Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 2(1)(d) of the Act
  • Section 2(1)(o) of the Act
  • Consumer Protection Act, 1986
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 2(1)(d) of the Act
  • Section 2(1)(o) of the Act
  • Consumer Protection Act, 1986
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Employees of Oil and Natural Gas Commission (ONGC) were members of a “Self-Contributory, Post-Retirement and Death in Service Benefits Scheme, 1991.” The scheme was voluntary for employees in service as of 1-4-1990 and was funded almost entirely by employee contributions; ONGC’s role was limited to a token contribution of Rs 100 per annum. Claims arose when the employees alleged that delays in forwarding their individual applications to the Life Insurance Corporation (LIC) caused financial loss. Treating the employees as “consumers,” the District Forum, the State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission and, in revision, the National Commission directed ONGC to pay compensation and costs. ONGC appealed to the Supreme Court, which consolidated multiple matters for decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, a relationship of “consumer” and “service provider” exists between the claimant-employees and ONGC in respect of the 1991 post-retirement benefits scheme.
  2. Consequently, whether the orders of the Consumer Fora awarding compensation and costs against ONGC are sustainable.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ (ONGC) Arguments

  • Under Section 2(1)(d) of the Consumer Protection Act, the existence of consideration is an essential ingredient; no consideration was paid to ONGC for any “service.”
  • Section 2(1)(o) excludes services rendered free of charge or under a contract of personal service; the scheme therefore falls outside the Act.
  • Reliance was placed on Jagmittar Sain Bhagat v. Health Services (2013) 10 SCC 136 to contend that free or employment-related benefits do not create consumer relationships.

Respondents’ (Employees) Arguments

  • Cited Regional Provident Fund Commr. v. Shiv Kumar Joshi (2000) 1 SCC 98 and Regional Provident Fund Commr. v. Bhavani (2008) 7 SCC 111 to argue that statutory or employment-linked benefit schemes can constitute “service” under the Act.
  • Maintained that ONGC’s delay in transmitting their claims to LIC amounted to deficiency in service, entitling them to compensation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jagmittar Sain Bhagat v. Health Services (2013) 10 SCC 136 Services rendered free of charge / under employment do not create a consumer relationship. Cited by ONGC; Court found it unnecessary to examine because it disposed of the matter on absence of privity with ONGC.
Regional Provident Fund Commr. v. Shiv Kumar Joshi (2000) 1 SCC 98 Provident-fund related services can fall within “service” under the Act. Cited by employees; Court noted citation but did not rely on it after finding no service was provided by ONGC.
Regional Provident Fund Commr. v. Bhavani (2008) 7 SCC 111 Similar to Shiv Kumar Joshi regarding applicability of Act to benefit schemes. Cited by employees; not determinative in view of Court’s conclusion on privity.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court focused exclusively on whether ONGC provided any “service” to the claimants:

  • The 1991 scheme was funded almost entirely by employee contributions; ONGC’s role was limited to a token amount of Rs 100 per year.
  • Participation was voluntary for existing employees and compulsory only for future entrants, reinforcing that the scheme was not an employer-provided service.
  • Management of the fund rested with an independent Trust; trustees—some nominated by ONGC’s Chairman and some by the employees’ association—controlled investment decisions and purchased annuities from LIC.
  • Because any service, if rendered, emanated from the Trust and not from ONGC, there was “virtually no privity of contract” between ONGC and the employees for the purpose of the Act.
  • Having reached this conclusion, the Court found it unnecessary to decide the additional statutory arguments advanced by ONGC’s counsel.

Holding and Implications

PARTLY ALLOWED: The Supreme Court set aside the findings of the National, State and District Consumer Fora insofar as they held that a consumer–service provider relationship existed between the claimants and ONGC, and it also quashed the costs imposed on ONGC. However, consistent with ONGC’s voluntary undertaking recorded at the start of the judgment, the Court directed ONGC to pay the substantive amounts (excluding costs) awarded by the lower fora within eight weeks.

Implications: The decision clarifies that voluntary, employee-funded benefit schemes managed by an independent trust do not create a consumer relationship between employees and the employer under the Consumer Protection Act. The ruling affects only the present parties; it sets no broader precedent on other issues left undecided.

    Chairman-Cum-Managing Director, Ongc Limited And Others v. Consumer Education Research Society And Others

    Deepak Gupta, J.— Leave granted. All these appeals are being disposed of by a common judgment since the issue involved is common in all the cases.

    2. At the outset, we may note that Shri Krishnan Venugopal, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellants submits that without prejudice to the rights of the appellants to challenge the impugned orders 2014 SCC OnLine NCDRC 127 of the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission as well as the Gujarat State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission and the District Forum, the appellants shall pay the amount as directed in the impugned orders. This has been done because the amounts involved are small, the appellants had retired a long time back and they should not be forced to go into the second round of litigation.

    3. The main issue involved is whether there is relationship of consumer and service provider existing between the private respondents (claimants) and the appellants.

    4. The undisputed facts are that all the claimants were employees of the Oil and Natural Gas Commission (for short “ONGC”). A Self Contributory, Post Retirement and Death in Service Benefits Scheme, 1991 (for short “the Scheme”) was introduced in ONGC after obtaining permission of the Government of India and the relevant portion of the letter dated 18-9-1991 granting permission reads as follows:

    “(i) Contribution to the fund to be established from the employee of ONGC would be in cash, with a token contribution of Rs 100 p.a. by ONGC.”

    5. The Scheme has also been annexed and the relevant portion of the Scheme reads as follows:

    “1. (c) Membership
    (i)***
    (ii) The Scheme shall be optional to the existing executives in regular service of the Commission on the effective date of the Scheme 1-4-1990. However, it will be compulsory for executives joining regular service in the Commission as new entrant on or after the effective date of the Scheme option once exercise shall be final and irrevocable.
    ***
    2. Contribution
    2.1. The contribution to be made by the member employee shall be calculated on his salary and the rate will be as given hereunder depending on his age on the effective date of the Scheme for employees on the rolls of ONGC as on 1-4-1990 and on the date of joining ONGC for new entrants. The rate of contribution fixed at the time of entry will remain constant. The following rates of the contribution are payable in the various age groups:
    (i) Below 25 years 0.5% of salary (ii) 25 and up to 35 years 0.75% of salary (iii) Above 30 and up to 35 years 1% of salary (iv) Above 35 and up to 40 years 2% of salary (v) Above 40 and up to 45 years 3% of salary (vi) Above 45 and up to 48 years 4.5% of salary (vii) Above 48 and up to 50 years 4.5% of salary Above 50 and up to 58 years 5% of salary
    ***
    5. Managing the Scheme
    (a) The Scheme shall be run by a Trust consisting of trustees to be nominated by the Chairman, ONGC and representative as may be nominated on the board by CWC of ASTO. The Trust would make investment plan of the fund as per pattern of Rule 67(2) of the Income Tax Rules, 1961 and would purchase annuity from LIC for the beneficiaries under the Scheme.
    6. Scheme is based on voluntary contribution by the member employees. No contribution will be made by ONGC towards this Scheme except Rs 100 p.a. No other financial liability on account of this Scheme will devolve on ONGC or the Government of India.”

    6. It is not necessary to deal with other facts. The case of the claimants was that due to delay in sending their claims to LIC, they suffered a loss. This averment is denied by the appellants but, in our view, that is not very relevant. The Consumer Fora held that the employees were consumers of ONGC and therefore passed orders awarding various amounts and costs in favour of the claimants and hence ONGC is liable to pay the same.

    7. Shri Venugopal has raised various pleas before us. The first is that in terms of the definition of consumer in the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 (for short “the Act”), the first essential ingredient is payment of consideration for availing services. The second contention is that rendering of service free of charge under a contract of personal service is not included in the definition of service under the Act. We may refer to Section 2(1)(d) of the Act, which reads as follows:

    “2. (1)(d) “consumer” means any person who,—
    (i)***
    (ii) hires or avails of any services for a consideration which has been paid or promised or partly paid and partly promised, or under any system of deferred payment and includes any beneficiary of such services other than the person who hires or avails of the services for consideration paid or promised, or partly paid and partly promised, or under any system of deferred payment, when such services are availed of with the approval of the first mentioned person but does not include a person who avails of such services for any commercial purpose;”

    8. We may also refer to Section 2(1)(o) of the Act, which reads as follows:

    “2. (1)(o) “service” means service of any description which is made available to potential users and includes, but not limited to, the provision of facilities in connection with banking, financing, insurance, transport, processing, supply of electrical or other energy, board or lodging or both, housing construction, entertainment, amusement or the purveying of news or other information, but does not include the rendering of any service free of charge or under a contract of personal service;”

    9. Shri Venugopal has relied upon the judgment of this Court in Jagmittar Sain Bhagat v. Health Services (2013) 10 SCC 136 in this regard. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondents has placed reliance on the judgment of this Court in Regl. Provident Fund Commr. v. Shiv Kumar Joshi (2000) 1 SCC 98 and Regl. Provident Fund Commr. v. Bhavani (2008) 7 SCC 111.

    10. In our opinion, it is not necessary to answer all the issues raised by Shri Venugopal since, in our opinion, there is virtually no privity of contract for providing service between ONGC and the claimants. From a perusal of the letter dated 18-9-1991 and the Scheme, relevant portion of which has been quoted above, it is apparent that contributors to the Scheme were the employees of ONGC. Whereas the employer was only making a token contribution of Rs 100 p.a., the Scheme was also voluntary and optional for the employees who were in service from the effective date i.e. 1-4-1990. It is not disputed that all the claimants were in service before the effective date. The Scheme envisages that every employee shall contribute to the fund at rates specified therein. The younger the employee, the percentage deducted from his salary is less and this rises progressively as the age increases. It has obviously been done to ensure that the contribution of the employee is equal i.e. those who have less years of remaining service will contribute at a higher rate and those who have more years of remaining service will contribute at a lower rate. The most important aspect is that the Scheme is managed and run by a Trust and not by ONGC. The trustees of the Trust are nominated by the Chairman of ONGC and representatives may be nominated to the Board of Trustees by the Central Working Committee (CWC) of Association of Scientific and Technical Officers. We have been informed at the Bar that 7 trustees are nominated by the Chairman of ONGC and 6 by CWC. Be that as it may, it is the Trust which manages the fund. Therefore, without going into the question as to whether any amount is being paid by the employees for contribution to the services rendered by the Trust, it is apparent that the service, if any, is being rendered by the Trust and not by ONGC. Therefore, we have no hesitation in coming to the conclusion that there is no relationship of consumer and service provider between the claimants and ONGC. We make it clear that we have not gone into the other questions since, in view of the aforesaid decision, it is not necessary to decide the other questions raised by Shri Venugopal.

    11. In view of the above discussion, we partly allow the appeals and set aside the orders 2014 SCC OnLine NCDRC 127 of the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission and the State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission insofar as it held that there is a relationship of consumer and service provider between the claimants and ONGC. We also set aside the costs imposed by the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission. However, in view of the statement made by Shri Venugopal, recorded in the opening portion of this judgment, we direct ONGC to pay the amounts payable (other than the costs) under the orders impugned to the claimants within 8 weeks from today.

    12. Pending application(s), if any, stand(s) disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Chairman-Cum-Managin... v. Consumer Education R...
    (Dec 9, 2019)