Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Class-III (Non-Gazetted) Recruitment and Promotion (First amendment) Rules, 2012.(2)
  • Class-III (non-Gazetted) Recruitment and Promotion (First Amendment) Rules, 2012,
  • Class-III (Non-Gazetted) Recruitment and Promotion Rules, 2010,(a)
  • Class-III (Non-Gazetted) Recruitment and Promotion Rules, 2010,
  • ARTICLE 301 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • ARTICLE 309 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Education Act, 2009
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Class-III (Non-Gazetted) Recruitment and Promotion (First amendment) Rules, 2012.(2)
  • Class-III (non-Gazetted) Recruitment and Promotion (First Amendment) Rules, 2012,
  • Class-III (Non-Gazetted) Recruitment and Promotion Rules, 2010,(a)
  • Class-III (Non-Gazetted) Recruitment and Promotion Rules, 2010,
  • ARTICLE 301 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • ARTICLE 309 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Education Act, 2009
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Tarlok Singh Chauhan, J. (Oral)

Factual and Procedural Background

The two writ petitions were taken up together because common questions of law and fact arose. The petitioners sought, inter alia, a declaration that the Tribunal's judgment dated 30 July 2018 (Annexure P-2) violated Articles 16 and 301 of the Constitution, a direction to the State to follow the Recruitment & Promotion Rule, 2012 and Notification No. EDN-C-A-9/2011, and a stay of the effects of the Tribunal's judgment during pendency of the petitions.

Relevant administrative and statutory context in the opinion includes: NCTE framed minimum qualifications in 2001; the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009 was enforced w.e.f. 1 April 2010 and NCTE notified minimum qualifications on 23 August 2010; the Himachal Pradesh government notified Recruitment and Promotion Rules for the post of Shashtri (Class-III, Non-Gazetted) in 2012 (first amendment dated 27 August 2012). The R&P Rules set essential qualifications for Shashtri as "Shashtri with at least 50% marks" and pass in the relevant TET, with certain relaxations for reserved categories.

Recruitment for vacant Shashtri posts (district cadre) was initiated in 2016. Some candidates had originally obtained Shashtri degrees with less than 50% prior to the RTE/2012 amendments and later "improved" their marks in subsequent years. Litigation followed: some candidates filed Original Application No. 4836 of 2016 (Vinod Kumar Sharma v. State of H.P.) and connected matters, seeking direction that candidatures be considered batch-wise reckoning from the year of initial passing (original certificate) rather than the year of improvement.

The Tribunal (HP CAT) by its judgment dated 30 July 2018 allowed those applications partly, directing respondents to consider candidates for appointment as Shashtri on batch-wise basis by reckoning their batch "from the date of issuance of original certificate/degree of Shashtri" and to do so expeditiously (not later than 45 days from production of certified copies of the order). The petitioners in these writ petitions challenged that Tribunal judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Tribunal's judgment dated 30 July 2018 (directing batch-wise reckoning from the date of issuance of original Shashtri certificate/degree) is legally sustainable.
  2. Whether the impugned orders/direction/judgment dated 30 July 2018 are violative of Article 16 and Article 301 of the Constitution of India (as alleged by the petitioners).
  3. Whether, for batch-wise recruitment and seniority reckoning, the batch should be fixed from the date of issuance of the original certificate/degree or from the date of improvement (i.e., after a candidate subsequently improves marks to meet the prescribed qualification).
  4. Whether interim relief (stay) should be granted against the effects of the Tribunal's judgment during the pendency of these petitions.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners challenged the Tribunal's judgment of 30 July 2018 and contended that batch-wise reckoning for recruitment/seniority should be from the date of improvement (i.e., the date on which a candidate subsequently achieved the prescribed educational qualification) and not from the date of issuance of the original certificate/degree.
  • The petitioners asserted that the Tribunal's order violated Articles 16 and 301 of the Constitution (as part of the reliefs sought in the writ petitions).
  • The petitioners sought a stay on the operation/effects of the Tribunal's judgment pending the writ petitions.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents' (State's) specific oral or written arguments in the record presented.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Alka Ojha v. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, (2011) 9 SCC 438 : AIR 2011 SC 3547 Affirmation of the proposition that the cut-off date by reference to which eligibility requirements must be satisfied is the date appointed by the relevant service rules; if none, then the date in the advertisement; if none, then the last date for receipt of applications. The court relied on this authority to state that the question whether qualifications must be possessed as on a specified date is settled law and to support the proposition regarding the proper cut-off date for eligibility.
Bhupinderpal Singh v. State of Punjab, (2000) 5 SCC 262 : AIR 2000 SC 2011 Referenced in Alka Ojha as part of the earlier authorities discussing the cut-off date principle for eligibility. The opinion notes that Alka Ojha referred to this decision; the court used the chain of authority culminating in Alka Ojha to support the settled proposition on cut-off dates.
A.P. Public Service Commission v. B. Sarat Chandra, (1990) 2 SCC 669 One of the earlier judgments referenced in Alka Ojha relating to the question of eligibility cut-off dates. Referred to (via Alka Ojha) as part of the established line of authorities on cut-off dates; used to support the court's statement of settled law.
District Collector & Chairman, Vizianagaram Social Welfare Residential School Society v. M. Tripura Sundari Devi, (1990) 3 SCC 655 One of the earlier judgments referenced in Alka Ojha concerning eligibility timing and related principles. Referred to (via Alka Ojha) to demonstrate the settled position on when prescribed qualifications must be possessed.
M.V. Nair (Dr.) v. Union of India, (1993) 2 SCC 429 An earlier decision referred to in Alka Ojha in the context of eligibility/cut-off dates. Mentioned (through Alka Ojha) as part of the supporting jurisprudence for the cut-off date proposition.
Rekha Chaturvedi v. University of Rajasthan, 1993 Supp (3) SCC 168 One of the earlier cases cited in Alka Ojha related to the timing of possession of qualifications. Noted (via Alka Ojha) as part of the chain of authorities supporting the settled principle on cut-off dates.
U.P. Public Service Commission v. Alpana, (1994 AIR SCW 2861) Referenced as part of the earlier judicial authorities discussing eligibility dates. Referred to (through Alka Ojha) to buttress the court's reliance on established law about cut-off dates for eligibility.
Ashok Kumar Sharma v. Chander Shekhar Referred to among earlier cases in Alka Ojha addressing timing of qualifications for recruitment. Included (via Alka Ojha) when the court summarized the settled position on cut-off dates for eligibility.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in the following analytical steps (as reflected in the opinion):

  1. The court observed that no plausible ground to assail the Tribunal's judgment had been set forth by the petitioners. The petitioners' principal contention was that batch-wise reckoning should be from the date of improvement and not from the date of issuance of the original certificate.
  2. The court examined the 2012 amendment to the Himachal Pradesh Recruitment and Promotion Rules (notification dated 27.08.2012). The amendment included a Note stating: "For batch wise recruitment the batch would be reckoned from the date of issuance of original certificate/degree of Shashtri."
  3. The court interpreted the combined and harmonious reading of the Note to mean that for batch-wise recruitment, if a candidate later improves marks to acquire the minimum essential educational qualification, that candidate's batch/seniority for batch-wise recruitment is to be reckoned "from the date of issuance of the original certificate/degree of Shashtri" (i.e., the date of the original certificate).
  4. On that statutory/regulatory interpretation, the court concluded that there was no fault in the Tribunal's order directing seniority for batch-wise appointment to be reckoned from the date of issuance of the original certificate/degree for candidates who had improved their qualification prior to the decision to fill vacancies on batch-wise basis.
  5. The court noted that the broader legal question of whether prescribed qualifications must be possessed as on a particular date was no longer res integra and is settled law: the cut-off date is that appointed by the relevant service rules, or failing that by the date in the advertisement, or failing that by the last date for receipt of applications. The court relied on Alka Ojha (2011) and the judgments referred therein to endorse that proposition.
  6. Applying the regulatory language of the 2012 amendment and the settled legal principle on cut-off dates, the court found the petitioners' contention without merit.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petitions were dismissed. The opinion states: the petitions are dismissed, and pending application(s), if any, were also dismissed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The Tribunal's judgment dated 30 July 2018, which directed that batch-wise reckoning for appointment/seniority be from the date of issuance of the original certificate/degree of Shashtri, stands; the petitioners' challenge to that order failed and their petitions were dismissed.
  • No broader implications were discussed in the opinion beyond the decision's application to the parties: the court relied on the explicit language of the 2012 amendment and on settled Supreme Court authority concerning the appropriate cut-off date for eligibility; the opinion did not purport to lay down any new novel principle beyond applying the rules and established case law to the facts before it.

    Sanjay Mishra v. State Of H.P. And Others

    Tarlok Singh Chauhan, J. (Oral):— Since common question of law and facts arise for consideration in both these petitions, therefore, they were taken up together for consideration and are being disposed of by way of a common judgment.

    2. The petitioners have filed the present writ petitions seeking therein the following substantive reliefs:—

    a) To pass an appropriate writ, order or direction declaring that the orders, direction, judgment dated 30 July, 2018 vide Annexure P-2 as violative of Article 16 and Article 301 of the Constitution of India.

    b) To pass an order or direction to the State to strictly follow the norms and rules as mentioned in the Recruitment & Promotion Rule, 2012, dated 27 August, 2012, Notification No. EDN-C-A-9/2011 vide Annexure P-1 and further to make batch wise appointments of Shashtri Teachers strictly according to the provisions mentioned in these R&P Rules.

    c) To pass an order and direction to stay the effects of Judgment dated 30 July, 2018 vide Annexure P-2 during the pendency of this case or till further order.

    3. The National council for Teachers' Education (NCTE) had framed Regulation, 2001 titled as “National council for Teachers Education (Determination of Minimum qualifications for Recruitment of Teachers in Schools)” to determine the minimum qualifications for recruitment of teachers to bring uniformity in educational qualification of teachers.

    4. The Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009 has been enforced all over the country w.e.f. 1 April, 2010. As per Section 23 of the Act, any person possessing such minimum qualification as laid down by the academic authority authorized by the central government shall be eligible for appointment as a teacher. The academic authority of the Central Government that is NCTE has notified the minimum qualification on 23 August, 2010.

    5. Accordingly, in consonance with Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009, the government of Himachal Pradesh vide notification No. EDN-C-A(3)2/2009-II, dated 17.05.2010 and subsequent amendments, notified Recruitment and Promotion Rules for the post of Shastri/Sanskrit Teacher/Oriental Teacher (O.T.), Class-III, Non-Gazetted) in the Department of Elementary Education in the year 2012.

    6. As per Recruitment & Promotion Rules, in force, the minimum educational and other qualifications required for recruitment as Shashtri are as under:—

    (a) Essential Qualification “Shashtri with at least 50% marks from a University/Institution recognised by H.P. Government.

    Pass in Teacher Eligibility Test (TET Shashtri) conducted by HPSSSB, Hamirpur.

    Note : Relaxation upto 5% will be allowed in minimum educational qualification and also in minimum qualifying marks for TET to the candidates belonging to SC/ST/OBC/PH categories.

    7. After seeking the approval of the State Government, the Department initiated the process of filling up the vacant posts of Shashtris in all the Districts of Himachal Pradesh in the year, 2016 as the post in question is District Cadre Post. However, there were some candidates, who had passed Shashtri degrees with less than 50% marks (less than minimum percentage of marks required for Shashtri as per R & P Rules, in force) prior to coming into force the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009 and amendment of R & P Rules of Shashtri teachers in consonance with NCTE norms.

    8. Such candidates/aspirants improved their percentage of marks in subsequent years that is after the amendment in the R & P Rules and some of the candidates thereafter filed OA No. 4836 of 2016, titled as Vinod Kumar Sharma v. State of H.P. and connected matters.

    9. Thereafter certain other cases were also filed which were then clubbed with the case of Vinod Kumar Sharma, wherein a direction was sought to consider the candidatures of these applicants for the post of Shastri on batch-wise basis by reckoning their degrees of Shashtris from the year of initial passing out and not from the year of improvement.

    10. The learned Tribunal vide judgment dated 30.07.2018 (impugned herein) allowed these petitions by passing the following orders:

    “…The original applications succeed partly and are allowed in part with a direction to respondents No. 1 to 4/competent authority(s) to consider the respective cases of the applicants for appointment as Shashtri on batch-wise basis in terms of the aforesaid Note by reckoning their batch “from the date of issuance of original certificate/degree of Shashtri”, as expeditiously as possible, but in any case not later than forty-five days from the respective dates of production of certified copies of this order before the said authority(s) by the applicants.”

    11. Aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment, the petitioners have filed the instant petition.

    12. No plausible ground to assail the judgment has been set forth. The learned counsel for the petitioners would simply argue that the batch should be reckoned from the date of improvement and not from the issuance of the original certificate.

    13. However, we really find no merit in such contention. It would be noticed that the recruitment in question was initiated in all the districts only in the year, 2016 and prior to that the Himachal Pradesh Elementary Education Department, Shashtri/Sanskrit Teacher, Oriental Teacher, Class-III (non-Gazetted) Recruitment and Promotion (First Amendment) Rules, 2012, had been already notified vide notification dated 27.08.2012 and the same reads as under:—

    “Government of Himachal Pradesh Elementary Education Department

    (Education-C)

    No. EDN-C-A(3)9/2011, Dated : Shimla-171002,

    27.08.2012

    NOTIFICATION

    In exercise of the powers conferred by proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of India, the Governor, Himachal Pradesh in consultation with the Himachal Pradesh Public Service Commission is pleased to make the following Rules further to amend the “Himachal Pradesh, Elementary Education Department, Shastri/Sanskrit Teacher/Oriental Teacher, Class-III (Non-Gazetted) Recruitment and Promotion Rules, 2010 notified vide this Department notification Number EDN-C-A(3)2/2009-II dated 17.05.2010; namely:—

    Short title and 1. (1) These rules may be called the Commencement “Himachal Pradesh, Elementary Education Department, Shashtri/Sanskrit Teacher/Oriental Teacher, Class-III (Non-Gazetted) Recruitment and Promotion (First amendment) Rules, 2012.

    (2) These rules shall come into force from the date of publication in the Rajpatra, Himachal Pradesh.

    Amendment of Annexure-A

    2. In Annexure-A to the “Himachal Pradesh elementary Education Department, Shashtri/Sanskrit Teacher, Oriental Teacher, Class-III (Non-Gazetted) Recruitment and Promotion Rules, 2010,

    (a) for the existing provisions against Col. No. 7, the following shall be substituted, namely:—

    Essential Qualification:

    (a) “Shashtri with at least 50% marks from a University/Institution recognized by H.P. Govt.

    Pass in Teacher Eligibility Test (TET Shashtri) conducted by HPSSSB, Hamirpur.

    Note:— Relaxation upto 5% will be allowed in minimum educational qualifications and also in minimum qualifying marks for TET to the candidates belonging to SC/ST/OBC/PH categories.

    b) Desirable Qualification:

    Knowledge of customs, manner and dialects of Himachal Pradesh and suitability for appointment in the peculiar conditions prevailing in the Pradesh,” and

    for the existing provisions against col. No. 10, the following shall be substituted, namely:—

    “100% by direct recruitment on regular basis or by recruitment on contract basis in the following manner:—

    (a) 50% by batch-wise on merit basis; and

    (b) 50% through HPSSSB, Hamirpur.

    The contract employees will get emoluments as given in Column No. 15-A and will be governed by service-conditions as specified in the said column.

    Note:— For batch wise recruitment the batch would be reckoned from the date of issuance of original certificate/degree of Shashtri.

    If more than one candidate has been issued the final examination certificate on the same date then the inter se seniority would be determined on the basis of TET (Shastri) merit and in the event of TET merit being same, senior in age would get precedence over junior in age.

    By order

    Secretary (Ele. Education) to the Government of Himachal Pradesh”

    (emphasis supplied)

    14. For a better understanding of the import and purport of amendment, it would be necessary to refer to the un-amended provision contained in Column Nos. 7 and 10 of Annexure-A of the amended Rules, known as “Himachal Pradesh, Elementary Education Department, Shashtri/Sanskrit Teacher/Oriental Teacher, Class-III (Non-Gazetted) Recruitment and Promotion Rules, 2010”, issued vide notification dated 17.05.2010, given as under:

    “7. Minimum educational and other qualifications required for direct recruitment a) Essential Shashtri with at least 50% marks from a University/Institution recognized by HP govt. (\b) Desirable qualification Knowledge of customs, manners and dialects of Himachal Pradesh and suitability for appointment in peculiar conditions prevailing in the Pradesh. 10. Method of recruitment whether by direct recruitment or by promotion, deputation, transfer and the percentage of post(s) to be filled in by various methods 100% by direct recruitment on regular basis or by recruitment on contract basis in the following manner:— a) 50% by batch-wise on merit basis. b) 50% through HPSSSB, Hamirpur. The contract employees will get emoluments as given in Column No. 15-A and will be governed by service conditions as specified in the said column.

    15. A combined and harmonious reading of the first part of the note clearly goes to show that for batch-wise recruitment, in case a candidate has improved the score so as to acquire minimum essential educational that is Shashtri with at least 50% marks from University/institution recognised by the H.P. Government then “his batch would be reckoned from the date of issuance of original certificate/degree of Shashtri” so that his seniority for batch-wise recruitment is counted “from the date of issuance of the original certificate/degree of Shashtri”.

    16. Apart from above, the note appended with the 2012 amendment (as reproduced above) makes it absolutely clear that for batch-wise recruitment, the batch should be reckoned from the date of issuance of original certificate/degree of Shashtri.

    17. Once that be so, then obviously no fault can be found with the order of the learned Tribunal whereby it directed the seniority for batch-wise appointment to be reckoned from the date of issuance of original certificate/degree of Shashtri for all those candidates, who had prior to filling up of the vacancy on batch-wise appointment, more importantly, when this qualification admittedly had been improved prior to the decision taken for filling up of these vacancies on batch-wise.

    18. The question whether candidate must have prescribed educational and other qualifications as on a particular date specified in the Rules or the advertisement is no longer res intergra. It is more than settled that cut off date by reference to which eligibility requirement must be satisfied by the candidate seeking a public employment is the date appointed by the relevant service rules and if there be no cut off date appointed by the rules then such date as may be appointed for the purpose in the advertisement calling for applications and that if there be no such date appointed then the eligibility criteria shall be applied by reference to the last date appointed by which the applications have been received by the competent authority.

    19. Reference in this regard can conveniently be made to the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Alka Ojha v. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, (2011) 9 SCC 438 : AIR 2011 SC 3547, wherein it was observed as under:—

    “14. The question whether the candidate must have the prescribed educational and other qualifications as on the particular date specified in the Rule or the advertisement is no longer res intergra. In Bhupinderpal Singh v. State of Punjab (2000) 5 SCC 262; ((2000) 5 SCC 262 : AIR 2000 SC 2011 : 2000 AIR SCW 1888), this Court referred to the earlier judgments in A.P. Public Service Commission v. B. Sarat Chandra (1990) 2 SCC 669, District Collector and Chairman, Vizianagaram Social Welfare Residential School Society v. M. Tripura Sundari Devi (1990) 3 SCC 655, M.V. Nair (Dr.) v. Union of India (1993) 2 SCC 429 : (1993) AIR SCW 1412), Rekha Chaturvedi v. University of Rajasthan 1993 Supp (3) SCC 168, U.P. Public Service Commission, U.P., Allahabad v. Alpana (1994 AIR SCW 2861) (supra) and Ashok Kumar Sharma v. Chander Shekhar (supra) and approved the following proposition laid down by the Punjab and Haryana High Court:

    “….. that cut off date by reference to which eligibility requirement must be satisfied by the candidate seeking a public employment is the date appointed by the relevant service rules and if there be no cut off date appointed by the rules then such date as may be appointed for the purpose in the advertisement calling for applications and that if there be no such date appointed then the eligibility criteria shall be applied by reference to the last date appointed by which the applications have to be received by the competent authority.”

    20. Having said so, we find no merit in these petitions and the same are accordingly dismissed, so also pending application(s), if any.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sanjay Mishra v. State Of H.P. And Others
    (Dec 13, 2019)