Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion (N. Seshasayee, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The present Civil Revision Petition was filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India seeking to call for the records and set aside the fair and decretal order dated 19.11.2020 passed by the learned Principal District Munsif Court, Madurai in I.A. No. 275 of 2020 in O.S. No. 641 of 2012. The petitioner is the plaintiff in O.S. No. 641 of 2012, a suit instituted in 2012 inter alia for permanent injunction against her husband and her parents-in-law.

The specific relief challenged in this revision was the dismissal by the trial court of the plaintiff's application (I.A. No. 275/2020) seeking re-opening of the case for the purpose of cross-examining D.W.1. The trial court's impugned order (extracts of paragraphs 5 to 10) records an extended chronology of the plaintiff's repeated adjournments, non-attendance, late marking of documents, prior dismissal for default (06.01.2014) and restoration (28.09.2015), closure of plaintiff's evidence (22.02.2018) for non-representation, and subsequent developments including closure of defendant evidence and an amendment petition allowed on 04.07.2019.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial court erred in dismissing I.A. No. 275 of 2020 (the application to re-open the case for cross-examining D.W.1) such that the order dated 19.11.2020 should be set aside under Article 227.
  2. Whether the pattern of repeated adjournments, non-cooperation and non-attendance by the plaintiff (as recorded by the trial court) justified the trial court's exercise of procedural discretion to dismiss the application to re-open the evidence.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeds by reference to the trial court's factual findings and a reflection on procedural discipline and judicial discretion:

  • Review of trial court chronology: The Court notes that paragraphs 5–10 of the impugned order set out a detailed timeline evidencing repeated adjournments by the plaintiff, non-attendance on numerous dates, minimal cooperation in marking documents, closure of plaintiff's evidence due to non-representation, the subsequent closure of defendant evidence and various adjournments thereafter. The extracted chronology is treated as the factual backdrop for the exercise of procedural discretion.
  • Institutional context and expectations: The Court emphasizes that courts provide a remedial forum with appointments (dates of hearing) that litigants and advocates must honour. The opinion analogises court postings to appointments with a physician and stresses that procedural appointments should not be wasted.
  • Procedural fairness and balancing discretion: The Court discusses the need to balance compassion with fairness. It recognises that procedural law requires elasticity to accommodate unforeseen contingencies, but warns against stretching procedural generosity beyond reasonable limits so as to defeat the courts' objectives and create processual inequality.
  • Doctrine mentioned: The opinion refers to a principle that courts have evolved — that where fault lies with counsel, the litigant should not suffer unduly — but it questions where compassion ceases to be justified and becomes undeserving charity. The focus is on the point at which repeated procedural indulgence becomes unfair to the opposing party and to the judicial process.
  • Guidance to trial courts: The Court endorses an approach of careful case-by-case assessment — described as "Watch, Weigh and Value" — to exercise procedural discretion fairly while being mindful of the socio-economic realities of litigants. Nevertheless, this guidance is framed in the context of condemning habitual or plainly nonsensical abuse of court appointments.
  • Application to this case: Applying these considerations to the record, the Court concludes that the revision petitioner had developed a habit of abusing the court's appointments (or that the conduct may have been the advocate's strategy). The Court found the petitioner's overall conduct "plainly and painfully nonsensical" and considered that the tolerance of further indulgence should end.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The Civil Revision Petition is dismissed. No costs are awarded. The connected miscellaneous petition is closed.

Implications and immediate consequences:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The trial court's order dismissing I.A. No. 275 of 2020 (the application to re-open for cross-examination of D.W.1) is upheld by this revision court; the petitioner’s challenge under Article 227 fails and the revision is dismissed without costs. The connected miscellaneous petition is disposed of.
  • Observations for practice: The opinion contains explicit admonitions to the Bar, litigants and trial courts about the need to honour court postings, exercise procedural discipline, and balance compassion with fairness. It recommends a "Watch, Weigh and Value" approach when exercising procedural discretion, while warning against routine indulgence that prejudices others and delays justice.
  • On precedent: The opinion does not cite or rely on any judicial precedents in support of its decision in the provided text.

This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion and does not add facts or inferences beyond the text.

    Fathima v. Rahamutullah

    Prayer: Civil Revision Petition is filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, to call for the records pertaining to the fair and decreetal order dated 19.11.2020 passed by the learned Principal District Munsif Court, Madurai in I.A. No. 275 of 2020 in O.S. No. 641 of 2012 on the file of the learned Principal District Munsif Court, Madurai and set aside the same.

    The Order of the Court was delivered by

    N. Seshasayee, J.:— The plaintiff in O.S.641 of 2012 has approached this court with this revision under Article 227 of the Constitution, challenging an order dismissing her application in I.A.275/2020 for re-opening the case for cross-examining D.W.1. She has laid the suit inter alia against her husband and the parents-in-law for injunction and for other reliefs.

    2. The learned trial Judge has dismissed the application Vide the order now impugned. Be it a cursory reading, or a careful reading, what this order conveys in paragraphs 5 to 10 is evident: it is a general statement, expressing the agony which the courts are put to by some litigants. It is extracted below:

    “5. The instant suit was filed in the year of 2012 for the relief of permanent injunction to restrain the defendant from interfering with the peaceful possession of the suit property without following due process of law. This petition is filed before this court at the stage of final argument. Hence, this court forms opinion that, it is necessary to find out the real intention of the petitioner/plaintiff from the available case records to decide his application. On perusal of case diary, it shows that issued were framed by this court on 14.09.2013 itself and this suit was posted for trial on 22.10.2013-11.11.2013-05.12.2013 and finally this suit was dismissed for default for non-prosecution on 06.01.2014.

    6. Subsequently this suit was restored as per order in I.A. No. 68 of 2014 dated 28.09.2015 and the suit was listed for trial on many hearings (i.e., 12.10.2015 - 05.11.2015 - 18.11.2015). On 24.11.2015, the plaintiff examined herself in chief as P.W.1 by filing proof affidavit and at the request of the petitioner/plaintiff, the main suit was adjourned to 09.12.2014 to 18.12.2015 - 19.01.2016 - 29.01.2016 - 02.02.2016 for the purpose of marking documents.

    7. After availing such opportunities, instead of marking documents on her side, on 11.02.2016 the petitioner/plaintiff filed an application in I.A. No. 178 of 2016 to receive additional documents and it was adjourned for enquiry on 04.04.2016 - 12.04.2016 - 02.06.2016. On perusal of docket sheet in I.A. No. 178/2016, it reveals that, the petitioner/plaintiff was not ready to conduct enquiry in I.A. NO. 178/2016. Finally, in the interest of justice, this court allowed the petition (I.A. No. 178/2016) on 14.06.2016 itself, without conducting any enquiry from the side of petitioner/plaintiff.

    8. Even after allowing such interim application (I.A. No. 178/2016), the petitioner/plaintiff (P.W.1) was not appeared before this court for the purpose of marking documents on her side for many hearings (i.e 29.06.2016 - 26.07.2016 - 29.08.2016 - 19.09.2016-19.09.2016 - 04.10.2016 - 20.10.2016) and the plaintiff/petitioner (P.W.1) marked documents on her side only on 02.11.2016. Even after that, the petitioner/plaintiff has repeatedly requested for adjournment on 21.11.2016 - 05.12.2016 to 20.12.2016 - 12.01.2017 - 06.02.2017 - 22.04.2017 - 29.04.2017 - 17.06.2017 - 12.07.2017 and finally petitioner/plaintiff (P.W.1)cross examined only on 27.07.2017.

    9. Thereafter, the main suit was posted for further P.W's on 09.08.2017, but the suit was adjourned to 29.08.2017 - 13.09.2017 - 03.10.2017 - 10.10.2017 as per request made by the petitioner/plaintiff. On 30.10.2017, a witness was examined in chief as P.W.2 and cross examined by the defendant side on 11.01.2018. After that the plaintiff side evidence was closed on 22.02.2018, because of non-representation from the side of petitioner/plaintiff. Thereafter the defendant side evidence was closed by this Court on 12.07.2018 and posted for arguments. But the petitioner/plaintiff side failed to argue their cases on 24.07.2018 - 07.08.2018 - 16.08.2018 - 30.08.2018 - 06.09.2018 to 19.09.2018 to 04.10.2018 - 23.10.2018 and this court closed the petitioner/plaintiff side argument on 31.10.2018, because of non-cooperation from the side of the petitioner/plaintiff.

    10. Thereafter the defendant side reopened their evidence, but it was reported as the 6th defendant is died. Thereafter, the amendment petition filed by the petitioner/plaintiff in I.A. No. 243 of 2017 and it was allowed on 04.07.2019, even after allowing such amendment petition, the petitioner/plaintiff filed amended application only after 5 hearings (18.07.2019 - 03.08.2019 - 14.08.2019 - 16.08.2019 - 04.09.2019).”

    3. The institution of Courts are available for remedying a wrong done to the right for the justly aggrieved. Still, the Courts do not invite the litigants to its premises, but merely make a remedial forum available and keep their doors open to all those who seek remedy. It is an invitation by appointment for those who have a reason to access the Courts for justice. It is their choice. But, once approached, they need to follow a certain discipline and a reasonable timetable.

    4. The Bar and the litigants need to realise that everytime the Courts give a posting for hearing their case, it is an appointment the Courts give them. Professionalism of the Bar and the responsibility of the litigants should impel them to realise that no appointments with the Courts are wasted. Incidentally, do they miss an appointment with their physician? It is time they realised that Courts are doctors of injured rights, and the appointments they grant them are honoured and made use of. When the litigants do not miss, say a train or a plane in time, miss a marriage or other social events in time, miss a cinema or a live show in time, miss an examination or an interview in time - and the list is endless, what makes them believe that their appointments with the courts alone should figure the least in their list of priorities?

    5. Is it a problem of inandequate professionalism of the Bar, or plain irresponsibility of the litgants, or unmindful generosity of the Courts that they themselves choose not to the take the appointments that they have given the litigants seriously? The pathalogy of delay in disposal of cases lie somewhere in this malady. The courts may not be solely responsible for this, but it cannot seek an exemption either. However, it is passed for, and derided as judicial delay. The same stakeholders who do not spare an opportunity to abuse and/or waste their appointments with the courts, and at times even with a design, blame them. With pain it has to be stated that, for the sin of a section of the Bar and the litigants, the Courts are forced to carry the cross all alone, struggling to explain the delay for the disposal of cases to the citizens of this country all the time.

    6. This court understands that there ought to be procedural elasticity for accommodating unforseen contingencies that affect human affairs. But to stretch it beyond its elastic limits will defeat the existential objectives of the courts, and the promise they hold for the citizens. We, the People, may not betray the trust the Constitution has reposed on us, and shame it.

    7. The primary challenge to the District judiciary is in handling procedural discretion. The Procedural law is a rule book of fairness, and the mindless abuse of procedural discretion, no matter who is responsible for it, would necessarily breed processual inequality among litigants. An overwhelming compassion to one of the litigants may be an expression of procedural fairness to that litigant, but it shall not be forgottten that it would be an act of unfairness to the other litigant. Right to justice is a composite concept: it includes both right to substantial justice as well as procedural justice. As the Mahatma has said, the means is as important as the end, and the process to obtain justice is as significant as the justice as an end.

    8. Having stated thus, the trial courts and the first appellate courts are reminded that the procedural law has its inherent elasticity and flexibility to accommodate multivarious circumstances which human imagination may not be able to visualise or catalogue. Hence, the Courts cannot afford to assume a disciplinarian-attitude, and obstruct the litigant's apiration for securing justice. Watch, Weigh and Value may be a reasonable approach that may enable balancing processual justice in individual cases. The Courts may not ignore that we are a country chiefly made of illiterate and ignorant citizens, most of who have to combat economic and social disabilities for their meaningful existence under the Constitution. Their right to justice therefore, should not be killed by fitting them all in a common denominator. Every case has its flavour, and every litigant has his own share of misery. It is hence, imperative that the Courts should watch, weigh and value each of them for accommodating their request for exercising procedural discretion.

    9. May the Bar and the litigants be now told firmly, but not impolitely, that the appointment which the courts give them is as precious as an appointment a physician gives his patient, for the Courts are doctors of bleeding rights.

    10. Turning to this case, here is a trial judge who has reasoned how the petitioner has developed it her habit to abuse the appointments that the Court has given her. Or, is it her Advocate's strategy?. The courts have been charitable to evolve a doctrine that for the fault of the counsel the litigant should not suffer. The point is, what is that point where a just compassion turns into an undeserving charity? And, is it not true that a section of the bar that has once abused the procedural opportunity is helped with unending opportunities to escape from their inadequate responsibility? Strong expressions they surely are, but this Court considers them as essentially just.

    11. The attitude of the revision petitioner is plainly and painfully nonsensical, and somewhere this game should end. And it has ended now.

    12. In conclusion, this Civil Revision Petition is dismissed. No costs. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petition is closed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Fathima v. Rahamutullah
    (Dec 14, 2020)