 19-25 years.

    12. In 1982, Ordinance 1 of 1982 was promulgated by the Governor of Tamil Nadu titled “Tamil Nadu Prevention of Dangerous Activities of Bootleggers, Drug Offenders, Goondas, Immoral Traffic Offenders and Slum Grabbers Ordinance, 1982”. The statement of object and reasons, so far as they are presently relevant, reads as under:

    “5. In order to ensure that the maintenance of public order in this State is not adversely affected by the activities of these five classes of known anti-social elements without resorting to the National Security Act, 1980, it was considered necessary to enact a special legislation to provide as follows:—

    (a) To define with precision the terms “bootleggers”, “drug offender”, “goonda”, “immoral traffic offender” and “slum-grabber”;

    (b) To specify their activities which adversely affect public order; and

    (c) To provide for preventive detention of the persons indulging in these dangerous activities.”

    13. The ordinance was replaced by Act 14 of 1982 with effect from 10.02.1982. Forest offenders were subsequently added to the original five categories of offenders vide Amendment Act 1 of 1988. Video Pirates and Sand Offenders were added in 2004 and 2006 respectively. In 2014, cyber law offenders and sexual offenders were added to the kitty taking the total tally to 10.

    14. While Act 14 of 1982 has grown in size, so has the litigation surrounding the challenge to detention orders passed under its provisions. It is a classic example the operation of Parkinson's 4 law; expansion leads to complexity.

    15. A perusal of the statistics published by the National Crime Records Bureau reveal an outrageously sorry state of affairs. In 2011 Tamil Nadu reported 523 detenues under preventive detention, the highest number in any State across India. In 2012, the number was 1781. In second place was Gujarat with 646 detenues (roughly 1/3 of TN). In 2013, the number was 1892, with Gujarat once again in 2 place at 594. In 2014, Tamil Nadu retained its unenviable first place with 1268 detentions with Telengana and Karnataka coming in 2 and 3 place with 339 and 232 detentions respectively. In 2015, the number was 1481 accounting for 47.9% of all detentions across the country. Even an insurgency ridden State like Jammu and Kashmir reported only 432 detentions accounting for 14% of the total number across the country.

    16. These statistics tellingly point to the callous and often indifferent manner in which the authorities have gone about resorting to the provisions of Act 14 of 1982. Preventive Detention law has become a shield for shabby and defective policing. The very fact that Tamil Nadu has retained its unenviable first place in the number of detenues in all States would clearly show that law and order in this State is clearly resting on rickety foundations.

    17. The Courts, on their part, have been handing down one decision after another reminding the authorities that preventive detention cannot be resorted to for the asking. As a matter of fact, an examination of the orders passed by the Madras High Court in April 2017 alone (as uploaded on to www.judis.nic.in) reveals that 313 out of 358 petitions were allowed and detention orders were quashed. In the residual 45 cases, most of them had become infructuous either due to the period of detention having lapsed or on account of the order being revoked by the Government.

    18. The situation calls for a thorough revamping of the Criminal Justice system in this State. It looks like the police are caught into this Vicious cycle. That shows on the poor record of convictions in serious crimes. Instead of finding a complete cure for the disease, police seem to be looking for temporary solutions without curing the disease. Unless we agree that there is a serious problem, there is no scope for change/improvement.

    19. “Once a Criminal Always a Criminal” is the result of the present system prevailing in this state. We have forgotten the fundamental purpose of Criminal Justice system which is reformation, rehabilitation and re-integration of the convict into society. If an accused is pushed to the extremes by this system where he finds that even if he wants to turn a new leaf in his life, this system will not allow him, he will rather surrender to his fate and turn out to be a hardened criminal. A Welfare state can never stoop down to such a level.

    20. The role of Probation officers has been completely undermined in this State. These officers play a major role in the path of reformation of an accused person. Role played by Probation officers has been succinctly explained in two judgements which are extracted here under:

    I. 2015 SCC OnLine Del 12325

    (Before Gita Mittal and J.R Midha, JJ.)

    Mithilesh Kumar Kushwaha v. State

    Crl. A. No. 249/2011

    Decided on 21.12.2015

    GITA MITTAL, J

    228. It needs no elaboration that a pre-sentencing report by a professionally trained probation officer is an extremely valuable tool for the court for assessing the possibility of reform and rehabilitation of a person accused of a capital offence. The report of the probationary officer in the present case would show that valuable inputs including the personal history of the offender, his behaviour and habits, family relations, physical and mental history, school and employment history are missing.

    229. Additionally, in the instant case, the probation officer has visibly been influenced by her interaction with the complainant and his family, which is not expected. Influenced by the submission of the family of the victims that the convict was a threat to them if released, the probation officer has gone to the extent of observing that “the family is in fear of safety”. The probation officer in the present case also seems to have got prejudiced by the information relating to the crime and has made deductions from the responses the convict may have given to her in respect of the merits of the case against him. This is clearly impermissible.

    230. It is evident from the above that the report of the probation officer is clearly not impartial and has not been prepared professionally. The probation officer is required to sit back from the contentions of both sides and make factual observations. A probation officer is expected to place facts before a court and not deductions. Furthermore, no sociological or psychological advice by any expert or specialized body was undertaken before submitting the report.

    231. But, our closest scrutiny of the matter (discussed later), would show that the probation officer cannot be blamed. We have found that Probation Officer's appointed in this city have neither the necessary qualifications nor the training to render the requisite assistance to the courts. This is not for any fault attributable to them but because of the requirement of The Probation of Offender Rules, 1960 and no effort appears to have been made by concerned authorities to impart the necessary training or equip the Probation Officer's with tools and technological developments as are available today.

    Pre-Sentencing Reports (‘PSR’) - a valuable sentencing tool

    244. The importance of pre-sentencing reports before imposing death sentences cannot be emphasized enough.

    245. Unfortunately, the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 does not provide a legal framework enabling courts to undertake the essential exercise of gathering relevant material to “enable just sentencing. There is no statutory provision in relation to courts requesting and obtaining pre-sentencing reports” (‘PSR’ hereafter). Section 235(2) of the CrPC in the context of sessions trial merely states that “if the accused is convicted, the Judge shall, unless he proceeds in accordance with the provisions of Section 360, hear the accused on the question of sentence, and then pass sentence on him according to the law.”

    246. Section 360 of the CrPC deals with releasing a person on probation of good conduct or after admonition. Though Section 360(1) states that a court may release a convicted prisoner on probation of good conduct taking on record the age, character, antecedents of the offender and also the circumstances in which the office was committed, it does not specify that a probationary officer (‘PO’ for brevity) be appointed to collect relevant sentencing factors.

    247. In this regard we may also advert to the Probation of Offenders Act, 1958 (‘the PO Act’ hereafter) which enactment provides “for the release of offenders on probation or after due admonition and for matters connected therewith”. Section 4 states that a person found guilty of having committed an offence not punishable with death or imprisonment for life, may be released on probation of good conduct. Sub-section 2 of Section 4 mandates that “the court shall take into consideration the report, if any, of the probationary officer concerned in relation to the case”. Section 6(2) of the Act deals with treatment of persons under the age of twenty one. It says that in order to satisfy itself whether Section 3 or 4 of the Act should be used, “the court shall call for a report from the probation officer and consider the report, if any, and any other information available to it relating to the character and physical and mental condition of the offender.” Section 7 of the Act mandates that the report of a PO shall be confidential. However, the proviso states that the court, may communicate the substance of such report to the offender and “may give him an opportunity of producing such evidence as may be relevant to the matter stated in the report.”

    248. It is relevant to note that the Probation of Offenders Act does not apply to situations where the offence is punishable with death or imprisonment for life.

    249. Section 2(d) of the PO Act defines a probation officer as either an officer who is appointed as a probation officer or recognised as such under Section 13 of the Act. This provision (Section 13) states that a probation officer may be appointed by the State government or recognised by it; or may be provided for this purpose by a society recognised in this behalf by the state government; or in exceptional circumstances, the court may appoint any other person who the court opines is fit to act as a PO in the special circumstances of the case. Section 14(1) of the Act deals with circumstances and surroundings of an accused.

    250. While interpreting Section 4 of the PO Act, 1958, the Supreme Court in a judgment reported at M.C.D v. State of Delhi, (2005) 4 SCC 605, held that if a court decides to exercise its powers under Section 4, it is bound to call for a report of the PO, in light of the use of the word ‘shall’ in the section. It further held that although the conclusions and suggestions of the PO are not binding on the court, exercise of powers under Section 4 would be illegal if done without calling for such a report.

    251. We have referred to this enactment as it sheds light not only on the existing statutory regime, but also to some aspects about the importance of the reports from designated persons which are in the nature of “pre-sentencing reports” (‘PSR’ hereafter). The PSRs by Probationary officers have also been recognized as one of the tools for sentencing in cases involving life imprisonment or death sentences.

    II. (2018) 4 SCC 433

    (Before Madan B. Lokur and Deepak Gupta, JJ.)

    Sampurna Behura v. Union of India

    W.P (C). No. 473 of 2005

    Decided on 09.02.2018

    MADAN B. LOKUR, J.

    72. In the context of conducting an effective enquiry, the role of a Probation Officer cannot be underestimated nor can we underestimate the significance of an accurate Social Investigation Report prepared by a Probation Officer. The duties of a Probation Officer have been detailed in Rule 64 of the Model Rules and this reads as follows:

    “64. Duties of a Probation Officer. - (1) On receipt of information from the Police or Child Welfare Police Officer under clause (ii) of subsection (1) of section 13 of the Act, without waiting for any formal order from the Board, the Probation Officer shall inquire into the circumstances of the child as may have bearing on the inquiry by the Board and submit a social investigation report in Form 6 to the Board.

    (2) The social investigation report should provide for risk assessment, including aggravating and mitigating factors highlighting the circumstances which induced vulnerability such as traffickers or abusers being in the neighbourhood, adult gangs, drug users, accessibility to weapons and drugs, exposure to age inappropriate behaviours, information and material.

    (3) The Probation Officer shall carry out the directions given by the Board and shall have the following duties, functions and responsibilities:

    (i) To conduct social investigation of the child in Form 6;

    (ii) To attend the proceedings of the Board and the Children's Court and to submit reports as and when required;

    (iii) To clarify the problems of the child and deal with their difficulties in institutional life;

    (iv) To participte in the orientation, monitoring, education, vocational and rehabilitation programmes;

    (v) To establish co-operation and understanding between the child and the Person-in-charge;

    (vi) To assist the child to develop contacts with family and also provide assistance to family members;

    (vii) To participate in the pre-release programme and help the child to establish contacts which could provide emotional and social support to the child after release;

    (viii) To establish linkages with Probation Officers in other Districts and States for obtaining social investigation report, supervision and follow-up;

    (ix) To establish linkages with voluntary workers and organisations to facilitate rehabilitation and social reintegration of children and to ensure the necessary follow-up;

    (x) Regular post release follow-up of the child extending help and guidance, enabling and facilitating their return to social mainstreaming;

    (xi) To prepare the individual care plan and post release plan for the child;

    (xii) To supervise children placed on probation as per the individual care plan;

    (xiii) To make regular visits to the residence of the child under his supervision and places of employment or school attended by such child and submit periodic reports as per Form 10;

    (xiv) To accompany children where ever possible, from the office of the Board to the observation home, special home, place of safety or fit facility as the case may be;

    (xv) To evaluate the progress of the children in place of safety periodically and prepare the report including psycho-social and forward the same to the Children's Court;

    (xvi) To discharge the functions of a monitoring authority where so appointed by the Children's Court;

    (xvii) To maintain a diary or register to record his day to day activities such as visits made by him, social investigation reports prepared by him, follow up done by him and supervision reports prepared by him;

    (xviii) To identify alternatives of community services and to establish linkages with voluntary sector for facilitating rehabilitation and social reintegration of children; and

    (xix) Any other task as may be assigned”.

    73. It is clear from a reading of the above provision that a Pribation Officer has a very important role to play in ensuring that a juvenile in conflict with law is given adequate representation and a fair hearing before the JJB and the enquiry is conducted in a manner that is conducive to the rehabilitation of the juvenile in conflict with law. In this regard, the preparation of an individual care plan and post release plan gain immense significance and a Probation Officer has an important role to play in this.

    74. Once again, it is of great importance that a Probation Officer should be given adequate training, sensitization and awareness of his or her duties and responsibilities. NALSA has made a significant contribution in this regard by preparing a training module for Probation Officers. We expect all the State Governments as well as MWCD to ensure that training is given to Probation Officers on the lines suggested by NALSA with improvements being made in adult learning techniques, training methodology, the curriculum and the course content in due course of time.

    21. Reformation can be brought forth only by changing our attitude towards criminals. Once this attitude is developed, the requirement to Register FIRs for statistical purposes, to justify passing unnecessary detention orders, will all automatically come down. Prison Reforms, Improving the role played by probation officers, Ensuring first time offenders rehabilitation/reformation and removing the criminal taboo, Effective usage of Neuroscience to identify the psychological/brain related impacts which pushes a person to commit a crime, to rehabilitate Alcoholics (which is increasing at an alarming proportion) and drug addicts who commit crime under its impact, cyber effects that induces/emboldens persons to commit crimes, to name a few, should immediately be assimilated with the help of a committee to be constituted by this court.

    22. It goes without saying that the quality of investigation has come down drastically and the data provided by the police, referred supra, makes it evident. The alacrity shown by the police in registering FIR and effecting arrest, is not seen in investigating the case, laying final report and taking the case to its logical end. The recent circular dated March 20issuedby DGP states that all the police stations will henceforth have exclusive investigation wing. As per the directions, the investigation wing will be responsible for investigation and prosecution of all cases registered in the station, including cases identified by the law and order wing. Further, the police officers attached to the investigation wing shall not be diverted to any bandobust work except with the prior approval of the zonal IG or commissioner of police. This is a step on the right direction. A conscious effort should be made by the investigating wing in every police station with the active coordination of the directorate of prosecution to take every criminal case to its logical end. The police should not be under the impression that their work gets over with registering FIR and effecting arrest. One of the main challenges for the prosecution in Serious crimes is the witness turning hostile due to various reasons. Witness protection scheme, 2018, which has now become the law of the land in view of the judgement of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Mahender Chawla case, (2019 (1) MWN Crl 340 (SC)), must be implemented effectively. The investigation officers must be updated on a regular basis on the March of law. Cyber crimes have reached monumental proportions and criminals committing these offences are clearly having an upper hand since these criminals are intelligent crooks and police officers require regular training and exposure to tackle these crimes. A complete overhaul is required to enhance the quality of investigation.

    23. A Heterogeneous committee is constituted to give its recommendations on

    A) Reforms that can be brought into practice for reformation, rehabilitation and re-integration of the convict/accused person into society and

    B) Best practices for improving, the quality of investigation.

    24. This effort is made to create a healthy Criminal Justice System in the State of Tamilnadu. The recommendations can be put to discussion and implemented by adding it to the rule book. Let this state restore the old glory and become a role model for all others to follow.

    25. The committee shall consist of

    1. Mr. R. Nataraj P.S. DGP (retd)

    2. Mr. V. Sithanan, Superintendent of Police (Retd)

    3. Mr. N.R. Elango, Senior Advocate

    4. Dr. K.V. Kishore Kumar, Director, the Banyan

    5. Dr. M. Sudhakar, Deputy Commissioner of Police, Anna Nagar District, Greater Chennai Police.

    The Committee is requested to submit its report within a period of eight weeks.

    26. This Court found the data provided to be inconclusive in many respects and in some major Districts with nil data (Refer Note 2 in para 2). The committee is therefore requested to again get the data for each District and scrutinize the same and submit the final data separately along with the report.

    27. The Government of Tamil Nadu [Home Department] shall provide an Office room for the Committee to conduct its meetings and to keep the documents and other materials in safe custody. The Government shall provide necessary assistance to the Committee in order to discharge their function.

    28. Post this case after 8 weeks.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M. Murugesan And Another Petitioners/Accused v. State Rep. By The Inspector Of Police .
    (Apr 24, 2019)